Тёмный

Hong Kong youth groups reject to march the PLA way 

South China Morning Post
Подписаться 4 млн
Просмотров 191 тыс.
50% 1

Subscribe to our RU-vid channel here: sc.mp/2kAfuvJ
China’s Liaison Office in Hong Kong recently asked 14 military-style youth groups to abandon British foot drills and instead adopt those used by the People’s Liberation Army. But, at a flag-raising ceremony on May 4, only one of the groups complied with the request.

Опубликовано:

 

7 май 2018

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 998   
@RickyPlayingGames
@RickyPlayingGames 3 года назад
Dude, let's be real here, if you been training marching for months and then near d-day they asked you to change how you would ussually march, your brain would spinning and ultimately blow
@yw8990
@yw8990 3 года назад
That's what I thought too. Wait until the next ceremony to see how it goes.
@saveriannathan1415
@saveriannathan1415 3 года назад
Up this one as a marching band personel
@AZ-ov4uc
@AZ-ov4uc 3 года назад
Bro you are best non political logic
@godofnothing520
@godofnothing520 3 года назад
Just do another training i don't see the reason why not.
@delta5-126
@delta5-126 3 года назад
Muscle memory if im correct?
@hongkongchief1879
@hongkongchief1879 5 лет назад
Interesting, i didnt know Hong Kong has youth groups formed to emulate army, air force and navy where Hong Kong itself does not have one
@Kobi-um7bj
@Kobi-um7bj 5 лет назад
@@ashton6478 Resistance to China is futile said the Borg.
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
We don’t have a military, but we have water police and Government Flying Service
@62294838
@62294838 3 года назад
This is the remnant of the British where hk used to have the presence of the military force. In the U.K. there’s the University Unit of Royal Navy and Army too.
@laowai9105
@laowai9105 3 года назад
Hong Kong has an army. The peoples liberation army take care of Hong Kongs defense needs against foreign or domestic reactionaries
@camelo1495
@camelo1495 3 года назад
@@laowai9105 I guess you take care of people's opinions and we should not have one but be appointed an opinion by a higher service. Which department is that?
@apiatkowski7183
@apiatkowski7183 3 года назад
I love how people are saying that people were treated so poorly under british administration. People in Hong Kong lived far longer than mainland Chinese due to not having to endure Mao's collectivist policies. And when HK was handed back to China most people with money, education, or democratic values moved to other parts of the commonwealth. Like in canada there is a massive HK population due to the mass exodus of people fleeing the PRC.
@ComedyLoverGirl
@ComedyLoverGirl 2 года назад
You're ignoring the fact that Chinese people lived much worse lives in the late Qing and ROC eras; this is the reason why the PRC was formed in the first place. It took time to lift the massive country out of poverty. Meanwhile in Hong Kong, though they became wealthy due to being a financial "front office" to connect the western world to China, the people of Hong Kong were never allowed any political agency. Every governor was British, courts were British, documents were in English and Chinese people were marginalised, with rampant crime and tens of thousands lived in slums. There was no freedom of press and attempts at decolonisation were violently crushed (just look up the 1967 protests - 51 dead and over 1000 arrested in a week). I would rather have my own country that has agency, even if it is slow growth, than to be a servant to a wealthy master who tosses me a bone now and then.
@Juan-ko3wb
@Juan-ko3wb 2 года назад
@@ComedyLoverGirl so... You're saying that hong kong should be independent rather than be subjugated to British or Chinese masters?
@mfxmeer9316
@mfxmeer9316 2 года назад
@@ComedyLoverGirl well the Qing era was the dark times of Chinese history but the kmt never had a chance o fix the country since here were the war lords the corruption and prc took advantage of that and took the discomfort of the Chinese people in to licking them were via propaganda means while he colonized parts were prospering like hong kong or some other colonies but in Hong Kong i is true that he British picked he governors them selfs bu they atleast helped he city prosper while the Chinese ones are helping the Chinese no the Hong Kongs
@mannygutierrez8641
@mannygutierrez8641 2 года назад
@@Juan-ko3wb well the people of Hong Kong were actually protesting for this before Covid hit and many were arrested by the Chinese government and after Covid they imposed very strict laws and policies which ultimately ended those protests
@lilbrit1019
@lilbrit1019 2 года назад
@@ComedyLoverGirl errr your forgetting the elected council what surrounded the governor, there were chinese judges in the courts. Hong kong was built by britain it was a rock of 160 people when we got it and when we turned it over the anglo / hong kong cooperation turned it into the richest city east of suez
@johnarviegumapac8360
@johnarviegumapac8360 3 года назад
Yeah reject the Chinese goostep
@ewangrainger2898
@ewangrainger2898 3 года назад
@Lei Feng - 雷锋同志 Malding
@random-le5qh
@random-le5qh 2 года назад
@Lei Feng - 雷锋同志 tankies
@EsJam_es
@EsJam_es 3 года назад
Their marching style is not only for marching, the history.
@Zachomara
@Zachomara 3 года назад
It's also a much safer way than the Communist goosestep. Overextending your legs cause serious joint damage.
@AnNguyen-wu9yo
@AnNguyen-wu9yo Месяц назад
The colonial history will be wiped out sooner or later by next generations. We have to accept that fact.
@HsingG32
@HsingG32 6 лет назад
Tradition of being colonized?
@CannibaLouiST
@CannibaLouiST 5 лет назад
Better by Britain than by anti-Chinese commies.
@Kobi-um7bj
@Kobi-um7bj 5 лет назад
@@CannibaLouiST Not better by Britain since they aren't Chinese. Only the peoples of their same races/ethnics are allow to rules over them, no outsider allow.
@CannibaLouiST
@CannibaLouiST 5 лет назад
@@Kobi-um7bj That's outdated European nationalism. The British is more Chinese than the anti-Chinese commies.
@technatezin
@technatezin 5 лет назад
@@CannibaLouiST Doubtful. The British culture is diametrically opposite to Chinese culture and have always been that way. British values are of military colonizers, Christian missionaries, hypocritical paternalism and destruction of native culture. Just ask India how well it's doing after British culture was done overrunning their country.
@CannibaLouiST
@CannibaLouiST 5 лет назад
@@technatezin India and Hongkong are two places. When Britain got Hongkong Island, Kowloon and the New Territories, they wouldn't disrupt local customs at all. Even before 1997, it was totally normal that officials would participate in local rites. Britain persevered tons of traditional Chinese cultures and customs while the commies destroyed the tomb of Confucius.
@limxuanyi5398
@limxuanyi5398 3 года назад
Personally (politics aside)I feel that China marching drills looks way better than the British one
@mercedesbenz3751
@mercedesbenz3751 3 года назад
it looks better because all their soldiers have the same color, same height, same dimensions, same looks. In case of other nations, its not like that.
@sadrakhusravani2852
@sadrakhusravani2852 3 года назад
As an Iranian, I agree with you.
@Bobbylim323
@Bobbylim323 3 года назад
The British one looks sharper tho, 90 45 just looks right, the Chinese one looks lazy in comparison
@FeelMyBirdie
@FeelMyBirdie 3 года назад
@Master mustard what does zionism have anything to do with the topic at hand?
@Hahaha41241
@Hahaha41241 3 года назад
The most beautiful in the world China, I like the Indian one too when they run, I find it cool.
@chestertan9369
@chestertan9369 3 года назад
That's British style of marching...somehow I found that kind of an irony
@johnanon372
@johnanon372 3 года назад
Younger generation likes UK more than older generation who actually lived under British rule.
@sirsurnamethefirstofhisnam7986
@sirsurnamethefirstofhisnam7986 3 года назад
@@deli9437 colonised by the ccp far worse than the British could ever be
@jeezyj6697
@jeezyj6697 3 года назад
They hated the British, but now know nothing is worse than being overtaken by the CCP
@user-zs4gn2gn6p
@user-zs4gn2gn6p 3 года назад
Actually it was fused with the locals developing a style of British and Hong Kong
@anothernpc4943
@anothernpc4943 3 года назад
@@deli9437 if they cherish the former empire then so be it
@thomasflaye1741
@thomasflaye1741 3 года назад
Thats how we march as a former colony too .
@xleplex7070
@xleplex7070 3 года назад
Which former colony?
@jiyakuches220
@jiyakuches220 3 года назад
British former colony.
@bladeoftheimmortal9117
@bladeoftheimmortal9117 3 года назад
That mean you didnt completely liberate your country 😥
@stoffsforfadingben8697
@stoffsforfadingben8697 3 года назад
@@bladeoftheimmortal9117 go back to daddy China 🥴 are you a Serb or what.
@bladeoftheimmortal9117
@bladeoftheimmortal9117 3 года назад
I see that the word China is always in your mind, same as Trump. Is it to difficult for you to accept the fact that China very soon becoming world strongest country in every field? 😁💖🇨🇳 Is it difficult to accept that China is not former colony of any other country and have its own independent history? Why China make you so frustrated and jealous?
@Felix-dv9wn
@Felix-dv9wn 3 года назад
The fact that this video is posted 3 years ago and most of the comments is less than a week, im impressed by how youtube algorithm work
@12mixes55
@12mixes55 8 месяцев назад
This year, I participated in the same event showed in the video. The scout association chose us to represent scout to march on a ceremony that happened on May 4th. They requested our group to march in Chinese style, instead of British Style which is the old and normal way. We had to adapt and completely learn how to march in that way, in the span of 3 weeks. The biggest difference between the 2 types of marching is definitely the way our legs move. For British marching, it feels more formal, where as for Chinese Marching, it feels more like walking, but is definitely still coordinated.
@fxfr_
@fxfr_ 8 месяцев назад
is it only for this event ?
@musicguy327
@musicguy327 5 месяцев назад
@@fxfr_ no they made it mandatory for all events beyond that, unless if the events aren't coordinated publically i believe (such as remembrance day)
@TheKkpop1
@TheKkpop1 3 года назад
Things would be different if they lived in 150 years ago. Thay can only ask how high when Britain order them to jump.
@user-ko7ol5qg4g
@user-ko7ol5qg4g 3 года назад
and 150 years ago women's rights were nowhere to be seen either. Nice job comparing history to modern society.
@Kulo_WC
@Kulo_WC 3 года назад
@Simsil Pasic Glad to see you're not able to decipher the simple comment. Much like the west, all wrong doings lead to China. RIP.
@audreandre
@audreandre 3 года назад
@Simsil Pasic haha another western that alway think they care about humanity
@marktn9851
@marktn9851 3 года назад
@Simsil Pasic Glad to know that how the brits got their riches n later pretend to be human. They hv shown that having a strong military is key to prosperity.
@padtag1742
@padtag1742 3 года назад
@Simsil Pasic do you even know before 1997, Britain send a white governor to rule HK and there’s no voting at all for them. And you think that’s ok for HK ppl?
@randycheow4268
@randycheow4268 3 года назад
TBH the goose step march used by China looks hard compared to the original ones
@eliyahuohiyon7461
@eliyahuohiyon7461 2 года назад
Exactly, that's why they're not using it. It's unnecessarily difficult.
@UnitedUnion51
@UnitedUnion51 Месяц назад
I am a student in Hong Kong, and I take part in the flag raising team. Just to let ya know: that's hard. Really hard.
@f1r3hunt3rz5
@f1r3hunt3rz5 3 года назад
And today, it entirely changes.
@TheCaptainSplatter
@TheCaptainSplatter 3 года назад
It went from suggestion to mandatory.
@johannapfelburg6286
@johannapfelburg6286 3 года назад
The only video I can see is of the police doing so, not the youth groups tho
@archangel7052
@archangel7052 3 года назад
ZzThey better...this marching is awful!!
@CaptainX2012
@CaptainX2012 3 года назад
@@archangel7052 have you SEEN the goose-step?? It's just plain ridiculous.
@joshuabonilla3491
@joshuabonilla3491 3 года назад
@@CaptainX2012 what’s wrong with goose step? A lot of militaries around the world practice it. It comes from Prussian military tradition. Wanna see a crazy one look at the Russian or Greek marches though guys are lucky they don’t pull any muscles!
@pauladambarral5039
@pauladambarral5039 5 лет назад
How about Macau I mean it's a former portugeuse colony in their portugeuse military style march
@cb250nighthawk3
@cb250nighthawk3 4 года назад
Paul Adam Barral Those guys didn't riot. That's why they get off scot free. Macau's business is exclusive of Shenzhen's. Their businesses are secure. And they never looked down on the mainlanders too. Humility goes a long way to help you move ahead in life. No?
@myro7958
@myro7958 4 года назад
@@cb250nighthawk3 e
@cb250nighthawk3
@cb250nighthawk3 4 года назад
my ro 🀄
@cb250nighthawk3
@cb250nighthawk3 4 года назад
my ro e for Mach e, Mustang Mach e. The iconic American symbol. Made in where? Nowadays? Here you go : ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1DTa1Ki2s2Y.html
@eugene7145
@eugene7145 3 года назад
@@cb250nighthawk3 reported
@zeta1593
@zeta1593 2 года назад
Can someone explain me the difference between the two march because I struggle to see them
@AG-kp8es
@AG-kp8es 3 года назад
As a kid, I saw the collapse of the USSR and the return of HK. A lot can change in 1-2 generations. I wil be alive to see HK fully integrated into China in 2047.
@booolee2389
@booolee2389 3 года назад
So we chinese should destory UK before 2047, in case of its return. Got it!
@user-sx2we1xe5q
@user-sx2we1xe5q 3 года назад
@@booolee2389 ?What are you talking about? You must be British who still wanna keep hk as a colony…
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
@@booolee2389 Well, the previous time any nation tried to it, its Capital got stormed by the British.
@booolee2389
@booolee2389 3 года назад
@@billcipherproductions1789 an interesting chanllenge, we woukd like to try.
@picklejuice500g
@picklejuice500g 3 года назад
Nope. Free Hongkong!
@cptfullsack6373
@cptfullsack6373 3 года назад
so we're gonna leave the mellophone player that's out of step alone?
@rexwebb4302
@rexwebb4302 4 года назад
This video has not aged well
@ghostofsolomon237
@ghostofsolomon237 3 года назад
Could they line up by the height, for the least. From tallest to shortest.
@Zachomara
@Zachomara 3 года назад
Are you asking Scouts to do that?
@ghostofsolomon237
@ghostofsolomon237 3 года назад
@@Zachomara Yes, it's like elementary school skill.
@kym6844
@kym6844 3 года назад
Well, its usually arranged from the tallest, then short in the middle, and then back tallest again
@shortfusedfox2593
@shortfusedfox2593 2 года назад
@@kym6844 In line infantry, yes. In close-ordered parades, maybe. Something like this? I wouldn't expect so. This seems textbook tallest-to-shortest to me. But they're basically boy scouts. I can't say I'm too worried their drill and sizing are imperfect.
@bryan24ish
@bryan24ish 3 года назад
Ill support what the young generation want s to achieve. Its not a total disrespect to their mainland. They cant deny hongkong become part of chinas succesful economic history. The british rule on hongkong back way ago give a chance to every hongkongers even in mainland to grow and prosper. And its part of their history . And respect
@martinshao3543
@martinshao3543 3 года назад
Yeah but what a lot of young HKers are trying to do is deny their relation with mainland mainly because of a biased education against mainland I believe. (Not sure if it was HK or Taiean.)
@bryan24ish
@bryan24ish 3 года назад
@@martinshao3543 no matter what it is just give them their peace. China is not china without the help of western countries and the americas .
@sunji568
@sunji568 3 года назад
@@bryan24ish Do you mean the kind of peace they tossing petrol bombs to the police and light up an old man? Please do your homework before speak.
@lilbrit1019
@lilbrit1019 2 года назад
hong kong was the richest city east of suez when Britain gave it back and also one the most free cities
@user-vv7ir1pl4j
@user-vv7ir1pl4j 5 лет назад
0:55 🤣
@santiagorappy71
@santiagorappy71 5 лет назад
Penguins 🐧
@gleaf4771
@gleaf4771 3 года назад
What's that?
@XuerLi
@XuerLi 3 года назад
The Pokemon was leading the team
@eliyahuohiyon7461
@eliyahuohiyon7461 2 года назад
Someone didn't leave enough space for the formation so they had to slow down while making it look like they were marching in step lol
@cody56011
@cody56011 3 года назад
The youth hv problem adjusting? Send em all back to mainland for rehab.
@doom1894
@doom1894 3 года назад
Chinese mainland couldn’t stop 15 year olds from protesting so yeah maybe the ccp should get put in rehab
@thegtafanboy
@thegtafanboy 6 лет назад
This is what being colonized in the mind looks like.
@etow8034
@etow8034 5 лет назад
You guys even believe in their silly Gods as well ! ...LoL
@andro7862
@andro7862 4 года назад
Not trying to be political, but british drills just look silly.
@markbenjamin1703
@markbenjamin1703 3 года назад
It doesn't when perform properly and by 5'9+ soldiers look at videos from 1950s or stick drill
@andro7862
@andro7862 3 года назад
@@markbenjamin1703 You'd be hard press to find chinese that tall 😅
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
Nah, it’s just because they are not well trained, Expect for the Axillary Medical Service Cadets, we are well trained guard of honour members , we even got extra training for that event but seems like they haven't film us
@carr16k
@carr16k 3 года назад
British drill even done by the best trained personnel just doesn't look as smart as other nations', with the silly swinging of arms and awkward stamp of the foot
@dabo5078
@dabo5078 3 года назад
@@markbenjamin1703 Still looks pretty terrible. Beside 5'9 British soldiers did not exist back than. They were still all starving from the economic devastation of Britain that was WW2.
@Nas145657
@Nas145657 5 лет назад
goose step parade? this is ridiculous.....
@deputy_commander7595
@deputy_commander7595 5 лет назад
Why you say that.
@Nas145657
@Nas145657 5 лет назад
@@deputy_commander7595 its hurt our leg if use goose step parade...
@deputy_commander7595
@deputy_commander7595 5 лет назад
@@Nas145657 i'm practicing that, and nothing happened.
@naphxing
@naphxing 4 года назад
Agreed. The marching is also far from being in unison.
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
Expect for the Axillary Medical Service Cadets, we are well trained guard of honour members , we even got extra training for that event but seems like they haven't film us
@andylau8585
@andylau8585 3 года назад
It’s published on May 8, 2018! What is the purpose for this?
@wiiistful7499
@wiiistful7499 3 года назад
Backstabbing motherland. South China Morning post is a "pro-democracy" "newspaper". If you didn't say me that it was published in 2018 I would have believed it was happening right now. I let you come to your own conclusion on why they still published this video.
@daniellai6367
@daniellai6367 4 года назад
Soon they will ask not to held Remembrance Day in HK
@ergenekon9981
@ergenekon9981 3 года назад
Hello, well here we are now.
@AmphiStuG
@AmphiStuG 3 года назад
That's awefully disappointing. You know an entire Canadian/British garrison fought and died during the battle of Hong Kong back in 41'? Of course now they teach the whole ordeal as "Foolish cowardly British commonwealth soldiers fight in vein and surrender" Which is a terrible shame in my opinion.
@Grayman58
@Grayman58 2 года назад
Glad they have kept the British style of marching. I think most people regret going back to Chinese rule because of a lease agreement🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
@tomaszzalewski4541
@tomaszzalewski4541 2 года назад
As I understand. People are actually devided over this
@IA100KPDT
@IA100KPDT 2 года назад
@@tomaszzalewski4541 Wrong. Most preferred to return to China rule. The riots are funded by Ned and is just a small portion of the population, mostly youth who are brainwashed and dont know the history.
@Bub2580
@Bub2580 2 года назад
For those who regret, they can always hv the options of migrating. Same as other countries, peoples do migrate but the LAND stay with the actual owner.
@MrDave1468
@MrDave1468 2 года назад
@@IA100KPDT I think a large majority would like to stay a democracy though
@LeScandal
@LeScandal 3 года назад
A little goose-stepping never hurt anyone... oh wait
@zachbedson2804
@zachbedson2804 2 года назад
To those saying British drill is bad, it isn’t. It only looks it when sloppy children get out of time, loose the step and have bad posture. Children doing a PLA style goose step would look even more broken, how many do you think could actually stay in time and not botch it?
@extremelycreativeusername
@extremelycreativeusername Год назад
British drills are immaculate when done right
@youtubeaccount5738
@youtubeaccount5738 Год назад
@@extremelycreativeusername That’s true.
@munkhazaya29
@munkhazaya29 7 месяцев назад
My Mongolian school's 10th graders were doing high knee marching and it was absolutely bad and these kids look even younger. Goosestep puts a lot of strain on the leg
@pet_yarnimals
@pet_yarnimals 3 года назад
Is no one looking at when this was posted.
@t.m.7192
@t.m.7192 3 года назад
They changed this year
@noorhijrah147
@noorhijrah147 3 года назад
sounds more like they're forced to
@winkus8586
@winkus8586 3 года назад
surely... hk is china. do you have a marching style different from your government standard?
@noorhijrah147
@noorhijrah147 3 года назад
the hk police has been marching British way since the beginning of its formation. if its doing fine(the marching style), why bother changing it?
@winkus8586
@winkus8586 3 года назад
@@noorhijrah147 it is british style not chinese style.
@ngmanlung1600
@ngmanlung1600 3 года назад
Actually I think Chinese March looks better, but for me as a scout (scout came from uk) I prefer using British style
@donkeykong516
@donkeykong516 4 года назад
Brit marching looks clumsy
@JATP-wp6eh
@JATP-wp6eh 3 года назад
Not if done properly.
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
Expect for the Axillary Medical Service Cadet, because they only asked the members of the guard of honour to attend that day, we even got extra training for that event but seems like they haven't film us
@mottscottison6943
@mottscottison6943 3 года назад
Funny how it is always the youths who never lived under foreign colonization before who reminisce about former colonizers. British for the HK and Japan for Taiwan.
@dickyarya8204
@dickyarya8204 3 года назад
I never seen a single Taiwanese wanting to be part of colonial Japan
@LelouchOfBritannia
@LelouchOfBritannia 3 года назад
@@dickyarya8204 Cause they just want to be their own sovereignty like everyone else. Not China nor Japans.
@IndoGunsnGear
@IndoGunsnGear 3 года назад
@@dickyarya8204 actually, I have met some really old people here in Taiwan who says that Japan's government is better than Taiwan......even though when they were born, Japan already gave Taiwan back
@dickyarya8204
@dickyarya8204 3 года назад
@@IndoGunsnGear is that your base claim
@IndoGunsnGear
@IndoGunsnGear 3 года назад
@@dickyarya8204 uhhh yea?
@ma.theresalavina7162
@ma.theresalavina7162 2 года назад
Beijing should just accept it as it is. I mean they can call it culture and unique. But communist is againsts culture. What a shame
@helloheaven5000
@helloheaven5000 3 года назад
Is the South China Morning Post playing sad music for the British Empire?
@fds7476
@fds7476 3 года назад
Why shouldn't they?
@tarfox3356
@tarfox3356 3 года назад
@@fds7476 For a dying empire yes, for HK no.
@fds7476
@fds7476 3 года назад
@@tarfox3356 Hong Kong is soon gone if the CCP is allowed continue like this. Kinda ironic that Hong Kong has never been a freer, more prosperous, more democratic place than as a British Crown Colony...
@tarfox3356
@tarfox3356 3 года назад
@@fds7476 Maybe it is not prosperous anymore because HK is gone for its economic positions as China has opened more and more and HK has lost its functionality as a trade port and gateway from China to the world, as well as China has finally realized it is no use to maintain Hong Kong's false prosperity to prove how successful 1 country 2 policies is. Don't consider everything based on the sense of "democracy" and "freedom" which HK also don't have it until the last days before handed over to China.
@lilbrit1019
@lilbrit1019 2 года назад
@@tarfox3356 china purposely sabotage hong kong to make it weak. remember in 97 it was the richest city east of seuz
@bawk2boom
@bawk2boom 3 года назад
Wait you too fast moving per frame i cant tell which one is
@lewjames6688
@lewjames6688 3 года назад
“May be encroaching...”? 🤣😂🤣
@truenorthstrongandfree3699
@truenorthstrongandfree3699 3 года назад
The CCP much prefers the Gestapo goose step!
@firefly361
@firefly361 4 года назад
They are just following their history and tradition.
@pickupthatcan9696
@pickupthatcan9696 3 года назад
I love your name
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
+ we haven’t learn how to march in the Chinese way
@AtlasFox
@AtlasFox 3 года назад
@Harald Harster Not necessarily so! They clearly embrace the values and traditions imparted by the British, and I think many Hong Kongers are nostalgic for those simpler times.
@JH-jz1sd
@JH-jz1sd 3 года назад
@@AtlasFox I can't disagree with you more. You should know en mass the youths of HK are the supporters of colonial rule. The older generation are the ones that remember what it was really like. HK has only climbed up the freedom index since returning to China. And don't bring up that it's been falling since the 2019 protest. We all know who's been stoking and reaponsible for that.
@DavBlc7
@DavBlc7 3 года назад
They stopped following history and traditions early this year.
@AlWalker2023
@AlWalker2023 3 года назад
Don’t forget to change the marching bands instrument from brass to erhu and the likes
@rafiqkie
@rafiqkie 10 месяцев назад
hey.. it's HK scout, those are my friends.. salute! I am a scout to.. hello from 🇲🇾
@RIFLQ
@RIFLQ 3 года назад
CCP: Is this colonial mentality?
@inquisitorkryptman7893
@inquisitorkryptman7893 3 года назад
Its anti tyrannical government sir
@maxchioa7822
@maxchioa7822 3 года назад
@@inquisitorkryptman7893 Could've chosen the Prussian one.
@lilbrit1019
@lilbrit1019 2 года назад
@Lei Feng - 雷锋同志 yea im not sure about that one chief. China right now is a imperialistic power Britain built hong kong from a rock of 160 people to the richest city east of suez. Its clear as day the city would still hold alot of british culture and traditions, and right now china is trying everything i can to erase it. Also free tibet, free Xinjiang and return inner Mongolia
@random-le5qh
@random-le5qh 2 года назад
@Lei Feng - 雷锋同志 wannabe communist, you just trying to influence us into thinking that living is China is better than the rest of the world while China is slowly becoming a totalitarian state
@Zergcerebrates
@Zergcerebrates 3 года назад
PLA way looks better.
@user-oq7dx9bn4x
@user-oq7dx9bn4x 3 года назад
It's no originated from PLA,It's learn to Prussian army.
@Zergcerebrates
@Zergcerebrates 3 года назад
@@user-oq7dx9bn4x Doesn't matter, it's used by the PLA so it's the PLA way, the Prussians don't exist anymore.
@sycen
@sycen 3 года назад
I don't get it why this is a problem
@FreedumbSauceFriedFrogs
@FreedumbSauceFriedFrogs 3 года назад
Don't we have any more important things to worry?
@donkeykong516
@donkeykong516 4 года назад
50 years is to give some time for HK to integrate back to mainland, grace period isn’t about permanency for HK
@bobjacobson858
@bobjacobson858 3 года назад
...but of course they won't really be given this much time, because the PRC government will go back on their word and not allow it.
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
But they don't want to be part of the Mainland.
@cypherpunk1984
@cypherpunk1984 3 года назад
@@billcipherproductions1789 Then get the F out of China's territory and go wherever they may.
@boysgangBkkp8
@boysgangBkkp8 3 года назад
@@cypherpunk1984 so ur saying China should give them independence then
@cypherpunk1984
@cypherpunk1984 3 года назад
@@boysgangBkkp8 I guess you have zero history knowledge about China and Hong Kong. What do you care about HK? Where are you from?
@HKGYHCheng
@HKGYHCheng 3 года назад
to be fair the chinese marching style looks cooler, although harder to train
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
I like the British one better though.
@TheHollandHS
@TheHollandHS 2 года назад
Then they just want uniforns to be same next year. Until these trolls make it's empty.
@1jh963
@1jh963 3 года назад
Hahaha now u know who is in charge
@badminton818
@badminton818 3 года назад
It is the end of HK prosperity.........
@MiCharlXXD4
@MiCharlXXD4 3 года назад
Its gone for quite a while
@dylanting3969
@dylanting3969 3 года назад
This video did not aged well.
@wiiistful7499
@wiiistful7499 3 года назад
Why do you say that?
@dylanting3969
@dylanting3969 3 года назад
@@wiiistful7499 Because Beijing has its knot around Hong Kong now. Very soon the PLA goosestep will be mandatory for consistency.
@MaRaX93
@MaRaX93 3 года назад
@@dylanting3969 You do know HK is Chinese right?
@avengersnewbie2348
@avengersnewbie2348 3 года назад
handed to china under a lease.
@thomasdollard7971
@thomasdollard7971 2 года назад
I think it makes Hong Kong unique withing China, they all showed proper honors for the flag raising.
@Utube1024
@Utube1024 5 лет назад
China marching style display a formidable fighting army. This is what military marching should look like. Not like walking in the park.
@TheValdy12
@TheValdy12 5 лет назад
Right.... US military and many militaries in the world must be sissies then.
@Utube1024
@Utube1024 4 года назад
@@TheValdy12 ...well they cried when captured by Iranian naval forces....LOL. Talking about bravery US military would not dare to mess around with military that has identical quality of weapons as them.
@muiry16rfc
@muiry16rfc 3 года назад
@@Utube1024 I guess you ain't seen the video of Chinese Soldiers crying on a bus heading for the Sino-Indian border... Ye don't try make out that certain peoples etc don't cry because fear strikes everyone.
@muiry16rfc
@muiry16rfc 3 года назад
@@Utube1024 also "Identical quality of weapons"? sheesh, never thought I'd see that... The Chinese MBT is a lower quality T-72 pretty much and would get pounded by most NATO nations tanks, including Japan's. Also Most NATO nations have extremely more and well better equipped Infantry.
@EngPheniks
@EngPheniks 3 года назад
You sir, are a walk in the park
@cuonghoang2243
@cuonghoang2243 3 года назад
lol just watch the latest video and then this pop up :))) time sure change
@troublingpolitics9242
@troublingpolitics9242 3 года назад
the new video is in reference to the police only. I believe the youth groups still march in the British style.
@cuonghoang2243
@cuonghoang2243 3 года назад
@@troublingpolitics9242 ah i see, thank you
@jieniu9128
@jieniu9128 3 года назад
The clip was from 2018
@Terry-em8ef
@Terry-em8ef 3 года назад
Who said they asked?
@badcat8481
@badcat8481 3 года назад
The Spirit of the Tank Man lives!!!
@zironthegamer
@zironthegamer 3 года назад
British style marching needs to be encouraged don't loose hope Hong Kong
@techmasteryt4536
@techmasteryt4536 2 года назад
Why should it be encouraged? I am from australia and I refused to March the proper way in the mandatory school military training and I did a Goosestep instead. And I got in heaps of trouble but I knew I was a hero for Goosestepping
@t_dix3029
@t_dix3029 6 месяцев назад
Because you were being a nut? Why would you march to a different country's drill movement? That's the height of disrespect and also idiocy. If you don't like it then leave the ADF, because you'll be kicked out anyways because you can't get onto pass out!@@techmasteryt4536
@george6696
@george6696 3 года назад
They can't and not dare to march like this anymore
@cauyawolfe4724
@cauyawolfe4724 2 года назад
No one wants to do the bootleg Soviet/North Korean march.
@MyYuwono
@MyYuwono 3 года назад
Encrouching hk freedom lol. Do you think british did not encrouching china sovereignity to force unequal treaties on china to forcibly grab hk?
@brendonchen2550
@brendonchen2550 3 года назад
two wrongs don't make a right. What has happened was the pass and what china is doing is the present.
@brendonchen2550
@brendonchen2550 3 года назад
@@signumxmagnum true, but what was done is done. Now China is encroaching on the little freedoms of hk. That is the issue
@MyYuwono
@MyYuwono 3 года назад
Hk is china so whatever china did to hk is chinese own matter. The same that the british did to hk in the past china could not do anything.
@brendonchen2550
@brendonchen2550 3 года назад
@@signumxmagnum it's a humanitarian problem, china is the problem. They aren't making things better
@signumxmagnum
@signumxmagnum 3 года назад
@@brendonchen2550 humanitarian problem pfffttt..
@fmtoussant
@fmtoussant 3 года назад
just like with the queue, some may need to lose a little more than what they was told to lose
@kk66
@kk66 3 года назад
3 years later....I really wonder....
@fajarkurniawan9434
@fajarkurniawan9434 3 года назад
Are they still alive?
@volt9031
@volt9031 3 года назад
Kekw
@DavBlc7
@DavBlc7 3 года назад
That was 3 years ago and now all Hong Kong group are forced to adopt Chinese marching style after their leader was replaced by a pro Beijing so they said! Police now follow the Chinese style drills.
@thetecno5800
@thetecno5800 3 года назад
@Robert Tey Except the UK changed and now is a country 1000 times better than China.
@hylimm
@hylimm 3 года назад
Goose step only for military, the rest are unnecessary!
@AmphiStuG
@AmphiStuG 3 года назад
Yeah, it would be kind of odd to have youth groups goose step. They're not part of the military or anything.
@hylimm
@hylimm 3 года назад
Fritz031 @ maybe they message they want to send to these youngsters are that they are no longer under the British rules!
@mbond007
@mbond007 3 года назад
the hong kongers only have to change the way they march but the uyghurs were imprisont and forced to change their beliefs and way of life .
@xingao8275
@xingao8275 3 года назад
Poor you, brain washed by the west media.
@jaffa3717
@jaffa3717 3 года назад
@@xingao8275 动态网自由门 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Free Tibet 六四天安門事件 The Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 天安門大屠殺 The Tiananmen Square Massacre 反右派鬥爭 The Anti-Rightist Struggle 大躍進政策 The Great Leap Forward 文化大革命 The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution 人權 Human Rights 民運 Democratization 自由 Freedom 獨立 Independence 多黨制 Multi-party system 台灣 臺灣 Taiwan Formosa 中華民國 Republic of China 西藏 土伯特 唐古特 Tibet 達賴喇嘛 Dalai Lama 法輪功 Falun Dafa 新疆維吾爾自治區 The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region 諾貝爾和平獎 Nobel Peace Prize 劉暁波 Liu Xiaobo 民主 言論 思想 反共 反革命 抗議 運動 騷亂 暴亂 騷擾 擾亂 抗暴 平反 維權 示威游行 李洪志 法輪大法 大法弟子 強制斷種 強制堕胎 民族淨化 人體實驗 肅清 胡耀邦 趙紫陽 魏京生 王丹 還政於民 和平演變 激流中國 北京之春 大紀元時報 九評論共産黨 獨裁 專制 壓制 統一 監視 鎮壓 迫害 侵略 掠奪 破壞 拷問 屠殺 活摘器官 誘拐 買賣人口 遊進 走私 毒品 賣淫 春畫 賭博 六合彩 天安門 天安门 法輪功 李洪志 Winnie the Pooh 劉曉波动态网自由门
@mbond007
@mbond007 3 года назад
Same to u mate .u were brainwashed by the communist government.
@giovane3208
@giovane3208 3 года назад
Political discussions aside, the British marching style looks silly. Look all those youngs marching. . . seems a excursion of goofys walking in a park.
@lakenneth374
@lakenneth374 3 года назад
China marching looks like the "Goose Stepping" marching, which is very unnatural - legs are straight and kick high out in front of you - no bending of the knee.
@giovane3208
@giovane3208 3 года назад
@@lakenneth374 I agree that goose step seems unnatural, yet the stiffness of gait gives soldiers an appearance of power, which the British gait style lacks. Marching in modern military parades must demonstrate synchronicity and strength, not naturalness. By the way, the Britsh marching style has an unnatural and accentuated swing of the arms. Anyway, it's a matter of taste.
@AmphiStuG
@AmphiStuG 3 года назад
It looks like they did the quick-march a bit faster than it's usually practiced, combined that with the fact they're just kids it didn't turn out well, I'd doubt the PLA march would look better though with how unnatural the gate is. A slow march would've probably made it easier for them to look professional.
@kevintsangmsc
@kevintsangmsc 3 года назад
Did they have the choice in form of marching initially? Encroaching feedom hahaha
@user-sx2we1xe5q
@user-sx2we1xe5q 3 года назад
No worry. Cultural background evolves by time.
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
Heck, in order for Hong Kong to get rid of the British culture, it'll at least take until the year 2200 at minimum to change it.
@ngmanlung1600
@ngmanlung1600 3 года назад
@@billcipherproductions1789 maybe even longer
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
@@ngmanlung1600 Yes.
@achillesrodriguezxx3958
@achillesrodriguezxx3958 2 года назад
If I was them I would have quit that uniform group.
@69roamie
@69roamie 3 года назад
This way that way only they don't have their own way.
@semperfidelis9083
@semperfidelis9083 3 года назад
And so they choose the british style? why colonies are bigger simps to the uk than the english themselves?
@ngrobert5054
@ngrobert5054 3 года назад
They still though England reality CHINA is going to help NOT white man
@evzenvarga9707
@evzenvarga9707 3 года назад
@@ngrobert5054 help them by taking their human rights.
@yeusean
@yeusean 5 лет назад
Definitely British style marching outdated and looks amateurish.
@johannapfelburg6286
@johannapfelburg6286 4 года назад
It's only amateurish because they aren't in sync.
@johannapfelburg6286
@johannapfelburg6286 4 года назад
@Golden Eagle Prussian goose-step? You call this Prussian? You want Prussia, go to Chile. The style is completely different between Prussian and Chinese parade drills. The way the knees are bent, how high the legs are raised, how much the arms move, whether or not their fists are clenched. Just because it came from Prussia, doesn't mean all goose-stepping is Prussian.
@napoleonibonaparte7198
@napoleonibonaparte7198 4 года назад
Geo H One could also say the Soviet style marching is outdated and amateurish.
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
Amateurish, yes I agree expect for the Axillary Medical Service Cadets, we are well trained guard of honour members , we even got extra training for that event but seems like they haven't film us
@nam4808
@nam4808 3 года назад
I mean Auxiliary Medical Surface, not Axillary. Sorry for wrong spelling. Plus I only see the Hong Kong Adventure Corps have problems in their foot drill
@mynahbird20000
@mynahbird20000 3 года назад
yep definitely the Queen's chinese would rather waltz to the tune of Michael Jackson or Madonna! No surprise!
@laopang91362
@laopang91362 3 года назад
Maybe there is a HK traditional way?
@UserUser-pq8bu
@UserUser-pq8bu 3 года назад
Do you think your Maybe make sense ? It is a colonial way
@Mariobrownio1989
@Mariobrownio1989 3 года назад
People in the west praising British colonies in Asia while recognizing the horror and tragidies of British colony in North America is pure gold
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
To be precise the UK didn't all of its colonies the same way. For example in India, they started a bloodbath of 200 years while in Hong Kong, it gave it an economic boom in the 1980s.
@Bub2580
@Bub2580 2 года назад
@@billcipherproductions1789 tbh, the brits made alot of money out of Hong Kong and left behind alot of confused peoples.
@o.l.9795
@o.l.9795 3 года назад
People of Hong Kong should get rid of the British influences once and for all, especially the visually offensive wigs worn by the lawyers and judges.
@claudiuspseudonymus1369
@claudiuspseudonymus1369 3 года назад
Oh, not to worry....in time they'll learn to walk the walk and march the march. The HK Police already goose step quite nicely...
@fahiruzrazali
@fahiruzrazali 3 года назад
Should've cat walk instead.
@HS-PGX
@HS-PGX 3 года назад
The British style of marching is a lot more dignified in my opinion. And for the lower part of the body, it looks more intuitive than doing the mainland style March.
@yes-uo8so
@yes-uo8so 3 года назад
Imagine being asked to change something when you're already at the stage of commencing it. Took you more than 20 years to find out that you shouldn't be under Chinese hands
@xya6530
@xya6530 2 года назад
Imagine u r Chinese but insists to be otherwise, how ironic
@jasonstormsong4940
@jasonstormsong4940 2 года назад
@@xya6530 A nation can be split into multiple states, just look at Korea, Cyprus, Sudan, Germany during the cold war, the Roman Empire following the establishment of the Tetrachy, et al.
@yes-uo8so
@yes-uo8so 2 года назад
Who wouldn't resist being stuck at the grip of a hammer and sickle
@xya6530
@xya6530 2 года назад
@@jasonstormsong4940 so wants ur point?
@xya6530
@xya6530 2 года назад
@@yes-uo8so oh… another clueless person trying to be mr/ms know it all on the internet
@ngrobert5054
@ngrobert5054 3 года назад
Cut the financial aid
@jerryzheng3226
@jerryzheng3226 3 года назад
They are kneel too long.
@harrychan297
@harrychan297 5 лет назад
Follow another way of marching, Isn’t a new form of colonisation? I really don’t understand why people comment below the video claims the Hong Kong tradition as a symbol of british colonialism. Hong Kong received a magnificent modernisation after the British occupation after 1842. The institution of Hong Kong has been established well by British order. The objective of “one country two systems” is to maintain british construction after 1997, it proofed the advantages of British rule in Hong Kong. If u think keeping british way is Hongkongers like to being colonised, it shows your ignorance of Hong Kong History and Modern Chinese History.
@yourmader6990
@yourmader6990 3 года назад
The Chinese march looks much better and feels more professional, this looks just like walking in a weird way.
@billcipherproductions1789
@billcipherproductions1789 3 года назад
It's kind of vice versa for me.
@martinshao3543
@martinshao3543 3 года назад
Yeah, this guys aren't well synchronized and lacks the spirit
@camelo1495
@camelo1495 3 года назад
What's the point...they can't really March anyway
@gofar5185
@gofar5185 2 года назад
there are expected reactionaries about national governments' platforms... the first reactionaries to national anthems and national flags were the "jehovah's witnesses"... teachers had difficult times how to handle the schoolers...
@pigionlover1828
@pigionlover1828 3 года назад
Now 3yrs after everything changs
@liquidh6344
@liquidh6344 3 года назад
The CCP really has insecurity issues.
@josephguo6256
@josephguo6256 3 года назад
never mind, soon they will have no more march.
@kevinchen7903
@kevinchen7903 3 года назад
Obviously we did not object to it Don't lie
@borninthewoods4482
@borninthewoods4482 3 года назад
Keep On Marching! 🇬🇧
@youtubeaccount5738
@youtubeaccount5738 Год назад
QUICK MARCH!
@stevewilson5292
@stevewilson5292 2 года назад
British foot drill is the best - a step far above the American shuffle-style marching and over-simple turns and halts, but not ridiculous like that drill-burlesque practiced on the Pakistan-Indian border. No goose-stepping either - it says "totalitarian" in a loud way. You'd think the PLA would have dropped it by now.
@sadrakhusravani2852
@sadrakhusravani2852 3 года назад
For what is Heidegger’s final message but that Western philosophy is a great error, the result of the dichotomizing intellect that has cut man off from unity with Being itself and from his own being…. Heidegger repeatedly tells us that this tradition of the West has come to the end of its cycle; and as he says this, one can only gather that he himself has already stepped beyond that tradition. Into the tradition of the Orient? I should say he has come pretty close to Zen (Barrett, 1956, xii). #Occidental_Thought #Oriental_Thought #Westernized_Oriental
@marcusmartin5758
@marcusmartin5758 3 года назад
They are sloppy and weak af, someone need to fire their drill instructor.
Далее
How Japan is Preparing for War with China
31:55
Просмотров 1,7 млн
Сумерки сасага🧛
11:41
Просмотров 1 млн
The 'border crossers' from China
13:51
Просмотров 13 тыс.
Hong Kong - Handover ceremony
7:36
Просмотров 88 тыс.
How does the Chinese Communist Party operate?
6:45
Просмотров 539 тыс.
How China Is Remaking Hong Kong in Its Own Image
9:51
Просмотров 326 тыс.
How Hong Kong is forever changed
13:20
Просмотров 298 тыс.