Gunners Shot Clips : China's Himalayan Blunder / Lt Gen Vinod Bhatia (R) / Lt Gen P R Shankar (R) 

Thanks Sir, you are not only updating our awareness but improving our way of thinking about China time to time. Thanks a lot. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Respected Generals Good Morning from Germany.Sir,not only Youth of Bharat but also NRI`s are against China,& I am 75 Years Old (My Name:Ajit Singh Malik)and have not forgotten Chinese TReachery just like that of Chinese Proxy Pakistan.... Jai Hind Vande Mataram Jo Bole Sau Nihal Satsiriakal

Hugely informative and thought provoking generals. Few important takeaway points 1. Galwan has helped India bury the ghost of 1962. India is now hugely confident of standing up to China and conversely the Chinese would have also got a reality check that India which must have reduced their confidence a lot. 2. The Galwan incident was like a Vaccine for India. It has woken the Tiger from it’s slumber and the infra build up and weapons addition has been huge. Maybe we would not have had the sense of urgency without Galwan 3. Not just India but Japan, Philippines and Vietnam are arming up. Especially Japan, which is moving away from its pacifist constitution to getting more dual use platforms as well as doubling its defence budget. It is even ready to sell arms to friendly countries. 4. Ukraine war has taught us the need for a indigenous military industrial base for sustaining wars of attrition for at least 6 months. Thrust on Atmanirbar is vital to get more Bang for the Buck. 5. The item of food security mentioned is very important. India must more towards more climate resilient food. Worrying Trena is large tracks of arable land is being diverted to Solar Power and Urbanisation. The latter being one of the main reasons for Pakistan’s food problem. 6. Skilling of our population is a huge requirement and hope this is taken up on a war footing in the next decade. 7. It is time world activates Tibet and East Turkmenistan (other two Ts of China’s 3T weakness). The world needs to step back from its recognition of China and Xinjiang as Chinese territory and bring it on the bargaining table

Brilliant discussion Big thank you

Lots of Regards and Love to two Generals ❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳Jai Hind, Vande Matram 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳💖🇨🇵

Jai hind gn. Sb. Mere favourite subject per conservation ke lie dhanybad

Very Informative Session, Jai Hind Sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Sir 🙏

Good discussion sir

Great to hear both of you. Listening to both of you is very confidence enhancing and reassuring experience for us. 🙏🏻

👌

A very crucial & healthy discussion. Ay d same time kl we should not forget China's extreme cunning ness for which we should be very proactive & carefull.🙏

Jai Hind Sir

✔️ Jai Hind 🙏

Jai Bharat 🇮🇳

Jai Bharat

🙏🙏 Sir Ji. Aapke Hindi pahelay say bahut improve ho gaye haI OR subject jo aap layty hai superb👍

The Famous Episode Once More...

Thanks!

✅

It is such a big border. If they transgress we should also choose some areas and inch into Tibet as well.

Sir China is sitting pretty over almost 4000 sq km of no man land pushing the buffer Zone in India. Our PM didn't go to Tawang. There is no blunder ,China playing as per plan.

Real hot subject true analysis 👏🏻🫡🫡🇮🇳🇮🇳

From my experience on China 🇨🇳 I can say they have never been trustworthy. Credit goes to the present Indian government and establishment for recognising it and for taking preemptive measures like infra development and hitting on the economics interest of China.

We need more cyber and conventional capability

I am a regular viewer of your videos, thanks for important and interesting informations. Recently there are a few predictions that within 2025 and 2030 there is going to be a India China war, could you share your views on this. Thank you

My interaction with young generation is mixed .They are more concerned about business ties than national interests ! I talk of the cream ..IIM guys

General all your episodes are intelectual. Please can keep it in english.

Audio/Voice is not clear please

Sir we don't understand Hindi since we are from South pls maintain English or create a separate channel for English

What about our withdrawal from Kailash heights .This issue ahs been discussed often as a tactical mistake

There is a famous saying defining types of people : *- Peaceful Person :* A person capable of being ruthless and great violence but choosing the path of peace. *- Harmless Person :* A person incapable of violence and who garbs his behavior as a peaceful behaviour! Sometime back you had spoken about Agni V and MIRV. So it seems like in the event of a war we have Nuclear Deterrence. However, do we have *Conventional War Deterrence* ?! Can we sustain a 30 Day 2-Front war while causing extremely serious damage to our opponents while defending the heartland adequately.

Sound quality is poor .

Gen Bhatia's voice is echoing. it would be better if he uses a collar mic

Bharat or India to be represented by present & future generation remains?

China's economy is 3 times of Indias.amd defence wise much advanced. If Chinese bring their Navy and rocket force against India then the concequenses will be much dire.😮😮😮😮

Audio is very poor quality

China,pak always think us as their rival,from 1962 onwards.which fact we recognized much later.we have no future strategy in our foreign policy

Let us be clear about China's policy towards India. China will keep India engaged on our borders and also exercise one-upmanship in diplomacy. India can only meet Chinese challenge by being economically, militarily and socially strong. We can never be complacent

China has an ambition from the beginning to shift it's border beyond Himalayas after capturing Tibet. It will have direct connect to South Asian Region and hot water ocean.

Respected Generals, is it not the right time to recognise Tibetan Government in Excile and encourage other countries to follow India ? Once Tibet is free, all such problems will disappear automatically. Bharat Mata Di Jai

poor Audio

Sir , what are the implications of China sending drinking water to Maldives. Security of India is at stake . What should India. Hope government of India takes corrective measures, before it's too late

India should give its military veterans proper space in making defence policies and should benefit from their experience.

China ke sath halat thek nahi hai upper se Sonam wangchuk ladakh ke logon ko bodar March karne khe Raha hai.agar Jana hai tho delhi March karna chai .pata nahi kya chal raha hai ajkal . Jai hind .

Sound quality is not so satisfactory

Respected General Shankar a humble Suggestion that you do a stream on personal experience of your and other Defence leaders .as more peoples like to listen the adventures tales

We should strengthen ourselves over the next five years(both externally and internally). These five years are our vulnerable years. After that, we are pretty much invincible.

And yet decades after 1962 tayaar kyun nahi Thea? Excuses, excuses and yet more excuses

India capturing Lipulekh and kalapani of Nepal is blunder

lIndia Tibet Relation - Arunachal Pradesh China had never a border with India. It was, is and will always be the India Tibet border. If China makes too much pressure on and provocation of India? In response India should sponsor an international Forum Discussion on Shimla Treaty between India & Tibet 1914 to internationalise Tibet China Conflict India dont need to respect One China Policy if China dont respect One India Policy - precisely speaking hit the rabbit, dont beat all the bush. Geopolitics Simplified Analysis

Please, either speak Hindi throughout or English throughout, don't mix because you have an international audience of listeners.

China had no border with BHARAT with Tibet being the buffer nation. Tibet's 6 million natuon could not really defend its nation. India was weak when China took over Tibet. The real issue is water. China being a great power may have jurisdiction over northern Tibet feeding its rivers but the 3 Indian river systems belong to Bharat. So China will have to be pushed back and the Tibetian nation restored. Bharat Leadership must exercise its right to push back China.

Hardly understandable! Indians claim they speak English but tell me if these Indian Gen. are speaking English? I would like to know what they are saying.

G"Jab raat hai asi matwali to subeh ka alam kya hoga " ? Jab retd..GN s ka body leagues itna dengerous hai to Abhi ke Jawano ka kya. ? Main aur general Shaker Sahab Bhatia Sahib se totally agreed hai. Welcome and thank you

Russians not able to defeat small country like Ukaraine. Israel not able to rout palestines or hamas. How do China aim to defeat a big country like India. Silly remarks to put up a bravado

I am a true nationalist but can't listen so many lies in this conversation...1. China ka exports down hogaya kahanse se hogaya sir China ka exports all time high hai iss wakt..2.China k weapon system humse 100 saal ahead hain quality mein bhi aur quantity mein bhi..3. China kA Adversary no 1 USA hai apke hisaab se magar vo khud decide karega ki usko kiss wakt kisko adversary no 1 banana hai agar usne India ko bana liya to humko kon bachayega koi bhi nahi jis USA ki godi mein baith ker hum apne AAP ko safe mante the uski sachai Ukraine war mein pata chal gayi USA NAHI bacha Paya Ukraine ko vobhi Russia se joki China se half he hai weapon system quantity mein ....4. Strategic patience se hum China se war jitne Wale hain to bhagwan he humko bachye...5.Kabhi humare General humko ye kyu nahi batate ki humre pass vo konse wonder weapon's hain aur kitni quantity mein hai Jo humko China ko harane mein game Changer honge abhi Tak mein Aisa ek bhi weapon system nahi dund Paya jiske muqabla mein China k pass ussse superior system naho ...6 sirf batein he batein jab hum APNE SARE CRITICAL IMPORTS CHINA SE KARTE HAIN LIKE MEDICAL MACHINES CONSTRUCTION MACHINE POWER GENERATION MACHINE TELECOM EQUIPMENT ETC ETC to hum China se khaak ladenge China jab chahe humko stone ages mein pahucha sakta hai sirf humko exports na karke....Humko hazaaro labs research and development ki lagani thi humko pata nahi abhi semiconductors ki chips banane k liye 50 saal se 100 saal lag jayega phir bhi jhuti kahaniya sunate raho desh wasiyo ko lekin agar China ne hum par humla kardiya Aur USA nahi aya bachne to sab ki ankhe fati rah jayengi aur tab ye sabhi expert dobara kabhi Nazar nahi ayenge ye batane k liye ki China kyu weak hai jaise ab vo sare expert gayab ho chuke ho bata rahe the ki Russia bahut weak hai aur NATO ki help se Ukraine uski ARMY ko khatam kardega ya bahut weak kardega ab vo sab gayab ho chuke hain aur log murkho ki tarah yakin he nahi kar pa rahe ki Russia ne Ukraine na sirf Hara Diya hai balki 40% western weapon system bhi khatam kardiye ....to Bhagwan k liye Sach bolo taki log mansik roop se tayaar rahe ki China India war mein humko kya kya dekhne ki milsakta hai Jai hind....

Please stop going to Qamar Cheema show.

Bhatia Sir's voice is not clearly audible due to excessive sound.

People of ladakh wont support you anymore what ypi doing there now bjp

Bhavishya Malika predictions 2025 second half Zatkka lagnaa suru !!! Aaggee aagee DEKHOO hottaa hai kyaa ???? Bay of Bengal , Punjab Kasmir , !!! Be Ready for sunami & China Navy attack!!!

Jai Hind Sir 🙏 Sir मेरे कुछ सवाल है! 1, भारत वन चाइना पॉलिसी से इतना क्यों चिपका हुआ है ??? 2, भारत को तिब्बत को संप्रभु देश क्यों घोषित नहीं करना चाहिए?? 3, सर आज भारत 2.5 फ्रंट वॉर के लिए तैयार है??? 2,

Ladakh is Khalsa Sarkar territory