We all need to remember that makeup does expire, so use the things that bring you joy! If something doesn't work on me, I just give it to a friend. Make-up's job is to make you feel beautiful. Life is to short for makeup that doesn't do it's job.
its so easy to keep buying it xD and not using it because its so beautiful....... i am forcing myself to dig into my blush (same one as yours #2) and use up my lip cream....... its too easy to hoard but then it will go bad x.x