Freed Russian prisoner on plight of captives in ‘Putin’s modern-day Gulag’

Подписаться 7 млн

Просмотров 69 тыс.

50% 1

Russian opposition leader Vladimir Kara-Murza was released in the historic prisoner exchange arranged by the Biden White House. Kara-Murza joins MSNBC’s Ali Velshi to explain why he believes “public opinion in the free world is stronger than any dictator.” Friend and activist Bill Browder also joins the conversation.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/...
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#MSNBC #Russia #Putin

Опубликовано:

16 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 199

@hideem1 Месяц назад

So glad you’re out of that horrible place!

@alexisarouge Месяц назад

I don't understand why this doesn't scare every American from voting for the far right this election.

@camelsheit_on_the_walls446 Месяц назад

@alexisarouge Many of them don't even know about these men and their stories, nor about the real Pootin and his regime of horror. As it is, the quicksand "news" of Fox entertainment and its like has them convinced that Russia is some kind of utopia... so much that allegedly at least a couple of trumpers have taken their families with them to go and live there, and they've been finding out it wasn't/isn't the sweet life they expected 🙄

@02markcal Месяц назад

@@alexisarouge Look up the definition of being in a cult.

@HomeMade_Polysynth Месяц назад

@@alexisarouge Because now more and more Americans and Canadians are moving to Russia from their countries, i suppose. From Germany too. And from UK

@VoltisArt 29 дней назад

@@02markcal most of us who have looked that up see it in following Trump instead of supporting each other and the UNITED States of America. Notice how easily we gave up Biden last month? No rioting, no screaming on Twitter, no attacking our neighbors. We were a bit worried, then it passed and we're better off for the change. That's because we believe in saving the country and moving it forward, not worshiping a goldenrod idol regardless of the traitorous rambling that comes out of his mouth.

@user-du2jy6ns2k Месяц назад

So happy to see this guy free - his bravery is humbling ❤

@FriedOrca Месяц назад

Bingo! Compare to the GOP who only had to stand up to Donny's petty nicknames, or being primaried, and couldn't muster the courage.

@mjl9002 Месяц назад

"Hypocrisy is the real cornerstone of the Putin regime - in everything they do." truth

@HomeMade_Polysynth Месяц назад

the same could be said about current us admins) btw this freed "russian" guy is paid by Soros

@raymond9716 Месяц назад

I'm sooo happy Vladimir Kara-Murza is finally free and was devastated for him and his family. I read Bill Browder's 2 books on both Bill and Vladimir's horrific experiences with dictator Putin, how Putin twice poisoned Vladimir, etc. He's sooo lucky to be alive. But thousands of Putin's other political prisoners won't have that chance and are tortured and in jail for 20+ years for speaking out against this murderous tyrant. Bravo for all the human rights work and fight for democratic laws you do, Bill Browder and Vladimir Kara-Murza! Please stay safe and NEVER return to Russia again!

@user-ie1dg7ud6o Месяц назад

Only to be next President of Russia.

@spxram4793 Месяц назад

@@user-ie1dg7ud6o the current one is a Stalin-remake, so Russia should go for any other president to have a future. And, beware of China. They exactly see the weakness of Russia, and they will make use of their knowledge.

@janeck.8695 Месяц назад

It's a great joy to see Vladimir Kara-Murza alive and free. I also wish everybody started paying attention to Bill Browder years ago

@eddielindaa Месяц назад

Courage...selfless The highest virtue What a brave man

@marshtahu5980 Месяц назад

Wow. This guy is a genuine Russian Patriot. Hidden in some god forsaken gulag and come out the other side still smiling. Welcome back.

@GuyMyGuiver-d3p 24 дня назад

Stand by you, Kara-Murza.

@georgine321 Месяц назад

Three of my favorite guys, the Russian, the Canadian and the Brit. So incredibly great to see the three of you having a conversation. Well done, veery well done.

@hypnophonz Месяц назад

I like them for who they are, not where they're from.

@Patbol59 Месяц назад

Vladimir Kara-Murza is certainly one of the bravest men in the world. Huge respect for this man 🙏

@brentlund2272 Месяц назад

Hope he does not go back...........You do not need to prove you are brave.....you have paid your dues !

@cocacola4blood365 Месяц назад

What dues? His actions are crimes only to Putin and his cronies, and that crowd has an ocean of blood on it's hands.

@rebeccadieter6131 Месяц назад

He is one of the prisoners released in the prisoner exchange

@lolawants2008 Месяц назад

I’m so grateful you made it out alive ❤ You are a true patriot & intellectual, & I know we benefit just with your presence in this world.

@Zurpanik Месяц назад

Love to you my friend! Love to all friends of humanity!

@tracythomson2604 Месяц назад

Bravo to you Vladimir Kara-Murza! Glad to see you ALIVE!

@SylviaBolton Месяц назад

It is good to listen to the ones who really know the truth about Russia….

@mztee8107 Месяц назад

Bravo to all who brought this about. Well done, Bill Browder. Kudos. 👏🏼👍🏻

@brianfreeman8290 Месяц назад

You, sir, are the bravest man in Russia.

@KimberN111 Месяц назад

I’m so happy for you and your family, welcome back! What Putin has done, and is doing, is exactly what will happen in the U.S. if Captain Bone Spurs gets back into office. Think about that folks. 💙

@Sundance1987 Месяц назад

Remarkable man Mr. Kara-Murza, exceptional human being. The miracle of the most intricate and determined diplomacy has united this courageous man with his beloved family and friends, and also with the world. --retired child psychologist in Florida, USA.

@SkepticalChris Месяц назад

True courage, is not the absence of fear. True courage, is understanding and knowing that you are afraid, but still doing what must be done. Vladimir Kara-Murza is the living embodiment of true courage. He knew and feared the consequences of speaking out, but he knew he had to do it regardless of the danger to himself or his family.

@lolavanenburg1647 Месяц назад

Great news that this man of principle is finally freed..Let’s hope the rest of the prisoners will also be liberated🙏🏼♥️

@miklek Месяц назад

Brave man👏👏I cannot understand why trump loves putin and wants to be like him...🤷‍♂️

@jannichi6431 Месяц назад

Sociopaths get worse without intervention.

@azarubina Месяц назад

I'm so happy for Vladimir Kara-Murza and for his family, especially for his wife Evgenya. He is a truly patriot!❣

@cathypreston1095 Месяц назад

Thank you for your service Sir. So grateful you are back in your family's arms. All sixteen souls released are true blessings.

@maridela Месяц назад

Amazing, blessings 🙏

@karentorkar8256 Месяц назад

How on earth do they survive in solitary. That would be virtually impossible. It would take enormous mental fortitude. It is happening to political prisoners everywhere. And even worse.

@user-xw9lc2nf2e 29 дней назад

Человек -- существо живучее! 😅

@jannichi6431 Месяц назад

"Velshi" shows good but a Must.see these days on weekend A.M. and Podcast. Thank you for Freedom Fighting. 📢🇨🇦🇺🇸

@JimmiAlli Месяц назад

When will they get rid of Putin?

@jannichi6431 Месяц назад

When Bibi is gone?

@janeinontario Месяц назад

Ukraine's army is having success in Kursk. Putin's response has been very slow. Is this showing his weaknesses? Putin may be close to the end of his reign.

@kerryeklundable Месяц назад

That mans mind is strong as an ox.

@jyrkiseppala3385 Месяц назад

Kara-Murza real hero! ❤️

@mikaellindroos1594 Месяц назад

He is a really tough guy but now stay out of Russia, please.

@shimshonmelamed2888 Месяц назад

It is "difficult" for us to understand...the dictator is not ready to accept the situation...how Russia failed to defeat Ukraine! Most importantly, he will not break the "spirit of freedom" here!!!

@jannichi6431 Месяц назад

🇺🇲📢🫶🩵💝🇺🇦

@eno.5796 Месяц назад

Amazingly Courageous man of true integrity.Perfect example of to have the courage of one's convictions.Bravo Sir!

@peacenow4456 Месяц назад

Vlad stay away from Russia this time!! Glad you are out. Stay out! And so respect both of them Bill Browder! You are stronger outside Russia! Dead is forever silence.

@adamgta6960 Месяц назад

This news of Kara-Murzas’ release is a blessing onto this world. If you read this comment VKM, Please don’t go back to Russia again until after Putin is dethroned. You are such a good man, but take this win, and be with your wife and son. Enjoy your life, you are a true hero.

@henrikarboejensen812 Месяц назад

Americans. Connect the dots, please. Trump like Putin.

@CACar_Nation Месяц назад

Trump doesn’t do war. You forgot about that

@igortchernowitzer927 Месяц назад

He condones putin to start wars @CACar_Nation

@judyweeks1480 Месяц назад

@@CACar_Nation trump bows down to dictators.

@katewoolf6059 Месяц назад

Someone lend their private island in Caribbean to Kara-Murza! This man needs to rest, eat & get some SUN!! His arms are too thin, his eyes are sunken, his chin is too evident 💔

@brandonhunter3036 Месяц назад

Glad to see that guy is out. I only pray he doesn’t offer himself up again as a Putin bargaining chip.

@troshko1 Месяц назад

Kara-Murza is such a well spoken and educate man. Wish him all the luck in the world. And hopefully soon, he will lead russia.

@nzclassictv6347 Месяц назад

Can you imagine Trump working to get these people freed. He'd more likely praise Putin for stamping out all opposition as he aspires to.

@dmangela5677 Месяц назад

Why not award Vladamir Kara-Murza American citizenship?

@loranv3435 Месяц назад

Tears of JOY 😂 Welcome Back 😊 HELP your Family and Friends

@2Uahoj Месяц назад

Amazing guy. Kind of a Russian Vaclav Havel.

@charlotteb4081 Месяц назад

Welcome Home Friend ❤

@rikkitikkiusa Месяц назад

Kara-Murza and Bill Browder are among my heroes and I hope I never had to be that brave. If we vote for DEmocrats, we can hope to avoid dictators for another 4 years. Every 4 years is precious when this kind of pressure is on our country and the West from the lies lies lies lies of the evil ones.

@Katiegirlluv Месяц назад

I almost lost total hope hearing Vladimir was ill in prison. So thankful he is feee!!! 🎉

@ColleenC-n5v Месяц назад

So beautiful to hear the wisdom of Kara Murzas heroic voice….a sage among men🌻🌻🌻☮☮☮💜💜💜✝✝🌻🌻

@gijbfhjm Месяц назад

Meanwhile he is asking to remove sanctions (from terrible Gulag which kept him)

@SanandaIAM Месяц назад

Freedom isn't free. ❤

@user-yg3wx4mq4o Месяц назад

Such a beautiful family!

@KevinE80 Месяц назад

No American or anyone who lives in the West should ever visit Russia.

@daveb6815 Месяц назад

The future president of the Russian federation

@hypnophonz Месяц назад

Welcome back to the free world Kara-Murza ! ! !

@rightfulheir9014 Месяц назад

I am very happy for Vladimir Kara Murza, but there are so many people like him that no one knows about. One can only imagine what kind of torment they went through before their death, and if they are still alive, what kind of suffering they are experiencing now. And what do their relatives feel when they know how their relatives and friends are suffering in prison.

@JanetteRuncie 29 дней назад

Great Interview So glad he`s speaking out

@02markcal Месяц назад

What a brave man and a true Russian patriot.

@VCE4 29 дней назад

You can literally lose your mind in conditions like this. This is outrageous.

@thomassanchez-oo6sb Месяц назад

To The Russian People Alexi Navalny gave up his Life to try to make Russia Free… what are the Russian people willing to do for their country ✌🏼❤️🇺🇸🇺🇦🇺🇦🇷🇺

@sittinandthinkin 29 дней назад

Bill Browder wasn't friends with Magnitsky. Magnitsky was a lawyer in his firm that he "knew".

@HomayounSafavian-mj9qs 28 дней назад

Greatest complements to Bill Bauder, Vladimir Karamorsa , Late Russian Heros Alexi Navalni, and Buris Nemsuf . These people are true pillars of humanity in today’s politics

@JanetteRuncie 29 дней назад

Thanks Bill for all you done for Vladimir Nothing greater in this World than the power of Love. Nothing could match it. Love brought Vladimir home.

@Mike-tb3ci Месяц назад

Not since Stalin has Russia had such a wonderful leader.

@Mike-tb3ci Месяц назад

History will judge these two men one a hero and a patriot the other a murderer and a thug

@jannichi6431 Месяц назад

Heroes upon heroes for Righteousness and Freedoms. Does Browder have any plans to help produce documentaries?

@arnovriends5873 Месяц назад

Glad you are back mr. Kara-Murza and reunited with your family, I hope you'll be part of a better Russia and the rebuilding of it's institutions, free press and proper democracy in the hopefully near future. also as a trustworthy partner in rebuilding Ukraine.

@EJODHIS 28 дней назад

What a story of courage and sacrifice. Unbelievable he survived and is free. Can’t help but notice his resemblance to another famous “Vladimir” from the past!

@leannevandekew1996 Месяц назад

Have you ever had a Trump Sandwich. A trump sandwich consists of toasted white bread, with an orange glaze on the outside, it's full of baloney with Russian dressing and a small pickle on the side. You can substitute the pickle for a small mushroom head.

@winstonsmith8565 Месяц назад

Have you heard the one about chick pea? What about rust and insanity? Phone spurs? Did I tell you about the time I worked at McDonalds and Trump hit on me? I was 15 at the time. Now I'm a supermodel and lead chemist at a chemical manufacturing center. And a nurse. Also an astronaut and Olympic medalist in pickleball

@LukoMartinez Месяц назад

if he goes back I hope he doesn't expect for USA to get him out again! tuck your tail and stay safe!

@dboy7161 Месяц назад

He should have never let u out

@georgine321 Месяц назад

Now...what can we do to help?

@anitakranitz6845 Месяц назад

WHERE IS LAWRENCE?????? DID THEY FIRE HIM?

@gijbfhjm Месяц назад

He doesn’t look like he was at Gulag. Look at Ukrainian POW returning from Gulag.

@guy.l8147 Месяц назад

Like saakashvili !! , he's in Georgian prison at the request of putin !! .

@Katiegirlluv Месяц назад

😢😢

@inzhener2007 Месяц назад

Comparison Russia with 1984 is correct but not entirely .

@Katiegirlluv Месяц назад

@getoffmylawnbeech Месяц назад

Vladimir you cannot go back, not until we get Putina! It is good to see you!

@michellediamsaymendoza Месяц назад

He must have written well-spoken English in that gulag because the words are flowing like he’s not from Orange County, California.

@olusegunjuba5142 29 дней назад

Putin is a beast and so also are is friends.

@igortchernowitzer927 Месяц назад

I am still perplexed at why he went back to russian fascist reich.

@elaineburnett5230 Месяц назад

Vladimir. Is back

@andreaserafini1688 Месяц назад

Putin has managed to keep the territory of Russia together, including what is above and what is below. The opponents, the oligarchs, the dissidents wanted to tear it to pieces. Everything revolves around this thesis.

@VoltisArt 29 дней назад

This is our future if Donald Trump returns to the White House - not as a hero against suffering, but as its cause, another country imprisoning people for merely disagreeing with the handful of people in power over the rest. VOTE.

@artandenglish_kate Месяц назад

So, let's sum up: V.V. Kara-Murza was almost killed three times: -1st poisoning in Moscow -2nd poisoning in Moscow -prison sentence He survived all three times. Now he says he is going to try his luck for the fourth time (going back to Russia). Does he think he is a cat with 9 lives? God Loves Trinity is more realistic, in his case.

@doraglenjordon7354 Месяц назад

These are the news stories that matter and will soon replace the ranting, raving, crazed rambling voice of Trump

@yuliiadorofeieva2969 27 дней назад

He looks too good as for person who thought he was going to die in russian prison😮 Or who is he

@1952bane Месяц назад

Putin has gone out of rails... But please tell us about your selfish "exceptionalism"?

@thomasmcmahon1263 Месяц назад

Me too he wants to make russia better but he's going to find it difficult some countries are difficult to save hope he doesn't return

@johnmcdonnell4216 29 дней назад

Putin must go soon!

@urbansahlin1285 Месяц назад

Trump ❤ Putin

@mariondowney4103 Месяц назад

Ben is head of the Heritage foundation and Heads up project 2025

@yuliiadorofeieva2969 27 дней назад

Why not show soldiers or civilians who returned from Russian captivity, same as Aslan Eidin you can ask Azov soldiers about conditions as there is no worse fate than be in russian prisons even one day

@meilinchan7314 28 дней назад

Vladimir Kara-Murza looks a bit like Vladimir "Lenin" Ulyanov.

@youtuberkolos Месяц назад

3 bald men ...

@alexklec-pilewski960 Месяц назад

So how did the articles get past the prison walls, did he email them????????????????????????

@miklek Месяц назад

He got them out through his lawyer

@Lilian-fh2ve 29 дней назад

Bless HIM AND BLESS JOE BIDEN...THE LORD MUST have love JOE BIDEN 🙏 a lot to accede to BIDEN REQUEST that is bothering his mind and make it possilble for his friend behalf..to be released.. I feel very sorry for this GOOD MAN That at last he is saved....🙏🙏God take care of him and his family ❤

@Serendipity818 28 дней назад

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

@susangribble6830 Месяц назад

WE WANT TRUMP❤❤❤❤❤❤WE WANT TRUMP❤❤❤❤❤WE WANT TRUMP❤❤❤❤❤

@HomeMade_Polysynth Месяц назад

Then why more and more Americans and Canadians are now moving to Russia from their countries. From Germany too. And from UK. Quite intelligent people a have to admit.

@wendywhite4929 Месяц назад

Dude you totally misquoted Orwell

@jont2228 Месяц назад

Trump 2024💯🫵💯

@odedao Месяц назад

Its just amazing how many "Russian opposition leader" the western media loves to throw around. if he has been speaking out at the age of 16, how come we are just hearing about him now. This is getting boring now

@solracblonde9480 Месяц назад

O, I guess he doesn't know that in the United States, many of our citezens are in solitary confinement. Some kept there for many many years.

@eliljeho Месяц назад

I think he does

@solracblonde9480 Месяц назад

@eliljeho I'm sure he does, so I guess he knows we torture our people here as well. If Putin has his way and Trump wins, then our prisons will be filled with political enemies as well.