Тёмный

Government Explained 2: The Magical Piece of Paper 

Man Against The State
Подписаться 14 тыс.
Просмотров 84 тыс.
50% 1

Continuing from where the first video ended, the human now tries to explain to the alien the concept of "countries", the difference between a democracy and a republic, and the purpose of a Constitution.
Transcript: managainstthestate.blogspot.co...
This is the sequel to Government Explained: • Government Explained
This video was made using XtraNormal: www.xtranormal.com/
If you would like to support me in making more movies, click the donate button on my blog (www.managainstthestate.blogspo...) or send me Bitcoins at 13aWNXnGg37DwTfTXASJTTXQqq6nfoDKv2.

Опубликовано:

 

13 окт 2012

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 350   
@pgplaysvidya
@pgplaysvidya 11 лет назад
"But whether the Constitution really be one thing, or another, this much is certain - that it has either authorized such a government as we have had, or has been powerless to prevent it. In either case, it is unfit to exist." - Lysander Spooner
@Go2Matthew
@Go2Matthew 11 лет назад
"I'm sure that's what they tell you." Awesome!
@jesse3564
@jesse3564 8 лет назад
Wow. I never realized the giant contradiction in needing an informed populace to ensure the constitution gets upheld, while the whole purpose of the constitution is to prevent the majority from violating the rights of the individuals
@arcadejaguar409
@arcadejaguar409 3 года назад
Human psychology is weird.
@mattxr2i
@mattxr2i 10 лет назад
This is a very refreshing and creative way to explain the problems in our system of government. Good job!
@kikulikokuli8260
@kikulikokuli8260 8 лет назад
+JulianBaynes1 Yeah, it's fucked up. The Western masses wouldn't accept a King as their own "legitimate ruler"(!), but no one bats an eye at Saudi Arabia having a King. Or maybe they all sense that a King == Dictator == BAD, but just can't connect the dots between _Government_ A and _Government_ B.
@kikulikokuli8260
@kikulikokuli8260 8 лет назад
***** Well yeah, I forgot about the figurehead Kings of England and Sweden, and.. are there any others? But they're not running the countries, they're more like mascots or something :P Oh, and actual _humans_ don't even want to wield power over other people,but _psychopaths_ sure as fuck do.. and they run the world.
@bananatrish499
@bananatrish499 7 лет назад
John Le Moignan I know. LOL
@bananatrish499
@bananatrish499 7 лет назад
I don't think we had much government at one point in time and it should still be that way.
@Bretislavka
@Bretislavka 6 лет назад
It is not about "the problems in our system of government" The problem is that something like the government exists.
@Spartacus547
@Spartacus547 5 лет назад
"I'm sure that's what they tell you" best line ever 😂
@earthpond8043
@earthpond8043 2 года назад
Haaa I love that ending remark. So true. Everyone is so brainwashed into believing and associating anarchy with chaos when in reality it doesn’t have to be that way at all.
@jf2369af
@jf2369af 2 года назад
I know I'm late like 8 years but just found part 1 last week and part 2 now. What a beautiful work of scientific facts. 1 and 2 are on my list of favorites for sure.
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 2 года назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@HK-dc2gh
@HK-dc2gh 7 лет назад
This poor guy haha he just wants to get home and drink a beer but this alien is turning his world upside down. That must be how people feel when talking to AnCaps
@kavtind
@kavtind 8 лет назад
Excellent video. Way too few views considering how correct it is. A shame.
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 8 лет назад
+HushHush Thank you! The first video got lots of views, but this sequel didn't go viral in quite the same way unfortunately.
@TigerLilyGzzTLRoars
@TigerLilyGzzTLRoars 8 лет назад
+Man Against The State I trust it will. Great work!
@fuckyourbullshit6380
@fuckyourbullshit6380 6 лет назад
thank you for the reply makes much more sense now maybe we can find a way to make the cost of living free one day...
@MrZiggy019
@MrZiggy019 8 лет назад
Great video...this is a great addition to the original "Government Explained"
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 8 лет назад
+austin thomas Thanks!
@MrZiggy019
@MrZiggy019 8 лет назад
Would you like to come on Truth Emerges Radio ???
@justinmarko80
@justinmarko80 4 года назад
@@ManAgainstTheState What happened to part 3?
@Foundry_made
@Foundry_made Год назад
"The gang that tells you what to do and robs you". The alien has it figured out alright.
@dennishackethal
@dennishackethal 11 месяцев назад
“But there’d be chaos without government!” “I’m sure that’s what they tell you.” 😂
@Rothbardian30
@Rothbardian30 7 лет назад
These videos are great. I'm glad to see that there are finally some videos geared towards teaching kids the truth about government.
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 7 лет назад
Thank you
@southtexasprepper6605
@southtexasprepper6605 8 лет назад
Awesome video brother, they should start showing these at the public schools.
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 8 лет назад
+Theo Martinez A few young people have actually commented that their teachers have showed this video in class.
@thegreatdeception5670
@thegreatdeception5670 7 лет назад
every child should watch this around the age of 12 or 13 then again around 17-18. we put too much trust in a gov that abuses its power(violence). funny how their violence is different then anyone elses. if people want or need your services they will seek you out. if not then leave them alone!
@livewire2759
@livewire2759 Год назад
"But there'd be chaos without government." There's more chaos WITH government. Individuals may have arguments, those arguments may even turn into fights... but when governments have arguments, those arguments turn into wars. War is chaos.
@UNITED-SNAKES-OF-WEIMAR
@UNITED-SNAKES-OF-WEIMAR 8 дней назад
Jesus Saves. AC/DC is satanic.
@jpbochi
@jpbochi 4 года назад
"government, a gang that tells you what o do and robs you." :heart:
@GNParty
@GNParty 9 лет назад
Thank you for uploading this video. It's very well written.
@CringePotato
@CringePotato 9 лет назад
0:16 the alien does not know of the Illuminati...
@saeedbaig4249
@saeedbaig4249 8 лет назад
+JulianBaynes1 But really, how powerful is the UN, if they're main board is made up of just 5 superpowers who can contradict and veto each other to prevent any progress from being made.
@kikulikokuli8260
@kikulikokuli8260 8 лет назад
+Sideeq Mohammad They're all connected behind the scenes. Listen to James Corbett of "The Corbett Report" for more information.
@RichTechnologyGroup
@RichTechnologyGroup 6 лет назад
AMEN to that haha
@TaliesinRising
@TaliesinRising 6 лет назад
This is great, thank you! will have to check all your vids. Love it.
@PeaceRequiresAnarchy
@PeaceRequiresAnarchy 11 лет назад
Nice job with the sequel, Graham. I wouldn't bet that this one will go viral, but it does a good job responding to the many comments that you got on the first one that the government is a republic, not a democracy. The comments pointed this out as if it made all the difference, when in reality as your video shows, it really doesn't. All of the main problems inherent in government still exist in a constitutional republic.
@Government-is-slavery
@Government-is-slavery 4 года назад
This part 3:46 is outstanding and smart.
@shawnbruce6934
@shawnbruce6934 Год назад
I've watched part 1. This is Brilliant and Well Done.
@TheCoolhead27
@TheCoolhead27 11 лет назад
By the way, I love your videos! Thank you, and keep up the great work waking people up!
@grumblekin
@grumblekin 10 лет назад
I would vote for this fictional alien in 2016 before I would vote for anyone on the Repub or Democrat ticket. FICTIONAL ALIEN 2016: He Couldn't Do Any Worse Than Obama
@NobodyNaboru
@NobodyNaboru 10 лет назад
He'd just get assassinated before he could even get into office. Government wouldn't like it if things didn't go their way.
@prairiehip5018
@prairiehip5018 10 лет назад
NobodyNaboru, You guys still have a chance to change your government by voting for Jessie Ventura, if he runs in 2016. Wish we had him here in Canada cus he would have my vote!
@NobodyNaboru
@NobodyNaboru 10 лет назад
Prairie Hip Oh I love him to death.... That was a terrible choice of words. Anyway yeah, the only reason he hasn't been taken out yet is because he's got too much attention. I still don't think even if we voted him in it would be enough. America is coming to an end and I don't anything can fix it. I don't think he'd run honestly, he's smarter than that.
@lagillas
@lagillas 5 лет назад
​@@NobodyNaboru Not really, how people in HK achieve their 90% economic freedom?. Yes by democracy... They separated from China. and become capitalist. USA can do the same and achive 100% of economic freedom by democracy. just vote an Ancap.
@thundermover4258
@thundermover4258 5 лет назад
What about trump?
@rockfish1000
@rockfish1000 10 лет назад
Love these videos.
@splifsend
@splifsend 11 лет назад
i kept expecting the alien to roll about laughing.. Government is exactly how it discribes it.. a monopoly on law in a geographic area
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
Thank you! I used Xtranormal. Credit for the lipsynching and character movements belongs with the people who wrote that software.
@TAOTemplar
@TAOTemplar 11 лет назад
Great video again! Thanks for spreading anarchic awareness :) Or at least planting the seeds.
@prairiehip5018
@prairiehip5018 10 лет назад
All governments say....Remain Calm…Just keep voting the two party system, pay your taxes, listen to the controlled media, and pay no attention to conspiracy theories and alternative news….
@jacquitachas
@jacquitachas 11 лет назад
Excellent video again!! Posting to TRY to wake people up! Thanks.
@aaronjmattis
@aaronjmattis 8 лет назад
These videos are great
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 7 лет назад
Thank you
@maurices5954
@maurices5954 6 дней назад
Thanks for creating this video 👍
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
That would be great. I know of French, Spanish, German, Slovak and Greek versions of Part 1 (the German one is even dubbed!). If you google "Translations and Mirrors of Government Explained" you will find my blog post listing those I know about. There may be more. I'm not aware of any translations of Part 2.
@pmfkpk
@pmfkpk 11 лет назад
Amazing work.
@roughsketchguitarlickz7455
@roughsketchguitarlickz7455 10 лет назад
it actually never says in the constitution to pay taxes
@johngault2041
@johngault2041 10 лет назад
Not in the constitution,but the 16th amendment does,ratified February 3rd 1913 and signed into law by Woodrow Wilson.Wilson also signed into law the Federal reserve bill,Those two bill authorized the government to steal our money and devalue it's worth.
@roymarshall_
@roymarshall_ 11 лет назад
These are fantastic, two videos that would make any rational man a voluntaryist.
@davdiaz24
@davdiaz24 11 лет назад
Great Video! Thanks
@MrGman543
@MrGman543 11 лет назад
the sad thing is, this cartoon character understands government better than most US citizens.
@panthera2
@panthera2 Год назад
The ending says it all in 2023. And this should be a TV show 🎉🎇⛄
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
Thank you!
@christianschallermedia
@christianschallermedia 8 лет назад
very reflective, thank you!
@Liberty4Ever
@Liberty4Ever 10 лет назад
"Anarchy! Anarchy! I don't know what it is, but I like it!" Ricky Bobby's son in Talladega Nights
@sortofanoakyafterbirth3661
@sortofanoakyafterbirth3661 2 года назад
The Constitution tells us that it gives government the power to force us to give them money via taxes. The paper that tells us to keep government small and unpowerful, gives it the power to force us to give it money. No conflict there...
@anthonyleinweber1336
@anthonyleinweber1336 9 лет назад
thanks for pointing me to the second part :)
@alooperboopermeme5737
@alooperboopermeme5737 8 лет назад
this video is too true here I thought I was the only one who thought like this
@0myjoe
@0myjoe 10 лет назад
Yh i've heard of it and looked it up a bit, it seems pretty kool and i'll vote for it if i could
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
Fantastic! Do send me a link when it is up.
@rebeccalavrick6572
@rebeccalavrick6572 10 лет назад
Loved it.
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 10 лет назад
Thank you!
@southtexasprepper6605
@southtexasprepper6605 8 лет назад
Larken Rose would love these vids
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 8 лет назад
+Theo Martinez He inspired them. The script for this one is largely based on a talk he gave.
@jacquelinel1618
@jacquelinel1618 Год назад
Take me with you alien!
@FreeAimDog
@FreeAimDog 10 лет назад
wow. like drinking a fresh bottle of water watching this.
@adamhouse6305
@adamhouse6305 10 лет назад
brilliant
@skulijakobsson5116
@skulijakobsson5116 4 месяца назад
Much Enjoyment 👍😎
@shawnbruce6934
@shawnbruce6934 Год назад
Thank You So Much for Making This. I subbed, am sending this to as many people as I can and urging them to Sub as well. Great Job!!
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState Год назад
Thank you!
@prairiehip5018
@prairiehip5018 10 лет назад
Keep sharing this clip.
@CapnDumpsterDiver
@CapnDumpsterDiver 10 лет назад
Thanks Jesse, cuz the change deal left us getting just change not the dollar....(anyone noticed every time they tell us their gonna do something they do it, but not the way they depicted?)
@ClassASurfacing
@ClassASurfacing 11 лет назад
Love it.
@Aztecatl7
@Aztecatl7 7 лет назад
Please do one on religion explained to aliens
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 7 лет назад
That would be too easy. Plenty of other people mock the idea of religion.
@mfspectacular
@mfspectacular 2 года назад
Government is a religion itself
@Hotcheeehatos
@Hotcheeehatos 11 лет назад
thanks for pointing that out :)
@yoonjikim7173
@yoonjikim7173 9 лет назад
This is surprisingly fun :)
@MirageScience
@MirageScience 11 лет назад
just perfect
@philipdaelman1684
@philipdaelman1684 Год назад
PRACHTIG .Thanks from Belgium .
@golemkonty
@golemkonty 11 лет назад
brilliant and 100% true! did you do it yourself? shat software did you use?movements of the characters are good, lipsynching is good as well(especially on the human character), but you sould put a subdivision surface modifier on the meshes, so they are not blocky! especially the eyelids of the alien dont feel good. Or you were just saving rendering time?! Keep it up, people must know the truth!
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
Yeah - if I could do a believable American accent I would have done! If the human talking about the British constitutional monarchy system of government, Americans and other people living in republics might have thought the video doesn't apply to their system. In fact, the main motivation for making this sequel was to answer those commenters who thought (for some reason) that the first video only applied to democracies and not to republics.
@MikhaelAhava
@MikhaelAhava Год назад
Nice.
@fuckyourbullshit6380
@fuckyourbullshit6380 6 лет назад
so can you do a video over why we can't obtain land for free and why the government that does not have a clear identity can own all the land without payment or consequence?
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 6 лет назад
I'll think about a video, but it is quite straightforward. The government owns the land today because the government has decreed that it owns the land. They can do this because there is no one strong enough to oppose them. There is no one strong enough to oppose them because most people believe governments are legitimate and that it is acceptable for them to unilaterally declare themselves as owner of vast quantities of land. Without this belief in governmental authority, the government could not make such a bold declaration. And without governments making whatever rules suit them, we would likely have non-particularistic rules for initial ownership of land, such as the homesteading rule.
@walterdennisclark
@walterdennisclark 11 лет назад
Graham, Please study the concept of "memes" and add that to the next discussion between the American with a British accent and the space alien who speaks even better English. Walt
@starlordjae2577
@starlordjae2577 6 лет назад
We watching while doing my history homework on the founding fathers and the declaration of Independence 😂
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
Sure, I can. Check out my video series called Law Without Government.
@ytroadfox
@ytroadfox 11 лет назад
Great video. Thank you for posting. It is interesting to see a very well educated human struggle with the systemic paradoxes of the republic. But if people didn't know libertarianism, they would still think it is the only choice.
@RevNowWhileWeCan
@RevNowWhileWeCan 11 лет назад
They're are many fallacies about gov't that people ask that should be addressed like, "who will build the roads?" and "how will we defend ourselves?". This is the jist of why people tolerate "being robbed".
@PK-MegaLolCaT
@PK-MegaLolCaT 11 лет назад
it not just that you need them..it that like it or not their always going to be some sort of leadership around .for example a newspaper is informs people of what going on around the world and by doing so its moving everyone toward one direction , its leading people . it has control over people but just as much as the people allows this.. the problem is that people never question whatever the information is true or not and just trust newspaper will make sure the newspaper will do the right thing
@Cioghy
@Cioghy 11 лет назад
lets imagine a world without the state: 1. people want security so a demand for it is created. 2. security companies come to supply that demand, competing to attract customers. 3. some people don't want these services, so don't pay the companies, in return not getting private security (at best the indirect security from their neighbors) 4. Are you telling me that the security firms will force him to pay, beat him and lock him up if he doesn't, just because he decided to protect himself? really?
@0myjoe
@0myjoe 11 лет назад
But how would be organise people to make sure everything that needs doing will be done? Everything from caring for the elderly to growing food to building roads?
@cannedboyz
@cannedboyz 11 лет назад
If you have the synched English transcripts, I can translate it for you. I can guarantee no typos, no misspelling and proper vocabulary.
@dalavidadalavida
@dalavidadalavida 11 лет назад
Don't ask for someone else to tell you, You have the answer, you just have to enter that mind space. And if we all do, it will be a new birth onto a new world.
@mitster85
@mitster85 11 лет назад
This is now a common theme amongst people I meet, this is the zeitgeist of our current time, civil uprising is coming, but it must be done peacefully ie. non violent resistence
@anniej01988
@anniej01988 Год назад
Still accurate to this day!!!
@ManAgainstTheState
@ManAgainstTheState 11 лет назад
I have studied memes - fascinating subject! Have you seen the video series "Everything is a Remix"?
@rbc13183
@rbc13183 11 лет назад
Agreed.
@xb17
@xb17 11 лет назад
hello still need a translation? i am a native spanish speaker and i REALLY think this message should reach as many as possible =) should i translate your transcript? and should i send you a PM somewhere so you can load the subtitles to this or other video? hope i can help.
@AAAAAAshingHaulers
@AAAAAAshingHaulers 11 лет назад
This great government passed a law in Minnesota that says since I have a prior drug felony.It allowed them to give me 5 years prison for possession of a "firearm" AKA BB-gun that couldnt even break skin
@TheCoolhead27
@TheCoolhead27 11 лет назад
Yeah I guess some people find a hypothetical conversation between an Alien and a Human "unrealistic" if they dont speak in American accents.
@PK-MegaLolCaT
@PK-MegaLolCaT 11 лет назад
I'm mexican and student from the Ibero university.. before peña nieto our current president was forced into power..he went to give a conference at the university to the students to answer some of their questions ..of course this being Mexico the conference room got fill by people paid to support the candidate and not a Single student. the actual student didn't take this lightly, because many of us are quite aware of the Peña's history with corruption and some act of violence he took part of
@meetKEL
@meetKEL 10 лет назад
This alien probably comes from a Resource Based Economy. I want to go there
@buterfly131
@buterfly131 11 лет назад
Could i use this and part one video if i translate it to Hungarian? Would love people there to see this too!! :)
@Hotcheeehatos
@Hotcheeehatos 11 лет назад
We should get a bunch of people together and translate this in a few languages!
@PK-MegaLolCaT
@PK-MegaLolCaT 11 лет назад
i don't know if I'm explain myself well , I'm not really good at it
@michaellawson4549
@michaellawson4549 8 лет назад
Once again these videos are SPOT ON and accurate in most everything except ONE very important aspect. @ 2:06 - 2:49 @ 2:50 you finally mention a Republic and the process that SHOULD be in these United States. While we use the majority rules (Democratic) way as a voting tool in electing our Congress and other smaller leaders, that "process" does NOT make us a Democratic Government. Our Constitution FOR the United States guarantees us a Republican form of Government in Article 4 Section 4. So if that is guaranteed in the Constitution, yet you say in the videos that we are Democratic government, then our form of Government is UNCONSTITUTIONAL. The process in which we vote is still not a "true democracy" as we have seen in a few presidential elections where the POPULAR vote loses to the Electoral College process. So in reality, not even our vote for POTUS is Democratic in function but a way to inform the Electoral College what to do. LOVED THE VIDEOS other than that.
@177SCmaro
@177SCmaro 8 лет назад
What is the difference, fundamentally, between being ruled by a majority of voters and being ruled by a majority representatives (politicians)?
@ColorfullCute
@ColorfullCute 9 лет назад
well it is good animations and how dose this guy know both of them
@Hotcheeehatos
@Hotcheeehatos 11 лет назад
actualy it says "No taxation without representation" Implying that there is taxes...
@obits3
@obits3 11 лет назад
Governments will continues to exist for ever in some form or another. Here's why: Step 1: People want security Step 2: People get price sensitive and pool resources to make security cheaper. Step 3: People create "rules" this group security must follow. Step 4: The group agrees to pay dues for this security. Step 5: Some people stop paying and become "free riders." Step 6: Everyone get's made at the "free riders" for not paying. Step 7: Taxes
@arcadejaguar409
@arcadejaguar409 3 года назад
"I'm sure that's what they tell you". And they're right.
@VeraceSzK
@VeraceSzK 10 лет назад
Look up the whiskey rebellion too. The founders weren't against taxes.
@LMMEjsmith
@LMMEjsmith 11 лет назад
1:32 you mean like State governments, representatives, and senators?
@mba2ceo
@mba2ceo 11 лет назад
MAX was right .... The wolves fight among themselves, who will feed on the sheep.
@UNITED-SNAKES-OF-WEIMAR
@UNITED-SNAKES-OF-WEIMAR 8 дней назад
Yep.
@shazbovalen7026
@shazbovalen7026 11 лет назад
One can not have capitalism in the absence of the state without the institutions of capital becoming the new state and business men becoming the new government.
@Sawa137
@Sawa137 11 лет назад
Check out his other video: "But Wouldn't Warlords Take Over?"
Далее
How AIs, like ChatGPT, Learn
8:55
Просмотров 10 млн
НЕ ПОКУПАЙТЕ ЭТО!
00:29
Просмотров 32 тыс.
Organisms Are Not Made Of Atoms
20:26
Просмотров 156 тыс.
Charity vs. Taxation - What is the Difference?
13:42
Просмотров 108 тыс.
Essential John Locke: The Purpose of Government
2:13
Learning to Hack as a Kid
5:03
Просмотров 10 млн
Hinduism Explained
17:52
Просмотров 6 млн