These uninformed panelist are unaware of the underlying problem why so many youth coming to F&O segment. The reason is, in India, there are hardly any job opportunities available for such high youth population. On top of that, the quality of jobs is horrendous at so many places. Youth see F&O as a only source of income where they are responsible for their own success rather than facing rejection each day from some XYZ HR of a company. Government should address unemployment rather than put guardrails on trading. Its like giving a medicine for stomach ache when someone is suffering from headache.
As SEBI chair has suggested F&O is becoming a macro issue with 60000 crore of household savings being lost, I would like to point out... According to this logic she should float a proposal to ban all competitions exams as.. For example in UPSC Around 10L aspirant fill form 5L appear for exam For which let's assume they take coaching investing around 2L as fees So 5,00,000 X 2,00,000= 100,000,000,000 ₹ of household savings are "lost" as only 1000 candidates will be selected!! P.S. I'm not accounting for opportunity cost of other exams ( CAT, NEET, JEE, NET & Others combined!!
This year may be worse. Last year I lost a lot of money due to poor investing decisions that I would not have made if I hadn't been so concerned about my portfolio. I wasn't sure whether to continue investing or make mortgage payments. After selling my investments, I realized that the house needed more work than I anticipated. I'm not sure how long I can keep going like this
To diversify your portfolio, invest in companies with observable cash flows. I've earned money in over 500 different markets in the previous 10 months since I employed a planner to help me strengthen my portfolio at the end of 2023. If 2023 teaches us anything, it's that good fortune is temporary. Even in good times, we should put in more effort to prepare for the worst case scenario
Okay how can one locate a reputable financial planner? I wouldn't mind searching the professional who served you. I'll be retiring in two years and may require some assistance managing my considerably larger assets. Don't want to take chances
SEBI SAID "macro" problem , 50-60 thousand crore lost by retailer in options,come on options is zero sum game so someone is earning and atleast government is earning
Agreed, major chunk of the meat goes to the government and brokers due to stt and other charges. Also in trading, it has been a story of decades that only 4-5% make good money all other loses it, what's new in that? It's just that they need to remove these daily expiries launched in the past year. Just Nifty and BankNifty were good enough. Same has been the case in the USA markets, its not that everyone is making money in 0 dtes there, but there are no such regulations. There is only 1 major index. The launch of more and more expiries were the major trouble.
It will help if the panel develops the art of listening before responding. Two of the panelists are ‘hearing’ only with the intention of responding. Do watch Simon Sinek talk on art of listening
Problem is SEBI looks only at F&O, they should look at total returns of Retail in all equity assets. Most retail loose because they hedge their cash positions. So 50k F&O loss is setoff by 2 lakh of cash profits.
The thought should be risk management and not who is making profit or loss. Any leverage creates issues for people who do not know how to manage them. Educating people is a good move but the current exposures require immediate attention which must be handled by increasing margin etc.
How does a kid learn to walk ? Should parents not allow him to try to walk out of the fear he might get injured or he is falling too much.. Everyone comes in a business makes some mistakes learn and make it a profitable business thats the truth sebi must know..
SEBI itself said that 70% retail investors lose money in cash market.Now this media crazy SEBI chairman would come up with new law that if a retail investor want to buy shares worth Rs 10000,he has to deposit Rs 100000 as margin.She would even say that this new rule is to save retail investor.Never heard or seen such BS lady.
SEBI is talking only about people loosing only in F&O. But SEBI is not talking of people loosing money on investing. Is there any stats on long term investing. I believe people are loosing more money on investing than F&O. Only institutions are making money.
My point is how many retail traders are defaulter on paying bank loan, you will hardly find few , how many big corporate players default their loan you will find more, bottom of the story is they dont want to educate you how to trade future and option, they dont want to make learning compulsory they are just interested in making things difficult. Has any retailer complain about losing money in option? all they are interested is in gathering TAX , TAX , TAX , TAX ... We are not far from day when there will be Oxygen tax, you are breathing oxygen so have to pay TAX
Politically this will hurt very very badly in elections if ministry allows SEBI to go forward with this and destroy the whole ecosystem of Retail FNO. There are ex presidents in other countries who has become pro Crypto and what are we doing in our country ?
First reduce margin attract small retailers to pump in funds ..squeeze everything ,, as Sebi's statement says 80 percent retailers loose .. now they kicking them out😅
what will SEBI do if retail shifts to commodity trading? Billions of rupees is lost in lottery tickets every year and this money goes out of the pockets of the poorest section of the society.
The lady in the black suit doesn't understand that getting spam calls is a fraud and has nothing to do with F&O trading. It's clear that the two on the anchors right side are clueless and probably are failed traders themselves. It's sour grapes for them.
The problem is that these 9-5 a day journos cannot digest the fact that people can earn money by sitting at their home and not being a naukar of anyone
Next, regulator will tell you what stock to buy and when you should book your profit. Wow, They are the guardian angel. They care so much about our money....awwww !!! 🤗
So if a 18 years plus doesn't know what to do with his/her money, how do you thing it is justified they are allowed to vote to decide who runs the country... simple rule - my money my decision.. I win or I loose I am solely responsible.
India se achha to pakistan he woha pe currency market start he abki baar BJP ko vote to her kiss nai dungaa.....All retailer trader are angry on BJP... this time 120 instead of 320 seat........
For first 2 years we lose money and learn from it for that we trade with small capital, you people doesn't know the process and keeps changing the rules its disgrace no more vote for bjp this government doesn't care about middle class people
The gentleman on the left said people trading in fno are putting market at risk!Haven't heard of a more stupid argument.. In 2008 crash how many people were doing FnO? Still people lost huge sums of money in equity.
We are not live in Foreign so w can talk in HIndi dear please try to speak in Hindi atleast in India so many people can understand whats your saying and giving information to all the People.
