Тёмный

Four Common Misconceptions about Nietzsche 

Julian de Medeiros
Подписаться 51 тыс.
Просмотров 4,8 тыс.
50% 1

Hello and good morning, it’s me Julian. Today I thought we should take a break and instead focus on Deleuze’s wonderful essay on Nietzsche in which he articulates four common misconceptions. I also try to provide a short introduction to Nietzsche’s philosophy and add 2 more misconceptions.
Thank you for watching, and if you’d like to help me keep making these videos please consider becoming a patron. Thank you!
Julian
#nietzsche #deleuze #philosophy

Опубликовано:

 

20 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 53   
@julianphilosophy
@julianphilosophy Месяц назад
For more: www.patreon.com/julianphilosophy
@jannesplatteau
@jannesplatteau Месяц назад
thanks Julian.
@narraliveproject2576
@narraliveproject2576 Месяц назад
Hi Julian, what do you think of Zizek disinterest toward Nietzsche's philosophy? Considering Freud himself took a lot ideas from Nietzsche and Zizek appreciated Freud.
@narraliveproject2576
@narraliveproject2576 Месяц назад
@stephen23122 aside from mischaracterization, once I watch a video where Zizek tell why he was not into Nietzsche philosophy. It's interesting but weird, as far as I remember, Zizek explain the way he found an enjoyment of reading philosophy as a good sex. For him, Hegel and Freud penetrated him deeply, but the same could not be say to Nietzsche. This make me think, is this because with Nietzsche there is only appearance? Just like what Foucault said.
@michaelcastady6600
@michaelcastady6600 Месяц назад
One of your best videos yet, I won't lie that "Strength is the ability to exhibit weakness": hit me like a truck. I'm very excited for your Delueze & Nietsche detour.
@anupamdebnath1884
@anupamdebnath1884 Месяц назад
Finally Deleuze!! ❤ Please do one video on why Zizek tells Deleuzian Rhyzomatic analysis is not opposed to Hegelian dialectics.
@romankonecny7106
@romankonecny7106 Месяц назад
Awesome vid as always, was entertained by sudden 4:48 mouth slip where you almost said Zizek instead of Nietche :D Force of habit huh
@9th.peroxide751
@9th.peroxide751 Месяц назад
Beautiful explanation! Thank you
@DanKoiti
@DanKoiti Месяц назад
Thank you for this video Julian, and happy Mother’s Day!
@uncommonsensewithpastormar2913
@uncommonsensewithpastormar2913 Месяц назад
Sorry, but I’m not buying the Deleuzian reinterpretation of Nietzsche. For example, Deleuze wants to make Nietzsche’s concept of the “eternal return” far more complicated than what it actually is. It is simply a thought experiment where you become so life affirming that you would live your life together with all of its disappointments and suffering over and over again if given a choice.
@TheYopogo
@TheYopogo Месяц назад
Well that's Deleuze's explicit approach. He's very clear that he's not claiming that his reading is what Nietzsche meant. He says as much. He's clear that he's using Nietzsche's concepts to develop his own versions. It's actually a very Nietzschian way of reading. It's Deleuze's and Nietzsche's instances of the will to power meeting creatively.
@uncommonsensewithpastormar2913
@uncommonsensewithpastormar2913 Месяц назад
@@TheYopogo Well, if that’s the case, to use the term “misconceptions” in the title in inaccurate.
@H.C.J.
@H.C.J. Месяц назад
Deleuze purposely cherry picks parts of Nietzsche. I assume this channel picked Deleuzes interpretation bc of deleuze’s Lacanian background, which fits in with the surrounding topics on this channel.
@osoisko1933
@osoisko1933 Месяц назад
There's suggestions in his notes that Nietzsche might have considered the Eternal Return more than an intellectual exercise. This is more where Deleuze based his interpretation on.
@1nfiniteSeek3r
@1nfiniteSeek3r 16 дней назад
The eternal return and ubermensch strike me as traps, pharmakon for "concept idolators".
@Peanut-jy7hd
@Peanut-jy7hd Месяц назад
Kudos to you Julian, brilliant summary yet again. You really have a godly gift for compressing such complex ideas!
@mephesh
@mephesh Месяц назад
Every thing you do Julian is great, waiting on every video
@comptonGANGBANG
@comptonGANGBANG Месяц назад
thank you for this video great analysis
@soaked189
@soaked189 Месяц назад
I loved this, thank you
@mrlspr
@mrlspr Месяц назад
My favorite channel ❤
@alexandruflorea1250
@alexandruflorea1250 Месяц назад
Thanks!
@mikecaetano
@mikecaetano Месяц назад
Deleuze and Guattari declare Nietzsche's On the Genealogy of Morals "the great book of modern ethnology" for its success interpreting primitive economy in terms of debt and debtor-creditor relationships, and doing so without consideration of exchange or interest or placing them in structure. Then they write: "Man must constitute himself through the repression of the intense germinal influx, the great biocosmic memory that threatens to deluge every attempt at collectivity. ... All the stupidity and the arbitrariness of the laws, all the pain of the initiations, the whole perverse apparatus of repression and education, the red-hot irons, and the atrocious procedures have only this means: to breed man, to mark him in his flesh, to render him capable of alliance, to form him within the debtor-creditor relation, which on both sides turns out to be a matter of memory -- a memory straining toward the future." (Anti-Oedipus, 1972)
@tabishshibli4067
@tabishshibli4067 Месяц назад
Please make more videos on deleuze!!!
@aidanknight1574
@aidanknight1574 Месяц назад
An analysis into Nietzsche’s and Foucault’s philosophies of power here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ArnP7_jMGCY.htmlsi=DOv6DMkhMoczfldN
@josephsuruiz
@josephsuruiz Месяц назад
Present! Thanks again and again for this, Prof. Julian! Looking forward for more Lacan and Nietzsche's contents. 😊
@corrupted6683
@corrupted6683 Месяц назад
There's a contralecture of Nietzsche's fascism in Georg Lukács's The Destruction of Reason. Its very interesting.
@plastic2666
@plastic2666 Месяц назад
ty
@Life_Of_Mine_
@Life_Of_Mine_ Месяц назад
Again some nietzsche. Yes. Thank you Mr. Medeiros
@1nfiniteSeek3r
@1nfiniteSeek3r 16 дней назад
I've read a lot of early Marx and Nietzsche and I see a great similarity in their work, I wonder if it has something to do with their brief dalliances with the pre-Socratics, specifically Democritus and Heraclitus.
@mephesh
@mephesh Месяц назад
I understood most of the topics but I didnt really understand the part about the child, thank you for explaining, Im past my lion stage and its ok to have a playful nature as child without all the battle and confrontation.
@markoslavicek
@markoslavicek Месяц назад
I believe I speak on behalf of everyone here if I say that we'd love to see Zizek in comparison to Nietzsche video.
@Jesse-ey5xd
@Jesse-ey5xd Месяц назад
Well shoot. That's everything I thought I knew 🤦😂🖖
@ronjames9759
@ronjames9759 Месяц назад
Is it correct to say that Nietzsche’s philosophy is mapping onto the anarchist project? (The emancipatory one, not the anarcho-capitalist bastardization)
@OleSandberg
@OleSandberg Месяц назад
anarchists - like Emma Goldman - certainly found Nietzsche useful and inspiring (and many still do).
@h1r0shishigami8
@h1r0shishigami8 Месяц назад
More stirnerian
@mofuker199
@mofuker199 Месяц назад
Julian can you please review Baby Reideer? I feel so uneasy because of the fact that the main character plays himself. It feels wrong yet I can't grasp why.
@callmeuriah.5433
@callmeuriah.5433 Месяц назад
you should do an episode on against the dialectic *please do an episode on against the dialectic, professor.
@unusualpond
@unusualpond Месяц назад
I feel soothed every time you pronounce Deleuze not “De loos”
@funkerdoo
@funkerdoo Месяц назад
I always read it like de le ooze
@theonetruetim
@theonetruetim Месяц назад
"They would rather believe in The Devil than in Life."
@Paradoxe44
@Paradoxe44 Месяц назад
Sure by changing the meaning of every word you can make anyone believe that Nietzsche said the exact opposite of what he actually said
@villevanttinen908
@villevanttinen908 Месяц назад
Nietzsche is not so anti- Hegelian he maybe wants to be, just remember for example master and slave dialectics. I have always thought his biggest enemy is Platos Socrates, that is to say , the " God like" ( moral) reasoning itself, aka virtues. And yes, Nietzsche , like Hegel believes in progress, but in this sense I think N is a fascist and elitist , maybe an elitist would be better word, cause he hated nationalism. In Geneality of morals he wrote: to speeding up destruction of the majority, that would be progress", so he is not a socialist, that what is certain. Eternal return is not thought experience cause Nietzsche doesn't believe in free will, I think. Heidegger would be big help to understand this concept, I think Nietzsche tried to prove that time is an illusion, cause we need this ( time) in order to suppres our memory, it's about recursion, tail recursion if you will, kind of primitive trivial cases who change history, like Nietzsche himself or Julius Ceasar alea yacta est, only one flip of a coin is allowed, in certain moment you cross a river and flip a coin, this is a true faith test, amor fati and overman.
@gorgon__soup
@gorgon__soup 22 дня назад
Still, Nietzsche adored Napoleon and Goethe for example that exhibit some kind of strength or mastery tbh... He also talked about the love-hate relalationship to the Sheep, in turn implying that he prefers the master mentality even though he has some sympathy for how the weak seem to overcome. I'm not convinced about this interpretation of Nietzsche. This is more a Deleuze interpretation of Nietzsche which should be clarified in the clickbate title.
@GottfriedLeibnizYT
@GottfriedLeibnizYT Месяц назад
Nietzsche may not have been a fascist, but his philosophy is definitely a breeding ground for fascism.
@ouaeeshommous
@ouaeeshommous Месяц назад
That's another one who neither understood a thing about Nietzsche nor from this video.
@lsobrien
@lsobrien Месяц назад
Leibniz may not have been a moron, but his philosophy is definitely a breeding ground for morons.
@GottfriedLeibnizYT
@GottfriedLeibnizYT Месяц назад
@@ouaeeshommous Understanding Nietzsche correctly is irrelevant. It's how he is understood or can be understood.
@ouaeeshommous
@ouaeeshommous Месяц назад
@@GottfriedLeibnizYT that's a very different point from your initial one which is completely a reductionist one. Many, if not every, philosopher or philosophical text could be misinterpreted and be a ground for many extreme thoughts and especially fascism. And this selective process is usually not a misunderstanding, but rather a deliberate process to rationalise fascism, and that does not make this idea or that "definitely a breading ground for fascism". This is insane!
@GottfriedLeibnizYT
@GottfriedLeibnizYT Месяц назад
@@ouaeeshommous Copium.
@11-AisexualsforGod-11
@11-AisexualsforGod-11 Месяц назад
What is a master other then an individual blind to one half of reality like a child scared of the dark? Neich is the champion of western narcissism i guess
@11-AisexualsforGod-11
@11-AisexualsforGod-11 Месяц назад
Slaves welcome.. open boarders! All is One
Далее
Philosophy 101: The Dialectic
36:40
Просмотров 5 тыс.
Guide to Žižek: The Pervert vs. The Neurotic
52:46
Must-have gadget for every toilet! 🤩 #gadget
00:27
Marx’s Most Important Idea
13:57
Просмотров 4,6 тыс.
Nietzsche's Most Dangerous Idea | The Übermensch
18:35
Explained: The Dialectic
13:43
Просмотров 6 тыс.
Masculinity is Fake
11:53
Просмотров 8 тыс.
Why do you postpone yourself?
11:08
Просмотров 885 тыс.
Explained: I Would Prefer Not To
11:00
Просмотров 9 тыс.