This video is like saying ghar se kachra saaf kardiya magar kithna bhi saaf karo kuch na kuch tho ghar ke andhar rehega hi... Kaash 100% of mullas went to Pakistan indian would have become soma ki chidiya already
Only solution "was civil" war like Abraham Lincoln did in America and Mustafa kamal ataturk did in turkey.There will no peace by weakness than war/violence. Just think when Bharat was partitioned for peace but still millionsof Hindus were massacred by peaceful,then how can you say it was good.
@@ang4065Hindus are enemy of Hindus no unity in Hinduism hindus are divided by seculars, liberal,communist and Bindu sherniya marrying with abdul and choosing their religion .
Even though india broke up to 3 parts, it is saved india as a country. Indian friend of mine told me this 30 years ago . At that time, I didn't think of it at then but it is very true
Maturity when you realise... Ambedkar was the first one who was in favour of complete population exchange..... Muslim and hindus. (Mentioned in his book)
@@uniqguy111APJ was Hindu by karma, he used to study Bhagwat Gita, visit temples, wear tilak on forhead. He was vegetarian, Never married and lived like hindu saint. He believed in Vedas not Sky Book. He named India's missiles on Hindu Gods Prithvi, Agni, Aakash. Because of all this many Moozlim scholars declared him Kaafir or nonmoozlim. In his funeral, leaving his family memebers all people who attended his last journey were Hindus only. Peacefuls population was bussy attending funeral of Terrorist Yakub Memon
@@uniqguy111 only few in crores can be refined .. and btw Mr. Kalam never followed any stupid things of islamm ..that's what helped him to think in other direction
Maturity is when you realize... Sir Ambedkar wanted to exchanged Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhists & Parsis and Muslims population without killing each other or creating Religious-based Conflict.... ( eg. He wanted send all Indian Muslims to Pakistan and Non-Muslim Pakistani must come to India by their choice but not forcing them )
As a Bengali Hindu, partition hurts me a lot because my family, especially my mother's side has been directly affected by that. My mom's family lived in Chittagong in former East Bengal(now Bangladesh). Their house was burnt down by those bloody mullas and all of them had to hide and cross the border to come to this side. They lost everything. My mom's mom(great grandma) became insane due to the trauma that she faced and for a long time, hated Muslims to the core(she had very good reasons). Those mullas killed my great grandfather. However, I do agree with your point that partition in the long run has been immensely beneficial to us. Look at Bhikharistan now and you'll easily understand
@@user-pj7co1qo1x I said Bengali Hindu coz Bengalis and Sikhs are the two communities which suffered the most due to the partition. And yes, there can be Tamil Hindu, Bengali Hindu and others just like there can be Kashmiri Muslim or paxtani Muslim. We aren't talking about nationality here so I think saying Bengali Hindu is quite alright
My grandma's brother was killed during the partition of Punjab in 1947. She tells me stories how her Muslim classmates warn her that they will remove all you Hindus and make Pakistan. But I still think that the partition was the best and only decision left due to radical Islamism present in Indian Muslim at that time.
@@adityamukherjee7038shut up bro you should say Bengalis, Punjabis and Sindhis. Please read about the geography and history of partition. Punjabis are not just Sikhs this includes Hindus also. And Sindh is given in such a way that we don't have its part in our country. They migrated from Karachi through boats. And Hindu Sindhis hold very big business in Karchi and Sindh at that time.
@@user-sf5gj4hu1c Secular sirf Hindu ke liye Muslims Christians ke liye nahi Sirf Hindu apne Customs aur Traditions share kare Muslims nahi Aur Jis Constitution ki tu baat kar raha hai,Use DR ambedkar ji ne likha hai. Aur Wo kehte hain Hinduism Bad hai Lekin Islam Worst hai.
You do have a brain right? That voting was not universal, so not all muslims voted, nor did all hindus vote in that. In fact only the rich and elite few got the right to vote and obviously, they were bought out ig. Know you facts, this channel is pure propoganda
@@napoleonbonaparte937Hindus are enemy of Hindus no unity in Hinduism hindus are divided by seculars, liberal,communist and Bindu sherniya marrying with abdul and choosing their religion .
I always supported Partition. Akhand Bharat is a concept of one land and one people. When people are not united, it means it is not Akhand.. Akhand means Undivided in english. Partition was a blessing in disguise. India would have an estimated 40Cr additional kachara population in Akhand Bharat if partition had't happend.
Everyone is always focused on Pakistan. But what about Bangladesh?? A majority of today's Bangladesh population has anti-India and anti-Hindu sentiment. The keep on entering India illegally. No govt does anything significant. Bangladesh has never officially announced war against India. But sending millions of Bangladeshis illegally is a different kind of war. Some people in Bangladesh still think that creation of Bangladesh is incomplete. When West Bengal, Assam, Tripura will be included in Bangladesh, the creation will be completed. This mentality is not less dangerous for India than the mentality of Pakistanis regarding capturing Kashmir.
@@eishuno Bhaiya ji mein khud Assam se hu. Tripura belongs to Tripuri people who r the original inhabitants of the land. It is later on when Bengalis started to arrive. The only good part is most Bengalis in tripura r Hindu Bengalis.
Pakistan is like a tumour which got severed from our body and I'm really thankful for Jinnah for doing so, Veer Savarkar was visionary who saw this crisis to be looming.
Pakistan is like the part of India which got infected by a deadly virus called Islam , that part was separated from India in 1947, but the virus is still active and doing its job inside India..
Indians need to be very clear about this that islamic radicalism existed way before India's independence, if not then massacres like Noakhali and Moplah (Malabar) wouldn't even had happened, so India's partition was kind of fortunate however only in the long run. India's partition is one of the brightest example of "Good intentions horrible execution".
I strongly agree with you. I always say to my friends, that partition saved hindus and its cultures. Whatever india has achieved, would not have been possible. Geeta ka bani hai " Jo hota hai aanche ke liye hi hota hai."
@@kum651 Yes, we know that it is your sole purpose of life according to Islam. While we dream of developed India with zero poverty, you dream of Islamic India. See the difference. All religions are not equal.
Dear Sham bro, absolutely true. What a clear and great analysis of the different scenarios. Nehruji took the right decision at that critical and difficult moment. The partition was the best option for Bharat's culture and civilization. J'ai Hind 🇮🇳
A Índia errou em manter os muçulmanos em seu território, todos deveriam serem expulsos para o Paquistão. Se houve partilha de território, e a Índia cedeu aos muçulmanos um pedaço de sua terra, todos deveriam ter ido para lá. A Índia cometeu um erro estúpido, entre vários. Eu amo a Índia, sigo o hinduísmo desde 2016,mas não dá para fingir demência diante desse erro.
As a Sikh partition was difficult for Us and for the Sindhis, Bengalis and Punjabi Hindus as we helped build the cities of Lahore, Karachi, Dacca, Rawalpindi. Economically Hindus and Sikhs were the backbone of these cities and our cultural contribution over the years has been immense. Although, looking at the state of Pakistan today, i have started to appreciate the silver lining that came along with the partition. Only thing that occurs to my grandfather: Wish we could have kept Nankana Sahib, Kartarpur Sahib (which is barely 4 kms from border) and eastern districts of Sindh which were Hindu majority. Also, Gandhiji and Nehru urged all muslims to stay back, to show their secular credentials. In my view Muslims who believed in and had supported the concept of Pakistan should have been urged to migrate. Only those who were secular and believed in co-existence should have been requested to stay back. That way we would have had a more stable population.
The partition was undoubtedly a horrific event that destroyed millions of lives but it also may have just given non-Muslim cultures enough breathing space to preserve and consolidate their cultures
I think your family came from Lahore , which was already a Hindu sikh dominated area also the culture of Punjab is not communal in nature. But my grandparents who came from east Bengal which had little to no dev at that time and was heavily Muslim dominated says partition was the best thing to happen. So partition story is different for everybody
Yes I am Punjabi Hindu from Gurdaspur and it was decided in the last minute that our town would remain in India ! Can’t imagine the outcome! But I absolutely agree what you are saying ! Once the best punjab cities Lahore Multan are now the dirtiest ! We will get back Kartarpur and Nankana Saab ! Dera Baba Nanak is waiting to get its link !
@@ShamSharmaShowI think military training should be made mandatory in India by Indian government like Israel, we have to learn from countries who handle terrorism best.
@@amit____singh No it isn't! This is 2023 not 1523; xtianity went through a lot of reform over the centuries. Without that, the west would never had developed into first world countries. Think before commenting.
Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh must be kept outside Akhanda Bharat. It will cause more trouble than benefit. Akhanda Bharat must be limited to India, Nepal, Bhutan, and Sri Lanka. Burma/ Mynmar could be considered in Akhanda Bharat.
I am Pakistani Muslim and a good student of History, I am 100% agree with you, division was more beneficial for Hindus rather than for Muslims, because according to research if any country exceeds 30% Muslim population it sooner (within 20-30 years) becomes a Muslim state, there are many such examples, most recent one is Nigeria. So by accepting division Nehro and Jinnah made different ideology of Hindus into a one strong nation and divided 35% Muslim population into 3 parts, (Pakistani, Bangladeshi, and Indian Muslim). And joint work of Congress leaders Nehru and Jinnah who was a newly converted Muslim from Hindu family, set the stage and fooled the Muslims. Well played Gandhi Nehru and Jinnah, well played Congress. In other case Muslims and Dalat (who were already major portion of Hindu population) would had sandwiched remaining Hindu population.
Our Bangladesh is highly benifited by partition. GDP of Bangladesh is now almost double of pakistan & gdp of Bangladesh is more than combined gdp of west bengal+seven sisters of india. It didn't be possible if Bangladesh would still remain part of india/pakistan. Bangladesh would remain poor or even poorer than north east india if partition didn't happen. So we are gratefull to gandhi ji,nehru ji,mohammad ali jinnah & sheikh mujibur rahman. Joy bangla💙
Yess, I wish..If that was prevented then our nation would be established as Hindurashtra in which Mu#slims would not create there Isalamic rashtra within it self... Partition would be only good if all people were distributed religiously which was not happened..If any Hindu says partition was right then he is indirectly supporting next partition.(If we compair current & 1947's mus$lims population in India.) So that would be better if partition was prevented. Also we didn't loose Hindus which are mus#lims now in pakistan..
बंटवारे के पश्चात 1% मुस्लिमों को भी भारत में नहीं रहने देना चाहिए था बंटवारे के पश्चात इन्हें यहां रखना ही भारत की सबसे बड़ी मूर्खता थी जिसका भार हम आज तक उठा रहें हैं।
जय श्रीराम🙏, नमन इतने आवश्यक विषय निरंतर उठाने के लिए एवं इतनी सरलता से इतने गंभीर एवं जटिल विषयों को समझने के लिए। इश्वर आप पर अपनी असीम कृपा बनाए रखे। जय मां भारती🙏
Wonderfully stated your sensible views which makes sense and is logical. Bharat needs to be strong, move forward, economically prosper, crime show a downward trend, peace, harmony prevail, all sections of the society prosper........list is endless. A strong, humanitarian, stable government at the Centre and in all States is needed who are interested in prosperity of its people.
Partition would have given better results had we heeded to Dr Ambedkar's advice of complete exchange of population (just like that happened between Turkey and Greece).
@@KoyukiSenorita SIMULTANEOUS INDEPENDENCE OF INDIA ALONG WITH PARTITION IN WITH ABNORMALLY SHORT NOTIIFICATION CREATED ABNORMAL EXPLOSION OF EMOTION OF HATRED AND VIOLENCE ON THE WESTERN FRONT LEADING TO THE DEATH OF 1--2 MILLION INNOCENT HUMAN BEINGS AND FORCED MIGRATION OF 5.5 MILLION HINDUS AND SIKHS FROM PAKISTAN TO INDIA AND ALMOST EQUAL NUMBER OF MUSLIMS FROM INDIA TO PAKISTAN WITHIN A PERIOD OF 4 MONTHS. AS REGARDS EASTERN FRONT, SLOW AND STEADY MIGRATION OF HINDUS, OCCASIONALLY SPURTED BY POGROM OF HINDUS BY MUSLIMS OF EAST PAKISTAN/ BANGLADESH HAS BEEN STILL GOING ON. THE PERCENTAGE OF HINDUS IN EAST PAKISTAN/ BANGLADESH HAS COME DOWN FROM 28 % PRIOR TO PARTITION TO 7.95 % IN 2022. TOTAL NUMBER OF HINDUS SUBJECTED TO GENOCIDE AND ETHNIC CLEANSING IN EAST PAKISTAN/ BANGLADESH WORKS OUT TO 17.6 MILLION TILL 2022.
I am American and my husband is Pakistani I visited the Country and I was so sad at the living conditions. We are Muslim. I pray that the Country is saved. They are the same the ppl should put away differences because they are humans apart of humanity . There is no seperation from that Alhamdulillah Allahuakbr Allahuakbr Allahuakbr
Partition should have happened before 1947 and in a planned manner with proper term and conditions which benefit india which was not done by that time government we lost land money but goal was not achieved in a manner which we want lot of waste left behind.
Incomplete Partition Didn't Help India. Either There Should Have Been No Partition Or Complete Partition. India Gave Half Of It's Land To Pakistan Still 25 Crore Muslims Live In India.
After so long he gave a good video, still some idiots and nonsense of BJP make Modi akhand bharat akhand bharat. Hope from today Nonsense Indians will stop demanding a united India.love from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Muslims are literally the poorest and most backward people in whole Indian subcontinent be it sports, business or anything Hindus are far ahead of muslims. I don't know how Muslims claim they ruled India 🧐
As Sai Deepak mentioned - Pakistan is a state of mind, not a country. Unfortunately we have millions still in Bharat with that medevial mindset. As they say, cut from the same cloth.
Lovely Film Doubt. The Nun was certain without any proof that the child was being abused by male priest. Her best dialogue was - I have my certainty no proof is needed. It is this doubt of a weak mind that killed basic human ability to connect with neighbours. Better we exercise our mind and make it stronger that no doubt will creep in. Unless u have solid proof that people living in India are harming India - it is best to desist.
@@iracture I can't help you if you have stuck your head in the sand. Tell me who beheaded that tailor in Rajasthan?. Or riots in UP?. The rampant destruction of public property that was done in blore a couple of months back?. Love j1had?. Shall I go on?. You can choose to ignore them if you want. But they won't..
@@iracture In the case of people living in India and harming her there should be no self introspection or searching for proofs. Its a matter of survival and a heavy blow is needed to suppress these miscreants. Relying on justice is only an excuse of the cowards,
@@vikrang is exactly view of Hitler type people. We need less of those..When one had a doubting mind , it gives rise to propaganda amongst citizens. As long as all communities prosper there is no reason of harming ur surroundings. Avoiding propaganda and having open communications is key way to avoid doubt. If u think someone if harming , best to confront them explain ur viewpoint and ask them to counter it.
Thanks for providing the subtitles. This was very informative for a European outsider to Indian affairs like myself. Your analysis is very sound. Long live strong and united India!
@@MrLeiduowenThat Is Important B'coz whole World Thinks That Indian Hindus hates Muslims For No Reasons😢 But Outsiders don't Know the History of Hindu And Bloody bitch Muslims 😤 Hail Hindu Nation India 🚩🕉️🔪
This is an extremely interesting view point... Partition was definitely a pain for the people... But it seems like a case where our forefathers sacrificed to ensure that idiots are removed from India and that will allow us to grow n prosper 😊 Jai hind ❤
I actually always loved the idea of partition Because It was because of partition only that India could focus on other departments Otherwise It would have been in a constant war And I actually want them to be always seperated
3:08 Khilafat movement was started by Ali brothers and gandhi supported this to ensure communal harmony and to add muslims in the path of independence. (Jinnah opposed this khilafat movement , WhatsApp se facts uthate ho ky) 4:35 bro partition means equal division na so it was equal distribution of armed forces and currency (not the division of natural resources) 6:24 That was fake and just a WhatsApp forward Gandhi never quoted this! And even if then at least see the sensitivity of what he was trying to convey. Lekin nahi ye sb thodi dekhnaa h It is nowadays fashion to criticize Gandhi. 9:51 Govt doesn't interpreted Hindus personal laws. It was only to end polygamy and to end patriarchy society as written in Hindus scriptures 10:02 Rajiv Gandhi not supported shah bano case becoz that time was tensed. There may be a armed rebellion by muslims (bs history ni dekhi jaati circumstances bhi dekhi jati h) 10:25 Art 29 and 30 preserve the culture of minorities and every nation has these regulations (because majority always suppress minority and prevails their will in all cases) (Thodi si political philosophy padh lo) 11:33 I agree with thiss for some muslims their religion is prior to every fcking thing and they are anti hindus well. But don't hide the fact there are still some muslims whoo are well educated and liberal. Like Khan abdul ghaffar khan who strictly opposed two nation theory. Like many muslim homes hide the hindus girl from being raped and killed by the mob. But you guys will never tell thisss neveerrrrrrrr Becozzz you have a manipulated ideology. And hindu muslim krke politics bhi to chalani h. History has it's own circumstances and need. Every action has a cause and a reason. And bro rewatch your video you sound so anti-islam. And study about secularism and why secularism pampers minority. Mr sham sharma biased CEO of secularism and graduated from WhatsApp university.
I always had a feeling that Partition was the best thing to have happenned to Bharat and its civilisation. My only regret was partition should have happened where atleast 90 % of Muslims eho voted for seperate Nation should have been asked to move to Pakistan. Other regret is we have compketely ignored and left our Hindu , Sikh brothers of Pakustan and Bangladesh in the hands of those vultures and barbarians. India in initial days of independence must have asked for population transfer or population swap so that our Hindu & Sikh brothers of Pakistan and Bangladesh would have got some dignity in their lifes.
Jatayu was also a vulture. Stop demeaning animals in comparison with those radical humans. Otherwise, there will be no difference than those Muslims who make fun of our animal gods.
@@Superman-ed4xz i will ask a question for you If God was there, when no universe mass energy nothing existed, then can you tell me from what God created all stuff just simple question
Living in Pakistan, sometimes I think that Mr. Nehru, Gandhi G and Congress were real heroes for Indian Muslims because they were trying not to divide them into three different states.....
@Hawk-00 Bhai, kaunse website se aisa tatti data nikala🤦? Muslims ki population max. 21% pe rukegi, aur wo bhi 2100 me. Uske baad stable ho jayega. Aap apna source ek baar mention kar do And btw, Yogi ji for 2029💪
So you want 200M people to go into exile, it will rip your country apart with riots, the entire global community will spit on you for being racist and will stop doing all business with you. Then you can go back to the poverty-stricken India of past and enjoy Hindu rashtra
@@geofreak400bhai tuh khud soch United India ma 105 CR hindu , 70 cr muslim aur 10 crore other minority rahti Phir hum hinduo ka kya haal hota Tujhe lagta ha hum itna muslim hone ka baad Ram mandir dubara banti Angrezo na hume bacha liya
@@LovepreetSingh-vx4hi boht lokan nu ghar shadne pye, guru ghar v shadne paye. Par je batwara na hoya hunda ta ajj jo extremism, terrorism te jahiliyat Pakistan vich he oh sari Punjab vich hundi. United Punjab vich hindu 40℅ muslman 50℅ te sikh 10℅ hunde te Imagine kar sikhan kol kini ku power hundi??? Ajj Punjab vich jo marji he sikh majority vich han, jadon da Punjab banaya Sare mukh mantri sikh hoye hn.
@Hawk-00 Bhai, kaunse website se aisa tatti data nikala🤦? Muslims ki population max. 21% pe rukegi, aur wo bhi 2100 me. Uske baad stable ho jayega. Aap apna source ek baar mention kar do And btw, Yogi ji for 2029💪
What India gain from partition?? Absolutely nothing. If India was divided on basis of Muslim and Non Muslims then why 240 Million Muslims are still living in India??
Maha Baratha was divided in two East and West Pakistan due to divde and rule policy adopted by British Government Also Muslim invasion of India and Islamic law and Religion was rooted and created division among Maha Baratha unity Now having three independent countries India 🇮🇳 Bangladesh 🇧🇩 and Pakistan 🇵🇰
Yes, Sham, I am aware of this "benefit" of Partition. However, I would not go so far as to give Mr. J. Nehru the credit of "farsightedness" in protecting Sanatana civilization. If he had that vision, he would have completed full population exchange, which was repeatedly pleaded by Ambedkar & Patel. Nehru partitioned Bharat ONLY for his personal ambition of becoming PM. Surely, he was the "pappu" of his era. Period...!
@@leederzubair2747 yeah they don't care about women. Just breed like rabbits and convert people with the help of a sword policy helped them in the past.
In 1947,there were 9 crores Muslim and 33 crores non muslims in British India which was 44 lacs square km. 9 crores Muslim got 12 lax square km while 33 crores non Muslim got 32 lax square km Gandhi son was Abdullah and Nehru son in law was Farooz Khan, so both requested Muslim to stay in India. 3 crores Muslim stayed in India, who married 4 wives and produce 40 children in a household, so 3 crores had a mushroom growth to 30 crores. What hell will they create in future is unknown to Hindus
Respect for Our brothers Living in Amritsar and rest of punjab and other border areas increases 🫡 whenever Bharat was in trouble our Sikhs brothers and sisters took the challenge and faced those chaos.
I always used to have this sense of relief thinking that Pakistan acting as a buffer state between India and Muslim extremist states. Anyways, you convienced me that accepting the partition of 1947 was one bad decision against the 'worst' one of not accepting it. Thanks for another insightful video! 👍
Why do we still have gandhi on our currency notes? His story must be a lesson for future generations about how an agent can manipulate and destroy societies?
INDIAN religion don't teach wrong things. Buddhism teach meditation, JAINISM teach don't to have desire, Sikh teaches equality while the SANATAN Dharm is the treasure of knowledge and the best and oldest great religion of world. Overall people should follow INDIAN religion except of foreign religion then only India can become superpower
Bro please no matter what happens please don't ever stop making videos 😢.This country can only be saved if you tell all people the truth and help them see through the history
One point is wrong. If there wasn’t Pakistan then there weren’t field for America to train Taliban militants against Russia. If Pakistan was part of India; India will never let the militants to train here. So it could have been a win win situation for both India and Afghanistan.
दुर्भाग्य से मुस्लिमों को पाकिस्तान तो मिल गया पर हिंदू को हिंदुस्तान नही मिला,इसलिए भारत में एकबार फिर पार्टीशन या गृहयुद्ध की नौबत ज़रूर आएगी 😭😭 कड़वा है पर सच है🤔
Incompetent leader's like gandhi-nehru could not have handled this large a country resulting in a civil war like situation.If we had netaji then the things would have been very different.😢
@@user-nk9gp6ui9tJokes actually on you Netaji was a leftist, He would have been like Stalin or Mao. His bravery is Legendary but he would have brought a lot consequences if he would have got into power. He even appeased Muslims too. Believe me Patel was the best suited person. He was a Hindu Nationalist after him it was Nehru unfortunately
@Hawk-00Bhai, kaunse website se aisa tatti data nikala🤦? Muslims ki population max. 21% pe rukegi, aur wo bhi 2100 me. Uske baad stable ho jayega. Aap apna source ek baar mention kar do And btw, Yogi ji for 2029💪
