Has There Ever Been a GOOD Jack Frost Movie? 

Michael Keaton is snowman

I will consistently maintain that rise of the guardians is an incredibly underrated film. I have always loved it

As someone who lived and breathed tumblr during its “The Big 4” era, thank you for recognizing that Jack Frost from Rise of The Guardians is an S-tier character.

When you said “Shut up Finneas” my brain immediately thought you were gonna come back with “We’re all here to see Ferb.”

Rise of the Guardians is SO good. It has honestly always bugged me that it hasn't gotten the acknowledgement it deserves.

Before watching Rise of The Guardians, I had no idea who Jack Frost is. Makes the whole no one can see him because no one believes thing hit even harder.

I’m so happy Rise of the Guardians is finally getting some recognition. When it was new in theatres it was one of my favourite movies as a kid.

Dude, I love Jack Frost. I always remember it as being goofy and weird, but also super emotional. A kid missing their deceased parent, the parent wanting to comfort their child, tell them everythings gonna be okay. Also; the bully sympathizing with the main character about not having a father, then helping out (and eventually becoming friends)? Thats grade-A storytelling, perfect for a holiday film.

I’m so glad you rated Rise of The Guardians positively. It’s one of my favorite movies

serial killer jack frost [x] magical powers [x] angry at the world [x] likes to cause mischief [ ] redemption arc YOU IGNORED A VERY CLEAR B TIER YOU JUDGMENTAL MONSTER

No joke that Jack Frost horror movie TRAUMATIZED me as a kid. I didn't sleep for weeks. My mother thought it was the Michael Keaton movie. The dude flipping melted into snow in the first five minutes.

I remember seeing a theory that the stop motion Jack and Frosty Jack are the same character, since both movies are Rankin Bass productions. I do like the idea that Jack became bitter over the centuries (but not beyond redemption)

Scott said the name Jack Frost 28 times He said just Jack 21 times He said just frost 6 times, The name Jack Frost was said 13 times in the video by someone other than Scott. I'm pretty sure I got an A on this test.

Oh I always ADORED Rise of the Guardians. It was quite cute and sweer and the animation was very pretty :)

"There's this devilishly handsome heartthrob, or...this cartoon guy." I absolutely lost it, I'm so happy Marty's version got the recognition he deserved.

I absolutely adore Rise of the Guardians , it’s my comfort movie and I watch it all year round whenever I need something to cheer me up!

“Rise of the guardians is underrated” “no one ever talked about rise of the guardians” Have people here never heard of the absolute monster that was the Rise of the Brave Tanged Frozen Dragons fandom?

I was full on screaming of happiness when you put Rise of The Guardians' Jack Frost on S tier, but went completely silent when you mentioned the fanarts, we don't talk about that Scott 😂

The transition from Jack Frost's face to yours as you talked about anybody being able to be Jack Frost was excellent editing, and then the hilarious ending scenes began.

Rankin Bass is so meaningful to me. Not only does it feel like Christmas, but they're so unique, and I actually love the choppy stop motion. Sure, they're often weird and bad (thinking about "Rudolph's Shiny New Year" with the Time Archipelago) but they're great. Edit: You can deny Rankin Bass all you want, but the Snow Miser and Heat Miser's songs are great

The better question is has there ever been a bad jack frost movie?

Amazing that Scott watched 5 different movies just to avoid watching the new Home Alone movie. And he was so right to make this call.

Rise of the Guardians is genuinely one of my favorite movies ever, like I was obsessed with the books when I was younger and love rewatching the movie now. It makes me so happy to see other people appreciating it too :]

i literally cried when the kid saw Jack Frost for the first time in Rise of the Guardians. What a masterpiece of a movie with a criminally underrated reputation

I actually love Jack Frost. I just thought no one cared about it. Rise of the Guardians is so underrated, they rarely play that on TV. I even saw it in theaters when it came out. Jack Frost was my Elsa lol Why were the 90s so obsessed with divorced and dead parents to make people feel good though 💀

I’m glad we all cherish Jack Frost from Rise of the Guardians. I was obsessed with him and thought I was alone 😭

I'm crying at that plot twist! "Snow dad is better than no dad."

The Amazing Spiderman came out when I was in high school and I resonated so much with how awkward Peter is in that version lol. It's my fave (live action) Spiderman, and I'm glad I'm not the only one who loves it. Also glad you mentioned Rise of the Guardians because that's a great movie, too.

Rise of the Guardians has always been my favorite iteration of the children’s mythical characters, actually how I learned about Jack Frost in the first place.

I dont care if people say Rise of Guardians is bad that movie was my childhood and i love it

I’m here for the Rise of the Guardians love. Might also be one of my favorite interpretations of Santa too❤️

I’m so glad Rise of the Guardians got the recognition it deserved, it’s honestly one of my favorite animated movies

I used to be obsessed with Rise of the Guardians and I agree: it is SUCH a good movie

I came expecting _Rise of the Guardians_ slander... My expectations have been exceeded, and I am thoroughly impressed. One of my favorite movies

I grew up with Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause alot as a kid. Its nostalgic for me

Being a mega Rankin Bass fan since forever, I’m so happy someone was talking about their Jack Frost specials!! Both movies you showed are some of my favorites! By the way, to answer your question on why Jack seemed friendlier in his solo special, I kind of have a theory as to why. I think chronologically his solo movie came first, and after being dumped by Eliseia, he grew a certain bitterness towards the world and a pessimistic view on love. With his attitude change, he developed an icy heart (like Winter Warlock in Santa Claus is Coming to Town) and his appearance changed as well to reflect it. At the end of Winter Wonderland, he learned to love again, his icy heart melted, and is seen completely reformed in Rudolph and Frosty’s Christmas in July as one of Frosty’s friends.

I like when Scott talks about things "no one cares about" it makes me feel good for caring about it also... no one talks about it

Rise of the Guardians was a movie I put on as background noise and then ended up being one of my favorite holiday movies, too underrated 👌

Can't believe the Michael Keaton jack frost movie is real and not a fever dream I had. In fact I realize I've watched it more times than I'd like to admit. But also 10/10 best movie in the world

The Frosty Special Jack and stop motion Jack are meant to be the same (it's confirmed in Rudolph and Frosty's Christmas in July where he helps save the day and is his stop motion version in his Frosty outfit) and if you look at it like that his stop motion version is a bit more interesting. Basically he used to be this really kind hearted winter spirit, but due to everything with Elisa he became a lot more bitter (especially if he sees someone basically taking credit for what he did). It's only when Frosty and Crystal are kind to him that he remembers how he used to be and tries to get back to that somewhat. His redemption comes full circle when he hears his pals Frosty and Crystal are in trouble and he wastes no time stopping by to help out. Also of note is how his solo special came out after the Frosty one (and his final appearance came out a bit later that same year) so they already had a personality for him and could have just kept the ball rolling with that, but choose to make him very different. In that sense he too is a perfect Jack Frost.

I’d consider the Snow Miser as an iteration of Jack Frost as well

Scott you aren’t alone, I used to watch that Michael Keaton Jack Frost movie all the time as a kid and my mom hated it, but I distinctly remember a little while where i watched it like everyday

It's an absolute crying shame that Scott has been consistently getting less views and subs, you are ligit the most original youtuber and create high-quality low-quality content, (which is the best kind)

I freakin love Rise of the Guardians! I haven't seen it in a good while though. The few clips shown here ended up bringing back childhood memories and got me tearing up. Growing up as the outcast among my classmates, I heavily relate to Jack Frost's desire to being seen.

i remember watching rise of the guardians as a kid and having a weird obsession with jack frost. for years id forgotten the movie existed or what it was just that i thought that one jack frost guy is cool and now that you show him its a crazy weird nostalgia hit. anyone else? nah just me ok.

I watched Jack Frost with Michael Keaton last Christmas, and ended up crying my eyes out. It may be a silly premise, but it's actually a really good depiction of handling grief from losing a loved one. It's depicted in a silly way so children can digest it easier. It's actually quite the brilliant film, I just think people go into it expecting something they don't receive.

scott just keeps getting better and better. no youtuber leaves me happier after watching a video than scott does. thank you.

Honestly scott you’re such a good RU-vidr you are able to make videos like this and share ur opinions and rank stuff without making people feel bad about liking certain characters or movies like I’ve felt watching others do these types of videos and it makes it actually enjoyable to watch not leaving u all self conscious about ur movie preferences

Man, the 70’s stop motion Jack Frost is legit one of my favorite Christmas movies. I love it. I mean, it’s basically The Little Mermaid, but the Little Ice Fairy Guy. 😂

I was obsessed with Rise of The Guardians as a kid. I remember getting the McDonald's card for Jack Frost after seeing it at the cinema and being like ridiculously happy and I used to carry it around until I got older and lost interest. I still watch it every year. Its such a shame it didn't spawn a franchise of holiday movies

Thank you Scott, for all the hot takes to keep us warm this winter.

So in the movie Edward Scissorhands, he ends up being the one to bring snow. Would this make him an incarnation of Jack Frost?

Finally, someone who understands the most important part of the Christmas season is ranking Jack Frost movies on a tier list!

Jack Frost (Rise of the Guardians) was the Eboy of my CHILDHOOD. My crush dressed up as him, and I’ve never seen him the same way SINCE 😏

You’re honestly the only commentary youtuber that makes laugh still. Always love your ideas and how you articulate your jokes.

Scott well done video and I teared up watching that movie and while reading the comments, I had no idea this movie had so much love and thank you for making this.

yeah, the one with the snowman. ☃️

Scott, you redeemed yourself in my eyes when you moved Michael Keaton to the S tier. I was about to throw these hands

i have thought about "snow dad's better than no dad" every day of my life ever since i heard it for the first time 18 years ago and i will CONTINUE to think about it every day until i die, thank you very much

Great video Scott! Merry Christmas!

i was not expecting scott's problematic trait to be his opinion on stop motion animation but i will forgive it.. scott and i are both childhood fans of the micheal keaton jack frost film and we must stand together

I remember being a kid and finding Jack Frost on tv and I thought it was the michael keaton one but after a few Christmasy murders i realized it was the scary one

19:15 nice detail (the transition) and have a good Christmas ☃️

Scott your comedy and quality in these videos have sky rocketed. Loved every second of this video. Keep it up legend.

I remember beating my first ever Pokemon game when I was 8 while the Micheal Keaton Jack frost was on. I associate that movie to my success in that game I always thought it was a great movie. Thank you for unlocking that memory for me!

I can feel the fellow rise of the guardians fans as I'm watching.

amazing video, really enjoyed!!

I could imagine Michael Keaton just accidentally saying on set *I am snowman*

If there's anything I'm qualified to be an expert in, it is the movie Rise of the Guardians. I have seen it over 100 times and I can't even tell you why. It's just my go-to movie when I want to watch something but can't be bother to pick something new. I unironically love it and it is the reason why Chris Pine has always been my top Chris.

Happy that Rise of the Guardians is finally getting the hype it deserves

Love that you love and appreciate both TASM and Rise of the Guardians. Both films have a special place in my heart!

It’s really nice to see one of my favorite creators watch one of my favorite Christmas movie, and love it.

I’ve heard that at the very least Guardians was a solid time

Rise of the Guardians was one of the only movies I watched when I was younger, along with Little and Big Monsters and Ratatouille. If you've watched the second one then you may or may not have thought it was a weird fever dream for years like I did.

19:01 - great transition Scott, love the way the narration matches the transition from e-boy Jack Frost to you

You Scott Cramer... are a genius. Dope vid, Merry Christmas.

When I heard “that EBOY” is was ready for a full read about how bad it was and I was ready to comment exactly why you’re wrong, if I had the confidence 😂

I really enjoyed Rise of the Guardians, as well. But I’m crying that he’s S-tier with the grinch 😂😂😂

I loved jack frost from Rise of the Guardians so much as a kid - still holds up today too, and my guinea pig is named after him 😌

The intensity at the end there was perfect thank you

Rise of the Guardians was one of my favorite movies as a kid and I'm so glad to see it getting some recognition here for the Masterpiece of Cinema it is

I just know the ROTG fans are sitting patiently through this video and ready to go to war in this comment section. Y’all are passionate, never lose that

Rise of the guardians was literally my favorite movie as a kid and to see one of my favorite content creators love it makes me feel like not an outcast and so different

I’m glad me watching this in mid July made your decorating for Christmas all worth it 😊

The guardians movie is literally my childhood.

Whenever I hear the name Jack Frost, I literally always think of Rise Of The Guardians.

I love Rise of the Guardians! I was so sad when it didn't do well. There are more books to pull from to make more movies. I was hoping for at least one more. I am glad to see you liked it. One of my favorites for sure!

Rise of the Guardians was the one movie my family downloaded on our iPad before we had things like "Netflix." It will always hold a special place in my heart, every long car ride or air plane flight, every trip to a family-member-I-don't-know-the-name-of's house or sibling fight.

My best friend growing up was family friends with William Joyce, the author and executive producer of rise of the guardians. Like, I swam in his pool. This is so surreal.

Rise of the Guardians is a gem, I dont care what you say! I'd be sour too if I died and didn't even realize it because im still roaming the earth. Now that I'm not triggered anymore from the thumbnail; time to enjoy another Scott video!

I love everything about this video, but the top 3 moments are your unwavering support for the amazing Spider-Man movies ✊, the unabashed love for the 1998 Jack Frost (it was one of our family's favorites to watch growing up), and Scott going all in on the Jack Frost banger that is "Have a Little Faith".

The 'but dad' thing made me remember how much i love that movie

Not jack frost exactly, but I nominate snow miser from The Year Without a Santa Claus. Cause c'mon, he sings an awesome song!

Michael Keaton's Jack Frost movie is a classic, fun for the whole family, and NOBODY can take my enjoyment of it away! (I even use the "butt Dad" joke on occasion)

you brought back memories with the stop motion animation movie

I find it endearing yet pressuring when videos mention that they won’t sleep till it’s done AND give a deadline on merch. I’ve definitely postponed sleep to finish some videos, but outside of having a newspaper come out with an ad for the video or a pivot from an article, I tried to avoid super hard deadlines

I grew up with rise of the guardians and it's truly one of my favorite childhood movies the story is so sad yet incredibly amazing and entertaining, I was really nervous because I thought you're not gonna like the movie and then I'll have to rewatch the movie because even though I trust you I don't trust my memory, but I did enjoy the video thanks for your service, I really respect you ❤

I loved Jack Frost with Micheal Keaton as a kid. I watched that movie so much to the point where I think I remember most of the lines from that film lol. I feel it still holds up today for the most part

This video made me laugh and cry. Ik it’s an old video but I officially subscribed off this one

when he begins to introduce the last frost and i’m expecting it to be the horror one (cause thumbnail) but then he just absolutely slam dunks my fave christmas classic 😳☃️🪓