Who should I react to next? Just for you my FREE course "Sing Better Instantly:" skl.sh/3aHdSuy. Join our B-E-A-U-TIFUL Family on Patreon to influence and support channel content, connect with great people, and get personal replies from me: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 😊💖
You should react to the metal band called powerwolf. I RECOMMEND the song called demons are a girl's best friend and also the one featuring the singer allicia white-gluz. Those are two very different version
So, you can hear the B1 because the B0 actually comes from singing a B1 with a different frequency created by your vestibular folds which creates a resonance an octave below. Whenever you sing with subharmonics, both octaves can be heard, but the lower one tends to be more prominent and can be further amplified in post production. I'm guessing they wanted both notes heard to create a fuller overall sound.
@@Marcell0Bass my bad. That was the explanation I read that made the most sense to me. It's hard to know which sources are reliable as there isn't a lot of scientific research on this. If you have more reliable information, please share.
@@natebaker3672 yeah. So subharmonics use your true folds (the same ones you use for chest voice and most singing techniques) they’re called a set of vocal folds because there is more than one fold in each set. You’ll have one fold singing a note and then another singing a perfect fifth above that. Because the frequency of these 2 notes are in a ratio of 2:3 it means that when they every time they oscillate at the exact same time, if you drew out that frequency it would be the octave below the fundamental pitch.
Vocal Fry + Sub Harmonics = Dragon Breath lol. I'm no speech pathologist, but when I start a lower note with a tad of vocal fry it taps into the octave below for a bit and pops into the note I was going for. Country singers do this often and I think that's what happened there. Beatboxers do this a lot with their bass sounds they can create, and the best ones can resonate both octaves. The human voice is truly phenomenal!
Maggie... If Geoff is using a subharmonic to get the B0 he is actually chesting the B1 and frying the 5th below (E1). You might be hearing the tonic (B1). I had the same reaction the first time I heard the song. That note is for sure a B0.
If I understand his technique correctly, he reaches some low notes by making one of his vocal cords vibrate at half the frequency of the other one. So a B0 with B1 overtone would make sense,
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
@@DougRayPhillips no subharmonic us when you use both your true and false vocal cords. The false cords create a sound a perfect 5th above the sound the true folds are making
Fun fact: Scott Porter was their original beatboxer (and Layne the original baritone) back in the day, when he left to pursue acting, Layne took over as beatboxer.
You should react to Voiceplay's Wicked medley (took Geoff 2 years to be happy with the arrangement) and Geoff Castalucci's cover of God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen. Loved the reaction 🥰 🎮
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
@@maggiereneemusic please, I beg you please do a reaction video of Lauren Paley ( the stairwell singer ) version of Ave Maria. Not the short version but the entire version. You will be amazed at her voice.
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Voiceplay video reaction I just posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Throughout their changing members over the years, VoicePlay itself has continued as a an amazingly capable and creative entity. The colors on their palette may vary but VoicePlay continues. In this one, the fabulous voices and harmony and video production add up to one terrific video. Adding in Maggie's visible reactions combined with her analytic skills and the high quality of the editing make for a most enjoyable watch and listen. 🎮
Submitted for your consideration: VoicePlay's version of Just Sing. You know how they often have featured artists? This song, which was created as a fundraiser for performing artists whose livelihoods were affected by the pandemic, is VoicePlay and nearly every artist who has featured with them, the original members (going back to 1997!), as well as a few other folks. And what a group of artists they are! If you keep the closed captioning turned on, each person is identified in turn as they appear, so you can keep track. Including VoicePlay, there are 23 people performing- including Geoff's niece (who looks to be maybe 10?) and Tim Foust from Home Free- so those captions help! It's an absolute showstopper of a song, and watching it never fails to make me happy (even if I'm crying by the end. Which has happened more times than I'll admit. It's that beautiful.).
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Scott Porter was VoicePlay's beatboxer from the beginning until 2003, when he started pursuing his acting career. That's when Layne stopped being the baritone and became the amazing perc machine we know and love! 😍 Scott's words at the end make me cry every time I watch this! They all did an amazing job! The harmonies are spectacular, and Geoff's lows, well, ya know! 🤯🔥🤯😍
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Are you sure Scott was the beatboxer? Given that both him and Layne are founding members according to Geoff(as he told Elizabeth on The Charismatic Voice)? Two beatboxer is a bit overkill...
Yes, I'm sure. Scott was the beatboxer, Layne was baritone, Earl was tenor and Geoff was bass. Mykal Kilgore was high tenor, but idk when he joined the group. Layne became beatboxer after Scott left. 😊
Yes, the B0 continued throughout... you can hear it very well on a tuned subwoofer. With subharmonics, the principle never goes away when the subharmonic is produced. With a B0, though, being so low in the human hearing spectrum, headphones not being able to produce it properly, and the compressed audio we use today, it makes that B0 sub slightly weaker than the principle B1.
I have scanned through the top 20 comments or so and nobody mentions Elis' highest note ever reached.....Everyone talks about Geoffs' low, but no one ever seems to mention Eli.... I remember seeing when this was first released that it was supposed to contain Geoffs' lowest and Elis' highest.....
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Yes we heard the B0. Geoff hits the B1 and his ventricular/vestibular folds vibrate at B0 at the same time as his vocal folds that are resonating at B1. Then he focuses the "feeling" of the B0 and brings it out. That's how subharmonics work. Also, Scott Porter was one of the founding members of Voiceplay, as you picked up from the speech at the end. He left to pursue acting. This tribute to Rek and Halo was such an incredible work of art and to anyone who played Halo for years until the wee morning hours, it is really emotional. "Goosebumps on my heart" - I love that one Maggie.
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Voiceplay video reaction I just posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Anything in octave 0, is in danger of not being heard, either because the speaker or headphone driver's range doesn't go that low, or because it's close to the edge of the human hearing range, and somebody with worse than average hearing at the low end, may simply be unable to hear it. It's possible they wanted the B1 to be audible in case the B0 fell victim to this. Heck, with sufficiently cheap speakers, anything below about G1 can get cut off. But most VoicePlay fans hopefully have _at least_ medium-quality earbuds (RayCon, or the Apple ones, or whatever). Personally my desktop PC has an actual subwoofer, which can reproduce lower pitches than the ear can hear, down into octave -1 or -2. If I turn the volume up higher than I usually do, I can feel these sounds, not with my ears but with my body. The acoustics in here are pretty good, and I have the sub positioned where it can reverberate off the opposite wall, and pitches below about 20Hz cause noticeable vibrations if they're turned up "loud". In principle, if you went down a couple more octaves, the resulting vibrations would be noticeable with the eye, but my sub doesn't go that low. If I put a long-tube fluorescent light in here, I'd probably be able to see (moire patterns resulting from the 60Hz flicker combined with) the vibrations from some of Geoff's notes, but on the balance I think I will stick with the lighting that I have.
5:38 You hear a B1 because that B0 is sung as a subharmonic, so the fundamental is very much still present and quite loud. He didn't layer the B0 with a B1. It just happened 🤷🏻♀️
I've been waiting for you to react to this one! When Geoff hit that B0, I was just as floored as you were! I was like "Wait! What!?!? Did he really just, ....!?" Geoff has actually been the inspiration in my working on my voice again. It's been nearly 20 years, so it's a little tired, but muscle memory is kicking in and things are coming back. Despite working to stretch my lower range, I'll never be as deep as Geoff, but I'm happy with my lyric bari-tenor voice.
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
He hits the B0 but not for very long. Not that a B1 isn't pretty darn amazing as well. 1 full tone to go before he goes off the bottom of the piano. I suspect he'll manage it at some point, but he has to be getting close to the limits of what human vocal chords can do. Regardless, this is an amazing arrangement.
The lower the note - the stronger the overtones of the note are. The overtone which is 1 octave above the fundamental is, probably, the strongest overtone. Maybe that has something to do with what we hear, when we are talking about the ultra low frequencies and ultra low subharmonics, but I'm not sure
The B0 doesn't disappear, since the subharmonic bass technique is a polyphonic, he sings the B1 as the fundamental, the adds the subharmonic, which makes both (fund B1 + sub B0) ring at the same time but the subharmonic tone becomes dominant, that is how the B0 is achieved. the as the harmonies come forward from the other singers, your ears get tricked into hearing the B1 as dominant, even though the sub B0 is still there. Pretty darn awesome imho. edit to answer one of your uncertainties: It isn't layering, the subharmonic is naturally 2 tones, an octave apart sounding at the same time the lowest one being the dominant tone. (there are also multiple subharmonic ranges, so you can achieve 3-4 sounds at the same time all lower than the fundamental B1 -> 1st sub range B0 -> 2nd sub range F0 --> 3rd Sub range B -1... but to my knowledge Geoff can't/doesn't use below the first subharmonic range)
You are one of a handful of reactors that I couldn't, and can't wait to hear react to their Wicked medley. It's one of Geoff's amazing arrangements. Can't wait to hear your reaction to it.
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
I clearly hear the B0 through the whole note. It just sounds relatively smooth and is rich in overtones. A B1 would never have that growly and sort of distorted tone to it. There is no doubt that it was a B0.
Maybe your headphones are the reason you predominantly hear the B1? I hear both, but the B1 is only more prevalent for me in the first one (right at the beginning), while the B0 is more prevalent in the second one to me.
I can hear the B0 sustained the whole time, but when you do a subharmonic the vocal folds are literally doing both pitches at the same time. Did you also catch Cesar's whistel range note toward the end there? They pull it way back in production, but you can hear it in the back ground...listen for it!
Compare this to the original Halo theme soundtrack. They are emulating and entire orchestra. For those of us who enjoyed the Halo saga, they are jumping from the theme, to game play to the ending outtake. The score for this game was epic! Geoffe is emulating the bass drums and symbols while the rest are filling in the strings. Gorgeous rendition.
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Was literally going to say the same thing. I know all the acapella groups communicate with each other. So if this was their paying homage to Pentatonix it was a great way to do it
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Pentatonix video reaction I recently posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
was that an E one ?.....production value as usual.... sustained B1 ain't bad....any tickle of a B0 is breath taking .....we ain't talking soy-boy squeaky peeping here
Unless I missed it I don't think you've done a reaction to VoicePlay's Phantom of the Opera feat. Rachel Potter. This was about 6 years back, before J. None. Tony Wakim was still with the group and I almost didn't recognize Geoff because he hadn't started to grow his hair long. And I must add they all looked good in those suits. Plus, Geoff Castellucci recently released a couple of fantastic solo videos, this time it's Way Down (cover of an Elvis Presley song) and Ghost Riders in the Sky. Check the Geoffs' name tags in Way Down and carry that thought into the the other video where (from left to right) its Jeff, Daryl, Geoff, Goff (who's left handed), and Joeph.
To get a B0 using the subharmonics technique, Geoff has to sing a 'true' B1 and sort of vocal fry it down an octave. So that may explain why it seems to 'shift' between the two. Then again: Singing a true B1 is difficult enough. Damn this guy is good.
Thank you for reacting to the tribute after the song as well as the song itself. Of all the reactors I've seen reacting to this song on RU-vid, you are the only one (so far) to watch and react to the tribute after the song in your reaction video. Most skip it entirely while others claim in the description or comments to have watched it off camera. So, thanks again.
Maggie see if you can find their newest from Skyrim "Dragon Born Comes" I think that is what is called. It is awesome. With Omar Cardona in costume as we have come to expect from our intrepid singers, actors and all time crazy fun group
The song style is not to my personal taste. However, I love the sound a capella. I found above all, watching your reaction as the BEST part of the video. Thank you, Ms. Maggie Renee'👍👍
still in love with you mags... omg, your facial reactions are completely brilliant. ♥♥♥ .. i will say taht a few halowwens ago we got a neko-maggie .. and i not only loved it, but i kinna miss the kitty mags :P
Every time you say "cheese muffins," I can't help but smile inside. Keep doing it. And the joy the music brings you is inspiring. Thanks for being you.
Love your reactions as always. I forgot I had my breakfast in the microwave while watching this reaction so I'm eating it cold. We could tell you had never played a game console. The game controller you showed is actually from a playstation, I think. The x box controllers has the thumbsticks off set, with the left one higher than the one on the right. I bought a used x box in 2005 along with Halo Combat Evolved. Halo CE was groundbreaking and changed the way first person shooters were made. When the x box 306 came out I stood in line about 8 hours to buy the next to last one they had in stock and had to run around to other stores to buy things like the memory expansion because everything sold out so quickly. Consoles back then took a long time to load the games and the theme would play then and parts of it throughout the game, different parts of it depending on what was happening in the game. I have all the Halo games including an unopened Collectors Edition which came with a Spartan Helmet.
Happy Holidays and thank you for your lovely comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Glad you enjoyed my reaction video! There is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond, if you are interested: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
Maggie, you are so wonderful to watch. Your reactions. Your singing. Pretty much everything. I'll see more of you in 2022 I'm sure. Meanwhile, Merry Christmas to you. I wish the best for you.
Excellent reaction-and I see you’ve been given a few short explanations about the B0/B1. Geoff actually does a video (maybe more than one) explaining how he does it. You might want to watch because now I’m seeing women do it, so you might be able to go really freaky low (for a woman) too. And yes, this is awesome!! Obviously I would love to see you do more Voiceplay, but you might also want to check out Peter Barber and Bobby Bass’s cover of Avi’s The Summit. Or The Bass Gang’s cover of Billie Eilish’s Therefore I am.
As a female, the lowest I can do a subharmonic is Eb3/Eb2; which isn't very low at all :( Do these other women actually sound good when they're doing it? I definitely don't yet.
Happy Holidays and thank you for your comment! 🎅🎄🎁 Did you enjoy my new reaction video I just posted to Geoff? Also, there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you for your support! 💖
@@Tootsiepop201 I’m a trans guy and before I was on hormones, I could do meh subs. Then again my alto 2 low end was kinda iffy and subs are very hard and take a lot of practice. Id have to find a video of myself to see what note I can go to, but it definitely gets better with practice! :)
If you haven't yet please react to VoicePlay's Boy Bands in 5 Minutes which came out mid-2019. At one point the camera pans away from the guys, off to one side where a man is saying to 3 women something about "the size of his wallet." That's the husband and wives and/or girlfriends of the guys (minus the single J None). About a minute after that when the guys are warming themselves around the fire in the oil drum, Rek is the black guy that walks by and hands Earl a sandwich.
Hey maggie nice reaction. Happy holidays by the way. I got a suggestion a is to react to one brazilian singer that is incredible, Gabriel Henrique, no joke with this man.
Well, in one of Geoff’s videos, he talks about a couple ways to do subharmonics, and one method actually comes out, technically, as two notes that (I believe) are full octaves. But, it also might just be the mix- not sure.
Love this cover. They have incredible voices. I really like their new cover of Dream On by Aerosmith featuring Omar Cordona. They hit a note that will get a holy cheese muffins from you.