Imagine getting kidnapped and forced into acting as someone's pet and then the first thing you hear of the outside world is your lame coworker calling you Teddy Bear
One of the things I find scary about this story is that the motivation behind the Kitty Cat Club doesn’t seem to be sexual at all. They just think men are dogs.
Paul Matthews just meowed. I regret watching this, because now I'll constantly lose my shit remembering about this mess lol Edit: I want to crawl out of my skin, why does Jon have to be so fucking good at acting? Who gave him that right? I haven't had such a visceral reaction over a video before, holy shit...
i have this image in my head of tinky just watching all of this being furious but he can't do anything about it because wiggly keeps stopping him because he thinks it's hilarious
I don't know if this is the fault of Wiggly, Blinky, or if those girls are just deranged, but this is the most horrific NT story yet. WTF It would have been fairly normal by NT standards if Melissa just escaped by herself or with the help if a lord in black, but having Paul take her is a psychological horror way beyond the other stories
its SO fucking weird but i love this story so much, it's genuinely unnerving and disturbing while also managing to make me laugh out loud multiple times i know there doesn't seem to be hardly any desire from fans for this as a nightmare time episode (which i do understand, its definitely not for everyone lmao) but i would love to see this in season 3
Would love a professional recording of this story. I watched a movie with a very similar premise and this was MUCH better and more tasteful, if you can believe it.
@@terrytheboxwithlimbs Lol I was actually referring to 2022's Good Boy, very disappointing film! I might check out Pet now, I'll go in with your thoughts in mind though!
Sorry, just watched this for the first time, WHAT THE FUCK. I AM ACTUALLY SPEECHLESS. WHAT IN THE GODDAMN STOCKHOLM SYNDROME WAS THAT. PAUL WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO YOU
WAIT- THIS WAS AN ACTUAL THING?!?!?!? They did trivia over it during the Halloween stream, and I just assumed it was a joke! I should know better, I know. But I remember legitimately thinking that it would be an interesting Nightmare Time episode, and was disappointed when it wasn’t in the S3 lineup. Now I am going to watch it and see if I was right.
Right after watching one of my cats came to say hello - even just saying that makes me feel disturbed. Never before has a piece of media effected me so vicerally. I pet my cat, and almost immediately recoiled. Honestly the best nightmare time since it will be giving me nightmares.
I genuinely dislike the implications of this story more than TGWDLM (from an in-universe standpoint) and i wish i hadn't watched it. Very uncomfy. Thanks for posting this video
I had to come here because all the talk about being traumatised by this story got me curious. Oh how I regret it now. I am a changed person after this.
I love this story but I wish I could read it instead of watch it because holy fuk I had to keep pausing it because I get second hand embarrassment so bad 😂
"I finally want to tell my wife something" 🤣 GO MR. DAVIDSON! BE BRAVE! "Did he finally tell his wife that important something? Not today..." Goddammit that made me legit sad. Stop toying with my emotions like this Nick! (JK Never want him to stop!) Tie him up... something we can use in Mr. Davidson's office... 🤨 Oh is there? lol. that's a fun little innuendo there. ... 😳😲Oh they actually went there... wait this is Starkid why did I think they WEREN'T going to actually go there. LOL 🤣
The most unsettling part about this is not only were the LiB not responsible for any of this, this is honestly worse than the things they actually did Edit: (THIS IS THE ONLY UNIVERSE WHERE PAUL AND EMMA DON'T GET TOGETHER. MY HEART IS PAINING)
This Is A Little Weird. When Joey Was Ted I Was Like Ok. But When He Was Dog Ted. I Couldn't Stop Laughing Or Smiling. And When Lauren Stroked His Hair. I Was Like O My Goodness. And Jon As Well As Paul And Cat Paul. But I Love Anything Team Starkid Or Tin Can Brothers Related.
I've heard a ton of stuff about this thing everywhere and seeing people's takes on it is hilarious so i have to watch it myself XD commenting so i can get my before vs after reactions, ill edit this comment when I'm done to see if this thing is truly as batshit crazy as I've heard. XD EDIT: whattheFUCK
I'd love to see a pro reread of this some time in the future, give it the proper Nightmare Time treatment. This is great, but the audio clipping, looping, etc. makes it hard to hear what someone is saying sometimes, and with how lore heavy the Hatchetfield stories are, types that analyze the hell out of them (like myself) want to hear every little detail possible. Edit: As deranged and horrifying as Melissa is, I can at least agree with her stance on declawing cats.