In one of the camp endings the player remembers all the way back to forest when Pony is talking about he infected Doggy because Willow forced him. So I don't believe this theory is true but it is a great theory.
1. The hunt is not cannon 2. It was confirmed that finley themself, the locations, easter eggs, and notes are cannon but the time travel is not. 3. All endings are cannon on their own timelines
Last time I heard a theory so complex, it was 2 years ago, you got talent man, the only problem is that Minitoon said the time travelling wasn't canon, but everything adds up. Amazing theory.
1st: The time travel is no canon, only the locations are. 2nd: The Detective had an objective or a reason to stay unstead of leave, (like Alleys, Station, School, Metro, Carnival, Mall, Outpost, Plant, Refinery, Ship, Camp and Lab)
when u said that finley is selfish that also explains why he said finders keepers and throws the egg at us cuz he wanted it for himself not to share with it
fr extra chapters aren’t even canon and how is Finely the antagonist if he isn’t the one who controls minds? How? And he didn’t even start the infection. That’s like saying “Mimi works for the insolence because moles like to dig underground and in the hidden ending cutscene the infected rose up from the ground” when most of them aren’t even moles
Wow, just wow. I am speechless, i can't fathom how good the editing of the video is and your theory, it actually makes sense to be honest! I think it's a really good theory!
lots of stuff to debunk while finley and the locations are canon, the time travel aspect is not a canonical occurence. There is no timeline to be ruined when the thing that does so doesn't even exist. the hunt is a seperate timeline on itself. For station, you dont go to a station with intentions of getting help, hearing your best friend from the speakers and then going out. As for metro, bunny was immediately infected in decay, seeing the uninfected as infected. She would have killed us so fast in the train. Also "Help find mr p faster"??? Mr p flew away with his helicopter to the plant, not to the carnival. in factory, the whispers come from insolence eyes. Yeahh... finley doesnt have any relation with tio. great video though, i love that flawed theories are slowly coming back, dont be ashamed because its no diffferent than the kreekcraft theories we used to feast on in 2020 and 2021
Even though most of the base info you’ve used are debunked and non-canon confirmed by Minitoon, it’s still a good theory! I’ve never thought of this before, but it’s still an interesting thing to think about!
This could give a small explanation to the ending scene in the decay chapter where the speaker says that the timeline of book 1 could have gone very differently. Either this is teasing something new coming or it’s just more intercity teasing
this could be true if the time travelling was cannon, and what if the hunt (canonically) set place in between 3 - 4 so when he hit us with the golden egg he sent us to safe place and that's why we didn't know what was happening so George had to wake us up.
Finley: ok guys I’m so done with life, I’m gonna *breathes* walk now 2024: *not enough air to breath because Finley accidentally breathed too much oxygen and now Earth is splitting apart because Finley also walked too hard*
Actually all the notes and stuff is cannon and so is Finley so there is nothing stopping this theory except for the fact that we don’t know WHEN he took us
@@Imagetwagon the notes and finley are indeed canon, but they have nothing to do with the time travelling. The time travelling and our quest to help finley isn't canon, but everything else is
@@slaoqeubotoaq well if finely is cannon and we arw cannon that would mean that we are opening all these doors and attracting all these monsters at once however the infected will always be targeting someone til theres no one left so if they weren’t targeting us then they would have targeted other pll possibly making a paradox of ether getting ataced or not Also if we got knocked out at the end and we were in the past that would mean we couldn’t have been doing what we were doing at said time making a paradox
@@danielfelipecorreamontano7085 Actually minitoon said all endings are canon but on different timelines, but everyone (including minitoon) basically has a consent that "ok hidden ending is the true one let's forget about the rest". He did that because the ending doesnt affect Intercity And that scene of Breakout was bc minitoon wanted to show us a bit of Tigry and Willow after that timeline in specific
