Hogwarts Legacy PS5 vs. Xbox Series X | Loading Times, Graphics, FPS Test 

The Xbox series x is a much powerful console and it has nothing to do with the console themselves it has to do with the devs that made the game the PC version has the same issues with the series x. It seems they paid more attention to the PS5 version to the game and a bit lazy with series x and PC.

@Glock4All This is probably why I love the fact that Microsoft Surpina (I know misspelt) Sony so that we can see their dodgy dealings and expose them.

And acceptance is realizing your too broke to get either💀

@@CSTITAN576 ok now what lil man?

@@Jin-_-._.104more powerful but no games to play

kids these days are such cringe lords

Had a Harry Potter game on the gamecube, took ages to get anywhere due to loading times between each and every corridor :D

In early 2000s you didn't had a smartphone to write that comment, think of in that way

Not really in the 90s on cartridge everything was pre-loaded and there was no loading time, also later on with discs the loading wasn't as long as the Hdd PS4/Xbox One day's due to much much smaller files.

Yea,i remember how long it takes the loading times on smackdown 2 know your role on ps1.

rich

Amazing I found a 9 minute comment ​@@user-on6cd1ki4q

It's applied you can see the students reflections in the water but with low quality of course.

@@bambigoki3550 Those are screen space reflections, not raytraced.

​@@moca6655 Agree with you, i can notice that it ignore the far details plus some strange artifacts and blurred results.

Think its because its on easy or story difficult

On both PS5 and Series X I honestly couldn't tell much of difference in the reflections and was also questioning if something is "changing" even in performance mode the reflection's seems to be there and similar to fidelity ray tracing.

@@OpenSurprise Thanks, yeah I’ve wondered if my mind is playing tricks or something and it is actually off

what are u sayin

@Johnny joker i said everything in my comment. I elaborated.

Is that patch compatible with series s because i haven't seen it.

Probably a capture card. If your looking for the best entry level one that looks amazing and doesnt cost a house, check out the EVGA XR1 Lite

@@SpartanPhazed A state-of-the-art Elgato costs 180 bucks. You must live in a tent then, lol.

@@Flotter-Flo 6eah 180 dollars is still extremely expensive for something that just channels display to your pc. Something simple like the xr1 lite for around 50 bucks is more than enough.

I found this video looking for a different fix. I implemented the "no frame cap" and it fixed a graphic issue I've had since March 2023! I had just accepted the issue as a glitch. Thank you for posting!! FYI. Hogwarts Legacy is my first console game.

a piece of metal that pulls heat away from the drive to cool it down so it won't overheat and throttle, or slow down

yeah idk why he didn't show the frametime graph of the PS5 but did of the series X and then claims the PS5 is so much better, kinda weird right ?

@@oropher1234 he’s a notorious Sony Pony

@@MichaelM28 if that was the case, he wouldn’t have made the Series X look weak in this comparison, while he didn’t even post a fram graph for PS5. Don’t make yourself look dumb on the internet, cause you’re not built to survive it.

@@oropher1234just take the L already. If it was Xbox bring the better console for the game you would be saying the same thing. I don’t hate either console but Xbox lost this one. I hope they fix because my brother has Xbox and I’m getting him this game

@@gregorylynch9313 I play on pc, but i just wondered if console had the same stuttering issues, and it appears they have.

Don’t know if that’s an option in the game

Ps5 can brute force vrr in unsupported games not sure about Xbox but vrr is an option on ps5 and should of been covered

@@ragingpheonix8429 bro xbox had vrr since xbox one days. Playstation doesnt have freesync it only has hdmi vrr which works between 48hz and 120hz and the force vrr isnt great. Xbox has amd freesync which works as low as 20hz and supports every game flawlessly. Vrr removes all stuttering and fps drop issue’s on xbox. It should be used at all time since you dont need an hdmi 2.1 monitor for xbox unlike ps5’s vrr which needs hdmi 2.1

Well on Callisto Protocol, Sony had their own team working along the developers in the final state to ensure they were getting a good experience at launch. Microsoft didn't get that opportunity. So the game ran poorly on both xbox and pc at launch unfortunately... If we look back to the ps3/360 days, the roles were the opposite: ps3 games always had lower fps and suffered from several issues, while the 360 had it pretty good.

Bro the only reason is more optimized on ps5 it’s cause of the I/o Mike Cerny built .. which he said for promotion “ the ps5 will be the easiest and the fastest console to make games on “

It’s frustrating to see MS literally not care to make the moves needed to further their sales. Best they did was say “Buy Far Cry 6 on Xbox” with nothing special and the game ended up mediocre. They need serious internal change and to realize that not all exclusivity is bad.

Oh yeah? Tell that too Dead Space, Biomutant, 720P Forpsoken, I can do this all day 🤷🏻‍♂️💀

@@Warr3nP3ace and the list is higher on Xbox side of it with games not running as smooth as PS5

The same thing will happen with PlayStation according to someone else on these comments

Unfortunately no. If you uncap fps then yes.

Me too

Same here

All versions are like this way

you get those loading times before you pass a door thats when the game is implanting new a.i activities to see

Balanced mode with fps cap off gives me the best result for the Series X aswell for the Ps5! But on the Series X no loading times infront of the doors..

what is 40ps mode

@@TheLoKoProductions i think he means 30 fps

@@TheLoKoProductions Balanced target 1800p 40 fps on PS5 but you need a 120hz tv with VRR or the option dont appear

​@@tamasfeka5026 no 40FPS mode (balanced) only available with 120hz TVs.

@@paracuja lol that's kinda odd, why 40? :D i would rather play at 60 at that point

Haha no buddy Sonys “ I/o in the ps5 helps devs create faster that was Cernys whole point games take too long to make he made it way easier

@@fabolousjada5070 the IO and Magic ssd once again ? Yeah that shit didn't help for forspoken it runs at 720p 🤣

Depends on the pc. Mine and my brothers run better and look better than the consoles version without and upscaling unlike the console. I have both consoles and it’s true allot of the games are a touch better on PS5

@@GeniusEliteZ you dont understand risk decompression chip logic do ya pal, im a computer scientist and it really is impressive do some research you sound dumb. Ever wonder how the best looking game ever made runs on a gpu that performs similar operation rates as the 2070 super? No you didnt did you 😂😂 its called ssd culled c/5

It’s no ones fault but Microsoft that the Xbox is poorly engineered. Stop blaming it on the partnership 🥱

Just admit the ps5 is better

@@SLZRSLTHRIDon’t be a cringe console fanboy

Wow the ponies are cringe😂

Frame rates definitely got better but still has dips on my series X

@@SSwizzyMusic yeah bro I’m truly sorry I bought an Xbox lol 😂 shoulda got a ps5

I’ve seen them on series X for split seconds sometimes but almost non existent on PS5

get a faster ssd

Don’t forget the stutter issues on PC, it’s awful.

"More dev time"...maybe the xbox is just inferior when compared to the ps5. Ever thought of that? :)

@@JohnnyWalker1077 both consoles got same Apu? Think about that 🤔

@@JohnnyWalker1077 I've got both consoles and each one plays certain games better than the other. For example, I have found Cyberpunk has better resolution on the Series X, but frame rates, it's about even. With maybe the PS5 performing slightly better. But i dunno if I'm just imagining that. Dev focus does matter. Look at the 360 and PS3. On paper the PS3 was the better console, but almost all 3rd party games played better on the 360 as it was just easier for the devs.

@@profbawbag6604 I've got a PS5 and 5800x3d/6900xt PC so I'm going to buy it in a year on PC cos we all know why.

Same there's no need for a xbox when pc has all the games and more games and free online.

It's a great single player experience if you ask me, am also not into HP but i really like this game, also i kinda got into Harry Potter abit while playing the game not to the point i would watch all movies or read books but still i watched some videos as i was curious about HP plot and some things in game

Bro fr u have never watched Harry potter? No way, u have to give it a chance bro, ik is boring but is just the first 2 movies, after that is pretty good

When someone doesn’t like Harry Potter I assume they were like home schooled their entire life. Imagine high school/college with magic.

How old are you?

@@double_joseph327 bro, I'm 44 and I've never watched a single second of Any HP movie. The whole thing just seems so fucking Childish.

Yes drop fps make the game trash on xbox

Which mode?

@@SOTVT performance

That's rough buddy 😕

Terrible for me too so laggy and stuttery. Don’t get why more people aren’t talking about this .

It's a monitor based technology. If your monitor has VRR, you can enable FPS counter on your monitor. Or if you have a capture card, capture card can tell you how much FPS you get.

@Hy Gaming Yeah the duel sense controller is pretty cool and the audio sounds great. I love Dolby Atmos on the xbox though 😂

@Hy Gaming Xbox has 3D audio too

@Dallas Canada *"have both consoles but I prefer xbox overall. Better game selection"* LMAO! Oh you were serious? Never heard anyone say that before, especially when the PS5 has the latest Final Fantasy. The entire Spiderman series. God of War Ragnarok. Far more exclusives and more popular games on PS5. Thanks for the laugh.

​@@BlendingWithHenry dont forget marvel wolverine,horizon series, uncharted series, kill zone series and many more

@@BlendingWithHenry he said in HIS opinion, sheesh the internet is the only place where people will attack you for stating your opinions

I have the same problem but with PS5

Gotta have a good hdmi cable too

Whitch tv you have?

@teemunevalainen225 the tv don't matter its the input and output of your hdmi and how strong its is. Say you have a 120 hrtz tv with 4k. The hdmi may not be able to handle that it could be doing 1080p and 60 hrtz. It all depends on what your tv and game system supports and if the hdmi can handle that.because if the hdmi can't handle it your not gonna get the full experience. That's why I dropped 80 dollars on a hdmi

What is a Vrr tv?

Ja zauważyłem na swojej że czasami podczas podróży w zamku fps chwilowo spadały zobaczymy jak pójdzie na performance

the patch is out and now xbox is run the game better

@@spurksterly I’ll be sure and tell that to my other 55 inch RCA with a 60 Hz refresh rate.

60 fps? I have ps5 too and don’t see any difference to be honest between fidelity and fidelity with rt. So I play on rt. P.S. Yes, some of the surfaces have way too much reflection but the world outside hogwarts is amazing with rt

Fidelity both with and without RT is capped to 30fps... So good luck with your 60 fps and 120hz screen lol

@@iraklitulashvili2820 Why not Balanced mode? Your screen can't run it? It's way smoother than fidelity

ROFL 30fps and up to only 60fps upscaled on a 120hz display, hmm yea great performance, winning !

Gotta have 4k enabled on series x for hdr

Why do you think the ps5 has extra content? Warner bros and Sony are in love and will continue to do further deals, not just Harry Potter ips.

Exactly marketing scheme cuz ps5 sales was low

@@MrBoomane561 they already sold almost 24M units 🥱

@@MrBoomane561 lol

Get this on Ps5 , the haptic feedback and adaptive triggers for this game is amazing🙌

I have only 6h into it and didn't find the dualsense features to be thaaaat changing. There is always a VERY small resistance in the right trigger, from which you cast spells and that's basically it. The only game that felt like really using it right was Ghost of Tsushima. Haptics make you feel the difference of your horse throttling over a bridge, for example. The grappling hook and bow create extreme resistance in the trigger, a way stronger effect than that from Legacy.

@@fagundo13 I was so hoping it’d be like astros playroom where you can feel the stone of the castle floor and the mushy dirty path to hogsmeade. They kinda choked in that department and left me kinda disappointed. Oh and also when you’re in Gringotts and go under the water that disenchants you, I was hoping for controller noise and splash. Lol I’m rambling but it would’ve been sooo cool.

@@fagundo13 so what’s your point to play it on … yeah you seem like a hater

@@fabolousjada5070 wtf I'm enjoying the game, it just lacks dualsense features just like many other amazing games. No need to get all defensive for your dear Hogwarts 🤣🤣🤣 I was literally describing the dualsense presence to the guy who asked about it

Cope

It’s not that more powerful like ps4 vs Xbox one how ps4 was 50% more powerful Ps5 has a faster ssd and better higher clock gpu

Excuses. If the Xbox is more powerful then it should be more optimized then PS5 obviously. Many games on PS5 have better frame rates then Xbox of the same games. It's not all about power but which system the developers can optimize best on

Nobody cares about it if it is a fact that the ps5 just runs Games better than the Series X

Not really. Series X has been lagging behind PS5 for most games now. They both are similar machines but PS5 has 1 native 8k while that same game runs at 4k on series X

It's due to optimization. Since PlayStation is the more popular console, some developers tend to optimize better for it at launch and then patch the Xbox version later. Keep in mind that for this game, Sony actually has exclusive marketing rights as well as some exclusive content. In general however, the Series X runs games at slightly higher resolutions and ray tracing performance is comparatively better.

@@sundarchip that’s why ps5 is the better mid-high range console as of right now. All it’s games and exclusives are better than Xbox let’s be real

@@strawberrysherbet9679 It isn't. Most games run better on the Series X as I've pointed out. Exclusives are subjective. Personally, I'd take Halo and Forza over God of War and Spiderman any day. 90% of the games I play are Bethesda games anyway and practically no new Bethesda will be on the PS5.

@@sundarchip well I get ya. I’m a die hard Xbox fan too but ever since I went back to PlayStation cause my one x broke. I’m just like damn PlayStation really do be stealing hearts and sales cause every generation that comes out PlayStation has always been the hottest

@@sundarchip Gaylord is dead and borza is mid

Cracking? My ps5 is silent, perhaps yours is faulty as the plastic on mine is pretty cool to the touch.

@@amnrilyes unfortunately it cracks. Maybe you're right. I asked some other gamers. Some of them have either the same problem with cracking or other problems. But anyway i love both consoles

I have both too and the Xbox is definitely the better built one. I haven’t had any expansion related cracking sounds from the PS5 but the cooling fan developed a tinnitus inducing high pitched whine after a month. I had to buy a different brand one from an older model (there’s 4 different types, all of varying noise levels I found out). That and the disc drive is so loud it sounds like it’s about to take off and has made me veer towards digital only games for it. The Series X on the other hand has been silent since I got it in ‘21 lol.

@@michaelt8215 can you tell me which console to buy between the series x and ps5

@@btwits_tanjim most people would say the ps5 is better. I would recommend to choose what games you would prefer. If its games like spiderman or horizon forbidden west then of couse the ps5. If you just want a new console then i'd say xbox with game pass. In my opinion its about the games not the power of the consoles. Both have almost similar hardware. If it comes to controller the dual sense is way better. On xbox i play with a razer. Hope this will help

But it is though on the PS5 lol

Lol I have a series x and PS5 and wish I bought it on PS5 instead of Xbox

@@CahtzHD 😄

@@christianmarmol3230 It's also running like crap on pc. Is a ps5 more powerful than pc??

@@Kitcho771 yes

If you check my channel I do it for all my comparisons, you will find 100s of games.

L take, im an Xbox fanboy but the game 100% runs smoother on ps5, the facts are there, look at the comparison, series x literaly has loading doors….. it’s unplayable in hogsmeade, waste of Fucking 70 dollars, wish I had this on the ps5 to be honest

@@AntagonistVRseriously? I hope they fix it because I’m getting a PlayStation and I’m going to get this game but I’m also going to get this game for my brother and he has Xbox so I hope I don’t get it for him and it’s ass

@@gregorylynch9313 yea there are stutters non stop when anywhere in hogwarts, being in hogsmeade will give you i some stutters, and simply running around outside will give you slight stutters, it fucking sucks, I wish I had a ps5 to play this on there

@@AntagonistVR I got both because I’m an indecisive imbecile but I also love HP. It’s actually insane and maybe I’ll do a recording but I can run around on PS5 and I’ll get stutters at the corners or doors but like you said on Xbox its like every few seconds there’s a stutter. Both systems should be MASSIVELY OVERQUALIFIED to 60fps this game and just look at GTA5. You know how many scripts are probably running at the same time in that game, plus one of the largest gaming maps that has to be rendered in online for 30 people. Not sure what the excuse is when with 5 delays it still came out like this.

@@Joseph-vn8gh Yea it really sucks, I hope they don’t just overlook this and never patch it because no meat yet how many RU-vid videos I see, almost NO ONE is complaining about the stutters on console and all the attention is on pc, it sucks

After my Microsoft account was banned, and I was unable to get it back, I switched on over to PS5. This game is amazing on the PS5.

You should feel sorry for your self bud Sony fanboys are the most delusional fan base ever your spit shit just to make your selves feel better 😂😂😂 how sad and pathetic, ignoring how bad the ps5 and been underperforming in multiplat

Nah if they did, FTC would have caught it by now. It's because Microsoft sucks. Ever wonder why HDR sucks so badly on Windows? And it's UI is forever stuck at 96 ppi even in 2023?

Can you check the file sizes? I think PS5 games are smaller in size. I know for a fact the same game is smaller on PS5 than on PS4, for instance. (I know because I can choose between which version I download from the PSN when the game is available for both PS4 and PS5).

@@Vertignasse82 I have PS5 and Xbox Series X

Which console has better graphics?

@@bsam5161 Both look the same to be honest

@@bsam5161 And I’m playing on a 65 inch 4K tv from this year. It has all the bells and whistles and I can’t tell a difference at all.

You have a frame rate counter while playing on a Ps5?

@@Crashed131963 no but it’s so obvious in the game the stutters are noticeable

@@leona7558 do you have the latest patch? This video just proved the game stays at 60fps 90% and only dope to 50fps here and there . A 60fps few second drop to 50 fps is not going to be notice by the human eye .

yeah they're really bad

Finally someone is saying something about these fucking stutters on Xbox, I don’t see ANYONE talking about it, it makes it unplayable

@@AntagonistVR i agree, no one is talking, i feel like i am the only one

@@Pqradjse I REALLY hope they fix the stutters bc I can’t play like this, 70 dollars in the trash for now

Yeah the same problem on series s and pc The game on preformence mod she have mor drop fps its unplayable For this time the 30fps is the only solution until the next update

Maybe pay for this? I want see documents about the medium xsx have rt ps5 not, i wish if ps5 show all ftc want to ms do the same im 100 percent know the medium have been blocek rt on ps5 by ms, its funny thing cause vloober is polish studio and one of main devs be in popular morning tv show, and got question about lower power in ps5 and this could be reason why this version dont have rt, and he forget and say 😅 this is not true we cant do this cause of power, than next question be so why ps5 dont get rt, he starting be nervous and say he cant talk about details there is a reasons for some decision but he is not right person to talk about this😅😅😅😅. Do ms show documents!!!!!!! I dont be shock if ms paying for things like this. Weird situation with cyberpunk where xsx got 2 tribes and have more npc on street even on xss so if xss can have more npc a ps5 lower power reason have no sense, ms promoted cyberpunk and have marketing deal with cd projekt i really want see documents, if ftc want from sony documents they do the same with ms remember this, and cyberpunk deal stinky from miles. Everybody comments ms buy game mode in cp2027, u still believe ms like stupid xbot?

So what if they did. MS has bottomless coffers of money, but instead of using said money to help out with development, or heck, maybe get their shit together when it comes to the grab bag of studios they already own, they'd rather spend a country's worth of gdp to buy publishers that have traditionally served everyone, including the Xbox. I am a series X owner (it's the only current gen system I own), and I don't get why people are exited for something like an Activision acquisition. As a gamer who really isn't concerned with MS shareholders, I have literally nothing to gain from this.

@@JustFun-ho6qy It funny when people yap about the acquisition like it affects how much money Xbox 1st party Studios get for development 🤪 Sony bought All their best Studios and have always been the ones throwing more money around at 3rd party developers to block game before Xbox was even a thing and people cheered them for it🤷🏻‍♂️looks like Microsoft finally got sick of it and decided to start investing in their Xbox brand after 20yrs of minimal support. Nobody said Sony has been doing business the right or fair way just let these companies compete 🤯 Sony abusing their power/position as market leader to keep content off other platforms and control studios paying for exclusivity until they felt dependent on Sony.

@@JustFun-ho6qy Nothing to gain? An entire library of games will be added to Gamepass along with all future releases day 1 🤷🏻‍♂️ Xbox will gain a tonne of Studios and IP to make games for the Xbox platform many being exclusive 🤯 I couldn’t care less about COD and think selling off the IP and keeping all the Studios would be the great(probably won’t happen). COD would die without the Studios that have been making it, it would take years for a new studio to make COD from scratch and it wouldn’t really be the same, Warzone would fizzle be out without the amount of studios stuck supporting it. I want games like True Crime and Prototype being made for Xbox not more COD

@@JustFun-ho6qy There’s definitely Nothing to gain from Sony trying to block the deal Activision will continue being stuck as a COD machine wasting all the talent to develop COD every year and support Warzone. We’ll never see the Legacy or new IP from Activision or Blizzard. Under Microsoft there’s a good chance studios get freed up to make New games

sony paid for that

Xbox patch today. Now it runs smoother than ps5

@@Rebelscum264 No

@@lofi1598 Cope. Atomic Heart also runs better on PS5, as does Wild Hearts, neither of which have any kind of exclusivity deal with Sony.

@@dr_feelgood1902 and dead space remake runs better on xbox and many others stop lie dont trust those xbox runs games better

Your numbers are completely wrong my guy. In no way are you getting those numbers. PLEASE stop lying.

60fps on fidelity...ok 😂

LoL don't tell bullshit. Fidelity/RT is max 40fps this fucking game is ghosting

Which console has better graphics in your opinion?

@@bsam5161 honestly I feel like the color looks a little better on the ps5. They both look amazing! You can’t go wrong with either one. I’ve been a PlayStation fan since the beginning….. however the Xbox is badass too.

why buy an inferior console? XSX has no exclusives, just get the superior PC ports. Still cant believe people waste all that money on a Xbox Series X 🤣

Got one too past holiday no regrets buddy your get higher performance in most multiplats and Xbox has good exclusives and more are on the way. Just ignore fanboys and have fun 🤩

@@Hazzan34085 thanks 😁 🤞

Get a ps trade in ur Xbox if u can. Both are good systems but Xbox at this point has no business charging the same amount as ps5 for there console when it's clearly inferior.

@@120382brian Yeah I thought about trading in my series x for a ps5 but all my friends are on Xbox atm, so will probably stick with Xbox for now

This performance count is very different from El Analista de Bits, there Series X performs better in most modes and Digital Foundry already said that Series X is more powerful... ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5cKmXJBBXvc.html

@@120382brian It has zero to do with the console 😂🤡

@@yesc3786 dont listen to this clown the game running better on xbox affter patch

It's enough to be impressive how there is a child in this world who discusses the console just like you lol.

Watch the video again… the pic on the right is better easily… The lighting is much better. PlayStations is always to saturated for my taste

?

Ouch right? 🤣🤣🤣

@@BlazeInferno360 ?

Leader of what?😂

@@riot9179 leader of the world!