Тёмный

House of the Dead by Fyodor Dostoyevsky (Book Review) 

Life Lessons From Books
Подписаться 4,7 тыс.
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.
50% 1

Hello everyone,
Let's face it. I'm obsessed with Dostoyevsky and this time around I read House of the Dead. This is a MUST read for anyone who wants to learn about human psychology, behaviours and traits when you put people together under forced labour and forced cohabitation.
This book was an eye opener. In lots of places, I couldn't help but be horrified such as the years of being chained to the wall, the pecking order, the constant insults, arguments, flogging and the bitter cold, the lice and most of all the meaningless existence just waiting out a sentence. No thank you.
The recount of the Siberian bath house - a hell on earth - where they piled prisoners inside was stifling to read. I nearly fainted just thinking about it.
Yet there were also moments where you could see Dostoyevsky appreciating his fellow man. I say in this video, he went through his own Victor Frankl moment in this prison - a personal transformation that we see in his writing of all his characters in his books afterwards.
While reading this book, I couldn't shake off the feeling that it was like reading Catch-22 (I have a book review on this channel on this Joseph Heller book). The themes of meaningless drudgery labour plus forced cohabitation, the bickering and insults of men living with each other, rang very similar to Catch 22. Maybe Heller was a Dostoyevsky fan too??
What did you think of this book?
Is it one that you'd like to read? (I'd say yes, put it on your reading list).
#reading #books #bookreviews #literature #booktube #lifelessons #lifelessonsthroughbooks #activatelearning #helenblunden #dostoyevsky

Опубликовано:

 

30 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 28   
@neon_trotsky
@neon_trotsky 4 месяца назад
You must read the brothers karamazov. The best book I've ever read.
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 4 месяца назад
Yes! It's on the TBR list as I have all of Dostoyevsky's books. Now that winter is coming, I think I may need to get cracking into this one. Thanks for watching.
@alyoshazeifman4657
@alyoshazeifman4657 7 месяцев назад
Nice review. Finishing it up now and it made the reading more enjoyable. It's not a bad book. It has some highlights, but I would say underwhelming compared to Dostoevsky's other works. Certainly useful to understand Russian history.
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts. Happy reading! 📚
@williamsawyer9894
@williamsawyer9894 3 дня назад
I'm finishing up reading "Notes from a Dead House" right now. This strikes me as essential reading. Why isn't it read and discussed more? How does it compare to Alexander Solzhenitsyn's "The Gulag Archipelago" (another book about Siberian forced-labor prisons)?
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks День назад
True. I should have read this book years ago! I'm sure if people knew about it, they'd talk about it more. Maybe they think reading Dostoyevsky is hard? (That's what I thought initially). I've not heard of the Gulag Archipelago. Would you recommend it?
@niles9542
@niles9542 10 месяцев назад
I am starting this book today as part of my own personal Dostoevsky December. Your review is fantastic and just what I was looking for before I jump in. BTW, I started with C&P then read Bros. K last year. I read The Gulag Archipelago, but that was in the Seventies, so I feel your review has braced me for the horror of the camp. Thanks.
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 10 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching. You’ll have no issues with reading this book after reading his others. You may even recognise some of the characters and situations in it after reading his other books. I love “Dostoyevsky December”. That’s a brilliant idea!
@Abuamina001
@Abuamina001 3 месяца назад
Charming review. Have you ever read "Hadji Murad" by Leo Tolstoy ? Another forgotten gem.
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 3 месяца назад
No I haven't. I haven't even heard of it but you sent me down a rabbit warren now exploring it. Thanks for this recommendation, I've added it to my list of books to read!
@Abuamina001
@Abuamina001 3 месяца назад
@@LifeLessonsFromBooks ... guaranteed hours of family fun and entertainment.🙂
@nicholasjones3207
@nicholasjones3207 6 месяцев назад
I’m looking forward to reading this after I finish devils by the same author. Also, having read gulag archipelago I want to read this. It will also give more context to raskolnikov at the end of crime and punishment. Thanks for the background
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 6 месяцев назад
Thanks for watching and sharing your recommendation too. Looking forward to reading Crime and Punishment too.
@bluecrow3748
@bluecrow3748 Год назад
I love this review !
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks Год назад
Thank you :-)
@sergejilarionovich9693
@sergejilarionovich9693 7 месяцев назад
Great review, thank you. Weird title translation though.
@doinitforthestreets
@doinitforthestreets 5 месяцев назад
Thanks for the review, I didn't find a lot on this book elsewhere on the internet either. I get Catch-22 vibes as well, an absurd humor that's quite enjoyable at times. I have a few thoughts based on what you said so I'll share them. As for being childlike, I'm a psychologist that studies human development and childhood trauma as it manifests in adults. What I see is that the psyche is composed of layers so that all adults have children within them. Ideally those children parts are better contained in an adult personality through a normal process of development, so that the infant's boundless narcissism and homicidal rage is not expressed through the power available in the adult male body. But many things can cause us to regress and stress in particular can cause us to default to "lower" brain functions (as in the triune brain theory), even in an otherwise high functioning person. So I see at least a couple ways that adults become childlike, one is through stress, while the other is born that way as the psychopath, the person that for whatever terrible reason continues to see the world through a purely narcissistic lens, but without even the loving heart of the infant. So I would imagine prison anywhere, surrounded by potential threats and at least a few psychopaths, would cause anyone to default to more primitive protective measures that appear childlike from the outside, but as he describes in the book, the way people handle this varies dramatically. At the same time, I don't read this book nearly as darkly as you do. It's got a catch-22 humor and what you read as conflict I often read as more like the working class humor and cajoling that can be found on any construction site today - it wasn't always violent or ill intent in the book, it seems to me. Also Russia in the 19th century was technologically primitive and the things that seemed hard in that prison were probably not that much different on the outside, as he suggests in a few passages, that even some people would prefer prison to the drudgery of trying to make it in the outside world. Next, what surprises me is how much freedom these inmates have, the most important example for me is banya (баня), the baths. In America it would be unthinkable that a group of murderous convicts would be let out into a village for what is effectively a cherished Russian tradition that's like a spa day. Sure, they were all crammed in and it was probably terribly gross in that format but banya is also such a gem of a tradition and some of my best memories are at banya. It's a time to cleanse and it's amazingly good for the body. So yes, of course it is physically brutal and dehumanizing to be in such a prison, but in contrast to an American prison today (and distinguishing what are technological differences from administrative/social differences), there are many aspects of his prison stories that are more humanizing than documentaries I've seen on American prisons today. The prisons in this books also seem to me very different, for instance, from what I've read of the later Stalinist gulags. But I'm no historian and could be totally wrong on these counts.
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 5 месяцев назад
What a brilliant, thoughtful and also thought provoking comment about your reflections based on your own experiences with your work. This is wonderful. I don’t have a psychology background so reading your take on it was fascinating. Also the differences between the Russian and American prisons. I had never thought about the regress and adult behaviour that stems from childhood. I assumed that the environment had some impact also on individual and collective behaviours. All I understood would have been that it would have been highly anxious and stressful. Thank you so much for sharing this. I really do appreciate it.
@MARKK-rz5yw
@MARKK-rz5yw 9 месяцев назад
Hello! I'm from Brazil, nice to meet you! I discovered your channel at the suggestion of a Brazilian booktuber! To date, I have only followed Brazilian booktubers. How great it is to discover the point of view of booktubers from other countries! I intend to meet other booktubers from various countries around the world! This is wonderful! See someone's point of view from as far away as Australia! That's why I'm the newest subscriber to your channel! Welcome! Thank you very much for your work! I love Literature! I intend to discover literature from all over the world! I'm even reading a book by an Australian author eradicated in the United States: GERALDINE BROOKS, winner of a 'Pulitzer': 'Caleb's Crossing'! Genius idea!!..... Greetings from Brazil! 🇧🇷
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 9 месяцев назад
Thank you!! Hello from Melbourne Australia! I’ve not read many Brazilian authors (only Coehlo) and I just looked to see who I can read. What would you recommend so I can find the English translation? Geraldine Brooks is a fabulous writer! Thank you for watching, sharing your thoughts here too. All the best for 2024 and happy reading!!!
@MARKK-rz5yw
@MARKK-rz5yw 9 месяцев назад
@@LifeLessonsFromBooks .....Our greatest Classical author is Machado de Assis. Followed by sensational authors such as Clarice Lispector, - one of our greatest Poets - Carlos Drummond de Andrade, also Classics: Guimarães Rosa, Graciliano Ramos, Jorge Amado, among others! Geraldine Brooks in: 'Caleb's Crossing, enlightened me on several sensational things that I would very much like to know, Like a little of Harvard's history; the issue of the first American Indians to study at Harvard (I never imagined that American Indians had studied at Harvard as early as the 17th century). The first Protestant immigrants in Massachusetts..... Not to mention the excellence of the graphic design in their work! I want to read her other works; I even grabbed her Twitter to send my impressions of her work! Thank You! All the best for 2024 and happy reading in 2024! Cheers! 🎇🎆🎊🎉🎆
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 8 месяцев назад
Thank you for sharing some of your best Brazilian authors. I'll look them up if their works have been translated into English. Mmm, you have prompted me to include some of Brooks works into my reading list for 2024! Happy new year!!
@MARKK-rz5yw
@MARKK-rz5yw 8 месяцев назад
@@LifeLessonsFromBooks Something interesting happens to me.... I have a certain resistance to reading authors from my own Culture! That's why I started reading the World Classics, to see what 'THE WORLD THINKS', and then make a comparison with what my own culture THINKS! I don't know if I'm wrong?!...... HAPPY NEW YEAR! GOOD READINGS FOR THIS YEAR! 🎊🎇🎆📚👍
@LifeLessonsFromBooks
@LifeLessonsFromBooks 8 месяцев назад
I don't think you're wrong at all. SMART MOVE! Genius in fact, because it makes you aware of another's perspective! (In hindsight, maybe that's why I don't read many Australian authors......)??????!!!!
Далее
Редакция. News: 136-я неделя
45:09
Просмотров 1,5 млн
▼ КАПИТАН НАШЁЛ НЕФТЬ В 🍑
33:40
Просмотров 442 тыс.
Se las dejo ahí.
00:10
Просмотров 5 млн
🛑самое главное в жизни!
00:11
Просмотров 35 тыс.
Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte (Book Review)
12:21
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.
OSHO: Books I Have Loved
15:13
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Fernando Pessoa - The Book of Disquiet BOOK REVIEW
17:20
The Gambler by Fyodor Dostoyevsky (Book Review)
17:52
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.
Demons by Dostoevsky Book Review
11:15
Просмотров 25 тыс.
The Grand Inquisitor | Dostoyevsky
8:39
Просмотров 97 тыс.
Редакция. News: 136-я неделя
45:09
Просмотров 1,5 млн