I think the reason she read it that way is that she hasn't spent a lifetime communicating with people through text, email, the internet. We all take that shorthand for granted and wouldn't read it out that way, but Ellie has no background on how people used to talk through rapid non-verbal communication.
_I leave you all of my weapons and equipment. Use them to keep Tess safe, and if you and she decide you're staying the night, I recommend pairing some rabbit with a nice bottle of Bordello._
It's cute and endearing, but it's not canon to Bill's full letter, the one that's going around the Internet. "... if you decide that you've had enough, I recommend pairing 40 Vicodins with a nice Brunello [a kind of wine]". This is how Bill and Frank went out, and, I think, more faithful to Bill's dark sense of humour.
I like to think a big reason Bill decided to join Frank (besides him not going on living without his purpose) is that he _knew_ Joel and Tess were going to check on them and he was completely at peace with leaving *EVERYTHING* to them. Probably believed they'd move in, probably hoped, so that all the work and resources there aren't lost.
Use them to keep Tess safe. Gosh that bit broke Joel 💔 was such a sad ending not because Bill and Frank died but because Bill succeeded in protecting and keeping Frank safe and Joel knew he had failed by not doing the same with Tess.
@@colin8696908 True, but with Joel saying that Bill and Frank's location being remote from FEDRA and possibly a couple of stray infected stragglers, I would assume only Raiders and looters who wanted to steal would've actually wanted to steal/loot
Its not just the fact Tess is dead and he failed her, but also Bill and Frank being dead too. Two friends he was counting on and now Joel is left alone with a girl, a duty and responsibility to deliver her to some unknown lab to develop a cure that we have not idea whether it would work
"Shit our character needs a car off these two gay plot devices! maybe we should create.... TWO ENTIRE LIVING BREATHING HUMANS IN THE MOST BEAUTIFUL RELATIONSHIP EVER SEEN ON TV!"
@@thatlonelygiraffeinc.6989hey that gay stuff hits different. It was done so tasteful. This is actually how real gay people act not all extra and shit
@@kingcamelot1395 i would have saved her. But i wouldn't have slaughtered the doctor and Marlene. She was begging for her life and Joel smoked her like it was nothing. I can't defend him. And he got the death he deserved. A true villains death. Felt no sympathy at all when he died. Sure I felt sad for Ellie but that's it.
@@kingcamelot1395 yeah because Joel couldn't see the big picture. Did you forget that she knew Ellie longer than Joel. She literally promised her mother to keep her safe. you think she wasn't hurt over the fact that Ellie had to die? In last of us part 2 you can literally see how conflicted she is over the fact that Ellie has to die. They had a chance (a small chance) to create a vaccine. Even if it's a small chance a great leader makes that decision for the greater good every single day of the week. Especially in those circumstances. Again i understand Joel but he was wrong on so many levels. And that's why he died the way he did. He did not deserve a heroes death. Imo his death was perfect.
1:22 is also great foreshadowing for part ll/season 2(if you know you know, I won't spoil). They probably had this scene cut this way for a nice parallel in the future.
@@festarii Okay so here's my in-depth thoughts process of this; spoilers for The Last Of Us Part II: The room is reminiscent of the first floor of Joel's house in Tommy's camp. We see this room when Ellie is rummaging through Joel's property, specifically when Maria calls down Ellie to try and stop her from going through with her revenge plot. Of course this scene is not within Joel's house, but it draws a lot of parallels with his house in-game, so I wonder if it was intentional, possibly setting up parallels for the following season(s).
For those who are curious, this is what the rest of the letter said after Joel took it from Ellie (I looked it up and it shows the full letter): "Use them to keep Tess safe, until such time as you and she decide you've had enough. At that point, I recommend pairing 40 Vicodins with a nice Brunello." -Bill
Another detail that some people might've missed is with Bill and Frank's last meal with the bottle already having pills inside of it, the extra pills that Bill crushed up and mixed into Frank's wine would make him pass away/fall asleep sooner than Bill who just drank the wine with the pills already in it, so Frank's last request of falling asleep first in Bill's arms probably happened as well
Kinda wished Ellie also read the part where it said, "do not make a mistake, or you will also get blown to shit. I am not joking. Don't fuck that up heh heh heh."
I love the game and I love this show. However, the one thing that I was disappointed in was that we never got to see Bill and Ellie interact in the show. The complete polar opposites they were made for some truly entertaining moments. In any case, god bless this game, this show, and this episode
I love subtle details of scenes in movies and TV. I’m not always right in my assessment. It’s very obvious that there is thick dust everywhere, but the trail left in the dust when she slid the key across the table, really drove the point home. I think that was no accident.
Though it is sad that the show does not have the interaction Ellie and Bill have like in the game, at least Ellie reading Bill’s letter has that semblance of her connecting to Bill.
@@chanteng1892 and one of the earliest acts early humans did was bash their neighbors head in and drag their women into a cave.....so Imma go on a limb and say you think rape should be legal, you fucking weirdo.
It was more of a forced gay character insert even though they supposedly make up 5% of the population, they have to be 25-50% of all TV characters. And then making him a low-key gay dude who is conservative and a survivalist is a taunt at conservative white males, by leftists, basically saying "haha you're actually secretly gay, and that's a bad thing you should be ashamed of" which is the opposite of what the left preaches to their own demographic, making them hypocrites.
Bit of a dick move for Bill and Frank not to at least push the bottle off the table before going to bed, if I was Joel I'd be like "hell yeah, free wine" and die lol
I love what they did to their story. I love the game and played It so many times before this came out and this was so amazing to see. They got a happy ending in the Show.
Even though the scene and monologue is just being read off of a letter, Bella Ramsey performs this monologue SO well. I love it so much. I can't wait to see more of them in Season 2.
The letter was hilarious and hit me hard in the end. As much as I love Ellie and Bill’s banter in the game, the way the writers treated this character in the show was phenomenal
The realized Joel needed a car, so they created the greatest love story on television, beginning to end, got Joel the car and then had him crash it literally the next day
"The bunker code is the same as the gate code but in reverse" That's actually a pretty smart way to make sure that Joel is the only one who can access the bunker after Bill and Frank are dead, besides them, he and Tess are the only ones who know the gate code.
on a practical level, how would they carry all of them? this isn't a video game, there's no real life way for a person to comfortably, safely, and quietly carry multiple semi-auto and auto and hunting rifles, shotguns, pistols, a bow, and all the necessary ammo for all of them.
It’s very nice to know Bill and Joel were on good terms with each other when Bill and Frank passed away, in the game Bill and Joel were barely on good terms with each other and they were just associates and had debts to owe to each other, nothing more than that and once Bill got Joel the car, they had nothing to do with each other afterwards and it’s also good to know Bill and Frank were also on good terms and died together unlike the game when they weren’t on good terms at all when Frank died, Frank wanted more from life than Bills shitty little town but I don’t know what he expected because Bill was the only one who could protect him and the world literally ended and he got bitten, wrote a hate note and suicide note before he took his life! I’m also glad to see Lincoln isn’t as overrun here in the series unlike the game where have the town was overrun but Bill still managed and booby trapped the town, Lincoln was literally so clean here but I was a little disappointed there wasn’t as much action in Lincoln here like there was in the game!
Because the window was open in Frank and Bill's room, there was draft. The door slamming shut prevented Joel from forcing the bedroom door open and thus made sure Bill's wishes were granted. I guess.
I may be reaching but it’s probably his ghost or his energy leaving the place for one last time to make sure Joel got the supplies he needed therefore he can rest in peace knowing Joel got what he needed
No, it’s just the draft from window caused a cross breeze and slammed the door shut. But yeah, there’s some symbolism there, too. I love how beautifully this was filmed.
@@Connection-Lost if you played the game bill was gay, it wasn’t out there but he was, there were signs in the game that he was. You’re Just another Miserable closet gay boomer.
For real, where do I get their flashlights? I see them all the time in the Uncharted games, as well as The Last of Us, but did not think they were real. Now that they're seen in the show, I now know they're real
Heard somebody, probably just in an attempt to be homophobic, say this episode didn’t push the narrative forward. They obviously didn’t understand this scene. Joel failed to keep Tess safe the way Bill did Frank, this isn’t just heartbreaking it adds to Joel’s determination to keep Ellie safe. You know when Joel was doing what he did at the end of the season, he was doing it thinking his job and purpose for still being alive was just to protect Ellie and fuck anybody in his way, guilty or otherwise. Excellent writing and a fantastic change from the source material
The show had way more emotion in it, and that says alot because the game had emotion as well, take Sam and Henry for example in the game 😢, that shit still shocks me to this day bro.
I don’t get it why didn’t Joel and Ellie didn’t make that place their home? it’s safe and isolated, nowhere near the infected. You could literally make that place a little small town full of people to safely live the rest of their lives
@@SolaireKnightusIt wouldn’t have made sense for them to travel all the way back across the country, with all the danger that entailed, rather than go back to live with Tommy and his community. Besides, why live alone when you can live with other people who’ve already created a community?
For as great as this episode otherwise was, it's a bit disappointing that the letter's text was so lacking in subtlety. Otherwise a fantastic episode. Even if it didn't have much to do with the overarching story, it's still my favorite from the show so far
@@reaverfang377 The letter is just very out of character for Bill is what I'm saying. It's lacking in the subtlety that he's known for. He's a man of action, not words. I can get behind the concept of him writing a short note like "take what you need and don't open the bedroom door." But this emotional essay the writers gave him is just indicative of a lapse in judgment during the writing process
I'll be honest i feel the Episode was mostly to answer what happened to Bill after Ellie and Joel left. Which tbh i actually like this alot. I DEFITNALLY would've like to see bill come back but tbh this fate is quite nice:)
@@YeetusMingus bruh, you missed the point. Frank changed him as a person but still possessed his blunt honesty. Plainly expressing himself in ways Game Bill never got to. It's a plot device the show is using to show the audience, the vast majority of which never played the games. So either you need media literacy class or you are fishing for reasons to hate this piece of media.
@@reaverfang377 You don't need to stoop to false hyperbole to try and make a point; I don't hate the show or even this episode. I just didn't think the letter was executed in a way that did justice to Bill's character, which I stand by. Neither in the show or the game, is it ever hinted that there is any fondness Bill has for Joel or Tess beyond some degree of professional respect; the letter makes no sense given the "relationship" they had.
They’re both old. Frank is ill and told Bill to give him A LOT of pills in his wine so he can pass on his sleep. Bill gave them BOTH the pills so they can pass together.
