History of the Crimean Tatars - Cold War DOCUMENTARY

Подписаться 409 тыс.

Просмотров 33 тыс.

50% 1

Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today's video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping with promo code "THECOLDWAR" at mnscpd.com/thecoldwar
Our historical documentary series on the history of the Cold War continues with a video on the history of the Crimean Tatars and their struggle for recognition and the establishment of a recognized homeland on the Crimean Peninsula.
How did Mongolia Survive Between Stalin's USSR and Mao's China? • How did Mongolia Survi...
Origins of the Crimean Crisis: • Origins of the Crimean...
What Happened to the German and Japanese POWs?: • What Happened to the G...
Was Russian Language Dominant in the Soviet Union?: • Was Russian Language D...
Did the Soviet Union Russify Other Nationalities?: • Did the Soviet Union R...
Soviet Education System: • Soviet Education Syste...
How Khrushchev Fed the Soviet People: • How Khrushchev Fed the...
Novocherkassk Massacre 1962: • Novocherkassk Massacre...
Soviet Tourism: • Soviet Tourism: How di...
Soviet Passport System: New Serfdom or Reform?: • Soviet Passport System...
Kaliningrad: How Russia Got a Stronghold in Europe: • Kaliningrad: How Russi...
How the Soviets Won the Early Space Race: • How the Soviets Won th...
Soviet Television and Radio: • Soviet Television and ...
Top-5 Myths About the Soviet Union: • Top-5 Myths About the ...
Support us on Patreon: / thecoldwar
RU-vid membership / @thecoldwartv
✔ Merch store ► teespring.com/stores/thecoldwar
✔ Patreon ► / thecoldwar
✔ Facebook ► / thecoldwartv
✔ Instagram ► / thecoldwartv
#ColdWar #Tatar #CrimeanTatar #Crimea #SovietUnion #USSR #Ukraine
Sources:
Salavat Iskhakov, “The Impact of the First World War on Bashkir and Tatar Muslims (1914-1918)”, Revue des mondes musulmans et de la Méditerranée [Online], 141 | 2017
Council of Europe, “Crimean Tatar’s struggle for Human Rights”, Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights 18 April 2023
Brian Glyn Williams, The Crimean Tatars: From Soviet Genocide to Putin’s Conquest, Oxford University Press, 2015
Campan Aurelie, “Surgun: The Crimean Tatars’ Deportation and Exile, Sciences Pro, 16 June 2088:

Опубликовано:

14 июн 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 324

@TheColdWarTV 15 дней назад

Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today's video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping with promo code "THECOLDWAR" at mnscpd.com/thecoldwar

@hybridarmyofthegdl2193 15 дней назад

The Crimean Tatar people's steadfast struggle against Muscovite barbaric imperialism over the past century is astonishing. It is a testament to their people's bravery and willpower. I hope they be free again very soon !! ps A current Ukrainian minister of Defense, Rustem Umerov, is of Crimean Tatar origin. in 2016, Jamala, a Ukrainian singer of Crimean Tartar descent won the Eurovision Song Contest with a song about her great grandmother's experience during the 1944 genocide

@hybridarmyoffreeworld 14 дней назад

@@hybridarmyofthegdl2193 +1

@diegoyanesholtz212 10 дней назад

Do History of the Chechen people in the USSR?

@Taylor-oq3gf 15 дней назад

in 2016, Jamala, a Ukrainian singer of Crimean Tartar descent won the Eurovision Song Contest with a song about her great grandmother's experience during the 1944 genocide

@egertroos-qh7hw 15 дней назад

Tatars are invaders just like russians so I don't pity them

@egertroos-qh7hw 15 дней назад

Tatars are colonizers just like russians

@AN-qi6ye 13 дней назад

The chorus of the song was in Crimean Tatar as well

@nenenindonu 15 дней назад

The Crimean Tatars speak a Kipchak Turkic language that partially originates from Cuman yet is highly mutually intelligible with Oghuz Turkic languages like Turkish & Azerbaijani

@egertroos-qh7hw 15 дней назад

Well tatars came from Asia

@ronmaximilian6953 15 дней назад

Kipchak was a Common or Oghuz Turkic language, although for 700 years before the Cuman conquest, Oghur Turks lived in Crimea alongside Greeks, Slavs, Goths, and Alans. It is my understanding that the Tat Karay language kept more of this heritage than Nogai.

@egertroos-qh7hw 14 дней назад

@@ronmaximilian6953 Oghuz turks didnt live in Crimea along with greeks, slavs and goths. tatars are colonizers from Asia

@patrickordos425 14 дней назад

@@ronmaximilian6953 you got a source for this

@samkugatano1053 14 дней назад

@@egertroos-qh7hw, Greeks, Slavs and Goths were not colonizers, you mean?

@extragoogleaccount6061 15 дней назад

Imagine coming back from surviving WW2 fighting for Russia against the Nazis only to find your family was forcefully relocated right before you made it back. And then being arrested yourself. Talk about injustice.

@boenzitem8747 13 дней назад

And Its all the dirty job of Stalin and Its right hand NKVD chief, Beria!

@user-uk5qe1xn8h 13 дней назад

Yeah, imagine coming back from surviving WW2 fighting for Russia against the Nazis to find out whole your family was evaporated by Crimean Tatars collaborators, and they keep living there like nothing has happened. The majority of Crimean Tatars were Nazis collaborators and deserters.

@tripsaplenty1227 12 дней назад

@@user-uk5qe1xn8h that's just russian propaganda

@son_of_alandalus 12 дней назад

@user-uk5qe1xn8h you better give a good source for that ridiculous claim, majority crimeans really??

@user-uk5qe1xn8h 12 дней назад

@@son_of_alandalus Erich von Manstein - nzis general that seized and occupied Crimea in 1942. His own memories "Lost Victories" (translation from Russian): The success of this assistance, as well as respect for the religious customs of the Tatars on our part, led to the fact that the majority of the Crimean Tatar population was very friendly towards us. We even managed to form armed self-defense companies from the Tatars, the task of which was to protect our villages from the attacked partisans hiding in the mountains of Yaila. The reason that a powerful partisan movement developed in Crimea from the very beginning, which caused us a lot of trouble, was that among the population of Crimea, in addition to Tatars and other small national groups, there were still many Russians.

@Rodzyniastyyyy 15 дней назад

Fun fact. A current Ukrainian minister of Defense, Rustem Umerov, is of Crimean Tatar origin.

@user-wl7zi6pc3j 13 дней назад

Yeah. But sadly, after the Russian Empire annexed Crimea in the 18th century, majority of the Crimean Tatars were expelled or had to flee to Turkey

@egertroos-qh7hw 13 дней назад

@@user-wl7zi6pc3jTatars were colonizers just like russians

@muhammadadeel8639 12 дней назад

@@egertroos-qh7hw Tatars are a mix of Cuman-Kipchaks and Tatars that arrived with Mongol empire. Cuman-Kipchaks defeated Pechenegs around 1000 AD and settled in east ukraine, crimea. Tatars came in 1250s with Mongol conquest. Crimean tatars as said in video - comprised of more than 20 different groups before national identity developed. It included remnants of Huns, Bulgars, Pechenegs, Cumans, Pechenegs, Tatars - all Turkic groups from 400 AD to 1774 AD. Before that were Scythians and Goths driven out by Huns from ukraine in 400 AD.

@egertroos-qh7hw 12 дней назад

@@muhammadadeel8639 Tatars are turkic like cumans so it doesnt matter. Both tatars and Cumans came from Central Asia and Urals

@egertroos-qh7hw 12 дней назад

@@muhammadadeel8639 Tatars invaded Kievan Rus lands that includes Kursk, Belgorod, Ryazan and of course Moscow. Tatars are invaders on slavic lands and were just sent back to their homeland in Asia

@TimRrstrm 15 дней назад

I was actually about to skip this episode, but then I thought 'oh well, it might be at least informative.' I am so happy I watched this.

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

What was the biggest slave trade raids in Europe taking place during 1441-1774 ?

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

A bit sad the amazing woman known as Şefiqa Gaspıralı was not talked about as an exemple of the great intellectual movement that was happening in Crimean circles. She even founded a whole magazine that was supportive of women's rights at a time and place that would have been unprecedented. Sadly, she had to leave following the Soviet conquest, twice saving herself from death. She spent the rest of her life in Turkey to support her Crimean nation in exile.

@egertroos-qh7hw 11 дней назад

Soviet conquest? Tatars invaded Crimea before the Soviets (russians) so who cares what happens to them

@egertroos-qh7hw 11 дней назад

Tatars are invaders

@christopherconard2831 15 дней назад

Throughout history there are places that are the center of "events". *Poland starts sweating*

@tng2057 15 дней назад

The Crimean Tartans staged a protest at the Kremlin in 87(I recall) and it was the first anti-State protest at the heart of the USSR for many decades. It marked the beginning of the demise of the USSR.

@ShubhamMishrabro 15 дней назад

Didn't Kazakhstan had student protest in 83 which was the start of protest against ussr

@naponroy 10 дней назад

It did not mark the beginning of the end. It was one symptom of it, that's all.

@tayletubby5138 10 дней назад

Based

@philsavage6186 15 дней назад

Honor to the brave Tatar people and the heroic Circassian people

@egertroos-qh7hw 11 дней назад

Tatars are invaders themselves in Crimea like russians

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

You have to specify Crimean Tatar. Despite their being Siberian Tatars, Mishar Tatars, Kazan Tatars and etc, Russians just gave Turkic people the name Tatar even though they aren’t even directly the same people . They are Turkic but not the same Turkic.

@egertroos-qh7hw 10 дней назад

@@againstviralmisinformation510 Turks are from Asia

@Maphisto86 16 дней назад

The Crimean Tatar people's steadfast struggle for self-determination over the past century is astonishing. It is a testament to their people's bravery and willpower. I hope they can once again find peace in their homeland in the near future.

@matthiasbindl7085 15 дней назад

@@sven1966 no, not when the Ukrainians retake crimea, it won't be

@tonnyscheire478 15 дней назад

These people enslaved thousends of slavs and sold them to the ottomans, they're not victims

@davidpeltier9148 15 дней назад

I agree with you, here. Just kind of ironic that the descendants of the mongols who oppressed the Russians are now oppressed by the Russians. Not saying either is right. History is just weird like that.

@egertroos-qh7hw 15 дней назад

Ironic is that they (tatars) along with russians are colonizers there and colonizer is opressing colonizer

@egertroos-qh7hw 15 дней назад

@@davidpeltier9148Well both russians and tatars are descendants of Asiatic barbarian hordes

@tomdis8637 15 дней назад

Great video as usual, David. I implore you to reduce or eliminate the music track. It's distracting (especially to we professional musicians!) and definitely detracts from your superb presentation style. BTW, those Cossacks around 6:00 look like some tough characters!

@User4385drfj 15 дней назад

I fear as a channel grows at some point they hire a "sound person" who often appears to feel the need to justify their existence. For those of us with difficulty hearing it makes fantastic work such as this barely watchable 😢

@_utahraptor 15 дней назад

I personally didn't find music annoying

@TimBabych 12 дней назад

Ten thousand times this. Please remove the music track!

@jimgordon1563 15 дней назад

Thank you for this. What about the Tatars who live within the Russian Federation and are their second largest nationality? RU-vidr Eli from Russia is a fascinating example of this nation.

@_utahraptor 15 дней назад

They share the name "Tatar" but are a different ethnicity with different languages which have different close relatives. For Crimean Tatars to stress this difference is very important since as the video says it was used to argue they were Tatars formerly living in Crimea rather than explicitly Crimean Tatars

@egertroos-qh7hw 7 дней назад

@@_utahraptorCrimean tatars are imvaders in Crimea.

@Pidpai 14 дней назад

Fabulous. Best episode thus far. I thought I knew much of this, however David has revealed much more. Lincoln

@shooter2055 15 дней назад

Good stuff! Thank you!! I was not aware-- --

@TathagataD10S 15 дней назад

Please make a detailed video/documentary on Chinese Civil War, especially that of Postwar including battles, strategies and political scenario during 1945/46-1949. Your Century of Humiliation was amazing, that kind of a video on Chinese Civil War would be awesome. ❤ Those who agree please 👍🏼

@JulianCourtneyLukacs 15 дней назад

Thanks!

@carlospargamendez4784 15 дней назад

Excellent!

@jarco5000 15 дней назад

A nice video contentwise once more. I realy love this channel. Only issue is that in the last 2 videos the music is too loud.

@michaelhaywood8262 14 дней назад

Would you consider doing a video on the 1964 Kremlin coup, when Brezhnev deposed Khrushchev?

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

Given their subject, I'm pretty much certain they'll talk about it eventually given how important to the cold war it was

@FoolOfAToke 15 дней назад

I am tired so I read this the thumbnail as "German Taters". Thought it was a bit broad for a cooking video but I guess since I clicked I was here for it. Crimean Tatars are cool to though I guess.

@DutchSkeptic 7 дней назад

What's taters, Precious?!

@ronmaximilian6953 15 дней назад

There were some non-Muslim Tatars including Christians and Jews, when the Russians took over. In fact, there were two Jewish communities. The first were Krymchaks , Crimean Rabbinic Jews, many of whom intermarried with other Russian Jews. The second are Karaylar, Karaite Jews. In fact, Karaylar leaders presented themselves as Tatars following the Mosaic faith to escape Czarist anti-semitic laws. The 20th century would be unkind to both. When the Nazis invaded, The Muslim Tatars protected the Karaylar in Crimea. The Faustian bargain was that the Karaylar could not protect the Krymchaks, most of whom were murdered in the Holocaust. None of this mattered to Stalin and his thugs as both groups groups would be subjected to the genocidal ethnic cleansing of 1944. Survivors of the Holocaust would then spend decades treated like Nazi collaborators.

@egertroos-qh7hw 11 дней назад

Tatars are turks aka asians jews were karaites

@nenenindonu 15 дней назад

The Girays of the Crimean Khanate who were among the latest and western-most royal families of Chinggisid lineage were also ethnically Crimean Tatar

@patrickjeffers7864 15 дней назад

Yeah the Girays made Moscow sweat for a few centuries. In the ottoman empire they were considered the "second family". If the Osmanlis died out, it was agreed the girays would succeed. Genghiz was that impactful

@xyeB 13 дней назад

Not true.

@samkugatano1053 15 дней назад

Thanks a million for this fascinating episode. By the way, I am not sure that Koreans, massively deported in 1937, as far as I remember, were allowed to return to their home region after Stalin's death. I may be wrong. Could you confirm it?

@D.S.handle 15 дней назад

I am also wondering about this.

@petergray2712 14 дней назад

They weren't. Their descendants still live in Central Asia to this day.

@samkugatano1053 14 дней назад

@@petergray2712, thank you for the confirmation. There is, therefore, a small flaw in the video about the nationalities that could not return to their regions of origin, as it seemed to me.

@petergray2712 14 дней назад

@samkugatano1053 The Koreans were overlooked because their expulsion occurred outside of the Second World War. Khruschev rehabilitated the other affected groups in large part because they had participated bravely in the defense of the USSR against the Germans, and Stalin had misrepresented their loyalty for purely spiteful reasons in order to deport them. The Koreans never participated in any such defense, and thus, there was no lobby in the Soviet military he had to placate by restoring their rights. In addition to the Koreans and Volga Germans, Stalin expelled the Meshketi Turks from their lands in his homeland of Georgia (and neighboring Armenia), and these three groups were exempted or prevented by the USSR and it's successors from reclaiming their homes and property.

@samkugatano1053 14 дней назад

@@petergray2712 Yes, indeed, the case of the Meshketi Turks has always caught my attention. Unlike the other peoples deported in 1944-45, they did not live in any (however briefly) German-occupied area. Apparently, following your reasoning, they were not strong enough to lobby to return to their lands when others were able to do so. Or the situation in Georgia was considered too conflictual to allow them to return.

@Uzair_Of_Babylon465 15 дней назад

Great video keep it up you're doing amazing things also they were in the line for the ottoman throne if ottoman empire had no heirs and that nearly happened in the reign of Murad 4th

@tomalexander4327 14 дней назад

Great episode!

@lipa1356 13 дней назад

Hats off to you all for this episode. I cant even imagine how much time it took you to research this all and make a highly educative video about the topic. The quality of the video is just amazing. Amazing job lads. Keep it up i love your videos and cant wait for more.

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

Can you name me the largest slave trade to take place in Europe during 1421-1774?

@sircatangry5864 9 дней назад

@@againstviralmisinformation510Venice, Madrid, cities where slave trade agreements made half of income

@againstviralmisinformation510 9 дней назад

@@sircatangry5864 maybe but they weren’t the largest during this time period.

@Numba003 13 дней назад

Thank you for yet another educational episode. I have heard of the Crimean Tatars, but I knew very little about them before listening to this. Thank you for teaching me a little! God be with you out there, everybody. ✝️ :)

@bikkiikun 14 дней назад

Thank you for using the proper term: Colonialism. Just because the occupied territories are right next door, instead of half way across the world, doesn't mean they're not colonies.

@Game_Hero 13 дней назад

This

@ethanpf449 10 дней назад

Always fascinating videos here

@Seouldrift7 14 дней назад

Miskito in Nicaragua, Intendance in Cabinda, People of the Panjshir Valley, Hmong's in Laos, Chams in Cambodia, Montanards in Vietnam.

@thestandardmanual3446 15 дней назад

Hope that in the future the Crimean Tatars return their land.

@aspieanarchist5439 8 дней назад

I`m of Tatar, Yakut and Uighur descent.

@nicolamarchbank1846 13 дней назад

An yes, the only catastrophe to have inspired a Eurovision winner. The whole relationship failed from the start, not a surprise they are so disloyal to Russia.

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

Things have vastly changed in Crimea now. Crimean Tatars are no longer enslaving millions of Russians and the Soviet Union collapsed long ago.

@Game_Hero 6 дней назад

@@againstviralmisinformation510 yet the russian empire they broke away from in 1917 is still there.

@grizzerotwofour7858 15 дней назад

❤

@jlvfr 15 дней назад

Hey look a guy trying to go around Stalin... what could possibly go wrong...

@Based_Stuhlinger 15 дней назад

I guess deporting millions of innocent people is completely fine then!

@hybridarmyofthegdl2193 15 дней назад

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

You lost me when you said Moscovite imperialism as if the people from Moscow themselves and only themselves went to commit this act ordered by an ethnic Georgian.

@MomentsInTrading 14 дней назад

I got through about 1/4th. The background music is way too loud. It needs to be turned way down.

@caseclosed9342 14 дней назад

I actually met a couple here in Florida who were Russian immigrants to the US and the wife was a Tatar. She was telling me how her family was from Crimea and her grandparents were deported after her grandfather fought in WW2 in the Soviet army against the Germans. It was a betrayal that they weren’t allowed to talk about and later her family relocated to a part of Russia near Crimea but never made it to Crimea. Either way she married a Russian man and they immigrated here to the US which considering all the crap going on between Russia and Ukraine and Crimea was a great choice…

@samwill7259 15 дней назад

One thing I know for sure. The Tatar life is never gonna get better if Russia gets to keep Crimea. Ukraine's not perfect but by god they're at least basically human

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

You do realize Ukraine also expelled the Crimean Tatars from Crimea right?

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

One thing is for sure without going to Crimea and seeing someone travel to Crimea you can’t make that conclusion without asking the Crimean Tatar people themselves. Crimean Tatar and Slav relations are really good right now.

@sircatangry5864 10 дней назад

@@againstviralmisinformation510No, Ukraine gave them autonomy, and Crimean tatars supported revolution of dignity

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

@@sircatangry5864 the Russians gave them autonomy as well and Crimean Tatars are happy right now

@sircatangry5864 10 дней назад

@@againstviralmisinformation510 Sure, that's why Medjilis (Crimean tatar representative political entity) is considered as *terorist* organization in Russia.

@eruno_ 14 дней назад

Ant etkenmen, milletimniñ yarasını sarmağa Nasıl olsun bu zavallı qardaşlarım çürüsin? Onlar içün ökünmesem, qayğırmasam, yaşasam Yüregimde qara qanlar qaynamasın, qurusın.

@Mrgunsngear 15 дней назад

🇺🇸

@mat3714 13 дней назад

Algorithm

@islammehmeov2334 14 дней назад

As CRAMIAN TATAR Thanks Man for making this video especially wen it is mad in one of the most Holy Day for my people

@Dest-i_Qipcaq 11 дней назад

Mende Qırımtatarım

@Mr_Stav 15 дней назад

2 Jewish & 1 German agricultural regions were supported & existed till 1941; Birobijan became a project for after the WW2. Jews returning to Crimea after the WW2 were encouraged to move to Birobijan then, not before WW2... This video is full of inaccuracies that change the history drastically...

@Mr_Stav 15 дней назад

Forced Collectivization came in early 1930s not 1920 like stated here

@seanc6128 15 дней назад

love to hear someone use the antiquated term "invalid" in tyool 2024

@MrGoldenAssassin1 12 дней назад

Man... The shitty things that Stalin did during his reign are uncountable

@IVWOR 15 дней назад

Цікаве та пізнавальне відео. Дякую ❤️ P.S. росія - терористична країна !

@yunusemresoylu7756 10 дней назад

As a Crimean Tatar who was born and raised in Türkiye, I salute all my brothers and sisters all over the world. Someday,all of us return to our homeland)

@tommy-er6hh 15 дней назад

Sadly, nothing about the Crimea Goths, who were still there in the 1800s, left behind from the great tribal migration to destroy the Roman Empire millennia before.....

@obsidianjane4413 15 дней назад

Is this video about the Crimean Goths?

@extragoogleaccount6061 15 дней назад

I think the guy is saying that they should have been at least mentioned

@Jay-ho9io 14 дней назад

@@extragoogleaccount6061they were.

@baneofbanes 12 дней назад

This is the first I’ve heard of them still being around by the 1800’s.

@BaltimoresBerzerker 14 дней назад

For those wondering why the Russians seemed so brutal or imperialistic towards the tatars, i recommend researching the history just prior to that featured in the video. Tatars, among others, held their last slave raid on Slavic Christians in the late 1790's which captured an estimated 20,000 people in just that single raid. These things don't happen in a vacuum, its a back and forth pendulum of subjugation.

@Hasanbas-rv3vm 13 дней назад

Russias had no problem with their people being enslaved

@BaltimoresBerzerker 13 дней назад

@@Hasanbas-rv3vm only by other Russians lol.

@baneofbanes 12 дней назад

The Russians held their own people as slaves into the 1800’s. And by the 1900’s that’s all history that no one alive had any part in. Find something better to do with your life than defend genocide.

@baneofbanes 12 дней назад

@@BaltimoresBerzerkerah so that makes slavery ok? Man you’re a piece of work.

@ylmazirdenyazc8393 11 дней назад

Can you bring out the same Excuse for the Circassians and other Northern Caucasian Peoples?

@GagaRinsky-lg5fw 15 дней назад

crimean tatar here, proud citizen of rf and tr. ask me anything

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

rf? tr? What do you mean?

@GagaRinsky-lg5fw 14 дней назад

@@Game_Hero russian federation and turkiye

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

@@GagaRinsky-lg5fw Ok, why would you be proud of Russia? The country that did everything it could in the past three hundred years up to this day to erase your identity and making your nation a minority in its own homeland?

@brkln621 13 дней назад

@@GagaRinsky-lg5fwyour mother language similar to Turkish?

@baneofbanes 12 дней назад

@@GagaRinsky-lg5fwjust say Russia and Turkey then.

@Beardman770 13 дней назад

I sympathize with the fact that this video is intended to advocate for the rights of crimean tatars today, but it is quite dishonest to skip the hundreds of years of history when the primary economic activity of the crimean tatars was conducting massive slave raids throughout Eastern Europe & transporting millions of victims to be sold at the Ottoman slave markets, ignoring this part of crimean history is similar to making a video on US history that skips the Atlantic slave trade.

@MMerlyn91 12 дней назад

Precisely what I said, they're not doing history anymore, just plain propaganda.

@ertugrulorbayyazanlar4079 11 дней назад

I am 1/4 Crimean ancestry, migrated to Turkey late 1800s. For my brothers and sisters who live under Russian/Ukranian rule, there will never be peace for you - but you are always welcome across the sea. We got problems of our own, but what we do have is yours as well. Regarding Russian annexation of Crimea, there are a lot of propaganda and this video is sadly one sided. I do not blame you guys, since this is a commercial activity and propaganda is just good for business. I will merely say that I have a friend that returned to Crimea after Russian annexation and it is much better now for Tatars. As a final note, in Turkish, the word Tatar is never added define the Crimean. It is Crimean/Kırımlı/Qırımlı, in recognition of our homelands.

@sircatangry5864 9 дней назад

Better for Crimean tatars? When Mejilis is recognized as terrorist organization in Russia? And in 2014 tatars with Ukrainians protested in favor of Maidan?

@eruno_ 8 дней назад

How is it better? You know that Russians literally put Crimean Tatars in prison just for raising Crimean Tatars flag right? There's a reason why Ukraine has entire Crimean Tatars brigade fighting against Russian

@user-le8md3xv5m 10 дней назад

Respect to Crimean Tatars, European Muslim ethnic group. Who love liberal democratic values and support orange revolution, euromaidan

@ionflorea2601 10 дней назад

😂😂😂😂 the best joke ever, if you think Muslim values are liberal democratic

@user-le8md3xv5m 10 дней назад

⁠⁠@@ionflorea2601I am never said about Muslim values are liberal democratic I said Crimean Tatars love liberal democracy. You very naive if believe in good Russians or Russians love freedom. Nordic russians and freedom always disconnect

@sircatangry5864 10 дней назад

@@ionflorea2601They support revolution of dignity and Ukraine, both are symbols of democracy, and in the same time they fight with Russia - symbol of autocracy

@Dest-i_Qipcaq 8 дней назад

Thank you (as Crimean Tatar) we are true Muslims, but we do not call ourselves Europeans, we are modern like Europeans and open-minded people. We are not too feminist, not too rude, we are people with ideals and decisions. We are fighting on the side of Ukraine. We will continue to fight both for our own homeland and for the freedom of Ukraine💛🩵🤞🏻🔥☦️❤️☪️🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦

@line_inthe_sand2569 15 дней назад

Tartar armies of the Middle Ages were the most infamous colonisers and slave traders of Eurasia. Kidnapping, killing and enslaving entire populations of Slavic, Turkic and neighbouring European/Asian ethnic groups in large scale seasonal depopulation raids. These slaves were taken away from their homes and sold off from anywhere from China to India to Egypt , killed out right or worked to death on farms or slave galley ships. The fate of the a slave on a galley was almost certain death, after being beaten and starved to death while working the oars all day on the high sea. This conquest and enslavement policy was sanctioned under the Tartar ethno-religious philosophy of "enslaving/killing non-believers". The Crimean Khanate (1450-1783) was NOT some utopian "Islamic" society before the Russians managed to defeat them after centuries of being enslaved/attacked. They did evil things. Just Like many other groups in history. Why would you completely leave this out of the video? This is like making a video on Saudi Arabia and not mentioning oil. It feels incomplete. The rest of the video was fine. Thank you.

@user-hq9qx3lu6h 15 дней назад

Heh... All peasants and simple people in Medieval Ages were kinda slaves, no matter what they are called or not. Difference is that in Russia even aristocracy never had any rights, they all were "holops of Czar", and this is systemic defect of all "russian culture". BTW, normans also were a slave traders, know they are the wealthiest and the happiest countries in the world. Think about it. P.S. And enjoy your rubles, freak!😅

@user-hq9qx3lu6h 15 дней назад

@obsidianjane4413 15 дней назад

Because it doesn't matter in the context of the "COLD WAR" and Soviet Union. What you are doing is parroting the rationalization for the abuses in the 20th century and projecting your own racism and bigotry. "Why would you completely leave this out of the video?" Did you miss the first couple of minutes of the essay after the manscaping ad?

@line_inthe_sand2569 15 дней назад

Nothing I said was even remotely racist. Listen carefully before you go around accusing people. Obsidian Jane. Tartar slave empire, raids and atrocities of the 1450-1780 period never justify any form of violence or purge etc carried out by Russians, Stalin or anybody else. EVER. Let's get that straight. Russian atrocities against the Tartars were horrible, perpetrated by very bad people and unjustifiable. You cannot kill people in revenge for killing people. That is wrong. You cannot justify murder or bad deeds. I am simply reminding this "historian" that his "History of the Crimean Tartars" is ridiculously incomplete. All he mentioned was that when the Mongol Empire collapsed circa. 1400-1500, the Tartars assembled around Crimea. Then he skips to the late 1700s. He skipped then over 300-400 years of history before the Russian Invasion. 300 years of very crucial Tartar history. Withholding evidence is not the job of a good historian. Detail is important.

@obsidianjane4413 15 дней назад

@@line_inthe_sand2569 That was pretty much the norm in that time period, you even admit it. That is also all beyond the scope of this video. The way you wrote it seems like an apologist for the behavior of the Soviets, who were dominated by Slavic Russians. The only way I can see that you don't appreciate the above is that you carry some sort of personal grudge and bigotry against the subject. So maybe reconsider your opinion here.

@TeutonicEmperor1198 15 дней назад

The title is a clickbait. That's not the "history of Crimean Tatars", it's the "history of the Crimean Tatar-Russian relations after the end of the Khanate". It's very beautiful to ignore the colossal crimes ,slave raids and trade made by the Tatars against the Christian people of the area and detouch them from their history painting them as eternal victims of the bad Russians or Ukrainians.

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

they are eternal victims as well, what happened almost a millenium ago changes nothing to that.

@TeutonicEmperor1198 14 дней назад

@@Game_Hero 1780s isn't a millenium ago it's 250 years. The Tatar yoke lasted for 500 years.

@monkofdarktimes 13 дней назад

And let's not mention the demographics replacement of the Goths and Greeks there

@Game_Hero 13 дней назад

@@monkofdarktimes national evolution through new peoples coming and fusing with the locals is nothing new, the peoples before the Magyar arrived in Hungary were and are still there, modern hungarian culture is a fusion of both. Same thing with France and the fusion of the Gauls that were there and the Franks gave us, with many further addings, modern French culture. The way it is presented is like poof, what came before and the people with it just disappeared, there's no "replacement". It's not a Beothuk situation.

@user-uk5qe1xn8h 12 дней назад

@@Game_Hero Crimean Greeks fled Crimea to Russian Mariupol due to genocide committed against them by Crimean Tatars. That is literally a historical fact.

@XozusMC 13 дней назад

"The prosecution the tatars have faced by Russia", what about the tatar raids and all the slavery of slavs? They deserved being conquered.

@Game_Hero 13 дней назад

this is literally a whataboutism

@karacaddy 12 дней назад

sie

@user-uk5qe1xn8h 12 дней назад

@@Game_Hero How consequences that follow malicious behavior can be pointed to "whataboutism". Do liberal clowns think that whataboutism is a silver bullet argument?

@Game_Hero 12 дней назад

this is literally a whatab0utism

@serhansali 10 дней назад

Both had done bad things, but Russians made it under the flag of civilization, also, tatars didn't want Russian culture and people to disappear and claim their land.

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

You literally skipped the part where the Crimean Tatars enslaved millions of Slavs and sold them to the Ottomans. The word slave comes from the word Slavs since they were used as slaves by Crimean Tatars

@serhansali 10 дней назад

At that time anyone could be a slave, it was common. Yes, both parties did bad things to each other, but tatars, unlike Russians didn't do it under the flag of civilization.

@swmark78 7 дней назад

Wrong, Slav comes from slava, which means glory.

@againstviralmisinformation510 7 дней назад

@@serhansali we can’t include all Tatars under what the crimes the Crimean Tatars did but yes the Crimean Tatars were responsible for enslaving million in eastern Europe one of the biggest atrocities at the time.

@againstviralmisinformation510 7 дней назад

@@swmark78 are you being serious ?

@serhansali 7 дней назад

@@againstviralmisinformation510 Yes, as Russians are responsible for killing millions

@meydallas 12 дней назад

The Russia/Soviet empire was along with British and French empires 1 of the worst empires in the history of humanity. These 3 empires are responsible for most of the crises in the world today. The sad thing is that they are still in denial, and for the Russia/Soviet empire, they are trying to go back to the old time and forget about all the issues they created in the past.

@againstviralmisinformation510 10 дней назад

The U.S. is arguably the worst today getting to be the worst in history with our support for genocide via bombs or sanctions

@DGronki 14 дней назад

If we assume Crimea belongs to rest of Tatars it should be independent but somehow USA and UE support Kiev regime in path to retook it....

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

"Kiev regime" says a lot about your opinions. A "regime" that many Crimean Tatars look to to increase their rights and efforts at cultural revitalization as it happened in Ukraine before the conquest of Russia trying now to erase them entirely as they always did. Self-determination path starts with Ukraine.

@DGronki 14 дней назад

@@Game_Hero Correct, my opinio is that in Kiev we have regime which beforae war behaves like nazis now west cuntries support it. They avoid election because thay do not want to allow Ukrainians to voto because decision of people could be different that they want. In the same time I think russia is also bad country which gives only death and chaos. Both regimes Kiev and Moscow are antypeople. But we cannot forget that USA, UE, UK, CHina and other countries just fueling conflict and noone cares abound peace and live. Both sides wants only win in name of "freedom", "democracy" and "keeping global order"

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

@@DGronki They can't have an election because they're in a freaking WAR. Russia absolutely doesn't even want to win in the name of freedom and democracy, it was nowhere in its rhetoric, it absolutely doesn't care, it wants the Neo-Russian Empire, while another try, I don't know, not to be CONQUERED by a neighbour. The allies could support the United Kingdom, China and the Soviet Union in WW2 because they asked and should have the right to get help when they're litterally at risk of being conquered, it's no different here. You want peace? How about making sure it happens and last by saying, I don't know, "Don't. conquer. other. countries. period", that's a way to punish those that by ego made the childish decision to invade their neighbours to get chunks of them when they could have decided not to, threatening global peace instead by breaking the taboo of territorial integrity. Relativism helps no one, peace least of all.

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

@@DGronki They can't have an election because they're in a *war* . Russia absolutely doesn't even want to win in the name of freedom and democracy, it was nowhere in its rhetoric, it absolutely doesn't care, it wants the Neo-Russian Empire, while another try, I don't know, not to be *conquered* by a neighbour. The allies could support the United Kingdom, China and the Soviet Union in WW2 because they asked and should have the right to get help when they're litterally at risk of being conquered, it's no different here. You want peace? How about making sure it happens and last by saying, I don't know, "Don't. conquer. other. countries. period", that's a way to punish those that made the decision to invade their neighbours to get chunks of them when they could have decided not to, threatening global peace instead by breaking the taboo of territorial integrity. Relativism helps no one, peace least of all.

@Game_Hero 14 дней назад

They can't have an election because they're in a freaking *war* . Russia absolutely doesn't even want to win in the name of freedom and democracy, it was nowhere in its rhetoric, it absolutely doesn't care, it wants the Neo-Russian Empire, while another try, I don't know, not to be *conquered* by a neighbour. The allies could support the United Kingdom, China and the Soviet Union in WW2 because they asked and should have the right to get help when they're litterally at risk of being conquered, it's no different here. You want peace? How about making sure it happens and last by saying, I don't know, "Don't. conquer. other. countries. period", that's a way to punish those that made the decision to invade their neighbours to get chunks of them when they could have decided not to, threatening global peace instead by breaking the taboo of territorial integrity. Relativism helps no one, peace least of all.

@General_1812 15 дней назад

Hey, what about american japonese in WWII?!

@user-hq9qx3lu6h 15 дней назад

BTW, One of the most successful and productive minority group's in American population nowadays. What was in WWII was in WWII, know the main difference between civilized, developed nations and post-meta-ironic barbarians, that covering their ignorance by cynicism and "geopolitics", that the second ones are incapable of reflection, admitting their mistakes and correcting them.

@user-hq9qx3lu6h 15 дней назад

One of the most successful and productive minority group's in American population nowadays. What was in WWII was in WWII, know the main difference between civilized, developed nations and post-meta-ironic barbarians, that covering their ignorance by cynicism and "geopolitics", that the second ones are incapable of reflection, admitting their mistakes and correcting them.

@D.S.handle 15 дней назад

What about ‘em?

@samwill7259 15 дней назад

Yea, it was a terrible crime and the American government has done nothing but apologize and pay out in response to that crime. What's your point? Has the modern Russian government taken any steps to make right with the Tatars?

@Jay-ho9io 14 дней назад

@@user-hq9qx3lu6h every other answer this account has is written in Cyrillic. I'm just guessing this is not the most good faith of questions it's asking.

@Toonimation-np6fu 11 дней назад

Why is it that when crimean tatars return to their homeland, its acceptable but when jews return to their homeland, they are called occupiers, invaders and settlers? Is the right of return only for non jews?

@kulrul9180 11 дней назад

Because one thing hapend in one hundred years in modern history , people have living memories or family members who were born there. And yews were expelled from levant by romans before 2000 years. It is like if some irish guys try to reconquer France on the basis that 2000 years ago France was Celtic

@swmark78 7 дней назад

Because Israel forced 1.2 million Muslims and Christians to flee, 2/3s of the population of Palestine in 1948. That literally gave away what little of Palestine was left for the Palestinians to Jordan and Egypt, who didn't want that land or the people forced out. Then in 1967 Israeli occupied that land. They also call any Palestinian "Arab" to deny they have any rights to the land. And that's not counting all of the illegal Jewish settlements in the West Bank. Because no matter how little of what was Palestine is left, they want that too.

@Toonimation-np6fu 12 часов назад

@@kulrul9180 Irish people are gaelic celts and Natives of France were Gaulish Celts. It's like saying China has a Right over Tibet just because both are members of sino-tibetan family. Do you hear yourself? And what is your solution then? To keep persecuting Jews and leave them without a homeland, when in fact it exists and is waiting for the rightful owners to comeback? Is it their fault that they were compelled to leave their homeland, the land of their ancestors or romans'? And initially they purchased the land legally from the muslim bedouins. But then, everyone likes targeting the weak, don't they? And by your same logic, before the crimean tatars, the bulgars and kievan rus ruled Crimea so technically it's their homeland so what happened with tatars isn't wrong as Russians, rightful descendants of the Rus' took the lands of their ancestors back.

@mohammedsaysrashid3587 15 дней назад

How many colonialist forces passed over Crimea ? They prosecutioned previous settlement before Golden hord Mongol , Ottoman Empire.... when the Ottoman Empire used the Crimean Tatar community as fifth columns against the Russian 🇷🇺 empire existed before WW1 and later years ....Russian competitors demanding Crimean separation for Crimean peninsulas important position ( ejection of the Russia 🇷🇺 from black sea and blocks 🚫 Azov sea against Russian nevagation) they do not love's Tatar community in Crimea.

@Kastoraki 15 дней назад

Tatars, with this word means that they don't belong to Europe, they belong somewhere in Asia....

@suzannakoizumi8605 15 дней назад

The Tartars need Jesus Christ of The New Testament.

@asgarihanif 15 дней назад

We have Jesus, along with Muhammad and the other Prophets.

@samwill7259 15 дней назад

Their muslims, my friend. They have both Jesus AND the New Testament

@asgarihanif 15 дней назад

@@samwill7259 We do not use the New Testament; but we believe the Qur'an is a pure version of the Gospel with newer and even older revelations compiled into it, as it is directly from God and not man.

@samwill7259 15 дней назад

@@asgarihanif Hate to break it to you but everyone else thinks they have the same thing

@asgarihanif 14 дней назад

@@samwill7259 Did i not say "we" believe, and not that it is? I tried to speak neutrally.

@Dest-i_Qipcaq 11 дней назад

Thank you for making a video about us. I hope the Russians do not OCCUPY the comments and make propaganda about we :) Azat Qırım🩵💛🇺🇦