The man sounds like he speaks American English. In American English, it is called Shepherd’s Pie. If you go to any supermarket in the frozen aisle, it will have beef in it and be called Shepherd’s Pie. This is a cultural difference. Americans also generally do not eat much lamb…
@@user-uk2qi6xi4d u are waffling. Cotttage pie is cottage pie and shepherds pie is shepherds pie, just cuz u call cottage pie shepherds pie doesn’t mean it’s right
@@bobjones3069IT'S IN THE NAME, He changed that one ingredient that mattered, there's already a thing called cottage pie, that's like makings spaghetti bolognese and calling it a lasagna like come on
@@snowbrute9036 Yup i've been making chicken burgers to be healthier, except i don't like chicken so i've replaced it with beef..... those are some tasty chicken burgers !!!!
We're American, we call it Shepherd's Pie whether its beef or lamb, and MOST of us make it with beef. Unless we're trying to appease Europeans or bougie food snobs we don't distinguish between Cottage Pie or Shepherd's Pie and we don't even use the term Cottage Pie here.
@@HalfLatinaJoy86 LMAO. never witnessed someone calling someone else a bougie food snob for pointing out the difference between cottage and Shepherd's pie, the least bougie and snobbish of foods. good god, you momes make me laugh. hot dogs aren't tacos either, you uneducated slob.
I love shepherd's pie😋 but I will need a little more gravy/sauce within the meat so when I cut it out it's thick saucy and juicy. Ramsey's recipe looks like crumbled beef with a thin layer of potatoes on top.
@@QBQ98 you know hot dogs were named after the shape of an actual dog right? so im still correct. would you call a sausage in batter, fried, a hot dog or a corndog? exactly. thats like saying a beef burger can be made with chicken, no, it cant, then it would be a chicken burger.
@@QBQ98 right, and this is coming from the same person who so confidently argued that they were right, when in fact, they were wrong in a multitude of ways... correct? 😂😂
And they're all completely false. It takes five minutes to research and find out that the name is not universal, even in the UK. They just heard the mediocre angry chef say it one time and parrot it. Meanwhile the same chef can't cook fried rice for his life
@@lukeandliz of course you have cottage pie... every time you make shepherd's pie with beef, well that's cottage pie. Most Mexican food uses the same ingredients but cooks slightly differently, you wouldn't call a burrito a chimichanga, a quesadilla a fajita, a fish pie a shepherd's pie, so why would you call a cottage pie a shepherd's pie?
@@david-joehollingworth3359 yeah no. Your examples are kinda bad tbh. Cottage and shepherds pie are literally the same except you use a different kind of meat, while the difference between Mexican food with tortillas has a wider range and it depends more on the style, while they mostly also have other ingredients.
@@naturescritter4691 everything about the two are different except tomatoe versus everything about the other 2 are exactly the same except your choice of meat, big diff muh boy
@@FunnyAFClipz Worcestershire sauce and English mustard is great to add to a cottage pie. But lamb is a much more sweet and delicate meat, so its best to go easy on the Worcestershire sauce and only add a tiny bit of mustard, if any.
- 2 pounds ground lamb or beef - 1 onion - 2 carrots - 1 celery stick - 3 garlic cloves - 1/2 cup red wine - beef broth to cover beef - 1/2 cup peas - 5-6 potatoes - 1/4 cup butter - shredded cheese - 1/2 cup heavy cream - 3 egg yolks - Parmesan cheese - salt & pepper to taste measurements from his insta. this recipe came out really good. i used stock to deglaze it and i put a splash of worcestershire.
If i may correct this a bit. When you add carrots, celery and onions. Thats called mirepoix. It needs to be cooked and rendered before a protein is added. Specifically, onions should be caramalized first, then add carrots and celery. let that cook, and build the dish on top of that.
Most aren't "hating" on his recipe. It looks like a great recipe for cottage pie which uses beef, the problem is he called it a Shepard's pie which literally HAS to be lamb.
Yep, and he had the b*lls to call out someone on his show for calling one with beef shepherds pie, he said "this is cottage pie" Kitchen Nightmares.....he's a blowhard....lol
@@bobjones3069because shepherd - sheep - sheep - lamb mince. Cottage pie is using beef. That’s more or less the only difference. Both taste great but I prefer shepherds. You can’t skip on the e Worcestershire sauce thiugh
@@Mort_and_Ricky No, it wasn’t meant to be mean. It’s the truth and why would you not want to know that? I’ve said it wrong all my life and after fifty some years I was a little shocked no one had ever corrected me. Karen’s do stupid meaningless shit, not truthful and helpful shit. 😅😊
@@M.Happie What do you think the Shepherd is in Shepard's Pie relates to? Could it be the lamb? Shepherds herd sheep, if it doesn't have sheep in it how is it a shepherds pie?
More like; Here's a potato sack. Go out there. Collect all the dicks you can find, fill the sack. Go back home. Eat all the dicks. Repeat until you promise to NEVER COOK ANYTHING EVER AGAIN
You know your wrong tho. Shepherds pie is with soft fluffy mashed potatoes that can look a wool and cottage pie is made with layer of sliced potatoes that looks like a cottages roof.
@@stewartsims6114no, a SHEP HERD is a sheep herder hence it is made with lamb. Made with beef it becomes a cottage pie. Both are usually made with mashed potatoes, but it probably wouldn't matter if substituted for sliced potatoes a la dauphinoise style.
@@stewartsims6114the idea of both is to use left overs to make a new dish. Shepards pie= sheep herders. Guess what they mostly had as protein. CAT!!! 😂😂😂 noo lamb. Soo lamb is what's traditionally in Shepards pie. Vs cottage pie usually contained beef, cause cows. Wild
@@charlieross4674 I believe "TILT" refers to the game of pinball where the player jostles the machine excessively resulting in loss of turn, or more generally something that is not permitted.
This is Cottage Pie because it is made with beef. Shepherd's Pie is made with lamb. Sheep, shepherd , get it? This cottage pie looks yummy and I think that I will make some. Time for Americans to learn the distinction in this British recipe. Thanks for sharing this.😊
These comments are annoying as fuck he said he was making Gordon's recipe didn't say what he was making was shepherds pie he just followed the recipe tf is wrong with you people
@@Shockgueythose arent authentic versions, only cottage for beef mince and sheperd for lamb mince. there isnt names for pork or poultry because they are recipes for specifically lamb or beef. americans try and say british people have no cultural foods, and then try and gotcha them when they talk about traditional food names and ingredients 💀
you had no clue of the difference until you read the comments 😂 find your seat kid. you dont even make your own mac & cheese and this is how you spend your time? grow up
Gordon Ramsay's *Shepherd's* pie... but uses beef mince... this is cottage pie. Makes me think of a Kitchen nightmare episode where Ramsay flipped his lid over the use of beef as *Shepherd's* pie has lamb in it, hence the name *Shepherd's*... Edit: yes, I had to look up the spelling of Shepherd
@@user-uk2qi6xi4d I reckon it is something else that cultural... Cottage pie originates from England, and Shepherd's pie from the sheeplands of Scotland. So I admit that it could have been lost in translation over the big blue. There is even a third variation, the Cumberland pie that uses chunks of meat rather that mince and slices of potato instead of mash. Thank you for the positive response, it got me researching.
No it is not made with ground lamb. Typically shepherd's pie is made on a Monday, the day after a traditional Irish Sunday roast. Leftover meat is used in the pie, yes usually lamb. However, this would be cut into lamb chunks, like a stew, not ground up. By using ground lamb, it implies you are buying the meat, the total opposite reason for this pie.
No you don't have a jack-o'-lantern if you carve a pumpkin in Feb. You have a carved pumpkin. A jack-o'-lantern is a carved lantern. Traditionally, the Irish carved a turnip and lit it with a candle. The Jack in jack-o'-lantern refers to tradition of an Irish dunk named Jack who sold his soul to satin and roamed the earth with a lit up turnip head.
There's literally the caption that pops up saying he doesn't like lamb so he used beef lol, and as much as lamb does taste good I prefer mutton anyway, it's nicer to eat something that at least lived a little and is grown rather than a baby lol
@@mztwixed Lamb Mince, Browned with onions, Lamb stock, Carrots, Chestnut mushrooms, Dash of Worcestershire sauce. Mashed married piper potatoes, Salt, Pepper and butter, Then grated cheddar cheese on top. Recipe from my Gran who was the cook in a Manor House. Oh and peas on the side not in the mince.
He is demonstrating gordon's shepherd pie recipe. This is the recipe for shepherd's pie. He did substitute lamb with ground beef, and he stated that. It doesn't matter if it's a fucking cottage pie now, he is DEMONSTRATING Gordon's Shepherd's pie Recipe. Maybe Gordon's recipe for cottage pie is completely different, maybe it doesnt even exist. Specifying which recipe is important.
its not called lamb pie tho, and its also not made out of sheperds, so your point is kind of pointless. i get what you tryna say but it just doesnt fit.
"Next I'll be making a grilled cheese sandwich, but I don't like cheese, so I'll use ham. And I'm gluten intolerant, so instead of bread, I'm using marmalade. Also, I don't have a grill, so i'll be deep frying it."
The most important seasoning for this is Worcestershire sauce! Only when its beef. Shepherds and cottage is different not only in the meat used. The sound of the potato was awesome. Looks delicious.
