Тёмный
No video :(

WWII Showed How Strong American Manufacturing Is the Foundation of American Freedom 

National Museum of Military Vehicles
Подписаться 19 тыс.
Просмотров 6 тыс.
50% 1

A nation’s armed forces consume military stockpiles rapidly during a state of total war. The Allies won WWII quickly once the U.S. entered the war because the U.S. dominated global manufacturing and became the 'Arsenal of Democracy.' Dan Starks, founder of the National Museum of Military Vehicles, highlights these dynamics and raises awareness of the risk posed to American freedom by outsourcing manufacturing so extensively over the last 50 years.

Опубликовано:

 

21 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 75   
@danor6812
@danor6812 Месяц назад
This man's 100% correct. I have been saying this since the late 70's.
@danielmcelroy8533
@danielmcelroy8533 Месяц назад
The USN today is the IJN of 1941. Well equipped, well trained, highly capable... and completely unreplaceable. I'd also add to your points, we've also abandoned our ability to source and acquire materials and the ability to move it around efficiently when we destroyed so much of our rail infrastructure. Even if we had the manufacturing capabilities, we don't have the ability to get the materials out of the ground or to and from the factories in the quantities needed.
@mahbriggs
@mahbriggs Месяц назад
@@danielmcelroy8533 We are not the only one in that predicament! Look at Russia!
@wwiiimpressionsinc.4727
@wwiiimpressionsinc.4727 Месяц назад
Amen, Mr. Starks! I've watched over the decades how the USA has allowed other "developing" nations to hollow out our manufacturing capability and it disgusts me.
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
great video! probably the most important one youve made yet. thanks for not pulling any punches!
@rotwang2000
@rotwang2000 Месяц назад
When you look at the combined GDP and the Per Capita of the Allies, Germany and Japan are simply dwarfed by the US, the USSR and the British Empire. The discrepancy is so big that's it's not even fair. The Allies have access to 95% of world oil reserves. They have a manpower pool ten times the size of Germany, Italy and Japan combined. There is a common belief that the Allies just barely beat the Axis powers. That it was a very close-run affair and if something had gone wrong the Allies would have been kicked all the way to the Bering Strait. The real question is, how the hell did Germany and Japan last this long against such an onslaught ?
@Cohen.the.Worrier
@Cohen.the.Worrier Месяц назад
Not fair is good, right?
@owensomers8572
@owensomers8572 Месяц назад
Germany, Japan and Italy had prepared for military action for many years before the "World War" started (arguably Japan had been preparing for decades). The US, USSR, Britain and France had sat on their hands since the early 1920s, with the USSR even conducting major purges of the Red Army from 1936 to 1938.
@rotwang2000
@rotwang2000 Месяц назад
@@owensomers8572 The one thing people immediately forget about WWI when discussing WWII is how terrible the war had been for countries like France and Britain. It's always brought up when speaking about the Great War, but so easily dismissed when WWII is involved. Simply put trying to beat the war drum in those days was pure political suicide. There was also the small matters of the Great Depression and there being a massive rupture between the pre-1914 world and the interbellum. The money that used to go to military buildup finally went to helping people. In many ways the person who went to war in 1939 lived in a more prosperous society, they were generally healthier than those who went into battle in 1914. France deduced quite correctly that defensive works were a major obstacle that could not easily be overcome if you had no vulnerable flanks. When building the Maginot line on top of keeping military parity with Germany, they forgot to secure the flanks in a proper manner. Britain had a massive empire to police and the cost was becoming insane. Germany, Japan and Italy were able to beat the military drum and survive politically by cancelling democracy. We always get mentions that a majority of people in the US were against going to war. But people had similar feelings in Germany and Italy or France and Britain. Nobody of sane mind likes to go to war unless the need arises. The US did learn one lesson from the Great War, in that they were unable to get their own industry sorted out for wartime production. Massive plans were made to lay the groundwork of a fast and massive shift in industrial production. Calling out the Army for being small is another misrepresentation. The US had little need for a massive army, in the same way you don't criticize Poughkeepsie for not having one of the top three international airports in the world. The US did have a massive fleet, which was far more important to US needs than the army which at best would to fend off invasions from Canada or Mexico. Italy was too poor and lacked the industrial capacity to play the role it tried to get. Japan built an impressive military arm and planned every step all the way to Pearl Harbor and then their planning becomes a comedy of errors, they become the dog that catches the car and has no clue what to do next. Germany was fantastic at crushing all it's neighbours in limited border wars, but once it tried imperialistic power projection and invaded the USSR they only had 16 weeks of total operational freedom. After that they start to demotorize their army because they don't have the fuel reserves to keep going at the same rate.
@hansulrichboning8551
@hansulrichboning8551 Месяц назад
During the war Nazi-germany and Japan brutally pressed out the countries they have occupied/conquered.Not to forget the Nazi-State was build on depts(for armament and the social benefits the Nazis sweetened up the dictatorship for the germans). Today Nazi-Germany would be rated on trash-level.If the Nazis would not be defeated, they would have went bancrupt sooner or later.
@hansulrichboning8551
@hansulrichboning8551 Месяц назад
@@owensomers8572 One of Hitler`s biggest misconceptions was, that he regarded USSR still as an underdeveloped agriculture country, tsarist russia was. In reality Stalin built up a huge heavy industry that was able to produce quite modern weapons and ammo, but he ruined russian/soviet agriculture(Russia was before 1914 the biggest exporter of grain in the world) by his nuts collectivs and wiping out independent farmers(Kulacks).The delivery of food and grain from the US and Canada helped the USSR probably more to survive and win than thousands of tanks and trucks via lent and lease.Otherwise the evil Nazi-plan to starve the USSR to death may have worked.
@mdxtrains
@mdxtrains 12 дней назад
Well stated. There is another WW2 fact that is often overlooked. The oceans that protected the US. At the beginning, Germany had overwhelming production of all the war material that they needed to bring the fight to Europe and Europe collapsed very quickly. One reason Germany was unable to continue to produce what was needed was their inability to control their own airspace. The early allied bombing strategy based in England was to hinder the German war production. The 1940's technology was not capable of either side attacking across the width of Atlantic or the Pacific to hinder the American production. Move to 2024 and the world is a much smaller place militarily and the oceans will not protect either side from the destructive capabilities of even conventional weapon systems. A WW3 would look much different and be devastating to all.
@dennishutchinson
@dennishutchinson Месяц назад
I agree with you 100%!! Very good history and clear points that need to wake us up.
@rene8736
@rene8736 Месяц назад
As a Austrian, i have to thank America that they didnt give up on Europe and helped to liberate it from hitlers disgusting "Third Reich"
@dennisswaim8210
@dennisswaim8210 Месяц назад
Another fantastic presentation from a fantastic museum. I have got to get out there and visit this museum! So impressive!
@hobbyfarmer62
@hobbyfarmer62 Месяц назад
Have to agree with all your points on our poor manufacturing condition, except I do feel that given enough time we could turn that around. Truth be told the blame can be laid directly at the feet of our politicians who willingly and actively encouraged the loss of manufacturing especially the 2 terms of Mr Obama who actually said on several occasions that our time as a major manufacturing power was over and should be.
@Benisjamminnn
@Benisjamminnn Месяц назад
I'd have to agree that the time of US centric manufacturing is over. You can't bring back these kinds of consumer goods manufacturing to the US without increasing prices. I can't remember the last election where "the other guy did/will make prices go up" wasn't a core part of the campaign. Thankfully, the US still has a strong auto and military industry. That at least gives us a chance to replicate the mass conversion of civilian industry to military.
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
it started under clinton in his 2 terms. remember ross perot talking about the giant sucking sound of jobs going overseas if nafta was adopted? unfortunately bush did nothing to stop it and OWEbomba made it that much worse.
@owensomers8572
@owensomers8572 Месяц назад
You mean like that Carrier plant in Indiana that Trump was going to save, that moved to Mexico (and there are plenty of other examples)? Yeah, blame Obama.
@ThumperLust
@ThumperLust 5 дней назад
December 7, 1941 the US had four fleet aircraft carriers, one sort-of fleet carrier wannabe (USS Wasp), one antiquated carrier (USS Ranger) and a jeep carrier. Only THREE fleet carriers were in the Pacific at the time of the raid on Pearl Harbor, (Saratoga, Lexington and Enterprise). The Yorktown, Ranger and Wasp were in the Atlantic with the jeep air craft carrier. Hornet had been finished but hadn’t even had a shake down cruise yet. The Japanese had only six fleet carriers, one antiquated carrier a single light carrier and two conversion aircraft carriers when the raid on Pearl Harbor took place.
@guylelanglois6642
@guylelanglois6642 Месяц назад
Facts. Won't hear that from congress
@phil20_20
@phil20_20 Месяц назад
Until AOC just impeached SCOTUS members.
@gsr4535
@gsr4535 Месяц назад
What it means today is, we're screwed. We have very, very little manufacturing anymore.
@owensomers8572
@owensomers8572 Месяц назад
Assuming you are talking about the US, that is nonsense. First off, in the event of a shooting war (as opposed to the limited objective police actions the US has been involved in for the last 7 decades) the US military, with its current man power and inventory, would rapidly defeat any attackers. Not that it would be necessary, but there is expansive manufacturing capability available in the US, there are tremendous stock piles of materiel and munitions, and there is an extensive pool of reservists in the form of recently (last 4 years) separated military members. Barring all that, many older veterans would volunteer to return to service (although would need some refresher training), and there is selective service in place if a draft was ordered, and extensive training capability to build up new forces if necessary. But you keep on blowing snot bubbles if it makes you feel better!
@gsr4535
@gsr4535 Месяц назад
@@owensomers8572 You must have been asleep for the past 30 years or so. Never heard of outsourcing . Hmm. Despite your pompous verbiage, you are economically illiterate if you truly believe the USA has the manufacturing ability and the population with requisite engineering & manufacturing skills.
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
probably more than you think. though the parts pipeline certainly is more globalized than back then.
@Mike_Oxhuge_
@Mike_Oxhuge_ Месяц назад
Completely wrong. We dominate the key industries (semis, aircraft, spacecraft, rockets, etc).
@gsr4535
@gsr4535 Месяц назад
@@Mike_Oxhuge_ Sure junior, sure. Keep smoking your "medical marijuana"! Hahahaha
@mahbriggs
@mahbriggs Месяц назад
Arthur Herman wrote a book called "Freedom's Forge"! It was about how the civian industry ramped up to win the war!
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
my favorite ww2 production stat is that during peak production in late 1944 a completed airplane rolled off the production line, on average, every 5 minutes! a brand new warplane every 5 minutes!!! i can only imagine how much ordnance was completed every minute.
@owensomers8572
@owensomers8572 Месяц назад
March 1944 was peak US production, 9,000 aircraft produced. Through the war the Axis (including proxies like Romania and Finland) produced 158,000 aircraft, the US produced 300,000, the rest of the allies produced about 100,000.
@philbosworth3789
@philbosworth3789 Месяц назад
Well put
@cipriantodoran1674
@cipriantodoran1674 10 дней назад
Good video. Good punch line!
@frankmenchaca9993
@frankmenchaca9993 Месяц назад
Xlnt! I believe a strong America starts in the school room. An educated work force will provide quality workers to the Nation. Right now we seem to be chasing our own tail, fighting amongst ourselves while the world passes us by. We are a great country now, but for how long?
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
which is why our public indoctrination system is so flawed and ineffective.
@hansulrichboning8551
@hansulrichboning8551 Месяц назад
Great analysis.Globalisation is a double egded sword.Many products became much cheaper in the last decades thanks to globalisation, but at the end the price may become to high in other respects. The western world is in danger to face the same problems the germans had in WW2.Advanced weaponry, but very complicated,expensive and slow in production.We(the western world) are more or less doing "business at usual"(despite some attempts to ramp up production), while russia is on a war economy-mode for nearly 2 years and still able to bypass sanctions via China,India and others. To reduce globalisation and dependence in fields of strategic importance may be necessary. To quote W.I.Lenin:"The capitalists will sell us the rope we will hang them with".
@CthulhuInc
@CthulhuInc Месяц назад
the us is not alone in the war for freedom - please don't forget that
@NMMV_USA
@NMMV_USA Месяц назад
Absolutely!! Thank you all American Allies. Didn't mean to suggest otherwise.
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
all the usas manufacturing prowess would have been for naught had it not been for the bulwark of britian, its commonwealth, france, the chinese, and the ussr. by the same measure their sacrifices wouldve been for naught had the usa not been involved with its industrial might. it was a team effort! i never forget that and neither do most the the historically minded people i know.
@phil20_20
@phil20_20 Месяц назад
China has known about all of this for all of those lost decades. They helped to bring it about, and that was no accident. The Chinese are building their army, and they are making us pay for it.
@2fwelding842
@2fwelding842 Месяц назад
While i agree with reducing dependency. The us ma ufavtireing capability is fairly present except in boutique form. A lot of complex high end manufacturering is done in us. That and massive stockpiles could work out. The issue would be in low end high production. We could crank out high quality high tech components, but would have issues on lpw quality mass production. light transport vehicles, small cargo carriers, helmets, uniforms... Last is going to be controversial but with how everything is right now why would china attack. They own large portions of and profit heavily from us. Ideological differences dont matter when your already a superpower.
@mahbriggs
@mahbriggs Месяц назад
I have heard that argument before, but guess who Germany's biggest trading partner was in 1939!
@2fwelding842
@2fwelding842 Месяц назад
@@mahbriggs which have you heard? I dont think either is original, if about manufacturing abilities, noone question's early german machining abilities. The us advantage is we have the size and resources locally. If talking trade ford and gm stayed involved helping germany until they werent legally allowed and up to winning lawsuits post war for damages to truck factories built to make trucks for germany during the war
@mahbriggs
@mahbriggs Месяц назад
@@2fwelding842 which have I heard? What was the choice? Is our heavy manufacturing capability no longer what it was? I don't think there is an y question about that. Was Germany capable of producing equipment with very close tolerances! Of course! But they could not mass produce it! When America began to mass produce the Merlin engine, we had to completely redo the blue prints and specifications because the British as did the Germans relied on highly skilled crafts men, an as a consequence were unable to produce in quantity! American industrialist had developed machines and processes to meet the same Hugh quality, but by using relatively u skilled labor!. I hope that answers toys question, if it doesn't, you are going to have to be more specific@
@jomama01
@jomama01 Месяц назад
One word answer - Detroit.
@jomama01
@jomama01 Месяц назад
Detroit’s manufacturers generated 25% of the national military production during WW2. 25% - one city.
@kennethreese2193
@kennethreese2193 Месяц назад
The Detriot Industrial region which was much more then just a city. The Tri Cities on the bay (Saginaw, Bay City and Midland) through Flint, Pontiac and down throught Ypislanti and into Detriot. Steel, copper, bauxite and chemicals arrived in the Tri Cities and left refined down to the heavy forges, mills and casting facilities in Flint and Pontiac and then headed to Ypislanti and Detriot to be assembled into planes, trucks tanks and munitions Had the government not sold us out the Nixon and later Regan sold us out to the Chinese along with Pittsburgh and Chicago and countless other north eastern and midwestern towns.
@Cohen.the.Worrier
@Cohen.the.Worrier Месяц назад
Isn't the US the biggest manufacturer of military equipment atm? And China's military is largely unchecked for decades. They _could_ perform very well, but they'll most likely make the same mistakes the Russians did.
@owensomers8572
@owensomers8572 Месяц назад
The vast majority of the CCP's equipment is still knock offs of the Soviet stock being destroyed in Ukraine. And CCP has to maintain the majority of its forces in China to keep the population behaved.
@isaacdarochaloyola1254
@isaacdarochaloyola1254 Месяц назад
I AM NOT AMERICAN, BUT I AGREE 100% PERCENT WITH WHAT THIS VIDEO SAYS
@michaeldelaney7271
@michaeldelaney7271 Месяц назад
The U.S. Navy is no longer able to repair and overhaul its ships to a high standard. Some languish in shipyards for years or are just tied up to a dock and allowed to rot away. The BRAC (Base Realignment And Closure) commission did a "great" job closing USN Shipyards. Cheap foreign ship builders have done a similar job on U.S. commercial yards. Congress has also contributed to our problems by mis-directing funds for the Armed Forces. We buy lots of shiny new ships and planes but skimp on maintenance, training and spare parts. The end result is that the Navy can't seem to take care of the ships it has and is unable to acquire the new ships it needs. Another indication of the condition of our Armed Forces, the USAF plans to fly the B-52 for ONE HUNDRED YEARS! This is a plane designed in the late 1940's/early 1950's that first flew in 1952. Are there any 1952 U.S. tanks the Army is planning to use for 100 years? Any Navy 1952 ships that are going to be in service for 100 years? Henry Kaiser where are you when we need you?
@volkerkalhoefer3973
@volkerkalhoefer3973 Месяц назад
more ships than tanks??
@markwilliams4264
@markwilliams4264 Месяц назад
Chinese manufacturers make tofu weapons.
@davidburke8682
@davidburke8682 Месяц назад
China dominates in peacetime manufacturing a wartime economy and peace time economy are two different things america can thrive in a war economy china cannot
@jmullner76
@jmullner76 Месяц назад
"Looks at where materials come from..." Maybe not so much.
@ewathoughts8476
@ewathoughts8476 Месяц назад
The most BS statement ever.
@owensomers8572
@owensomers8572 Месяц назад
@@jmullner76 Much of that "manufacturing" has already left China for cheaper producers in India, Vietnam, Indonesia and other places. Don't expect too much from China.
@stephenhensley7004
@stephenhensley7004 Месяц назад
Our economic war with China began in the early 80s. As a result of the last four decades, we could not win WWII today, let alone go toe to toe with China on the battlefield. Next time you are at any store, look at where the products you are interested in are made. It takes a very diligent effort to avoid purchasing items not made in China. Should war with China come, it will take a large nuclear first strike to possibly defeat China. NAFTA was the co-conspirator leading to the loss of our industrial base. The latest news is John Deere has begun moving jobs to Mexico.
@thurin84
@thurin84 Месяц назад
thats not true. up until fairly recently we were creating and propping up chinas economy. china would still be a largely rural backwater were it not for the usa sending all its manufacturing there. the thing is the chinese ccp culture prevents chinese manufacturing from being sub standard. the climate the ccp creates engenders Cha bu duo (ie good enough) and mei you ban fa (theres nothing to be done about it) which translate into crap products. you think the chinese stuff is crap that you and i buy is crap? well they send the good stuff here. the domestic material is just garbage. including the military. i agree about the nafta subversion. i can still hear perot talking about the giant sucking sound as us manufacturing goes overseas.
@alansivkoff282
@alansivkoff282 Месяц назад
And the USA was the only country to experience the depression years.stop using this as an excuse .
Далее
Rare M31 & M32 Tank Recovery Vehicles of WW2
18:51
Просмотров 11 тыс.
Half-Tracks: The Mechanical Centaur that Won WWII
21:43
30 Tons with 2 Guns: The M3 | Did it matter?
11:45
Просмотров 131 тыс.
Icelandic Swords: Blades of the Viking Frontier
25:05
Просмотров 182 тыс.
One American vs 250 Germans (WW2 Documentary)
19:00
Просмотров 4,4 млн
Evolution of The  Churchill Tank | "No Damn Good"?
24:11
How a P-51 Mustang Works
18:37
Просмотров 8 млн