*FIXED FULL CLIP! DANIEL HAQIQATJOU, SHAMSI, MANSUR, SHAIKH  

zhamsi: let me finish! let me finish! 80% of sentences are "let me finish!" but he continues to interrupt others.

When one speaks he should always refer to the Quran & Sunnah, this is the weapon of the believer

Shams what Daniel said at 7: 90 onwards is the TRUTH!! You shouldn't argue...I respected you before but NOT anymore!! No Muslim country should've or should normalise relation with Isreal

Subhanallah look how calm and relaxed Brother Daniel is, when you got someone like shamsi barking in your face

All this energy put to defend the injustice, tyranny, treachery and betrayal, it's crazy.

Shamsi is the worst in this crowd to have a conversation with. no regards for others whatsoever, while you can see the calmness in Daniel. Shamsi will almost beat Hatun Tash in terms of being the most annoying in Speakers Corner

"Talking too much means winner" shamsi's thought.

Shamsi is really annoying. He doesnt answer any question and never let anyone speak. Its just constantly him talking over people whenever he feels uncomfortable

Shamsi says let me finish but dosent let anyone else talk

Shamsi openly criticizing all Muslims but scared to criticise rulers. Sad, so sad.

Shamsi argument is weak how can you make peace treaty with someone who is killing your brother

Daniel is very good in analytical thinking but shamsi is totally different

Brother Shamsi really behaved inappropriately and dishonestly. Didn't let the other speak at all. Brother Daniel seems extremely respectful, let others speak, and asked specific question, which remained unanswered, and avoided by Br Shamsi

انَّ النَّاس إِذا رَأَوُا الظَّالِمَ فَلَم يَأْخُذُوا عَلَى يَدَيه أَوشَكَ أَنْ يَعُمَّهُمُ اللهُ بِعِقَابٍ مِنْهُ

shamsi becoming so adamant even if he knows he is wrong he sticks to it , may Allah guide him

The irony is Shamsi living in the west...so how and whom is he giving Baya too? Sheikh Rishi Sunak? Lol

Daniel is a Diamond. This is so lucky to able to talk to a Genius like Daniel. Cry Shamsi Cry

You can't have a fruitful discussion with Shamsi, unfortunately.

In my opinion, Shamsi doesn't let people say anything, it'll be a tiring conversation.

Daniel brother have great knowledge ❤️

My favorite people are all in there. Despite their differences, I love them for the sake of Allaah azza wa jalla

When Daniel asks about can we make inkar on muslim rulers shamsi calls it digressing but then he asks random people in the crowd if they know the conditions of prayer while they're talking about this subject. I bet that's not digressing at all right?

May Allâh ptotect Shamsi. He's the only consistent one amongst all of them. He always refers to Quran and Sunnah upon the understanding of the Companions and the scholars who followed them without innovating (may Allah be pleased with them) . He doesn't care about pleasing the crowd. May Allah bless him.

I can't stand these disrespectful loud mouth Shamsi. Calling your guest a liar, screaming, wont win you a debate.

Calling Shamsi a bootlicker is not fair, bootlicker is an understatement!

Free Palestine

‪Imagine that while France is occupying Algeria, they are also signing a peace treaty with Algeria. ‬ ‪Shamis’s logic will you call that صلح الحديبية ‬

We should follow quran and Sunnah.There is no place of emotion in Islam.

Palestinians are very upset with shamsi after they saw this video

You can clearly see how Daniel is uncomfortable the way shamsi behave screaming jumping not letting people speak Bro come on you should observe these things in a debate! I won’t scream that much for normalization with terrorist state! Madkhalies are exposing themselves good Daniel keep it up 👍

I agree with Daniel. Shamsi isn't knowledgeable when it comes to politics.

Shamsi is calling shaykh dedew shanquiti a Sufi, but he uses salahedine ayubi who was also a Sufi as a reference. He also doesn't want you to criticize the leaders, but he criticize hamas, Taliban, Morsi Any explanation?

This Shamsi is really annoying. Interrupts and talks over others and start crying when people interrupt him. He’s not a scholar nor is he qualified to talk about these matters and defends leaders with his soul. Really feel annoyed whenever I listen to him.

I love all these guys please agree and find common ground

😢 its so sad to see our ummah arguing each other. May Allah unite us

Why Shamshi is always shouting? 🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂

These brothers are both amazing daees may Allah protect us from this fitna.

Thank you Daniel 👍🏼.

Daniel, you are absolutely right ❤

May Allah raise the madaakhila with their rulers

Shamsi is unfortunately not a Aaalim whatever he hears from his Sheikh's he comes to the park and repeats that. I although like his background collection of books. Allah guide the brothers towards what is right and unite the Ummah.

Brother Mansoor is very reasonable and logical. Alhamdulillah. Free Palestine 🇵🇸

The Quran, the Sunna and most importantly the treaty of Hudaybia signed by our beloved prophet Sallallahowalewassallam dismantled the emotional arguments brought against Shamshi position

There were no Zionists in the time of our prophet. But now it is, so it's not the same. Shamsi jou lost

Shamsi calling Daniel liar. After he has asked if we should normalise relations with Israel. Shamsi couldn’t answer.

Haqiqatjou: do u condemn normalisation of Israeli occupation? Shamsi: butbutbutbutbhithudhudhudhudhudayibiyahtreatyofhudayibiyahakhiakhiakhiakhi

Shamsi says dedew is an ash3ari to disprove anything he says, but I literally hear him in the same convo bring up abu al-hasan al-ash3ari, abu taahir al-baghdadi and ibn hazm to prove his point 🤣🤣🤣he doesn't know aqeedah.

Poor Daniel has to debate a hyena

Legend has it, Shamsi has still not finished. This is the result of being a Selfie.

Allah knows best.

Shamsi got very emotional, but his argument with the treaty of Al-Hudaybiyyah, where Muslims had to return to the pagans, and Abu Jandal رضي الله عنه who's Suhayl bin 'Amr's son رضي الله عنه, not a Muslim at the time. When the Muslims saw Abu Jandal in chains, Suhayl said this is the test of the treaty, and Abu Jandal was given back to the mushriks. This doesn't necessitate normalization, but in dire necessity the Sharee'ah allows such a disadvantage treaty. The Qa'idah (legal maxim): المشقة تجلب التيسير Al-Mashaqqah Tajlubu Tayseer _(Hardship begets ease)._ [Al-Majallah #17] And: الضرورات تبيح المحظورات Ad-Daruraat Tubih Al-Muhdaraat _(Necessities permit the prohibition)._ [Al-Majjalah #21] And the evidence for the legal maxims are: Allah سبحانه وتعالى said, فَمَنِ اضْطُرَّ غَيْرَ بَاغٍ وَلَا عَادٍ فَلَا إِثْمَ عَلَيْهِ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ غَفُورٌ رَّحِيمٌ But if one is forced by necessity without wilful disobedience nor transgressing the limits, then there is no sin on him. Verily, Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. [Al-Baqarah 2:173] يُرِيدُ اللَّهُ بِكُمُ الْيُسْرَ وَلَا يُرِيدُ بِكُمُ الْعُسْرَ Allah intends for you ease, and He does not want to make things difficult for you. [Al-Baqarah 2:185] And Allah ﷻ Knows Best. Ask the scholars of Islam. I'm just clarifying that in times of necessity, then this legal maxim becomes valid. And Allah ﷻ Knows Best.

shaykh muhammad is a stabilizing force, may Allah SWT preserve him and those like him, like dear brother shamsi

Brother shaamsi , what is your opinion about woman leader obedience ( in bangladesh)? Shamsi: Go ask scholars But about Daniel he said he is "Kharji " now he dont refers to scholars.He is giving his fatwa .its not someting small to call a muslim Kharji.

As these conversation goes on, is like shamsi is going the wrong way again, subhanallah.. May Allah guide us all 🤲🏽

Masya Allah all of my favourite speakers get together at SC. It would be nice if this conversation can be conducted in proper manner. We are all muslim..

Dear Muslim brothers, let us concentrate on things that are critical to our salvation as Muslims as opposed to fighting each other due to small differences. You are all good Daees and we appreciate your efforts. Keep it Up!

Forget the issue about "normalisation" because no one in the park has authority to speak on the matter. Rather it was made clear that supporting the Zionist regime is clearly haram. However people should have questioned shamsi on why he asks everyone if they are salafi or not as if he has the membership gateway to salafiya and why did he say that Palestine has shirk everywhere and Saudi has "NO" shirk anywhere. Also he claimed that MBS is a salafi as if he knows MBS personally, why this unquestionable support and defence for the Saudi people and not the people of Palestine also who gave him the authority to ask people if they are salafi or not this is the main issue regarding shamsi not the normalisation with Israel because he objectively has no authority or knowledge to answer that question.

Shamshi is the only one who confronts openly and expose people who go against the Quran and sunnah

Time to United the ummah, no time to argue among themselves 🥲

@10:50 when sheikh start talking about when the Muslim nation came together under the arab flag and not under Islam. This was around the birth of arab nationalism with the boundaries were split up under different countries. I learned about a man called Lawrence of Arabia and he and I’m sure many other Brits played a major hand in splitting up the ummah and promoting arab nationalism instead of unifying under islam. Seems like everyone should’ve been fighting with the ottomans instead of against them.

As’salaam u alikum. Meaningful debate

Shamsi you lost all the respect

These types of topics can never be discussed on the roads ....... This is not good that Daaees start discussing such sensitive topic on roads among themselves like laymen..... They are MashaAllah knowledgeable and should try to discuss by arranging a meeting among themselves. This is not proper manner and although I love Daniel and I am with his stance ,still I think he always bring the issues on the road .

If you know MBS & his current plans in Saudi....you will absolutely know that there no relation between sulhul hudaibiya....

We should have a healthy discussion in a gentle way as if there is no conflict but a collective approach to understand something....otherwise if we appear to argue, enemies will take banefit from it by increasing the gaps by fanning the argumentation and high tones between muslims ..

يا شمسي هم معتدين لا تطبيع و لا صلح مع معتدين لهيك لا دخل حالك بقضيه مش فاهم فيها يعني انت تقبل الصلح مع فرنسا هم بالجزائر محتلينها و متحكمين في ماء و طعام و كهرباء و نقل و ما عندكم جيش و لا مطار انت تقبل الصلح بهاي ظروف

When Omar r.a. decided how much the most in dowry can women ask for a women criticized Omar and said you can't do that, and she said that in front of all of the people. Then Omar realizing that He made a mistake and changed the ruling.

Genuinely i don’t understand why we can’t criticize these so called Muslim rulers when they don’t even implement the sharia I would assume that this only applies under the sharia. Am I wrong for thinking this, let me know.

I’m beginning to think Shamsi is paid by Saudi Govt. At this point

Innalillahi wa inna ilaihi rojiuun

Shamsi is like an animal no one else speaking but him honestly embarrassing

The only problem with our duat is over simplification and dont have experience in strategic discussions. They are good in dawah sphere, no doubt but they are quite naive in reading the political scenarios. It's not about you monopolize the truth but the ability to understand that one can never be right all the time or wrong all the time. United and agree to disagree 😊. Do you best in your specialization with the intention to unite the ummah. Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ✨️

DANIEL HAQIQATJOU👍

You can't criticize the leader?😮😮 That’s so shallow of understanding the Islamic principle of citizenship. They know for certain from history how Umar RA was criticized by a woman over the issue of divorce/mahar. Stop being naive and emotional

To whom is Daniel’s Bai‘ah to effectively? Why didn’t anyone ask him? To Biden, Obama? bush? Trump? He himself calls himself a „proud Texan“… so to whom is his allegiance?

he can't call him a kathab, that's not for shamsi to say. may allah guide us all

It is so annoying that he had to say "let me finish" over 200 times because nobody wanted to listen to his nonsense, and still he managed not to let anyone else talk. Embarrassing character.

Shamsi is rhe kind of giy who never learns or admits he is wrong.

Subhanallah, brother Daniel is speaking facts based on whats happening to Palestinians in front of our eyes.

Why give bay'ah to democratic president of algeria who implementents many secular / french laws??? 26:45

Answer for shamsi and his followers about Palestine and Israel قال الله تبارک و تعالی فی کتابه العظیم فی سورة النساء وَما لَكُم لا تُقاتِلونَ في سَبيلِ اللَّهِ وَالمُستَضعَفينَ مِنَ الرِّجالِ وَالنِّساءِ وَالوِلدانِ الَّذينَ يَقولونَ رَبَّنا أَخرِجنا مِن هٰذِهِ القَريَةِ الظّالِمِ أَهلُها وَاجعَل لَنا مِن لَدُنكَ وَلِيًّا وَاجعَل لَنا مِن لَدُنكَ نَصيرًا﴿۷۵﴾ (

Shamsi doesn’t have atticates of debate he doesn’t allow other to speak

How do we know who is a scholar or not? What if there are disagreements on ones qualifications? What if the scholars named are paid and funded by the West unknowingly? Why hasnt anyone showed any references or recommended any books? I would love some books to explain all this especially a few books from different perspectives and madhhabs

I feel sorry for Shamsi. I cannot believe there are still brothers today who still defend the tyrants who were imposed on us by the West and rule us by Kufr.

So lovely ❤

There is a big difference between scholars and leaders.

Say what you want about Shamsi but he is kicking everybody's behind here.😎

الى شمسي نقول كما قال أمل دنقل لا نصالحْ ..ولو منحوك الذهب أترى حين أفقأ عينيك ثم أثبت جوهرتين مكانهما.. هل ترى..؟ هي أشياء لا تشترى..: ذكريات الطفولة بين أخيك وبينك، حسُّكما فجأةً بالرجولةِ، هذا الحياء الذي يكبت الشوق.. حين تعانقُهُ، الصمتُ مبتسمين لتأنيب أمكما.. وكأنكما ما تزالان طفلين! تلك الطمأنينة الأبدية بينكما: أنَّ سيفانِ سيفَكَ.. صوتانِ صوتَكَ أنك إن متَّ: للبيت ربٌّ وللطفل أبْ هل يصير دمي بين عينيك ماءً؟ أتنسى ردائي الملطَّخَ بالدماء.. تلبس فوق دمائي ثيابًا مطرَّزَةً بالقصب؟ إنها الحربُ! قد تثقل القلبَ.. لكن خلفك عار العرب لا تصالحْ.. ولا تتوخَّ الهرب! (2) لا تصالح على الدم.. حتى بدم! لا تصالح! ولو قيل رأس برأسٍ أكلُّ الرؤوس سواءٌ؟ أقلب الغريب كقلب أخيك؟! أعيناه عينا أخيك؟! وهل تتساوى يدٌ.. سيفها كان لك بيدٍ سيفها أثْكَلك؟ سيقولون: جئناك كي تحقن الدم.. جئناك. كن يا أمير الحكم سيقولون: ها نحن أبناء عم. قل لهم: إنهم لم يراعوا العمومة فيمن هلك واغرس السيفَ في جبهة الصحراء إلى أن يجيب العدم إنني كنت لك فارسًا، وأخًا، وأبًا، ومَلِك! (3) لا تصالح .. ولو حرمتك الرقاد صرخاتُ الندامة وتذكَّر.. (إذا لان قلبك للنسوة اللابسات السواد ولأطفالهن الذين تخاصمهم الابتسامة) أن بنتَ أخيك "اليمامة" زهرةٌ تتسربل في سنوات الصبا بثياب الحداد كنتُ، إن عدتُ: تعدو على دَرَجِ القصر، تمسك ساقيَّ عند نزولي.. فأرفعها وهي ضاحكةٌ فوق ظهر الجواد ها هي الآن.. صامتةٌ حرمتها يدُ الغدر: من كلمات أبيها، ارتداءِ الثياب الجديدةِ من أن يكون لها ذات يوم أخٌ! من أبٍ يتبسَّم في عرسها.. وتعود إليه إذا الزوجُ أغضبها.. وإذا زارها.. يتسابق أحفادُه نحو أحضانه، لينالوا الهدايا.. ويلهوا بلحيته (وهو مستسلمٌ) ويشدُّوا العمامة.. لا تصالح! فما ذنب تلك اليمامة لترى العشَّ محترقًا.. فجأةً، وهي تجلس فوق الرماد؟! (4) لا تصالح ولو توَّجوك بتاج الإمارة كيف تخطو على جثة ابن أبيكَ..؟ وكيف تصير المليكَ.. على أوجهِ البهجة المستعارة؟ كيف تنظر في يد من صافحوك.. فلا تبصر الدم.. في كل كف؟ إن سهمًا أتاني من الخلف.. سوف يجيئك من ألف خلف فالدم الآن صار وسامًا وشارة لا تصالح، ولو توَّجوك بتاج الإمارة إن عرشَك: سيفٌ وسيفك: زيفٌ إذا لم تزنْ بذؤابته لحظاتِ الشرف واستطبت الترف (5) لا تصالح ولو قال من مال عند الصدامْ ".. ما بنا طاقة لامتشاق الحسام.." عندما يملأ الحق قلبك: تندلع النار إن تتنفَّسْ ولسانُ الخيانة يخرس لا تصالح ولو قيل ما قيل من كلمات السلام كيف تستنشق الرئتان النسيم المدنَّس؟ كيف تنظر في عيني امرأة.. أنت تعرف أنك لا تستطيع حمايتها؟ كيف تصبح فارسها في الغرام؟ كيف ترجو غدًا.. لوليد ينام كيف تحلم أو تتغنى بمستقبلٍ لغلام وهو يكبر بين يديك بقلب مُنكَّس؟ لا تصالح ولا تقتسم مع من قتلوك الطعام وارْوِ قلبك بالدم.. واروِ التراب المقدَّس.. واروِ أسلافَكَ الراقدين.. إلى أن تردَّ عليك العظام! (6) لا تصالح ولو ناشدتك القبيلة باسم حزن "الجليلة" أن تسوق الدهاءَ وتُبدي لمن قصدوك القبول سيقولون: ها أنت تطلب ثأرًا يطول فخذ الآن ما تستطيع: قليلاً من الحق.. في هذه السنوات القليلة إنه ليس ثأرك وحدك، لكنه ثأر جيلٍ فجيل وغدًا.. سوف يولد من يلبس الدرع كاملةً، يوقد النار شاملةً، يطلب الثأرَ، يستولد الحقَّ، من أَضْلُع المستحيل لا تصالح ولو قيل إن التصالح حيلة إنه الثأرُ تبهتُ شعلته في الضلوع.. إذا ما توالت عليها الفصول.. ثم تبقى يد العار مرسومة (بأصابعها الخمس) فوق الجباهِ الذليلة! (7) لا تصالحْ، ولو حذَّرتْك النجوم ورمى لك كهَّانُها بالنبأ.. كنت أغفر لو أنني متُّ.. ما بين خيط الصواب وخيط الخطأ. لم أكن غازيًا، لم أكن أتسلل قرب مضاربهم لم أمد يدًا لثمار الكروم لم أمد يدًا لثمار الكروم أرض بستانِهم لم أطأ لم يصح قاتلي بي: "انتبه"! كان يمشي معي.. ثم صافحني.. ثم سار قليلاً ولكنه في الغصون اختبأ! فجأةً: ثقبتني قشعريرة بين ضلعين.. واهتزَّ قلبي كفقاعة وانفثأ! وتحاملتُ، حتى احتملت على ساعديَّ فرأيتُ: ابن عمي الزنيم واقفًا يتشفَّى بوجه لئيم لم يكن في يدي حربةٌ أو سلاح قديم، لم يكن غير غيظي الذي يتشكَّى الظمأ (8) لا تصالحُ.. إلى أن يعود الوجود لدورته الدائرة: النجوم.. لميقاتها والطيور.. لأصواتها والرمال.. لذراتها والقتيل لطفلته الناظرة كل شيء تحطم في لحظة عابرة: الصبا بهجةُ الأهل صوتُ الحصان التعرفُ بالضيف همهمةُ القلب حين يرى برعماً في الحديقة يذوي الصلاةُ لكي ينزل المطر الموسميُّ مراوغة القلب حين يرى طائر الموتِ وهو يرفرف فوق المبارزة الكاسرة كلُّ شيءٍ تحطَّم في نزوةٍ فاجرة والذي اغتالني: ليس ربًا.. ليقتلني بمشيئته ليس أنبل مني.. ليقتلني بسكينته ليس أمهر مني.. ليقتلني باستدارتِهِ الماكرة لا تصالحْ فما الصلح إلا معاهدةٌ بين ندَّينْ.. (في شرف القلب) لا تُنتقَصْ والذي اغتالني مَحضُ لصْ سرق الأرض من بين عينيَّ والصمت يطلقُ ضحكته الساخرة! (9) لا تصالح ولو وقفت ضد سيفك كل الشيوخ والرجال التي ملأتها الشروخ هؤلاء الذين تدلت عمائمهم فوق أعينهم وسيوفهم العربية قد نسيت سنوات الشموخ لا تصالح فليس سوى أن تريد أنت فارسُ هذا الزمان الوحيد وسواك.. المسوخ! (10) لا تصالحْ لا تصالحْ

SHAMSI quran and sunnah like always thats why he converts tons of ppl, meanwhile the layman shooyokhs here who who have the highest degrees criticising him just gettin emotional 🤦🏻‍♂️

despite of the difference, I amazed on how these people trying to understand each other to clearing things. May the truth unite us all, aamiin

Did shamsi really said he is pleadging allegiance to tabon from algeria? 😂😂😂😂

If Hamas are the rulers of the Gaza District of Palestine, what gives a Madkhali like Shamsi the right to criticize them? Are they not Muslim rulers, who have a right to make decisions of war and peace? This is just another one of the thousands of examples of Madaakhila violating their own claimed principles. Oh, and at least Gaza doesn’t have Hindu temples or foreign military bases, unlike certain countries that I don’t need to name.

May Allah give victory to the Muslims in Palestine. Allahum strengthen their Eman and their Hugga. Allahum help the righteous Resistance group against their enemies and those who are supporting the enemies and discouraging the Ummah against establishing the khilafa.

From this exchange, Im sorry but the knowledge is with shamsi and sh muhammed. Danial is speaking on the context from a perspective that is independent from whats been revealed. He didnt provide, barely if any, any backing from Quran, Sunnah perspectives of the scholars. He was speaking entirely from his own logical inference and understanding of politics. Of course, everyone has good intentions in this discussion, but i feel the truth is clear here.

Daniel: emotions and appealing to the crowd Shamsi: quran and sunnah, sahaba said, prophet said.. etc

this shows why we are in that situation right now ...

Al-Kaafiruun.(QS 109:1-6)

I'm not a Muslim, but man you need to get some shia fire in there. They know what it means to oppose the oppression in action, not just words. Nothing against the Sunnis, but Shamsi's rationalization is depressing. I know you guys are gonna bash my shia comment, but come one, even I can see they have merits in their efforts, Sunni ideological disagreements aside.

Shamsi is a Dawah specialist but his understanding of Islamic politics is weak.

شمسي يصرخ وصوته مزعج جدا وهذا كله دفاعا عن ضلاله في حبه للحكام و المساندين للكيان، هذا رجل قال امامي هو تبون رئيس الجزائر، خلاص شو بدك تسمع امثر من هذا الضلال