please everyone dont judge these two legends..Enjoy d gazal..But yes everyone style of playing tabla is different so you will feel this one is different from others
There seem to be a lot of comments about all Tabla players not playing properly when accompanying Hariharan. Actually, I think Hariharan asks them to play play in a somewhat more expressive and playful manner than is usually the case in ghazal accompaniment. If you listen, to the album that Hariharan did with Zakir Hussain, Hazir, you realise what I think Hariharan asks from a Tabla player. Someone of the Sabir Khan's calibrate could play however is demanded of them..
Sabir Bhai carried the great legacy of his father Keramatullah Khan sahab ....one of few greatest sangatkaars in Indian Classical Music Syndrome ....So please show some restraint before passing comment about legends ....
those who are judging the legends ..... vo koi inke pair ki dhool bhi nahi BETA ABHI ITNE BADE BHI NAHI HUE......its our goodness ki hum inhe sun paa rahe h...
It may be anything either off beat or on beat..but its gustaki ke upar ustadi...kya baat..off beat me gazal..aur ustad sabir kha ne toh..good renderation..
Everyone cannot accompany these kind of singer. Accompany is different level of Tabla. Gustaki maaf no doubt Ustad Sabir Khan Saheb is a great tabla player of Farukkabad gharana.
No one like out of beat music ,but I think by mistake its happened, (Saam) is very important in any Ghazal.if you are showing different variations during playing tabla but didn't come correctly on (saam) then all variations is out of order.
Actually Ustad Zakir Hussain chaned the world of tabla in ghazal the old style of ustad Tari khan is amazing by all means but its defiently dated and music is constantly changing
+Mashal Ahmadi you made a valid point.... heard this sung a few times and could tell something was a bit off.... much respect to Sabir Ji and Hariharan Saab
Either one is playing off beat or singing off beat...but they are improvising tallentedly..and see..every time it hits on saam only....hehe..really credit
Aaron Joseph no such thing...he is the khalifa of Farukkabad baj..and his lineage is so long...actually..sabir ji is the king of gazal..he knows how to play..but they are trying to present something new...
