Spongebob Halloween had a gray disc because it was a reissue with a different cover, but the other two never got reissued which is why they have the original artwork.
Well I know the SpongeBob Christmas one did get a reissue with a new cover, so not exactly true. I don't know if the To Love a Patty one ever got a new cover art or not.
I have that dvd, But i have those 3 dvd's Individually. I Have both The 2002 print and 2011 reprint Of Halloween. And another 2011 reprint of halloween in a spongebob scary pants collection slipcover. I have The 2008 reprint of Spongebob Christmas, And it Contains the original 2003 disc art. And I have to love a patty on DVD.
To love a patty is dumb. It's not even a valentines day episode. I'm not sure why they didn't include the episode "Valentine's Day" from season 1. Its literally in the title. I wonder if Nick did this to promote the newer episodes.
He didn't say it was the worst episode he just doesn't care about it at all because the SpongeBob to love a patty DVD has a whole bunch of new episodes from later seasons
