Тёмный

How NOT to Write a Codex - The many problems of Chaos Daemons 

Poorhammer
Подписаться 123 тыс.
Просмотров 93 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

28 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 264   
@IzzysIssues
@IzzysIssues Год назад
"I can't wait another 5 years to see them try again" is an admonishment so powerful that Asmodai balked
@michaelchampion936
@michaelchampion936 Год назад
Missed out that the only faction to not be able to get a mortal wound save is Nurgle, so the 'most resilient' has no resilience.
@michaelpsellos770
@michaelpsellos770 Год назад
It's still a fluffy list though because nurgle is also the God of despair and depression
@theotv5522
@theotv5522 3 месяца назад
@@michaelpsellos770 The only one suffering despair and depression are the Nurgle players themselves.
@Bluecho4
@Bluecho4 Год назад
I think GW accidentally scored a minor win by having Khorne Daemons be the only ones, thus far, to make the transition to Combat Patrol. Because they ended up being the only one of the four "subfactions" that's actually playable. Well, other than Flamer spam, and as we've seen it doesn't need to be Chaos Daemons for that.
@JCMiniPainting
@JCMiniPainting Год назад
They put all their Flamers into the AoS Tzeentch and Tzangor box, which is why they(flamers) were conveniently sold out everywhere for the last few months.
@markusnehles2910
@markusnehles2910 Год назад
depends on how many points you play. at 1000p mono tzeentch is disgusting to play against
@Dracus40k
@Dracus40k Год назад
Good review. As a Competitive Slaanesh Daemons player (itc #1 for the last 6+months) they did make our Greater Daemons a little tougher with daemon saves, but still only T7, and because they are 20 wounds now they can't hide like they used to... It forces us to put them in the warp to manifest, but then you lose all that speed that you're supposed to have. The points costs are awful when you compare even internally between Daemonettes and Seekers of Slaanesh. Daemonettes for 120 points are 10 models/wounds at T3 and 41 attacks at AP -2. For 100 points you get 5 Seekers/10 wounds at T4 with 21 attacks at -2 and 10 attacks at AP 0.... Why would you take Seekers? They are the same number of wounds, die just as easy as t3 to t4 is a very minor difference and they have less attacks with worse AP. Sure they are faster, but they aren't going to kill if they charge and they will just die when they get shot. Sad times. I won more events with mono Slaanesh Daemons before the new book came out, even going 4-2 at LVO last year, only losing to 2 top 20 placed players including Jack Harpster. Everything is over costed.
@Florkl
@Florkl Год назад
“Nobody plays with 2 damage shooting.” *cries in Custodes*
@brendimo216
@brendimo216 Год назад
Just stumbled across this podcast and love the format and discussion/rant. A great piece to just listen to while building and painting, keep up the great work! Also, the art for both of you is amazing, did you guys get them commissioned and if so, who is the artist?
@thepoorhammerpodcast
@thepoorhammerpodcast Год назад
(Brad here) We use art GW owns because we're way too poor to commission art and GW can shut us down whenever they want anyway. This way we're at least not stealing fan art. My art is from the current Thousand Sons codex, Eric's is from I think 8th edition GK? Our video editor ran them through some processes in photoshop to make them less detailed and more abstract.
@richardpatterson4496
@richardpatterson4496 Год назад
Ngl played 3 games of them after not playing demons in a while and something felt off but I couldn't put it into words, very good video ty.
@papanurgle8393
@papanurgle8393 Год назад
I find it kind of funny that GW got it right back in 3rd ed, at least conceptually.
@Blondguyification
@Blondguyification Год назад
As a mono khorne player I have to agree I was unaware of everything but the flamers. The only complaint I had was no second warlord trait.
@Kizuke21
@Kizuke21 Год назад
I've been saying this since I started playin with Daemons as my first army back at the end of 7th edition. I'm glad to see I'm not the only one with this thought process.
@RvBnerd618
@RvBnerd618 Год назад
I once played Daemons back in the start of 6th Edition. Seeing how they are is very unfortunate even if I don't play the game anymore.
@BR-bn1mz
@BR-bn1mz Год назад
I don’t hate it as much, and it does have some ideas, but they definitely went too far into the “buffs for mono” direction rather then “less efficient if mixed”, and it could be laid out better. Maybe extra warp dice for mono or 2 less for mixed? Should atleast be able to pay 1 CP to retain some of them I like that it is all together (better then bringing 4 books), but, especially running mono there is a lack of units overall, bringing cultists, Tzaangores, Traitor Guard and the future Khorne cultists would help a lot.
@solidsentinel1285
@solidsentinel1285 Год назад
I’m extremely worried but hopeful for the world eaters codex
@quahodron2756
@quahodron2756 Год назад
in 15:42 is a freakingly loud sound randomly thrown at the viewer. As I was hearing this under headphones, I fucking literaly jumped up and got nearly a stroke by this sound. I thought my house would crumlbe. Please consider to not try to kill me again (soon). Also I will consider to hear you with soundsetting 25% next time. :P
@robertkb64
@robertkb64 Год назад
Can’t believe GW miscounted the stratagems. Obviously Khorne has 8, Tzeentch has 9, Nurgle has 7, and Slaanesh has 6. HTF did GW give everyone except Khorne 8?!
@lilweasel2005
@lilweasel2005 Год назад
Hello I am new and have a question if anybody could answer. I want to build a daemon army, I have purchased some models but upon arrival and inspection I realised that they may not work together. I have brought 1x great unclean one 1x daemon prince 1x pox bringer 1x infernal enrapturess 1x blood master 1x bloodletter unit And the bit that throws me off I was gifted a death guard combat patrol, can I use this in the same list? If so, what disadvantages or advantages does it pose for me. Thanks
@benstaffordson7163
@benstaffordson7163 Год назад
To give a MINOR nod to Slaanesh... In 8th they were 7" move, advance and charge. In 9th, boards are smaller and they're at 10" move, no advance/charge. The average advance roll is 3.5.. so with a smaller board, let's call it 3. It's about the same as having an inbuilt 3" advance and charge. It's dumb, there's no flavour, but it IS somewhat equal.
@brothertobias
@brothertobias Год назад
It's not equal, because you forgot the trumpet. 7"+d6+1 is usually (2/3 times) better than 10" and the armies are just as far away from each other as before - 24" or sometimes 18".
@thegreyknight1092
@thegreyknight1092 Год назад
love your show!
@majorearl12
@majorearl12 Год назад
Recently did Dark Angels vs Daemons. I lost due to them having 3-5 model Flamers that wrecked everything i had (why these are so powerful is beyond me). Then couldnt use AP at all which was super annoying since i probably couldve taken down several other things. But watching the Warp Storm, we were friends playing but i moved 12" away, and moved up another inch since i had the extra movement in a biker and they let me (im still new and it was the first time playing against Daemons). That was the only thing they used their points on lol The Warp Storm was useless, and yea they had three big characters that were scary with 20 wounds that i just couldnt take down since he pounced my 2 Redemptors second turn. But the Flamers carried the match, the Blue Horrors were weak but my DW Knights fighting them wouldve been annoying after the last turn (turn 3), their bloodletters were easy to wipe out but overall it was fun and just an annoying game overall because the Flamers get to throw like 30 shots EVERYTIME they shot lol
@Fallstorm777
@Fallstorm777 Год назад
I agree the Daemons Codex could be better but going the AoS route I don't think is the right fix. As a former fantasy player I hate what AoS did with Daemons and honestly this is one reason I jumped into 40k vs playing AoS, because in 40k all the factions remained the same i.e Daemons of Chaos are still Daemons not Disciples of Tzeentch, Nurgle Maggotkin, followers of farts or whatever other stupid title they have come up with.
@deusmortis9751
@deusmortis9751 Год назад
chaos demons lead me to start homebrewing, currently I use the units and rules from 9th but psychic from 8th
@ValeraManuel
@ValeraManuel Год назад
Hey you guys didn't even talk about the army of renown and its amazing potential! /s
@ShumaBot
@ShumaBot Год назад
Got in at 888 views, nice. It'll be interesting to see how this is a worse design than the ork book.
@timeenoughatlast3368
@timeenoughatlast3368 Год назад
Oh the Necron comment hit hard... Yeah reanimation protocol sucked so hard and was worthless on Destroyers/Canoptek units, basically just encouraging warrior/immortal spams. Even though I also play GSC i was so annoyed that the banner rule is a better reanimation protocol than anything the Necrons got.
@Walpurgisnackt
@Walpurgisnackt Год назад
I played chaos, in third edition. When chaos has a bad codex they really go all out
@Tutel0093
@Tutel0093 Год назад
Having Daemonic as a list of rules is not new and is not the most efficient. 20 years ago same rule did almost the same thing and it was explained in a 2 lines sentences The trick here is Daemonic rule is not and should not be hard to remember and understand, but 8th and 9th edition amount of rules over rules over rules give us the fake necessity of needing Clear, point per point, clarifications. The rules are not hard. I don't care if the Tags are 11 words. I don't care if every unit I play has 4 differents IF the game DOESN'T allow to twist, minmax, munchkin, crack and bend rules like these 3 last rulebooks we had
@peglegpaulzy9118
@peglegpaulzy9118 Год назад
at this point i might as well sell all my daemons and just play world eaters
@andreasottohansen7338
@andreasottohansen7338 Год назад
Ah yes, it seems the Warp Storms suffer from a classic balancing issues. Having a means to solve a problem, but not having any problems. So the answer is, of course, not to streamline things by removing the pointless solution, but to just make you worse, so you now have a problem to solve.
@ShishouDzukiZaManako
@ShishouDzukiZaManako Год назад
oh corndogs
@Grimmlocked
@Grimmlocked Год назад
found this channel and i was about to get back in.... but nope looks like GW is still apathetic to actually making a game.
@LinkiePup
@LinkiePup Год назад
Personally I feel like the worst is the Necron codex. The units are way to underpowered, the saves are bad, and all units are way to over costed for how good, or bad they actually are. Deamons are bad. But christ the data-slate barely helped the poor skeleboys.
@LinkiePup
@LinkiePup Год назад
Mind you, this is my own opinion, and is not subjective.
@SirFluffy100
@SirFluffy100 Год назад
....Comment for algorithmic reasons.....
@TheDoctorOfFails
@TheDoctorOfFails Год назад
I dont not want them to split up my army so i have to buy more factions but this book is so bad i cant stand to play it anymore.
@TheDoctorOfFails
@TheDoctorOfFails Год назад
Also I played 90 plauge bearers in 8th was very fun but they ran in 30 blobs with apoc movement trays.
@joshy7759
@joshy7759 Год назад
It'll take the runtime to convince me that there's a codex worse than AdMech.
@Khorzho
@Khorzho Год назад
While I respect people's opinion, there are parts of this that are factually incorrect, and as a Chaos playing vet (first army was Noise Marines) for over 30 years, you've stared not only a gift horse in the mouth, but a trash talked one of the best offerings (if not the best) the faction has ever had.
@Grubnar
@Grubnar Год назад
So, why don't you correct them?
@Psycho-Babble
@Psycho-Babble Год назад
I have played 4 games with the demons codex all 1250 pts all against the same person playing Nids in all games. So there is a lot of control in the experiment. 1st game 75% Tzeentch 25% Nurgle - win 2nd 75% Nurgle 25% Tzeentch - tie 3rd 100% Khorne - loss.... Bad loss.... 4th 50% Tzeentch 50% Khorne - win I'm not competitive tournament level player, been plaing for a few years, have several armies, watch and understand strats - semi experienced player. Mono faction is not viable. The limited units and special rules penalize mono Deamon. Each Deamon fills a battlefield roll, it's like trying to play an army of all chaos cultists. They do 1 thing good and they have no army wide abilities. With Khorne, there are no objective based units. Who sits on points? No-one, you have to table your enemy. I honestly think that Khorne is the worst as he has the least abilities. Fewest stratagems, no psychic powers to draw from and all of his heralds do the same thing. Tzeentch has 3 different herald buffs. Sure 1 is far better that the other two, but there are options. Khorne has no damage stacking potential. You can make Plague bearers do 4dmg/attack. (can't speak for slaanesh as I haven't played them at all) this whole book is rubish, in my opinion they all need work. I can see flamers getting nerfed because they're being abused then just ignoring everyone else for a few months until the tourney stats show up.
@aprinnyonbreak1290
@aprinnyonbreak1290 Год назад
Agree. The mono god factions already suffer badly from just being locked out of meaningfully controlling particular phases, and Khorne has that the worst. Demons tend to be defined by their inadequacy more than other factions, but as power creep has pushed things like IG being able to rarely Melee, Necrons actually being able to get around, Custodes actually getting cheap bodies to park on objectives or tarpit, and so on, the demons have never gotten that love. Khorne still can't magic at all. Nurgle still can't move. Slaanesh still can't shoot. The Daemons either need vast increases to their individual options, a bigger pool of perhaps less good but versatile neutral Daemons to patch those critical holes in their armies, so they aren't just giving up phase control for free in a game where EVERYONE can exploit that
@Psycho-Babble
@Psycho-Babble Год назад
@@aprinnyonbreak1290 I think that two potential solutions (at least ones I would like to see) are out each god in its own book or like you said, create a pool of neutral Deamons. Unfortunately they removed furies from the last few codecies, so I don't think that would be likely.
@18120polls
@18120polls Год назад
As a mono nurgle player, it feels like they were super terrified about the durable subfaction actually being durable for the points. Plaguebearers are roughly twice as tough now as they were but cost roughly twice as much....so they're really not any tougher than their garbage 8th edition state. And Great Unclean One's just kinda die because the only thing that makes them tough is having a high Toughness trait...but when so much of the game gives you +1 to wound...or flat-out skips the wound roll to begin with...they just die. To basically everything. They're just as tough as the other 3 greater daemons but do significantly less damage with less mobility and a giant fucking base. I dunno. Nurgle feels awful.
@vice1219
@vice1219 Год назад
Nurgle has dominated the demon codex for 15 years, let someone else get the spotlight
@18120polls
@18120polls Год назад
@@vice1219 How about no. How about they're all playable.
@CosmicDrama
@CosmicDrama Год назад
as someone that went in with mono khorne, and was considering diving into doing duo khorne/nurgle. seeing the nurgle stuff was so depressing... then seeing that flamers are so damn strong... the daemons are shelved.
@jamesespinosa690
@jamesespinosa690 Год назад
@@vice1219 Please go away with that loser attitude. They should all be viable and internally competitive. GW are terrible at balance. This is the problem. There is no disputing this.
@brothertobias
@brothertobias Год назад
How would the "toxic plaguebearer-spam" even work, when Plaguebearers are confined to 10 models per squad? Did GW expect people to bring double Battalions for 12x10 Plaguebearers?
@personpeoplehime
@personpeoplehime Год назад
As an ork player, the mono datasheet stratagem rant hit home for me
@olive3365
@olive3365 7 месяцев назад
i'm a little late to this video but you guys grew 84k subs in 14 months???!! that's absolutely insane and congrats to on that! you 100% deserve it!
@thepoorhammerpodcast
@thepoorhammerpodcast 7 месяцев назад
Thanks for the kind words. It's been a pretty surreal year.
@thepoorhammerpodcast
@thepoorhammerpodcast Год назад
(Brad here) If you notice a few minor editing issues on this episode, sorry in advance. It was kind of a crunch to get this one out on time during a holiday week. Also sorry in advance if you aren't a fan of more negative episodes. I don't want to devolve into ragebait content, but I needed to get this out of my system... This book SUCKS! If for some reason you want more of this topic, I spent about 2.5 hours ranting to Eric originally and there's a longer one hour cut on our audio feeds: poorhammer.libsyn.com/episode-42-dissecting-a-daemonic-disaster
@jonasandersson5838
@jonasandersson5838 Год назад
Sounds awesome
@jonasandersson5838
@jonasandersson5838 Год назад
Also, you missed a huge point with dark invigoration, the one troop made to be all round durable, the Plague bearer, isn't affected by it. And why did they nerf disciples of be'lakor...
@lorenzosgarallino
@lorenzosgarallino Год назад
Just merge each Daemon and Specific CSM legion and have 1 only codex for each Chaos God.
@thepoorhammerpodcast
@thepoorhammerpodcast Год назад
PLEASE!!!!!!
@zahndrekhsb1080
@zahndrekhsb1080 Год назад
Found my demonkin codex a few months ago and omg I love that codex so much, it was the best book other than the legions codex
@autumnlotus6250
@autumnlotus6250 Год назад
I rather play mixed daemons. But I know others enjoy that mix like in AoS
@schwegburt3002
@schwegburt3002 Год назад
Yes please. At the very least I wish Troops in the Daemon Codex were considered 'Agents of Chaos' by default for each respective Legion. I'd love to field some Daemonettes in my EC list for fun but taking a CP kick to the balls just to field Troops means 'hell no' to that idea. Sure, I could field a Patrol w/ an HQ and Daemonttes but that starts warping (kek) too much of my list.
@OroshiNagisaka082719
@OroshiNagisaka082719 Год назад
Honestly, what I would love is just 3 ENORMOUS codexes, like 3 corebook sized, With each alliance (xenos, chaos, imperium) and that's it, thanks we're done. And while at it, normalize chaos soup, xeno soup and imperial soup
@DonaldPlummer
@DonaldPlummer Год назад
I wonder how busted it would have been to give Nurgle 5+++ vs damage 1 (and mortals). Maybe give them a warp storm power to make that 5+++ vs anything . Anyway, great talk!
@icklemoo
@icklemoo Год назад
should have just made all nurgle have inbuilt -1 wound on all models
@lucashucbourg-muller7024
@lucashucbourg-muller7024 Год назад
As a Ynarri player who fell in love with their fluff I feel your pain. The new codex has them be craftworlds with two squads of harlequin troups. It's incredibly infuriating.
@yesicollectwarhammerfiguri9473
Just finished the video after it popped up in my recomendations tab and I gotta say good job guys, very informative, well spoken and edited, you've earned yourself a sub! keep up the great work
@brothertobias
@brothertobias Год назад
This is not a codex: it's 4 indexes you are supposed to use in other Chaos armies. Which is laughable.
@Thornscale
@Thornscale Год назад
As a Dedicated Chaos player, and lover of Chaos Daemons, I 100% agree with doing Codex Nurgle, with Death Guard and Nurgle Daemons mixed, and so on and so on for each. Imagine how much Codex World Eaters would've benefited from that. They could even say - If your Warlord is a Daemon, Plaguebearers become troops, if your General is an Astartes, Plague Marines become Troops. It'd be so clean and elegant.
@TonklinFallen
@TonklinFallen Год назад
I remember back in the 2nd Ed days when daemons were massively powerful - with a high points cost attached. Back then the rules for Daemon armies were that only other Daemon armies could fight against them (in lore these battles were fought in the warp). The points cost for these armies were 100k+ for an "average" battle. It sounds like GW has spent the last 7 editions trying to get Daemon armies to fit where they don't belong, and are fucking it up in a way only GW can.
@Bluecho4
@Bluecho4 Год назад
"Each of these should have 40 Stratagems, like every other Codex." Technically, the book - when taken as a whole - has 30 Stratagems. (I'm counting the 4 Relic strats as 1, obv). You would never run more than 1 god in your army, obviously, but you could. Hence, "Chaos Daemons" is an army with 30 strats. Also, can we just examine the flavor fail of not giving Stratagems to the different gods based on their special numbers? Why doesn't Tzeentch have 9 Stratagems? Why does Khorne have 6 and Slaanesh 8, when their numbers are reversed?
@aprinnyonbreak1290
@aprinnyonbreak1290 Год назад
Makes sense. Khorne stratagems should be condensed, simple, but predictable anyways.
@Ynwell_theslaaneshi
@Ynwell_theslaaneshi Год назад
@@aprinnyonbreak1290make it notes, not even full sentences “give ur charge + 2” or something similar. On the other hand, give Tzeentch those bloated rules that ask you 3 conditions, but if you can pull it off you get rewarded a lot “if your blue horrors are exactly 6” away from any enemy unit, and there is no brimstone horror model in your blue horror unit, and you haven’t moved in your movement phase, roll 3d6 for the enemy unit; every 2+ is a d6 mortal wounds”
@klo45pl
@klo45pl Год назад
Guess who is the best shooter! Is it A. A greater daemon of tzeenth B. A space marine terminator C.A tau tank commander longstrike D.A genestealer cowboy.
@Compa_Doom
@Compa_Doom Год назад
I'm actually against make god specific books. I want to play daemons. I don't want 4 different armies out of my one. But i can see the appeal people would want for it. The biggest wtf is still the unit cap for troops. like wtf am I suppose to do with 10 daemonettes? they don't hit hard enough to matter and they die to anything.
@frostsden6783
@frostsden6783 Год назад
Just happen to stumble upon y'alls channel and I am thoroughly impressed! Love the video format and edits you guys do for your guy's content. From one small channel to another, here's a like follow and a sub. And a best of wishes for your 40k journey for RU-vid 🙂
@jean-philippehaufroid6425
@jean-philippehaufroid6425 Год назад
Gonna be interresting to see your take on the world eaters one. From the leaks, it doesn't look good.
@Kai-sw8rd
@Kai-sw8rd Год назад
How much do you think storing warp storm points by default would help? My worry is you'll get a fix like that in the next dataslate, and it turns out to be nowhere near enough, and then you have to wait another 3 months to try again.
@MrFalk358
@MrFalk358 Год назад
So i used to play chaos demons like 10 years ago, and recently got back into the hobby. Your breakdown of the codex was eye opening for me, because I actually enjoyed how little stratagems there were (mind you not realizing that other factions had more, just the fact that i could take a look at the codex online and start playing). One of the things I thought after playing a fluff tzeentch only list was "Nice this feels familiar, flamers used to be super strong and I guess they still are". I think they are in fact even stronger now than they used to be ( not that thats very surprising). I guess we went full circle in a way.
@lorenzosgarallino
@lorenzosgarallino Год назад
Ps: love this video, only when you throw out all the bad unfiltered you can appreciate the good. And oh the Bloodthirstiers are VERY good. And fun.
@autumnlotus6250
@autumnlotus6250 Год назад
I severely miss the old 7e rules. Random, fun, and and summoning was a serious threat. Now it's garbage all around
@LordZylok
@LordZylok Год назад
Nurgle is essentially just a stat-check. Does your enemy have good shooting or melee of STR 6 or 7, preferably damage 2? If so, you lose! Hurray! Funnily enough, Death Guard is probably one of the worst match-ups for Nurgle Daemons. Their extra toughness means nothing in melee, a single Volkite Contemptor will almost straight up delete a unit of plaguebeares a turn, Fleshmower Drones trade excellently with Beasts of Nurgle or Plague Drones all day, and win just about every time. Pretty much the only tough nuts to crack are Nurgle Soulgrinders, and the GUO. And by tough, I mean DG can't one-round them.
@gravyjones9746
@gravyjones9746 Год назад
Lol Ork dex is written pretty badly too my guys
@icklemoo
@icklemoo Год назад
ork book is just a sad tragedy of a book ... I have been into orks since the 90s . and this current book is just trash unless you want to run buggies/snagga stuff .. . no love for the dread wagghhh/stompy stuff. ..
@dxpsumma383
@dxpsumma383 Год назад
I am really on the fence about collecting and playing pure demons and this video is such a bummer. (But great job and thanks a lot for bringing these issues to the light!) I hate how in AoS I would have to buy 4 books to play demon. I don't want mortals, just pure demons because of the nice double use of demons in AoS and 40k. Chaos Daemons seem to be lacking though in all those tricky little things like stratagems or "core" that are completely unknown to me as a returning player from 5th...
@shivorath
@shivorath Год назад
Wow, as a Nurgle player I am so glad I jumped ship to AoS back in the end of 8th edition. Yikes!
@JCMiniPainting
@JCMiniPainting Год назад
Very well articulated critique. I got lucky early on, invested into every Daemon faction during early 9th, and was able to go into Disciples of Be'Lakor. I'm certain that it's the best option right now, because you get to dip into the best parts of the book without having to commit to the worst part. I can have War Dogs, Belakor, and all the best daemons, with all their strats, AND I still get to use the mediocre Warp Storm and CK once-per-game Dread ability. My list is still obviously 15 Flamers with troops to go score points, and due to GW's HORRIBLE porting of the Army of Renown and it's strats, there is also no reason to bring Chaos Marines (even tho it's 1/3rd of the point of the AoR). To see how fucky everything is for me, and then to realize I got it better than everyone else did, is astounding to me. I have a laundry list of fixes that I would make JUST FOR DoB. It's a really shitty feeling knowing that not only will GW likely never fix them, but may never even know how badly they dropped the ball in the first place.
@1moretake51
@1moretake51 Год назад
New to the channel, really loving it. Though I do have one question. Why is binging with babish giving me in-depth rules analysis?
@thepoorhammerpodcast
@thepoorhammerpodcast Год назад
That's the best thing anyone has ever compared my voice to, I'll take it.
@ionceateapinecone
@ionceateapinecone Год назад
Listen, two things in this codex are unequivocally fantastic: -Daemonic Allies/ Manifestation fixing the terrible summoning rules of 8th -Splitting Horrors is factored into the points cost of the models on your datasheet now Warp Storm is underwhelming as an armywide rule, sure, but bringing Daemons in a Chaos Knight list? Banger. Horrors finally being competative? a godsend to people who paid for and painted 50 horrors to have a full splitting unit.
@RooftopTal
@RooftopTal Год назад
Splitting horrors is so close to being fantastic, but the amount of times they get wiped, and you spent 5-8 extra points on a rule that effectively didn't exist is so frustrating. Manifestation and the spooky morale stuff is great, though
@TreeRaper
@TreeRaper Год назад
I would be ok with the warp storm dice if the effects were bullshit strong. They couldn't even just steal from AoS and use the Skull Throne or Depravity Points system! It's literally right there for the table to steal!
@TheBlightspawn
@TheBlightspawn Год назад
When i looked at the Daemons codex as an Deathguard player it felt a bit underwhelming. I had to check i hadn’t missed “chapter tactics” like -1 damage for Nurgle.
@AndrewSmith-nj8zh
@AndrewSmith-nj8zh Год назад
As a Nurgle daemon player, I should also add that dark invigoration is borderline useless for us. It can’t revive anything, since plaguebearers and nurglings have too many wounds and beasts of Nurgle won’t be healed because they heal to full wounds every phase. For 5 warp storm points, I should at least be able to revive plaguebearers. At least I won’t ever be tempted to use it, and can spend my warp storm points on something more valuable, like the Nurgle powers or the -1 to hit.
@MadisonRamanamabangbang
@MadisonRamanamabangbang Год назад
Warp storm, I think that like A: some things need to be just made innate again, its dumb that faction-abilities are now locked behind a random currency. B: Warpstorm points NEED to build up, make it a "Oooo, I'm saving up for a real banger of an ability if you don't deal with me soon" C: There needs to be a passive warpstorm buildup, like atleast 1 point needs to be given no matter what Or heck, you could make it so that warpstorm points build up but you get -1 per turn
@ashardalondragnipurake
@ashardalondragnipurake Год назад
if theres too few demons to make a full codex why not just skip one of the 5 million spezmarine+ updates and release some new demons the ever changing embodiments of the power of change... have no variation but hey more boring armored dude with gun
@MrSmitejr
@MrSmitejr Год назад
I legitimately thought that you rolled warp storm points each turn, rather than round. It didn't feel overpowered.
@elerosse9
@elerosse9 Год назад
I am kinda glad to hear this and I'll go listen to the podcast too. I really felt "alone" on this take, I deeply love daemons and I am not pleased by this codex writting. I still find it's kinda the "best" daemon codex made but for me it's still the worst 9th edition codex (compared to the period it was released). I found that people around are too much positive about it. It still brings some good things but the internal balance is absurd to such a level that even with cost reduction, it'll still not feel "fun". As in general, there isn't much things to do on the board, so you feel trapped to the deepstrike+charge mechanic, heralds are jokes (and the named ones are even worst, unless maybe skulltaker because he isn't compared to a better psyker). There are so many things who doesn't make sense (even without speaking of the Be'Lakor army of renom). It feels like having an elite army without the durability, a melee focused faction without the tools to play it, etc. In my mind daemons became a bunch of "stats" and they try to find their soul. Like we came from a such pity pit from years of "nothing" that it still need more time to complete a real form. Making daemons able to ally to everyone must have forced GW to not give them too much tools to use because it would be "paired" with some of other chaos codexes. I feel like only Khorne is in an "ok spot" as all you want is charge, kill and be happy collecting skulls, even if I feel it too simple and a bit quickly boring.
@davehultermans7238
@davehultermans7238 Год назад
Plz talk about the new flamers after their nerf. I wanna see you explode with the irritation haha
@flatheadgg2443
@flatheadgg2443 Год назад
As someone who used to play with a lot of slaanesh stuff in my army l can affirm that removing the "fight first" rule is probably the best change in this book. It sounds nice and easy on paper but with how combat works in 9th it's just a complete and utter brainfuck and it would almost never happen anyways so l'd mostly just ignore it. Good job for once james.
@LSgaming201
@LSgaming201 Год назад
Tzeentch's spells sucking isn't new. Tzeentch's spells sucking has been a thing since since at least 6e. Possibly even further back.
@kamikeserpentail3778
@kamikeserpentail3778 Год назад
Warp Storm sounds really dumb. So there are abilities there that the army had by default, or that other armies have just by having a specific subfaction. If you have them half as often you would think they'd be twice as powerful to try to make up for it. And that doesn't even properly make up for it, since you won't necessarily have them when you need them. Though the unpredictability of it could be helpful in messing up your enemy, the fact is your army needs to be able to function against multiple types of armies. You can't be stuck with an ability that is good against shooting when fighting pure melee. They also design really poorly all around. I was so hyped when my Gargoyles had their guns made stronger. ...And I knew in the back of my mind that they'd be raised in point cost proportionally. So what happens? Almost no one uses them, or if they do they're pretty much purely for screening or obsec. People just go monsterous Tyranids and Warrior spam because they don't know how to make each unit fill a unique enough role so spam becomes a bad idea. Why take that when this is strictly better? Because it shouldn't be strictly better. They have a competitive scene, they should be taking balance seriously, and that can't be done if they can't design properly to begin with.
@muffinman6048
@muffinman6048 Год назад
As an undivided player, it's really sad to see that playstyle gutted. The whole reason I got into Daemons was to have a multicoloured horde, and now I'm just told to suck it up and pick one or 2 subfactions.
@Perkustin
@Perkustin Год назад
Impressive you managed this kind of video in 35 minutes, most of them are 2+ hours. I wish they had developed the idea of the 'Undivided' daemons they introduced in WHFB 6th/40k 3.5 with chaos Furies etc, i think it would have helped with the power gamer vs army theme thing and the keyword spaghetti that seriously plagues demons to have good 'undivided' choices. Certainly to me would make them a whole lot less unappealing as an army, every army and even artwork that has them all working together like a happy family just grinds my gears.
@icycoatl3185
@icycoatl3185 Год назад
“Imagine if your army rule just didn’t work some turns” …. Actually, if the army rule in question had some sort of baked-in disadvantage… that could be interesting. You could be praying for it to come up in one turn and not another.
@timunderbakke8756
@timunderbakke8756 Год назад
So what I learned is I’m not buying this book and I’ll just use wahapedia if I use Tzeentch with my thousand sons. Also, subbing because I like the format. It would be kind of cool if next edition all the books are by chaos god and you can take them without the CP tax. Lean into Tzeentch daemons or thousand sons if you prefer, but can mix if you want.
@stepanserdyuk4589
@stepanserdyuk4589 Год назад
The short summary of the codex: they replaced most of the weird special rules into simple auras, really buffed the profiles of units (sometimes integrating these old special rules into the flat statline, as in the Slaanesh's speed or Khorne's strength and attacks), and polished it on top with the solid set of army-wide abilities, such as deep-strike and Ld manipulation (which works really great when you have it on everything - the more tests the opponent has to roll, the more fails he'll inevitably make). But at THAT point, GW probably got afraid they'll overbuff the daemons, so the stratagems and the army-specific ability of Warpstorm was written too "safely". It's not a bad codex, I definitely like playing it, but yeah, the lack of the sub-faction specific bonuses is especially glaring.
@brothertobias
@brothertobias Год назад
>sometimes integrating these old special rules into the flat statline, as in the Slaanesh's speed Which is flat out wrong, because a 7" moving, D6+1 advancing Damonette is still faster than a 10" Demonette. A 14"+d6 Fiend is faster than a 14" Fiend. A 14+3+D6 Keeper of Secrets is faster than a 16" Keeper of Secrets. Slaanesh got GUTTED and everyone was pretending they're okay coping "oh wow, Demonettes move 10 inches", which is completely irrelevant because they're 12 POINTS PER MODEL and mandatory 10s. I would rather have 20 old Daemonettes than 10 new ones. Or you know what, I will take 10 Old demonettes, because that is 60 points saved on awful, unuseable troops. But the results speak for themselves: Slaanesh went from the BEST daemon list to basically never seen and we have more 8th Edition Demonettes logged into competitive results than 9th edition Demonettes.
@abrarnoorani8385
@abrarnoorani8385 Год назад
I could argue that on release Necron codex is also up there
@prophet89
@prophet89 Год назад
I think one of the biggest reasons I won't play 40k anymore is I don't want to risk paying money for a codex that has a high chances of being poorly written or changed within a week.
@Bluecho4
@Bluecho4 Год назад
They could literally strip all the rules out from the codices, making them just art and lore books, and it would make them more fit for purpose. It would certainly make them more valuable long-term for players of that army. Forget a book that becomes outdated after 3 years. Codices get outdated before they're even published. And what is there is just bad.
@darko-man8549
@darko-man8549 Год назад
If I had to use a Slaaneshi metaphor, the Chaos Demon codex story is basically: each codex was beating the meat faster and faster, each new OP buff was slapping it hard and harder...then...suddenly, it jizzed and all the life was gone, after that, there was no slapping. And thus, CD was born
@RooftopTal
@RooftopTal Год назад
There are even more bits that just don't work. Horrors have the same issue as necrons; they're priced for splitting, but if they get wiped, it doesn't trigger, meaning they often just... don't split. One of the tzeentch warp storm effects is extra wounds in melee, where we're terrible. The blue scribes now cast random spells at the start of the turn, meaning you can accidentally cast the spell you needed your lord of change to fire off, making it a liability. Screamers are melee only, but have a 4+ ws and a 6+ melee save (can you tell I play tzeentch yet?) Nurgle can't use dark invig properly, as their troops have 2 wounds. And the worst in my opinion: the rule that makes greater daemons _have_ to take the warlord trait means that the ones that were clearly designed for the heralds (such as the to one for getting a cast and an action for something like psychic interrogation) never see play. Even with all that, I prefer it to the malfunctioning stuff we has in 8th, but man, I wish we could catch a break.
@elerosse9
@elerosse9 Год назад
In the Tzeentch family, you forgot the joke what the changeling is. A 1 spell caster, with a special rule to perform in melee, ONLY against infantry. Can't take any relic. Cost 20pts more. Just end up in melee and die. Screamer 6+ melee is a pure bad writting. Looking at soulgrinders, being Tzeentch... end up with a better melee save. It's indeed better than the last codex who was left behind without even a single try of help. Even the release of the codex is... special. Absolute 0 new model, so furies are gone. Instead, to avoid being the only codex who get less datasheets in his new codex we got a khorne fortification for priests (so why should I put a duelist on it). It isn't like we could have Dexcessa and Synessa with non named characters rules or even fit a lacking part of heavy support for slaanesh.
@MineKynoMine
@MineKynoMine Год назад
What are you talking about, Kaldor's warlord trait is working as intended. It turns off the invuln for Ynnead and Khaine, what else do you need?
@MajorLeagueNerd
@MajorLeagueNerd Год назад
This was well spoken! I was so excited for this codex, but it was a huge let down.
@amishrambo4096
@amishrambo4096 Год назад
THANK YOU i swear i was the only one who hated this codex this thing was written with all the love of the 8th ed "inquisition" codex
@JachymorDota
@JachymorDota Год назад
Even though I am neither collecting nor playing anymore, I am happy I never got into Daemons. It almost always felt like uphill battles with what every other Army got. The only way I wanted to play was silly fun around daemonic summoning: A Word Bearer HQ detachment summoning an army out of thin air. A bunch of Slaanesh harpists flooding the field with KoSs. 3 Great Unclean Ones inviting more of them. Actually having more than three Skull cannons. But well, since I learned GW is happy to break armies with artificial limits, I got bummed out of making silly lists.
@Speeds_Gaming_Corner
@Speeds_Gaming_Corner Год назад
300 point unit that only shoots AND psychics hits on 3's? That's so dumb! *Looks at the stormsurge on my shelf that hasn't seen play all edition*
@redrumssam5888
@redrumssam5888 Год назад
BROOOOOOOO.....personally I LOVE that Chaos Daemons is 4 armies that I can mix and match I love the creativity I can unleash with it. God I hope they don't split it up.
@Tajealos
@Tajealos Год назад
Additional comment on Dark Invigoration: It doesn't work on Plaguebearers It specifies that models can only be replenished if all models in a unit have 1 wound each Plaguebearers have 2 wounds each So best case scenario, you can heal half a Plaguebearer, while they get to sit and watch all your Bloodletters, Daemonettes, and Horrors (don't even get me started on the Horrors) get their friends back Should've probably specified Core Infantry instead so Plaguebearers aren't completely screwed over
@williamtimonen6814
@williamtimonen6814 Год назад
I honestly think there should have been an undivided sub faction to. Even if its weaker. I miss the fun of daemon armies of multiple gods.
@Alpharius8119
@Alpharius8119 Год назад
Missed that all the other Gods got 8 startagems but Khorne got 6, when you remember their sacred (corrupt) numbers this is one of the biggest insults
@lukecook402
@lukecook402 Год назад
Don't talk to me about Reanimation Protocols I freaking have hated that rule for the last two editions and IT DOESNT WORK. But yeah I absolutely understand where this comes from, cause I've had the same issues with Necrons. My condolences.
@DarthBoberEXMinMaxMunchking
I probably won't get a notification of your reply (YT stopped sending those long time ago), so please go to my channel and send me an email instead if you want. Do you think making a supplement that tries to match CSM detachments with Daemon detachments in a more lore-friendly (Tzeentch hates Nurgle and will only ally with Slaanesh CSM maybe etc...) way would be a way to fix this situation? Obviously a whole lotta extra rules would have to be made, but it might be a way to reward mono-faction soups between Thousand Sons and Tzeentch Daemons, Death Guard and Nurgle-daemons... while giving us Chaos players a chance to build a variety of interesting and playable lists.
@meanmachine6328
@meanmachine6328 Год назад
The problem with making 4 daemonkin books is it would make more of gw's models sit on shelves. when you have 2 codex's merge together you will be using half the amount of models and some of the units you would have used in either book will never be touched anymore because you have a better option that came from the the other book. Like why the hell would a khorne daemonkin or tzeentch daemonkin use their chariots or soul grinders when they have the heavy support choices from chaos space marines. Why would tzeentch daemonkin use tzaangors at all if you have daemons instead. It wouldn't be a good decision for a company selling models to do
@azuritet3
@azuritet3 7 месяцев назад
The new RU-vid pseudo-animations are so bad and I hate them. I'm allergic to rainbow sparkles, but I will suffer through it for you two.
@samuelnorton1391
@samuelnorton1391 Год назад
One thing that got skipped over that is super questionable, is that you can't take khorne relics on vehicles. Meaning the bloodthrone, which is the only khorne vehicle that could even take a relic, can't take one. It makes even less sense when you compare it to slannesh, which can take relics on their vehicles. I don't understand why they made this exclusion, it's not like it would make the bloodthrone overpowered or anything, it just makes no sense.
@dontgetmarried
@dontgetmarried Год назад
I'm plotting an Iron Warriors successor warband that uses daemons instead of cultists for cannon fodder- you don't have feed or maintain daemons. I'm bummed they're not as cool as they were when I first started playing
@TheThomasCW
@TheThomasCW 5 месяцев назад
"Bring the Flamer, the HEAVY Flamer." -Russian Badger
@Scrombo2
@Scrombo2 Год назад
6:22 ........I wanna say that's thematic because Tzeentch but, mostly I feel sorry for chaos players
@thegloriouswizard5270
@thegloriouswizard5270 5 месяцев назад
A year late, but: FUCK THE META. Games Workshop CAN NOT WIN.
Далее
Designing the Impossible! - A Perfect 40K Intro Box
31:29
The 40K Models We Wish Existed
1:13:57
Просмотров 330 тыс.
Это нужно попробовать
00:42
Просмотров 336 тыс.
titan tvman's plan (skibidi toilet 77)
01:00
Просмотров 5 млн
A Journey in Collecting Drukhari
1:02:52
Просмотров 101 тыс.
Inquisitor Eisenhorn - Complete 40K Lore - (Inquisition)
3:06:51
We tested every 40K Army Builder so you don't have to.
1:02:18
How to Make a Codex (That doesn't SUCK!)
1:11:20
Просмотров 124 тыс.
Это нужно попробовать
00:42
Просмотров 336 тыс.