Simple....In india, government agencies will be misused and arrest the News reporter or shorter seller .. Rather than investigating whether any fraudulent had happened or not.. and be transparent with the public
Who in Indian media you think has spine to expose? #HindenbergReport is based on whistle blowers' documents, who you think should have approached and got published? Go talk to scribes, ground reporters, they will tell you how their reports are thrown in dust bin by their editors!
Let there be an investigation into the allegations, not by SEBI, but by an independent agency. If SEBI chairman is found guilty, she should be dismissed and criminal proceedings initiated.
But why she didn’t reveal the previous historical connections when she was entrusted with investigation by court. What is the harm in revealing those things
People defending the chief in the comment section will ignore you....they don't like to hear anything negative against the ruling govt.....also they might call you a propagandist.
@@MasterNPC-yp4on Of course it was targeted towards the market. They are trying to earn money by short selling shares after they published the report over the weekend. The whole of Kangress & Pappu's ecosystem were telling investors to pull money while he himself earned 46 lakhs off it in the last 5 months. But the retail investors showed them middle fingers. It's the same people who are inviting Adani to invest in their states. Hypocrisy at its finest.
Hindenburg thought that they can expose malpractice in India and the public will crash the market. Hindenburg didn't know that India runs on malpractice.💪
If they truly want to expose the corruption they shouldn't have earned money out of that scandal. Hinderberg research is funded by soros. Soros also earned his wealth the same way. Destroying stock markets in England, Malaysia, indonesia, thailand and Japan. He is just greed not saintly being.
What they need is a nice big Short-squeeze. But the real reason for Hindenburg is actually to take revenge for the strict rules by SEBI for F&O traders. In a way, Hindenburg is good for F&O traders to put a check on SEBI malpractices.
We cannot blindly defend her without thorough investigation. Defending one corrupted person will only ruin the Indian image. Better face neutral and find the truth
Last time Hidenburg made millions of dollars shorting Adani shares. Who lost the money..Poor investors. Now Adani shares are stronger than then. Also GQG Partners and sovereign wealth funds Abu Dhabi Investment Authority and Qatar Investment Authority UAE made millions out of that fall. Hope investors have learned their lesson from that. This is pure market manipulation.
The question is, is there conflict of interest, yes or no. Why didn't she make it public before she holds that position. If you do your job right, nobody will be able to point out your mistake. Simple..
@@MasterNPC-yp4onShe may not have done public disclosure, but she did disclosure to SEBI itself, when she joined as just a board member in 2017. She rose to be a full time member, and then later as Chairperson. At the time of joining, she transferred all the fund units to her husband in Singapore. And the fund never invested in Adani group. Also, she redeemed the units in 2018, when the fund manager Anil Ahuja, their friend left the fund, and this is before Adani shares started rising in 2020, and 4 years before she became Chairperson. So, there is no conflict of interest.
Actually, not many people lost money. Adani shares had such low availability, that not many people had bought it. Atmost some HNIs and some funds held it. But when they sold it, due to first report, then many retailers bought cheaply, and made a lot of money. 😂😂
Another interesting point Dhaval Buch was a purchasing agent for Hindustan Unilever, before becoming an advisor to Blackstone. Hindenberg says that he has no experience in real estate or capital markets. Ms Buch says he became an advisor before she joined Sebi. My question is does the finance minster get up one fine day and anounce a SEBI member out of the blue? Or is there a prolonged process. It is possible that Ms Buch was being considered for a job in SEBI at the time her husband became a consultant.
most of the folks don't understand the depth of the comment 🙂. Whatever opposition does is anti-national, if folks can't imply this simplification, then I offer my sympathy. I am standing in support to SEBI and Adani. Jai Hind!
The fact that people are angry on Hindenberg for exposing or trying to expose the nexus between a regulatory body and a company, but not on the irregularities found in this, shows just how shallow their thinking is, if you want to become a global leader one must also face global criticism
1. Ms. Buch has reported all her transactions before joining as sebi chief according to SEBI statement. 2. 360one, the AMC that manages IPE plus fund, issued a public statement that this particular product did not invest in any shares related to Adani group. 3. Hindenberg received a show cause notice from Sebi. So the short seller is trying to question sebi's credibility. Hindenberg's conflict of interest anyone? Also, her investment was in private capacity when she wasn't a sebi member. Not like she gambled with public money.
@@Tup7kSh7kur I did and I thought these points were missing from her report. It would've been evident if they read Sebi response and 360One AMC's response. Anchor pointed out conflict of interest because Ms. Buch invested in Adani shares. But the fund says it didn't and Ms. Buch had no say in where the fund would invest because it was at fund's discretion. So what's the case? Anyway an investigation should be done to increase transperancy. But if its proven false Hindenberg should also be held accountable because they are actually hurting retailer investment directly.
@@jacs-hr3sb These guys are hapless trolls. They forget more they troll more suspicion will rise. You know when BJP is protecting SEBI they are deepshit involved.
Congress asking SEBI Chief to resign based on mere allegations by anti-India lobby but they will not demand their ally Arvind Kejriwal to resign from CM post in liqour license scam case. Double standards much?
How stupid can Bhakts get….is it lack of education and discernment or just plain stupidity that emanates from Saffron Party and their lapdogs media that infects common man?,
It's ironic how Palki and some Indian politicians argue that Western companies and politicians shouldn't comment on what's happening in India, yet they themselves freely discuss and critique events in the West. It seems like this should go both ways
It is hypocrisy, for your info firstpost is owned by Mr mukesh ambani, it is clear for sometime that she is a BJP propaganda spreader. She never criticse the govt or talk about inflation and tax Teritisom
No one talks of how the US Senete members get information before the market gets the information in the public and they take positions. Wait, isn't that insider trading ... I guess the land of the free is not free for all. We all need to relax and see what this all proves and how much of it has lined the pocket of the Sebi Cheif before we make judgement on anyone.
Palki saying that Hindenburg's target is solely Adani and not India would have been believable the last time(despite the timing being a bit to coincidental & politically convenient for vested interests) , but concealing this SEBI "trump" card (probably another failed one)until this moment in time, is proof that the efforts are concerted, not entirely financial in nature & gives reason to immediately take note, protect, investigate & retaliate! Palki, ignoring red flags like this just brought Bangladesh to its knees, so please don't advise GOI on things you are not 100% sure about, its detrimental.
Jali na Jalil na Teri? Idk why report on Adani is attack on India. Adani is just a greedy guju, our nation has many industrialist he is not the only one. He is the only one that's completely depended on the government.
Who is Hindenburg for India? Why Ms Palki is sounding so indi side? Any one from outside India come and say something and you guys didn't even reaserch before reporting? Suprised.
Rahul thinking that involving outsiders in to the Indian matter and he will rule successfully then rahul is nothing short of a mad. You are done bro get married and get another piece like you otherwise khandan barbad ho jayega . 👍
I don't understand one thing like why we guys accuse someone of doing something like adani & SEBI chief of not taking actions and also Hindenburg of haven their own personal interest . Shouldn't an investigation be done and the truth must come out . A tight slap for the one lying here
I am a simple person. When pappu says something i believe the opposite. Example: i am hindu. I belive his sunnath is done when Mr Ganddi (indiras husband) was alive.
@@Tup7kSh7kurI am pretty sure Pappu has no idea either. Otherwise he wouldn't have earned 56 lakh off the same market he was advising retail investors to pull money from. The trick didn't work this time. Your WhatsApp University rhetoric fell flat.
@@Tup7kSh7kur Seems you could comprehend the Hindenburg report? Care to explain in simple terms on what does it actually allege? And what illegality/collusion/scam/crime it accuses of? Looking forward to your explanation.
Why we focus on short selling, check if the allegation is true or not ... We should check & report is correct, if our system is manipulated or not ... Hindenburg is not doing charity, they need lot of money to research, find the fact & publish
I don't understand indian. They seems to lack critical thinking. Once they believe in something, they will never question its authenticity. If s.o tries to point out something, they will never try to dive deeper into the issue. They will become defensive immediately. AND what they defend is not even related to them. I guess that why they worshipped everything there
Since all of the investigative agencies are under the boot of bjp's supreme shri and therefore biased, we must be thankful to hindenburg types for exposing supreme shri & co.
SEBI chief to b sent out. She shd b beyond suspicion. If Nirmala support , she shd b terminated from post. The so called honest lady FM honesty is doubtful
As long as a Thief-turned-Chowkidar is at the helm of affairs and as long as the boot-licking media and the investigative and enforcement agencies turn their blind eyes to these fraudsters, Adani is safe, whatever the findings of the Hindenburg. Any roof-top shoutings of the opposition will not be heard either by the Chowkidar or by the President or by the speakers of the Lokasabha and Rajyasabha. Efforts to cover up of this scandal have already begun...
Hindenberg being a short seller (which they openly admit)has a high reputation of being transparent and trustworthy. You like it or not, every investigation they have done in US is very thorough and reliable. If they say a fraud is going on, you better believe it.
Then why Hindenberg remained silent when Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) was about to collapse? The SVB collapsed and with that Hindenberg's credibility was tossed into the dustbin. If I am to be believed then I will state that all the short-sellers are blackmailers and dubious entities/ guys who attempt top profit at the expense of retail investors. But every time they will not succeed. A liar will not be believed at all times. Hope you know the Aesop's Fable with that ending.
"If SEBI chairperson didn't disclose this investment while investigating Adani Group earlier, that's conflict of interest." Then again, what do you expect? People who invested on 4th-June-2024, on elections results, in Mutual Funds got the NAV of 5th-June-2024. This is 5% loss in less than 24 hours. (enough media reports are out there.) To put this in context, interest on savings bank account is around 3% (pre-tax) and it is close post tax return of FD in high interest environment. And you know who was the guilty? No one. In a system like ours, you are bound to loose the faith eventually, and consider yourself lucky whenever you are not caught in such incidents.
If some foreign media saying Modi’s number one all media, highlighting the point at the same time, somebody criticise highlighting some mistakes, everyone against foreign media. What a nonsense
I told a friend of mine when Adani issue prpped up and parliament was rocked on the issue and the CJI appointment of 5 member committee about SeBi matter on Adani ( all are corporate coolies),I told my friends to buy Adani shares when they were down. Later when SC gave clean chit to SeBi adani shares zoomed. You know Adani Modi connection and the power of Modi. So the best way to make money is like what i told instrad wasting time talking about corruption, corrupt people.
Shady and inappropriate way for a SEBI chief while millions of Indians pay short term and long term capital gain. Shame on Madhabi Buch and Government for bootlicking adani. Period.
It's not finding irregularities in any country, adani isn't india and Heidelberg has tried to shortsell Elon Musk as well , and other American companies. You should be angry at how adani enterprises are inflating shares,not at hindenberg
I see a lot of difference in the way of your narrative. You started sounding more like other news channels, who get their funding from...?!? Now does News channels have responsibility to show their funds, sources, agenda, etc. It would be interesting to know this, as well...
It’s good that our market didn’t crash. But ignoring this serious allegation is not wise. But who will investigate? This is classic movie “jaane bi dho yaaron “ in execution 🙊🙉🙈
SEBI was too busy screwing up retail investors with their KYC, aadhar,and PAN linking,registerings,verifications and changing rules every now and then and even freezing accounts of small retail investors.
Any serious true commitment to prevent corruption should ban any routed 'funds' from any tax haven, tax haven=blood money laundering center. So any fund from such 'havens' should be send to hell of jail.
Very balanced approach. The chairman should have disclosed potential conflicts of interest last year. Btw Mayawati of all people has also made a very balanced approach-- she has not called for resignation but an inquiry
The people abusing the report perhaps have bank accounts in Mauritius. Those who don't have bank accounts in some tax-havens and investments in shell companies, would be sensible enough to ask questions such as why such fishy transactions by SEBI chief? Why no disclosures to Supreme Court about these investments in shell companies which are under investigation by SEBI itself? How much did the husband's firm benefit from REIT rule changes by the SEBI? Who were the clients of their advisory firms and did they benefit from SEBI rules? There were previous allegations on SEBI chief regarding Kotak and ICICI Securities which may also be probed to restore trust in SEBI.
Hindenburg tried to attack Adani again. Last time they did Adani came out strong with strong balance sheet, reduce debt and now they are focusing on what they are good at with alot of investments from sovereign wealth funds from gulf.
Corruption is always Corruption. Don't deviate who found or report. fight against Corruption is top priority for india. i know is it not easy but we can control it...
