Holding Long and Cutting Short: 2 Brilliant Moments in Editing

Подписаться 3,7 млн

Просмотров 1,5 млн

50% 1

This weeks list is a close up look at a pair of brilliant editing moments. One from the film Ida, a cut lingers for what seems like an eternity, the other from No Country For Old Men, where the edit cuts short to remarkable effect.
Let us know what you think about these 2 moments and also be sure to let us know if you have any other great moments of holding long or cutting short that we didn't mention.
As always, subscribe to Cinefix for more of our Movielists and Brilliant Moments!
More Recent Cinefix Videos:
Things You Didn't Know About Jaws!
• 7 Things You (Probably...
Make You Own Mega Man Costume
• Make Your Own Mega Man...
Star Trek Beyond - CineFix Review!
• Star Trek Beyond - Cin...
The Infiltrator - CineFix Review!
• The Infiltrator - Cine...
Make Leeloo Dallas’ Costume from The Fifth Element - DIY Costume Squad
• Make Leeloo's Outfit f...
7 Scariest Movie Moments of All Time
• Scariest Movie Moments...
The Bourne Identity - What's the Difference?
• The Bourne Identity - ...
DIY Costume Squad - Poe Dameron's X-Wing Suit!
• Make Poe Dameron's X-W...
Ghostbusters Review!
• Ghostbusters - CineFix...
7 Things You Didn't Know About Star Trek!
• 7 Things You (Probably...
3 Brilliant Moments from Game of Thrones!
• 3 Brilliant Moments fr...
Things You Didn't Know About the Rock!
• 7 Things You (Probably...

Кино

Опубликовано:

31 июл 2016

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1,2 тыс.

@GhostShakz 8 лет назад

No county for old men is such an amazing movie

@skuzzyj 8 лет назад

Seriously, every time they bring up a scene, I'm reminded just how spectacular that adaptation was. If it isn't the Cohen brother's best work, it's definitely a very, very close second.

@VoiceofKane3 8 лет назад

+SkuzzyJ What's number one? Fargo or The Big Lebowski?

@TheEternalOuroboros 8 лет назад

i was bored.

@Aeon2Flux 8 лет назад

+Brady Snyder Raising Arizona.

@Gravitynaut 8 лет назад

+Brady Snyder Fargo is their best movie, at least for me. No Country is a masterpiece but Fargo is just so unique and yet just as thought provoking as Country. It's funny yet bleak, and the characters are some of the most memorable ever put to film. It's easily my favorite Coen Brothers and one of my favorite films, No Country falling just barely behind. The Big Lebowski is good for a surreal laugh too.

@HDmexsComboCon 8 лет назад

The Hanging Scene from 12 Years a Slave was gut wrenching and tragically a masterpiece. It conveyed what it needed to and then made it better by staying on that shot for as long as it did.

@bobunitone 8 лет назад

As was later on where it stays on a close up of his face for a long time. You really feel his horror.

@HDmexsComboCon 8 лет назад

I am mentioning the spot that happened at 0:30. But I am aware of the scene you are mentioning too.

@ssharkbait 8 лет назад

I was happy they did a little mention to 12 Years. The editing in that movie is fantastic.

@atayookee 8 лет назад

Yes, I agree. That long shot was "too long." I was so uncomfortable watching it as someone who isn't a person-of-colour. A movie with a great long shot relative to what's going on is the ending and pieces of "Come and See," which is a Russian war film from the 80s. The long shots are very short in duration, but they carry a lot of weight because they jump back to the same image.

@HDmexsComboCon 8 лет назад

***** anyone that is not white/Caucasian. lol

@hicks727 7 лет назад

if he didn't check his boots he would have made it through the light

@nashtravelandlifestyle 3 года назад

😂😂

@belmondo3330 3 года назад

Yeah but he did that to make sure there is no blood on his boots after he killed her

@hugoescobar6339 3 года назад

Holy shit

@2Darkaiser 2 года назад

@@belmondo3330 thats what he is trying to imply... the fact that there was no need to kill her but did it anyways and doing so he took time instead of just leaving with the money...

@RaniShrividya 2 года назад

Lol

@geogaddi6215 7 лет назад

no country for old man is just a masterpiece.

@whoisbhauji 2 года назад

Absolute. Is it that the original material is so good? Is it the casting, acting, editing, minimal music, desert landscape? So many experts have tried to explain why it's good... but somehow it seems beyond all the explanations.

@arizonaarmadillo5829 10 месяцев назад

Hardly. It was humming along quite well for the longest time, but that ending was a bad joke. Almost as if the producer had thrown up his hands and told them, "Okay let's get this damn thing wrapped up. I don't care how you do it. We're out of money." When it won the Academy Award for Best Picture I almost put a brick through my screen.

@ahmedimamovic8896 10 месяцев назад

@@arizonaarmadillo5829 Nah man, you just didn't understand it, that's all.

@reymondlopez7468 8 лет назад

absolutely love how you guys break down a scene. makes you appreciate a movie more

@plumlogan 8 лет назад

if you dig this, check out nerd writer's video on Hitchcock framing a scene

@orlandocruz1036 7 лет назад

check out Every Frame A Painting. that channel is awesome

@blnstr9321 5 лет назад

It is WAY too much thinking and bullshit. That is what excruciating breakdown of detail for a scene in a movie is.

@user-mi4rm7ih6s 8 лет назад

Great video, and I differ slightly on the interpretation of Chigurh's car crash. To me it's not solely about audience misdirection to illustrate the significance of chance, but also to criticize Chigurh's ideology as delusional. Throughout the film Chigurh is presented and referred to as something more inhuman than a regular bad guy, something more like a force of nature. It's also pretty clear that Chigurh buys into his own hype, having people call HIS coin toss for their survival while making it unmistakably clear that he believes it is fate rather than himself that is directing his actions. However, Chigurh himself is not above fate and Elizabeth tells him as much before he kills her. It's no coincidence that this scene comes right before his car crash. I don't think he survived to indicate that chance is the only reality but rather to avoid indicating that karma is the only reality. His survival indicates that evil has always existed and always will exist (to believe otherwise is vanity) but his random and serious injury (differing thematically from his earlier injuries in the film by being irrelevant to his amorality, hence the Coens making sure to indicate that he had the green light) indicates that fate does not protect its worshipers any more than its deniers.

@timy9197 8 лет назад

Agreed. I couldn't have worded that better myself.

@superkang7448 8 лет назад

Spot on.

@DodderingOldMan 8 лет назад

Damn, I like that analysis.

@Unpossible8888 8 лет назад

Precisely. Another small scene that highlighted Chigurh's all too human fallibility was the one where he missed a shot directed at a crow by the road. Hardly an unstoppable force of nature.

@ulaytube9953 8 лет назад

Really? These thoughts actually crossed your mind? You're seriously analysing something to such an extent? Are you just trying to sound smart? I think you are...

@harryalerta 8 лет назад

I love how this kind of list is more meaningful and full of content because you explain the greatness of the scenes.

@luca_hc_gruber 8 лет назад

I think that was a bit too over analysed for my taste

@NaijaCINE 8 лет назад

That's because the folks at CineFix are students of film, not just regular film watchers

@MegamanStarforce2010 8 лет назад

+ Sulaymaan Dar Yes they would, in brilliant films like this. The level of thought is in fact the reason these films are so great.

@NaijaCINE 8 лет назад

You might appreciate the 'pretentious analysis' if you ever were put in the position to actually create a film. It's like creating your own little universe; layers and layers of genius functioning in front of and behind the scenes that goes completely unnoticed by the common consumer, just like in everyday life; we don't realize the level of living complexity happening around us all the time, cause we're so used to it; we're not paying attention. We don't need to actually, but we can appreciate it when people point on the brilliance in the seemingly mundane; and that's what folks like CineFix do.

@MegamanStarforce2010 8 лет назад

Sulaymaan Dar But *why* were they brilliant to watch? This is one of the many reasons why. You didn't notice, but these types of subtle editing tricks have a massive effect on what you're thinking while you're actually watching. This is merely describing these effects you didn't notice in detail.

@Moscato_Moscato 8 лет назад

Cinefix can you please do more of these videos!

@MousePounder 8 лет назад

@GioRodz 8 лет назад

PLEASE!

@sophieward7225 8 лет назад

@sjoerdwennekes 8 лет назад

@harrypedro 8 лет назад

@Murilo5150 8 лет назад

Prisoners is an AMAZING movie. Seriously..

@eggycat 8 лет назад

Couldn't agree more!

@Ayvee1138 8 лет назад

Yes it is my friend, yes it is

@d3lay3d36 8 лет назад

hugh jackman shouldve won academy award

@BAlexThompson 8 лет назад

I wish that they used Prisoners as their second example instead of No Country.

@vb2388 8 лет назад

Absolutely...my favourite from 2013...and the director of that film is making Blade Runner 2...can't wait for that!

@timalphadog2 8 лет назад

I need to watch No Country. Even tho I'm pretty sure it's been spoiled for me 10 times over.

@ramairgto72 8 лет назад

Bruce Willis is dead. :D It's worth a watch, it's got some great "one liners" and great sittings. This movie really needs a part2.

@MrJammybob1 8 лет назад

It's a fantastic film, beautiful in it's simplicity. Yet it's still a great thriller, alongside being a very interesting and thoughtful narrative. Seriously worth a watch if you love film.

@johnsmith5669 8 лет назад

It's not so much a plot heavy movie, I'd say. Spoilers couldn't ruin the film because it's about symbolism, emotion, character, and dialogue. The same could arguably be said about any Coen Brothers' movie.

@sidharthaa 8 лет назад

get ready for awesomeness to watch it!!!

@BOKtober 8 лет назад

I assure you it hasnt been spoiled for you, you will be pretty much dumb founded but feel the need to watch it again. Such an amazing piece of film making and made even better by the use of ambient noises as the soundtrack which adds an awesome layer of realism and grit to the movie, its also very darkly humored

@beninglis8097 7 лет назад

That exorcist 3 scene they reference makes me feel ill. You are wound up and lured into a false sense of security so perfectly, then somewhere between letting your guard down and realising you are still on the hook... BAM!

@michaelbloomer451 4 года назад

Best jump scare in cinema

@MrBeastknows 8 лет назад

Honestly, never see Ida but watching that scene for the first time, right as she opened the window I literally thought "welp, see ya downstairs then" lol. I had no suspicion, I knew basically right away. That usually happens for scenes like those, not sure how everyone else sees them.

@MrBeastknows 8 лет назад

The No Country for Old Men scene was excellent when I first saw it. Maybe if I saw Ida and its scene before this video, maybe I would've been more affected.

@Nevi234 8 лет назад

yeah as soon as I saw the window open and the camera linger, i knew it would happen. same for when i first saw that game of thrones episode. i'm guessing that was the point. i still think letting the shot linger is a good technique, as it lets the audience think about what's about to happen. Ida's a pretty good film.

@bobunitone 8 лет назад

Ida is a spectacular little film. The compositions alone are enough to watch it.

@07foxmulder 8 лет назад

Yeah, it was pretty obvious why the scene was fixed on the window.

@MegamanStarforce2010 8 лет назад

That was the point really. Maybe people won't be as fast as you, but a shot lingers so it can give you a chance to anticipate what happens next. It could've not happened outright, but you 'expected' that it would, because that's what they wanted you to do. It wasn't a surprise, just something that's meant to slowly sink in.

@rorychiovitti3257 8 лет назад

I kinda knew she was gonna jump out the window, i just had a feeling...

@kissmyasthma3155 8 лет назад

Never seen the movie but does she die or survive?

@222browneyes 8 лет назад

I think that's what made the scene effective for me; her jump is inevitable, and we just have to watch and wait.

@cefa99 8 лет назад

she died

@therev012ify 8 лет назад

+Sue Donym well, no shit lol

@nothingimportant5203 8 лет назад

i thought she was gonna cut her wrists in the bathtube,

@SuperGetlife 8 лет назад

Honestly, in my opinion the Coens are the best working filmmakers today. They write, direct and even edit their films. They tell their stories exactly how they want to and damn that creative control pays off.

@turkeygrasslesnatch4742 7 лет назад

The long cut at the end of Episode 24 of Evangelion is one of my favorite long cuts and one of the few drawn out scenes in animation. You don't quite understand the drama upon first viewing, but it makes much more sense on multiple viewings.

@mike92505 4 года назад

Exorcist III was one of most underrated horror movies of all time. They didn't have to resort to the battle in the cell with the priests. The old catholic hospital scene was one of the most chilling ever. Totally caught me off guard with the late night. light duty personnel between changing shifts, and the false sense of security with the police officer, checking the hallways. Those little noises in the quiet, just enough to peak the interest of the nurse, was absolutely brilliant. Loved it, and loved Brad Dourif, one of his most iconic roles this side of LOTR.

@diegosanchezescobar2159 8 лет назад

Why just 2, why not 5960?

@tincano-beans2114 8 лет назад

they just wanted to no country for old men (because it's literally the best movie of all time and no other movie can ever be as good as it *sarcasm*) but 1 movie isn't a technical list sooo...

@diegosanchezescobar2159 8 лет назад

+Alex Kerley I agree with half of that, but you cant make a list of just 2 man, not even 3. You don't see Top 2s or 3s running through the streets naked, do you?

@PVC_640_XXX 8 лет назад

Ha! Funny you'd say that cause yesterday...

@zemagiko8570 8 лет назад

it's not an Intel processor.

@Daniel-Rosa. 8 лет назад

This takes *_work,_* my friend!

@unemployicus 6 лет назад

"A story has two parts: its narrative, the story that is being told, and its narration, the way that its being told." Narration is what makes Kubrick's movies so great. There's a lot more to their meaning/a deeper meaning then what the characters are communicating through dialogue.

@MrMomoitin 7 лет назад

watching CinFfix is like taking every film class at college but 100 times better. you learn more watching these and its free!

@jadelynnopal 7 лет назад

There's another meaning to the jump cut used in No Country. The end of a jump cut in a scene like that implies that you've already seen what was important in that scene. Let''s take another look at what happened. He walked out of the building and checked his shoes. Now, I don't know about you, but I find it an interesting turn of events to first walk out of a building and THEN check the bottoms of your shoes to see if there's something on them. Which raises the question of what he could be expecting to see when he checks down there. Using logic based on what was in the scene just prior to that one, it should be fairly obvious that the Coen Bros actually gave us an answer to that implied question.

@lustgarten 5 лет назад

not a big deal, but cutting from him in one scene to another is a "cut" not a jump cut.

@ROVideos 7 лет назад

I thank RU-vid algorithm fo recommending this to me. Now I'm a subscriber.

@MyLifeJapanTV 8 лет назад

You make learning about filmmaking SO much fun! Your channel is simply BRILLIANT.

@forformgamer 7 лет назад

I just cant get enough of the videos talking about the art form that's cinema. This is great!

@FloraWest 7 лет назад

That shoe check was so fantastic. I almost jumped out of my seat in the theater.

@joshwinter1097 8 лет назад

The final shot in Prisoners is tremendous.

@vincentknight27 8 лет назад

I love these videos "Brilliant moments" so much. Seriously your examination and the way you do your video essays really interesting Thanks for doing these

@paksta 8 лет назад

Yes! I love trying to 'get' movies and decode the message the director is sending when you realise everything has meaning and purpose. You took my appreciation of cinema to a whole new level. Thank you!

@NaijaCINE 8 лет назад

My vocabulary increases every time I watch a CineFix video

@molesticles 8 лет назад

Remember a spoiler alert is sometimes necessary Ida is relatively new and only about 1/1000 people have seen it. The moment you chose is the fulcrum on which the movie works. Be careful not to ruin cinema for first time viewers. I'm lucky because I've watched a huge amount of the best movies ever made, but I'm only 27. Be aware that most people wouldnt have the breadth of film knowledge as yourself and once in a while throw them a bone offhandedly while you write. But yeah... another exceptionally well done video. Keep up the good work.

@SpecificallyDanielSwan 8 лет назад

These brilliant moments videos are so good. Like a film school that you don't pay for and attend in your underwear.

@howryou5144 4 года назад

My all time favorite movie no country for old man.

@bizmonkey007 8 лет назад

When it comes to the long shot, it's not just the editing, but the direction as well. The director, in key instances, is the one that makes the decision to hold the shot longer. Both work together in the editing room to ultimately shape the film.

@coyotesong 4 года назад

I've been a fan of the Coen bros since their first release, Blood Simple, which shares many qualities with No Country--taking place in Texas, moody, violent moments, intelligent. similar to other commenters, the first time i saw it i was like ok, good, but no big deal. I went back and was utterly blown away by its perfection. The conversation about the coin between Kelly McDonald and Javier Bardem was in my mind the critical essence of the film.

@TheJanvicgwaps 8 лет назад

No Country for Old Men is the best from the Coen Brothers but then again Fargo.

@trevorminyard8885 8 лет назад

And The Big Lebowski

@TheJanvicgwaps 8 лет назад

THE DUDE!

@daviddicken8394 8 лет назад

The Man Who Wasn't There was a good film, its very odd but i liked the storytelling and Beethovens' Pathetique Symphony melded quite well with the film.

@TheJanvicgwaps 8 лет назад

NetHandle WompaOne My personal Fav is Burn After Reading haha I dunno why.

@TASCmedia 8 лет назад

Watch their film A Serious Man. It is very strong.

@nathansilva8141 8 лет назад

You guys made me love No country For Old Men even more than i already do

@Ayvee1138 8 лет назад

These are my favorite type of cinefix videos! Keep em coming!

@louislafontaine6068 7 лет назад

My comment got here the same way the coin did

@bridgetsilver7332 5 лет назад

Louis LaFontaine 🤣 Well done!

@michael-1453 4 года назад

You know whats the date on this comment? 1958.

@hakan341 7 лет назад

he checks his boots to see if there is blood. in my opinion there is a meaning. it says something about the character

@flyersruleJC24 8 лет назад

these videos are BRILLIANT. they make me so happy

@zman7117 7 лет назад

Thank you for finally explaining No Country For Old Men!!

@sanjaygond 7 лет назад

The Universe has no justice;just cause effect and little chance - almost poetic 👏👏

@Divineshot 6 лет назад

Very informative.

@DJTheMetalheadMercenary 7 лет назад

"Life is just cause, effect, and a little chance." Brilliant man.

@timespace.productions7513 8 лет назад

Thank you so much for including Haneke! I believe no living director understands stillness like him.

@Charly-Music 8 лет назад

Damn I love these videos

@amunra7173 8 лет назад

I always thought it was pretty obvious that the Bardem shoe check was a solid indicator that she'd been killed. He displays a specific amount of attention to his foot tracks throughout, from putting his feet up, to killing in his socks & removing them. So, that he checks his shoes, is all we need to know of that scene. It's brilliant execution of direction, literally. They literally direct you to make that connection. My personal favorite Coen film

@abbykimmes9457 8 лет назад

Brilliant. Both cuts had me guessing, and yet I saw them coming. I love analyses like these!

@jakeboos9860 8 лет назад

literally the best channel on RU-vid

@vinsanimo 8 лет назад

more of these less movie reviews

@judaychop 8 лет назад

Assistant TO the regional manager.

@sophieward7225 8 лет назад

@sjoerdwennekes 8 лет назад

@peace4myheart 8 лет назад

Agreed. I find the reviews a bit annoying. Watched one and couldn't finished. Never watch any other reviews after that.

@thylordprang4197 8 лет назад

agreed

@anonymouschicken8735 8 лет назад

I thought it was pretty obvious she was going to jump. Maybe I'm just fucked up, but the clues were there.

@BAlexThompson 8 лет назад

Same here. But the way it was done was very beautiful and earned. I want to see the whole film as I've never heard of it before.

@anonymouschicken8735 8 лет назад

+B. Alex Thompson I second all of that, haha

@JupitersDancer 8 лет назад

That's exactly what he explained

@Monkstar1 7 лет назад

I agree. Maybe that long shot of her silently sitting in the tub smoking was a huge clue. And if so, they didn't need the window shot (unless the window is important story-wise). If they showed the tub scene and then cut to her body on the street, we would've known the same info. If they showed the tub scene and then a regular duration window shot with her jumping, we would've known the same info.

@montagproject 7 лет назад

Yes it's pretty obvious from this clip, because upfront You expect that there will be something special and unexpected in that scene, but believe me, in the movie it does surprise more, because we see Wanda as strong and cold, not a person that would think about suicide really. By the way, both movies are great.

@royalirish6246 8 лет назад

these lists are what makes this channel great

@shayharvey1174 8 лет назад

Excellent analysis Cinefix. I'm always engrossed in your videos. Good job and keep up the good work.

@rsm5173 7 лет назад

No county for old men is a typical coen brothers ending. Fargo, Burn After Reading, the Big Lebowski. All end without a typical story resolution. This is not to say it's a bad thing, I for one love it. I love it when average audiences get annoyed with is subversion of expectations.

@CaptainKronkers 6 лет назад

RSM The Big Lebowski has probably my favorite ending to any movie ever

@pete49327 5 лет назад

@@CaptainKronkers Wasn't it a guy rolling a bowling ball? Or maybe Sam Elliot doing his cowboy thing?

@CaptainKronkers 5 лет назад

@@pete49327 Both

@RainbowDreams321 8 лет назад

Your channel is like a wonderful film class. Thank you

@Tairai_Daos 8 лет назад

This makes me want to take a refresher movie class again. This was quite enjoyable

@LucasA84 8 лет назад

absolutly love these types of videos. keep it up.

@theohayes7119 8 лет назад

I would love it if you covered the Grand Budapest Hotel's cinematography. I'm sure it would be an interesting video, plus I'd love to see what you make of the "squared-off" style.

@ikethenerd8942 8 лет назад

10 emotional/moving moments in film. Parts where the music, acting, cinematography, and or editing provided that extra little sucker punch of feels?

@Euphytoseful 8 лет назад

The last battle of The Last Samurai is one of the moments that always bring me on the verge of crying even though I've seen the movie like 10 or more times.

@thejohntremendol 8 лет назад

great idea for a list!

@07foxmulder 8 лет назад

The final five minutes of United 93. I've watched that film a few times and that last few minutes always leave me mentally and emotionally exhausted.

@shoujahatsumetsu 8 лет назад

The suicide scene in When The Last Sword Is Drawn.

@hockyjocky4 8 лет назад

"The Greatest Game Ever Played": After Shia Lebouf's character wins tournament his dad is there tipping him money. I cried OUT LOUD like a wounded animal once they showed him on screen, and I'm not even afraid to admit it

@NewNormalWorldOrder 8 лет назад

No Country for Old Men is EXACTLY what a film is SUPPOSED to be. It's my all time favorite movie.

@BloodShotComet 8 лет назад

Absolutely love these kind of videos, learn so much in such detail too. Keep these kind of videos coming CineFix :)

@rileybrooks5982 7 лет назад

My video froze at "maybe the director's just lingeri-" and I thought it was a joke

@jaxpk2669 8 лет назад

MORE MORE MORE MORE!

@youthnation1 8 лет назад

Love it! Keep them coming.

@jesusdominguez5733 8 лет назад

These videos are awesome, I hope you keep making more like this one because editing it's an underestimated art form and almost anyone talks about it.

@opedromagico 7 лет назад

DAMN! That is some content!! Thanks guys! ~faço videos tb~

@12ealDealOfficial 8 лет назад

Plainly obvious I'm a Vertigo fan, but the scene of Judy's complete transformation is a scene I'd love to see analyzed on CineFix.

@TheGeorgeD13 8 лет назад

Yeah, speaking of that film's director, Hithcock is a masterful editor. Well, he's a masterful filmmaker overall.

@StreetHierarchy 8 лет назад

I absolutely love the cutting on the graveyard dream sequence.

@Monkstar1 7 лет назад

Hichcock was a masterful storyboarder. Every shot was planned out ahead of time. He didn't just shoot a lot of random shots so he could 'edit' them into his masterpieces.

@12ealDealOfficial 7 лет назад

Monkstar1 Let's not forget, Hitch planned out every facet in pre production so well he would just trust his crew, simply sitting on set and letting the picture almost take care of itself.

@Minorheadlines 8 лет назад

I love your channel, always a pleasure to watch and learn!

@antonio-hi5rm 8 лет назад

These kinds of videos is why I love this channel

@ntinakoulas 7 лет назад

Now i want to be a director

@feedelstick4670 5 лет назад

For the moment when Anton check his boots while going out of the house, it actually has an importance: it tells us that the girl died. In the whole film, we can see that Anton wants his boots to be clean. So him checking if there is blood on his boots is a clue about the fact that he killed the girl.

@l-zam6344 7 лет назад

These videos help me to appreciate films more. Thanks

@RathFGC 8 лет назад

These are the best movie videos, period. Thanks (:

@fernandabritobandeira6998 7 лет назад

Together with the NAME of the movie, will be amazing if you put the YEAR of the movie

@quentinlewis1153 7 лет назад

Amazing video, as always. However, I always perceived the cut of Chigurh leaving the house as something more maningful that it seems. It is a way of showing the audience that he is checking the boots, hinting to the fact that he has probably killed Carla Jean Moss. Indeed, throughout the movie we have seen that Chigurh is really conscious about his boots after a killing, so in my opinion it is a way of implying that he is checking if they are still clean and untouched by Carla's blood.

@geraldricoguevara3340 Год назад

Perfect. I waited for this analysis in the video, and only got it here! You sir are sharp!

@Firefighterboi 8 лет назад

these open my eyes so much

@Ziziky 8 лет назад

You guys are just downright amazing.. Thank you for everything you do..

@riparianlife97701 8 лет назад

You might have finally redeemed "No Country For Old Men" for me, after dozens have tried and failed. Good catch on King Tommen's window jump being a ripoff.

@brotherdantheman5409 8 лет назад

I think the word you're looking for is derivative.

@riparianlife97701 8 лет назад

Patrick Reedy Call it an homage if you want, but it's still a copy. It wasn't an original idea.

@judahhooper2619 8 лет назад

shortest list ever...........

@judahhooper2619 8 лет назад

that doesnt even make sense?

@bobunitone 8 лет назад

I read it like the Comic Book Guy from the Simpsons.

@MegamanStarforce2010 8 лет назад

That's a good thing. It gives them a chance to show the scenes in their full state, and give the audience the idea of 'why' they're so brilliant, without being overly long or redundant.

@judahhooper2619 8 лет назад

yeah no fucking shit Raft Lack

@raftlack4326 8 лет назад

Judah Hooper =D

@freestylerja16 8 лет назад

I love it so much!! Awesome work as usual!!

@chriskasatka2095 5 лет назад

All movies with long cuts, silence and/or rain give me a giant woody.

@extendedtrailermusic2646 8 лет назад

"'No,' the movie says. _'No.'_"

@limbolegs 7 лет назад

I'm really good at guessing what is going to happen in a movie right before it happens

@aidan499 6 лет назад

Congratulations

@Lunarthief357 8 лет назад

I learn so much watching these videos!

@StereoChimps 7 лет назад

best channel about movies i love it !!! it all make so sense !

@tonyconniff 6 лет назад

This is great! BUT... please don't run irrelevant music under and through the movies you're showing. Trust the movies' soundtracks... or silence. Thanks.

@531ff 5 лет назад

Tony Conniff or just make a video yourself

@muffinman5741 7 лет назад

I hate how european movies always make people always directly commit suicide when anything remotely sad happens to them

@jamesforster3713 5 лет назад

I think you should watch the film, it is fairly justified in this scene.

@fabellyd.9213 8 лет назад

I love learning from these videos and how they are explain with so much passion!

@tylerh5990 7 лет назад

I really appreciate the over-analyzing. Seriously, from a film watchers perspective, it's on point. However, from an average movie goers perspective, the beauty of these intricacies goes mostly unnoticed. Thanks.

@sumitdev6914 7 лет назад

Who else think that Ida's long shot was stupid but No Country For Oldmen's is classy?

@kevinmathewson4272 6 лет назад

it's only stupid if the emotional weight of the scene is completely lost on you

@BFG-hv2ml 6 лет назад

I never seen that movie but maybe if i’d do, i would understaaaaaaaaaaand 🎶

@pavellawesome 7 лет назад

I don't know, man. Sometimes it seems that you people try to find too much in films. I mean, maybe it is just one of those long scenes that Coens like to put in their works. There's no need to search for the meaning all the time. Sometimes there isn't any.

@michaelshearer8155 6 лет назад

nonsense

@kevinmathewson4272 6 лет назад

In this case you're actually wrong. You're wrong because the scene really does produce the effect he's describing. It's not a hidden meaning, it's an effect. It's not "Interpret the flow of this shot as the following verbal meaning _____." It's not code on the back of a cereal box. It's an effect, and we all felt that effect when we watched the movie, so when he talks about it we all think "Yeah, that is correct, that is how it felt." The shot produces a certain effect, and he dissects why it produces that effect.

@rollercoasterdude96 6 лет назад

I dunno, everything in No Country felt extremely deliberate. There are many filmmakers, on the other hand, who overload their works with lengthy shots without recognizing their purpose or impact. If people just like to stick long shots in their films for the hell of it then it's pretty easy to recognize that they don't carry any weight.

@Fennec333 8 лет назад

I appreciate the new captions with the titles!

@ApertureofmyEye 7 лет назад

This entire channel is so incredible. If you love the craft of filmmaking it's worth your time to watch every single video.

@whoisbhauji 2 года назад

every frame a painting was the best... cut short like the second example

@molesticles 8 лет назад

Thanks for reminding me to watch No Country For Old Men again. To think that that movie is 10 years old makes my mind feel smaller.

@MattSolnick 8 лет назад

Thank you. Thank you so god damn much for this channel.

@zapillofilms 8 лет назад

Congratulations for the video! Specially the comparison between the scene from 'No Country for Old Men' edited as in the movie and edited in a more conventional way. You can really appreciate the importance of the editing with that simple but brilliant example.