Тёмный

HLT Special: Jaitley Vs Chidambaram Debate: The great face-off (Part 1) 

Headlines Today
Подписаться 695 тыс.
Просмотров 212 тыс.
50% 1

Here are the former and the current finance ministers of the country debating about the economy, politics behind the last elections and the reasons why some of the UPA's major financial pushes did not work. Listen in for some clear and audible debating, with Karan Thapar moderating on the occasion of the launch of Rajdeep Sardesai's book : 2014 : The Election that Changed India.
For more news from Headlines Today visit / @headlinestoday
Tweet us on Twitter: / headlinestoday
Like us on Facebook: / headlinestoday

Опубликовано:

 

6 ноя 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 133   
@AdityaSingh3
@AdityaSingh3 9 лет назад
This civil, informative debate between the two - Chidambaram and Jaitley - is a pleasure to watch. Well done Rajdeep/Karan.
@johnnyappleseed6823
@johnnyappleseed6823 9 лет назад
This is how debates should be done. That noisy obnoxious Arnab lacks critical thinking. Panders to the low life.
@kabilan
@kabilan 6 лет назад
Arnab is not here thank god. He is a mad barking dog. Jaitley is draining without any knowledge
@tanmayhoshing5585
@tanmayhoshing5585 9 лет назад
Excellent articulation by Chidambaramji.
@razack321
@razack321 6 лет назад
See the posture of sitting both it shows the attitude of each other......
@shivaarunaachalam3789
@shivaarunaachalam3789 5 лет назад
Chidambaram is great
@uneducatedindian732
@uneducatedindian732 9 лет назад
I don't knw why there is so much hate towards Karan Thapar, can u name one english news anchor in india, who conducts the debate in a cleanest manner, wit no cross talking, in an unbiased manner, who asks tough questions to both sides of the story, who doesnt allow the panelists to speak rhetorically or digress from his questions but always focuses on the content and in logic and most of all, at the end of the debate, educates the viewer about the subject and empowers him/her to judge who is right and who is wrong???, i can only name one anchor who does the above mentioned things in a debate, which is KARAN THAPAR.
@sukhijaramesh2189
@sukhijaramesh2189 6 лет назад
It is the fact.there is no one near to Karan Thapar.In his platform whosoever speaks is not disturbed by any other speaker and Mr.Thapar does not allow from deviating from the question asked.I love to see it.Agreed with your views.
@oneforallah
@oneforallah 5 лет назад
It is because of the simple fact that for Intellectuals who can see through what karan thapar does it is all good. We see all the positives and negatives and decide on the course which is better despite it's negatives, but for fools when he (karan) acts leftist and asks tough shit to right wing interviewee they use this and start circle jerking all that happens in an interview and make asymmetric conclusions from all this and thus a bad party gets eventually elected. Here I'm talking about the Modi interview and his previous left leaning interviews to the BJP members who are mostly right. Now coming to why this is bad again, Congress has been an accelerator for corruption and religion and caste based politics all these years. Another factor is because he isn't karan Thapar he is seen as Lord Karan Thapar by many who get irritated by his line of questioning and just want him to nod and agree and ask easy shit, but I personally love that Karan gives a tough time to whoever he interviews. We as Indian's need to understand Nehru had a vision for us and we should be again Thankful to Jinnah for kicking the Muslims out of this Nation, who are even considered inferior by the Arabs. Now we all have a hate towards Nehru for the whole Kashhmir situation and the religion politics of the INC but that was needed at his time to sustain peace not anymore ! 1. We need to get rid of caste so BJP must rise to power 2. We need to get rid of corruption so BJP must rise to power 3. We need to get more trade and GDP/PPP so BJP must come to power 4. Unemployment rate is so high and to curb that again BJP must rise to fucking power
@ASTROMURTHY
@ASTROMURTHY 9 лет назад
purposely the audio on Chidambaram is distrurbed
@sreedharannair9337
@sreedharannair9337 6 лет назад
Jaitley is no match to Chidambaram. Chidambaram is intelligent. He understands the Indian economy better than any other indian finance minister not discounting Mammohan Singh a true economist.
@prasanthbab1
@prasanthbab1 8 лет назад
I respect these two journalists, as they have done job in formal manner. keep it up.
@abhinavsrivastav8677
@abhinavsrivastav8677 Год назад
Would be happy to see a similar debate today between Niramala and Chidambaram
@sajeevraj6111
@sajeevraj6111 6 лет назад
Mr.jetly what telling its not clear he dont no how to explain this budjet
@andrew8394
@andrew8394 9 лет назад
By the people, For the people, Of the people. An Enigma !
@itzvishal
@itzvishal 9 лет назад
The title "The Great Face Off" perhaps would have been more apt for the misconduct & the ruckus that Rajdeep had created while in US!
@deekay5992
@deekay5992 6 лет назад
What Congress did to economy was criticized, but now what has the BJP done to it ???
@vijaybgood
@vijaybgood 9 лет назад
Rajdeep speaks tangential to logic...
@digantsonwane4417
@digantsonwane4417 9 лет назад
18:10 is so idiotic that probably jaitley didn't even want to contest that.
@ravindertalwar553
@ravindertalwar553 2 года назад
Good to watch and listen for important information
@muralinadarajah6455
@muralinadarajah6455 6 лет назад
Jaitley - Accounts Assistant Chidambaram - Accountant
@pkaul01
@pkaul01 7 лет назад
I fail to understand how Mr. Godson or Godfather has opined that Chidambram cannot be matched and all that hyperbole of higher conscience,and higher intelligence of Chidambram is poppycock. It smacks of regional and caste loyalty and affinity. ArunJaitley is a highly competent politician and professional. He is very persuasive, well informed and very articulate. He has matched Chidambram word for word. Chidambram may be very intelligent, but Arun Jaitley is not a slouch either. Just rid yourself of your prejudices Mr. Godson.
@koshurdalit1488
@koshurdalit1488 6 лет назад
pkaul01 jaitley is inferior nottherner and chidambaram proved superior south indian
@amitthakur8162
@amitthakur8162 6 лет назад
pkaul01 I fully agree with you that arun jaitley is a master of all trades.
@venuramana4633
@venuramana4633 3 года назад
Can you please conduct such meeting with present finance minister with Congress finance minister chidambaram
@ashoks5317
@ashoks5317 4 года назад
Mr.PC. Why can't you answer the question put to you by Shalini Singh in Hindu on 2G
@juliannevillecorrea
@juliannevillecorrea 9 лет назад
i #promise the #rupee that i will #price the #sum of MY services as a function solely of MY #burden & not by all else !
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
14:45 "when he (rs) says it was economy and not corruption, don't forget there is a link between the two!"
@tungsten118
@tungsten118 5 лет назад
really intellectual attributes of a Finance minister ' 'P. Chidmbrm. '
@merrymeridian9372
@merrymeridian9372 6 лет назад
Even if BJP comes in power, finance ministry should be done as consultant from congress
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
13:35 "explain why he left you in shambles" is akin to "explain why theft happened before you came in", and adding an " you think" merely amounts to questioning the thinking, implying why not pretend they were not thieves and everything is hunky dory?
@balaji9585
@balaji9585 9 лет назад
though to understand what they are phrasing about
@sukuvar
@sukuvar 9 лет назад
Arun jaitley is an asset to india.. he had spoken very well... knowledgeable.. and cool.
@Tatpunjiya
@Tatpunjiya 3 года назад
The man responsible for the fall of the economy was the president at the time Pranab Mukherjee who,they are not naming
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
26:57!
@thaoveikey1745
@thaoveikey1745 6 лет назад
Jaitley looks uncomfortable before chidambaram. Inferiority complex may be.
@dijuad6912
@dijuad6912 4 года назад
True
@thetruthabouttamilpolitics3524
@thetruthabouttamilpolitics3524 2 года назад
"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, but wiser people are so full of doubts." - Bertrand Russell. P. Chidambaram is a Nattukottai Chettiar dog. Nattukottai Chettiar dogs are the key creators of one hundred years of the most toxic possible hate against Brahmins in Tamil Country. But, they are also the most devoted hindus and along with the vellala dogs, the topmost castes of tamil country. 'Dravidian' Movement was built by Chettiar + Mudaliar + Pillai for the British people, to thwart the freedom struggle of the Congress. And, today, a Chettiar dog is a powerful man in Congress. Chidambara chettiar was the minister of state for internal security when Rajiv Gandhi ordered IPKF to be sent to Sri Lanka. And RG signed the Indo-Lanka accord with Jeyawardene Chettiar, the executive president of SL. Did both chettiars lure India into sending IPKF to fight the LTTE? The LTTE was the face of the uprising of the lower castes against vellala oppression. A section of the sinhalas, the dominant ones, goyigama et al, were probably on the vellalas' side. What happened in SL was not tamil vs sinhala. It was vellala vs non-vellala. Indians are the dumbest morons on earth. Im having a hard time explaining the Brahmin hate of tamil country and Dravidian Movement to Indians and Brahmin retards. Chettiar + Mudaliar + Pillai, the topmost tamil castes, and the most devoted 'hindu', if you will, of tamil demons built that hate, and chettiar dog and his son are talking like proper congressmen. I don't know whether to laugh or cry. Also, PC's ilk, Nattukottai Chettiar dogs built one hundred years of the most toxic possible non-violent hate in human history, against the Brahmins. They were/are the tamil elite castes, and tamil is a barbaric, intrinsically hateful and vindictive society. Them and vellala dogs have been filling the tamil collective consciousness with visceral/vitriolic brahmin hate for a hundred years, non-stop, but this chettiar dog pimped a brahmin whore for his son. And that son of his continues to badmouth brahmins, even while married to a brahmin whore. Its actually common. Chettiar/Mudaliar/Pillai filled tamil sphere with brahmin hate, but have no shame targeting brahmin women for marriage, and continue to do that hate, even while married to brahmin women. That was probably one of the reasons why they built that hate through their Dravidian Movement. Attack the men, and take the women. This is non-human. Tamil is not a normal society. Its sad that even brahmins of TN have no clue whats been going on.
@MK-jd7id
@MK-jd7id 6 лет назад
Jaitely perhaps is not aware of what's talk happening in public. Without knowing Jaitely, says people are not let down. Chidabaram is Master, Jaitely is just a student.
@sanjeevkmaurya-d2653
@sanjeevkmaurya-d2653 4 года назад
And look what just happened to Chiddu
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
3:23 "..so parties which relied on caste ...all did reasonably badly" - hope that grows into a flood of India ignoring caste and communal basis! 3:23 - 3:49!
@sandeepmhaske9578
@sandeepmhaske9578 6 лет назад
Jyotsna Gokhale
@panghalaniruddh6166
@panghalaniruddh6166 Год назад
Mani Shankar Aiyar was sitting there only, somewhere around 12:00
@aryanwarrior6233
@aryanwarrior6233 Год назад
Jaitley is so so articulate
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
9:30 - 10:53 "... Mukherjee had taken the decision without informing the PM ..I don't know what that says about the cabinet system" - rs still pretending, or trying to browbeat audience into pretending, that post 2004 there was a cabinet, unless he refers to furniture in kitchen of the house where decisions were issued from?
@uditadhikari
@uditadhikari 9 лет назад
Mr. P Chidambaram you giving assurance would not make sense because you were the one who came up with the retrospective taxation.
@kumaratul609
@kumaratul609 4 года назад
Extremely dignified and meanfull debate .. Kudos to moderator
@mogambokhushhua4184
@mogambokhushhua4184 3 года назад
Very rare to find now a days
@vishalkhongshei9719
@vishalkhongshei9719 Год назад
Both of them they are good Lawyers...
@pradiptakumarpanda4904
@pradiptakumarpanda4904 9 лет назад
Can Karan Thapper & Rajdeep Sardesai differentiate the statements given by Sri Jaitley about the economy in the instant debate vis-a-vis his statements given as a BJP leader?
@k.ganesanganesan6825
@k.ganesanganesan6825 5 лет назад
Please let people know what is truth.
@ashokkumar444
@ashokkumar444 9 лет назад
The Moderator is disquilified...this is NOT a English language contest
@ashokkumar444
@ashokkumar444 9 лет назад
do NOT argue on symentics English is NOT local language..Chidambaram is a Harvard University unqualified...go after his son. He is a Dhoti rappiest eg Bihar.. Arrest and jail these traitors.
@nrupensingh7995
@nrupensingh7995 2 года назад
Chidambaram - my favorite Congress leader along with Sachin Pilot
@Nokapp23
@Nokapp23 9 лет назад
I don;t like Arnab's style at all. But he has always stick out his neck to expose dirty politics of India. If NaMo is changing course of Indian history than Arnab Goswamy is also changing course of Indian journalism. Unlike this two.
@sohambanerjee99
@sohambanerjee99 3 года назад
BOTH OF MR. JAITLEY AND MR. CHIDAMBARAM ARE LAWYERS - NONE OF THEM ARE ECONOMISTS- YET THEY ARE FINANCE MINISTERS! NEITHER WAS YASHWANT SINHA, WHO WAS AN IAS OFFICER! DR.SINGH WAS MOST SUITED FOR AND THE BEST FINANCE MINISTER! PRANAB MUKHERJEE AND OTHER POLITICIAN FINANCE MINISTERS LIKE Y.B. CHAVAN, WERE ALSO GREAT
@kuwaityadav3456
@kuwaityadav3456 6 лет назад
AJ 0% vision because he talk politics whenever he talking about India economy while PC always talk India economy not politics
@mohananpoovan8116
@mohananpoovan8116 5 лет назад
Chidambaram and hisGovt of the. time has. lost all vt
@anandkrishan9054
@anandkrishan9054 9 лет назад
Rajdeep will earn lot of money .... ek kalakar patrakar11
@harishinamdar81
@harishinamdar81 9 лет назад
Mr.Jaitley, why do u leave tht sword of retrospective taxation hanging? Why can't you do away with it once for all? Unless this current BJP+ govt gets rid of evil practices brought in by UPA, I just see no difference between Jaitley and Chidambaram. Jaitley is just another Chidambaram in kurta and pyjama.
@gatesrocks
@gatesrocks 9 лет назад
he made it clear that there are a lot of court cases in which the Govt of India has already taken a stand based on that retrospective taxation proposal. Those court cases are in progress
@prabinshekhar7054
@prabinshekhar7054 6 лет назад
Harish Inamdar So you want Taxless Democracy ? it sounds Madness. Tax is how the fund is raised .Topic was UPA was not capable of Efficient Utilisation of Fund in a proper manner . It was same as you carry a Bucket full of Water with big spills ,water get wasted in midway path (Feed by Mafia ,Corrupt leaders ) & what reached to the People was An empty bucket !
@kuwaityadav3456
@kuwaityadav3456 6 лет назад
AJ playing with economy
@Nauginaugi5
@Nauginaugi5 6 лет назад
chidabaram is a god compared to jaitley
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
24:52 "see the people of India did not vote against us because of retrospective tax" - right, it was coal and Commonwealth and 2g and mask PM and so on!
@nimotalkssense
@nimotalkssense 2 года назад
The thumbnail made me say get someone who looks at you like jaitley does to Chidambaram
@samthomas9953
@samthomas9953 4 года назад
Mr. Chedembaram.is jenious
@durgeshsingh7735
@durgeshsingh7735 2 года назад
so.u r sam
@BallyBoy95
@BallyBoy95 9 лет назад
Spoiler: Arun Jaitley clearly made the more persuasive argument, so I'd predict that majority of the viewers felt that he had won.
@CoolDude-et8si
@CoolDude-et8si 7 лет назад
Bruce Wayne I believe Chidambaram totally outclassed jaitley..
@sreedharannair9337
@sreedharannair9337 4 года назад
Did you left your brain at home?
@parthparekh7471
@parthparekh7471 7 лет назад
jaitley ji destroyed pressitute
@prabhakarawasthi9244
@prabhakarawasthi9244 2 года назад
5
@margaritavelez9991
@margaritavelez9991 9 лет назад
Hola Hola Hola
@elsinpravin734
@elsinpravin734 5 лет назад
Yk
@elsinpravin734
@elsinpravin734 5 лет назад
K
@chandrakiranraju
@chandrakiranraju 6 лет назад
Partners in crime
@godsonswaminath1412
@godsonswaminath1412 8 лет назад
jaitley blah blah blah. chidambaram specifics. chidambaram cannot be matched. higher consciousness and higher intelligence. For jaitley it is very difficult to match him.
@arnavdey5937
@arnavdey5937 5 лет назад
Jaitley always great articulator. He is the best orator of indian politics. Rest are good in rhetoric but less in substance
@ianshhh
@ianshhh 2 года назад
Both crooks
@rameshramakrishna2229
@rameshramakrishna2229 Год назад
Pm modi speech i re backed black money but nobody question it how it's.
@anandkrishan9054
@anandkrishan9054 9 лет назад
This channels seems a congress channel as I can see poster of Pappu with Sri NaMo..
@gulfizakhan9316
@gulfizakhan9316 5 лет назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 shri namo
@anandkrishan9054
@anandkrishan9054 9 лет назад
Rajdeep talking crap
@leopardtiger1022
@leopardtiger1022 2 года назад
Both are slippery wily, Chidambaram ruined congress party with his 20% commission on projects.
@parthparekh7471
@parthparekh7471 7 лет назад
rajdeep and thapar is presstitute
@kabilan
@kabilan 6 лет назад
Parth Parekh and so are you
@socialviews5868
@socialviews5868 5 лет назад
Great Chidambaram
@DrJG9
@DrJG9 8 лет назад
18:00 - 18:40 chid claims economy was "challenging" in 2004 too, pretending they are all the same; FM won't have it, correcting him "we left 8.7% in 2004, got 4.4% in 2014"!
@vasukinagabhushan
@vasukinagabhushan 5 лет назад
Jaitley must be the worst finance minister in history.
@harishp7753
@harishp7753 5 лет назад
He didn't how to handle of India economy....
@poet_pratik
@poet_pratik 7 лет назад
Chidambaram is a Comedian or What!!
@steamerSama
@steamerSama 7 лет назад
He spoke pretty good. Which part are you specifically talking about?
@CoolDude-et8si
@CoolDude-et8si 7 лет назад
Pratik Bhaarat R u a comedian?
@allembrace
@allembrace 7 лет назад
CHIDAMBARAM is a Sad sadist !!!!
@kabilan
@kabilan 6 лет назад
प्रतीक भारत पलोड़ *दर्पण* - हिन्दी कविताएँ no Jailtley is
@genx6619
@genx6619 5 лет назад
LUNGI CHIDAMBARAM...FRAUD CHIDAMBARAM....excellent jaitely sir
@shankar4330
@shankar4330 5 лет назад
You should be one of those racist fucks. Match your intelligence with that dhoti guy (not lungi) and then come degrade him. You roti stuffing pan spitting northie
@yahyakp2110
@yahyakp2110 4 года назад
Dhinraj Shetty is a N. Indian paan-reeking fuck face
@chrg1614
@chrg1614 9 лет назад
'Talk' is very cheap, hire a Karan Thapar.. 'Innovative Thinking and Action' is rare.. for those attributes we need a Modi..
@gulfizakhan9316
@gulfizakhan9316 5 лет назад
Jaitely kitna insecure lg rha h chidmabram k samne.. Kyunki usko economy ka e bhi nhi pta or samne baap betha hai.
@jkpillaijkmalayalam2413
@jkpillaijkmalayalam2413 4 года назад
P Chid Telling not truth Only Mr. Arun is correct JAI BHARAT JAI ARUN Jiiiiiiiiii
@shivaarunaachalam3789
@shivaarunaachalam3789 5 лет назад
Chidambaram is great
Далее
Frankly Speaking with Arun Jaitley - Full Interview
48:33
Annual Lecture No.1
1:23:23
Просмотров 24 тыс.
India Today Conclave: Q&A With P. Chidambaram
14:10
Просмотров 15 тыс.
Frankly Speaking with Narendra Modi - Full Interview
1:17:29