The Roberto Clemente rookie(I believe )in the thumbnail I traded my boy for the O.J. rookie. At times I regret it but what I got in return was on my wishlist. Definitely missed a good card.
I definitely wonder if it was a reprint. It wouldn't make sense that he would have the Heritage priced at $70 and the update which is the bigger card at $10. Either way, great score on the gloves and the cards. Can never go wrong with vintage Mays.
You cheated yourself 13:50. The price for the card lot he gave was $60, which included the $45 Carr card, which he stated he wanted the $45 price for it. So without the Carr card, the remaining cards would be $15 before any discount. But you offered $20, and hence he immediately was like "uh yea! oh yea!" You must take this as a learning experience my young Padawan.
Yeah I actaully realized I messed that up at the time. Sometimes you get more of a discount when you buy more, so removing the Carr wouldn't necessarily drop the price to $15, however I think the 3 cards were $1 each and the Mays was $15 so I paid more than asking anyway - doh!