Тёмный

How Political Islam Has Evolved Over Time 

Подписаться
Просмотров 40 тыс.
% 487

Stephen Grand and Shadi Hamid discuss how political Islam has changed in response to the conditions it faced throughout history, but not in the way that conventional wisdom suggests.
www.brookings.edu/blogs/up-front/posts/2014/07/07-transitions-of-power-middle-east-grand-hamid

Опубликовано:

 

7 июл 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 82   
@n-tv5fm
@n-tv5fm 2 года назад
Political Islam is present pretty every where.
@arusirham3761
@arusirham3761 2 года назад
Agree
@tusharmallick4413
@tusharmallick4413 5 лет назад
Why sir you not talking about Indian we are suffering from 1000 year because of Islam.. I am from India sir
@bajaxbajax910
@bajaxbajax910 5 лет назад
The west is traumatized by Islam. We can't even acknowledge our own history. Your people at least know the truth.
@what.happend.to.my.handle
@what.happend.to.my.handle 3 года назад
Lol. Sir, it's not Muslims actually you're being brainwahsed by Hindutva and Bollywood. I feel sorry for you. Becasue you're persecuting Muslims in India for the past more than two centuries now.
@ninjaabdi3489
@ninjaabdi3489 3 года назад
@@what.happend.to.my.handle ikr they kill Muslims for eating beef
@cybersecuritywithjo7318
@cybersecuritywithjo7318 3 года назад
@@bajaxbajax910 how are the west traumatised by Islam?
@cybersecuritywithjo7318
@cybersecuritywithjo7318 3 года назад
The conflict is on both sides. Pakistan and India have both experienced violence.
@nabeelbhattacharya2633
@nabeelbhattacharya2633 Год назад
Democracy made Political Islam much stronger!
@Kjom4
@Kjom4 14 дней назад
What does this mean for politcal muslim groupings or islamist groups in the West? Would a repressive approach (like McCarthy-Doctrine or communism containment politics) have liberalising effects?
@tessjones5987
@tessjones5987 5 лет назад
I am ready to go to the Starship Academy. Not Sharia Totalitarianism. We need to move forward in our social systems not back to this oppressive forceful fascism. This United States Constitution is the way forward not the Llife of Mohammad. We need to respect others, allow others independent thought, free choice, not have to hurt what is not like us. That is what the Prime Directive says. DO not harm Do not interfere. Do not come here and try and change the USA. We are a more maginficent country than any other.
@cichlidfeak
@cichlidfeak 5 лет назад
Haha and yes You are being overtaken by muslims....just the way you took the land from the original native Americans. Karma is a bicht!
@ninjaabdi3489
@ninjaabdi3489 3 года назад
Haha I dare you to say that to the arab countries they won't give you oil 🤣 😂 no oil for America then that country is broke the only reason they are surviving is beacuse of foreign countries and your law is corrupted to evangelical Christians in the politics made the law corrupt respect people why do I see protests for freedom every time america gives no respect to people
@N0Xa880iUL
@N0Xa880iUL 3 года назад
@@ninjaabdi3489 if you look at the stats America is getting most of its oil now from U.S. itself.
@dynamitebsb4520
@dynamitebsb4520 2 года назад
@@ninjaabdi3489 if they don't give oil, the usa will take it! Have any doubt refer history haha
@faisalahmed-oo6jr
@faisalahmed-oo6jr 8 лет назад
many good points.!
@kernetbus
@kernetbus 5 лет назад
This is not about political Islam.
@arusirham3761
@arusirham3761 2 года назад
Then what?
@rravisankar3355
@rravisankar3355 2 года назад
Spirituality and religion are essentially all about connect with almighty. It is about every human being internalising oneself in deep reflection to the Divine for safety, prosperity and peace. If one studies religions almost all of them call for each of its members to work from within oneself as a matter of religious practice and it always linked to ethical life. However some religions are bothered more not about themselves but others who are not the followers of their faith. Their scripture is oriented more about how others outside their faith are to treated and deal with them towards either conversion or extermination. When a theology is focused on people outside their own faith, then it is no more spiritually but politics. All the tragedies and turbulences around the world are unfortunately sprang out of these theological inscriptions. There blind and deadly political ideologies masquerading as religions pose a great challenge to the humanity.
@ideology1966
@ideology1966 4 года назад
The "peacefull, loving, tolerant "religion"? of Islam-muslims Quran Sura 8:12 (The Spoils of War) Medinah In the Name of Allah, The Most Gracious, the Most Merciful: "(Remember when) your Lord revealed (the Message) to the angels: "Verily, I am with you: Give strength to the believers. I will bring about terror into the hearts of the disbelievers: So you strike about their necks and hit hard over all of their finger-tips and toes".
@lollypop801
@lollypop801 3 года назад
THANK YOU
@ninjaabdi3489
@ninjaabdi3489 3 года назад
@@lollypop801 your stupid if you don't think that this was sent down to the prophet beacuse the pagans were gonna attack the Muslims do you think in a war you give them a kiss and flower to protect your people no yo defend yourself in a war you have to kill someone
@ninjaabdi3489
@ninjaabdi3489 3 года назад
This was a bloody war it wasn't sent down to terrorise people this was sent down to fight the pagan meccans who wanted to kill the followers of the Prophet pbuh
@Bruh-nb1hj
@Bruh-nb1hj 5 месяцев назад
This was an order given to the angels at the battle of badr. Does god not promise that those who transgress are to be destroyed
@LifeLifeLifeIsLife
@LifeLifeLifeIsLife Год назад
Only one way: (The liars must use the “good lies” to create a lot of new religions).
@thinkfirstthinkagain9911
@thinkfirstthinkagain9911 3 года назад
i think, the main problem of common muslims and including most of their Quranic scholars, are too much "legalistic," (fiqh oriented), as if ayatollah (god guidance) is only one: al Quran (holy scripture) and its derivatives (hadist, ijma, qiyas, etc). factually, God him self, in very first revelation to Muhammad, is not asking Muhammad to study (iqra) the holy Quran (cos the kitab doesn't exist at that day), instead He command Muhammad to study (iqra) other ayatullah, we called as ayat Kauniyah (universe and all of His Creations in it). That why in serious and encyclopedic Islamic traditional school, we always taught that beside al Quran, there is another god guidance (ayatullah) called ayat kauniyah (the universe and all god creation in it). and for qur'anic scholars, we also know --from al Quran it self, there are two others god guidance (ayatullah), that we as muslims should seek for God Guidances: called as ayat insaniyah (human being) and ayat tarikhiyyah (human history). if common muslims and it scholars, uses all 4 God Guidance in balanced ways, we will not always fall into legalistic point of view when we talking or examining Islam point of view about woman/feminism, politics, evolution, LGBTQ issues, democracy, secularism, separation between religion and state, on terrorism, etc. for me, if sociology, political science, statistics, history on the rise and fall of civilizations/countries (as interpreters of ayat kauniyah and ayat tarikhiyyah) comes to the conclusion that democracy with separation between religion and state, is the best political system in the world for advancement human civilizations, then all Muslims should choose democracy with separation between religion and state, as preferable political system to practice in all Muslims majority countries. also if expert on biology, doctors, psychiatry, etc (as interpreter of ayat kauniyah and ayat insaniyah) , said that beside man and woman (as gender), we also has intersex, hemaprodyte, woman with more testosterones, man with more X chromosome, etc, then all Muslims should choose to agree that god him self gave us guidance / ayat that beside man and woman as gender, there also another genders/pronouns that we should cherish, protect, and respect (cos if we don't respect others God Creations, are similarly with we don't respect our God as their Creator). if we stubborn, only picks, one ayatullah, we called al Quran (holy scripture/ayat Qauliyah), as the one and only god guidance to follow, then muslims and it scholars, will always fall upon into legalistic point of view (fiqh oriented) when we examining what is islamic point view on everything under the sky. wahabbiyah, isis, al Qaida, etc are trapped in this narrow point of view about Islam and its believe. of course, for responsible and encyclopedic islamic teaching, all those narrow point views on Islam are wrong (at least incomplete), misguided, and disrespecting God. umar bin khattab, as on of few sahabah (closed friend of Prophet), several times choose to disregarding some textual issues stated clearly in al Quran, and pick other decision after he choose as Muhammad successor, as leader (khalifah/amir), if there are more fairer and more justice way (socially) on making decision as Amir/Leader, rather than choose from what already state very clear in al Quran. he always choose more fairer and more justice decisions, even others sahabah question his decision. and as we know it, umar bin khattab is one of several sahabah (closed friend of Prophet) that guaranteed (informed) by the Prophet that he is going to heaven. his way of leadership decision, was a hard evidence that the closest friend to Muhammad, also not only consider holy scripture (ayat Qauliyah), but also social aspect, fairness, and justice (ayat kauniyah), when he making decision as a leader. nobody in umar bin khattab time, dare to called umar bin khattab as heretic/bid'ah, kuffar, or infidel. but in modern era, several of loud muslims, loud muslim scholars, and most of jihadist will immediately call us heretic/bid'ah, kuffar, or infidel if we also uses 3 other God Guidance's beside ayat Qauliyah, when we speak, analyze, examining islamic point of view on everything under the sun. how strange is it, if we following completes God Guidance's, then be called as infidel, kuffar, or bid'ah. legalistic approach (fiqh oriented) on Islam has bad impact on advancement of Islamic civilization, and has backward effect on development of its peoples: the Muslims. but yes, in Islamic jurisprudence (ushul fiqh), we also has similar concept with Umar way, but unfortunately has more narrowed approach and clearly far from sufficient to be implemented in modern era, we call them: maslahah mursalah (public good principle) and maqashid syariah (ratio legal over legal specific). if muslims also incorporate social science, biology, technology, history, political science, psychology, etc (as part of rightful interpreter all of God Guidancs/ayatullah), many problem we faced today in many part of Muslim countries, will be addressed in responsible way. Muhammad him self, in his own word (Hadits Bukhari Collection no 6015), said: muslims should follow person with specific expertise on handling matter, so let political scientist handle political matter, health matter should handle by doctors, etc. do not let everything under authority of quranic expert. in general, muslim should treat expert on other ayatullah (scientist as rightful interpreter whole universe and all of His Creations in it, as rightful interpreter human being behavior and it history) equal to expert on holy scripture (al quran). Furthermore, on all wide range of social issues, every new founding/understanding as result from responsible research by scientist, should supersede (abrogate) any old interpretation from holy scripture, cos all of new founding/understanding as result from responsible research by scientist, are also rightful interpreter of God Guidance (ayatullah). falling to do so, should be interpreted as a disqualified argument/opinion. Many argument/opinion base on fiqh (islamic legal specific), kalam (theology) and falsafah (philosophy), factually in most areas are quite obsolete for addressing social, economic, and political problem in modern era, cos most of them are derived only from ayat Qauliyah (Quranic centric), which is an incomplete way to sorting our problem in modern era. Most of old argument/opinion already supersede/abrogated by new founding/understanding as result from responsible research by scientist. Muslims should back to the complete of God Guidance in balance way on solving problem in Muslims world, not only using holy scripture as final say. and stop kuffar/infidel calling game, cos that game from a complete, genuine, and responsible interpretation of 4 God Guidances, is simply un islamic. and, as an open end conclusion, there is a deeper question: why common muslims and its scholars dare to disregarding 3 other God Guidance's? why muslims and its scholars become legalistic (only focus on 1 ayatullah / 1 God Gudance (ayat Qauliyah) called alquran, as if salvation of a civilization fate can be and must be depend on 1 cause only? as brief answer is: corruption and abuse of power by people in high power, it cronies, and big business that closed to muslim countries rulers at that time. all of them, almost single handedly creates and propagate common muslims and its scholars into disregarding 3 other God Guidance's. peoples in power, it cronies, and big business that closed to muslim countries rulers push and push relentlessly to narrow interpretation on morals and public interest thru perverted interpretation on the holy scripture. even, they dare to appoint unqualified islamic scholar as qadi for them to uses as fatwa producers in favors to their vested interest. since then, islamic civilization goes down spiral into inevitable decline from it's greatness. many fatwa produced in their regime will makes serious, genuine, and responsible islamic scholar scratching their head and shocked. fatwa on mihnah policy, on banning printing technology, banning radio, tv, google, youtube, etc, are among of perverted interpretation on holy scripture. it lead to tradition/repetition/reinforcement on using narrow interpretation islamic law for beating and punishing dissent and discontent on social injustice in islamic society. furthermore, it lead islamic society to become close minded, anti science, and trapped in textual approach tradition on just 1 god guidance called al quran (ayat Qauliyah) only, with narrow and more narrow interpretation. common muslim today and it scholar today are the real victims of bad fatwa born from dark alliance between high power, it cronies, big business that closed to muslim rulers before them. lets wake them up, by spreading the real genuine of God Guidance's and it's rightful interpreters that we called: sciences. amen.
@ayrramadan8819
@ayrramadan8819 5 месяцев назад
No such Thing! It's a term designed to discredit Islam!
@ingridarvidsson7597
@ingridarvidsson7597 4 года назад
That is a lie.
@cherp5837
@cherp5837 3 года назад
What
@arusirham3761
@arusirham3761 2 года назад
Please write a book mam
@ygcg8696
@ygcg8696 3 года назад
Islam is political. Don't know where the non political Islam is , frankly !
@ayrramadan8819
@ayrramadan8819 5 месяцев назад
Islam is a way of Life! It can't be limited to spiritual life!
@ayrramadan8819
@ayrramadan8819 5 месяцев назад
Islamist and Jihadist are Zionist terms designed to discredit Islam!
@darthvader5300
@darthvader5300 5 лет назад
Dennis Prager Distinctions In Torah
@cetviesauthor-writer4223
@cetviesauthor-writer4223 4 года назад
level and kind. repression over nazis is fine, is it not?
@SajiSNairNair-tu9dk
@SajiSNairNair-tu9dk 5 месяцев назад
Old👈👉democracy vs religion
@jhljhl6964
@jhljhl6964 4 года назад
Creeping sharia law
@Johnwick-dt9vx
@Johnwick-dt9vx 4 года назад
Islam appeared as a protest against idolatry. And what is patriotism but a subtle form of idolatry; a deification of a material object. The patriotic songs of various nations will bear me out in my calling patriotism a deification of a material object. Islam could not tolerate idolatry in any form. It is our eternal mission to protest against idolatory in all its forms. What was to be demolished by Islam could not be made the very principle of its structure as a political community. The fact that the Prophet prospered and died in a place not his birthplace is perhaps a mystic hint to the same effect. Allama iqbal
@Sufian95
@Sufian95 3 года назад
Islam appeared as a political system for Arabs only to conquer the world. Islam is evil.
@Johnwick-dt9vx
@Johnwick-dt9vx 3 года назад
@@Sufian95 humans have huge tendency to evil
@Sufian95
@Sufian95 3 года назад
@@Johnwick-dt9vx that's why humans invented religions while free men and women always fought religions. Can you understand the difference?
@Johnwick-dt9vx
@Johnwick-dt9vx 3 года назад
@@Sufian95 humans corrupted everything including Religion to satisfy their unjust desires and fantasies
@neerajnambiar4145
@neerajnambiar4145 3 года назад
The fact that your mahammad died not in his birth place.lol.. Killed and married childern , killed his brothers and thousand of others due to his I'm a self proclaimed messager of God attitude. Man what are they teaching you in that Qur'an. Brainwashed
@SofienLetaief
@SofienLetaief 4 года назад
lol another American pion.