Food Theory: YOU Solved the Grubhub Mystery! 

Sometimes I forget just how cool the theorist community is.

MatPat: * Makes a FNAF theory that makes sense * Scott Cawthon: Lol I'm gonna change it again MatPat: Makes a GrubHub theory as a joke GrubHub: Lol canon

Matpat: YOU solved the Grubhub mystery Me who hasn't lifted a finger: Ahh yes...all in a good day's work 🙂

Am I the only one who wanted more of this amazing saga? I mean I know there were 3 videos… but I am just in awe.

This is still easily my most favorite food theory series. Part 1: Haha, funny grubhub meme theory. Part 2: Oh... Oh dear. Part 3: MY CHILDHOOD NOOOOO XD

"Giant snake, birthday cake LARGE FRIES, CHOCOLATE SHAKE." The lyrics of the Fairly Oddparents theme song connects the missing woman to being Trixie by the receipt featuring LARGE FRIES, and a CHOCOLATE SHAKE!

Considering the fairly odd parent clip where trixie screams “feed me and tell me I’m pretty!” at Timmy, it may have Ben trixie that ended her relationship with neutron who she believed wasn’t tending to her needs properly. This would also explain the grub hub bag as potentially neutron still holding a grudge after the breakup and deciding to feed trixie... to death.

It’s also worth mentioning that the dog reacts to the food appearing in front of taco guy, therefore being more real than the gems or stars the other characters experience

"You solved the Grubhub mystery" The legends who did absolutely nothing: "You're very welcome, MatPat"

package: says “confidential” matpat: *shares the entirety on the internet to millions of people*

The thing about the FOP connection is that the 2nd and third crossover specials make it very clear they’re set in separate universes. Like they can only get back and forth with dimensional portals.

Remember Jimmy has an evil clone in an AU. So it's possible that we're seeing how the evil AU in Jimmy Neutron turned out.

“YOU Solved the Grubhub Mystery!” Me who literally didn’t say or do a thing: Aw, gee, it was nothin ☺️

1. Glad you included JT Power Hour because that expands the GCU even more. 2. I still think the JT Power Hour contributed to the idea of GrubHub because Jimmy saw Timmy’s fairies and assumed they were computer programs that could do exactly what his personal GrubHub app can do…except Cosmo and Wanda were Timmy’s personal apps. So I honestly think the entire concept of GrubHub (Jimmy’s special version) was directly influenced by Timmy’s fairies. 3. I highly doubt Jimmy killed Trixie, but I wouldn’t put it past Cindy. Her character was always the possessive, demanding, jealous type and generally toxic. 4. Cindy may not have known the brown dog was Goddard. Jimmy certainly had the capacity back in the day to make Goddard more lifelike, but seemed to admire the mechanical appearance more. I think he disguised Goddard to appease Cindy, OR he pretended to get rid of Goddard and “adopted/bought” a new “real” dog. I suspect Cindy wasn’t ready for that, or still rejected Goddard, and forced Jimmy to give him up. 5. The reason we don’t see Cindy and Jimmy together as a couple may be because their marriage failed, and not just due to Cindy’s sub-par personality. Cindy would have every reason to be angry if Jimmy just played video games all day, as that leaves her with the burden of housework AND breadwinning. She may now live in the blue house to avoid her husband/ex-husband(?). 6. If 3 and 5 are true, Cindy’s motive for killing Trixie could be a step beyond jealousy. If Cindy thought Jimmy was distracted by Trixie or that Jimmy still secretly loved Trixie and was distracting himself from Trixie via games, the best way to both get her husband off the couch AND remove a threat to their relationship would be to eliminate the most probable source-in this case, Trixie.

MatPat: At first I was like, "Mmm GrubHub lore" as a joke, right? MatPat: But bro MatPAt: *I don't think it's a joke anymore*

It’s incredible how a Grubhub ad became a meme that then spiraled into a massive collaborative mystery ARG that involves Jimmy Neutron. Man the internet is funny!

This series just goes to show that MatPat can’t even make an April’s fools video without sounding convincing.

You should really consider making a cospiracy theory chanel or something like detective stuff or whatever bc this is gold

You always find a way to make wholesome things dark. And I’m so there for it lol keep it up

the fact that grubhub is quickly becoming the fnaf of food theory is really terrifying

I’ll admit, when you mentioned that Jimmy might be responsible for the grub hub bag, my brain went to blaming Cindy for dropping it- possibly to get rid of a romantic rival.

This is so bizarre, I remember now every single clip of the show that’s brought up/shown. I forgot how much of a fan I was of that show as a little kid, I even remember making my family watch the movie for it for movie nights, and made my older brother fall in love with the Sheen Show thingy

13:30 Isn't Dimmsdale in California, though? In the episode "Fairy Idol", they show exactly where Dimmsdale is, which is California IIRC.

Can't believe how interactive grubhub is with the community to actually have deep lore. i love this

Grubhub marketing team must be like: “yeah… that’s tooootally what this is and how it happened… yes”

While I can't remember much of the show I still love Cindy's sassy confidence XD

this theory is like hearing a summary of a soap opera

Just remember MatPat, if we’re wrong, this will be the most elaborate April fools prank ever....

I swear Mat Pat is the only guy that can make a lore about a commercial series and connect it to Jimmy Neutron

I think its more likely Cindy coulda done the deed as a last ditch effort for Jimmy not to leave her since he would get dotard and get rid of an old flame he might have still been pining after.

I spotted another hint that it’s Jimmy’s old house if you look at 11:41 you can see that his neighbors house is blue with a red roof and when you go back to see the picture of the house being circle you can see that next to that house it’s a blue house with a red roof.

Ok MatPat, hear me out. What if Taco guy is secretly one of Jimmy’s clones! Whenever he eats a taco in the clip you showed his eyes lit up and looked almost mechanical. What if he dropped the bag on Milkshake Lady because he was evil! What if he has Jimmy locked up somewhere and now holds on to the controls over the Grubhub town…?

Package: *Confidential* MatPat: "Hm TIME TO SHARE THIS WITH THE WORLD :D"

6:38 so Jimmy made diamonds--which later feature in the grubhub commercials...?

I litterally cannot get over the intro. So well done!

The other angle of the grub hub bag is that Jimmy started showing interest in Trixie Tang while married to Cindy, and that Cindy hijacked some controls to take out Trixie, hoping to get Goddard, but not being experienced enough to accurately target it.

It's also possible that Jimmy went back to see Timmy and talked to the Fairies. Converting magic into science, he created an app. A dark twist is that he's using fairies as servants for his app.

This started out as a April fools joke and now it's pretty much cannon.

i remember binge watching these grubhub theory videos you made 3 years ago. good times.

Just a reminder: MatPat made a theory about a food commercial related to a 20 year old kids show as a joke, and then the creators ACTUALLY RESPONDED THUS MAKING IT NOW HAVE POSSIBLE CANONICAL LORE

"feed me and tell me im pretty!" such a mood trixie, such a mood

This is one of my favorite theories on the channel

MatPat: asks us if we can theorize what GrubHub is telling us MatPat community: I HAVE BEEN SUMMONED

"Magically". Since Fairly OddParents is now on the table, what's to say Timmy didn't WISH for it? There are magic stars everywhere too.

When you were talking about, it being Jimmy that killed milkshake lady something popped into my head. What if it wasn't Jimmy that killed her but Cindy! She could have been threatened by milkshake lady still being around! And being married to Jimmy at the time she would have had Direct access to his phone if he was asleep!

In one of Taco Guy's ads, you can see the dog ordering tacos from Taco Shack for a brief moment.

It takes a lot of time to make foodtheory videos takes a lot of time and he has so many videos I just wanna thank him and teem theorist for all memories

"How many times do you want to say GrubHub?" Matpat: yes

Fun fact: A Jimmy Neutron reboot apparently has been confirmed for paramount +. So we might see if any of our theories are right in the near future. I think it's slated for fall 2021, so see you all then.

this is literally the most insane level of niche detail and thinking of EVERYTHING , proud of the theorist team, those who made this video and fans alike!

I’m confused,shocked, and loving this series

I’m almost 100% sure that they moved the chimney, since there’s actually a hole where the chimney used to be in the photo! You can actually see the hole in the side of the house, which we know exists on Jimmy’s house since we see it in the feature film.

is so hilarious how accurate it is, but I still have a question unanswered, are any of the animation team that worked on the grubhub commercial related to jimmy neutron?

I don’t know if you have ever thought about starting an official game theory discord server but it would make it super easy to talk with and get theorist to communicate together

i love this channel, keep up the good work!

Matpat: I need your help for evidence. The thousands of theorists too bored to do anything else: _YES SIR_

This all started as a April Fools joke that was, in and of itself, an April Foods joke. Round of applause. 👏👏

The house theory you proposed makes sense how it most likely isn't his house, however, a neighborhood near my residence is being bulldozed and rebuild but better. I propose the same could have happened with Jimmy's neighborhood.

10:09 blues clues !!!!!!!!!!! my childhod!!!!!

There's a problem with this: The 15 Year Future Jimmy/Cindy relationship only happened like that because Libby became an evil dance-crazy dictator. Their actual relationship wouldn't be like that at all.

I'd investigate Cindy as the murderer. She had access to Jimmy's tech.

the way the editors make these concerning scenes with the characters is just amazing

Just something I noticed when watching the ad ( I do know that I’m late lol) most of it happens in Cindy’s or “salad lady’s” own fantasy. But milkshake lady or possibly Trixie is there. This means that the must have met at some point, but what concerns me more is that she seems pregnant in that commercial. There is a possibility that the Cindy Vortex commercial might possibly be placed in the past.

"Jimmy Neutron is a murderer via grubhub" is not the hot take I was expecting

The tan house that was circled also has the empty space where the chimney would be off it hasn’t been knocked over and moved. The windows are in perfect placement too. Two big windows in the middle of the y axis of the house on either side of the chimney area, the two smaller windows are most likely covered by the tree. I really hope you see this. My comments never get noticed.

This is his best video I’m liking right now for how good it is ❤❤❤

I think that in a Grubhub commercial with the giant Grubhub box, the Grubhub delivery driver is Betty Quinlen. There is a similar skin tone, and you can kind of see the brown hair, and you may think the it is the same delivery guy from another commercial, but the driver has blue pants instead. And since you could not find who she could be, she could be the delivery driver.

One small thing, throughout the Jimmy Neutron series, Jimmy messes with time travel more than once, and the future is far from certain. When Sheen accidentally gifts Libby a perfume spray that would make her evil for her birthday, Jimmy, Carl, and Sheen see a future where she’s taken over the world. The rest of the episode revolves around them actively changing that future. Jimmy seeing how miserable his 26 year old self was, he would definitely put effort into changing that future.

Knowing Cindy, I'd blame her for some fairly odd murder. We know how vindictive she can be.

Game Theory and Food Theory are def my favs

This entire theory is so ridiculous but at the same time so entertaining

I absolutely love it how this started out as a April fool's joke even he admitted it wasn't supposed to be this deep but since apparently people have been making connections to it he is now going with it if this becomes the fnaf of this channel I swear to God

Let's take a second to imagine what would have happened if the creators of Earthbound or Undertale replied to MatPat after his Sans is Ness theory. *How many parts would he have made?*

I love your intro I keep watching it over and over again!

This theory cummunity is so cool i love the theorist!!

The best part about this is that GrubHub definitely just put a bunch of random stuff together to see if he would somehow connect it all

Flashbacks to MatPat saying that he had “solved” FNaF by the third video, anyone?

MatPat: And you guys did a great job! A double + to you! Me on my bed literally rotting while watching this: oh yeah you're totally welcome

I LOVED the blue clues reference thank you for that

Man,.Trixie Tang yelling "FEED ME AND TELL ME I'M PRETTY!!!" never gets old!

Does anyone else notice how Jimmy’s eyes flash when he bites any grub hub food? I can’t make it out. it might just be reflection from the tv, but it ONLY happens when he eats grub hub food.

14:33 loving how she gave birth with a milkshake in her hand 😂

This was easy to wrap my head around at first but now... I had to watch this video twice to understand now...

I strongly believe that Grubhub had no intention to make a hidden story, but MatPat discovered something, and they are just going with it now.

This is one of the most elaborate sponsorship/advertisement schemes I've ever scene. I applaud you all for a very tactifully planned co-op.

I would like to mention in the delivery dance ad, chicken sandwich guy magically summons food in seconds like taco guy.

I’m still scared of him. I didn’t think there could be Lore behind a literal FOOD DELIVERY APP.

At this point, Mat should throw out his ‘certified false’ stamp

The Trixie thing still bothers me, since the Power Hours confirmed canonically that the two are in the same UNIVERSE, but quite literally different dimensions. Even their art styles are canonical and noticed by the characters who cross over. Of course, Jimmy has consructed a portal between the two before, so anything is possible I suppose.

Me re-watching the 2nd merge mansion video: only one more video from the theorist.. Also me: re-watches lily's garden, the 1st grubhub video and watching the other 2 grubhub videos too

Wow. We went from delivery service app to a childhood favorite character being a murderer. Wow.

The chimney being moved has an even better explanation: energy-loss. The chimney is a good distributor of the heat from the fire, so it's relocation to a more efficient location would make economic sense and it'd be reasonable for a local government to require that only fireplaces that's not wasting heat would be allowed to be used

I think at this point franchises create lore based on what matpat theorizes

I don't know if anyone has noticed yet, but the receipt lists 1 L Fries, L chocolate shake. In the opening theme song of fairly odd parents Timmy wishes for Large Fries and a chocolate shake!

Dang this goes deep but I love that the theorist community is amazing so amazing that they are willing to go into detail about this long parter🥰😉❤️👌😉

I really hope this series continues, it's actually the most entertaining series on all three channels if I'm going to be honest

MatPat must’ve been like: “Confidential? Ha, shouldn’t have trusted me with THIS!”

The theory is really good! :0

The thing is timmy has a secret wish he wished that nobody grew up in an episode and when he was questioned about it he said he wished for it 50 years ago so trixy and everyone else in the fairly odd parents universe never ages.

Ok so I have two theories about Milkshake Lady's/ Trixie's death: 1 it could have been an accident on Taco Guy's/ Jimmy's part because we know he is prone to not have his inventions always go as planned, and in an attempt to refine the Grubhub app he created to deliver the entire towns order at once hence the giant bag something malfunctioned, thus crushing Milkshake Lady while on a walk with Goddard. Causing Jimmy to spiral into depression not leaving his couch, playing video games and ordering food all day. Or 2 : After marrying Salad Lady/Cindy out of convenience because Trixie was in Dimsdale or away at college and not wanting to alter the future's timeline. But Jimmy sometime later reconnects with Trixie but she has moved on as well, Cindy finds out about the reconnecting and not wating to be outdone hijacked his invention causing the bag to crush Trixie but making Jimmy believe it was his fault. #BUTITSJUSTATHEORY Love this mystery/saga🧐💜