Gotta say that that clip was brilliant. A truly hard comparison. Both work so hard, Dusty is a better mark, in fact I was a better mark but Buddy is 6'6 tall. That is a huge advantage. Before you argue I love Buddy & am a Swans fan. Buddy is the best long goal freak probably even including Peter Hudson. Yeah I'm that old, in fact I used to watch Sergio Silvagni play. Both are incredible ground ball players but Dusty wins this one by a small amount. That Buddy is that good down low considering his height is a feature of his freak. I was 6'1, Dusty size but in those days the main tap ruck. I had leap factor but my ground skills sucked so I can only admire it in others. Dusty is in his prime, Buddy isn't so young anymore. I wondered if he should be playing in 2019. Management of injuries as you get older as they play havoc in your life after footy is not fun. Both of them are also very difficult to snag,
Mids and mid/forwards will probably pick dusty, key backs and forwards will pick franklin. Can't compare them, both one of a kind players that are definitely in the GOAT conversation
