Hermes Kelly 25 vs Birkin 25 - Which is Right for YOU? | Review & Comparison | A Practical Guide

Подписаться 5 тыс.

Просмотров 92 тыс.

50% 1

Today we'll be Reviewing & Comparing the K25 and B25! I'll talk comprehensively about Pros/Cons to determine which bag is right for YOU. I'll also include Mod Shots, Weight of both bags, Wrist & Forearm shot to visualize Birkin handle drop, Which bag is practical? Which bag is my favourite? Let me know if you're team Kelly or team Birkin! :)
Bags featured: Hermes Kelly 25 Sellier Apricot GHW, Birkin 25 Bleu Nuit GHW
Item mentioned: Carrie Atelier Rose Gold Bag Hook
carrieatelier.com
-----------------------
♡ About me
Hi everyone! I'm Jane. I do videos on fashion (pairings, lookbooks, reviews, hauls), luxury and shopping mindfulness. I love creating looks that are feminine and classic (with a twist). Fashion is art that you can wear. Often, what you wear and how you present yourself to the world can give you the confidence to be your best self. That is what fashion helps me achieve, and I hope it can achieve the same for you.
Thanks for letting me share my style and musings with you. :)
Subscribe for videos on Fridays!
-----------------------
Music from Uppbeat (free for Creators!):
uppbeat.io/t/kevin-macleod/mon...
License code: KSULWBMIJVXOARYN

Хобби

Опубликовано:

21 апр 2022

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 161

@layzeh3266 7 месяцев назад

This is the first time I saw your video and I love watching it. No frills, straight to the point, and no ounce of drama. Thank you. Keep making videos like this. 🙌

@janeshappyplace3687 7 месяцев назад

Thank you!! ❤

@TarantoCurson Месяц назад

None of my friends and family could tell if it was genuine or fake. It ended up saving me a ton of money! But I am very satisfied with the high quality and great service I purchased *preluxs* .

@kkstory8403 2 года назад

Grateful for another Hermès videos! Your demonstration and comparison is really clear and easy for understanding! Gain a lot from your soothing voice!

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Yay!! Happy to help! 😘 Thanks for watching! 💕

@HelloL.G. 2 года назад

I really enjoyed this comparison review, especially with the added category of practicality! Thank you

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Yay! Happy you found it helpful! ☺️

@littlebean8856 2 года назад

I’ve always thought Birkin is slightly more flashy than Kelly, not only because it’s well known but also the way we carry it on the crook of our arms in front of our bodies makes it even more in your face. I always thought it’s just me but glad to hear it from you too. ❤️❤️

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

YESS that is a great point about the way you hold the bag too! I feel the same! 🙌🏻

@owenbeharry8478 10 месяцев назад

The Kelly is more classic

@jyotigadher 2 года назад

The best review/comparison for these bags IMO. Thank you so much 😘

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Yay!!! 🧡🧡☺️

@yooni8697 2 года назад

Thank you so much for including the weight of the bags as well as the top handle measurements!!! Those were extremely helpful! 😊

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

🙌🏻🙌🏻 glad it helped!! 💛

@JamieReviewsStuff Год назад

Slightly obsessed with that Bleu Nuit color. It’s gorgeous!!! 💙 Thank you for the video, I’ve been going between these two and I think I’ve final come to a decision.

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Thank you! Glad the video was helpful 💛

@lydialeung9106 Год назад

Your comparison analysis is spot on, very detailed. 💖✨Thanks for sharing

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Thank you!! 💛☺️

@NoSacrificeBags 2 года назад

Great comparison and review for these timeless bags💕The colour of your Kelly is absolutely beautiful!

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Hehe thank you!!

@chanellovervynguyen3832 Год назад

Thanks for your review! Love them both… I finally got them❤❤

@hongily25 10 месяцев назад

I’m so glad you started your preference! The amount of RU-vidrs who don’t decide is mind boggling.

@janeshappyplace3687 10 месяцев назад

😂

@Wiiniihvlog 2 года назад

The color of the Kelly is really beautiful 😍

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Thank you!! 🥰

@mariaau1182 Год назад

Wow I really enjoyed this video! Great comparison 😊 I never thought I’d like an orange bag but your orange Kelly is stunning !

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Thanks Maria!! 😘😘

@mariaeden6601 Год назад

Your videos are so informative and short and pleasant to watch!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Yay! Thank you! 🥰

@sarah0098 2 года назад

Yay great video. I am lucky enough to own a B30, K 25 and C18. Hands down kelly girl for me too! Also agree C18 is such a practical bag, it’s probably my most used. Your blue nuit with GHW is simply stunning!!

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Thanks Sarah! 😄💕 What a lovely collection! I was debating between B30 and B25 :). Yesss love my C18 too 🙌🏻🙌🏻 I think I would use it even more if it wasn’t white 😅

@dluckygurl8 Год назад

Wow, that blue nuit with GHW is stunning!!! Defninitely a combination that I'd keep in mind when purchasing another Hermès bag in the future! I don't own a Birkin and not planning on buying one so def TeamKelly here! The mini Kelly II in chèvre Mysore leather has been on my wish list for a while now but, because of your video, I'll have to add the K25 sellier in box leather (I have a vintage K32 retourne in box leather)! Thank you for such a great comparison video! Just subscribed to your channel!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Woot! #teamkelly 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙃 mini Kelly in chevre sounds dreamy 😍

@juainaar7642 Год назад

Tqvm for this very interesting and honest review of 2 very sought after bags. As you say, both bags are not very practical. With such high price points Hermes has indeed done a very good job of marketing these bags...!!

@ZahraJ22 2 года назад

Amazing video thank you so much and you even put the soundtrack you are awesome xx

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Thanks for watching!!💕💕

@egi__lyricsadder5545 Год назад

she's so proud of the bags

@DivineStyle08 2 года назад

Gosh ! Your Kelly gets me every time !! I love it 😻😻 my dream color !!

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Hehe yay apricot! 😄🙌🏻🙌🏻🧡

@ldomligan 2 года назад

Great review !! I love your voice it’s so soothing

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Thank you!! 🥺💕

@christallaktorides6904 2 года назад

Thank You for the comparisons. Very helpful.

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

☺️

@PandoraBoxMusic 2 года назад

Just came across your videos and love all of them! Very honest and helpful content, thank you. Already subscribed ;)

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Aw thanks love! Happy you’re here!! 💕💕💕😍

@heidii.4024 2 года назад

Your video is easy to listen to and informative. Love your top, btw. I love sellier bags in epsom (Birkin or Kelly) because of their structured look, and that epsom is lighter than other leathers. As far as togo, I like the slight vertical veining and this feature is difficult to replicate by copiers.

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Thanks Heidi! ☺️ Yas love structured bags! 🙌🏻 Good point about the veining being harder to replicate 😮 I never thought of it that way!

@ohoop Год назад

“Togo is amazeballs” literally killed me 😂😂. This is a fantastic video, I so enjoyed it!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Hahah thanks girl!! 😉

@ccrider4556 4 месяца назад

Excellent comparison video!

@janeshappyplace3687 4 месяца назад

Thank you! ☺️

@karenann17 Год назад

Thank you. I am petite and you gave valuable information. 😊 I have subscribed.

@leslieolivia7687 2 года назад

Hi! Thank you for posting this comparative video. I don't own a Hermes bag yet but my heart is very much leaning towards the Kelly 25 retourné, possibly in a bright color (nata, jaune poussin or gold). I'll attempt to get one in Paris soon x

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Oooo those are dreamy combos!! Good luck! 😍

@suzimaynard2171 7 месяцев назад

Thanks for your informative video. I love your bags on you! I always thought that I would own either a Birkin or a Kelly one day too in size 25. I do feel this size is too big for me after watching your video. I am a retired teacher so don't need to carry much around now. I think the mini Kelly is cute but not sure how practical it is because you have to leave it open. I much prefer the Picotin Lock 18, Mini Lindy and Mini Bolide.

@factisfact9426 2 года назад

I love the color of the Kelly 🧡

@annalizettehernandez1214 Месяц назад

Love the reviews! On the hunt for my first Hermes bag and it's so hard to decide for such a big investment! Thanks

@LifewithLokie 2 года назад

Oh no... what do i do? I actually love both now... 😆😅 TFS jane! Excellent video

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Hahahaha Lokie 😂

@sveta_russkaya 6 месяцев назад

Helpful!!! I chose Kelly

@JulianGarcia-mp9kj 7 месяцев назад

Great video!

@JessicaAnhDao Год назад

Really really helpful. Thanks a lot!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Glad you found it helpful!! 😄

@kimmykero2421 Год назад

Great review! I personally prefer the Togo leather (and also tend to shy away from attention)...that would be my con with any Hermes bags...I suppose I must first get one (if I can put in the require effort)!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Hahaha can’t go wrong with Togo :)

@myraparis Год назад

Wonderful! ♥️

@zhangjingyi8895 2 года назад

I have a grey B25, even I m over 5'7 but it still look good on me. So probably the whole look with the bag may be affected on the width of each individual rather than the hight. Especially for the width of shoulder.

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Yup agreed, width will definitely affect the proportions of the bag as well. Good point on the shoulder 🙂

@jessicaboo8424 3 месяца назад

great video ❤ thank you

@ABR-rs7be 2 года назад

team Kelly. great video

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

😃🙌🏻

@sharynbeech7917 2 года назад

Really good review

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Thanks! 🧡☺️

@charmynejoy61 Год назад

I really like the way you talk ☺️

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Thank you! 🥰

@lisakim3487 Год назад

Great video - best comparison I've seen. Which make me want your opinion on another combo - K25 retourne togo? What do you think, maybe best of both worlds?

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Haha perhaps!! 😄 I think it may be the most functional but maybe lacking that structure :)

@hasna.h1137 2 года назад

Hi Jane I would love to see your jewelry collection ? Thank you

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Noted! :)

@deafheart23 Год назад

I want the exact opposite of your bags. I want a Kelley 25 in Togo Retourne and a Birkin 25 in Epsom Sellier 😍👜✨

@Ooo.spicey 2 года назад

Omg I love ur kelly 😍

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

:D thank you!! 💛

@indymathias794 10 месяцев назад

kelly 25 i love so much

@DivineStyle08 8 месяцев назад

I keep coming back to your Kelly lol Where is your top from ??

@Yo_mama_wears_combat-boots Год назад

Amazing bag colors and hardware!!! 💗 Love your honest Pro's and Con's; Music and lighting are great. I have been wanting to get a Kelly 25 vs 28(?) but hesitated because of the opening of the bag. The Birkin is amazing. I own a 42 JPG in Gold with GHW. Love it, BUT I get a lot of attention and I hate having to carry it on my forearm. It gets HEAVY! I don't like the attention and often feel I am a target. 😣 The black spots are strange. I do know Epsom can attract and hold particles more easily than the other leathers. I haven't looked closely at the Constance but will check out your other videos. I have a few Evelyne bags that work great but I like more soft, though structured bags these days. New to your channel, but love your work!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Haha thank you! 😀 Agree with the soft but structured bags 😊

@jennifers-w2590 2 года назад

Great video. None of these Cons apply to me thankfully cause I have the K32 (vintage box sellier) and the B35, Clemence so it seems if you get a bigger bag of each many issues wont exist

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Your bags sound yummy 😍, good point!

@jennifers-w2590 2 года назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 :) and lastly, thanks for diving right in to the points. It drives me crazy when ppl just ramble on and on about silly details no one cares about. 😆

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

@@jennifers-w2590 🤣 I feel you girl. Unfortunately even if I wanted to ramble I do not know how to 😅

@lynjaraparcasio8744 Год назад

So classy

@uhohotdog3483 2 года назад

Thanks 👍

@rosya.traveler4269 2 года назад

Both are beautiful

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

😃🙌🏻

@joyLoveC Год назад

Great video! Do the sangles scratch the bag when you leave them hanging?

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Nope they shouldn’t! :)

@sopiduckie Год назад

Thanks for putting together this video! It is very helpful! I had a question…what kind of bag hook is the one in the video and where can I find it? Thanks!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

The bag hook is from Carrie Atelier! I linked it in the description box below :)

@sopiduckie Год назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 Thank you!!

@Lulinguyen 2 года назад

I really like the top that you’re wearing in this video! Where did you get it? Thanks!

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

It’s from 3.1 Phillip Lim! :)

@HJ60123 Год назад

Hi there! Loved your video. Thanks for sharing. :) Do you by chance use an insert in either of your bags?

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Thank you! :) I use the 7rp for my birkin ☺️

@HJ60123 Год назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 Good to know! I just got my first B25 in Paris and want to make sure it's properly protected. lol. ;) Thanks again!

@HJ60123 Год назад

Sorry but can I ask you one more question about the Carrie bag hook? It looks gorgeous, but is it heavy? After seeing your video, I totally want to get it but don't want to add too much weight to my bag. Thanks!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

@@HJ60123 congrats on your B!! :) The Carrie is heavy enough to feel substantial and good quality but doesn’t weigh like a brick or anything haha

@HJ60123 Год назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 Omg! Hilarious. Love how you said weigh like a brick. Thanks for the reply! :)

@ccrider4556 4 месяца назад

The bag hook is a perfect gift. How can I buy this?

@janeshappyplace3687 4 месяца назад

Check out Carrie Atelier! It’s linked in the description :)

@asakuwong4260 2 года назад

What is the brand of the table bag holder ? It’s nice :)

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

It is Carrie Atelier! :)

@natashanatasha649 Год назад

Thanks for the video! I decided that I’ll buy Chanel not Hermes :) it’s awful: one bag is heavy when even empty, the other u can hardly put your arm inside. So uncomfortable, how can they cost so much. Thanks for sharing!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Haha yeah they’re not the most practical bags 😅 but I guess the heart wants what it wants 🙈

@natashanatasha649 Год назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 😀

@thefavouredone Год назад

Hi! Can I know what is the colour of your Birkin? It is stunning!

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

It’s Blue Nuit! :)

@DaniOchannel 2 года назад

Lol, i agree that neither are practical. They are our extra babies. I have a k32 in clemence and the soft leather is really easy to use. I previously considered a k25 but i do feel that it will be way too small now. I'm looking for a b25 next. I intend on attaching a strap to the sangles and only using it by the strap when I'm desperate 💕💕

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

“Extra” babies indeed 😅. Yum K32 in clemence 💕 sounds functional and nice and smooshy :). Oo the strap on the sangles is a good idea but I worry about the sangles getting deformed :/

@DaniOchannel 2 года назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 yeah I plan to use the strap only when I need it but to carry mostly with top handles still. I was also thinking that worse case scenario, Hermes could replace the sangles right?

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

@@DaniOchannel Yeah that could work 😀

@myw002 2 года назад

Very helpful video! Do you have an IG to follow as well with these recommendations/daily fashion? Also do you make recommendations for men's fashion as well?

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Hey Matt! Thank you! 😄 I do have a personal Instagram but don’t update it too much. Maybe later on! 🙂 Haha I don’t think I’m qualified to talk about men’s fashion unfortunately 😅, if it were up to me all men would just wear suits and dress shirts 🤣 I am very biased hahahah

@myw002 2 года назад

Even if you can opine on men’s wear from Hermes as an example would be helpful. I’m actually trying to work towards a Birkin for the SO, so accumulating stuff on the way there.

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

@@myw002 noted!

@jeehanleedesign9965 2 года назад

love kelly 25 more...

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

😄🙌🏻🙌🏻

@cherryblossomsandwisteria855 2 года назад

Team Birkin anytime. Biggest reason, closing a Kelly bag is a hassle, but in Birkin u just have to put the things in and that's it

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Agreed! Birkin are definitely a lot easier to get into 🙂

@qdyuqgwdhiqwduyqw 15 дней назад

People keep saying they buy luxury for quality, originality and tradition. But really, isn't 90% for the hype and prestige and ego? Not as good as the $200 premium knockoffs H Q D U P S Great quality and price

@tahiraanis7722 Год назад

Where is your sweater from?

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

It’s from Phillip lim! :)

@trishnguyen8098 6 месяцев назад

K25 is better to choose slouchy leather, k28 is better with rigid leather

@samarae 24 дня назад

Birkin

@Mavericklie Год назад

hi where did you buy the hook?

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

Carrie atelier! :)

@Mavericklie Год назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 thanks. yout video is really helpful. im thinking to buy a birkin 25 but not sure how much i have to spend to be offered a birkin

@lalainatojo6330 Год назад

Definitively team k, but I won't say no if Someone gives me a Birkin 😂

@egi__lyricsadder5545 Год назад

well, i mean, if i had the money, i would probably buy it too, but i dont have the money 😭

@kateanette9398 6 месяцев назад

Great review. Not really sure why anyone pays 10K or more for a bag with cons. No shoulder strap/ strap not adjustable, heavy, hard to get into etc. Also these days a security risk. The more I watch Hermes reviews, the more sure I am, that I'll never buy these particular bags. There's a lot of quality bags out there, that are actually functional. I do get that these are good quality and classics, but no. They are pretty, though :)

@xyz-pg3zd 25 дней назад

What would you buy?

@kateanette9398 17 дней назад

@@xyz-pg3zd As it is now, I think I have enough bags for the rest of my life lol. Just one vintage high end, the rest are Coach, Minkoff and Ralph Lauren. All great quality, and no need to baby them :)

@xyz-pg3zd 17 дней назад

@@kateanette9398 what’s the vintage high end that you have?

@kateanette9398 9 дней назад

@@xyz-pg3zd Vuitton Alston shoulder bag, from 2002 :)

@ladyp5511 2 года назад

I think they're both impractical and I will save my dollars for something better.

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Haha I agree with you. That’s probably smart, but they’re so beautifully impractical 🥲

@ZahraJ22 Год назад

What’s your height for reference? Xx

@janeshappyplace3687 Год назад

I’m 5’4!

@DaniOchannel 2 года назад

Do you have a picotin? My concern about gettibg a picotin is that I'll like it more than the Birkin 😂

@janeshappyplace3687 2 года назад

Hahahaha that is an interesting dilemma 😂. I don’t have a picotin but they’re cute! Hey, if you end up liking it more than the birkin then I don’t think your wallet will be mad about that 😉😏

@DaniOchannel 2 года назад

@@janeshappyplace3687 true, wait a few years, then resell the birkin.

@ccyoutube8793 5 месяцев назад

Ridiculous for that price they can’t do adjustable strap???!!! Definitely daylight robbery but I’ll leave it to you rich people my intelligence doesn’t agree with this girl math 😅

@kiyahraef 23 дня назад

I know people personally who have so much genuine luxury brands yet they live in their mama house. I own my own home, drive a lexus and i do buy real mid luxury bags but anything over $1000 im getting a H Q D U P S replica and keeping money in my pocket.