So if that’s the case why hasn’t it been successful? Why has the majority of communist countries reverted to capitalism? Why has communism fostered dictatorship and Authoritarian leadership. If communism has delivered to the poor equally then why are the communist leaders living more affluent than its constituents?
That is not the truth. The western countries that tell us not to intervene has government companies themselves and they even send their companies to go and steal from other countries and they support them. This lady does not have any solution except fake accent
@@AndrewMcFarlane_1 We can't speak or think as if Capitalism is an economic system endorsed by G-d. If America is a poster boy of Capitalism. I would venture to say her too paved her economic trajectory through atrocities. Indigenous Red Indians had to die in their millions. I can even point out too that trans-Atlantic slavery fueled that is now viewed as a G-d given gift to humanity, system called Capitalism.
@@comancheflyer4903 have you heard of the 1 child policy? How many children were killed because of that? I can tell you... 336million... The parents wanted those children... The CCP didn't...
@@bafanamahlatse1923 with all the natural resources we constantly Boast about why are our oeople nd children dying risking their lives for better. Kenya has shown Africa how it's done against Evils imposed on them.
Thanks for this well-researched presentation. You were absolutely Brilliant on this panel! Displayed Exemplary Self-Control amid severe provocation. The condecention displayed by the gentleman from the "ruling" party, when he repeatedly spoke over you, was a disgrace!
black anc males only use females in their party, in reality they believe their male genitals automatically puts them above females. Sort of like juliarse's 'natural intelligence' concept ....
Concerned Citizen here. Welcome back Katlego! I like your teaching methods and research, you back everything with facts and logic, things our politicians lack. Can we learn from Singapore and countries like Japan...
@@jacklenge531 The land ownership is just a saying. Most people don't want land, if they got land they wouldn't know what to do with it ! I don't own land. Let the farmers who know how to use it, keep their land. Ahole !
Well done,Katlego.Indeed a concerned citizen.Intelligently presented and as always reminding us to beware of the "Tavarishes".Brilliantly researched and on point.Bravo!!!
I think you crushed... no, you obliterated that ignoramus comrade in the ENCA debate. Well done. And , thank you for today's video. The great misfortune is that 90 percent of South African people want to live in ignorance and only vote for the present and not for tomorrow. I really do pray that it will change. Keep up the good fight, dear lady🤗
I urge everyone to look into the horrors of The Great Leap Forward. The stories of what people were doing for food is truly heartbreaking. Stories of people resorting to eating family members who starved to death or even murdering people and cannibalizing them. People were even giving away their children in exchange for food. The Chinese Famine is truly the worst famine in human history. It's very sad and scary that people in modern South Africa are pushing for policies that lead to the death of 45 million people due to starvation.
💔💔💔 I really think History (undiluted) should be made compulsory in our schools, not an option Knowing history equips us to identify people, policies and parties that want to lead us to life and success and those that want to lead us to death and failure What happened in China under Communism truly is heartbreaking and if more people knew this, they would shun communist parties very quickly
@CitizenConcerned I agree. The only part of history that's focused on in South African schools is Apartheid. A vital part of history for sure but it's what keeps us voting along racial lines and stuck on identity politics. Broadening our knowledge of history will show us that evil truly knows no colour and neither does good.
For people who are out to vote for the incumbent party( esp) or any commie party they should read: Countdown To Socialism by Anthea Jeffery. 2. External Mission: ANC In Exile by Stephen Ellis. These two books WILL MAKE all the other books such as Andre de Ruyter's: Truth To Power, Kyle Cowan's: Sabotage: Eskom Under Siege ETC make sense. At least for me they connected the dots. These voters are either drowning in ignorance (which is dangerous) or confusion or just stubbornly loyal. S/O to everybody who really loves this country and are independent thinkers. Let us be on the right side of history!! S/O to you @katlimoagi South Africa let us READ READ READ AND READ!!! PLEASE!
The cultural revolution was so sick! Tell me this isn't what happend/is happening in SA. Parent/child , teacher/student relationships? The "young and energetic" may act anyhow without corrective consequence? And isnt this mainly in the majority group? I recommend that people read External Mission: ANC In Exile by Stephan Mills and Countdown To Socialism by Anthea Jeffery. These helped me connect so many dots.
I am FOR Capitalism because less babies are being born under Capitalism. Keep up the good work. At this rate there will be no more Westerners and East Asians by 2100
I am FOR Capitalism because less babies are being born under Capitalism. Keep up the good work. At this rate there will be no more Westerners and East Asians by 2100
Mugabe was a loud and arrogant idiot who brought misery upon his people. His bread basket is now a basket case and a circus..unfortunately, ANC is going full speed in the same direction. To be honest there is good and bad about both Communism and capitalism. It is also true that there is no example of any capitalist country where race or ethnicity has not mattered. Ultimately, we are moving away from capitalism to technofudalism with both the United States and China at the helm of that new epoch.
My sister, not sure if you went unprepared or you're just not meant for public debate but I do love your videos. You're pumping wonderful meaningful videos. Please keep it up there. We need more of people like you. Kudos 👏
Thing about communists regimes is, they mistake their huge Egos for strength, and we see it in SA too, with how the ANC and especially the EFF having the gall to threaten and tell other countries whats what. Putins paper army melting in Ukraine, and China falling apart internally while selling the world the notion all is peachy, and then their forces shitting their pants whenever any American is nearby. They are like like the bully at school, who pokes the quiet kid, slowly working toward getting a PK thatd put them in their place.
@@bafanamahlatse1923 Dont think she got it right. The ANC is more trying to immolate the methods of Russia or China. They are, of course very typical of communist regimes, both in attitude and methods. All of the things that brought ruin to all countries that adopted Communism.
Ohh how I love this channel. Love the way you just keep shedding truth and light into our lives. Keep up the good work. I admire the time you put in to deliver accurate information, that many south africans need to hear and see to open their eyes.
Brilliant, I am so glad you have presented these historical facts. Thank you for presenting this so well in this way on your channel. Sadly Dictators tend to loose sight of the value of "Human Life". 🙏
The lagest Apple manufacturing factory in the world is in China and owned by Americans but Malema says we must do away with America and be a socialist like china😂😢
we need a new government that can attract apple and tesla to set up factories here. we also need General electricity and Tesla to invest in green energy in south africa.
Omg my Girl you are a shining star. Your parents and family Ahould ne proud of you. Can you school these dumb and ignorant politicians who just open their mouths. Well done sister.
Thank you for another well researched and explained subject. There's so much information, put into time line sequences that is frankly, eye opening! 💕👏🏻
I hope ANC leaders and followers are listening especially that EFF stokvel leaders. Communism has no place in SA unless we want to turn this country into a waste land. Julius Malema and his cult followers need to read more and understand economic models that work throughout the world.
I have a few friends who had been working in China main land for 6 years.. And not even being involved in their worker unions, they had their bonuses from last year reclaimed this year. As the Chinese company they were working for, is in such dire straights that they are doing everything they can to get money, even stealing from their employees.
There are mass firings in the US tech sector including Tesla? One was even sleeping in his car to achieve record production. China is building a better society than the US were they have massive incarceration, homelessness and decaying infrastructure
China has capitalist zones but still a communist country. Capitalism has different versions. Germany capitalism is different from USA capitalism. China is practicing their version, I guess.
Nope. Exchanging value for money. That's capitalism. And China's economy is capitalism. That's why they have "rich" people too. Cuba is a communist country. Go check "the rich" in Cuba. You are probably doing way better than them.
The bottom line is that both the ANC and EFF needs to listen to the people what they wants and needs are not dictating to us what is right or wrong because they are always wrong and right to fill their own pockets.Rightly said Beware of the comrades😊😊
@@tshedisomoloi9689 go check Cuba and Venezuela communism, and see if it "works" for them. By the way I've heard Shivambu shouting with a loud voice: " we want to be like Cuba!!!". 😂😂😂 It's so sad when you see stupidity being supported by so many who don't comprehend the catastrophe laying ahead, which will badly affect the very same supporters!! What a disaster!!!
I can't resist to comment. Iwas born in Mozambique. just like me, many of my friends and family, Mozambicans by birth, believed that the independence would turn us into a proud independent nation. No so, Frelimo, choose the path of communism and cientific socialism. Nationalised all the buildings, houses, businesses, doctors, industries. Forced people into comunal farms. The result was a total colapse of the economy, mismanagement, famine, corruption, and many people arrested for disagreeing with their policies. A civil war started and over a million people dead. Angola went through the same. Civil war, stagnation and corruption. Isabel Santos, the daughter of the president became the richest woman in Africa, at the age of 35+-. A country incredible rich in natural resources and yet the people are still miserable. When I listen to Malema, I have not doubt that he will push South Africa into the abyss and collapse. It will take South Africa decades to recover from it. A leader motivated by hate, will never bring anything good. Just look at Hitler.
That Karl Marx that People like Julius Love so much..... actually lived most of his life in England..... his but wrote about an ideology that he never lived. Conman!!
England tested all these policies but finally choose d the one that will allow England to kill and steal from any country in the world. Now England is going down because there is nothing more to steal. So what was keeping England economy was stealing and exploitation and not capitalism
That was what I asked myself while studying Marxism.This guy came from a middle class family and lives in England.Got in trouble with one of my profs when questining this dicotomy.Anyway I passed😅Send this video to Julius and his "doctor" colleague AND JJT.
@@kfutuahnkain86 I don't usually reply to uneducated people but let me try today... okay answer this question, why Ther is no billionaires in communist but they are lots of billionaires in capitalist??? But you say communist benefits the most and capitalist benefits few.
@@sizwe000 Stop making noise but tell us those policies that will narrow the gap between the rich and the poor in SA? Simple. This lady is misleading people without coming up with solution. When capitalism fails they tell us that it is not capitalism and when communism works they tell us that it is not comunism. The truth is that, what works is a combination or a good mixture of both. Apatheid government was doing well in terms of economy more than ANC by intervening in the economy and that is why they created all these government companies. so long as the intervention is not taking away the existing private sector there is no problem and that is what EFF policies are. No one has faulted EFF on their policies
JJ must educate himself. SA is a mixed economy (Socialism + Capitalism). We have over 700 SOEs in almost all sectors controlled by government including land bank that has powers to acquire land.
Greed, lack of jobs, and how to exploit the system for maximum personal gain. With Artificial intelligence and China's big advancements in that area, the middle class is fainting faster and faster. There is nothing to trickle down to the needy and desperate! God bless you! 🙏🙌❤
Thank you for saying this straight out. Communist China is over. Our current government is doing exactly what communist China did. We can just hope South African voters will be informed on 27 May 2024. 👍🇿🇦
hi katlego it is pity your show is not broadcasted into every home and school i am surprized the comrades has not banned you .Some people only look back and will never move forward,Malema is preparing a RED GAURD with our young people .lets start building a new south africa for a better life for all .apartheid was a form of communistic values do we want that again May GOD bless you and keep you safe always sending lots of love Robert
History in schools is not taught fully by reducing the content that implementers don't like. To get rid of bad leaders we just have to pray and God will help us by turning the hearts of voters to vote for good leaders.
The ANC did the same on a smaller scale with older black people with necklaces. They also used the youth. Their own family members were executed because the youth were angry when older family members reprimanded them. They were accused of treason and snitches for NP.
Our politicians want power with a lack of evolving education. They all have memory rather than vision. South Africa does not need to copy any ideologies. Systems do exist to make SA great. SA need right sober caliber of politicians and a coherent strategy.
I agree with you Bonginkosi these things of communism and capitalism were created by human beings China was engaged into communism structures and later to capitalism maybe we as south Africans can also create our own structures that can make this country to go forward I would suggest that commutalism can work combination of communism and capitalism because capitalism on its own in S.A has failed richer getting more richer and poorer becoming more poorer
Capitalism gave us apartheid but we don't define it as Capitalism, why then should socialism be defined by it's bad leaders? If it is genuinely that bad why the double standard?
Capitalism is called a free market society. Free market is one where the government let's citizen's buy or sell or own whatever they want. Apartheid was a system against people of colour that's opposite of Capitalism. Capitalism is a free market. Apartheid didn't give us a free market. Therefore you can't say it's capitalist.
PERFORMANCE DRIVEN ECONOMY BASED ON HONESTY AND SINCERITY. LEADING BY EXAMPLE. JUDGING BY RESULTS. A MERITOGRACY WHERE EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS ARE EMPLOYED.
I commend China for giving their local entrepreneurs a monopoly in whatever business they opened. They made sure they blocked foreign competition to local businesses the same way America does. The only difference is that America does it in a subtle way while China does it blatantly. Another thing they do is that they allow foreign companies to come in and use their cheap skilled labor to create products, few years later they copy those products and make them better than the foreign companies. It's a good strategy. However I don't agree with everything that they do. If you speak out against the government in China that advantage they gave you gets seized by the government and you lose everything and may even get death penalty for it. Any government that can't be sincerely criticized is not a fair government cos all it takes is one corrupt leader and China will be back to full blown communism.
It's very important also to expose ourselves to another narrative on this topic. Clearly, Capitalism wins on PR but a book by a South Korean economist, Ha-Joon Chang 'Kicking Away The Ladder' shines a light so brightly. Developing economies are preached to, to adopt free-market economy whereas the so-called developed economies never adopted the free-market system, government intervened heavily in the economy but they are telling others not to do so. Who is fooling who here, when their governments have just intervened to rescue private banks during the 2008 financial meltdown? Capitalists hate interventions yet run to government when in trouble The South Korean experience is something to admire. Joseph Stieglitz, a US academic also writes extensively on the lie that if you enrich the few capitalists, their wealth will 'trickle-down' to the poor. If Communists lie about taking wealth from the rich to the poor. Capitalists also lie with their trickle-down rubbish.
You are correct my brother. The big economies are using these policies to keep the rest of the world poor by them exploiting or stealing from every country else they should also open their economies for us to also buy their public companies. You can also read a book called the economic hitman
