GUESS The Meltzer Star Rating Episode 2 

Y'all shine brighter than Dave :D

I really like this format. I think a brief summary from the review would add insight to why meltzer gave it that rating

You could do this again but Friendo Edition. Do a community post asking us our favourite matches. You pick some and find the star ratings

First time ever joining live. Excited to join the friendos

Dave certainly is a very special guy, I'll say that much. Super special, and his ratings are clearly based on reality.

I was at the Falls Court Everywhere match on that RAW. Was in Charlotte, NC. It was the same show Cesaro and Sheamus had the bar fight and became friends, which is why they were known as The Bar

Katras were not aligned today, friendos, even I got none right and I had Google at my fingertips! But I like this fun little nerd challenge between you two. It's nice when good friendos can hang out and make fun of each other for getting things wrong.

This was much better than guessing one whole PPV. These new rules keeps you guessing and it’s funny when one has the same match on their list. 😅

I like this way you guys are doing it! Can't wait for the 3rd one these are fun and enjoyable to watch!

This was so much fun. I love these episodes!

I like this bit. I give you 3 and 3/4 wombat cubes. Good stuff guys, but a little room for improvement.

3:58 I'm immediately picturing a trap with two or three wrestlers who have to battle each other to retrieve a key in true MitB fashion, before time runs out. Lionsgate, Twisted Pictures, book it!

Honestly just make the video even longer this is great

For the Starrcade 1997 match they mentioned during the Superbrawl match, I say this about it: Even if the plan went off without a hitch, I would still say the match would've been a failure because of how the match was structured. With what they said about how Hogan beat the hell out of Sting for most of the match at Superbrawl, that happened at Starrcade as well. So, even if the planned spot happened, it wouldn't have mattered because Sting would have looked like a weak champion regardless.

I think totaling the difference between your guess and the correct answer could be a good way if you want to score it. Lowest wins ala golf

Friendos!

The race for the flag match lol

I love the Okada sticker, does anyone know where that's from?

You could use the series to stick it to your broadcast partner and only pick matches that you know they haven't seen.

First, I love that Enforcer was present in this video. I might have teared up a bit. Second, I was the one person who loved the zombie lumberjack match lol. You guys are great and its fun watching you go back through Dave’s ratings.

Steve you and Larson need to check out your wrestling news, STAT. Cash Wheeler was arrested in Florida!

Thank you for talking about that flag match. Legit made me stop watching WWE for a year because of how bad it was. My most hated match ever

I think a fun way to do this would be the start with a set number of star points (if you're doing 10 matches on a 5 star scale you have 50 points). You put in your guess for how many stars Meltzer gave and how many you're off by you lose that many points (ie if you guess 4 stars and it was 4.5 stars, you lose .5 star points). Whoever ends with the most star points wins the episode

I was at Battleground 17 and its the last time I bought a WWE ticket. Ooof the Cena Rusev match was terrible. So was the prison match.

you should attempt to get Meltzer on to do one of these with you so he can explain why he gave it what he gave instead of trying to find his newsletter

One constructive criticism: Next time, all Sid matches only!

You too can learn a thing or two from Dave!!