Is Astrology a SCAM? | Open Letter 

Kaisa laga video? ❤

Ironically I saw an ad of "Astro talk" before this video 😅.

Summary 1. Individual don't want to take responsibility of their works 2.Reduce uncertainty 3 .fascination for prediction 4. Psychological reason - (confirmation biased , placebo effect, survivorship biased, barnum effect)

After reading the comments to this video I Came to The conclusion That most people don't Know The Difference Between *Astronomy* And _Astrology_

literally every big youtuber did the astrology sponsorship and you spoke up the real thruth despite receiving such a big offer you are truly a real and honest individual

Couple of years ago , I got a call from a person saying that I had won lottery of 25 lakh . He asked for my bank account details to transfer the amount . His voice was calm and soothing and a simpler person would easily fall into the trap . I kept talking about this and that , wasting time trying to get him irritated . Finally , I asked him why he was doing this , some poor person would be cheated of his lifetime savings . He replied that he used to be an Astrologer but because of lockdown , his income was stopped . He said he had a good voice and could convince people . We talked for a bit and he explained Astrology had a psychologically soothing effect for some people who have difficulty facing reality . When there is a Demand for anything , some one will start the Supply

Apko astrotalk ka sponsor nhi mila kya 😂😂 just kidding but apne ekdam sahi aur sacchi video banate ho jo society ki ankh kholne liye bahut sariri hai❤❤❤

I'm not completely confident about predicting the future yet, but I've been delving into astrology as a hobby for a while now. What I can definitely affirm is that examining someone's Kundli provides valuable insights into their personality and family connections. At first, I had my doubts, but as I looked into the Kundlis of my friends and family whom I know personally, I was able to uncover aspects such as their behaviour, tendencies towards making impulsive decisions, inclinations towards affairs, and sources of happiness. And to my surprise, it all turned out to be accurate! Disclaimer I am an software engineer and not a pro at astrology .

Currently While many Indian RU-vidrs and few Celebs are doing paid promotion of astrology based apps, this video is literally an Eye-opener. Thanks and appreciate your work..... 💯👍👏

I Believe in Astrology but not in Apps like AstroTalks rather i contact with Brahmin Pandit who are in nearby Temples they always give me almost accurate predictions about my future

I see no difference between people who believe in astrology and people who think that our earth is flat.

"If a star disturbs my life, it would not be worth a cent. You will find that astrology and all these mystical things are generally signs of a weak mind; therefore as soon as they are becoming prominent in our minds, we should see a physician, take good food, and rest". - Swami Vivekananda

Acharya prashant 1:25😍😍

आचार्य प्रशांत ने कभी ये राशि फल और ज्योतिष को सही नही बताया, वो तो अंधविश्वास के खिलाफ एक बुलंद आवाज है। वो कहते है, जहा विज्ञान नही हे वहा धर्म नही है।

I would request everyone to study astrology from a scientific and research oriented mindset. Astrology works, not the fraudsters in guise of astrologer

I never learned astrology. but during my schools I used to check the hands of my friends and do predictions. The fun fact is that I already know what they are going through, it was easy to give suggestions and predictions based on that relatable. Now I am 25, they still believe me 😁😁.

I am following your channel since 3 years regularly, your content is unmatched

please make a video on electoral bond

Video dekhna ka mood nhi tha Acharya Prashant ji ka thumbnail dekh kar aaya

I'm here for Acharya Ji....❤❤❤

People feel everything is fake and fraud untill they meet the right ones. My maternal grandfather just by looking face of someone 12+ year old could draw his house, tell his networth, what he had for breakfast, his past his future and many things which that person doesn't even aware of.

"Throughout Heavens and the Earth, OpenLetter alone is the honoured one."

Please a podcast with Acharya Prashant

Thankfully Acharya Prashant saved me from these superstitions and saved my life❤

It works on " you find what you look for "

Personally I have a keen interest in astrology. It's a subject that has fascinated many cultures across the globe. I'm more interested in the personality traits that the kundali gives. I do, however, take it with a handful of salt. I think it gives more combinations than the MBTI test XD Also, I think astrology is only indicative and gives you some things to think about that you might have not considered before. Some of the astrologers I have met have been very forthcoming about their predictions being indicative at best and that the rest depends on what I do in life as the future depends on the present. They mearly tell some auspicious time period and what avenues could be focused on. But I don't think one should totally depend on astrology. Just take it as a fun activity you do once or twice in life lol

Bro is onto something 💀💀

Sir ji my advice don't show news clips they can give copyright ©️😊

Aapko nhi mila Astrotalk se sponser????😂

That's why Acharya Prashant is important.

The ancient astrology of India is a whole different thing with the morden capping astrology......... hence i don't mix both.

Acharya Prashant ❤

Sir please make a video on The International Society for Krishna Consciousness, it has a lot of controversies 😅

My respect for you is now increasing video by video; there was a time when you only made videos criticizing the opposition, praising the ruling party and doing whataboutry. But in recent videos, thankfully, you started discussing problems and creating awareness. Great work, man. ❤❤❤ 1:26 and thanks for giving shout out to Acharya Prashant Ji, He is the need of today's society.

I was thinking that astro talk ad is coming😂

😂इसी विडियो पर ad भी Astrotalk का ही आ 😂रहा है

Un 😃,mai Prashant ji k Shikshao ke bare mein कुछ बता रहे होगें करके आयी थी। Dear friend,s , 👉आचार्य प्रशांत वर्तमान मुद्दे जैसे जलवायु परिवर्तन ,गरीबी ,भुखमरी अशिक्षा ,पशु क्रूरता, स्त्रीसशक्तिकरण जैसे मुद्दों पर खुलकर बोलते हैं (मैं अभी 1 घंटे पहले क्लाइमेट चेंज के ऊपर उनके वीडियो देखकर आई हूं )

shocked to see that comments arnt turned off gud work bro

Wo bich m acharya Prashant wali clip ki poori video astrology ka pakhand todne k liye hee kafi hai ☠️

लोगों को सच नहीं बस कोई झूठा नशा चाहिए बस कोई सहला दे यही चाहिए होता है ,और वो दे देते हैं। लोगों तक सच पहुंचाने के लिए हमें उन्हें गीता,वेदांत का करीब लाना होगा, जिसमें आचार्य जी भरपूर प्रयत्न कर रहे हैं,हमे उनका साथ देना होगा। 🌿

you are one of my fav indian channel....i am pakistani and i love your content....you address the issue facing our desi society. bless you.

Acharya prasant is a man with logical mind

While other are promoting astrotalk he is exposing astrology...good job 👏👏

Let me tell you something which will amuse you. My Mama (maternal uncle) was an astrologer (Asian Summit Gold medalist in astrology). I used to ask Mama how do you convince people to believe you, because future is uncertain and no body would believe if they haven't seen it yet. So what Mama used to do, he used to tell their past. That you have already experienced and only you know it. Believe me, Mama used to reveal such deep dark secrets which people made astonished, they used to be shocked. How this guy knows about me. I can't write everything over here or else I would have written stories which are too interesting to hear. My point is- it is all about calculations and perfection. In market there are many fake astrologers who are responsible for such bad name. And astrology can never be 100% accurate, if that happens then what about God and Universe? So some portion Gods will keep it to them only. If everything could be predicted then we could avert natural calamities too

Bhai 3 bar coverpage/thumbnail change kar chuka hai😂😂

Even youtuber are supporting it but why

Why premananda maharaj photo on the thumbnail???

Astrology can't decide a future but it tells behavior of people in general. These signs are constellations they don't have anything to do with human life.

Bhai jab band bajti hai tab admi mummy mummy chillata hai. Uske pehle sab hoshiyar hi bante hai. It's a long life and you are very young. You will see many things that you find hard to believe now but will believe later on. Logical reasoning does not work on many aspects of life in this world. Wait till you grow old.

You probably don't understand the basic of astrology

Vedic astrology from our very advanced ancestors is a great tool for life I study astrology and understand it. So much logic there is! Once you yourself understand it, you'll know your birthchart never lies

Thank you for the open letter Channel and by which you are educating us and disclosing polluted layers present. I am thankful to you for adding the clip of Acharya Prashant at the start of the video. I appreciate your work for awareness and education. We should get rid of such nonsense and stupidity.

Mai astrology pe dependent nahi karta....but I know it's a way of reading your karma. So I believe it but don't sepwns on it. Only dependent on hardwork+smartwork.

Consciousness is the greatest asset. A wise man can detect possibilities. An astrologer or say the group has to follow the person or play-god to get predictions occur. A realistic person knows but out of fear of negativity follow them.

8-10 saal pehle believe karta tha but roz roz kuch bura hone ki tension lena bekaar lagta tha to horoscope dekhna chod diya tabse life acchi chal rahi hai 😂

Brother ❤ main kafi time se notice kar raha hu tumhare content kafi hadd tak _Aacharya Prashant ji💙🙏 k bataye hua - real jaruri and most important and valuable muddon ki jhalak 🔥 mil rahi hai or yah ek achcha sign hai ..💯 Hamare is time ki sabse important topics ko bharat k aam logo tak lana Bohot zaroori hai,, to ye aapse Bohot aacha kiya !❤

Acharya prashant ji❤ ne saare pakhand pandit ke chehra saamne laadiya hai

Kis kisko astrotalk ka ad aya ? 👇🏻👇🏻

Acharya ji btate hain sahi jivan jina bo bhi sachche dharm par adhrit pramarikta ke sath

मैं एक ऐसी इंसान हु जो कुछ करे अगर बिगड़ जाए तो अपनी गलती खुद स्वीकार करती हूं ना ही की ये सब झूठ पर 😅😂😊

Open letter Please make a video on reality of reality shows Such as bigg boss, Indian idol, super dancer etc Hope you will make it, your audience is waiting for your next video 😄

Bro is so smart he knows the power of thumbnail😂😂

Mere dada ek bahot bade pandit the....unke pas delhi or mumbai se bhi log apna kundli dikhane or dosh ka samadhan ke liye ate the...vo apni energy se vo dekh lete the jo tab hua jab vo khud hi vaha nahi the....unhone apne death ka time or date bhi bataya or fix ushi time par 5 sec late unki death hui....ab ap kahenge ki mind ne alarm set kar diya kyuki unhone khud ko itni bar kaha ki vo kab marenge...toh mind ne ushi time shutdown kar diya? Vigyaan ki ek seema hai...or ye seema jaha harti hai vahi bhagwan ka astitva dikhne lagta hai

Indian Astrologers don't highly rely on Sun Sign. They've their own system of measuring. Their system is known as sideral system, depending on the inclination of the sun with the earth. They do have moon signs love signs as well. Indian astrologers rely on nine planets. I don't check astrology columns on a daily basis.

I am from Sanatan dharma, but I don't how astrology can predict our modern job which doesn't exist on ancient times

I mean ............ There was a possible death of a guy in his 25 age in his daughter kundli in 3 months with organ failure, and he died within 3 months with liver fail. There was possible settlement in foreign country with businesses work within a month and that man was told to get back in america amd restart his business and now after 15 years that man still doing great there. Where i saw this, i saw it with my eyes it was my father who said this.

Ad of astrotalk😂

Depends on your experience.

Each word of your video is really eye-opening and helpful.

bro please remove the photo of premanand ji maharaj. he is not an astrologer or he does not support and kind of astrology he is only a life guru or teacher who teaches us the way of living a life

Astrotalk ad 😂before video 😅

why did you put pic of acharya prashant in thumbnail

Are acharya prashant ka astrology se kya lena dena ??

While majority of creators are making money by promoting Astrotalk you take a seperate stand by not promoting it. Thank you for being a responsible creator. Love you bro :⁠-⁠)

You spoke my heart, I have always noticed these things and never believe astrology as kundlis will predict as per your current mindset and situation, but your future happens as per your decision that u make....

Im very surprised now a days pretty big youtubers also promoting these astrology apps ! And ha the way they promote this is also very funny like tell some bs story of prediction by astrologer 😅

The problem is of authenticity. Just because there are sham Astrologers out there doesn't mean that the entire field is sham. Try to think of it like this : If a research turns out to be bogus, do you come to the conclusion that the process of research itself is crap or that this particular instance may have had its flaws? Astrology, as I understand it, is relatively less generalized. That is to say, individual acumen plays a lot of role in terms of interpretation. This spirit is in line with that of ayurvedic approach which was also practiced in Vedic times. It is only as good as the guy practicing it. Whereas with western medicine, you could be an illiterate homeless junky or a Nobel Prize winner, Paracetamol given to me by any of you would work the same way. Our model of reality is heavily influenced by what we consider to constitute the definition of "sensible". What we're taught, what we study heavily influence this chain of command which we then label as true.

Can't say about The news astrologers, magazines ones or fake gurus . But the predictions of some astrologers are true. It's also worth mentioning thing that it can not change course of life but minor positive changes.

Perfect video… it was very mandatory!!!

Acharya Prashant ji ❤🔥🙏

Acharya Prashant don't teach astrology

i used to think the same whatever it is, is only science and nothing more than science but as i am maturing and seeing things reading knowing the history knowing sanatan dharma our book now i realized how wrong i was. there is something beyond science. Having faith in astrology is not wrong but over faith is dangerous

I think all astrologer said that : Sayad hum astrologer pe koi video banane wali hai 😂

Guess which ad was the first to roll up when I clicked on your video 😂😂

Astrology has been around for several hundreds of years so it has developed into a state where it can be used to categorise people based on their character. Most astrologers provide general view of a particular category of people. Astrology cannot predict the future, but it provides certain insights to a persons future but for the most part, these general insights becomes a reality and the same people would believe in astrology even more

Entire concept of astrology is based on the words "may" and "can" 😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨

Sri Krishna says Karm kro fal usi k anusar milega this is Karma

Dekho bhai, agar astrology wagera hota na toh Bhagavad Gita me Bhagwan Krishna khud hi Arjun ji ko kehdete ki tumhare nakshatra ye kehte hain wo kehte hain. par unhone ye bakwas nhi ki balki bola ki sari chinta chhodke Karma karo

Definitely the most level headed RU-vidr in India.

thnx for making this eye opener!

Bhai great video! Just one correction at 10:50 no satellite has taken a picture of the Milky Way from "the outside" all of the images where we can see the milky way as a "whole or complete" galaxy are artist renders. It is just TOO big for any satellite to reach that point right now. The furthest man-made object is only just reached the outermost point of our solar system(Voyager 1). We can see the milky way at a good dark spot at night (with no light pollution) and based on the data and images collected from our reference point, it is estimated to have that shape, as seen in the pictures. The one at 10:31 is how we actually see it cause we are in it.

My grandpa was healthy strong man, in 1975 april and astrologer told my grandma and papa that ...bad time will come ..my grandpa gonna die soon by accident ...they will face financial problem for long period ...guess what in may 6 a bus knocked down my grandpa he died instantly at scene😢 Rip grandpa 😣

Astrology doesn't predicts future but Vedic astrology is much more complex and can tell your personality almost accurately ❤

I allways learn news things from your videos thanks for that

Please make video on Tarot readers and twinflame channels who take advantage of people's emotions after they have gone through break up and loot people 😌 No " the wheel of fortune tarots" channel is not harmed in this comment 😂

Astrology is truely phenomenal and if an astrologer is good and learned he will definitely help in dealing any issues an individual has. Identifying a learned astrologer is a challenge though

Keep up the good work 💯💯 Just one thought We can keep on discussing such topics but our parents loved ones relatives and in-laws are Hyperbolicly superstitious And ye moh moh k dhage humari sil k chale jate hai Be it shadi ghrhpravesh mundan dah sanskar Everything and it muhurat In the end we have to abide by that As its too big of a market to tackle

Now some body talk about it in years

Good job on covering theoretical part. But you have not been practical about astrology. I'm not say it's perfect and I only believe when I have do things practically. One day I found my kundali stuffed inside a drawer. I opened it and started reading it. Slowly and slowly I found the vague predictions are getting true. Almost 80 to 90% of things were true. That day it opened my mind about astrology. I could say that your video was biased and you haven't even tired it yourself. Just for everyone, I don't read astrology daily, but yes I do read it when I need help or to checkout my past predictions which again are almost true. I didn't expected you to make this kind of video. You just highlighted all the negative part of astrology but not the positive part. Unsubscribing you.

ok this was a good one. You should pick the next scammy thing that is feng shui.. you make the world's best house and even then some idiots will talk BS through feng shui and try to use it as a bargain point to lower the price of the house even when it's perfectly at market rate.