Тёмный

History Briefs: Field Marshal Bill Slim 

Great Stories from the Past
Подписаться 8 тыс.
Просмотров 105 тыс.
50% 1

British Field Marshal Bill Slim was an outstanding General and, arguably, Britain’s finest army commander of the Second World War. Today he is often compared to the American General, George Patton.
He is best remembered as the commander of the British 14th Army, the so-called Forgotten Army. In similar manner Bill Slim was also a, somewhat, forgotten General during the Second World War and, as such, he never received the credit or notoriety that he deserved.
Commanding the British 14th Army, he defeated the Japanese at the Battle of Imphal and Kohima before leading that army in the re-conquest of Burma. The Battle of Imphal and Kohima is today considered by the National Army Museum in London as being Britain’s finest land victory in history.
Slim would end his military career as Head of the British army and so became and first and only Indian Army Officer to hold this prestigious post.
What makes Slim even more extraordinary is that he never came from the traditional officer class of the British army during the early 20th century.
Having been brought up in poverty in Birmingham, he joined the army at the outbreak of the First World War gaining a temporary commission.
In this story we tell, not just of his great battles but also of his rise to the top of the army. And of how other, less talented Generals who considered him to be “different”, attempted to side-line him often to their own detriment.
This video forms part of the History Briefs series from "Great Stories from the Past" which is designed to provide a quick yet reasonably detailed overview of famous and renowned people in history.
Keep up to date with the latest news and information from Great Stories from the Past by visiting us on twitter:
/ greatstoriesnow

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 769   
@markl4670
@markl4670 3 месяца назад
My Father met Bill Slim after the War, when he was Deputy Chairman of British Rail. My Father was invited to his office in London for a chat. My Fathers Brother had served in the Chindits and was killed in action in 1944, his body was never recovered. My Father said that they discussed his Brother at great length and that Field Marshall Slim showed great empathy and sadness for my Fathers loss. He was a hero to my father.
@user-zs5nr8dd1z
@user-zs5nr8dd1z 9 месяцев назад
Believe me comparing Bill Slim to Patton is NOT a complimentary comparison at all. Patton was a wastrel with his men's lives and with materiel. Bill husbanded his men's lives and materiel.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
To be honest I don't know enough about Patton to make a genuine assessment. From remarks being made in these comments we may take a closer look at Patton on this channel to see whether his reputation owes more to Hollywood than the battlefield. However, the point in this video that is being made about Slim and Patton is not that they were similar as Generals but that they were similar to the extent that neither followed the norm of their fellow commanders in their respective services. Thanks for watching. I hope you enjoyed the video.
@terryfoyfoy7926
@terryfoyfoy7926 9 месяцев назад
Wastrel he was a nothing
@rahulingle8806
@rahulingle8806 9 месяцев назад
👍
@jamespickering2982
@jamespickering2982 9 месяцев назад
My father was general slims driver he also attended my christening my father and mother both stated he was a absolute officer and gentleman.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Lovely comment. Thanks for sharing.
@jackieking1522
@jackieking1522 9 месяцев назад
Tomorrow I'll visit my dying friend whose wife's father was Freyberg's tank driver. Wee world. My dad thought the Sun shone from Bill Slim, not least because he ( me dad) once had to fly some SEATO brass "home" for tea before taking some badly wounded troopers to hospital. That would not have happened with Slim.
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 8 месяцев назад
Slim abused children.
@murraybrown1711
@murraybrown1711 6 месяцев назад
Dad after flying spits in 681 squadron volunteered for 221 Group and flew Slim on a rece in a L5 light observer plane up to the Irrawaddy river before the push onto Mandalay, couldn't speak more highly of the man, one of his most proudest moments of the war he said.
@StevenKeery
@StevenKeery 9 месяцев назад
Interesting story, he was quite a leader. A shame he and the 14th Army are not better known, their exploits deserve more recognition.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
I entirely agree. Thanks for your comments.
@nigelbarker8726
@nigelbarker8726 9 месяцев назад
My dad met Bill Slim. He was in the Signals and was sent to replace the General's broken phone. Slim asked him how he was doing.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 8 месяцев назад
Great story. Thanks for sharing.
@davidharris4062
@davidharris4062 9 месяцев назад
What a man, knew what it was like not to be brought up with a silver spoon in his mouth, so could know what the conditions his men lived under back home, someone like this, along with his me can be and were Heroes, history like this should be taught in schools, utmost respect for ‘Uncle Bill’ and the Forgotten XIV
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Even though he came from an impoverished family, he was both intelligent and well educated which was important in his career. He shoukd bevused in schools as a fine example of what can be achieved. Thanks for watching.
@davidsweeney4021
@davidsweeney4021 9 месяцев назад
I'm a Brummie like Sir Bill, I believe he was doing a Technical course at the University of Birmingham before WWI but "snook" into the officers course as the war (WWI) started which he was not allowed to join according to the stupid rules. So he was always clever
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
@davidsweeney4021 Essentially, you are correct. He was clearly brilliant at beating the system of those days. I find it fascinating that Generals Irwin and Leese both tried to conspire against him. Both got sacked as a result, and on each occasion, Slim was promoted to their jobs!
@clivestainlesssteelwomble7665
@clivestainlesssteelwomble7665 9 месяцев назад
I grew up and live in walking distance of a house on the Birmingham Smethwick border that carries a Blue 🔵 plaque commemorating that the house was once home to this man and his work with the Chindits in defeating the Japanese and keeping them out of India. Then pushing them back. Birmingham was also the starting place for the ideas and research that began the development of what became the Atomic bomb project. The same Scientists joining Oppenheimer's team..
@alganhar1
@alganhar1 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933 He was also far from the only British Officer who came from an impoverished background, indeed by mid WWI most field officers were at best middle class, often lower. I think the most illuminating is one particular officer, the Chief of the Imperial General Staff from 1916 - 1918, a Gentleman by the name of William Robertson. He was most assuredly lower class, and is the ONLY soldier in the history of the British Army to rise from Private to Field Marshal. This idea that all British Officers were upper class twits is really a myth that needs to be properly crushed, because it is largely false, at least in the last 100 or so years. Another myth was that these guys were old. In 1918 of the Divisional Commanders in 1918, 82% were under 50, 37% were under 45, and 15% were under 40....
@BillHalliwell
@BillHalliwell 9 месяцев назад
Thank you for this engrossing history of Viscount Slim. I was a young Australian boy when William Slim became the Governor General of Australia. Despite minor controversies, usually blown out of proportion by the press, I can well remember the fondness average Australians felt for their distinguished and heroic G.G. My father purchased his books and I can remember reading them and still being impressed even if my understanding of all the issues were not complete. In fact, it was my 'study' of William Slim's books that first gave me a taste for military history. This desire was enforced by my short service in the RAAF. Many years later as a mature-age university student, while a working journalist, I set out to become a military historian when my time on the newspapers finished. Thanks, originally, to Viscount Slim's adventures in Burma, I've now studied military history for over 16 years. Interestingly, much of my time in those years has been on the detailed research of a man I like to call the 'Australian equivalent of General Slim'; the similarities between these two great soldiers is unusual if not uncanny. Australia's only Field Marshal, Sir Thomas Albert Blamey, was born to a poor Drover's family in outback NSW, near Wagga Wagga, in 1884. Out of school young Tom Blamey toyed with the idea of taking to the clergy for a time then became a teacher. He joined the Australian Army just in time to be sent to the Staff College in Quetta and to see the start of The Great War, serving initially as an Intelligence Officer. Tom was chosen to be the Chief of Staff to Australia's O.C., General Sir John Monash, for most of WW1. Monash repeatedly wrote, and declared publicly, that without the astounding planning skills of, then Major Blamey, the significant Australian victories on the Western Front, especially at Amiens, would not have been possible; instead of claiming all the accolades for himself. Once, perhaps, better known to the likes of Churchill, Wavell and Montgomery etc., during the first half of WW2, General Blamey, although known and, oddly controversial, in Australia for a time; he was almost totally forgotten a mere handful of years post-war; then he died, prematurely, in 1951. His early death, soon consigning his memory to old Army veterans and, later, to historians, myself included. Prior to this, at the last possible opportunity, Field Marshal Sir Thomas Blamey was honoured by the largest funeral, of any kind, ever witnessed in Australia, to this very day. Yet, once again, his name swiftly faded in the Australian consciousness. The Australian Army recruit establishment was, decades later, named 'Blamey Barracks' and there is a statue of Blamey in the gardens of Melbourne's 'Shrine of Remembrance'; Melbourne being Blamey's long-time 'second home'. My final, direct memory of Viscount Field Marshal William Slim was the genuine and widespread sorrow, in Australia, when he passed away in 1970. Once again, thanks for this excellent video. Cheers, Bill. H.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments. We have a long list of interesting military characters that we are working on and that list includes the Australians FM Blamey and General Morshead. If you can think of any others please let us know.
@kparker2430
@kparker2430 9 месяцев назад
Tom Blamey - australian, proud.
@ekting48
@ekting48 9 месяцев назад
Morshead deserves some more credit for Africa in my opinion. While not a victory, he and the aussies held Tobruk for a long time. @@GreatStoriesNow933
@ianlowcock6913
@ianlowcock6913 9 месяцев назад
Blamey was a crook who robbed the men of their beer ration, took bribes from the Egyptian suppliers of blue movies, and joined Dug out Douggie in berating our militia men for fighting that awesome withdrawal along the Kokoda Trail. Their parade was shameful, with those two never was beens abusing genuine heroes.
@BillHalliwell
@BillHalliwell 9 месяцев назад
@@ianlowcock6913 G'day Ian, 15 years ago I thought like you do now. You couldn't be more wrong. Sitting in the archives of the AWM are documents (about 1500+ of them) that, from multiple sources, and since corroborated, prove TAB (Thomas Albert Blamey) was not involved in any of those activities. We have original copies of those documents and the archivists at the AWM proved to us that these files had never been accessed by anyone doing research on the many books and publications that have given TAB a good old kicking. The 'old man' was so honest he made enemies in high places. Rupert Murdoch's father was one of them. He, and others, including the - self-confessed - antisemite, C.E.W. Bean, set out on a none too secret campaign to take down TAB's reputation. This was carried on in modern times by 'cowards' who attacked him, and his widow, Olga, after TAB died. My research partner and I began the study of TAB with totally open minds. Indeed, Prof. David Horner (ex-Army), commissioned to write the official history of TAB, is on the record with his opinion that we found out more about TAB than anyone else, because we and our assistant researchers bothered to simply look at those files. Several recent authors have continued to kick TAB's life and career. Fitzsimons is among their number. We are not attacking those writers; we're simply saying that they 'drank the Cool Aid' that was that started to be made as far back as TAB's days as Victorian Police Commissioner. The documents we have will be publicly available on our website after we have released a book and our 3-hour documentary on TAB. This, I hasten to add, will not be for personal profit. We have expended over $60K of our own funds, over the years, and there's no way we'll be recouping that. We are simply trying to right one of Australia's military history's greatest injustices. If you, Ian, or anyone else, can produce documentary and witness record evidence that TAB was 'who you think he was' then you can send that info to us. That really would be 'impressive'. Cheers, Bill Halliwell & Bernie McDonald, et al.
@CoolestDude38NC
@CoolestDude38NC 9 месяцев назад
I am an American. I read Slim's book, "Defeat Into Victory" several decades ago. I found it to be a good book. Inspiring, Slim lays out his thoughts on elite units in armies, based on firsthand experience commanding such units. Slim mentions he believed most elite units are a waste of money and manpower and drain off the best men into small units that get misused and nobody knows how to use them properly. However, Slim says in his book there is one kind of elite unit he believed was useful and it was one along the lines of the SAS...a unit that operates DEEP behind enemy lines targeting strategic targets and operated directly under the high command. I recommend Slim's book to anyone interested in military strategy. It is a unique book and written from a British Army perspective.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Remarks about Slim's views on elite units are gaining much traction amongst these comments especially with regard to the Chindits. Very interesting what you say. Thanks for watching.
@CoolestDude38NC
@CoolestDude38NC 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933 I don't know a huge amount about the Chindits. I remember from my youth here in America watching a few TV documentaries about the Chindits. I remember they were basically the British equivalent to America's Merrill's Marauders. Larger force light infantry who specialized in deep penetration operations behind Japanese lines in the jungles of Burma. I remember the Chindits got chewed up pretty badly...it was an all volunteer outfit...correct? I also remember the Chindits were commanded by an officer named Orde Wingate...some considered him eccentric.
@voiceofraisin3778
@voiceofraisin3778 9 месяцев назад
@@CoolestDude38NC The man used to parade naked except for an alarm clock round his neck. He was far beyond eccentric. The problem with the troops in the far east was that they had been striped of decent officers to fight the Germans so when the Japanese attacked they had low tier command, second rate units and no clear plan, they got smashed. Then any attempts at offensives also got smashed becasue the Japanese were lighter and more flexible. The chindits showed that the Japanese could be beathen in the Jungle, that offensives worked and that instead of fighting heavy the British army could be light and flexible. Militarily they were limited, as a morale booster, proof of concept and training school for air supply and medevac they were priceless.
@thodan467
@thodan467 9 месяцев назад
Was that not Paras?
@ericfeatherstone
@ericfeatherstone 9 месяцев назад
@CoolestDude38NC Book recommendation: Quartered Safe Out Here, by George MacDonald Fraser (the author mentioned at the end of this video)
@dougmoore5252
@dougmoore5252 9 месяцев назад
The men were aware of how difficult it was to acquire supplies of any kind and realized of the efforts made to keep it coming. This attention to logistics was a critical part of his ability. He of course had many other abilities and his leadership was outstanding.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@carlosspiceyweiner3305
@carlosspiceyweiner3305 9 месяцев назад
He was by far the best general the British army had in WW2, he did the most incredible things on a shoe string. Montgomery couldn’t hold a candle this man’s skill.
@richardward2469
@richardward2469 9 месяцев назад
You might want to have a little look at a man named Bernard Freyberg.💖💖🎏☯️
@carlosspiceyweiner3305
@carlosspiceyweiner3305 9 месяцев назад
@@richardward2469 Freyberg was very good, but never commanded an army. He had a corp level command a couple of times, he is one of the reasons that people think Montgomery was so good.
@richardward2469
@richardward2469 9 месяцев назад
@@carlosspiceyweiner3305 100% but imagine if he did command an army. The war might’ve been over sooner.💖☯️🎏
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the suggestion.
@user-zs5nr8dd1z
@user-zs5nr8dd1z 9 месяцев назад
@@carlosspiceyweiner3305 Not sure why you would think that Freyberg was such a n influence on Montie's reputation. Monty made his own reputation and well deserved it was too. Freyburg was a good solid divisional commander and chosen by NZ to lead their troops because he was no Patton.
@EndingSimple
@EndingSimple 9 месяцев назад
"Looked like a private with general tabs." That sounds a lot like Ulysses S. Grant. Its great to finally know of a worthy general I hadn't know much about before.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your thoughts on that quote.
@wintkyaw7576
@wintkyaw7576 8 месяцев назад
As an Burmese officer in Myanmar Navy and an instructor of War History to the cadets at the Defence Serviced Academy , I have great respect to Gen. Slim. We study his book as a text and take his leadership skills and stratagies as the most brillient examples in the history of wars and very useful for Myanmar Army.
@johnphelps9788
@johnphelps9788 9 месяцев назад
I went to St Phillips Catholic Grammar School in Birmingham after passing the 11 plus in 1956. William Slim's name was prominent on the old boys honour roll. My parents emigrated to Australia 2 years later and on telling my form teacher that I was going to Australia he said you are following in the footsteps of William Slim who was by then Governor General of Australia. I never really knew much of his history so thankyou for posting his story.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
No surprise, he was acclaimed by your old school! It was in 1956 that his book was published and he became more famous. Glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for watching.
@davidsweeney4021
@davidsweeney4021 9 месяцев назад
John, That is brilliant
@stevethomas5849
@stevethomas5849 9 месяцев назад
Not bad for a lad for a Lad from Bishopston Bristol.
@johnphelps9788
@johnphelps9788 9 месяцев назад
@@stevethomas5849 how did he end up in Birmingham at an Edgbaston school?
@Daddyclive
@Daddyclive 9 месяцев назад
To compare Slim to the American General, George Patton is madness. Slim used his superior battlefield experience and intelligence. Patton, "old blood and guts" ruthlessly threw his troops to overcome the enemy. American troops called Patton "our blood and our guts."
@jontyc3479
@jontyc3479 9 месяцев назад
Well said I thought exactly the same.
@therealmrfishpaste
@therealmrfishpaste 9 месяцев назад
Patton relied on the fact that his troops were always better equipped and supplied than his enemy's...Slim, on the other hand, was victorious at the head of a woefully under-resources and under supplied army - Britain prioritised sending supplies to Russia ahead of sending supplies to the 14th Army
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
The comparison made between the two was that each of them fought "differently" in comparison to others in their respective armies. The comparison is not that Slim and Patton fought in the same way. British Generals are always likely to approach a battle or campaign completely differently to an American through, for no other good reason, a lack of resources.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 9 месяцев назад
@@therealmrfishpaste Yeah Slim had only 21,000 men to contend with 100,000 Japanese. Patton had 221,000 men vs 90,000 Germans.
@Liendoelcm
@Liendoelcm 9 месяцев назад
It had been agreed that the first to be defeated would be Germany and the Japanese would follow, hence the lack of supplies to Slim and the 14th Army until Germany's collapse. Slim concentrated on wrecking the Japanese supplies to their troops, doing a fantastic job with what he had.@@therealmrfishpaste
@chiron14pl
@chiron14pl 9 месяцев назад
As an American, I knew more about the central and south Pacific campaigns, but remember coverage of the Burma campaign on TV. This covered that but its focus on the man, Bill Slim, added an important perspective on both his leadership and the impact he had on the British military
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
We ought to also mention General Stilwell with his US/China army that was fighting to the north of Slim.
@stevethomas5849
@stevethomas5849 9 месяцев назад
He was humble never courted the the pomp of being a Field Marshal such as Monty. He was a Soldier that cared for his multinational multicultural army. He told his driver to give a lift to any Solider he would pass. A true gentleman.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
I don't disagree with what you say other that that Monty was not necessarily typical of all British Generals of the period. As always in life, there are good ones and there are not so good ones, whether as commanders, as leaders, and with regard to their inter-personnel skills.
@DanBeech-ht7sw
@DanBeech-ht7sw 9 месяцев назад
His multilingual, multicultural army was very reminiscent of Hannibal's, AND he used elephants
@Desertfox170
@Desertfox170 9 месяцев назад
Far better than Monty
@DanBeech-ht7sw
@DanBeech-ht7sw 9 месяцев назад
@@Desertfox170 well obviously Monty never tried elephants
@tonystewart7146
@tonystewart7146 9 месяцев назад
As an aside, I attended The Slim Boarding school in the Cameron Highlands of Malaya. My father and our family were in Malaya because my father was in the Australian Army stationed in Malaya. We lived in Penang. This School was Named after Field Marshal Bill Slim.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Nice story. Thanks for sharing.
@therealmrfishpaste
@therealmrfishpaste 9 месяцев назад
My great uncle flew for the SAAF during WW2 and immediately after the war had to ferry various generals around for their postwar conferences. Most of the generals came with large quantities of baggage in expensive suitcases, but my great-uncle recalled that all Slim ever took with him was a battered card-board suitcase with the name SLIM written across it in chalk.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Nice story. Thanks
@paulgreene8186
@paulgreene8186 9 месяцев назад
8
@dougmoore5252
@dougmoore5252 9 месяцев назад
He pushed for supplies for his men and they knew it and fought even harder as a result. Brilliant!
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Its an important part of leadership.
@adienowed6366
@adienowed6366 9 месяцев назад
Truly a great commander,but also an inspirational leader of men.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@catholiccrusader5328
@catholiccrusader5328 8 месяцев назад
I loved Slim's motto 'God helps those who help themselves.'
@anorthernsoul5600
@anorthernsoul5600 9 месяцев назад
I am of Rhodesian birth, so maybe can offer a unique viewpoint on both Uncle Bill Slim and Bernard Montgomery. I have two relatives that fought under each one. My own Uncle Bill who was in S1 and S2 patrols of the LRDG, he was wounded during Operation Compass in North Africa. Whilst recuperating he heard of recruitment into a unit that a couple of his Rhodesian mates were joining. So once discharged he joined and was accepted. He was a farmer, as a lot of Rhodies were and could pretty much repair anything in the field. A valuable skillset to have in the LRDG. He wasn't too sure about Monty when he took over, he actually met the bloke, a skinny short chap with linnet legs and a squeaky voice was my Uncle's immediate impression. But Monty was the best thing that had happened to the British, Commonwealth, French, Polish forces (sorry if I missed anyone out) in that theatre. He gave a speech to all units that there's not to be any more retreating from Rommel and the Nazi/Italian forces, but what is little known is that he demanded that all troops to be given at least one hot meal per day of good decent fare. No general had done that yet for the Allied troops. To have hot showers once per week minimum and plenty of fresh drinking water. Regular weekend leave in Alexandria and Cairo, especially Cairo which was highly prized. Montgomery had the nick name not very well known, "The Spartan General" because he had the bare necessities and ate the same rations as the soldiers did under his command. A bog basic bunk same as the squaddies to kip in. No chandeliers, champagne, and caviar unlike Mark Clark and Eisenhower. My other relative was Uncle George on my mum's side, we all had British ancestry, he was a Lancashire lad from Wigan. He joined the Lancashire Fusiliers and was sent to India then onto Burma. All they did was retreat with Japanese always a step ahead of them in going through the jungle and setting up roadblocks behind them that they had to fight through losing many troops whilst doing so. As depicted in this video. This all stopped when Bill Slim took over, he put a halt to defeatist talk, he immediately ensured that the troops under his command were well catered and cared for. Same as Monty, the best food available and hot showers whenever possible. He addressed all officers saying that if they were not willing to do what every soldier under their command is ordered to do, then he will break those officers in front of their men. Now that is a commander. As Bill Slim later recalled in his memoirs, “In 1943 for every man evacuated with wounds, we had 120 evacuated sick. The annual malaria rate alone was 84 percent per annum of the total strength of the Army, and was still higher among the forward troops. A similar calculation showed me that in a matter of months, at this rate, my army would have melted away.” Lieutenant General Slim saw correctly that more than half the battle against disease is fought not by doctors but by regimental officers. Those in direct, regular contact with the troops are best placed to ensure that personal anti-mosquito measures are observed and that daily doses of anti-malarial drug Mepacrine are taken. General Slim initiated surprise checks in which every man in the unit was examined. If men had not taken the drug, and if the overall results of blood tests for the medication within the unit were less than 95 percent positive, Slim “sacked the commander. I only had to sack three; by then the rest had got my meaning.” Because of this emphasis from the top. Monty was a prima donna, and courted publicity without a doubt, he was also an insufferable pain in the arse, but he looked after the soldiers under his command whenever possible. Not neglecting that they had a job to which is always difficult in war because you will suffer heavy casualties at some point. Uncle Bill Slim was all the of the above without the ego of Monty, and carried out incredible feats without the resources Monty had. For myself, the finest General the Allies had during WWII. Both my Uncles were lucky enough to survive the war. Bill went back to the family farm In Lubimbi in West Rhodesia/Zimbabwe pretty much unscathed physically and mentally. Uncle George along with the rest of 1st Bn Lancashire Fusiliers joined the Chindits in 1943 along with the 77th Indian Infantry Brigade. He was casevac'd after the Chindits had taken Mogaung with shrapnel wounds and a broken leg from a mortar round. His war was over. Mogaung was made famous because Joe "Vinegar" Stilwell had informed the media that "Chinese and American forces have taken Mogaung". Mad Mike Calvert who had taken command of the Chindits after Wingate's death replied - “The Chinese-American forces having taken Mogaung, 77th Indian Infantry Brigade is proceeding to take umbrage.” This is said to have prompted Stilwell’s staff to search in vain for “Umbrage” on their maps. Maybe Mad Mike Calvert would be an interesting topic for a future video? His career did not end with WWII.
@crouqetoo2
@crouqetoo2 9 месяцев назад
I have just taken possession of his book,"Prisoners of Hope", it's still to be read,I have read numerous books on the Burma capmpaign. "The Road Past Mandalay", by John Masters. Of all, yes all the commanders I have read about,in the Burma campaign, I would have been proud to have been able to say that I served with this man,John Masters.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thank you for your wonderful contribution to the comments on this video. There is little that I can add except, perhaps, your point on officers being expected to do what their soldiers did and ensuring their troops health. Writing as a former British Army officer, these principles were really drilled into us probably, I suspect, as a result of the influence of both Slim and Monty. Indeed, albeit many years ago now, all potential officers for the regiment in which I served had to undertake recruit training before being sponsored to Sandhurst. The idea that officers have a cushy time in comparison to squaddies has not, in general, been reality in the British Army since the First World War. Thank you also for your suggestion about Mike Calvert. We have a number of requests to do something on the Chindits so we will definitely look at that and I may well use you quote about taking umbrage!!
@crouqetoo2
@crouqetoo2 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933 you have credited me with the Mike Calvert quote , when in fact it was Northernsoul5600.However, I was aware of this fact from one or another of the Burma ww2 books I have read. I should mention amongst many other things that Mike Calvert is credited with.He commanded the 77thDiv on op Thursday,2nd. Chindit incursion.When Stillwell demanded he attack and take the Burmese/ Japanese village that Stillwell later announced had been taken by the Chinese/American forces, this caused the remark , made by Calvert that his unit had taken Umbrage.There are so many leaders in the Buma ww2 campaign that deserve their stories be told.Mike Calvert is but one of them. I also served from 58 to 81 as an OR in the Argylls.Then from 81 to 99 as a cqms in the Black Watch TA unit
@carrickrichards2457
@carrickrichards2457 9 месяцев назад
The forgotten 14th: "When You Go Home, Tell Them Of Us And Say, For Your Tomorrow, We Gave Our Today". (Kohima Military Cemetery Memorial). Thank you for this wonderful summary.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments. Glad you enjoyed it.
@brettcurtis5710
@brettcurtis5710 9 месяцев назад
George Macdonald Fraser's Quartered Safe Out Here is perhaps the finest "From the Foxhole" account of the Burma Campaign - a must-read - you won't regret it!
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Really good suggestion.
@davidbundred1721
@davidbundred1721 9 месяцев назад
Agreed. Captured both the terror and humour/comradeship of jungle warfare. I am still laughing at him being hung upside down in the well, I think to retrieve a hat whilst remembering the jap who emerged naked from the cave intent in killing him
@johnford6967
@johnford6967 9 месяцев назад
He came to our Regiment (First Welsh Guards) stationed at Windsor Castle in the late 1960s to give a talk. Read the book Defeat in to Victory.This man is one of greatest generals The british ever had...
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Agreed. Nice to hear from the Welsh Guards.
@davidsauls9542
@davidsauls9542 9 месяцев назад
What a fine example that doing what is best for your men, will lead to victory. He thought of the big picture, then made sure all the needed parts were there, the basic things others dismissed. When he moved his headquarters out of the administrative building and near his troops, he also established hospitals and malaria care centers as near them as possible. This kept the men in the field and gave them fast relief of their medical issues. He did what he could for his men and they knew it. What a stark contrast to the many generals that were distracted by self promotion.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments.
@Mathemagical55
@Mathemagical55 9 месяцев назад
Montgomery protested to Clement Attlee over Slim's appointment saying that he'd already told Crocker that the job was his. Attlee's reply: "Well untell him."
@41divad
@41divad 9 месяцев назад
Excellent. Another finger in Montgomery's eye
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 9 месяцев назад
Attlee caused the deaths of many British civilians via "Sidney Stanley".
@janlindtner305
@janlindtner305 9 месяцев назад
A well-deserved epic for a great warrior, a man who was in harmony with his subordinates who must have admired him, I would have given my best anyway, my portrayal of a leader. Excellent lecture.👍👍👍
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching.
@iangrimwood3345
@iangrimwood3345 9 месяцев назад
My grandad served under him in Burma. Said everyone liked him!
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Uncle Bill!
@andrewbantick6311
@andrewbantick6311 9 месяцев назад
Same
@MotionMcAnixx
@MotionMcAnixx 9 месяцев назад
As a kid I always thought he was an Aussie. I mean - Bill Slim just sounds so Australian. He became one of our Governer Generals too.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
He was certainly an Honorary Aussie
@nilsbrown7996
@nilsbrown7996 8 месяцев назад
At Remembrance Day this year there was an incident where an Asian man with an old Hong Kong flag with the Union Jack in it got very very upset with a protester (free Gaza). It was a huge reminder of the contributions in that theatre against a vicious form of empire in Hirohito’s Japanese aggression. They haven’t forgotten.
@lambertodgr8
@lambertodgr8 9 месяцев назад
When I worked for. him he was sir William slim Governor General of Australia A gentleman .he was a great man an appreciative employer Lady Slim treated me like I was her own son I have very fond memories of my time at government house .
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 9 месяцев назад
He raped and sexually abused children in Australia.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks, nice post!
@nickjung7394
@nickjung7394 9 месяцев назад
Fortunately we have had such men come to leadership roles at the right time. It is not luck but the competence of those in overall control who have the ability to recognise real talent! Looking at the quality of our MPs, civil servants and military leaders, i have no confidence over the future security of our country!
@davidevans3498
@davidevans3498 9 месяцев назад
So true
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@philhawley1219
@philhawley1219 9 месяцев назад
The powers that be today are hell bent on running Britain into the ground. We need a peaceful revolution now. If that doesn't work it will have to turn nasty.
@tonyb2614
@tonyb2614 9 месяцев назад
He was my Father's CO in Burma and God Father to my big Sister.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Wow!
@johnschuh8616
@johnschuh8616 9 месяцев назад
What an honor.
@dougmoore5252
@dougmoore5252 9 месяцев назад
I am amazed that people don’t know him better. I guess that they are speaking about the British public. As an American I hope that we appreciate this fine man and his successful ways.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@caloricphlogistonandthelum4008
@caloricphlogistonandthelum4008 9 месяцев назад
Slim and Alexander, the two best commanders in... the whole of the second World war! Thanks for this.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@iankingsleys2818
@iankingsleys2818 9 месяцев назад
Alexander was good but at times was lazy
@user-fb8ez7nb4m
@user-fb8ez7nb4m 9 месяцев назад
Field Marshal Bill Slim gave a speech at Scots College in Sydney, when I was a student. I will never forget his address to the boys, or the praise that he gave to the turnout of the Scots College navy, army and air force cadets and the Scots College pipe band, who he stated were the as good if not better than any unit that he had commanded. His parting message to us that day was... OWN UP, PAY Up and SHUT UP... a message I have passed on to my son.
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 9 месяцев назад
Slim raped and sexually abused many children in Australia.
@dougmoore5252
@dougmoore5252 9 месяцев назад
Slim is my favorite British General in 20 Century.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Couldn't possibly argue with that! Thanks for watching.
@davey7452
@davey7452 9 месяцев назад
Interesting footnote Bill Slims time as Governor General in Australia was so successful when his tenure ended the Austrian government honoured him with an Australian passport and and an Australian generals pension something never done before or since.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@davidparris7167
@davidparris7167 9 месяцев назад
Why and how would the Austrian government issue Slim with an Australian passport and pension? Sounds absurd.
@davey7452
@davey7452 9 месяцев назад
@@davidparris7167 read his biography it’s fascinating his happen about 60 years ago you have very cynical view about human nature before making a general conclusion verify the facts first.
@davidparris7167
@davidparris7167 9 месяцев назад
@@davey7452 But, I repeat, why is the Austrian government, A European country, involved in issuing an Australian passport and pension to British subject? And What's with my cynical view of human nature? You are obviously not particularly bright.
@davey7452
@davey7452 9 месяцев назад
@@davidparris7167 I'm talking about AUSTRALIA not Austria this country is in the southerh hemisphere and is part of the British Commonwealth not the one in Europe at the time British generals were sent to the commonwealth countries as Governor Generals, the representatives in that countries parliment to represent the queen of England in the local national government.
@kparker2430
@kparker2430 9 месяцев назад
Salute that hero. There is your role model for the young and lost generations. What a man.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@dionysusrex9183
@dionysusrex9183 9 месяцев назад
He was also a pedo. What a man indeed.
@Liendoelcm
@Liendoelcm 9 месяцев назад
Quite simply the best memoir I have ever read. Slim was a genius, who had nothing, was given nothing, took over a retreating army, and ended up hammering and destroying his enemy. Against Slim, the Japanese forces simply evaporated until there was no punch left in them and they just stopped fighting. Read Slim's story and learn why he was the soldier's soldier.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the suggestion
@gar6446
@gar6446 9 месяцев назад
"Defeat into Victory" Simply one of the finest biographies. The Monty Memoirs was just volumous self agrandising drivel, and if anything diminished his reputation imo. But the venomous competitive enviroment of the US military really caused much of this. The British being a small army had for centuries worked with allies to achieve goals for centuries. The US continental army didn't, fiercely independent in a culture of competitive rivalry, they sometimes seem to hate rival services more than the actual enemy. Even today the Brits find the US Marines easier to work with than the Army. Special Forces are a whole different thing.
@tylerstamps2786
@tylerstamps2786 9 месяцев назад
“Britain’s greatest battle “ wow that is a bold statement. Very much enjoyed the doc, thx for posting.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for watching.
@dougmoore5252
@dougmoore5252 9 месяцев назад
I read Defeat into Victory when a young man and never forgot it. Have thought about him periodically.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for all your comments.
@williammorris584
@williammorris584 9 месяцев назад
Defeat Into Victory is one of the best and most self-effacing military memoirs I’ve read. Slim is as critical of himself as he is complimentary of his troops. For all that, he was unable to obscure his greatness. Twice other generals of the old boy network tried to sack him and got hoist by their own petard. In fairness, both (Irwin and Leese) were able men, but underestimated Slim’s ability, accomplishments, and sharp elbows.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
You summarise the situation very nicely. Your comments reminded me of the thought that the cream coming to the top but then I remembered an anecdote about Mountbatten. When his ship HMS Kelly was torpedoed in the North Sea, he jumped overboard and when he came up to the surface he found himself next to the chief stoker who apparently said to him, "Its amazing, Sir, how the scum always comes to he surface!" Thanks for watching. Hope you enjoyed the video.
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 9 месяцев назад
Slim was a paedophile.
@alantoon5708
@alantoon5708 9 месяцев назад
It is past time for this great man and leader to obtain his just recognition. He delivered results when others did not.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Totally agree. Thanks for watching.
@hojoinhisarcher
@hojoinhisarcher 9 месяцев назад
Good Vid. I met, as a quite young man ,an old Brit, a contractor building wharves in 1970 whilst working construction in Victoria B.C.He was a crusty, reclusive sort of character of few words who mentioned one day at a lunch break he had fought at Kohima.I kept up with him for a few years until he died, but I never worked for him again as his style was micromanagement and bending beneath a barely repressed rage.On occasion,at times anyways...I wan't having any of it, but I did respect him,and that surprised him. I had of course never heard of Kohima and it as was only slightly referred to in a general history of the war,when I was ,years later taking a military history course, We live and learn.
@BeardedChieftain
@BeardedChieftain 9 месяцев назад
He was so admired by Australians that as his stint as Governor General came to an end, the people of Australia petitioned Her Majesty to retain him as GG and thus he did two stints as GG of Australia. My favourite quote? I have a few from this great leader so let's start with: "Nothing is so good for the morale of the troops as occasionally to see a dead general". William Slim, 1st Viscount Slim
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Love the quote. Thanks
@BeardedChieftain
@BeardedChieftain 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933 No Problem. Sir William Slim is also considered the father of modern Infantry patrolling doctrine, especially within the Commonwealth. He has quiet a lot of notable quotes, but like all good military leaders, he kept his orders brief. He said "Patrol, patrol patrol. Then patrol some more" or something very close to that. I do not have my Aide Memoir for section commanders close at hand to copy that quote from. I wrote it inside the cover many many years ago. Viscount Slim, like Earl Wavell is a God amongst the Infantry...well at least the well educated amongst our ranks ;)
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
@BeardedChieftain As a former infantryman, my opinion is that the importance of patrolling cannot be over emphasised
@sparkyfromel
@sparkyfromel 9 месяцев назад
Slim was the only British commander the Australians had time for , one of the reason he was made Governor general of Australia after the war during the war a young soldier called to him .. "Sir , we'll follows you anywhere" to witch he answered .."son , wherever we go , I'll be far behind ! "
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the quote. I've not come across that one. But here is a quote that I did find, made by Slim about Australian troops: "Australian troops had, at Milne Bay, inflicted on the Japanese their first undoubted defeat on land. Some of us may forget that, of all the allies, it was the Australians who first broke the invincibility of the Japanese army." Thanks for watching. I hope you enjoyed the video.
@a3rtj
@a3rtj 9 месяцев назад
Great biography of a great leader. My dad signed up in 1939 at the age 18 and fought in the North Africa campaign fighting at Tobruk and El Alamein with the 8th army. After this campaign he was shipped out to India and fought in Burma. He had served under Montgomery who he had little regard for, but always spoke with the highest regard and respect for "Bill Slim" and I remember as a child him sharing a few stories and photos of his time in Burma which despite the circumstances was a country he always wished to return to. Watching this video of the great man and the conditions they fought in brought a tear to my eye and how this generation lived and died, true heroes. THANK YOU !
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thank you very much for your post! Tobruk, Alamein and Burma - that is truly some war record. I understand entirely where you are coming from and I feel it is so important to understand what that generation went through before it is all lost. My father fought under Montgomery, then Clark but far preferred Alexander. Thanks again, glad you enjoyed it.
@JojoBoy-gh4gb
@JojoBoy-gh4gb 9 месяцев назад
The British Japanese clash in Imphal is often refereed to as the “Stalingrad of the east” , a brutal battle full of savagery, hand to hand combat extremely primal, a fight to the finish in the Japanese bushido style of fighting . Japanese General Mutaguchi foolishly decided to not use his Nakajima bombers parked in Singapore . The battle recorded the second highest casualties in WW2 after Stalingrad . Even today the few survivors that live today from Nagaland and Manipur get tremors when recounting that battle and require to be pacified with opium due to severe anxiety attacks .
@shumyinghon
@shumyinghon 9 месяцев назад
all that Slim did to retrain the British army are the very things that would have enabled them to fight the Japanese effectively in Malaya in 1942. Their inability to live, fight in the jungle coupled with a 'fortress mentality' caused them Singapore and tens of thousands captured. The re-trained British soldiers finally proved their mettle in Imphal and Kohima. it deservedly be placed above the battles in europe in significance.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Malaya and Singapore was a fine example by the British of how not to run a campaign. Everything that could went wrong; the list is endless! To top it, the command structure was weak and the senior officers were second-rate. In my opinion, Dill's appointment of Perceval - one of his favourite staff officers - to command an army without sufficient experience as a Commander was one of the worst appointments of the war.
@Kysushanz
@Kysushanz 8 месяцев назад
Many years ago, as a young 2/Lt I read "Defeat Into Victory" and was so impressed that I made it my hand-book for Officer studies. There were two Generals I admired in WWII - Slim and Rommel, for different reasons. But ask me to make my pick - definitely Slim! I did some time in Malaya and really appreciated the situations Slim found himself and men in; just made me all the more admiring of his achievements. Hugely under-rated general.
@williammacalevey4625
@williammacalevey4625 9 месяцев назад
My father's boss was Bill Slim and is mentioned in his book Defeat into Victory. They were good friends too.
@joannicholson3051
@joannicholson3051 9 месяцев назад
so proud
@kesfitzgerald1084
@kesfitzgerald1084 9 месяцев назад
Not just a great soldier but also a great man.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching
@stephenholmes1036
@stephenholmes1036 9 месяцев назад
A soldier's, Soldier very like Gotthard Heinrichi. He cared about hos men, got them food. Fought malaria, got them fit, got them air support fighting and freight, got everything they needed. Far better than anyone else in the British army only Walker the submarine killer comes close. He made the Montgomery look like the reasonable commander he was. Slim the best by a good way in the army, Walker the navy,
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Never thought of him in comparison to Gottard Heinrichi who is usually thought of as Germany's best defensive general.
@stephenholmes1036
@stephenholmes1036 9 месяцев назад
@GreatStoriesNow933 As in how he treated his men and how he was liked and he was a good offensive and defensive
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
@@stephenholmes1036 Good thought. You may have a good point there.
@fjardine
@fjardine 9 месяцев назад
Have read his book, saw him on the world at war. Thank you for taking the time to make this content.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed it
@chrisinfidel
@chrisinfidel 9 месяцев назад
Amazing man. Also the troops under him were brilliant. This proves that there is nothing wrong with multiculturalism when different races interact in a positive way, with a common goal.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
very true.
@colinmartin2921
@colinmartin2921 9 месяцев назад
Slim was not burdened with the upper-class burdens of most British generals, and consequently he was able to take a common-sense approach to dealing with the Japanese in Burma.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Good point.
@jontyc3479
@jontyc3479 9 месяцев назад
And you could tell the iffiness and passive disdain (He is not one of us) shown to him from those who thought they were of better class (whatever that means).
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 9 месяцев назад
After demolishing the Italians at Beda Fomm, Dorman Smith asked General Richard O'Connor how it felt to be a completely successful commander. O'Connor replied, "I would never consider a commander completely successful until he had restored the situation after a serious defeat and a long retreat." Slim faced that test.
@Dav1Gv
@Dav1Gv 9 месяцев назад
My father was in the Forgotten Army (after fighting the Germans, Italians and Vichy French in the Middle East). He certainly felt Slim was a great leader. Patton was an aggressive commander but he was in a force which had every advantage in weapons and supply, he can't be compared with Slim - look at their individual records. A first class video though.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
The comparison between Slim and Patton is that they were different from the other generals in their armies, not that they fought in the same manner. Sorry if we have created a misunderstanding.
@Dav1Gv
@Dav1Gv 9 месяцев назад
Thanks, 'different' is fair comment.@@GreatStoriesNow933
@peterrobbins2862
@peterrobbins2862 9 месяцев назад
Slim was a competent, innovative tactically and brilliant something Montgomery,and many of his contemporaries could never be
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Monty is coming in for a real bashing amongst the comments. I expect that if he had not been such a self-opinionated person he might have been better remembered. He actually bought me a drink once ... but that's another story!
@greva2904
@greva2904 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933I think Montgomery’s abrasive personality - there’s a pretty good chance that these days he’d have been diagnosed as having Asperger syndrome - is clouding more and more people’s judgment regarding his talents. The Americans automatically seem to despise him, and a lot of other people seem to be jumping on the bandwagon, for no particularly good reason other than that everyone else is doing it. They can’t seem to separate his talents as a general from his personality faults.
@mediapartners9950
@mediapartners9950 9 месяцев назад
An incredible leader, a soldiers soldier. 🫡
@davidhall8059
@davidhall8059 9 месяцев назад
A leader that soldiers would follow anywhere, as a young soldier I remember lining the route at his funeral.
@terrystephens1102
@terrystephens1102 2 месяца назад
Bill Slim was also a very successful Governor-General of Australia - his war record earned him great respect as a first-class leader.
@janiceduke1205
@janiceduke1205 9 месяцев назад
HERO 💯✨. IMHO Best💎 British commander WW2 . 👏👏👏‼
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Many would agree with you. Thanks for watching.
@cedenullis5906
@cedenullis5906 9 месяцев назад
Thank you for a most informative account of yet another outstanding British Commander!
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@iankingsleys2818
@iankingsleys2818 9 месяцев назад
Some thirty year's ago George MacDonald Fraser's "Quartered Safe out here" was published. An excellent autobiography from a 14th Army NCO. It complements "Defeat into Victory" and Slim comes well out out it. Unlike other officers Slim would often carry a rifle with him rather than a pistol
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your post. I agree!
@donaldelfreth553
@donaldelfreth553 9 месяцев назад
On other posts on Reddit I have exhausted my superlatives in describing Field Marshal Slim. While this is indeed a very good video, more mention should have been made about the absolutely essential tactical and logistic support provided to the 14th Army by its associated RAF and USAAF units.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
The RAF's Keith Park became involved in organising this logistic support. As he is quoted as saying, "The British Army advanced on the wings of the RAF". He was also decorated by the Americans for his efforts. so entirely accept your point. Thanks for watching.
@philipwardle6820
@philipwardle6820 9 месяцев назад
From what I've learned previously the RAF and USAAF support seems to be well recognised. My uncle served in 684 squadron which spent some months flying over Burma in photo recon Mosquitos, on a grid pattern, for use in making accurate maps of jungle areas. From their forward operating base in the Cocos Islands they also conducted long range recon across vast areas of S/E Asia.
@vonsprague7913
@vonsprague7913 9 месяцев назад
New subscriber here! Beautifully written and narrated with excellent footage. Shabash! My Grandfather was Indian Army and my Uncle Gordon Jones RE was a Chindit. We owe so much to the Indian Army the largest volunteer army in history and also to the West African troops who had such great spirit and moral. To some of us the XIV will never be forgotten! Thank you. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments. The Indian Army is perhaps misunderstood, including its origins with the East India Company.
@vonsprague7913
@vonsprague7913 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933 very much so and far from being the army of slaves some think it to be. Recruited from India's many warrior casts and a very honourable profession.
@ardshielcomplex8917
@ardshielcomplex8917 9 месяцев назад
An Aussie veteran here, the Indian Army (and Air Force ) were magnificent both in WW1 and WW2.
@ardshielcomplex8917
@ardshielcomplex8917 9 месяцев назад
​@@vonsprague7913Even Ghandi recognised that Japan had to be defeated before Indian Independence could be achieved, thankfully the Indian people in general supported that.
@trevorfuller1078
@trevorfuller1078 9 месяцев назад
@vonsprague7913: Not also forgetting troops from East & Southern Africa too! Troops from Kenya, Uganda, Tanganyika, Northern & Southern Rhodesia & Nyasaland, as well as some from South Africa too! An example of this is, if you go to Lusaka in Zambia (Formerly Northern Rhodesia), the largest Zambian Army Barracks to be found there is called “Arakan Barracks,” in respectful commemoration of the men (Many of whom did not return or else were severely wounded, while performing their respective war-duties then in Burma!) of the Northern Rhodesian regiments who served in Burma, particularly in the Arakan Coastal Campaign there in 1943-44 during WW2!
@frankbaine3918
@frankbaine3918 9 месяцев назад
Read his book, which inspired me to emulate the leadership skills he so well used with his soldiers. They worked out very well.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments. Very interesting.
@nicholasforman1195
@nicholasforman1195 9 месяцев назад
A remarkable solidier who my father once met in Burma as an RAMC Doctor in 5 Army Commando.Bill S;lim was held in the highest esteem by everyone in the 14th Army and as an outstanding military leader who literally turned 'defeat into Victory' .
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks very much for that anecdote.
@gerryg1056
@gerryg1056 9 месяцев назад
Fascinating and interesting film on a great General and man. My father served with the RAF in the far east during WW2, and although he rarely spoke about those times I remember him saying how respected Bill Slim was among all those who served in that theater.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Old servicemen never seem to tell tales of what they went through. Thanks for your comments
@user-gv1kp3uj3w
@user-gv1kp3uj3w 9 месяцев назад
My father was in the Chindits as part of the 7th army from the south staffs regiment. He never said much about his experience during the Burma campaign, but always spoke highly of Slim. He said he always had a high regards and faith in his troops. But for Slim and the Australian troops, he did not think he would have survived the campaign. I found the video really interesting.
@Sgt_Bill_T_Co
@Sgt_Bill_T_Co 9 месяцев назад
I could have written your reply myself, apart from dad was from the Royal West Kent Reg. he too rarely spoke of his time there.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments. There is of course lots to be said about the Chindits but that will have to wait for another day! Glad you enjoyed the video.
@davidsweeney4021
@davidsweeney4021 9 месяцев назад
My Grandfather was in that army, Royal Artillery. and proud that Sir Bill Slim was a Brummie like me
@PeterGonet
@PeterGonet 4 месяца назад
My father was a sergeant with the Inniskilling Fusilliers stationed in Burma under the command of Field Marshall Slim. I just thought I'd mention that.
@daveleadbeater7652
@daveleadbeater7652 9 месяцев назад
I read that excellent book.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@Free-Bodge79
@Free-Bodge79 9 месяцев назад
To hold an army together with so many different nationalities, languages, races and religions was a feat all on its own. Then to turn them in to a effective and eventually winning force is something really special. He was a great commanding officer. Well thought of by his men. Not enough is made of him , in the military history chronicles of this country. ! Long live the memory ,of the brave men of the 14th army and all who supported them. From all corners of the globe. May they rest in peace. 👍💛👊
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@kiwifruit27
@kiwifruit27 9 месяцев назад
A truly excellent video about a remarkable man. I still have my father’s copy of Defeat into Victory and have read it several times. This must be the best small channel on RU-vid. I hope you get the subs and views you deserve
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your kind remarks. We love bringing these stories to our viewers. Thanks for watching
@philipdurling1964
@philipdurling1964 8 месяцев назад
Glad that you mentioned the Indian, Assam Regiment. These brave men stood shoulder to shoulder with their British brothers in arms. There is great affection, even today, for this magnificent Indian Regiment in the UK.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 7 месяцев назад
There appears to be quite a misunderstanding o the (colonial) Indian Army. Glad to have mentioned the Assam Regiment and to make the point that the Indian Army was a really effective fighting force.
@markanderson3376
@markanderson3376 9 месяцев назад
Very interesting video. Keep these coming.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
We will do our best. We have many more in the pipeline
@mickcardiff3044
@mickcardiff3044 9 месяцев назад
Enjoyed that thanks..
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed it
@user-rh4uw8cb2j
@user-rh4uw8cb2j 8 месяцев назад
This is the first time that I have heard Slim speak, and in that, he does command respect, and that his plans could be rendered easily understood! It was little wonder that he knew his men well and became the best general of WW2!
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 8 месяцев назад
Model, Manstein, Rommel, Guderian, von Bock and Kesselring were all far better.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 8 месяцев назад
@@MarkHarrison733 Slim was as capable as any of them, see Operation Extended capital.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 6 месяцев назад
You are not comparing like with like
@dongeiger4500
@dongeiger4500 9 месяцев назад
This campaign was against the Japanese army while the Americans in the pacific were fighting mainly against the equivalent of the Japanese marines. This battle in Burma was some of worst fighting in WW2 and was totally unknown, sadly!
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Interesting point. Thanks for your comments.
@adamlee3772
@adamlee3772 9 месяцев назад
Really a very interesting documentary. Thanks for sharing it here.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed it!
@asullivan4047
@asullivan4047 8 месяцев назад
Interesting and informative. Excellent photography pictures/reenactments enabling viewers to better understand what the orator was describing. 1st time I've heard about this fella'. To lead an Army thru Burma takes skill/experience/determination.
@chilebike6556
@chilebike6556 9 месяцев назад
'Things are rarely as bad as they seem, or as good as they seem' - Useful words.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
👍
@hacc220able
@hacc220able 9 месяцев назад
Slim finally recognized as the superior British General over that of Monty or any other British General. Monty always left a bad taste but Slim a graceful man, unassuming, and brilliant ascribed victories to his men due to their courage and tenacity. Slim was absolutely the man of the ages for the British Army in WWII.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments
@MarkHarrison733
@MarkHarrison733 9 месяцев назад
Slim was a nonce.
@bravo2zero796
@bravo2zero796 9 месяцев назад
Absolutely fantastic video
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks. Hope we can make some more that you like!
@annettehadley9718
@annettehadley9718 9 месяцев назад
my husband just reminded me of one of General slims quotes... ( I hope I got it right )... Forgotten army... no, no ones ever heard of you !
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for your comments. I have not come across that quote before but appears quite plausible.
@crouqetoo2
@crouqetoo2 9 месяцев назад
No, that was part of Earl Mountbattens quote to the 14th army
@annettehadley9718
@annettehadley9718 9 месяцев назад
@@crouqetoo2 Hi... you are probably right.. I knew it was someone that said that !
@ianlowcock6913
@ianlowcock6913 9 месяцев назад
A great man. His Unofficial Histories has pride of place in my library.
@georgemorgan8787
@georgemorgan8787 9 месяцев назад
Wonderful video. I didn't know much about Bill Slim. What a great man. My uncle served in Burma as a young captain. Very lucky to survive a Japanese grenade that killed the man next to him.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Thanks for the post. Many soldiers take the view than they never know when luck is going to be on their side.
@edjones7709
@edjones7709 9 месяцев назад
Patton isn't a patch on Slim.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
I am not disagreeing with you but to be honest I don't know enough about Patton to make a genuine assessment. From remarks being made here in these comments we may take a closer look at Patton on this channel to see whether his reputation owes more to Hollywood than the battlefield. However, the point in this video that is made by military historians is not that Slim and Patton were similar as Generals but that they were similar to the extent that neither followed the norm of their fellow commanders in their respective services. Thanks for watching. I hope you enjoyed the video.
@jameswaterfield
@jameswaterfield 9 месяцев назад
General Slim should NOT be likened to Patton, he actually cared about his troops! Hence his nick name.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
He is likened to Patton because Slim fought differently to other British Generals as did Patton compared to other American Generals. Not because they fought like each other.
@jameswaterfield
@jameswaterfield 9 месяцев назад
@@GreatStoriesNow933 he gave objectives to his subordinates, following his overall strategy and let them work out their orders. Micro managing was not his thing. A lesson learned in the trenches of Gallipoli
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 9 месяцев назад
@jameswaterfield Slims methods sound similar to German “Mission Command”
@Clabahoy
@Clabahoy 8 месяцев назад
Just a bloke without an ego getting stuff done.
@stephenbrown13
@stephenbrown13 9 месяцев назад
Excellent, so informative!
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching.
@mikesummers-smith4091
@mikesummers-smith4091 9 месяцев назад
Slim's forcing of the Irrawaddy is one of the outstanding military operations. Persuading the enemy to weaken his centre before launching your main attack at that very point by a unit they thought several days march away is - just, well. One of the most telling anecdotes in _Defeat into Victory_ is how he cut his HQ's rations whenever any of his frontline troops had to. Typically, he doubted it made any difference. IDK about you, but if I'd been up to my arse in muck and bullets and he'd given the order, I'd have invaded Hell.
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony-
@Bullet-Tooth-Tony- 9 месяцев назад
@mikesummers-smith4091 Not to mention it's impressive given the sheer SIZE of the Irrawaddy River, it's wider than the Rhine river.
@johnhudghton3535
@johnhudghton3535 9 месяцев назад
Thank you for such an excellent, thorough yet brief account of this true, courageous and capable British hero.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you e joyed it. Thanks for watching.
@simonmorris9877
@simonmorris9877 9 месяцев назад
My great uncle fought in the 14th army. I am trying to learn more about his experiences as he died 27yrs ago and never divulged any details of his service. The mighty jingles (a youtube channel) recommended the biography mentioned here and i will be purchasing it and doing some follow up research. Thank you for this upload.
@GreatStoriesNow933
@GreatStoriesNow933 9 месяцев назад
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching.
@asimnawaz9256
@asimnawaz9256 9 месяцев назад
Hero of Imphal and Kohima
Далее
Hermann Göring's Marshal's Batons
11:15
Просмотров 130 тыс.
Slim: Britains Greatest General
55:01
Просмотров 14 тыс.
Flo Rida - Whistle НА РУССКОМ 😂🔥
00:29
Prelude to Victory: Burma, 1942
21:18
Просмотров 324 тыс.
Field Marshal William Slim
1:00:33
Просмотров 37 тыс.
Why Did The Americans Hate Monty?
19:35
Просмотров 944 тыс.
The Real Story Of The Tomb Of The Unknown Warrior
21:30
Over Compressed Engines, Forgotten Tech From WW1
20:07
The Aden Emergency & Battle of Crater 1967
23:30
Просмотров 291 тыс.