The genius... 20 years gone just like indian star players done and dusted.. Your words and commentary and humble presentation in big finals will b thr for generations to see.. Thank u
@@mayankdewli1010 Hi dear 😊😊😊 Check Harsha Bhogle playing history at Osmania University of Hyderabad in his college years. Just to share the truth to you, in case you aren't aware of. Kindly don't mind. It's to share for all people to know about this. Cheers, take care, bye ☺️👋
Anil Kumble also was a good player but things didn’t go well between kohli and kumble. Gautam also talks his mind. His success will depend on how the captain gets along well with gambhir.
GG is aggressive when you are on the other side , behind the scenes he is just opposite ask KKR management, he is more like Gary Kirsten in approach with streaks of brendon mccullum as a coach, but here ofcourse more superstars than in KKR with players having mind of their own. He will do just as good Rohit Sharma is different human altogether that's a huge plus. Its in T20 where GG will have to navigate things, Kumble was too rigid plus Virat was the captain GG isnt as rigid as Kumble contrary to his on-field image. Many may not agree I thought Kumble was more rigid wrt processes while GG is more rigid and determined wrt results, you can choose your process but if it doesnt give result GG provides an alternative that's his philosophy
Many Happy Returns of the Day Mr. Bhogle. Listening to your voice is calming and the commentary is exemplary. Thanks for all the joy and coveraqe. Keep up the good work.
BGT will be the toughest assignment for GG. Australia will be hungry and waiting to pounce on Indian batsman. They better go prepared for that series. Otherwise it will be a disastrous summer down under.
I was waiting for Harsha's Video & boy o boy, did this man Deliver!! Thanks Harsha for another beautiful video!! You're Truly the Voice of Indian Cricket!!
bringing stockmarket similes into cricket... feels cool huhhh... Lots of Respect Sir... The man who can inspire you to develop a better finance strategy while talking cricket... lots of respect!!!!!!!
Its exciting to see GG as coach..just hoping there would not be any ego clashes in the dressing room..Thats why I think people are not completely bullish on this..
Mr Bhogle Gambhir's greatest challenge is going to be keeping his own emotions in check. We Indians are an emotional lot and we need a leader who plays a calming influence. Dravid succeeded because he trained to be a coach. He started at the bottom and adapted and did not hog the limelight. Gambhir in some ways exactly the opposite. The players will have difficulty in adapting to his more authoritarian approach. He did contribute to India's two World Cup wins, but other than the match saving double hundred in NZ his overseas test record was abysmal. His character in standing up to fast bowling in 2011 in England was questionable. 39 year old Dravid ended up opening the batting and Gauti, hiding behind his so-called injury batted down the order. So in short, he talks the talk, but doesn't always walk the walk. He has never coached at any level. India needs a Qualified Coach, not an ex player. Youngsters like Jaiswal understand, respect and acknowledge that. Case in point Zubin Bharucha. There is a brilliant lot of young qualified coaches coming through the Indian ranks. They would have made a far better choice. Just like you are a trained journalist who does a far better job than most ex cricketers, which is also acknowledged by your audiences (whatever the ex cricketers might say). It is high time we stop ex players hijacking this game. Clubs are making it mandatory for coaches to be certified. So why not the national team. If you want to be a national coach, go and get the qualifications like Dravid did and start at the bottom. Journalists like you should be pointing this out to the Board. Ex-players trained to be players, not coaches. They need to retrain and commit to their new career choice. Sports channels should also make it mandatory for ex cricketers to undergo a course in journalism/media. Currently this entire debate is hijacked by ex cricketers. They need to understand that their careers are over and we as a society should let them know this. Gautam Gambhir does not deserve to succeed as a coach on merit. He doesn't even deserve to be there!
Unsure if Gambhir has the required Emotional Intelligence. His interviews often display this where he makes over the top dramatic statements when they don't actually achieve anything other than creating sensational headlines.
Obviously you cannot compare Dravid and Gambhir in terms of batting ability. Dravid is an all time great, Gambhir was just an average international player. But I don’t think that is a problem in terms of coaching.
Some of the best coaches are average players, so don't get me even started there. At this level they don't need much "coaching" in terms of skills. What they need is mentoring and that's his forte. Whatever his faults as a player, his passion for his team, being the ultimate team man and fiercely nationalist are huge attributes. So I don't agree with you at all. But the proof will be delivered to both of us soon. Let's wait and watch
@@saikat93ifyGambhir was average player ,but results he was able to produce were not average .I am not sure you can call anyone average , with the way he played in 2 icc finals😮😮
What u said is absolutely correct, Harsha Sir. I observed a different VK in 2024 edition. He has mellowed down as if he has attained enlightenment in last one year. So I do not see a conflict between the Delhi guys. For the first time that I am following Indian cricket for last 40 years I am seeing a coach more powerful than the captain, selection committee chairman & BCCI president. Gives me a feeling of European football team where coaches are the boss. We will wait to see the outcome in little more than a year time because I do not see Gautam staying at the helm of Indian cricket if we fail in CT25, BG series, Ind-Eng Test series & Test Championship.
Harsha sir you deliberately avoided talking much about ruturaj . The selection committee, the coaches , the media are the main reason for the talents wasted . The team selection is just based on personal likings of the committee. Following are your words on ruturaj after initial matches in ipl 2024 ; At the moment if there is a t20 team without ruturaj it may be from another planet . Ruturaj has always performed well but the problem is that je doesnt have a pr team like gill or other overhyped players. Ik very well this comment like many others will be neglected . Indian cricket day by day is just getting over shadowed by internal politics and favouritism. This isnt only about ruturaj there are and were many such players with immense talent but the bcci members wasted their career due to personal grudges . A recent example which was quite hyped was of the exclusion of rayudu from the wc 2019 due to problems with then cheif selector msk prasad . I have utmost respect for you, but you should also be vocal about this .
@@vinayr2753 Depend on your perspective... Just see what Kumble's successor Ravi Shasthri did... He won 3 consecutive BGT as coach... No other coach has done that... Shasthri won 2 series in Australia... So Replacing Shasthri with Kumble has been a master stroke... Shashtri also brought Pant to test team,Kuldeep chahal to team...Rohit was made a good test batter after the age of 32... So bringing on Shasthri by raplacing Kumble was a good decision
@@arunvikrama Punjab Didn't Qualify most of the Times Since 2007 ipl Start, Your Statement Shows all Coaches of Punjab are Useless , Travor Baylis Coaching for KKR SRH and PBKS ,KKR won 2 times and SRH wins 1 time but PBKS Didn't Qualify it's Coach Problem or Management Problem, Coaches only Coach Not to Play
I'm optimistic about Gambhir too. He's definitely patriotic and has an aggressive, straightforward personality. He needs to manage the experienced and senior players well. He's been vocal about giving opportunities to everyone, so I'm hopeful he'll support young talent effectively.
I agree with Harsha for a change. Having said that, I’m amazed that for someone who hasn’t played a day of cricket at the highest level to be spouting sermons is a bit overrated!. Lucky man! broadcasters seem to like you hence you make a living. God bless!
Mr Bhogle you had justified the replacement of Rohit Sharma by Hardik Pandya as just another corporate decision. The Ambani hire and fire. Nothing wrong with a secret captaincy clause in Hardik Pandya's contract. Yes the Ambani management including Boucher, Tendulkar, Pollard have the right to put their choice of captain in place. But should'nt they have given Rohit Sharma to look for a move through the IPL auction in December 2023. A captain who has led MI to 5 titles. An admired , selfless leader of the Indian cricket team. where is the sporting spirit. You Mr Bhogle justified it as normal boardroom moves. Just see how Rohit Sharma & Rahul Dravid have supported Hardik Pandya and created a warm and bonded dressing room.
This is life Venu ji! Do you think Hardik would have come as just a player after winning an IPL as captain? The circle of life moves on. Franchise sports is new in India, but this is what happens all over the world. The aging players get pushed out, the team gets built around young ones after a cycle. The problem here in India is that we have to respect everyone and keep everybody happy. Successful clubs worldwide don't operate like that. All business no emotion!
@@MrKushaagra So you disrespect your captain who has led your franchise to 5 titles. A captain who is lauded and respected as one of the best in international cricket circles. So your favourite Hardik Pandya has won 1 IPL title and deserves the captaincy. Ha ha. At least tell Rohit Sharma so that he can move on to some other franchise. Egg on Ambani and MI management face. Now Rohit Sharma is the WC T 20 winning cricket captain. No rancour with Hardik. Treated him with full respect. That's the spirit of cricket. Now front runner Hardik Pandya has been replaced by Surya Kumar Yadav as Indian T 20 cricket captain. Ha ha. More egg on Ambani and MI management face.
@@venugopalrao3597 Venu ji I don't watch cricket at all. I've no favourites. I'm trying to convey that going forward business decision will take precedence over other things. I was a big fan of David Beckham, Roy Keane from Man United. They were the soul of the club. They got removed in an instant. Similarly, favourite basketball players like Russell Westbrook got traded for future prospects of the team. We are generally very bound by emotions. I'm just letting you know that franchises don't work like that.
Venugopalrao - COMPLETELY agree with U. Those that justify Hardik over Rohit have simply lost their marbles. According to them Rohit is good enough to win the WC but not good enough to lead a franchise team. Utter rubbish. Also, they should have given him a way out before they made that change. This wretched Ambani family is ruining everything good in this country!
@@KartikKumar-hc5iz Appreciate your opinion Kartik ji. Understand the sentiment associated with Rohit's captaincy. But how come the Ambani family has ruined everything in India? They have given lakhs of jobs, thousands of businesses came into being because of the Jio revolution. Anant Ambani's wedding itself has given so many jobs. In fact you might be using a jio sim as we speak. 😂
I beleive if he will focus on innovation rather than on invention, things will go well for us... There is an old saying.... If something is not broken why fix it.... Best of luck to Gauti sir....
Sometimes you just have to take a bet on the character of a man and trust they will do what it takes to deliver. Sometimes the right attitude plays a far greater role than pure ability. And Gambhir has never lacked for character or courage. Ofcourse only time will tell, right man at the right time, it feels like. But it also feels like a all or nothing deal. Its either going to be a great success or a complete failure...not a mediocre situation where everyone keeps hoping things will get better.
He's a good guy - Passionate, aggressive, eager to win but there is also a challenge that isn't being spoken about - India's batting hasn't been very successful in swinging conditions overseas, and he himself had a poor average in those countries as a batter - How will he ensure the batting unit gets the right guidance to make the adjustments they need to? Maybe he needs a very good batting coach alongside.
hey Harsha sir hope you are doing well sir I want to work in cricket field but I have no experience I do not have any idea in this how to approach in this field I am from agra and I am 19 year's old sir please guide me I want to meet you please sir reply aapke ke sath koi kaam mil sakta hai
@ganrev17 No doubting his knowledge of the game but he is no longer the analyst he used to be. As for talking 'diplomatically ' that's putting it mildly ! He now takes great care to ensure that he is on the right side of the powers that be. If you notice, he tends to skirt around contentious issues or takes the side of those in authority. Witness his comments on the Rohit - Hardik captaincy issue at MI on this very channel and you will get what I mean. He took the side of the MI owners and feigned surprise about Hardik being booed, even faulting fans for expressing their anger in the only way they could ! Pity that the man who was once called 'the voice of Indian cricket' has come to this !
@@philm3967 Well said. Harsha doesn't hurt anyone, and wants to keep a good relationship with everyone. We as cricket fans don't want that. That's why I love Pdogg, who gives a frank opinion about everything, criticizes when required, without supporting anyone. At times he might be wrong but that's fine.
I am bullish on Indian team but somehow have a feeling deep down our generation doesn't go along with stubborn coaches, hence have a gut feeling that Gambhir's era is going to be bit similar to Kumble's era - Motivation might be missing from players when you are not pushed like Ravi Shastri. I think coaches like Gary Kirsten and Rahul Dravid are strict and on field and very friendly off field hence people can connect with them very well share problems and have feeling of playing for country and coach - that thing could be missing in Gauti's innings as a coach. Having said that I would be very happy to be proved wrong by him.
His commitment was never in question . As a coach his temperament would be tested. We have seen him in IPL , but for such a long tenure his temperament would be tested.
Gambhir is temperamentally difficult guy to lead India as head coach! He has a record of fights with many players particularly virat kohli. So he has a lot to prove taking over from a legend Rahul Dravid!!!
Kohli and Rohit are at the tail end of their career. He needs to have an open chat. Their role should be to help GG develop next generation of players who can take up the leadership mantle. At the same time GG also needs to be patient with the seniors and not overcoach them
Big Fan of you Sir @harsha but Indian cricket is not in safe hands. Full of favouritism!!!How a playervleftvout from tge sqaud after sciring an100in overseas also that were in a tricky pitch and series decider
One of the rare occasions where I would disagree with Harsha. I am pretty sure GG will end up having a rift with players within the team. Not the right choice but happy to proven wrong.
This kind of favouritism and Partiality for Rishab Pant and Gills are not good for Indian cricket. The lobby have clearly selected Gill and Pant also doing all th PR for them without performance.(Telecast/Commentary) Players like Samson Gaikwad and Rinku has to sit out even after performing well with the limited chances they got. First of all its our nations team where everyone should be treated equally..
I just cannot wait for india tour of Australia in November that will be the biggest test for Gambhir, Rohit and co especially the test matches you will get to see young hero’s emerging there or we would be whitewashed let’s see
Gambhir selection is a risk and selection process was not very transparent or competitive, almost seems handpicked. Could be too much testosterone in the dressing room. Checked out the Tamil Cricket Podcast - Match Paatheengala Boss where resonating fears of Indian fans with Gambhir selection
What f are u talking about, you don't have the deep scenes of thought process. When you don't take any risk in anything then you are stand in same place always.
Gambir will not long last he is an egoistic man, and the indian team management treated badly him fro 2012-2014 gambir retired because of that, so he will give back to senior players like kohli, rohith, rahul Like greg chappel may be some issues will be there soon
No Abhishek sharma No Ruturaj Gaikwad No Mukesh Kumar No Yuzi Chahal Former KKR players r made captain and vice captain And players from KKR r given preference What is Gambhir doing with Team India
Captain runs the show period………….melo coaches who are good man managers are successful. Last three successful coaches John wright,Shastri, Kirsten and dravid. Even in corporate world you don’t want a manager who teaches you your job, but helps you at the right time.
The BCCI seems to have vetoed his requests to appoint Lakshmipati Balaji and Morne Morkel as bowling coaches, and Jhonty Rhodes and Ryan Ten Doeschate as fielding coaches- worrying.
I felt that HB is trying to hide some feeling/emotions when he was commenting on GG. Anyhow, my take is that it would be just a mediocre tenure for GG.
Is Chat GPT better than Harsha? It is almost good enough to mimic his voice and face. If Harsha has over 25 years of experience in Sweet Talk, with cricket just serving the context to speak, then Chat GPT needs no time at all. When AI is good enough to beat chess grand masters then Sweet Talk is no brainer. When technology can plant hair and fashion the hairstyle then it can substitute for a real human with little bit of context thrown in. LLM can be trained successfully. AI lacks heart. ¿ Who cares for heart? People are not hired because they possess good heart. People develop good heart just to be reackoned and for retention. Well spoken as always. Good luck.
With this temper if India to loose few matches , he will resign himself with self respect . Mark my words - we need patience of Dravids and Dhoni’s not Shastri’s, Kohli’s and Gambirs
For a Coach's profile, Gambhir is too talkative .. not just needlessly talkative, but many a times even harmfully talkative. Coach's job is at the backend .. not in front of a media mic & camera. Coaches who sweat it out at the back end & stay laid back on the front, are more likely to create a happy pleasant workplace. I suspect that dressing room is gonna be a bit hot. I hope he does not meet Kumble's fate .. though he is lucky to be coaching a mostly newbie gang with "yes sir" tendencies rather than a strong, young yet strong personality stalwarts in their prime. All legends are on their last laps & would want to avoid confrontation. Apart from that, he has been an absolute hero as far as crunch performances as a player are concerned.
New greg chappel is ready 😭😭😭😭 Ruturaj , Abishek showing his talent …. Harthik already vice captain now normal player …. Gill is most selfish player but 3 format he is the Vice captain ….. T20 and TEST he is not suitable his batting technique…. Gambhir politics will starting against some players 😭😭😭😭
Making Surya captain is a terrible choice, one made by Agarkar and Rohit mainly because Rohit can control Surya better than he can Hardik. Hardik was the vice captain and he was obviously the better choice long term (he is 3 years younger). Hardik has more experience captaining 2 IPL teams and has done very well captaining India for a year and a half he was allowed to do so. Surya was all giddy and bubbly when he was given the captaincy against SA in late 2023. I just don't think he is a leader who can lead other men and win big trophies, he is barely a big game player.
Gautam Gambhiar is GG as combative aggressive open and careful as Gautam in Gautam out ( G G in as GiGo Garbage out ) GIGO One weakness is his offside stance with Media and Politics GG is patriotic as King Kohli Many time’s unrelenting character works as positive and negative to King Kohli and Gautam Gambhir Both are from Delhi Both were captains to India Team Both were opening batsman and fearless combative Question is whether their control on hot plate and media savvy with hot partners with young children deliver their dreams India accepts and rejects quickly heroes and Maharaja cultures with huge fan following each to Kohli and Gambhir It’s like a former Maharaja ( Captain) and current outgoing Maharaj with With many players like Bumrah Suraj Shami And Ravi Chandean Ashwin in the box can King Kohli retire gracefully as he did with T20 to ODI and Test cricket I stopped watching cricket as Havala started 1983 later with Kapil and Azzaruddun messing Made me mess Sachin play till 2016 Picked up when Virat played 2017 Active cricket fan 2017 yo now Watching fingers crossed Rohit Virat Pandya Bumrah and hope life doesn’t disappoint again Now Giko in KoGi out ROKO toh to ROKO Roko to Rohi Rakhana to ROKO
