poor dude got MURDERED by comment bots anyways it's a tiktok cape so i would've regretted nothing regardless. guess i just get more reason to not regret it :)
Counterpoint ! The pixel on the cape was colored like this on purpose, as the artist may have taken into consideration that THAT pixel was the most facing into the source of light (sun), and the rest is color theory.
I like how the "problem" of the TikTok cape was a single slightly different colored cyan pixel that absolutely no one would ever notice it without using Photoshop
@Joseph_14441 3 subscribers. Your Mum Your Dad And your Alt Wait. You don't have a Dad, so maybe you just have two alternate accounts. That'd make more sense. Also just so no one tells me, I know this guy isn't going to reply. I just like making fun of these kinds of people (annoying).
If you subtract 35babe from 35b9bb, you find the difference between the two colors (converted to decimal) is 259. Thats 259 off out of 16 million colors.
It's even funnier when he says he absolutely doesn't believe you can see it with the naked eye, meanwhile I saw immediately what was wrong the second he singled those pixels out.
To me it appears a tiny bit darker than the right colored. And as it should, since its green and blue components are slightly lower, which corresponds to a darker shade
Reminds me of a classic russian anecdote: A man writes a letter to a match factory: "For 10 years I have been buying matches from your factory and counting the number of matches in a box. One time you put 59 of them, then 60 pieces, sometimes 61, and yesterday you put 56. Are you people in your right minds?"
I used to have problems like that at my work when parts were being kitted. It takes way too long to count a thousand parts by hand so they put it on the scale and count by weight. Problem is variations in the weight of each individual part meant that the kit would sometimes be off by a few pieces. Too many wasn't a problem, spare parts get returned easily. Too few and I had to go find someone to get more parts out of storage.
The real question is not "why are there slightly different amounts of matches in each box," but rather "why have you been counting your matches every time you buy a box for TEN YEARS?!" I see the similarity to this situation. Although I do have to wonder exactly how this happened. I would have guessed that people usually use the color picker tool when designing textures with multiple instances of the same color, so... what in the world happened here?
at 2:32 you say you can't see it with the naked eye, but it is pretty easy once you look at it closer, It has an ever-so-slight color difference and now I can't unsee. it
Nooo nooo why after he brought it up i could accually see the diffrence in the color in the fact that the upper one was a bit more greenish, Ive been drawing for too long
Hm, I wonder. When I last had my vision tested, I was 20/13, I've always had light sensitivity problems with things like fluorescent tube lighting, and if you gave me a nothing more than a swatch and an HSL colour wheel, I could pick out that swatch within 1 or 2 hex values. Are I Tetra? I've never heard of it before.
the video has three color channels, tetrachromacy doesn't have anything to do with it your display can't even show more than three color channels either
@@K-Anator Do you have two X chromosomes? If so, was your father colorblind or color deficient? If the answer to either question is no, then you _probably_ don't have four different sets of cones. But there are always exceptions and outliers.
You can definitely see the colour difference with the naked eye. Ive been doing art for a while now and with some training its pretty easy to spot out miscoloured pixels etc. Ofc in this case it was in the very top corner which is almost never seen or focused on, but had i opened the sprite myself i probably couldve picked it out after looking around Its important to note that some people have better colour vision than others the same way some people have better short or long range vision, its generally more uniform, but there is variance in the number of light cones and their density between people
I are superman. Above average colour acuity and last I was at an optometrist I had 20/13 vision, though I'd hazard to guess it's more towards 20/15 now. That or maybe I can blame it on spending all that time as a teenager customizing my MySpace profile. Who knows?
2:25 "now you can't see this with the naked eye" Uh yes I can, the 'foreign pixel' is slightly more saturated than the rest of the cyan pixels. Its a subtle difference, and is unnoticeable unless you are looking for it.
2:26 except most artists and graphic designers, even if they wouldnt notice naturally, can DEFINITELY see a shade difference even if its tiny, including me
This happened to me on a project I worked on with a pixel art map. It wasn't until I went to try and reduce color count in libresprite that I noticed a few different colors had near perfect duplicates used on like one part of the map
I might be making this up but I think I can see a slight difference between the two pixels. The miscoloured one looks slightly lighter than the proper colour. There is definetly a slight difference between the two though…or I really am just making stuff up.
@@MinecraftFan963 That might actually help you in cases like this, depending on which cones your colourblindness effects. Given the red channel stays the same, but the blue and green are the ones that shift, you may notice a larger difference in the overall colour because, for instance, the green channel means very little to your eyes. Not exactly sure how it'd work out, but it makes sense in my head. As soon as he said it was that pixel I picked up on it being brighter, before he said why it was that pixel, but I've been playing with graphics software for 20+ years and have either learned over the years to spot these minute differences or it's something to do with my light sensitivity and 20/13 vision.
I have a very good eye for colours, i can tell the difference. But the fact that somebody noticed it WITHOUT getting told is just messing with my brain
What I love is that these kinds of things are submitted as big reports, when they could literally be done on purpose because having slightly different shades of color on a texture creates more visual noise and makes the human brain produce happy chemicals
I couldn't see it until you pointed it out, but that's only because I have a pretty good monitor in a nice dark room and a good eye for colour. Absolutely don't understand how someone spotted this without opening the texture and literally checking the colour palette lol Or perhaps they used some code to analyse the hex colours of all the pixels to find odd instances with low frequencies of use? But yeah, your idea is probably the right one.
I liked the cape design. I made a TikTok account just to get it. I spent several hours trying to get it. I followed several tutorials explaining what you need to do and couldn't get it. So apparently you had to watch a stream which was in a similar location and they had to have it enabled as a price. There were exactly 0 such streams anytime I looked. The way they implemented it was the biggest FU from Mojang I think I've ever gotten. Right after how they released the beautiful cherry blossom capes after the mob vote ended, the one vote I missed because I prioritized real life stuff before a silly vote which I had no real incentive to participate in (and I also forgot when it was supposed to take place).
Technical explanation Delta-E of those 2 color is 0.8085 with Delta-E 2000 or CIE2000 standard Human eye can distinguish between 2 colors with value of 1 and only some people can do that And normal consumer monitor has Delta-E of more then 2 For reference a good calibrated OLED monitor might do avg Delta-E of 1 and that would set you back for a entry level color grading monitor of at least 1k USD
adding to the pile, they must just love to do this, i found one pixel like this, while I was trying to research how to make a vanilla looking texturepack, on the deepslat redstone texture and thought that was the only one, and oh boy was i wrong.
2:28 it's pretty clear to me tbh it's subtle, but I can definitely see the difference I'd never notice it in game with the lighting though, and I wouldn't notice it if it wasn't pointed out
Ever since I realised about two years after I tried get Java and Bedrock on my PC but failed and said I’d come back to it in future but then realised that they’re now sold together and anyone who bought them separately before this change got a Vanilla Cape, I’ve really wanted to collect every possible cape, because I hated just having the Pan Cape which everyone automatically got when the character creator was added, and that one random cherry cape from when 1.20 came out. So I was quite happy when they released three new capes for their fifteenth anniversary, and I wanted to get all of them. But then I realised one was a TikTok cape. I don’t have or intend to use Twitch or TikTok, but I did spend over an hour on your stream one time trying to get the Twitch cape, and eventually did. But I am not desperate enough to get every cape to go onto TikTok. But yeah now I’m trying to get the MCC cape. Almost there. Just a few more of the beanie-wearing challenges and the last four cave challenges and I’ll be there
I would have more in mind the fact that the bottom part of the cape just occasionally just flip itself, but yeah sure a random pixel that only someone with a keen eye would notice-
I am probably wrong but if there are so many 1 pixel color changes it might be a sort of a anti piracy system. What i mean by that is if someone steals textures from Minecraft Mojang can file a lawsuit and prove that its theirs because of those 1 pixel changes. Companies making maps often add non existent villages and cities to their maps for the same reason
I noticed the miscolored pixel right away, its (to me) obviously darker than the others. There is 2 reasons why, one is the type of monitor you use and the other is something a lot of people dont realize. Just like how there is people who are color blind due to have less rods to receive light in there eyes, there is people who are more color perceptive and can distinguish more shades of color than others due to having more rods to receive light in their eyes. (i am one of the people who can see more shades of colors than normal.
If you look at where the lighter colored pixel is on the cape... its on the top, where the light would hit. Its actually very possible that this was intentional color design and not a mistake at all. light colors tend to be more effected by changes in lighting than dark colors, and the majority of the cape is black, so it would be more noticeable on the blue if the cape were to have the same lighting conditions irl
Honestly, as a software engineer, i love this kind of stuff. Mainly because attention to detail is important. Also because it's easy work for days when you are lazy
When you went close up I could tell they were different XD the naked eye wins this round... just crazy that someone noticed it without first knowing it.
Looks awful in my opinion, too busy and disorienting. The Elytra texture is even worse somehow. I'll gladly stick to my 15th anniversary and migratory capes.
I can see the difference between the two different shades of cyan. The singled out pixel is slightly lighter than the rest of the cyan in the texture. I saw it almost immediately.
It actually make sense... There's more light on that pixel because it is facing up so it's colored slightly different... If the red one isn't slightly different I would consider that one the miscolored one then.
I used to think I was ever so slightly colorblind but then I saw the difference between the pixels and was barely able to tell the difference (miscolored one is a bit more “toothpaste-y”)
I've just finished a project fixing all the miscolorations in the original Programmer Art textures and I'm soon gonna continue with the JAPPA textures. Let me just say it is not fun in most cases.
i don't think any of those other examples are discolored what so ever. I think they just used some slight self-determined "noise" (recolored it to add more realism and imperfections.)
2:28 when you zoomed in it was instantly noticeable to me that it was miscolored. I dont know if its just me playing Geometry Dash too much or staring at the screen too much, but the color difference instantly clicked. Especially when looking at the shared corner, it took a bit of squinting to be able to see the difference a second time, but yeah, that pixel is slightly lighter than the rest.
