*HEATED* Creating Our PL OVERRATED Xl 23/24 | FULL DEBATE! 

Genuinely don’t understand how Theo has got to this point. Guy is as sharp as a bowling ball

saying fabio silva when hes at rangers is wild

Fabio silva might be the worst shout in the history of pitchside 😂😂😂

Tom Garret bites every time Lewis winds him up

A 48 minute Pitch Side vid, ahh this is unreal supply of pure delusion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That Fabio Silva shout had me dead

Freezy ball knowledge makes Theo look like a prime SAF

When Tom said Saka was overrated Theo looked like he wanted to cry 😭

As a Villa fan, we do not rate Matty Cash

The Max Aarons shout has to be one of the worst. Bro has been out injured for half the season and has played pretty much whenever he's been available. Convinced Theo hasn't watched a single Bournemouth match in his life.

30:19 bro said fabio silva😂

cal being salty over the fa cup QF loss against united is absolutely hilarious 😭😭

Can we include graphics for tier lists and teams?

Romero hasn't received a yellow card since early December. Mikel Arteta has more yellow cards than Romero this season. That's a terrible reason to include him. He's class

Why is Cal slagging off Dalot

martinez is crazy guys been injured and hasn't been able to shush the haters last season he was fantastic lol

Chelsea fans don’t even rate Chilwell

Disasi playing every game doesn't mean Poch or the fans rate him. It means Chalobah, Fofana, Badiashile, Silva and Colwill have been injured and he hasn't

As an everton fan, DCL is overated to all premier league fans, to everton fans he aint overated hes just shit, and pickford aint overatted, hes underated if anything, golden glove leader, and has literally kept everton from losing games.

15:00 Tom doubling down when he’s objectively wrong. He has started in midfield multiple times at the start of this season, not “playing striker and dropping deep” that was more his position last season when he was in his best form at liverpool

“People act like Martinez is like their main guy” I guess it’s not just a coincidence that United plaited their best football by a mile when he came back from injury. If any United centre half is overrated it’s Maguire.

How on earth is Romero overrated? I think there’s so many people who have an agenda with him just because he’s an old school defender, hard in the tackle, aggressive. He’s scored the most goals as a defender with 4. World Cup winner. How on earth is he overrated just because Gary Neville hates him? Wth

Reev had a stinker

I had no idea who Fabio silva was until today

Why does Theo think every football fan starts their sentence with “OH MY GODDD” ?

These fellahs don’t know what overrated means half the players they’re picking are just not having good seasons but no one is overrating them

Some absolute honkers here but van de Ven isn't better than Romero. Standard take of someone who doesn't actually watch Spurs properly and uses Romero's discipline against him rather than actually watching him defend.

Dalot 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 nice one calfreezy great explanation as well 👍

That Romero shout is so poor. The agenda is real. Messi even praised him and he won a World Cup.

How did Varane and Dalot get mentioned? They’ve both been one of our best players this season🤣

Dalot 😂😂😂😂😂 been united best player.

cals a liverpool fan right that would explain why he picked united players when the aren't even rated by anyone lol

From Theo’s Fabio Silva shout to Lewis calling out everyone, I’m clucking like a hen

38:28 for the next 15 seconds was just pure gold hahaha

Calling caicedo overrated because of his price tag is actually deluded, caicedo has been slandered by the media and RU-vid commentators all season while quietly putting in good performances all season he’s been consistently at a 7-8 all season but rival fans are so biased they can’t see it

Genuinely dont see how any man utd/newcastle/ chelsea players can be in this list when the majority of football fans say they are all shit. They cant be overrated if most people dont rate them 😂

Did Lewis just compare Erling Haaland a man who has scored what 80 plus goals in the last 18 months to Sunderland Central Defensive Midfielder Grant Leadbitter? No wonder people hate football podcasts 🤣🤣

Fabio silva is the worst shout in pitchside history

Caicedo is the most lazy argument. Firstly, as an individual he's been very good, Tom saying poor is objectively wrong. His numbers are similar to last year and we love watching him tear through midfields, just watch more.. He's said Gusto can't defend and Caicedo's been poor. I'm positive the only times he's watched Chelsea is the 3 times they've done a live on here. Secondly, Chelsea paid what it took. You don't pay, you don't get. People seem to think that your final value is the level you should be currently playing. Keep that attitude but it's just not how football works anymore. It's an investment. Same as if joined LFC for the same amount. It's securing one of the best young (23) versatile 6/8's in world football that you'll have at your club for years. It's an investment. Hope this helps but I'm well aware this would go over the average football supporters head.

lewis is stupid but you can tell that no one really watches Chelsea bcz if you did, you'd know that Enzo has been terrible this entire season and Caicedo has been single-handedly carrying that midfield

6:02 shaking his head saying dalot hasn’t been consistent 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 are you actually messing ??? Why comment on something you don’t have a clue about

Theo calling Cash overrated because Konsa "a centreback" is starting above him, when in reality thats a flawed arguement, Konsa plays over Cash because Emery likes too have one attacking fullback on one side and one very defensive fullback on the right, so in transition villa move too a 3 in the back. This also isn't emery adapting because Cash is too bad too be starting he's done it at Villareal and other former teams he's managed. Cash doesn't start because he's more of an attacking fullback.

fabio silva is the worst shout i have ever heard 😭😭

Tom garratt 23/02/2023: Also, I am now a fully fledged member of the Lisandro Martinez fan club. Seeing him live turned me and yet again tonight he was a rock. He’s the type of player fans adore

So if Ben White is overrated as a CB playing as a fullback does that make Dan Burn an overrated fullback as well. Thoughts?

Seeing Theo laugh after saying he leaned Spanish from Portugal had me die 😂, bro know exactly what he was doing

3 players in from Cal and all 3 are appalling. Why is he even on this?

The romero shout is absolutely mental

LEWIS HOWLERS: 1. 'You guys dont watch newcastle' yes they do you make them stream newcastle every other week. 2. 'My keepers between raya and pickford' the top 2 for clean sheets this season. 3. 'Longstaff' after putting him in team of season ahead of rodri 4. 'Odegard' after saying longstaff is having a better season 5. Defending pope who cant get in england squad 6. Halaand. 🤯 7. 'Fabian schar is the best passing defender in the league' Did i miss any....? 😂

Nah the Fabio silva shout who’s at rangers on loan and everyone think is shit is too funny 🤣🤣🤣

Their Odegaard take is shocking. He‘s performances in big games this season have been very good. He‘s basically also leading all midfielders in Europe in every single creative metric

Zinchenko is probably one of the most underrated players now based on the way everyone laughs when you even mention his name. He's in the 96th+ percentile on passes attempted, completed, and progressive passes per 90. He's capable of recycling possession in Arsenal's system better than almost anyone else capable of that LB spot

Romero is such a horrible shout from Reev, so many better choices lmao

Theo going at everyone’s lists and then having an absolute shit one himself was so amazing

Tom thinks someone is underrated or overrated based on what the people next to him say instead of the general consensus

Personally i think theo put in a stinker here ,onana and varane have been very good this year ,varane goes under the radar because his tackles are clean and tidy,whereas a Martinez for example does more agressive tackles so other united fans latch onto it,varane is manuniteds best cb for sure.also lewis saying "varane has been replaced by evans "shows he hasnt watched manunited and calling him a "champions league merchant " just seems stupid tbh,hes manunited cb by far

Romero overrated? He’s so fucking good

Saka not showing up in big games is such a MYTH

These guys don’t really know the definition of Overrated. Literally a player can be very good and still be overrated, for example Saka, he is a good footballer but Arsenal fans overrate him so much. Players that are shit aren’t overrated.

Saka's been playing through injury while being double teamed by everyone and still has 30+ goal contributions. Also his record vs the top 6 is amazing

Blades fan here - Varane is class when he plays - Dalot has been great this season - Bruno has been their most consistent player for years - this lineup is so anti-United

You can tell Tom is just yapping to piss theo off. Bro said turn up in big games rather than scoring against Watford - we've not been in the prem for 2 years 😂

Bro, overrated isnt people who have been shit this season. Or people who were better last season and worst this season. Its legit players who are good, but not as good as some managers/fans think they are. Rashford isnt rated by united fans, he has dropped off massively. So he isnt overrated, hes just a form player. Dalot this season has been consistent and as such has been getting praise, but people still want awb in his place or we get a new rb, so he cant be overrated. In liverpool, the way szoboslai was at the start of the season was really good, performed well but dropped off slightly, but is still being rated based on the first half of the season can be argued as overrated. Players like stones and van dijk are outstanding and have been great this season, but then comparing them to terry, vidic and more legends is just overrating them

Most Liverpool fans want Gakpo sold he isn’t really rated so don’t know how he is over rated

Martinez is one of our best players when he’s available do these lads even watch United? He completely changes our game, one of the best ball playing centre backs in the league no doubt. Dalot shout was mad as well been our player of the season😂 I know we’ve been shite so people will says it’s not hard..😂

I think apart from Haaland, Ben White might be the stinkiest shout I've ever seen... he's literally being begged to play for England because he's been the arguably the best RB in the league

How is Caicedo classified as overrated when everybody says that he has a bad season. He is overpriced, but not overrated. At this moment it seems like he is more like underrated, cuz he is actually solid for the last couple of months. 🤦‍♂️

Saying Saka is overrated is just utter stupidity. People say Foden and Palmer are better than him by a mile so how is he overrated. He is easily top 5 in his position. Foden is a right winger he’s a cam so a top 5 list in no specific order would be: Saka, salah, rodrygo, Palmer, and yamal/sane. And top 3 would be: Palmer, Saka and salah

Reev can't go a single video without digging in on Lewis and Newcastle. Yes Newcastle have been very poor this season compared to last and Lewis is very biased but Reev literally cannot go a single debate/combined video without focusing solely on Lewis and seeking Tom's validation. Sometimes Lewis will even make good points and Reev will just not acknowledge it. Just keep an eye on him in these type of videos and even the past videos, he can't let Lewis go.

I swear theo chose Arrons because he was a high potential rating on fifa 20 🤣

The Ederson shout is Outrageous. He's class

Mark of a man when u ask someone’s opinion then cry because u don’t like the answers

I get why hes there but based souly on performance Caicedo has been incredibly underrated, everyones been blinded by his price tag (understandably) even though hes been our best midfielder this season even better the Gallagher in a poch system that leaves him in a one man midfield. He hasn't been worth the price but will definitely be in the coming seasons and when he leaves he'll be a Chelsea legend

Saka was literally englands best player v France.

Cal, atleast Rashford gets in a purple patch, what about Gapko?

If you watch this for entertainment purposes only it’s enjoyable but if you’re here for knowledgeable conversations LEAVE😂

First time I’ve disagreed with Tom on that matty cash shout. The Villa fans I know (quite a lot due to living in the area) can’t stand the guy most weeks and want him replaced. He’s one of the only players I hear them actively draw out for poor performances every week. Villa fans do NOT rate matty cash, nor does anyone else, therefore he cannot be overrated

Lisandro Martinez overrated?? Literally one of our best players last season. Calling him overrated this season when he's been injured the whole season

Got a strong opinion on the Haaland one . He struggles for city because there’s no space for him. He needs space to run into. He will score goals in any team but it’s hard for him with no space to run into

Saka "disappears in big games" was the best england player in the world cup quarter finals.

I cannot stand Lewis acting like an exciting dog whenever a Man Utd player is being mentioned in these lists. Guy is salty cause we dunked on his shit team in leauge cup final

tbf ederson is underrated he makes a lot of great saves and i rarely see a mistake or a shot he should save, he can’t be overrated cus rarely anyone says he’s the best in the league, i do think he’s third after alisson and vicario now but even third is impressive in this league with a lot of top keepers

Cal saying everyone only remembers Rashfords "purple patches" is so ironic considering its the complete opposite

Theo got so rattled about that silva shout that he just kept sticking by it even though he knew it was the worst shout ever 🤣

Ederson is more underrated rather than overrated. He is one of the best in the league and people would rate him higher if he played for any team other than city

The Romero shout is crazy. Top 5 CB in Prem, better than Van de Ven and has less bookings than Arteta this season

For everyone to say that Arsenals best players are overrated, you also can’t say Arteta is. He’s must be the best manager in the league then😂

villa fans do not rate matty cash, he should be no where near an overrated XI

I'd love to know why Tom keeps banging on about Saka not being world class or top 3 in the world when he also says Foden is up there with Bellingham and Mbappe saw how Foden plays in Saka's position for England last 2 games and he was dreadful yet never hear a word about it

I really don’t get the Martinez shouts, as a United fan he improves our defence sooo much when he’s in, he can be a bit rash but so can a lot of the top tier prem defenders

Konsa isn’t keeping Cash out of the Villa team, it’s because Villa have got an injury crisis. Having said that, Cash is overrated.

Gakpo has 18 GA this year and gets slated by Liverpool fans. Tom doesn’t watch enough footy

The slander against United is crazy and they obviously just don’t like the team. Cal literally has dalot, Martinez, Bruno and Rashford in his 11 and no one calls him out for it and he’s a LIVERPOOL fan. Dalot has been outstanding for us this season Martinez is injured but when he plays, he transforms our team and we can consistently play out from the back (Lewis keeps begging this small tax thing, literally no one brings that up but him, if he watched him play he’d know it’s just because he’s a class cb especially alongside Varane. Bruno is our most consistent player that does so much work for the team all round and they just can’t stand that he’s a top midfielder. And Rashford is going through a rough patch so I do understand people saying he’s overrated but I think that’s literally just because he plays for united (big team/expectation tax) They may as well just put a disclaimer at the start of the video saying “We don’t like United so that will be accounted for in our lists”

Haaland is not a bad shout. He's spoken about as being someone on a similar level to Mbappe, which he is miles away from. He was completely anonymous in the crunch cup matches at the end of the season for City.

I don’t understand how they can say Lisandro Martinez is overrated he does need a solid centre back next to him but he’s ridiculously good at progressing the ball and makes us play entirely differently when he’s on the pitch

Is there any way of watching these videos with Theo muted the whole time

"the people will speak for us" Saka isn't world class.

i think toms saka shout is spot on, i think people protect saka a bit much

I’m a city fan and doku has actually got mad potential. Like he’s the one player that is electric and takes players on. He’s brilliant just needs to do it more often which will come. He’s like 21

The bias against United is insane, people just hate on united players for the sake of it