(I'M NOT MONOPOLIZING PLEASE BE OPEN MINIDED I'M TRYING TO HELP YOU. ) Monarchs can get lost easily if there in a building pretty crazy huh plus if the monarch caterpillars eat Tropical Milkweed it would be a 100% percent chance that the butterfly won't get to Mexico or Canada with the other Monarchs butterflies. So please switch your tropical milkweed and grow the native milkweeds and like i said it before I'm trying to help you save the monarchs. And yes i have researched them for 8 years now.
Thanks so much for this video! I saw a female laying eggs in a patch of milkweed and ran out to find eggs but I wasn't sure what I was looking for. I found your video, went back out and found 4 eggs! I can't wait to see them hatch with my kids and watch them turn into eating machines! I have a field full of milkweed!
it is especially fun to see the monarch female move from plant to plant like that and find the eggs. Glad it was helpful. ck out my monarch playlist and keep me posted!
All 4 caterpillars turned into chrysalises today - I caught one on video. So exciting! I was curious about something. At the 5th instar, when they were pudgy and strong, I noticed them ocassionally fighting. They had an entire new plant to devour every day but they would all crawl to the top and push, shove, and sometimes even lunge at each other. I was worried they would hurt each other with those powerful jaws. Any need to be concerned? Was it all posturing with aggressive antenna waving?
Great video series! I really appreciate it and have learned a lot. It has inspired me to raise some Monarchs myself. We had a monarch female lay a ton of eggs on one puny Narrow-leafed milkweed we had in our front yard (it was partly in shade, so didn't get big). I'm not sure why she laid all of them on one plant since we had tropical milkweed in the backyard area. I didn't even notice them until there were a ton of caterpillars covering the plant. Sadly, it was such a small plant that most of the caterpillars died due to lack of food. : ( It made me really sad, so I went out and bought a ton of native milkweed plants (Showy, Narrow-leafed, pine, common, etc) for our yard to prevent this from ever happening again. Now we have a butterfly garden full of native milkweed plants and butterfly-friendly flowers so there is plenty of food for them. We live in the San Francisco bay area and the monarch population in California has declined by 99% here. It's awful. So I will do my part to help them out. : ) Monarchs are hanging out in our yard every day and there are already eggs and caterpillars all over the plants we bought, which makes me very happy.
Hi Peridot 180! Great to hear what you have accomplished building a monarch/milkweed garden. Sad to hear about the state of the western population. When I was still teaching high school biology...i got a grant and was able to fly out and photograph the winter roosts there in California at Monterey Bay! Fantastic experience and I was grateful to be able to witness it! Keep me posted on your observations of caterpillars and adults visiting your garden!
Get rid of the tropical milkweed. It is non-native, blooms late, and can confuse Monarchs into laying eggs too late in the year instead of migrating back to overwintering grounds.
@@yellowstonehiker1 Hi, I cut all of it back every year. It's not an issue if it's cut back in the fall. I have never had an issue with it and the butterflies do not stick around in my area, so I haven't seen it affect their migration. There is a LOT of debate surrounding this subject and I honestly don't want to get into it. Thanks.
@@peridot180 too many people are lazy or aren't responsible with tropical it's best to just have everyone do fully native, there's 5 people in my neighborhood with tropical and I'm the only one who cuts mine down and I have told them to do so but they don't
Thanks to your video. This morning I found two eggs on our campus plant. Now that I know what to look for. I’m close to having my first M butterfly soon. Praise Jah
Hi Frank. Another awesome video. I love your videos. I've learned so much from you. God created everything. He sure was wise. I work in nature for my job. I'm very lucky.god bless.😊
I work for the pa game commission. I work at the food and cover core. We work with biologist and improve habitat. On game lands. We are doing alot of work for what your video is about. We are planting native wildflowers and native grasses in our herbaceous openings. It's amazing how many critters use the different plants. And we will manage a lot of the openings with controlled burns. I love your videos.
I'm glad I found your channel too. It brings nature to my door. Thank you. Life is good. We will be headed home to pa Saturday. 2 weeks at our Maine cabin goes by quickly. Take care teacher.
Ive been doing this for 3 years, and it is truly AWESOME! i plan to make a series on my channel (although that's not what my channel is for, lol) of raising my monarchs this year! i found 7 eggs earlier, and am going later (maybe) to get more! This is one of the best videos i have ever seen.
Wow! That's sounds great Fostoria productions! Love your enthusiasm and excitement. Thank you for kind words re my production. Sub ing you now to see what yours is about! I love trains too! Looking forward to following your monarch rearing this summer! Post regularly!
(I'M NOT MONOPOLIZING PLEASE BE OPEN MINIDED I'M TRYING TO HELP YOU. ) Monarchs can get lost easily if there in a building pretty crazy huh plus if the monarch caterpillars eat Tropical Milkweed it would be a 100% percent chance that the butterfly won't get to Mexico or Canada with the other Monarchs butterflies. So please switch your tropical milkweed and grow the native milkweeds and like i said it before I'm trying to help you save the monarchs. And yes i have researched them for 8 years now.
I've always had a profound interest in nature study. In my youth, now over a half century ago, and living in the country, I learned to raise not only monarchs, but also black swallowtails (which fed on carrot leaves), hawk moths ( which ate tomato vines), and once even carried an American silk moth or caecropia through larval to adult stage. It was fascinating to watch the caecropia spin its cocoon. So, of course at now 80-plus, I was delighted to discover your excellent series on the milkweed/monarch relationship. I hope some young people (and even adults) will be "turned on" to nature study by your excellent presentations. P.s.: I also gathered praying mantis egg clusters, and released the nymphs into my flower garden.
When I bought my house, 16 years ago, it was all lawn. Since them I transformed much of into a food forest, right now I have a few thousand milkweed plants in different stages of development. While preparing a bed for cabbages, I ran into three caterpillars within 2 feet of each other. First ones of this season. I have different types of milkweed plants depending on the time of the year. I live right in the middle of the old section of town surrounded by lawns. Got permission from the "city" in 2005 to convert my property. I live in Minnesota.
Carmen what you accomplished sounds really really amazing and inspiring. I need to put more effort in getting rid of tall rescue mainly over space created and cleared for my septic field! I would love to see photos! Can you share (photos and our video) with me and our learning community on my Nature at Your door Facebook page. Find the drop own menu ...visitor posts and you can share there! If you were closer I would come up to see you! I am very inspired by what you shared with me already! Kudo s and shout out to you!
(I'M NOT MONOPOLIZING PLEASE BE OPEN MINIDED I'M TRYING TO HELP YOU. ) Monarchs can get lost easily if there in a building pretty crazy huh plus if the monarch caterpillars eat Tropical Milkweed it would be a 100% percent chance that the butterfly won't get to Mexico or Canada with the other Monarchs butterflies. So please switch your tropical milkweed and grow the native milkweeds and like i said it before I'm trying to help you save the monarchs. And yes i have researched them for 8 years now.
I remember raising Monarch caterpillars...they demolished the whole milkweed plant, and my dad had to get some more. We had about sixty caterpillars total. Once they started becoming sluggish, I knew they would be leaving their host plant to find a place for their beautiful jade chrysalis!
@@natureatyourdoor it really is!!! And more amazing is how beautiful their chrysalis is!! Jade with gold ornamentation!! And what goes on inside that chrysalis....one time I was with my dad on a furniture job he was doing...and underneath the overhang of the house were about 18 Mourning Cloak chrysalis'. We cut them from the silk they had spun and put them in a screened in box my dad had made that was about two feet wide and five feet tall. Each chrysalis was hanging from a chrysalis tree, and eventually they began to emerge and we let them go and watch them fly away. I used to love butterfly hunting with my dad on Saturdays, and one time while we were out hunting we came across a plant with buckeye caterpillars. We dug up the plant and replanted it at home and watched their life cycle. It's amazing and also how they knew when it's time to pupate, and leave their host plant. I do remember my aunt growing parsley which the Eastern Swallowtail caterpillars love, and sure enough, they started laying eggs. As you know, if disturbed, the swallowtail caterpillars will show false horns and emit a very offensive odor.
First visit. Greetings from S.W. Ontario Canada🍁. My friend and her granddaughter just gifted me my first caterpillar🐛. I'm enjoying learning about this miracle💚 of nature.
Now that you broke the leaves that hold the monarch eggs you have essentially separated the monarch eggs from the milkweed plants so how would you expect the baby monarch to survive when it is hatched since they no longer have the milkweed plant to live off of? How would you put the leaves that hold the monarch eggs back to the plants if you want to?
? These eggs were collected for me to take responsibility to provide under controlled conditions protected from parasites and reared to maturity and tagged to contribute to research. Have you seen my other monarch videos...re:rearing?
This year there are a lot of lizards around, and I am pretty sure they are eating the caterpillars. I have different types of milkweed and I am noticing the eggs... wonder if I should harvest them and try to help them out. I live in Florida.
Such an informative video thank you. what do you do with the leaf and egg after you pick them with the eggs on there my wife is so excited about finding some in the yard she is a butterfly junkie. but doesn't want anything to happen to them so they're still on the plant
I have one chrysalis one caterpillar going into a chrysalis and six caterpillars in all different stages. Been doing it for four years. Love it love your video Howell Michigan.
I’ve raised several monarchs from egg stage over the seasons. I started with my daughters (homeschool project) and I have continued to raise at least a few per season. Today as I was leaving my home, I saw a monarch just hanging out on the milkweed by the mailbox front garden. It looked to be trying to lay an egg, but not on the underside, so that was the first weird thing. And it stayed there for so many minutes that I could not stay to watch. I came home 30 minutes later and I could not find an egg. I thought a monarch lays an egg rather quickly..and always on the underside…??? I’m not sure what to make of that.
Hello I live in central Florida and found a monarch caterpillar near my milkweed a hurricane was coming so I thought I'd bring it inside to give it a better chance at surviving.It's made it chrysalis already so when it emerges will it migrate to Mexico or stay in Florida? Thank you.
Hello again my monarch butterfly emerged and I released her.I think it's a female.Will she stay close to our yard or go someplace else? Because she was hanging around our yard for hours but now I can't find her.Thank you.
Thank you for your video! Thanks to you I just went out and found 3 eggs on my milkweed plant! I did not realize they were so small. So now on to start watching them transform. Thank you!
That is awesome. I spend hours and hours watching J-larva hanging trying to capture that exact moment. Its in one of the videos in my Monarch playlist....I barely saw it happen. When they are ready it happens really fast!
Hi Marbles6346! Yes, possible mistaken ID. The leaves often, in affect, "bleed" a tiny drop of sap that at first glance look like a egg and have same size and color. These often catch my eye and I have to take a closer look. If you can look at them with a magnifying glass ...see if they come to point at tip and have vertical lines or striations. A sap bubble will just be smooth and round! If you can take a close up photo you can share with me on my NAYD Facebook page under a tab called "visitor posts". Let me know what you see after closer examination!
Just found a monarch caterpillar! I have a crap ton of honey vine milkweed all over my deck and some of it wound it's way around some sunflowers where I spotted one by accident. I found some caterpillars eating my sunflower leaves as well. Only reason I know what some of my plants are is that I downloaded an identification app. It seems like monarchs love milkweed when I did some researching. I feel bad because I just pulled some out. If I find any eggs or another caterpillar on the vines I just pulled out what do I do?
Just lay the leaves or vine on the milkweed you ID d...if eggs or loose leaves you can wrap some string or green gardening tie wire! (Sorry for late reply..i missed to many comments and not sure why ! Apologies)
Yes. The female will lay eggs but only on milkweed. The one you found is likely to be a migratory..and exhausted butterfly, provide nectar rich flowers or an orange slice and see if it can refuel and get on its way!
I keep seeing a monarch caterpillar every year on my milkweed they eat all the leaves and then disappear. I never see a cocoon or butterfly. I can’t figure out why.
Probably by the time you read this reply they will have already hatched. They hatch within 3 days. Keep leaves/eggs from exposure to direct sunlight! And let me know if the hatch successfully! Keep me posted! (Sorry for late reply I am currently climbing in Switzerland! ) lol..see my swiss playlist!
Monarch caterpillars have a unique MO for getting partially around the toxins in Milkweed by severing veins. Early instars will cut a Crescent in the leaf, as it cuts all the veination around where it intends to eat. ( C is for caterpillar) Bigger cats will chew thru half the petiole or rachis and then go to town on the leaf from the tip back.
I was just reading about them this week...i mention them in tomorrow's episode in milkweed bugs. The article I read ..said to...crush them with your fingers! Ack! Well...you can't spray them right. I have actually done that with classroom monarchs...depending on how many colonies you have...it works. They are tecnically invasive oleander aphids. Good luck. Keep me posted on how that works out for you.
Wow! That would be most awesome and amazing. For that volume I do not know where to begin. But...please keep in touch and keep mrup to date on sources, effort, plan and results!! 🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀👍👍👍👍👍💪💪💪💪💪
For about 4 daysI lost all my plants outside and when I came back to look at my milkweed there was tons of eggs on it and they were three monarch caterpillars on it and then my other one there were three? more caterpillars on my other milkweed but the bad news is one of them died in my other full milkweed they all just died somehow😢
Yeah one of them is dying but I'm trying to bring it back to life or I can just give it give it to my grandpa cuz he's really good at taking care of plants so I was going to give it to him and so probably will come back to life
@@natureatyourdoor It happened on my phone but not on the tablet so could have been a glitch on the phone. So sorry for the error and thx for posting the video! Grand daughters and I have raised some monarchs a few summers now and so rewarding❤️
I watched all your videos on monarchs and appreciate them. Thank you. One of my fifth instar caterpillars keeps circling the top of a fine mesh cage. It does not seem to settle on a place to spin. I sewed a smooth stick across the top of the cage, but that has not helped. He has a lot of energy but seems unsettled. Thanks again for any help.
Hi Jane Bowers! That is not unusual at all....when we reared hundreds in the classroom we would have escapees travel great distances to find the just right spot for them to pupate! In human non-science terms...think about it...you pick the safest spot you can...with just right light and humidity and protection...and once you start to Pilate..there is no changing your mind! You are stuck there ...with no ability to move or escape for ten or 12 days! You better pick right spot! Stress right? Hard to decide! But...one could but that in evolutionary-based, survival of fittest terms as well!
I would think not...if they are "holding tight" ...mostlikely tied themselves down with silk. I understand your concern but with the soft brush you should have favorable results! Just be gentle.
I think i have traveled back to 1985 to biology class, what an amazing teacher you were then and now! I love sharing these with my kids. ~ Sarah (Templeman) Smith 🦋🦋🦋
Thanks for checking in Sarah! Thanks for kind words! Nothing means more to me, is more humbling then when I hear the children of my former students are learning From me too! ...and grand kids now too! Ha!
(I'M NOT MONOPOLIZING PLEASE BE OPEN MINIDED I'M TRYING TO HELP YOU. ) Monarchs can get lost easily if there in a building pretty crazy huh plus if the monarch caterpillars eat Tropical Milkweed it would be a 100% percent chance that the butterfly won't get to Mexico or Canada with the other Monarchs butterflies. So please switch your tropical milkweed and grow the native milkweeds and like i said it before I'm trying to help you save the monarchs. And yes i have researched them for 8 years now.
Good question! Monarchs lay one egg per plant because one milkweed plant is barely enough food for caterpillar to reach maturity. Tent caterpillars for example feed on cherry trees. They can put all their eggs in one place because lots of leaves in tree.
@@natureatyourdoor I have 3 varieties of asclepias growing, no pesticides, all native to Ohio. I check for eggs every day, I planted double this year (including the plants that returned from last year) so I am hoping for good show! 5.1 hectares roosted in Mexico last year so I am hoping for a good show this year. Each time I travel to TN I toss seeds on the ground and scratch them in near creeks and such. I bought 7 microsopes (used) to donate them to our wildflower garden and create a class for kids and adults. My plants are close to blooming right now, I expect females to lay in late June - July. I released the last batch August 11th through August 18th last year!
@@Dobviews hey Appalachian girl designs! I am impresed both with your knowledge and efforts! If more people were like you.... So glad to,make your acquaintance!
@@natureatyourdoor You would have gotten a kick out of me last summer. I turned into entomology geek chic girl on Monarchs last year. I got a chance to meet my neighbors and show the kids the beauty of nature and monarchs. I am holding a mini class this year with 14 signed up. We spent all last year planting asclepias all over our city. Can't wait to see how things go this year. *I've gone buggy!* lol 🐛🦋
I don't have any specific recommendation. Roots/rhizomes can be dug from fields or roadsides with permission from land owners. Perhaps your local nursery has some native milkweed that are great for monarchs and look great in your garden!
You can take leaf with eggs on it and place it between the leaf and stem of a milkweed in another patch. Eggs hatch in 3 days..or you can gently move newly hatched larva with a soft water color paint brush on to another milkweed plant! 😃🍀!
Check out link I sent you for DIY bug box! The key is ventilation..alternatively you can take any container and put cheese cloth over the top with a rubber band!
This is awesome! Thank you. I’m starting a bug unit study with my 4 year old and we would LOVE to do this. So right now is a good time to find them?? I’m in San Antonio, TX. Boy, I need to study up more!
This is awesome! You might even want to invest in a butterfly net! I just tagged my first monarch...and he is headed your way! The entire east coast population all the way from Maine and Canada will funnel through Texas on,their way to Mex. As well,as Midwest monarchs! Exciting for me to have a Texas connection. You will have to TELL ME!! if they are egg laying right now! Keep in touch...keep me posted!
Frank Taylor So cool! Okay, we will start looking for eggs this week and get a net also. I will definitely keep you posted! Thanks for teaching us how to find them 😊
@@jamiesjabber5333 let me know how it goes...within a week,will have a Insta and FB platform up,where we can share more easily..including photos..write me anytime! Btw..i summited Guadeloupe mountain a couplo years ago! 😉
