It is absolutely crock shit ridiculous that Carrie didn't make this group. She is a fantastic singer. Simply fantastic, with great stage presence and charisma. But Robin went with looks instead, so Natalie and Crys are in while Carrie is out.
I always found the storyline of this song hilarious. Chrys couldn't remember the words to the opening, so they switched her last minute and she memorized a brand new half of the verse right away. :P
See, Carrie was my favorite. But she didn't fit this criteria. While her voice was phenomenal and she was gorgeous and sweet, she wasn't the "sexy-girl-group" type. She deserved better.
@galveston I know right... "Beauty is a talent!" In my opinion the strongest were Charlye, Tiffanie, and Nichole because all three of them could sing and dance and never let the competition get to them. I also like Carrie, and Ilisa,
Jarretsabean exactly Christina and Natalie were bitches they didn't cared about girlicious at all because they both ended up leaving they only got chosen because of Natalies looks and Cristina was her bff by that time, tiff should've never been axed she cared, nichole proved she cared when she was the only member left in girlicious and Charlye should've been in there so much all 3 of them got a long, carrie I didn't cared about her that much but I guess now that you mentioned it she could've been that extra 4th member. She also was an amazing singer they didn't pick her because of her age and how she struggled with the dancing routines
Seriously i hate that Carrie got kicked out for not "meshing" with the group because of the vocals because as much as i LOVE the Girlicious Album and Tiff she didnt mesh either...I mean she was over the top in almost every song on the album and she didnt match...i dunno i think Carrie is more Girlicious anyway...But Chrys was my FAV and she made it...They sound better now that its just 3 tho...Nic, Nat, and Chrys sound WAY better now =) Carrie is in a rock girl group FYI =p
@galveston I actually think Carrie, Jenna, Chrystina and Tiffanie had the best voices, Out of the three left now, Chrystina defiantly outshines the other two in vocals.
@xXMakeMeSwayXx If the four girlicious members were based on actual vocal chops, it was Carrie, Charlye, Jenna, and Ilisa who should have been chosen. Nicole and Tiffanie were also good, but Natalie and Chrystina got in on their looks IMO.
Christina was supposed to open the song but she kept on forgetting the words, and she was a mess at rehearsal so they switch parts and gave it to Carrie
well carrie ROX but they booted her cuz robin felt tha rockin' carrie is better off a solo artist and the pretty natalie needed a group for support. BUT THEY BOTH RULE!
Carrie, Natalie, Nichole, and Jenna for me. You gotta have vocals, dance skills, looks, and stage presence/charisma. what Carrie and Jenna lacks, Natalie and Nichole makes up. it's a balance; works out better,
Carrie got a contract? By whom? That's great news. :) No, the winners aren't bad singers, but the kind of music Girlicioius producers is all about image and the glitz. It's overproduced. Think of En Vogue and how rich their songs were--it was about the *music* rather than the image. Actually, I think Chrystina is the most talented of the 4 winners. It's a shame she isn't singing ballads; she *really* has the voice for it. Tiff's good a good voice, but Nicole's is too baby doll for me.
No, I'm not saying that Carrie isn't good looking. Carrie's very cute, but she isn't "tarty" looking enough. Robin wanted heavy on the slutty/tarty look. I'm sorry, but the emphasis *is* on the girls' looks instead of the music. Girlicious is a long way from the days of En Vogue, who were sexy but had real music that invoked real emotion and meant something. The best voices of the 12 were Carrie, Ilisa, Alexis, and Jenna. Have you heard Alexis singing her own music? She's great.
There's nothing wrong with an attractive image unless it supercedes the importance of the music. Nat is a pretty girl who's an "okay" singer. Why did she make the group over Carrie, Jenna or Charlye? Why was she put in at all when there were originally only plans for three girls? The only answer is that Natalie was included for her looks. I hate the songs produced so far. It's about the image and not the music. TIffanie should be singing songs with power and substance that evoke emotion.
Tiffany's voice is horrible. I still can't beleive she was put in the group. I wish they had just given Carrie more dance training and put her in the group.
