[FULL] Mariah Carey - Hero (Live in France - April 30th, 2023) 

She’s working on her legato again. She isn’t taking as many breaths between every couple words like before. Her upper register is still not there, but her mid register sounds good to me. I like how people just shut up and listen, she still delivers this song really nicely considering everything her voice has been through. She could stick with her mid register for the rest of her life and she’d still sound incredible to me.

I can feel that she wants to give more but the voice can't. I am a fan and I salute her showing up even not at her best because it's her passion and she loves her fans so much. Nothing to prove here. She's made her mark. She will always be The Mariah Carey. No one can touch her legacy. Hope she can do a concert here in The Philippines. ❤️✨🇵🇭

No matter how her voice sounds.. when it comes to this song, it always fits her better than anyone else...

2:23 you can tell she made this up on the spot

3:49 omfg that downwards run is amazing

Mother is sounding so good! Her smile at 0:35 says it all - she knows she sounds good!

You see. Mariah set the bar too HIGH even for Herself, and it’s not a bad thing at all. It just proofs how talented and gifted she is

it’s crazy how better she’s gotten in a few months, i love her sm

her voice definitely doesnt sound as constricted and bad as last year. Her vocal ability is back to about 2019 again.

It's lovely seeing her singing live even just in the small crowd. The voice is actually there and she can still sing beautifully and I'm waiting to some of her video clips this year.

0:55 AttempRiah having her moment.

Every time I hear her sing this song, it really hits me differently. The song, itself, is already inspiring, but the way she delivers it is so different. It has that emotion like telling you what the song is really all about. ❤️

Ok let's keep it real, her voice is shot. To hear perhaps the greatest female voice of all time struggle in this way is genuinely sad, but even in this condition she has moments of genius that display her musicianship. The consolation is she has zero left to prove. She was given the most incredible gift and shared every last ounce of it with all of us - all whilst inspiring a new generation of singers. Thank you forever MC.

Reading these comments, I expected worse but actually she sounds more fluid and better than last year. Satisfactory despite being hoarse.

She did good here. Some people can't let her live

Just got off work and seeing this just warms my heart. It’s so good to see her singing still. Forget about the notes and all that extra bs. Just the fact that this legend is still on stage doing what she was born to do after all these years looking amazing and sounding great is just so awesome

She sounds really good here. Well-balanced resonated voice. I hope she can adjust this song's range to suit her current voice better. Generally, beautiful performance!

0:08 the tone on “your heart” is straight out of the 90s

omg she slayed this down. She looks real comfortable but also really nervous at the same time. She has a lot of really good moments

You are the first to upload the full slay ✨️

She did that totally live which is awesome.

I can’t imagine what it costs to have Mariah perform at your wedding …

The confidence!! She’s so comfortable here and it shows vocally!

She sounds sooo good

She doesn't be like a singer now. Take a deep rest at home. God bless her.

3:36 again, these downwards runs have me shook

Wow this performance is good. She was physically shaking but she still sounded nice. The falsetto was on point and her mid belting range was good. I mean if she had not been that nervous she would have sung that song better but I'm not complaining at all.

jesus 🔥🔥😍that really fast run on "knows" 2:24

I just find it disrespectful to talk and have full conversations while someone is singing😢 like wtf and then this is a legend in front of them

I have so much respect for Mariah. I can honestly not even fathom what it must be like to go through so much vocally and have to find your way to work with how your voice changes. All I can say is that I will love every single note she ever sings. We see how much she's working on improving her voice, and I for one can really hear the difference with a couple of years ago, she is not only improving with how she sounds but MUCH MORE IMPORTANTLY: she seems happy. And thats all I want for her. And for real, the 2:40 belt really made me emotional. It wasn't large or anything, but I didn't expect her to touch upon that note so I was baffled. Thank you for being you Mariah!

Woahh its easy for her to switching head and chest voice 😍 I can say her voice is well rested from that day. Awesome! ❤

Her voice come from the angels i always loved you and always will my queen mimi ❤️

She's getting much better ❤

she sounds good. very fluid and full. raspy yes but that’s normal

Ion care what yall say, I prefer her live raw vocals over a prerecorded track anyday! 🫶🏾🫶🏾🫶🏾🫶🏾

She's getting better

Y’all say “as lamb” to hold some weight but the real is the lady has been singing and over singing constantly for the last 30 years. Mind you she has been the laughed at, ridiculed, and often thrown aside as a joke because she’s not singing the same at 53 when she was 25. You’d never treat Aretha, Whitney, or Celine like this who all faced MAJOR vocal decline why is Mariah the subject to bullying? Mariah is a gift from GOD and her voice is still in good shape maybe it could be better if she got her nodules taken out who knows but one thing about MY MOTHER is that she is not afraid to fight.

At least she’s singing live so I love it 🥰

She seemed very relaxed and it showed through her singing. This performance was much better that I expected. She doesn’t have anything to prove. I just love to see her in her light doing what she loves ✨🫶🏽

I don't think it's bad. Of course we all expect more from her, especially since her schedule hasn't been very hectic in the last 3 years, so she got plenty of time to rest. (I detest when lambs say her voice is tired because of all the singing she does in the studio: if that would be true, she actually would sound so much better! Exercise helps). She bragged so much about having her voice back during the pandemic. I had very high expectations, which were crushed in December. Her Christmas shows were painful to watch, which was unusual since her vocals on the AIWFCIY tours used to be stellar under any circumstances. The last time her career had gone quiet between her pregnancy and Idols her voice had become stronger than ever. Check out her shows at Gotham Hall (NY) and Sporting Monaco (Montecarlo) in 2012 plus her performance on Idols 2013. So why this time resting was not enough to rescue her uber-damaged voice? 1.Age and nodules conditions 2.Bad habits (drinking/partying) 3.Lack of proper vocal exercise. Some people say she should remove her vocals since they had gotten so bad she can barely carry a tune anymore. I think she should. I know she's afraid of losing her voice like Julie Andrews did in '97, but there's plenty of successful cases (including Adele, Sam Smith etc..) which proves medicine has developed over time and surgery can give amazing results. I know she relies on AIWFCIY, private gigs and brands affiliations to pay her bills, but what if she could have one last trip around the sun as one of the best vocalists that ever lived? No pre-recorded bullshit, no rehashing old hits, no dummy "diva gimmicks": just her and her voice. One new album and a 2 year residency at the Beacon Theatre. No dancers, no stupid corsets, just her singing her heart out in a pair of blue jeans and a t-shirt (as homage to Glitter). Come on..... She's 53...it's now or never.

Wow she sounded great!! ❤❤❤

So many of you in here just criticise her & after what’s she been through I don’t think any of you can still sing the way she sing. So learn how to shut up & listen. Or skip the video & move on!

It's Mariah live! 😍

y'all aren't giving her enough credit. the only thing she's lacking a bit right now is some confidence and a bit of belting range. but everything else has made significant improvements. go back to when she would perform hero in 2016. this sounds *way* more fluid and less constricted. the legato improvements are terrific. but enough of the hyperanalyzing, we love you and support you always mimi!!!

Thanks Mariah, we love you ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ beautiful singing.

She sounds amazing. I love it. ❤

Thank you😭😭😭 Been finding for the full footage

Let's just enjoy her presence while she still exist. I really enjoyed her whispery sound here. I wish she does more of that sound , and stay in her rich midbelts.

Jus looking at Mariah Carey would make me tear up if i ever saw her in concert and hearing her sing always make me feel better.

Much better thank you God!!! It’s more softer and not choppy

2:10 to 2:17 the way she sits and sings to a person, so wholesome

This is very good version of her lately. Love Mother MIMI always.

She sounds amazing 😍 love Mimi

She sounds so good!!! Omg that was great, she served vocals!

Wow... she has improved on the performance in this song a lot. You can tell she's been taking better care of her vocals. I don't know if it'll ever be as it was back in the 90s and early 00s, but you can definitely see the growth.

She looks so beautiful and more natural here and golden.

She looks amazing. 💜

0:01 her falsetto sounded so sublime!

Ela só precisa de confiar em seu potencial novamente, sem medo de errar, arriscar mais ao vivo!! Eu nao me importo que ela desafine ou que sua voz quebre pois essa é a realidade atual, se ela deixasse o medo e a insegurança de lado ao cantar tenho certrza que ela soaria mais confortavel no palco!!!

the voice cracks.. but her aura and her presence.. that alone is what makes this performance ethereal...

What happened to her voice?? OMG!

Mariah's biggest competition will always be herself from previous eras. I do my best not to compare and instead I just listen and enjoy.

I would love to see Mariah evolve her career by restarting Crave Records. She is such a force in the music industry and she could guide the music industry so much as an executive. Much more coin too.

A big improvement over last year. She's still having problems with her upper belts but she's sounding a lot more fluid and no breathing problems like last year. And her tone sounds so lovely too.

It’s perfect!!! 🔥✨✨

This is painful to watch. SHE is a beast in her prime unfortunately she prolly hasnt been taking a good care of her voice

She so beautiful 😮❤

Always love her to sing this song❤

Live is too good ❤❤❤

This was pretty tough to watch. It’s like she wants to give you more, but her voice just won’t go where she wants it to. Major props to showing up, and still working through this performance. A real professional

I love love Mariah her songs mean so much to me

Wow,she couldn't do the alternate "Lord knows" either. I can just imagine how she feels. Mariah I think its time to get professional help (and take it) if she hasn't already.

The voice is not gone…thats her gift she was born with it…she just needs to adjust to where it is today & not try & sing like 20 years ago & she will be fine.

Her tone here is reminiscent of 2001-2002. I think she pretty much sang Hero the same way during this era and I prefer it.

43 46 she singing softly she's doing fine. She stay that way I love her dearly

Mariah looks great love this she sounds good healthy #FOREVER LEGEND ❤️

2023, Fantástico!!Mariah sigue teniendo una voz genial!

If I'm honest, this was hard to get through. I can't even lie. But she looks amazing, and will always be a vocal legend. 💛

As pessoas são injustas com ela, ela tem nódulos! Mariah tem muita qualidade vocal!

Alcohol isnt vocal chords' friend

Omgg yass, Do you have the my all 2nd chorus or cimax clips? 😭

she sounds so good SLAYYYYY

it's not flawless, she's still struggling with the high notes but this performance is so much better than last year.

still great performance by my mimi diva😘❤️

Absolutly thé most butifull woman god created

Why do everyone become voice specialists under Mariah videos where is that same energy with other artists great job Mariah 55 and strong

Devemos ter respeito a está artista que encantou e encanta gerações ela tem alguns caroços nas cordas vocais a muitos anos por isto não consegue dar as notas mais ainda deixa muitos cantores no chinelo

Acredito que ela voltará a cantar como sempre o fez..está se dedicando e também parece mais feliz. Pra mim sempre será Diva❤ love M.Carey😊

She sounds good to me, keep singing Mariah ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉

A voz está linda

I'm really loving this, the changing notes and addlibs were on point🙌❤

I swear the lambs are the worst. I read the comments before seeing the video and was expecting a disaster, but it was actually okay.

It’s quite sad to see her big decline in recent few years since 2019. Even though she’s capable to hit that note 0:56 in the first verse in a forceful way, her current voice condition (weaker stamina for demanding songs and nodules?) doesn’t allow her do that again in the second verse 2:08

Mariah sempre lindíssima demostrando carinho com os fãs Ylove AMO muito filha lindas

Wow Diva world no 1

Won der full i love it ♥️

Please upload the rest of the show (if you have the footages)! 🙏

Oh thank god she has finally realised her staccato sounds terrible and lazy and has stopped doing it. Bravo! This was beautiful ❤

I lowkey loce tha “you can FIND love” part 🤭

The voice is still there Mariah just needs more vocal rest but the voice and tone are definitely there. From 2:20 the fluidity in the voice is there consistently through to the end of the song. It’s almost as if the first half with the nodules warmed up her voice because you can hear the fluidity in the IN TIME YOUR FIND THE WAY!! And it was all live. Y’all can count her out.. I will never.. On her worst day they could never emulate her tone or captivate her musicality.