Gradual Change or Eternal Inertia: The Pseudo-Secularism in India | DU Lit. Fest |  

India - Hindu vs muslims China - Atheist vs Muslims Sri Lanka - Buddhist vs Muslim Israel - Jew vs Muslim France - Christian vs Muslim Myanmar - Buddhist vs Muslims Middle East - Muslim vs Muslim

Tippu killed 800 iyengar brahmins in one Deepavali night in Melukote near Mysore !! Even till today Melukote do not celebrate Deepavali!

Islam originated from Mecca but - India has the second largest Muslim population India has second most number of mosque India was partitioned on the name of Islam So many countries which were a part of India in ancient times are now Islamic countries 50000 temples were demolished during the Islamic rule in India there are 57 Islamic countries more than 100 Christian countries but no Hindu countries in the world because Hindus are the CEO of secularism only Hindus have taken the responsibility of secularism others are busy in converting people Still Hindus are secular

True.. After reading Anand Rangnathan's book.. I can't describe the state of my brain and heart..being basically of fiery nature..his book has just made me like a volcano.. a word wrong by friend and relatives i just burst out for supporting the wrong people if they do.. One thing is - you can actually hear Anand R speaking as you read the words. He has exactly written the books as he speaks on stage or debates.

They didn't name their son Taimur without knowing the meaning. They did it purposely to mock Hindus. The Hindus carelessly go and watch their movies. You all know whom I am referring to. In case of the Chief Minister named after the dictator of Russia, at least when he was named by his father, that dictator of Russia was still worshipped.

Anand Ranganathan and Aabhas Maldahiyar are great. But my respect for Rahul Shivshankar has increased a thousand times coming from this kind of relatives.

Dr Anand Ranganathan is a genius . Pranam to all of you..

Thank you Anand Ranganathan Ji for speaking for Kashmiri pandits/Hindus. I am a Kashmiri Pandit who has not gone to her homeland Kashmir for last 34 years. #kashmirfiles

I too an ardent reader of history books, Anand's also he's perfect in his assessment, I admire his views, but am old and blood doesn't boil in haste. I was 7 when we rolled our bags and left Sindh in1947, memories are still fresh because bleeding flesh never get errazed. I am keen observer of Bhatiya event. My father was Netaji's worker, government railway contactor, work's spaning from Dhaka to Afganistan and Assam. I in 1963 have puffed cigerettes with Nehru at Kalaikunda before dawn for day's, also met Sam Bahadur and PS Bhagàt PVSM at Calcutta. I am few of lucky Bhartiya who have seen life's turbulence and survival, my last wish is RETURNING TO PAST GLORY which in last 1½ Century was lost for whatever reason. Hope to witness it in this life . Please pray for my wish.🙏

How many Muslims became secular By secularising our education system

I agree with Anand 99% of the times. But he is wrong about his criticism of the demolition of Babri structure. Had it not been demolished we would never have managed to find evidence of a vaishu temple underneath it. Sometimes what is morally correct is not what is legally correct.

The HINDUS Temples should have schools to teach us Hindus our culture, language and our history. 🙏🇮🇳🙏

Good discussion by Rahul Shivshankar, Anand Ranganathan and Aabhas Maldahiyar.

Absolute pleasure, listening to all 3 gentlemen. Thank you. Be well.

When you are a khan in India you get the guts to name your child taimur, not in any other country they will dare to do this kind of non sense.

The thing is the attitudes of the middle ages continue even today in that community.

Endless talents ..Anand and Rahul.

Thanks

नूपुर जी के जीत की हम हृदय से शुभकामनायें देना चाहते हैं . जय हो विजय हो यही कामना है♥♥♥

The most important message to the young students … YOU ARE THE ONES WHO WILL CARRY OUR FLAME IN THE FUTURE …

I am shocked that the things we are knowing now are being tried to vanished by the leftist through the academic power. We need more informative videos on these topic , every time we can't vote parties on roti , kapda , makan , we need ideological benifits to. We need more videos with appropriate references, facts , Evidences . ❤

Chhatrapati Shivaji founded Hindu empire in 1674ad. Maharani Tarabai , wife of 3 Rd Chhatrapati Rajaram with her Generals Killed Aurangzeb in 1707 at AurangBad. This ended Mughal rule Maratha Hindu empire ruled most of India leaving Hyderabad and Mysore ( Hindu ) till 1848. But Hindu Principalities at Gwalior,Indore,Dhar, Gujarat , Nagpur ,,Kolhapur,Tanjore( all Maratha ruled ) protected Hindus till 1947. Rajasthan’s four Major kingdoms and Mysore, Vijayanagaram were firmly embedded. History of these is never written in history text books.

just wow

Look what happened to the Native American Indians. This is what is happening to Hindus now. 🙏🇮🇳🙏

Excellent discussion with three intellectuals...loved listening to the same

One of the best videos , deserves to be seen extensively by all Hindus if not by all. Hope this is only the beginning of such developments. We are with you. God bless. Hope the Judges of our Country watch this video with neutral stand.

Sangam Talks always give discussions in substance.

This is so sad and also awakening

Please run a awareness campaign about "Malabar gold & diamond" as well. It is a Kerala based company owned by a "vishesh samudaay". It earned Rs. 51,000 crores last year. And you all know what is happening in Kerala. Imagine how much of this amount is being used against our own people in Kerala. Most Hindus are not aware of this. If we buy anything from this comapny, it means we are funding our own enemies. Hindus should not buy jewellery from it. There are many local / branded Hindu jewellers, from whom we can buy our jewellery. Bhale hi thode extra paise le lega, Kam se Kam humaare logo ka Sar tan se Juda ya luv jeehad ko promote to nahi karega.

We should not ask secularism unti our culture and tradition is or will safe.... Right or otherwise?

shocking😔😔

Please discuss in Hindi so that your voice can reach rural india

Patience. Detoxing is a slow process. If anybody wants immediate change, he will have to resort to revolution, may be at the cost of lives. The choice is open to everyone.

44:45 " 1 billion hindus left the judgement in the hand of 5 people " and look how long did that take 500 years so if u want kashi back legally u need to wait another 500 years if u can wait leave the judgement to 5 people again...

Rahul, your intellect and ability to craft argument is commendable.

India always been an accommodative nation for all communities. So secular nation is detrimental for Hindus and it's a political weapon to isolate Muslims from main stream social system.

Super conversations

Excellent discussion.

Very thought provoking discussion ❤🎉😊

At least few young activist told the truth, though taking real actions will take time. It has to be movement of people.

The most beautiful thing debated ever. Thank you #Sangam_Talks

Great guys...Rahul n Anand...n truthful

Also thank you Rahul Shivshankar and Anand Ranganathan for your sacred work and a good heart for majority Indians.

If babri was not broken the same supreme court woul never have given it

To Anand R... Is modi to solve the problems of hindus.. what hindus are doing . Do hidus expect modi to say openly he is pro hindu or do all hindu things. Its the right time to Hindus to fight for their rights or against injustices. Tragedy is Hindus are mum

superb dibet...⚡

Eye opening conversations!

Anand the world hindus, because hindus are law abiding.

This is for Rahul S - Please start using "Sanatan Dharma" instead of "Hindu" - a misnomer used by invader/outsider. "Sanatan Dharma" - a set of righteous conducts an individual shall follow at different phases of his/her life. This set of conducts vary at different phases of life and his/her profession, like "Childhood Dharma", Dharma of Youth (Bhrmacharjha)" , "Ghreshtya/Sangsar Dharma", "Raj Dharma", etc.

Good discussion

Excellent discussion

I've never expected Rahul Shivshankar ji speaking so much facts for the first time. I am truly impressed to see his level and depth of knowledge take a bow. And Mr. Ranganathan sir please be patient great things take time.

Thank you.

Love Anand ! Totally exposes the hypocrisy, just became his newest fan!👍👍👍👍. Totally true about the ancestors of Indian Muslims being victims of these invaders.

जय हिन्द 🇮🇳🙏

. A great talk show. Loved every minute ❤️ A feeling of depression sets in accompanied by raw anger towards the so called secularists, who are/were nothing but boot lickers of appeasement. Add to that is the raw deal from the courts. Double whammy. One real answer will be to declare those groups majority or minority as per population in each state, if not in each District. ...

Yes that is true sir 🙏

Very meaningful and needful news who should come to know by all ❤🎉😢

Ok; Dr. Ranganath, that, bringing down that monument of insult ( Babri structure) was not the way Hindus should have adopted was not acceptable. But imagine, had it not happened that way, that day, do you really believe that the day what Hindu society would have seen the pleasant movement witnessed on Jan 22! Any way, I am proud to be part of that action that day! and today breathing a pleasant air of satisfaction!

Ourgjab on that time sir 🎉

Great sir, I missed this earlier , but this is not tiger by the tail... This is you holding a tiger by its ears.. great for those how would listen. Please hav these discussions in Hindi, Bhojpuri, Assamese, Nagameene....

So truly said by Rahul sir that they romanticised history for hindu-muslim bhai bhai but group reality and people collectively memory was and is different even today!!

Today Hampe Badme Hoysla on that time to going to seeing on that day sir 🙏

Shashi tharoor had no understanding of Sanatan Dharma or religions. Hindu Pakistan is a damn good idea as argued by Sanjay Dixit.

🎉🎉

Anand Ranganathan 🔥

सभी सनातन धर्म प्रेमियों को जिहादियों के त्यौहार ईद की हार्दिक (दुखकामनाएं) 😂😂😂😂😂

An interesting piece by Tavleen Singh, The Indian Express 21.04.2024 :- Many things have changed in India since Narendra Modi first became prime minister. But one change that has gone almost unnoticed is that a process of real decolonisation has transpired. And because of this the old, colonised ruling class has been swept away. This is a very good thing. It should have happened long, long ago. As someone who belonged to that ruling class, I consider myself well qualified to explain why this process of decolonisation was overdue and how we failed India as its ruling class. The truth is we were an effete, hopeless bunch. We spoke no Indian language well, but this did not matter to us. We were proud of speaking English well. In our drawing rooms we sneered at those who dared enter without speaking good English. And at those whose table manners were not embellished with western refinement. In short, those who fumbled with forks and knives and preferred eating with their hands and without cutlery. When we travelled to foreign lands, we made a good pretense of being Indian, but we never cared to understand what it meant to be Indian. We pretended to know everything about India’s ancient culture and civilisation, but we knew almost nothing. In the schools and colleges we attended, we learned more about western civilisation, history, and literature than about our own, so it was not totally our fault. When it came to politics and elections, we stuck loyally by the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty and its various heirs because they were people like us. We did not care that Parliament had been turned into a private members club. It was our club. Nor did we care that the Congress Party under Sonia Gandhi’s stewardship had also become a private club. It was our club. In our drawing rooms we talked endlessly of democracy and secularism and saw ourselves as ordained to protect these ideas. Then along came Narendra Modi and the earth shifted beneath our feet. He may not have been personally responsible for everything that changed but he was a vital part of the political change that happened, and this somehow became an essential element of the bigger changes that were happening. Suddenly, almost overnight, after Modi first became prime minister, we became not just powerless but irrelevant. A new breed of Indians who spoke Hindi well and English not at all started replacing us in the high offices of government, as political analysts, and anchors in TV studios, in journalism, in Bollywood movies and TV series. They were not impressed with our skills in English, and we were so impressed by how Indian they were that we tried to emulate them just to belong. Some of us have succeeded, most of us have not. Those who have not but wish to continue being relevant cling these days to Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi and hope that somehow, they will be able to defeat Modi. Some act as advisors to the current heirs of the Dynasty and fill their heads with grandiose ideas like saving the Constitution and saving democracy. But the truth is that Rahul Gandhi’s main message remains the same as it was in the last general election. This is that Modi is corrupt and that he works only for a handful of rich Indians. He steals your money, he shrieks at his political rallies, and he gives it to his rich friends. How exactly does this work? As leader of the Congress Party, he is seen, especially by foreign correspondents, as the only man who can defeat Modi. It is bad luck for him that he seems so incapable of convincing Indian voters of this, despite trying hard to prove that he is one of them. He has worked with farmers in rice fields, transported coal on bicycles with miners, listened to the woes of vegetable sellers and spent long hours with mechanics in dingy shops to show how much he cares about the ‘common man.’ So why is the common man not impressed? Could it be because these gestures come across somehow as noblesse oblige and not genuine acts of sympathy? What is it about ‘autocratic’, ‘dictatorial’ Modi that attracts ordinary Indian voters more? The answer that I got to this question on my recent travels in rural India is that people have seen changes in their lives, and they believe that these changes have happened because of Modi. These are not remarkable changes. They are simple things like roads, drinking water, electricity, and Internet services but because they were not there before, they seem remarkable. Many of these things should have happened long ago. But because we were so colonised a ruling class, we did not notice that ordinary Indians were forced to endure the worst public services. In our drawing rooms and in our entitlement, we did not care about such things because in our privileged cocoon it would have been unthinkable to go to a government hospital or a government school. Modi’s advent burst the bubble in which we lived, and the truth is that most of us have no idea why this happened. We continue to hope that he will be defeated this time and hope that the message that democracy is in danger will resonate with voters. When the results come, we are likely to be disappointed again. I met nobody in rural India who saw Modi as corrupt and autocratic. -----++---+--++--++-----

🙏🙏🙏

Like the psuedo histories of ramayana, maha bharatha etc.

O.M.Mathai, private secretary to Nehru wrote 2 books...(an eye opener) a) Reminiscences of the Nehru Age (1978) and b) My Days with Nehru (1979). Where he has written (among other things), the feeling of entitlement the Gandhis have about India as though they inherited this country to do as they like. They had their shot for 60 yrs and what much is there to show? Unemployment, poverty and inflation has been there since independence and was at the highest till 2014. The percentage has come down drastically and they harp about it as though India was a garden of Eden till 2014

❤❤❤❤

❤❤

🙏❤️🙏

Wish I had all these videos as podcast

great scholars

I don't think common people are worried about Modi coming back to power, people with vested interest only for ex: those who are part of religious conversion web. Converting people who are struggling financially /emotionally were the easy target. Maybe this Govt is going after those people and thier organizations. That is the reason peddling this Hindur rashtra scare and minority in danger narrative. Govts in the past showed the blind eye when things were happening. May be their funding comes from there too?

👍

❤❤❤❤❤

You people are do good ❤❤❤ more offensive ....data will be appreciated ❤❤❤

You are so right I was told that Ashoka converted after Kalinga war after seeing all the deaths. So corrupted was our history to malign our religion. This is what happens if you have a Muslim as our education minister

The Ghandhi's are not HINDUS.

Three days to going on that nadihils on that time sir super on that time sir

Anandji take care of your heart, you speak a lot from it.

Very good discussion. Where we will get the book

❤❤❤❤👍👍👍👍

Guys this is not just to make you informative but to provoke and awake you from slumber. Don’t just limit yourself at praising people also your blood should boil out of anger and then it should further find its expression through your action in our society only then the change will come….. so start reacting to these discourse whenever or wherever you hear such discourse

I often think that its more important to read the Quran first and The Hindu Epics later on. As they say, keep your friends close but keep your enemies closer.

🎉👍🇮🇳

This book release & discussion would have happened before pranprathishta of Ram temple in Ayodhya & video uploaded only 6 days ago.

इविल एवरी वन टू टेकिंग आन थाट टाईम सर 🎉

Today learning school on that books on that time to write on that songs on that time sir Hampe Badme Hoysla on that time sir

Watch Mother India, how Nargis shoots his own Son Sunil Dutt. 😩😩

The king used to say on climbing on the throne "NADANDYOSMI, NADANDYOSMI NADANDYOSMI" and then the Raja Guru tap on his head with " Dharma Danda" ( Sengole! ) saying "DHARMA DANDYOSI DHARMA DANDYOSI DHARMA DANDYOSI" !

Angkor-wat was originally built by a Hindu king that was changed to a Buddhist temple by his son and his own son who took to be a Hindu had changed the temple back as a Hindu temple. But his son who became a Buddhist changed back the temple to a Buddhist one. Today there is a four armed Vishnu idol standing in the courtyard with Shankhu, Chakra, Gada, Padma bearing a Buddha head placed on it!! So change in a temple from Hindu to Buddha and vice verse may not be due to invasion but conversion as with Ashoka and Chandra Gupta who took to Jainism!

If Modiji open any masjid every muslim voted for him, what happened to our Hindu

Ranganathan is 🔥.

Why can’t we have a TRUTH & RECONCILIATION COMMISSION … ?

By bhaichara they meant make others feel like bhai and make them chara

We are tired of waiting