Тёмный

How to Respond to Critical Reviews 

Scientific Writing with Karen L. McKee
Подписаться 15 тыс.
Просмотров 5 тыс.
50% 1

Peer review can be a stressful process for scientific authors. How should you respond to reviewer criticisms? What if a reviewer personally attacks you or makes unfounded statements about your paper? How you respond can determine the final outcome of the review process. In this video, I offer five tips on how to respond to reviewer comments and how to prepare a reconciliation document to accompany your revised manuscript. I specifically address the situation in which a paper has been provisionally accepted with major revision or has been rejected but invited for resubmission after revision.
If you liked this video, you may also enjoy these videos:
8 Ways Your Scientific Writing Will Annoy Reviewers: • 8 Ways Your Scientific...
How to Write a Scientific Paper When You Have Negative Results: • How to Write a Scienti...
If you use video in your research or would like to make a video about your research, check out my other RU-vid channel, The Scientist Videographer: / sciencevideography
Follow me on Twitter: @SciWri_KLMcKee

Наука

Опубликовано:

 

20 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 16   
@user-gk6kg4yw6w
@user-gk6kg4yw6w 3 года назад
I've always responded to reviewers' efforts by simply saying, "Thank you for pointing it out" or "We appreciate your opinion". But you gave me different ways to show gratitude to reviewers. Thank you for your insight.
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK 3 года назад
Thanks for commenting.
@penncollins4963
@penncollins4963 3 года назад
Thanks a lot. just received a decision from my journal: accept with major revisions and it is overwhelmingly not easy to go about it. and to add to that, the reviewers only gave me a week to finish it. I got no choice but to do my best to get it done. your video helps alot.
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK 3 года назад
Good luck! Glad my video helped.
@penncollins4963
@penncollins4963 3 года назад
@@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK Thanks so much! Love your videos and I'm currently watching other videos on your channel...
@sidhuraosurya8751
@sidhuraosurya8751 5 месяцев назад
Your video really helps. Thank you so much!
@nasseralhajj6806
@nasseralhajj6806 3 года назад
Thank you very much!!! Very helpful points, I am preparing my revision these days, and your explanations made my day.
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK 3 года назад
Best of luck!
@nassimayahiaoui448
@nassimayahiaoui448 3 года назад
Thanks, i’m preparing my revision (MR) and your video make me less stressful as i know how to deal with it now as it should to be. Regards.
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK 3 года назад
Glad it helped!
@chiragboghani
@chiragboghani 3 года назад
Stress reliever advise 👍
@xiangli1133
@xiangli1133 2 года назад
Thanks
@scarlet113
@scarlet113 3 года назад
Dear Karen, Do you also have a video on how to write critical reviews in the process of being an (anonymous) reviewer for the peer review process? There are guidelines by the journals, but it would be still valuable if you could share your experience as a reviewer.
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK 3 года назад
Thanks for the suggestion. It’s on my to do list.
@sheminjohn123
@sheminjohn123 3 года назад
Thanks
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK
@ScientificWritingwithKarenLMcK 3 года назад
Glad you liked it.
Далее
What Do Journal Editors Want?
3:58
Просмотров 2 тыс.
How to Conduct a Scientific Peer Review
11:53
Просмотров 3,7 тыс.
His reaction 😳 (via @kaitlyn.b0506/TT) #shorts
00:10
ПОЮ НАРОДНЫЕ ПЕСНИ🪗
3:19:41
Просмотров 1,8 млн
How to Respond to Reviewers | Research Paper
13:38
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.
Resubmit your article to a journal
9:05
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.
Responding to Reviewer Comments
27:02
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.
Common Writing Mistakes in Scientific Papers
12:28
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.
$1 vs $100,000 Slow Motion Camera!
0:44
Просмотров 24 млн