Тёмный

Going Head-to-Head with James Churchward about the LOST CONTINENT OF MU 

World of Antiquity
Подписаться 248 тыс.
Просмотров 34 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

29 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 503   
@lindenstromberg6859
@lindenstromberg6859 21 день назад
The influence of Mu may be greater than just humanity. I heard some bovines talking about Mu.
@andersand6576
@andersand6576 21 день назад
I am cow hear me mu. I weight twice as much as you. And I look good on a barbecue. (:
@andrewblackard3369
@andrewblackard3369 21 день назад
That must the the source of the legends that Wisconsin is the legendary Land of Moo.
@lucasroche8639
@lucasroche8639 21 день назад
😂
@bodnica
@bodnica 21 день назад
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@oldguy6976
@oldguy6976 21 день назад
😂😂
@algi1
@algi1 21 день назад
Interesting how in kaiju and other Japanese sci-fi movies Mu is very prominent. I guess, their pop culture latched on to Mu in a similar way Western pop culture latched on to Atlantis.
@howbootu
@howbootu 21 день назад
I guess mu is easy to say in Japanese. And Atlantis not so much. It would be like a-tu-ra-n-ti-su. Whereas mu would just be mu.
@NovaSaber
@NovaSaber 21 день назад
I think English-speaking writers just don't like the name "Mu". Even when they put a lost continent where Mu supposedly was, they often call it something else (sometimes Lemuria, even though that's supposed to be the Indian Ocean's lost continent); and at least one Japanese-to-English dub ("Mysterious Cities of Gold") changed Mu to a different name.
@garymaidman625
@garymaidman625 20 дней назад
​@@NovaSaberinterestingly, Mu is a letter in the Greek alphabet.
@juanausensi499
@juanausensi499 20 дней назад
Being in the Pacific, it makes more geographical sense.
@bipolarminddroppings
@bipolarminddroppings 20 дней назад
​​@@juanausensi499the Australian aboriginal people probably have a similar myth with the continent/island located near them. Humans are humans, we tell similar stories because we have similar experiences. The European/Mediterranean Atlantis myth might be based upon a kind of cultural memory of Doggerland or some other landmass that was swallowed up by the seas long ago.
@103cubobo
@103cubobo 21 день назад
Just once I'd like to hear about a lost continent whose people where just, like, fine. Not particularly advanced or anything.
@PlatinumAltaria
@PlatinumAltaria 21 день назад
Does Doggerland count?
@Moishe555
@Moishe555 20 дней назад
@@PlatinumAltaria It only counts if its inhabitants taught everyone how to build a pyramid
@cyan1616
@cyan1616 20 дней назад
The real secret is that these "advanced" civilizations weren't all that advanced, they probably just had a better way to make pottery or ax heads, maybe they were tinkering around with making really efficient plows. These were once big technology, and they were all just regular civilizations like everyone else.
@gabriellavedier9650
@gabriellavedier9650 21 день назад
I was actually familiar with the concept of Mu very early. The video game "Illusion of Gaia" and the semi-sequel "Terranigma" both used Mu as optional mystery continents for the game, as they roughly took place on sort-of Earth. Also my high school library had books about Mu.
@ThatBoomerDude56
@ThatBoomerDude56 21 день назад
I always thought *"Mu"* was equated to and an abbreviation of *Lemuria.* Somewhat intriguing when I heard about it 50 years ago but I always thought it was mostly nonsense. Largely because of the tectonic plate thing. And also the Maya & Inca & etc. timeline is just wildly off from the supposed Atlantis/Lemuria/Mu timeline.
@jamescobban857
@jamescobban857 13 дней назад
When Jules Verne wrote The Mysterious Island the core of the plot was The Swiss Family Robinson but he wanted to set the story at the exact opposite side of the World from Paris. But Swiss Family Robinson was set in the Malay archipelago, so Verne had to exploit a reference to Mu to explain how continental animals are found on his imaginary remote Pacific island.
@JMM33RanMA
@JMM33RanMA 21 день назад
Le Plaongeon was the same kind of imaginative fantasist or grifter as Sitchin, who pretended to translate Sumerian before real scientists had done so. The so called translations of the Egyptian book of the dead by Joseph Smith are the same. That the hieroglyphs have been reliably translated has had little impact on the true believers who prefer opinion and belief to science. This is, unfortunately, also true of the followers of other pseudo-archaeologists and fantasists. EDIT: After commenting I remembered some reading from decades ago. Casey and Blavatsky claimed to have communicated with the dead. Their proof was what they had dreamed, or interpretations thereof. This brand of fantasist bunkum is not new, but the end of the 19th and early 20th Centuries seem to have been a hotbed of such tripe.
@barbarossarotbart
@barbarossarotbart 21 день назад
The reason why all theories about lost continents are doomed to fail? Plate tectonics!
@njalsand133
@njalsand133 19 дней назад
The game terranigma was the first time I've ever about Mu decades ago.
@curiousmonster8221
@curiousmonster8221 20 дней назад
A very learned way of calling it all bullshit. 😄
@exittomenu
@exittomenu 21 день назад
my gods, you can literally just say anything and someone somewhere will bite lol
@waynemyers2469
@waynemyers2469 21 день назад
and, voila, you have discovered the Washington Democrat.
@konsumterra1
@konsumterra1 21 день назад
a classic - Lemuria wiill complete the phantom continent trilliogy
@Its_Shaun_the_Sheep
@Its_Shaun_the_Sheep 21 день назад
Please SUBSCRIBE for common sense!
@pcatful
@pcatful 21 день назад
The word Maya is developed by Europeans from “Mayapan”, the late capital (post 900 CE). It’s not a word from ancient times.
@almitrahopkins1873
@almitrahopkins1873 20 дней назад
Art being “interpreted” as writing is usually indicative of theosophy in the late 19th and early 20th century. It’s a weird “religion” that believed that every written text is a religious text. You get a lot of the Atlantis bullshit out of theosophy and its offshoots, like the Thulian Society. Personally, I always thought it was just a result of a sort of inferiority complex that came from there not being things like the pyramids that existed in Africa and the Americas in Europe. Blavatsky and the other adherents of Theosophy were heavily involved in eugenics that was popular at the time as well. Their beliefs in the inferiority of other races were justified by their belief that there was a lost advanced culture, which you can no doubt remember being influential in certain German regime in the last century.
@dsharpness
@dsharpness 20 дней назад
T's so...witness the quarreling among the major religions about which is first, Ur, Mu religion...but, we are one species, of a forgetful sort, not unlike other specis!...the example put forward is the early Egypt was more skilled in monument building than the Ptolemy Egypt...early Egypt was Mu like, like all of a sudden there...we've lost the steps they took...we record our steps, like the invention of flight...but four thousand years from now, how will flying be remembered?...memory is a bone of contention....
@frankvandorp9732
@frankvandorp9732 19 дней назад
That doesn't apply here at all though. This guy with his Mu theory essentially posits the Mayans as the ancestors from whom all civilization originated, with China, India and the Middle East adopting it from them, and white Europeans living on the farthest fringes, one of the last peoples to be civilized. Not exactly the story that German regime loved to tell, with their beliefs about the superiority of that race.
@almitrahopkins1873
@almitrahopkins1873 19 дней назад
@@frankvandorp9732 It comes from the same place, not that the two were connected. Sorry if I didn’t make that clear. This is the same hyperdiffusion theory, just with a different origin and outcome.
@petertaysum8947
@petertaysum8947 21 день назад
The British Empire's involvement in India (and the Middle East) sparked genuine interest in the history and geography of these lands back in the West. Whether it was the Engineers pioneering the railway networks, or Military and Administrative personnel (Sir Henry Rawlinson is a great example), many were fascinated by the ancient cultures that were evident. There were the Plant gatherers, combing the foothills of the Himalayas. A vast quantity of information was gathered that Academia was eager to consume. And so was a growing middle class and increasingly literate working class, and an expanding publishing industry was eager to exploit. Writers such as Haggard and Arthur Conan Doyle were immensely popular. Fakes and forgeries could be found in the bazaars from Suez to Hong Kong. Then add in some forbidden territories such as Tibet, that old "they" are hiding something from us and ... Now we have MCU, LOTR, Star Wars, Dune and 40K. The appetite for fantasy is insatiable.
@1lightheaded
@1lightheaded 21 день назад
For a moment, I thought you were referring to Henry Rawlinson from Rawlinsons End. .
@dmorenol01
@dmorenol01 21 день назад
so Mu was 2 to 3 times the size of Australia? Wow...
@J_LorraineK
@J_LorraineK 21 день назад
It seems to me that Churchward should have just written a novel and presented his fiction honestly. 😮
@armok409
@armok409 21 день назад
That's what frustrates me about pseudohistorians, they could have used their creativity towards a perfectly benign and entertaining end, probably contribute to humanity's cultural achievements in a meaningful way too, but no, they decide that they want to confuse the masses and make actual historian's lives more difficult... It always is nice to see it when pseudohistorical nonsense like Atlantis (or Mu) is treated as the pure fiction it ought to have been treated as from the start, taken down a peg if you will, doubly so when we have a legend like Dr. Miano debunk those who promote such things as supposed fact.
@julietfischer5056
@julietfischer5056 20 дней назад
A lot of these folks believed they'd made great discoveries. When Churchward and Donnelly wrote, archaeology was still about collecting things for museums or private display. Glorified treasure hunting, even as many of the looters/collectors tried to understand these ancient and contemporary cultures.
@julietfischer5056
@julietfischer5056 20 дней назад
@@armok409- To be fair, archaeology and anthropology were still developing as sciences. The shadows of white superiority and the Bible-as-sober-history were cast over darn near everything. Those peoples who hadn't needed to invent wheels, guns, and cities were considered 'stuck in the Stone Age' and inherently primitive and simple-minded. That world wanted an explanation for the great cities (ruined or not) in lands inhabited by dark-skinned people. And there were these stories of ancient civilizations, and misunderstandings of myths and legends, and Plato's Atlantis. And there were these ruins and other structures on islands in the Pacific, and in the Americas, and in Africa to explain. And the comforting idea was an ancient Aryan civilization that taught the brown world how to do more than eat, sleep, and screw. And there were plenty of enthusiastic True Believers who might (not) be educated in what little was known about ancient languages and cultures. People who thought all writing systems were alphabets and 'translated' ancient texts and carvings in weird ways. Or who couldn't shake their cultural ideas enough to try to see things differently from usual. Plus, yes, any number of fakers and con artists.
@Cat_Woods
@Cat_Woods 7 дней назад
@@armok409 "It always is nice to see it when pseudohistorical nonsense like Atlantis (or Mu) is treated as the pure fiction it ought to have been treated as from the start" Yes! Same with religious mythology. Always refreshing when religious mythology is treated as mythology rather than history.
@rossamullen5918
@rossamullen5918 21 день назад
It’s good to know that making stuff up existed before the internet.
@wheezesanchez5661
@wheezesanchez5661 21 день назад
How fantastic it must be to think no one made anything up until the end of the last century
@BrettWMcCoy
@BrettWMcCoy 21 день назад
You mean like how Plato mentioned Atlantis in "Timaeus" and "Critias" nearly 2400 years ago?
@rossamullen5918
@rossamullen5918 21 день назад
​@@BrettWMcCoy I should have added passing it of as historical fact.
@DataBeingCollected
@DataBeingCollected 21 день назад
@@BrettWMcCoy Next you’re going to tell me that the sinking of Numenor is also a made up story.
@BrettWMcCoy
@BrettWMcCoy 21 день назад
@@DataBeingCollected And the Doom of Valyria?
@brizo68yeah74
@brizo68yeah74 21 день назад
All i knew about MuMu was that its ancients were justified and that they drove an ice cream van. Thanks for the education.
@oscura70percent
@oscura70percent 21 день назад
and they like to roam the land
@lakrids-pibe
@lakrids-pibe 21 день назад
Mu Mu Land ♫ ♬ Mu Mu Land ♩ ♫ All bound for Mu Mu Land ♪ ♬
@agilekind
@agilekind 21 день назад
The KLF (well, one half, Bill Drummond) took Mu Mu from ‘The Illuminatus Trilogy’, which is yet another source of conspiracy theories and false history! In the book they’re called: ‘The Justified Ancients of Mummu’ and are a “secret society based on a primeval Babylonian deity, Mummu.”
@Armyjay
@Armyjay 21 день назад
and they burned a million quid.
@Crabby303
@Crabby303 21 день назад
🤣🤣🤣
@stevenleonard7219
@stevenleonard7219 21 день назад
When I was a child I found the idea of lost continents and/or cultures and civilizations intriguing. As an adolescent and subsequently a young adult the idea of the possibility that cyclical rises and falls of civilization answered a lot of questions I had. Luckily when I enrolled in university 50 years ago I took my first course in anthropology. My professor was a vociferous antidiffusionist. The myths of ancient civilizations were exactly that, myths. Von Däniken and other proponents of ancient aliens were no more than fanciful fiction. Diverse historical ancient cultures arrived at similar solutions because generally they were humans coming up with human solutions. They did not need to learn from “advanced” beings but could rather using ingenuity invent what they needed. While Heyerdahl may have proven Egyptians could have sailed papyrus boats to the Americas there has been no evidence of such.
@spiritualanarchist8162
@spiritualanarchist8162 21 день назад
Same here (more or less) When I was a kid, Von Daniken's books seemed a good (and exiting ) explanation why & how so many different ancient cultures looked alike. I went to University to study history, and that was that. Over the decades I've seen the same pseudo- nonsense pop up every few decades . The internet is re-cycling all the long disproven nonsense again. Sadly social media reaches tens of millions .
@ericcollins-mf8vb
@ericcollins-mf8vb 21 день назад
@@spiritualanarchist8162 Von Danikens first book Chariots of the Gods was a good read at the time with 'proof' based on interpretations of artworks still in existence. The conjectural interpretations are exposed as fraudulent with the publishing of follow up editions based on erroneous claims, provable today as quoted evidence of 'perfect' masonry blocks when checked with a carpenters square are definitely not as expertly carved with lasers as Erik Von D. would have his followers believe, I think his following editions were easy money from the converted to whom it makes so much sense.
@Rynewulf
@Rynewulf 20 дней назад
@@spiritualanarchist8162 Von Daniken wasnt even original, he's cribbed virtually everything from New Age writers or the 1800s Spiritualism that they copied
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 20 дней назад
​@@spiritualanarchist8162 but they don't look alike? Actually what fascinates me is how DIFFERENT all these ancient cultures and nations are. Even close ones: see Egypt to Nubia to Levant... Mayans had writing and Aztecs, which lived nearby, didn't. Peru civilizations had amazing stone structures but not pyramidal like the Mesoamerican ones, and those step pyramids were completely different from Egyptian ones, used as platforms instead of tomb covers. So instead of xapatones they had a flat ground with walkways to them.
@julietfischer5056
@julietfischer5056 20 дней назад
@@Rynewulf- The New Age post-dates his rubbish. But there were plenty of books and such about Atlantis and expies of Atlantis for him to draw on. His main contribution was to claim that brown people needed extraterrestrials to teach them things.
@yaldabaoth2
@yaldabaoth2 21 день назад
Back when you could just make s**t up and call yourself an expert. It's almost like pseudoscience youtubers today.
@nycbearff
@nycbearff 12 дней назад
I think it would have been great fun back then, if you were healthy and rich. Otherwise - give me the modern world, with all its problems.
@Imperiused
@Imperiused 21 день назад
Churchward was just straight-up writing orientalist fanfiction
@missourimongoose8858
@missourimongoose8858 21 день назад
@@Imperiused I bet his great grand child is writing for rings of power now lol
@thepurplephoenix6423
@thepurplephoenix6423 19 дней назад
Came here to say this lol
@petrapetrakoliou8979
@petrapetrakoliou8979 21 день назад
Plate tectonics were quasi unknown in Churchward's time and were considered as a dissident geological theory, so he probably wouldn't have known about it. Nice presentation of Oceanic versus Continental crust.
@juanausensi499
@juanausensi499 20 дней назад
Yes, to be fair, the first zoologists had the problem of similar animals and plants being on opposite sides of the oceans and needed some kind of explanation. Before the idea that continents could move, the most spread hypothesis is that those animals and plants crossed land bridges/continents/island chains that are sunken today.
@julietfischer5056
@julietfischer5056 20 дней назад
@@juanausensi499- Those sunken lands were invoked to explain lemurs on widely-separated islands, and given the name Lemuria. Yes, Lemuria originated as a scientific theory. Then it was linked with Mu and we all know what happened.
@BaronVonQuiply
@BaronVonQuiply 21 день назад
We're Muvin' on up!
@timfogelson7076
@timfogelson7076 21 день назад
But is he going to the east side and a deluxe apartment in the sky.
@Fauntleroy.
@Fauntleroy. 21 день назад
​@@timfogelson7076No, you had to go to Lemuria for that sort of thing.
@AnnieRegret
@AnnieRegret 13 дней назад
@thecreweofthefancy
@thecreweofthefancy 21 день назад
Are you doing the Tartarian junk next? It is one conspiracy that makes me angry because it denies things which are still in living memory.
@blaizecunningham6080
@blaizecunningham6080 21 день назад
Is that the one where all of our buildings and societies are built upon the remnants of older buildings and societies that were buried in a "mud flood"(or words to that effect?) very recently?. I seem to remember a "theory" much like that, that was termed "Tartaria" or something like that. The theory basically postulates that in the last century or so and giant flood of mud flowed across the world and buried all of our societies in 20ft of mud, and rather than clear it away and document the event, the rulers of the day decided to just rebuild on top of older partially buried buildings, path over all the mud, and then censor all of the evidence and for some reason forget all about it. Some funny stuff right there. I think we can all agree on that.
@thecreweofthefancy
@thecreweofthefancy 21 день назад
@blaizecunningham6080 yes and star forts and basement windows get thrown into the mix.
@thecreweofthefancy
@thecreweofthefancy 21 день назад
@@blaizecunningham6080 oh and the Worlds Fairs were not actually Worlds Fairs, but the remains of this civilization.....
@Flagdad
@Flagdad 21 день назад
my guess is that's what the Mongols called themselves or it was a actual nation the Mongols actually conquered that was undocumented
@thecreweofthefancy
@thecreweofthefancy 21 день назад
@Flagdad oh good, you don't know this conspiracy theory yet. Don't Google it, stick to what you just said.
@andrewblackard3369
@andrewblackard3369 21 день назад
I can't quote a source for you right now, but I read once that some Spaniard erroneously attempted to translate Mayan glyphs to Spanish words based on sound-alike comparisons or something similarly bogus. Then several other Europeans compounded the error by attempting to translate Mayan codices and inscriptions into Spanish using this bogus language cross-reference. The writer concluded that this was the source of the claimed Mayan accounts of Mu.
@Monte-o2f
@Monte-o2f 21 день назад
Brother I drink too much, smoke too much ,and rearly shut the f up, 57 years, tired old stubborn roofer, I hear all see all from the Roof . But you hold my attention, I follow . You are of the Kind. I love Love Love you so much. Capt'n...
@Jebediah1999
@Jebediah1999 20 дней назад
@@Monte-o2f I'm the same but a.bit closer to the ground. Its the knees. Wish I had a.new pair of knees and a new back.
@collyernicholasjohn
@collyernicholasjohn 21 день назад
Thanks Doc, you’re an inspiration! Rational,reasonable, critical and love your storytelling.
@premodernist_history
@premodernist_history 21 день назад
18:15 Maya names are so gnarly.
@GarGhuul
@GarGhuul 21 день назад
So Laplange is the sole origin for the idea of a “Lost Continent of Mu?” The idea ha s made great legs in all sorts of fiction, even video games.
@J_Z913
@J_Z913 21 день назад
Dr. Miano masterclass! ❤
@HepCatJack
@HepCatJack 21 день назад
The Texas Long Horns sometimes spoke of the ancient continent of Moo.
@PRH123
@PRH123 9 дней назад
It was a wonderful place, full of long green grass, fresh clover, no fences, and the hamburger, bottled milk and cheese had not yet been invented. Sigh.
@michaelmanning5379
@michaelmanning5379 21 день назад
Fish, barrel, 12 gauge.
@rubenducheny2788
@rubenducheny2788 21 день назад
Excellent as always! Thank you!
@geolauf
@geolauf 21 день назад
Thank you for your fantastic work Dr. Miano.
@lakrids-pibe
@lakrids-pibe 21 день назад
Heinrich Schliemann called his son Agamemnon ? lol
@pcatful
@pcatful 21 день назад
“Known to belong to the ancient sacred mysteries”. How can a mystery be known? (It’s a secret apparently. One carefully guarded by the guys in the Masonic Hall down the street. And… we’re NOT going to tell you.)
@espacoipiranga
@espacoipiranga 21 день назад
i think "mysteries" in a religious context is a "secret revealed to the initiate", something like that.
@benbarrus6309
@benbarrus6309 21 день назад
I just got my in flight entertainment. Looking forward to this. Thx Doc.
@NonyaBiz-t5f
@NonyaBiz-t5f 21 день назад
I can't tell you how excited I get when I'm sitting here on a whatever day and I see a new WOA video pop up. Bonus points for weekend releases like today. It doesn't matter what I was watching before or what I was planning on watching, I know what I will be watching as soon as I see that notification appear! Thank you as always doctor miano!
@PrimordialOracleOfManyWorlds
@PrimordialOracleOfManyWorlds 21 день назад
fun fact - the toho sci-fi movie, Atragon, was based on the reappearance of the lost continent of Mu and their fight for world domination.
@DataBeingCollected
@DataBeingCollected 21 день назад
I wonder how much of all of these myths, Atlantis, Mu, Flood Myths, etc can be explained by oral traditions in relation to The Early Holocene Sea Level Rise (EHSLR), specifically the Meltwater Pulse events. While most of the research has been on Meltwater Pulse 1B, the final Meltwater Pulse somewhere between 8000-6000 BCE seems to me the most likely event that would have completely inundated the last parts of Doggerland, Malaysian Sundaland, Australian Sahul-land, The Pacific Northwest to include whatever was left of Beringia (bridge was gone by then), and the Persian gulf region. While I am agnostic about the Black Sea Deluge hypothesis, that would also fit into the timeline. I am not an expert in this, just something I’ve looked into!
@AveragePicker
@AveragePicker 21 день назад
Not sure which MWP you are referring to......Do you know the number? There is a 2B but that is the study of a current ice shelf. But either way, MWP events, you'd be looking at a rise of meters over the period of hundreds of years. They are not flash flood events.
@DataBeingCollected
@DataBeingCollected 21 день назад
@@AveragePicker Like I said, not an expert. I do not know a specific event here, but a 8,000 - 6000 BC event would be a post 1B event. I think 1B is the only one with any really solid data. MWP 1B would have been about 11,500 years ago. Also called the catastrophic rise event 2 (CRE2). The way I understand it, meltwater pulse events are attributed to the collapse of continental ice sheets, like giant ice dams holding back a ton of water. For Doggerland specifically, you have the Storegga Slides around 6200 BC (these specific slides are not necessarily meltwater pulse related slides) , which triggered very large tsunamis in the North Atlantic Ocean, which ultimately sank Doggerland. With meltwater pulse ice sheet collapse, you would have an initial massive wave due to the slide itself, followed by the release of the actual meltwater trapped behind the collapsing ice dam creating the permanent sea level change. For reference, a landslide in a narrow Alaskan bay in 1958 created a 1,700 foot/ 518 meter wave which is the largest tsunami we have recorded, and it had no associated meltwater pulse. Just a rockslide with no change in sea level. These waves can also travel up to 500 mph / 800 kmh and cross whole oceans pretty rapidly. While a rise of few meters might not seem like it is a lot, if you have a pulse event, you have the initial tsunami, which then recedes, leaving a sudden and permanent rise in sea level once concluded. You could describe it as a gradual rise looking backwards, because that is ultimately what it looks like after the catastrophic event. In addition to that, you also have to consider how a slow gradual rise of sea water, even without a tsunami can impact entire floodplains once it reaches a tipping point. This is a major concern with sea level rise in our modern day, such as the Netherlands. Once the sea level reaches a critical rise, many basin type geographic features will be rapidly inundated without needing any aid from a massive continental ice sheet slide.
@AveragePicker
@AveragePicker 21 день назад
@DataBeingCollected Theres not an initial tsunami....its a rapid rise but rapid here is relative and takes place over 100s of years. There's no overnight event or week or whatever. That's just not how they work nor is it possible.
@DataBeingCollected
@DataBeingCollected 21 день назад
@@AveragePicker The Storegga Slides were concerning enough for the development of the Ormen Lange gas field off the coast of Norway in 2004 that they took a good long look into it to make sure they wouldn’t cause a repeat. It was determined that there was a glacial component to the slides, which led to their conclusion that they were safe to proceed barring a new ice age. You don’t have to agree with it, but it is a still a topic that is being actively debated in academia, and I am just a guy who’s interested in it and wanting to bring the idea into to the conversation here. I am ultimately agnostic to it, (meaning I won’t lose sleep over it if it’s completely debunked) but I do think there is some promising research here that shouldn’t be ignored just because it doesn’t seem to fit our previous models or understanding. Bad speculation and bad theory should be debated to show why they are bad, and I’d rather know that my previous model was bad and change to the more accurate model then stubbornly argue for a flat earth, or whatever. If you actually work in a field related to this research and know why what I am sharing is actually wrong, please provide it so we all can better understand. While a lot is made about combating pseudoscience on this channel (something everyone is guilty of to varying degrees), I am not making an emphatic claim here, just bringing light to the general public a position and opening it up for public debate. I think the way you’ve approached this, (expert opinion or not), requires that we also discuss the lesser known topic of Pseudoskepticism. Marcello Truzzi attributed the following characteristics to Pseudoskeptics: Denying, when only doubt has been established Double standards in the application of criticism The tendency to discredit rather than investigate Presenting insufficient evidence or proof (when making a claim) Assuming criticism requires no burden of proof (IE, criticism of an idea, any idea, is somehow excused from burden of proof) Making unsubstantiated counter-claims Counter-claims based on plausibility rather than empirical evidence (IE, claiming something is not plausible or possible without explaining why) Suggesting that unconvincing evidence provides grounds for completely dismissing a claim Carl Sagan is famous for the quote “Extraordinary claims require Extraordinary evidence.”, also called the Sagan Standard. Where did he get this? From Marcello Truzzi. If you are skeptical, please provide me some real skepticism!
@AveragePicker
@AveragePicker 21 день назад
@@DataBeingCollected All I am pointing out is that meltwater events are not, nor are they led by, or followed by, a large scale disaster taking place over a matter of days. Hancock tends to promote that they do because he needs a single fast event for his ideas to work. But that just is not how meltwater events occur.
@tracimcmurray5244
@tracimcmurray5244 21 день назад
Thank you, Dr. Miano. Mu, Lemuria, Tartartia, etc--they are are all glorious tales and wow, IF they were true, how fantastic a history that would be! Alas, no concrete evidence has been found. But as you stated, most people will not take the time (and it takes a LOT of time) just to disprove something or validate it. I appreciate you taking the time to break this one down in fairness.
@garymaidman625
@garymaidman625 20 дней назад
Lemuria initially was not a continent where civilization started, that was only later. The origins of Lemuria based on the evidence that Lemur fossils have been found in Madagascar (where they are still found) and the Indian subcontinent, but not anywhere in Africa or Arabia, so the biologist at the time, Philip Sclater, in the mid 19th century, proposed that to account for this anomaly, there had to have been a land mass between Madagascar and the Indian subcontinent that had since sunken, a land mass called Lemuria, literally the land of lemurs. This, at the time, was a pretty logical theory and not pseudoscience at all. Since the rise of the scientific discipline of tectonics, this theory has since been disproven, the explanation is now that Madagascar and the Indian subcontinent were once joined together. Just because Sclater's theory has since been disproven, doesn't make it pseudoscience, in fact his initial theory has been bastardized by these pseudohistorians.
@Danboston2funny
@Danboston2funny 21 день назад
He must’ve been one of the inspirations for Zachariah Sitchin,… why translate when you can just make stuff up🤷‍♂️😆(sad)
@welhungyongmancitywok8189
@welhungyongmancitywok8189 21 день назад
as a Dutch person i can tell you the lost continent of Mu is not lost just very tired.
@GizzyDillespee
@GizzyDillespee 21 день назад
I got Churchward's Sacred Symbols of Mu from the dump (Amherst MA) in their "take it or leave it" library. Someone had donated a small vintage esoteric book collection. I read the book, and the "evidence", IOW the translations and connections implied, seemed specious. When the book was published, I wouldn't have been able to know that. But this was the early 2000s, and I knew the Llhasa and Mayan ideas were off. There were some interesting illustrations, but the conclusions seemed unlikely. I ended up giving the book to a friend of mine, and don't miss it. It would like nice on a boolshelf behind me in the webcam. If you want a more interesting exotic orientalist travelogue of ancient wisdom teachings, I'd recommend Magic and Mystery In Tibet, instead.
@GizzyDillespee
@GizzyDillespee 21 день назад
I think Sacred Symbols had a lot of speculation about Rapa Nui. If memory serves, it looked for commonalities in various civilizations.
@alanmarshall4989
@alanmarshall4989 21 день назад
your work is much appreciated doc.
@Tim_J_
@Tim_J_ 20 дней назад
Churchward is like the L Ron Hubbard of "History"
@tonyhoede6251
@tonyhoede6251 21 день назад
stories like this frustrate me so deeply. There’s real creativity here! If these were presented as fantasy they’d be wonderful.
@MossyMozart
@MossyMozart 16 дней назад
@@tonyhoede6251 - The same can be said of Graham Hancock. He could have been another Prachette!
@stuartnicklin650
@stuartnicklin650 21 день назад
This is the best video i have seen on RU-vid in months. I have barely heard of any of this.
@darkushippotoxotai9536
@darkushippotoxotai9536 21 день назад
Funfact for gamers out there : The secret cow level in Diablo games is allegedly set in the continent of Mu.
@chrisball3778
@chrisball3778 21 день назад
Twist: Heinrich Schliemann actually did find the ruins of Atlantis, but accidentally destroyed them by digging through them in search of the 'Platonic phase'. That's why his fake grandson couldn't show anyone where it was.
@InfiniteUniverse88
@InfiniteUniverse88 16 дней назад
An earlier writer, Rudolf Steiner mentions Lemuria. Some writers use the terms Mu and Lemuria interchangeably. Even earlier, Blavatsky mentions Mu. She founded the theosophical society, which may have influenced Churchward.
@Catdad76801
@Catdad76801 21 день назад
Sagan's Demon Haunted World is a must-read for pseudoscience avoidance.
@fordprefect80
@fordprefect80 21 день назад
I've read it twice, great book.
@CoolClearWaterNM
@CoolClearWaterNM 21 день назад
I always liked the Mu silliness more than Atlantis. Probably just because ridiculous Atlantis stories have been done to death so when a fantasy writer uses Mu is seems more 'original'. It's a bit like the over-saturation of zombie novels. Write a chupacabra story and I'm more likely to read it.
@TheCosmicGuy0111
@TheCosmicGuy0111 21 день назад
Oh man here we goooo
@daveshrum1749
@daveshrum1749 21 день назад
Wow this is less of a debunking and more story time ! Lol 1 flim-flam artist using the evidence from an earlier flim-flam artist to support their made up personal fantasies. Just wow.
@matthewludivico1714
@matthewludivico1714 21 день назад
Historical study of pseudoscience is intriguing.
@lococomrade3488
@lococomrade3488 21 день назад
Watching Alchemy turn into Chemistry is the coolest deep dive.
@matthewludivico1714
@matthewludivico1714 17 дней назад
I understand it really begins with divergence of philosophisical thinking, starting with Francis Bacon, inspiring later generations to build chemical laboratories and work using mathematical and empirical methods, independent of alchemical systems. So really once you accept a better ideal system as empiricism and natural philosophy (the idea that nature holds observable and reproducible laws), we can reject the input of alchemical restraint. And produce pure science. I would say history says Francis Bacon of the father of the philosophical thought thay paved the way for practical scientific exploration in laboratories by those he inspired...Robert Boyle, etc... By the time of Lavosier, alchemy is viewed as garbage by the scientists.
@matthewludivico1714
@matthewludivico1714 16 дней назад
See Francis Bacon
@lococomrade3488
@lococomrade3488 16 дней назад
@matthewludivico1714 The Disappearing Spoon is an awesome book, for anyone who hasn't read it. Also, archaic and insane medical practice is always hilarious.
@matthewludivico1714
@matthewludivico1714 16 дней назад
if only TikTok existed hundreds of years ago
@chuckkv
@chuckkv 20 дней назад
They're justified and they're ancient. And they like to roam the land. They don't want to upset the apple cart They don't want to cause any harm But if you don't like what they're going to do You'd better not stop them 'cos they're coming through
@pawekranzberg6259
@pawekranzberg6259 15 дней назад
@@chuckkv A man of culture, at last.
@brunopereira6789
@brunopereira6789 19 дней назад
Churchward just needed to have written a fantasy novel and he would've been much happier for it
@spiritualanarchist8162
@spiritualanarchist8162 21 день назад
Funny how the same grift keeps popping up every few decades.
@williamallen2777
@williamallen2777 21 день назад
Atlantis is on the map of Mu 2:16 on the Atlantic side so he really likes adding continents. I wonder how many more he thinks there are?
@davepx1
@davepx1 20 дней назад
I'm impressed that they manage to squeeze some bits of ocean in between. :)
@alepaz1099
@alepaz1099 21 день назад
"It's not what they wrote, it's what they meant" trust me bro' It's sad to know that charlatans and nonsensical idiots are not a new phenomena 🤷‍♂
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 20 дней назад
32:50 We have lion statues guarding Vorontsov palace in Odesa, except they're like 150 years old so not unique to antiquity.
@olorin4317
@olorin4317 21 день назад
Bad sci-fi writers have done some real damage.
@sharktomesmiles
@sharktomesmiles 21 день назад
I love this channel.
@miaththered
@miaththered 21 день назад
sits down to learn a thing.
@scoon2117
@scoon2117 21 день назад
I'll learn it and immediately forget it.
@billstapleton1084
@billstapleton1084 13 дней назад
Was Mu real? Let's just do the research. Use Lidar to look at the depth of the Ocean. If you go back 12,800 years ago you find the water level was 300 ft lower than today. Using this, how much land is exposed?
@varyolla435
@varyolla435 12 дней назад
Ah......... = are not the oceans a tad "deep"......... Also you might want to familiarize yourself with the term: _"bathymetry."_ Moral: we already have mapped the ocean floors. More to the point here however is that islands etc. "do not sink". What can potentially happen is that owing usually to volcanic eruptions landmass which was previously above the waterline can see that "blown up"or subsumed as the ground is undermined by magma such that the part sticking out not unlike an iceberg is no longer visible = yet the rest below remains..... So having already ascertained the nature of the ocean's seafloors any possible underwater areas of land close to the surface - aka _"seamounts"_ - are already known. These are your areas where known islands/atolls exist and if something was there we would see some evidence of it. The rest of the ocean floor - comprising most of it - is endless earth crust with the regions of tectonic zones and underwater volcanoes = where nothing could exist anyways as those are miles down in most cases.
@petrapetrakoliou8979
@petrapetrakoliou8979 21 день назад
The historical theories of Churchward were hilarious in his time. On the other hand he couldn't have known about how continents work as nobody did at that time.
@alaing246
@alaing246 21 день назад
Merci!
@WorldofAntiquity
@WorldofAntiquity 21 день назад
And thank you!
@BenWard29
@BenWard29 4 дня назад
Your reading of Le Plongeon sounds so much like the spoken part of the Donovan song "Atlantis". Great song. I hope Donovan doesn't actually believe in Atlantis.
@gurnolla
@gurnolla 21 день назад
Consider if you would the volume of ocean water Wu would have displaced. Other continents would have suddenly had vast new coastal area exposed.
@clwho4652
@clwho4652 21 день назад
That was my first thought when I saw the map, something that big would displace so much water that large portions of the real continents would have been under water, even some of the places psudo-history people claim is evidence for their fiction ancient civilizations. Then there would have the tsunami caused by the sinking of mu, there would defiantly know if there was a tsunami that big.
@salinagrrrl69
@salinagrrrl69 21 день назад
Dear Dr. Miano, praises 2U for moving along & forward undaunted by the barbs of your academic arch advisary the DIABOLICAL DrDeBunk.
@davepx1
@davepx1 20 дней назад
That guy's just not well. Best ignored.
@tonysargent1699
@tonysargent1699 21 день назад
Did he sell lots of books? People in the 1930's were still strong believers in the supernatural and also of adventure, so Churchwood was writing for people like himself, which would have payed dividends for both his ego and his pocket! Cool stuff, Doc. Cheers.
@Big_Tex
@Big_Tex 21 день назад
Dude missed his calling, he should have just written some Tolkienesque fantasy novels instead of pretending to discover history.
@itsnot_stupid_ifitworks
@itsnot_stupid_ifitworks 21 день назад
I'm finding it hard to understand mu
@Couchflyer-NY
@Couchflyer-NY 18 дней назад
Oh man, it’s fantastical. Just substitute Mu with Smurf and all the pieces fall into place.
@user-wb7nv9ht1g
@user-wb7nv9ht1g 21 день назад
Has Joe Rogan started investigating Mu yet? Im guessing not and imagine he'll have an expert in Mu.
@MrFreezook
@MrFreezook 21 день назад
❤👏👏👏 Awesome as usual, Thank you Dr. Miano.
@ClimateScepticSceptic-ub2rg
@ClimateScepticSceptic-ub2rg 21 день назад
'Moo', or 'Mew'? I always called the Greek letter, 'mew'.
@davepx1
@davepx1 20 дней назад
I always pronounced it "Mew" (though I'd only heard of it through the Androids of Mu), but a short "Moo" sounds more correct. English-speakers love to make vowels more convoluted than they are.
@TheLeppus28
@TheLeppus28 21 день назад
So these guys were just Graham Hancock and UnchartedX of their times?
@salinagrrrl69
@salinagrrrl69 21 день назад
That would be ...yes. Add the THC bad hair Greek to that.
@1lightheaded
@1lightheaded 21 день назад
Add a bit of Sitchin and Ignatius Donelly
@gil-sc3qe
@gil-sc3qe 21 день назад
😂
@cozmothemagician7243
@cozmothemagician7243 21 день назад
Oh, I can play this game too.. Steve Wozniak's twin brother's son showed me a secret document written by the 1st AI in 1784. It details George Washington's journey to Venus in a balloon. It was written in Incan Fortran that only a select elite can read. How did I do?
@gil-sc3qe
@gil-sc3qe 21 день назад
😂👍👏
@waynemyers2469
@waynemyers2469 21 день назад
Garbage: (1) How does someone "show someone a secret document."? (2) The "elite" are NOT "selected", they are born and (3) Balloons are notorious for losing their structural-integrity when faced with the extremes of outer-space. Both heat and cold, when coupled to the Vacuum, tend to viciously attack the material and structure of even the most robust balloon resulting in complete implosion and ultimate destruction. Under such unrealistic conditions, the idea of Washington making a Venus circuit in a decade is doubtful and lacks material evidence. *not as easy a game as you thought, is it? But that's probably because you are not a liar by nature...
@JayCWhiteCloud
@JayCWhiteCloud 21 день назад
Oh, boy...Time for a coffee break!
@wetcanoedogs
@wetcanoedogs 21 день назад
no joke,i took a little time off and made it two programs.his booklet why history matters is a good read and much like this.
@trumpbidensameclub6668
@trumpbidensameclub6668 12 дней назад
Mu...Garden of eden.
@andersand6576
@andersand6576 21 день назад
Have anyone done th calculations how much water woild displaced and wjere the shorelines of the rest of the world would be? All the new land would become dry would make for an interesting fiction.
@Taomantom
@Taomantom 21 день назад
At 36.5ish your voice tone and choice of words made me laugh like hell. Nice sarcasm Dr. M!
@karlkarlos3545
@karlkarlos3545 21 день назад
I learned a useful term today: 'Gish Gallop'. Thanks, Dr. Miano. I noticed that it is used by a lot of conspiracy theorists and also by a certain presidential candidate, since real-time fact-checking is always impossible.
@AllHailDiskordia
@AllHailDiskordia 21 день назад
The nonsense from ages ago, the weirdos really love that
@andreweaston1779
@andreweaston1779 17 дней назад
I have a question for you if you dont mind. There is a channel named 'History for Granite' and I was wondering if you could check them out. I was watching their last video, and, they referenced UnchartedX. Only because they pulled an image from them, but, the fact that they were mentioned is worrying to me. The channel is sort of speculative. But, I personally do not think it ks baseless speculation. However, I can see that it might be simply because I am not super well versed in the material. The channel videos regularly hit over 1 million views so it is not small time. I appreciate your time, and the work you do. Love your channel.
@AveragePicker
@AveragePicker 17 дней назад
History for Granite is legit. Some of their recent videos have been speculating on some things, but it is based on actual research and grounded logic. (EX: They lay out a pretty good argument for the order the casing stones were placed in and extensively mapped them looking for patterns in size that might be clues.) They may not be totally correct but it is all quite reasonable and they lay out their thinking very clearly. They do a really good job at showing slight variations in historical documentation too. Highly recommend their channel.
@yensid4294
@yensid4294 20 дней назад
Um, I am by no means an authority in Meso American history but didn't Egyptian Culture pre date the Maya by thousands of years? I don't personally see strong similarities in either their art or architecture to the Egyptians. And if I'm not mistaken, their religious practices were very different too.
@varyolla435
@varyolla435 20 дней назад
Think about the Mu narrative + think about the timeframe when it was created = think about what was going on back then.......... Moral: Churchward took his cue from Le Plongeon. Further you see this story arise at a time when Egyptology was all the rage - it was published after Tutankhamun's tomb had been discovered by Carter and the press of the time massively covered Egyptian stories. So people who lived at time when Egypt and Egyptian artifacts and stories of _"eastern esotericism"_ was all the rage in the culture - yet they had no real background in archeology/history per se - craft a narrative based upon = "knowns". The Mayan culture would not be understood as it now is for many years to come - but the Egyptian culture was widely recognizable. So in stereotypical fashion people employing _"confirmation bias"_ allow themselves to interpret what they see based upon things familiar rather than a more objective analysis as we today try to do. p.s. - yes the Egyptian dynastic culture was older than the Mayan one - hence your "known".
@toastrave7820
@toastrave7820 15 дней назад
i remember first hearing about the land of Mu from a Toho(the studio that made most of the Godzilla films) film called Atragon.
@varyolla435
@varyolla435 14 дней назад
🎯 It happens to represent a case where _"correlation equals causation"_ ends up being accurate after all - though I must add this is often not the case. Early print science fiction genre is used by Hollywood as the basis for their own version of that entertainment genre for movies/television -------> this results in a large customer base forming which becomes inculcated with these narratives -----> what will become the LAHT industry seeing that large, exploitable customer base crafts its' own narratives which basically rip off Hollywood et al's.........who ripped off the early print science fiction writers.........who created their narratives based upon the cultural excitement of the day. Moral: the development of the _"world of MU"_ goes back to the 19th Century when pseudoscience was all the rage + when ancient Egypt and _"Oriental esotericism"_ were equally soup du jour in certain circles. Man creates his fantasies which are both based upon popular themes in the culture of the day as well as help to shape the same.
@1Kent
@1Kent 21 день назад
Keep up the good work Dr M, the truth is out there.
@-OICU812-
@-OICU812- 21 день назад
How big could Mu be? Didn't a cow jump over it? It seems I heard something to that effect.
@JuanitaGrande
@JuanitaGrande 20 дней назад
THANK YOUUUUUUUUU!
@Zarkov777
@Zarkov777 20 дней назад
Thank you for your sanity!
@EnigmaSeeker2012UAP
@EnigmaSeeker2012UAP 20 дней назад
Atlantis is real, it's just Egypt. Think about it. No woo woo needed.
@OldieBugger
@OldieBugger 21 день назад
Oh, I like stories with MU in them. Just as I like other Fantasy and Science Fiction stories.
@KasumiRINA
@KasumiRINA 20 дней назад
31:44 Did it ever occur to anyone that means El Dorado was built by Maya Plisetskaya? While pirouetting.
@jackcotner8981
@jackcotner8981 21 день назад
Excellent, interesting presentation.
@TheGahta
@TheGahta 21 день назад
Muh continent! 😂
Далее
Why we should go back to writing in runes
20:39
Просмотров 494 тыс.
50m Small Bike vs Car FastChallenge
00:22
Просмотров 3 млн
DeDunking Channel SLAMS One of My Videos!
54:29
Просмотров 58 тыс.
When Fake Archaeology Uses Fake Science
21:44
Просмотров 70 тыс.
What Is the Best Bible Translation?
55:07
Просмотров 179 тыс.
Viewers Ply Me with Ancient History Questions
49:09
Просмотров 27 тыс.
The Emptiness of Pyramid Sarcophagi
23:54
Просмотров 248 тыс.