Тёмный

Honor Magic V3 Pen vs Samsung Fold S Pen Comparison 

maddada
Подписаться 620
Просмотров 12 тыс.
50% 1

EDIT: I managed to find a way to make double tapping the pen's button play/pause music when outside the camera app, and take pictures remotely when inside the camera app (even if standing far from the phone). You just need to download "Button Mapper" and get the paid version, then click on "Add Button" and double tap the pen's button to register it, then assign the 1 tap option to play/pause music. You should disable the action inside the notes app so you can switch between eraser and pen by doing the double tap.
I came into this video with the goal to see if Honor's Pen UX is close to Samsung's or still too far behind.
After trying the 2, I can confidently say that the Magic pen is a great alternative to the S Pen and you can get a few extra benefits from it (writing on the main screen and free mark).
You can also download third party apps from the Play Store to cover the AI part that Samsung added with the Fold 6 (They're a gimmick for most people IMO)
The Honor's device hardware is a pleasure to hold and use, and the pen functionality is very similar to the Fold 6's pen. So I would still buy the Magic V3 again over the Fold 6 any day of the week.
Samsung no longer have the massive lead that they used to have when it comes to this part of the user experience.
I hope Honor adds camera air actions soon as that would take the Magic Pen to the next level.
Some notes:
At 4:25 I wanted to show what Samsung Air Actions do (for the S Pen Pro) but didn't get back to this. Basically they allow you to hold the pen's button and do gestures to take a picture or switch modes. This can be very useful at times, and I hope Honor add something like this since their Pen is also Bluetooth.
Samsung has the AI features for the Notes App, most are coming to the Fold 4 soon, but I didn't get them yet (you can find them on youtube by entering "Fold 6 AI").
I'm on the Chinese version of the Honor's Software, I believe the Global version will bring more AI features like Samsung has.
Either way there's tons of AI apps on the play store that do Image generation so it's nothing special IMO.
Just wish the Magic Pen had Air Actions to take photos with the camera and change shooting modes by holding the pen's button and gesturing, this is a great feature if you have the S Pen Pro (most people don't)
The Honor allows you to use the pen on both screens which is really useful since the outer screen on the Honor is wide (66mm vs 60 on the Fold 6).
I also missed to mention that you can charge the Honor pen very easily through a well hidden usb c port. And it should last around 5 days with moderate use. (charges to 100% in less than 20 mins)
Samsung's S Pen Pro also requires charging, while the one that comes with the S Pen case doesn't (therefor it lacks air actions)
The S Pen (non-pro) can be stored in the S Pen case which is a plus for some, but I hate the extra thickness and would rather keep the pen in my shirt pocket which is possible because the Magic Pen has a clip.

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 120   
@davidkostka7602
@davidkostka7602 Месяц назад
Looking forward your Q&A video 🙏🙏. Would be nice to demonstrate some notifications maybe.
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Sure will do that :)
@bdoviack
@bdoviack Месяц назад
Have you found an easy way to carry the stylus with the V3? Would be great if there was a case or something that could carry the phone and stylus at the same time (without adding too much bulk).
@jemfalor
@jemfalor Месяц назад
same thinking. still looking for a hinge pen slot but to no avail.
@ecocadia
@ecocadia Месяц назад
I use a Fitbag sleeve for the V2 with a pen holder
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@bdoviack Ill show the way I carry mine in the Q & A. I don't like stylus cases because they make the phone thicker.
@chrs1128
@chrs1128 9 дней назад
Thats why i am still with the samsung fold 6. I realy like the samsung case with the built in smaller pen. Give me this for the honor and i am in
@Alex83mlf
@Alex83mlf 5 дней назад
@@chrs1128 smaller pen but so uncomfortable, expensive and... no Air Commands! And don't forget you can use it only on the inner screen. Plus, the "S-Pen Case" made the Z Fold 5-6 much thicker!!!
@fendykusumohadi
@fendykusumohadi Месяц назад
Please review deeply the camera honor magic v3 also. Thanks 🙏
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Sure will do tomorrow hopefully.
@fendykusumohadi
@fendykusumohadi Месяц назад
@@maddada thanks 🙏
@AlexAnder-iq2ix
@AlexAnder-iq2ix Месяц назад
​@@maddadaThanks in advance 🙏 Great videos, keep on like this 💪 We like to see the main camera in real, no fakes 😂
@fendykusumohadi
@fendykusumohadi Месяц назад
Can't wait to see you review the camera & video 4k 60 at maximum zoom out , which vivo x fold 3 pro can reach maximum zoom 10x at 4k 60 and 4k 30 fps while recording video.. and 4k 30 ​ @@maddada
@AlexAnder-iq2ix
@AlexAnder-iq2ix Месяц назад
@@maddada thanks in advance for the camera review
@BigBoss-ms8ff
@BigBoss-ms8ff Месяц назад
Does it overheat? Can you do some benchmark tests to verify if you have this issue as well?
@davidkostka7602
@davidkostka7602 Месяц назад
When can we expect your Q&A video? Cant wait! Haha 😅
@ameerr.7614
@ameerr.7614 Месяц назад
Bro also if you can make a full gaming and stress test review of it, it will be the first on youtube as of now
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@ameerr.7614 sure will do
@kseigfried08
@kseigfried08 Месяц назад
Wich pen exactly are you using? I have a Huawei pen and can not get it paired. Did you do something speciall to get it paired?
@jemfalor
@jemfalor Месяц назад
thanks for this info. honor magic-pen
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Search for this on Ali Express and you'll see the one I bought "Honor Magic Pen For Honor Magic V2". It costs ~100 USD.
@jemfalor
@jemfalor Месяц назад
@maddada no no. I'm thanking @kseigfried08 because he had tested huawei pen on honor phone. i wanted to know if other AES pen works on honor phone, that's why i thanked him
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@jemfalor didn't mean to mention you on the previous message, sorry 😅
@scottrixon5312
@scottrixon5312 Месяц назад
What is the Honor notes app like? I assume it syncs, but no desktop app? Can you test with OneNote for a cross platform app? Good test on the outside screen while off, and like the idea of keeping the same note open... Very smart.
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
It does sync to Honor Cloud, and I believe there's a way to access them from your browser (not 100% sure though, didn't do enough research since I don't use this app). You can't sync the Honor Notes App with OneNote, so you should use OneNote to create the notes on the phone instead.
@simonkaggwanjala
@simonkaggwanjala Месяц назад
How much did this cost? Give us details please. Which country did you buy it from?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Bought it from average dad tech store. Has 1 year warranty but need to ship it to use the warranty. And I paid 1210 british pounds for it.
@Alex83mlf
@Alex83mlf 5 дней назад
@maddada did Honor, by chance, send a OTA upgrade to let the Magic Pen to be use as a trigger for the Camera to pic photos by tapping the Magic Pen's button?
@maddada
@maddada 5 дней назад
No, but there's a way to do it using "button mapper", you can make it play/pause music when outside the camera app, and take pictures when inside the camera app. See my 1 week review video, I speak about how you can do this.
@RashidMidani
@RashidMidani 19 дней назад
Can u advise my pen in honor is showing less option than your videos ????r u using honor Chinese rom ? Im using V2 on ios 8
@maddada
@maddada 19 дней назад
Yes the international Honor V2 has less options for the pen but the ones you're missing aren't thaat useful to be honest.
@i-Mozart
@i-Mozart 4 дня назад
عندي ماجيك v3 بس خيارات القلم اللي عندي اقل من اللي عندك هل اقدر اضيفها لجهازي ؟
@maddada
@maddada 4 дня назад
@@i-Mozart هلا اخوي، لا ما تقدر تضيفها حالياً بس ممكن يضيفونها فتحديث. الصراحة الخيارات الاضافية للقلم الي على النظام الصيني مش خطيرة لذيك الدرجة وتقدر تسويها بطرق ثانية فلا تشغل بالك عليها كثير.
@sirnikolas
@sirnikolas Месяц назад
Awesome mate! Thanks from downunder 🇦🇺😍
@laurelchang61
@laurelchang61 15 дней назад
Is the Honor Magic pen part of the package? Where to store the magic pen? Can't seem to find any hidden compartment to store the magic pen in V3.
@maddada
@maddada 15 дней назад
Yes, is coming with the phone in most countries if you buy the international version. I carry mine in my shirt's pocket or in my shoulder bag, but you could probably find some cases on aliexpress that can house the pen (will make the phone thicker though)
@nacho3570
@nacho3570 Месяц назад
Sorry if you mentioned it, but can you select any text on the honor as you can with the samsung?? On my Z Fold I can select text from any app by holding the button, even if it's not an editable field. (I don't mean taking a screenshot and then using OCR like Smart Select. I know you can do that in any phone) Also does the pen work as mouse in the browser (i.e. opening hover menus that normally don't work on phones)
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Thank you for telling me about the "selecting any text" feature on Samsung, didn't know about it even though I used the S Pen a ton. On the Honor you'd have to take a screenshot (3 finger swipe down or from the pen menu) then select the text from that (you can translate, search, copy, etc.) Yes, the hover feature does work on the Honor. It seems this feature stopped working a while ago on my Fold 4 because I had an accessibility service on, I disabled it and tried multiple browsers and Firefox is the best one for this hover behavior (on both the Magic V3 and the Fold 4). I see a lot of reports on reddit that it's not working except on Firefox.
@nacho3570
@nacho3570 Месяц назад
@@maddada Thank you for your response!!! I love how in depth your videos are. Now I'm gonna watch the Samsung Dex one
@user-iz2wp7tb1n
@user-iz2wp7tb1n Месяц назад
Great Video ☺️ Can I ask please what Wireless charger did you buy for your Honor v3?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
It's the 100w Honor Wireless charger, got it from Ali Baba, but wouldn't recommend it if you like to use your phone unfolded while on the pc. I'll talk more about it in the FAQ video very soon.
@sebastienmorelli4488
@sebastienmorelli4488 Месяц назад
Nice video, thanks ! Do you know if Nova launcher and the Time-line function in GMaps work on MagicOS ?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
They do work on the international version that will come around September hopefully, but they don't on the Chinese one that I'm showing here.
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
Excellent thanks habib, I was between Honor Magic v3 and Vivo xfold 3 pro, I was worried about honor's battery life and now it looks like it's a 2 day battery, can you please confirm. By the way thanks bro I'm watching from Australia 🦘
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
The battery life is excellent so far, and if you need to charge up you can get 0 to 50% charge in 20 mins (wireless charging is almost just as fast as wired - 66w wireless vs 50w wireless)
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
@@maddada شكرا صديقي العزيز
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
What do you think about Vivo xfold 3 pro or xfold 3? Have you tried it, in fact I never used S-pen even when I had Galaxy S23 Ultra
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Honestly get the Vivo Global if you don't care about the Pen and want to buy a Fold now + don't mind a bit heavier and thicker phone. It has a bit better cameras and performance than the other foldables and everything should work great due to it being global version. I didn't get it because of the extra weight and size and the lack of the pen.
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
@@maddada I agree even the Chinese version is alright I don't use android Auto because the latest Mercedes Benz don't let you use it in full screen , the performance looks very steady and higher than other foldable phones, trashed Samsung Z6 easy in benchmarks, Xiaomi mix fold 4 had a terrible result too , the only thing that holds me vs Honor Magic v3 is it has bigger battery 5700mha and extremely fast charge 120watt and zies camera set almost to what I have vivo x 100 pro which is a beast, Honor Magic is just thinner than vivo, I can get Vivo xfold 3 pro under 1900 AUD and Honor is just 2200$ . But still I love Honor just because it's thin
@TheYeowyap
@TheYeowyap Месяц назад
where do you bought this phone? also does it comes with google play store?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Yes it does, bought it from average dad tech store. I would recommend waiting for the international version around September if you can as there are some things that don't work with the Chinese version that I'm showing here.
@RonRon-pk7ob
@RonRon-pk7ob Месяц назад
Average dad is the worst store around. He talks to people just like they work for him. Everybody should avoid him.
@fchaabo
@fchaabo Месяц назад
Thank you so much, Maddada, for yet another detailed great review. You have earned my sub! I just have a few questions please: 1. Is the handwrite to text (type) feature as good as Samsung's handwrite recognition in the notes app of the V3 and does it support mutliple languages? 2. Is there a handwrite to text feature built in the keyboard like in Samsung's keyboard? 3. Is there a feature to cut out parts of the handwritten notes to move them around in the V3 notes app like there in the Samsung notes app (it's the selection tool)? تابع عملك البارع. سوف تصبح من أهم اليو تيوبرس في المستقبل. لقد أحببتني أكثر بهذا الجوال العظيم!
@fchaabo
@fchaabo Месяц назад
If I could also add 2 more questions please not related to the pen: A. How are the speakers for music compared between the V3 and Fold4. Which do you feel is better (in loudness, clarity, and bass)? Maybe you could demonstrate this as part of another new video, which could be part 3 for comparison. B. If you would rate the OS of both the V3 (Magic OS) and Fold4 (OneUI) on a scale of 10, what would it be for each? Thanks again!
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Handwriting to text works great didn't face any issues with it. You can also make it take handwriting from the whole screen (not specifically on the text box)
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
I don't think there's handwriting in the keyboard, and the default keyboard in the Chinese version is not great (it's called honor ime). I switched to SwiftKey for it's amazing swiping and Ai integration (copilot).
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Yes there's a selection tool in the notes app, let's you scale and move the handwriting
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
The speakers are louder and clearer than the fold 4, no complaints.
@lawrencetq5689
@lawrencetq5689 Месяц назад
Thanks for this. How're you finding battery life?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
It's splendid, full day of heavy use without thinking about charging. And if I do need to charge then it's 0 to 50 in about 20 mins.
@RonRon-pk7ob
@RonRon-pk7ob Месяц назад
Which pen do you like better?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
I like the Honor one more, but I'll answer in the Q & A video today :)
@shirlleychan
@shirlleychan 21 день назад
What the difference for third party app like onenote? Both supporting pressure sensitive ?
@maddada
@maddada 21 день назад
Yes, pressure sensitivity works with both pens.
@mohamedzaghloul2580
@mohamedzaghloul2580 23 дня назад
Thx for the lovely video. Can you take photos with the honor pen please?
@maddada
@maddada 23 дня назад
Yes, I show this in the next video (Honor V3 FAQ)
@BigBoss-ms8ff
@BigBoss-ms8ff Месяц назад
Thanks a lot!
@SomeJohndoe
@SomeJohndoe 12 дней назад
Hows the palm rejection can you rest your hand on the display whilst writing?
@maddada
@maddada 12 дней назад
The palm rejection is good, as soon as the tip gets close it ignores your fingers/palm. Didn't have any issues with this.
@SomeJohndoe
@SomeJohndoe 11 дней назад
@@maddada great thanks
@adamtiba
@adamtiba Месяц назад
السلام عليكم اخي ماهو رايكم بالجهاز وهل تنصحون به بعد التجربة وماهو رايكم بالاشعارات
@mohamedfawzy4377
@mohamedfawzy4377 Месяц назад
جهاز اونر معايا وأفضل بكثير من فولد ٦
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
بنشر فيديو قريب اتكلم عن رايي للان، بس الجهاز اسطوري الصراحة. الاشعارات مافيها اي مشاكل.
@Jam-nv5gm
@Jam-nv5gm День назад
Hey, thanks for the video. Do you find the pen experience as good as the s pen? I use my fold 4 extensively for work and I draw on it everiday. Used to have a Note 10+ before it, so not sure if I'd be downgrading from Samsung s pen and software to Honor!
@maddada
@maddada 14 часов назад
It's good but the only thing is the tip is not plastic and thin like the one that comes with Samsung, so it's personal preference if you would like it or not. (maybe for precise drawing the Fold's is better since the tip is smaller. But for taking notes they're both good)
@Jam-nv5gm
@Jam-nv5gm 6 часов назад
@@maddada thanks, I guess I'll have to wait for Samsung to evolve. I have a Microsoft Surface and the pen is way worse than the s-pen, I would regret it for sure.
@maddada
@maddada 6 часов назад
I'm hoping Samsung wakes up and gives us a great Fold next year too. Just had to switch away from the Fold 4 because I found it very hard to use.
@Jam-nv5gm
@Jam-nv5gm 6 часов назад
I think between this one and the Huawei Tri fold they will defenitly have to to do something. To me it didn't have to be as thin as the V3, only a bit thinner, but it should be the same aspect ratio, not only for better screen space, but better battery, integrated S-Pen and pen support on the outer screen.
@maddada
@maddada 5 часов назад
@@Jam-nv5gm yes the outer screen's width is main reason I went with the Honor and canceled my Fold 6 Preorder. Hope it's better next time.
@stu13th
@stu13th Месяц назад
Is the pen the same one that you use with the V2 or do they have a new one out for the V3 now?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Same pen
@jemfalor
@jemfalor Месяц назад
​@@maddada I'm hoping they could introduce a new slimmer pen using silicon carbon battery
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
By the way which colour was lighter than others, I forgot to ask 😂
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Black is the lightest color at 226g, the other colors are 230g so it's not a noticeable difference at all. Black is also slippery without a case because it has a different material. Just get the color you like.
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
@@maddada how heavy is the weight with the cover that you showed us, is it thr one you got from the box or you purchased separately?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
​@@AloMal-wj6fxI showed the one that came in the box in the other video. I'll check the weight and reply in the Q And A video tomorrow.
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
@@maddada thanks again for your help I appreciate it
@balloonredd
@balloonredd Месяц назад
Do you know what the pen protocol is? Ks it AES 2.0. do the box or manual mention.
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
I just got the pen case no box or manual. I can't find anything online about the protocol. Why are you asking btw?
@balloonredd
@balloonredd Месяц назад
@@maddada just curious if i can use other AES 2.0 styli i got lying around
@saleh45251
@saleh45251 Месяц назад
Does google command voice work with it? (hey google)..if so, how to activate it?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@saleh45251 No you can get vivo x fold pro international or wait for Magic V3 international for that. For me I have a button on homescreen to launch assistant because I don't like it waking up mistakenly.
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@saleh45251 I'll share more on the q & a video today.
@balloonredd
@balloonredd Месяц назад
just use button mapper and assign voluime down to it
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@balloonredd Thank you for the idea :) Button mapper is very useful!
@LorrenceTubbs
@LorrenceTubbs Месяц назад
My Google Assistant doesn't work at all on my V3 🤔
@RonRon-pk7ob
@RonRon-pk7ob Месяц назад
Can I know where did you buy the Honor Magic pen from?
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Ali Express
@musabtulaimat8976
@musabtulaimat8976 Месяц назад
اسمع تبيع مستعمل ؟ عندي شرا
@musabtulaimat8976
@musabtulaimat8976 Месяц назад
please come fomo on saturday
@AloMal-wj6fx
@AloMal-wj6fx Месяц назад
It's very funny when compared to Samsung Z4 as it looks with a cover like a construction brick in your pocket .
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@AloMal-wj6fx yep, the Fold 6 is better but still thick, especially if you put a case on it.
@AlexAnder-iq2ix
@AlexAnder-iq2ix Месяц назад
​​​@@maddadacan you please also check the weight of the V3 without the case? I saw somewhere that it is 236g instead of 226g??? Thanks 👍🍀
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
@@AlexAnder-iq2ix no it's 226 for sure. 230g for the non-black colors.
@AlexAnder-iq2ix
@AlexAnder-iq2ix Месяц назад
@@maddada Did you verify it? In another video someone took the white V3 on the scale and it showed 236 gramms.
@defnot.ibrahim6450
@defnot.ibrahim6450 Месяц назад
i love your videos so much keep it up 🤍
@maddada
@maddada Месяц назад
Thank you man :)
@musabtulaimat8976
@musabtulaimat8976 Месяц назад
هههههه نصاب انت؟؟ بكم التلفون جد
Далее
BeastMasters Hawk just had enough #ti13
00:30
Просмотров 341 тыс.
HONOR Magic V3 Review - An Amazing Foldable!
24:29
Просмотров 27 тыс.
Pixel 9 Pro Fold Review | Google vs Galaxy Z Fold 6
19:45
Things To Try On Your Samsung Today
14:22
Просмотров 65 тыс.