Тёмный

HubChat: Is Bangernomics Doomed? 

Подписаться
Просмотров 32 тыс.
% 2 358

It's tough old time for the concept of Bangernomics. Are the glory times over? What are your thoughts?
Delightful HubNut goodies can be purchased at hubnut.org
Or, support HubNut at patreon.com/hubnut or via Channel memberships: ru-vid.com/show-UCfxlBQnvNXX6o-2KbCMszWQjoin
Want to help Hubnut for free? Don't forget to like the video if you like it, and share with your friends if you really like it! Thank you all.

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

 

10 янв 2023

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 734   
@bordersw1239
@bordersw1239 Год назад
20 years ago I had a mate who was designing ECUs for multiple manufacturers. Each had their own standards for how many years the ECU should last on average. He drove a battered old sierra. I asked him why a guy with such a well payed job drove a battered old car, his answer “it’s the last car made without an ECU”. 😂
@FFVoyager
@FFVoyager Год назад
You can fix ECUs. Or rather, you can get them fixed.
@Markcain268
@Markcain268 Год назад
@@FFVoyager I had to buy a used one for a MK2 cavalier Sri, £600, actually more than the car was worth lol
@erik_dk842
@erik_dk842 Год назад
With a carburettor you can enjoy poor running from new and guaranteed after 100,000 km.
@Markcain268
@Markcain268 Год назад
@@erik_dk842 unless you know how to keep your car in tune, I really miss those Sunday afternoons playing with a twin choke Weber on my manta, I bought a gasket set for it for a few quid and it ran like a dream afterwards, very satisfying and easy work, I could do it all day long lol
@volvo480
@volvo480 Год назад
I have 30+ year old cars with ECUs. If they fail I can replace them with Megasquirt or Megajolt and to be honest, I've never seen one fail except when someone reversed the connections. It starts becoming problematic when the computers in the car are linked and locked with VIN numbers, then it becomes impossible to change them without intervention of a dealer.
@100SteveB
@100SteveB Год назад
A subject dear to my heart. I have been driving since 1987 and have always had cheap to buy used cars. They may have been cheap to buy, but they were damned good cars. My current car - a mk2 Mondeo saloon, I have had for 15 years, and to be honest, I don't think i want to change it for something newer, my old mondeo is reliable, and comfortable, and with very little in the way of fancy electronics to go wrong. Just a short few years after my car was built in 1997 vehicles started to become complicated, with numerous can bus modules that can be prone to failure. Modern cars can have over a dozen such modules, and failure of one can bring the whole car down. And manufacturers are trending towards not supporting them after they are just a few years old. I see so many instances on channels like PineAuto diagnostics where new modules are simply no longer available after 5 years or so. So your left having to find one second-hand, and with many of the modules you need to program them to the car. On top of that, so much under the bonnet these days is made of plastic that goes brittle after a few years. Manufacturers these days seem to be building in obsolescence, basically expecting the car to only last a few years. I myself am lucky, I have my own workshop with car lift, welder, compressed air etc. I also have my own spraying equipment. So i am set to keep my car on the road for as long as I like, or as long until the government stop me. I also have a cupboard full of spares that will keep the car going - common items like suspension components, coil packs, and those pesky vacuum heater controls. And if you think the demise of bangernomics is gaining speed now, just wait until electric pretty much takes over. You will not be buying a cheap electric car for under £1000 that is going to be worth having, the battery packs will be knackered, which will cost you ten times or more you paid for the car to replace. Yes, you might find a cheap electric car in the future, but you will be stopping every few miles to charge it - to whatever capacity the packs have left in them. I spoke to my MP about how all of this is going to effect low income families - her answer? You can lease an electric car for as little as £250 per month! That is £3000 per year. That simply does not compare to the days of bangernomics where you could buy a decent car for less than £1000 and get a few years reliable use out of it. I can see many low income families being forced off of the road, the gap between the rich and poor growing even more. And, with the price of electricity these days, EV's are not so cheap to run after all. I know I take keeping my used car to the extreme, but in the 15 years I have had my car, I have known plenty of people that have bought 7 or more either new, or nearly new cars in that time. I wonder who's carbon footprint is the bigger? Anyway, I totally agree Ian, the days of cheap motoring are fading, I myself am grateful to have spent so much of life in a time where cheap motoring was easily possible. Not so sure that will apply for my grandchildren, I have a feeling they will be paying a few hundred ££ per month to lease a car, and that will no doubt be a car that is only designed to last a few years. For me, I am keeping the Mondeo, it may be 26 years old now, and they were everywhere when i bought it 15 years back, but your hard pushed to see any nowadays, it's getting to the point where people stop and talk to me at petrol stations about the car. It appears to be turning into somewhat of a modern classic. I think i have talked myself into the challenge of keeping it on the road for the rest of my driving life!
@briansturrock2041
@briansturrock2041 Год назад
Agreed with you absolutely there, my own motor is now 30yrs old (sierra) owned same time as yourself, however 2 things you don't mention is the road tax £285, and the fuel consumption is not great at 35mpg,
@DoubleZeroGarage
@DoubleZeroGarage Год назад
I agree, I have 2 American cars that do about 10mpg, I’ve always had a cheap shed to run around in as well, I’m actually currently looking for one so I don’t ruin my other cars with salt on the roads. It used to take a few hours to find an old car to run around in, I’ve been looking for about a fortnight now and still not found anything worth having, the last dozen or so I’ve checked the MOT history on have had advisories for rusty brake pipes for between 4 and 6 years, all now showing as brake pipes covered in grease! People in general just refuse to accept that advisories still need fixing and just don’t care enough anymore about keeping a car safe and legal, they’d rather advertise it with a covered number plate so you can’t check the MOT history
@100SteveB
@100SteveB Год назад
@@briansturrock2041 Talking of road tax, makes you wonder how long EV's will be road tax free? At the moment the government are dangling the carrot in front of the donkey so to speak - to encourage us to change, but can the government afford to lose both fuel duty and road tax in the future?I can see something like 'pay to use' roads coming soon, they are going to want their money from somewhere.
@cornishhh
@cornishhh Год назад
"You will own nothing and be happy"
@cornishhh
@cornishhh Год назад
@@100SteveB If nothing else EV's tend to be heavier so wear out the roads faster. The main cost is public charging facilities which someone will have to pay for to make EV's viable.
@TMxl-w5t
@TMxl-w5t Год назад
I'm amazed, how few people have any mechanical skills at all, i.e. people waiting for breakdown companies just to change a flat tyre... I started repairs at around 14 (with absolutely no idea at all, what I was doing), repairing my dads lawnmower, then moved on to mopeds, motorbikes, cars etc. it was the only way we, at the time could afford to have our own transport.. with the internet/RU-vid, things are much easier to learn how to repair things... now I've reached the grand old age of 65.. sadly COPD, has now ended me fixing much at all.. Cheers 👍
@elelegidosf9707
@elelegidosf9707 Год назад
The under-£500 car used to be a staple of the UK car market, but it's definitely disappearing fast. It's because of a combination of bonkers car inflation lifting the bangers out of the bracket (a £500 car is now a £1,000 to £1,500 car) and the increase in scrap values, as you say.
@carldavies4662
@carldavies4662 Год назад
exactly as I was going to say. Iv been in the sub £1k price point for many years and have usually ran each car for 3 years+, amongst a pool of cars I am working on and alternating between SORN and taxed. it worked well when I was living at our Farm in France with barns and 100m driveway, but is a bit tight at our Durham terraced...I must get back to France to start bringing back the collection as some of them are worth far more now than I paid. I wouldnt say Bangernomics is dead, its just changed a little, as the right cars are worth dropping a few quid into and hanging onto.
@FFVoyager
@FFVoyager Год назад
But the 'bonkers inflation' works on the cars too. I bought a decent enough 9 year old Rover 75 diesel for £1100 back in 2009. That would be be equivalent to £1800 today. My first car was a really tatty £80 2CV in 1981 and that would be equivalent to about £500 car today!
@simes205
@simes205 Год назад
Plus ULEZ
@elelegidosf9707
@elelegidosf9707 Год назад
@@simes205 ULEZ pushes values down, too. After the first ULEZ expansion I picked up a non-ULEZ K11 Micra in London for £410. I drove it a few months and then sold it for £850 outside London. As Miss Hubnut says, there's going to be money to be made buying cheap ULEZ disposals there and reselling them in the country.
@robertmaitland09
@robertmaitland09 Год назад
My Starlet is 25 years old this year. Bought it for £500 4 years ago, it's my only car. I've done 30K miles in it and use it for work, shops, days out and camping trips. It is amazingly well made, easy to maintain and returns 50mpg. I don't think I'd find another one below a grand as they are becoming collectable.
@reverendbarker650
@reverendbarker650 Год назад
We used to have one, pretty good car overall, to compare , my sons 2017 Corolla had to have a replacement rear wheel bearing , failed at 70,000 kms, out of warranty, cost $700 au !!
@erik_dk842
@erik_dk842 Год назад
@@reverendbarker650 You didn't shop around for a better price? I can't imagine it's rocket science to replace. Edit: Looked it up. It's an old fashioned separate press fit bearing with a US list price of $75. ANY mechanic could replace it in less than an hour. My Skoda uses bolt on bearing assemblies that I have replaced in my driveway using a jack and axle stands
@reverendbarker650
@reverendbarker650 Год назад
@@erik_dk842 I don't do car repairs any more , no tools or inclination to do it,my necks stuffed ,i have carpal tunnel on my wrists, I'm not up to it. As for the bearing, that's the price the Toyota dealer quoted my son and I said at the time it seemed pricey, but he didn't look anywhere else as far as I know, like most people nowadays he doesn't do car repairs, as he has no tools or skills to do it. . From memory it was a rear wheel bearing but it might have been more then that, could have included the hub, which is pretty pricey, its about $400 . the last bearing I had go was a Nissan bluebird many years ago and I was only charged $50 to replace it, used to work on my old Holden and it was simple job to do myself but as I say , I cant be bothered anymore, i just buy newer cars which don't break down anywhere near as much as the old ones did, I've had Mitsubishis for the last 12 years from new and neither of them has had a single thing go wrong with them , unlike the Nissan which was always breaking down
@ep1929
@ep1929 11 месяцев назад
​@@reverendbarker650I'd expect cars last longer down under as the rust problem won't be as bad. The British winter plays havoc with the underbody of many cars because of all the salt that's put down on the roads.
@martindooley4439
@martindooley4439 Год назад
Love this. In 1987 I wrote my degree dissertation on Automotive Electronics. Applications and Implications. I cited improved efficiency performance and safety would come at the expense of end of life owners and home maintenance. I was right 😊😊 eh 😉
@RetroRich2000
@RetroRich2000 Год назад
I inherited my Dad's 2010 Kia Rio2 a few years back, with only 20300 on the clock, it now has a little over 26500. I've been tempted to sell it, as it's a rather lacklustre 1.4 auto, but it's just so damn reliable!
@alarmactionukalarmactionuk893
Keep it!!
@paulwatts2192
@paulwatts2192 Год назад
When I passed my test back in 1979 my first car mine was a second hand Hillman Avenger easy to work on. All you need is a Tool box. New cars you need a computer to plug it in.
@ebutuoyYT
@ebutuoyYT Год назад
The look Miss HubNut gave Mr HubNut, when Ian mentioned scrapping the Charade could have frozen a polar bear's dangly bits 😀
@CortinasAndClassics
@CortinasAndClassics Год назад
the scrappage scheme has a lot to answer for. I was lucky to get my Rover 75 in 2019 for £250.
@gotham61
@gotham61 Год назад
Spot on discussion. Same basic thing here in the USA. New cars today are considered disposable, and fail in ways that are uneconomical to fix. I tend to go for cars which are a little older, and lately have been holding on to them as daily drivers for much longer, putting money into them as needed. Specifically, I have focused on 1980s-early 90s W123 and W124 Mercedes Diesels. Extremely durable, and will keep going for as long as you are willing to keep fixing problems as they come up. They have no fancy electronics to go wrong. At least twice recently I have spent more of repairing problems than the purchase price of the car, but it's still much cheaper than flipping through newer cars.
@martinneumann7783
@martinneumann7783 Год назад
Speaking of bangernomics: I'll pick up my sweet 2008 Citroën C1 from my trusted garage tomorrow. One sill was ill and had to be welded. I'm curious what this will cost again... Like every car that I did own, I want to keep the C1 running as long as possible. Fortunately I don't need her daily; I'm cycling to work. Have a good time everybody and always a nice trip. Cheers - Martin/Germany
@AnthonyBrown-jm4rj
@AnthonyBrown-jm4rj Год назад
Ian - 100% agree with your comments. Carol our austerity Corsa C is knocking on the door of 20 years old. Probably not worth much more than a few hundred quid. But there is no rot and it’s only done 75k miles. I’m happy to keep spending a few hundred per year to keep up the MoT. Taught two kids to drive and the clutch is original. Modern enough for me. Keep up the good work and keep driving the cars you love….
@660einzylinder
@660einzylinder Год назад
Bangernomics can work if you A) have access to reasonable tools/equipment if you need it, B) are fairly well versed at working on frustratingly awkward cars, C) tend to stick with one make/model and learn the wrinkles. The list could go on, but you get the idea. You are spot on regarding public transport. I live in the very rural Fens. We have a bus service to the village, the first bus leaves for the town in one direction just after 9am, the last bus arrives in the village at about 4.30pm, so not much use for getting people to mainstream jobs. There is no bus to the town in the other direction at all. Scrappage and ULEZ has/will undoubtedly see the loss of some decent cars, and ULEZ type schemes are becoming more widespread. I recently swapped a C3 for a Maestro, partly for the ease of maintenance. I suspect this debate will rumble on, and on, and on...rather like some of the better bangers!
@Toby_the_Glen
@Toby_the_Glen Год назад
As the 'take up' for EV's continues over the next 10 yrs (good or bad, right or wrong?) 'older' fossil fuel cars will feel the lack of support. It doesn't matter where you live , your car needs VED and insurance and MOT. That's how they'll get you, regardless of how expert your maintenance skills, or how cheap and basic your car? The powers that be want these old cars off the road. In Japan, for example, they have a system where the older the vehicle becomes the tougher the MOT becomes, just to apply more leverage to owners to buy new. Not forgetting the used car market will be turned on its roof. When only EV's are available to buy, who in their right mind wants a 10yr old Tesla? And finally, batteries.......?
@mukkinfuddle
@mukkinfuddle Год назад
Purchased a 1999 K11 Micra for 700 quid 3 months ago, 36,000 miles and in beautiful condition all documented, spent an age sourcing it, with prices ranging from a grand to two and a half grand, absolutely nuts, there are still some bargains out there but you have to be in the right place at the right time, taking it to TFOE in July and very much looking forward to it.
@williamross2579
@williamross2579 Год назад
Its why I drive a Morris Minor, literal simplicity, plus, ok parts have gone up, but it is still economical to keep it going compared to modern (last 20 years).
@hunchanchoc8418
@hunchanchoc8418 Год назад
Spot on, sir. :-)
@sim6699
@sim6699 Год назад
I've gone older too because modern cars are so awful
@paulnicholas9436
@paulnicholas9436 Год назад
Got to admit I scrapped my old 2006 4x4 before Christmas still with MOT got over £400, down to long term cost of repairs. I did own it for over 5 years. I know a retired mechanic and when we talk it's always comes down to late 80's and 90's cars are always the best.
@ianrobertson2634
@ianrobertson2634 Год назад
The other issue is high cost of brand new cars having a triple down effect. I paid £14k for my new Fabia 5 years ago, the same car now is over 20k. I am just keeping my Fabia for as longs as I still need a car. I have no intention of replacing it and I think a lot people are keeping their cars longer too.
@scottishcarenthusiastsandtrain
Same, we bought our Fabia new five years ago and we have no reason to get rid of it, we will run it into the ground as no intention of getting rid as nothing in the current Skoda range appeals and prices of the same spec fabia are more than I paid new.
@clivet3252
@clivet3252 Год назад
The problem with keeping your car longer now is that the older it gets and the higher the mileage gets, the harder it is to bridge the gap if you want to replace it.
@nickwilliams1108
@nickwilliams1108 Год назад
I love the relative simplicity of the Aygo mk1 I recently bought for my daughter to learn to drive, though I did pay more than I would have a year ago…
@erik_dk842
@erik_dk842 Год назад
That's why it makes sense to pay more for an Aygo or it's siblings then something like a Chevrolet or Kia of similar size or slightly larger
@adzib1823
@adzib1823 Год назад
Agreed, my girlfriend recently passed and has a 107. French jokes aside, they really aren't bad cars: good engines, good parts availability, and excellent economy. They're kind of the most modern iteration of 'an engine and 4 wheels', and all the better for it. I know my mother also had an almost new C1 from 2006 until only a couple of years back and clocked up 120k miles or so, without any real issues at all - I think the only thing she mentioned was using a lot of oil towards the end of its 'life' (probably just a clogged PCV valve which can be cleaned in about 30 mins, if that).
@ebutuoyYT
@ebutuoyYT Год назад
Changes to the MOT have not helped, as if the engine warning light is on, it's now classed as a major fault. Combine this with tyre pressure monitoring systems, fitted to newer cars, which often become faulty, means you can fail an MOT, for a part that is hardly a critical safety issue, but is expensive to fix = Blood Boiling.
@PC3Pointless
@PC3Pointless Год назад
@yossarian Including many MOT testers so lots of people are wrongly getting failed MOTs when it doesn't apply. I'm not saying an EML shouldn't be investigated but so long as its still passing emissions an EML isn't a safety issue on an older vehicle.
@adzib1823
@adzib1823 Год назад
@yossarian Thanks for that, I didn't know of that fact until reading your post just now, I'll have a look into it.
@OsellaSquadraCorse
@OsellaSquadraCorse Год назад
@@PC3Pointless Commonly not a safety issue, however.... for several makes, the "EML" is a warning light, not an EML warning, so it can also cover things like ABS modules and traction/stability control. If course, without checking the code/s in the system, there's often no way to tell.
@alarmactionukalarmactionuk893
It depends if you take your car to a genuine honest workshop that lean towards keeping you on the road and regular return business rather than a corrupt kwikfit type outfit just because theres one local.
@person.X.
@person.X. Год назад
Manufacturers can now build cars that could last more or less indefinitely for motorists doing the median annual mileage. That would kill their market so they have become very clever at building in obsolescence through unnecessary complexity, unnecessarily fragile parts (plastic) and unnecessary systems such as tyre pressure monitoring systems etc. I drive heavy trucks for a living and they basically do not wear out. Consumable wear out obviously but the key parts are designed to last for decades and millions of miles. The main cause of breakdowns is not actual mechanical parts but faulty electronic parts such as sensors.
@neildaniel8232
@neildaniel8232 Год назад
There's also another issue with the scarcity of bangers around the 15+ year mark: people think that anything that old and in reasonable nick is now a classic! Very few decent cars now drop down below the £1k mark, they seem to hover around the £1.5k area until a big bill occurs then it's either scrap it or trade it in only for the dealer to scrap it. Oh and Bristol is currently awash with LEZ rejects, they'll be for sale in the next 6 months or so when the exemption for locals expires.
@OsellaSquadraCorse
@OsellaSquadraCorse Год назад
Sellers often don't help themselves on that score: "Find another!" Ok then, I will, if you insist.... "Becoming rare" i.e I think this must be true so I'll add another £500 to the price. "I know what I have" Good for you. You'll probably be keeping it then, unsold...
@clivet3252
@clivet3252 Год назад
All the factors that used to bring down the price have gone. Instead of high mileage bringing the price down, low mileage pushes the price up massively. Age doesn't seem to be a factor anymore. Unfashionable cars are no longer cheap if the condition and mileage is good. There's not much under 2 grand on Auto Trader that I would touch.
@ChopsGarage
@ChopsGarage Год назад
1999 Toyota Camry with 225k Miles just in! Runs like a champ. 2 Owner. Bangernomics at its best (2.2 4 pot with no block issues lol!). Agree Gumtree is no longer cheap. Facebook Marketplace has replaced it in my eyes. I guess what was £500 is now £2000, so what is now £500 is pretty much was scrap/end of life previously. It does not help that the price increases seem to have private sellers thinking that they can sell at retail pricing either with zero protection or preparation. I think Mrs Hubnut is correct that the dead is now really dead eg needing a £1000 Body Control / Keys and Barrel swap. Bangernomics cannot be done with post 2005 and needs to be petrol as diesels are so overly complex now. Is it also easier now to just flog your banger to WBAC than deal with missed viewings, tyre kickers and wanabee Mike Brewers. The £100 Micra K11 Automatic is still going strong with no spend on the Homebuilt channel by the way! By the way that business exists, someone with loads of space filling it with old tat, its Chops Garage lol!!
@owensteele1645
@owensteele1645 Год назад
I love Camries. I used to see your latest Camry driving round my area quite a lot. It's "sweet as a nut".
@colinmale3331
@colinmale3331 Год назад
As a car mechanic in 2010 I bought a Renault Scenic on a V plate for £500 as a trade in. Was going to be a stop gap but continued to be our family vehicle for the next four years. I remember her fondly, really helped us financially through tough times.
@jamesdecross1035
@jamesdecross1035 Год назад
Hey, just a quick message to say I love the discussion format, and how you two bounce thoughts and ideas off each other. More of the same please! And yes, it does make me think… and lots of other people, I expect.
@jasondear8440
@jasondear8440 Год назад
A very valid and engaging chat Ian, my little Jimny barely scraped through the last MOT ! i m dreading this June as am disabled and can no longer get underneath, so its either gonna be really expensive or scrap? but what then? like others have said no longer can you get a Bangernomics car due to inflation etc etc.....I feel a mobility scooter on the horizon! Gulp!....great chat guys keep em coming!
@paulmoore6345
@paulmoore6345 Год назад
Picked up an 05 plate zafira 1.6 from a garden for £800 last July. Spent the same amount since on tyres cambelt and exhaust. But going forward it's a solid car will be good for another few years. So a good result.
@BelfastMurf
@BelfastMurf Год назад
It’s channels like yours that keep older cars out of the crusher. My 20 year old Accord cost £700 around two years ago. I might get something similar today for double that. It’s had a set of tyres, one alleged service (they didn’t change the plugs, so God knows what they actually did), the n a second service for the MOT, reconditioned ABS pump & a new wishbone. The only thing that doesn’t work is the air con which has a faulty pump. I live in Belfast, so that’s only an issue for three days every two years or so. Even better, I like the oul thing more than the few brand new cars I’ve driven. Win win. Keep the faith!
@davidpring9108
@davidpring9108 Год назад
08:21 I know what it feels like in relation to emission zones. I had to sell my perfectly reliable and cheap to maintain mk2 Clio from 2005 because it was not Euro 4 compliant. Bristol introduced a new emissions zone which meant my clio would have been subject to a £9 fee every day for my work commute, sometimes again if I was working nights £18 for nights... In the end I could not bring myself to scrap it. 41k miles on the clock. Had to finance a nearly new car.... The new car does have cheaper tax and insurance, does better MPG too, but it is a shame we are being made to give up our reliable older cars
@StevesMachines
@StevesMachines Год назад
I was offered £500 for my C4 scrap. I scrapped it as it needed a clutch at £2000. Old (Hubnut) cars are trendy again too so everything is now considered valuable.
@SPTSuperSprinter156
@SPTSuperSprinter156 Год назад
What you also have to remember is that what is considered "old" works on a constantly sliding scale. Tatty old Sierras for instance once went for 200 quid, they now go for much more... because they're older, and there are less of them. But have a look at a lot of the stuff that's currently between 15 and 20 years old, and assuming it isn't something that was rare when new, it's cheap. Things like old Astras and Corsas are practically being given away. Scrap prices rising certainly don't help; the only time I've scrapped a car in my life was when scrap was worth almost nothing - and it was touch and go whether I'd have to pay them!
@graemew7001
@graemew7001 Год назад
@@SPTSuperSprinter156 I did that 20 odd years ago with a Renault 5 and no scrap man would come and get it from further than 10 miles away and it wasn't driveable. I did get it gone but like you I thought I was going to end up paying them to collect it.
@jonathanfrankel6787
@jonathanfrankel6787 Год назад
It’s easy to take a risk on a £500 car but now that same car is £2000 , better off spending more and buying something newer with a warranty .
@Markcain268
@Markcain268 Год назад
@@jonathanfrankel6787 providing you can afford it
@StevesMachines
@StevesMachines Год назад
The cars I consider old are now realy old! I was shocked to find out the Berlingo was 25yr old. I've seen quite a few old new minis for sub £1k, smart cars too.
@Rockythefishman
@Rockythefishman Год назад
The real question should be what is “cheap” , it used to be under a grand but now it’s more like 2-3 grand now sadly. People are holding on to cars longer because they can’t afford to replace.
@jameswild3800
@jameswild3800 Год назад
Been doing it for years but now keeping them going is the priority
@jameswild3800
@jameswild3800 Год назад
And I live on Angelsey
@johnnorth9355
@johnnorth9355 Год назад
Oh yes. Never underestimate the desire of the government to get as many people as possible out of their cars (except themselves of course). The use of ULEZ zones will greatly restrict where you can economically use older cars and take a look at what is proposed for Oxford to see what other draconian legislation is in the offing.
@robertcoughlin4961
@robertcoughlin4961 Год назад
I really enjoy your videos! As part of the HubNut cultural exchange, my family is introducing HubNut-isms to Alabama - like Palaver, Bodge, Gubbins and phrases like “needs must”. In exchange we would appreciate you saying “Y’all”, referring to your eldest male child as”Bubba” and referring to good time as “high cotton”. Keep up the good work! All the best!
@annewhistleketle6350
@annewhistleketle6350 Год назад
The Netherlands is no different, same problems. 2 or 3 Years ago i bought a semi scrap 1.2 Punto of 2007 for €350,- delivered at home. Tinkered about € 800,- worth of new components ( brakes/fluids/filters/dampers and springs, etc..) in it and it is still running flawless. Fortunate that the 1.2 and 1.4 Fiat FIRE engines are still fairly simple and easy to work on with cheap new parts available everywhere. Guess this Punto is surely worth above €1000,- at the current market but i am not going to sell it, can't get such a good car for that price anywhere.
@jamescoe764
@jamescoe764 Год назад
I've always been a proponent of bangernomics, through necessity as much as choice. I now have an approach similar to yours Ian, keeping my old car running in good mechanical shape. What went wrong with my life 😂😂
@chrisfrob
@chrisfrob Год назад
What a very interesting topic. There is obviously a 'sweet spot' towards finding a vehicle where its inherent reliability and simplicity are optimised to provide a usable car at an affordable price. Looks like many 80's & 90's vehicles still appear to fit the bill!
@03timdol
@03timdol Год назад
My favourite purchase was a W reg VW Passat estate 1.8t petrol. £250 had it 4 years and took it from 150k to 197k before the engine died (oil pump died and the engine got hot and seized I think). Only real expense was a couple of hundred quid on some new exhaust and general servicing (oil and filters each year which I did myself for like £50 or something). Scrapped it for £170. Wonderful, practical and even slightly fun to drive but best of all dirt cheap motoring
@rgorham99
@rgorham99 Год назад
For clarification the London ULEZ starts from the south/north circular and from August will extend to Greater London which is roughly anywhere inside the M25. I'm in Kent so plenty of Ulez adverts about as it affects commuters in all counties around London.
@syncro16se
@syncro16se Год назад
This was a very nice and entertaining episode. 🙏⚘ Greetings from Sweden
@MeMe-qr3go
@MeMe-qr3go Год назад
Speaking of dual mass flywheels: They are a wonderful idea. It's just a shame that most of them aren't very well designed. A lot of them have flimsy inner bushes where a double row bearing should be. It's about as much use as a chocolate fire guard :)
@Mrflash222006
@Mrflash222006 Год назад
The scrappage scheme in 2009 killed the old car market plus parts for anything 15+ year is a mare to get hold of or is so expensive it’s not justifiable
@realresultstraining6061
@realresultstraining6061 Год назад
Great discussion, loved this video. Thank you!
@FrankJCarver
@FrankJCarver Год назад
My brother and his girlfriend built the models. It's nice to see them displayed.
@steve5772
@steve5772 Год назад
I've always practiced bangernomics. For the first 15 years of my life on the road, and working all over the country, the most I spent on a car was £500 (a lovely low mileage, old man-owned toyota Camry). Most of my first ones were free because it used to cost money to get a scrap car taken away. In 2020 I ended up needing an auto and ended up spending £1000 on a car with a questionable head gasket, at that point I realised bangernomics is pretty much over.
@jimmydesouza4375
@jimmydesouza4375 Год назад
Bangernomics sounds like a naughty euphemism. Also mentioning scrapping vehicles that don't have a problem, there's a trucker youtuber who I occasionally watch (KevTee), one of the main jobs he does is pick up scrap cars. He picked up a IIRC 5 year old car that was scrapped because it wouldn't start, and the reason why it wouldn't start was because the owner didn't realise you had to put the automatic gearbox in a specific gear for the car to start.
@karllelliott681
@karllelliott681 Год назад
Excellent discussion points raised by both of you on this subject. It was a very enjoyable listen this morning. I am reminded strangely of the continuous wave of historical invasions throughout our islands history, starting in the SE of the country and then forcing the local populations to relocate further north and west. Seems like the introduction of new car policy in the SE of this country today is doing the same to the existing car population - what a strange parallel methinks!
@neilthompson5217
@neilthompson5217 Год назад
I live in the north east of England and cheap cars rarely exist now , what once would have been a £200_£500 car is now in the £1000+ price bracket 'craxy'. And I think electronics stop cars from reaching old age , I own my late father's Volvo and I'd love to keep it forever but in reality the electronics and price of fixing electronic problems will make that impossible for me .
@mikes747
@mikes747 Год назад
My Peugeot partner cost me £850 just over a year ago. I think the bargains are still out there but they're harder to find. Also the more modern old stuff can be a nitemare with sensors etc failing all over the place!
@person.X.
@person.X. Год назад
Very good point about late 90s/early 00s cars. That was when cars were the best as an overall package - driveability, reliability, durability, affordability etc.
@PetrolTaster
@PetrolTaster Год назад
I think it might be a good thing for the survival of older cars that they are getting more expensive. If a car is worth £500 and needs a £300 repair, many would just scrap it (Although I would argue that's not often the best thing to do economically). If a car is worth £1500 but the repair is the same price then it makes it a easier to swallow, especially if getting a replacement vehicle will cost another £1500 anyway. Personally I think mid 90-s to mid 00's is the sweet spot, but there's still plenty of durable cars through the 00's even into the 2010's. It seems to have got steadily worse though, the ratio of reliable to unreliable models has probably shifted over time. I don't think I'd touch anything diesel from within the last decade, DPFs, DMF's, EGR's, VGT's, SCR, injectors, pumps... many expensive components which on certain engines seem to be a case of when, not if. It's hard to imagine a euro 6 diesel still being driven about at 25 years old...
@MascaradooGaamer
@MascaradooGaamer Год назад
I like old car, but not in the way "If it breaks i'll get another one" I like fixing them, giving them dignity so they don't get scraped.
@ep1929
@ep1929 11 месяцев назад
I've done bangernomics since 1990 - so 33 years. Most of the cars have lasted between 3 & 7 years. God knows how much money this ethic has saved - I'd definitely say £50,000+.
@workonesabs
@workonesabs Год назад
I've ordered a couple of large mugs. As for Bangernomics, the Vectra Estate I scrapped last year got £400 for it. Also, for example I bought a 56 reg 3.0 cdti Vectra Estate 7 years ago for £2000, and seen them go now for £4000! crazy! ?( and offered 4k for it!)
@SPTSuperSprinter156
@SPTSuperSprinter156 Год назад
Until this financial doom sorts itself out and prosperity returns to the UK, I think this era of making do and fixing it will continue, as you say just after the 9 minute mark. That isn't always a bad thing, it means less waste, but lack of prosperity in general isn't good so I hope this malaise doesn't last too long.
@Markcain268
@Markcain268 Год назад
I had 20 year old ford focus, cost me £250 and had a knackered gearbox, £300 to get it reconditioned and it was back on the roads
@Rutch
@Rutch Год назад
I'm happy there was some sort of BMW ad not too long ago where they promoted their customers to keep driving their old beemers.
@EVguru
@EVguru Год назад
I've been slowly fixing a friend's Mk5 Golf 1.4tsi. Usual slipped timing chain problem, resulting in a set of bent inlet valves. Parts are pretty cheap, but the complexity of this supercharged, turbochared, direct injected petrol engine is proof of the last wheezing gasp of the internal combustion engine. The complexity wouldn't be quite such a probelm if you didn't need so many special tools to undo or even reach fasteners.
@scottishcarenthusiastsandtrain
Great little Vlog Ian and Carly, I too think the days of Bangernomics are gone although I am sure with the ULEZ in Edinburgh, being inforced from next year we may see a few cheap cars coming up for sale as Edinburgh is not charging you money to come in. Instead they are going to fine non compliant vehicles £60, again you get a grant to buy a EV or a Travel Pass or either walk or take public transport!
@marks-0-0
@marks-0-0 Год назад
I still love my Berlingo for its amazing condition and its tardis like proportions. If the engine ever blew up I'd love to convert it to electric if the price of the work wasn't too obscene.
@automotivel3501
@automotivel3501 Год назад
We have same issue at College, where we used to buy cheap old cars, for students to work on, or if someone scrapping one give them same amount. Nowadays they are fetching over £500 scrap value.
@daniellee9015
@daniellee9015 Год назад
Absolutely brilliant video Ian Miss hubnut 👍❤️ very interesting topic on banger nomics brilliant
@cliffthelightning
@cliffthelightning Год назад
Another factor in my opinion are all the Discovery car save shows, crappy cars that would have cost 200 quid 10 years ago are now being advertised as 'BARN FIND' for 1700
@cfc1001001cfc
@cfc1001001cfc Год назад
My wife's coworker back in 2006 had a 2004 Daewoo Nubira with only 8,000 miles that he wanted to sell for $4,000. It checked out in good order by our mechanic, and we bought it. We drove it for 15 years, and scrapped it when the timing belt broke on its interference engine. We will never get a deal like that again!
@brucemacdonald876
@brucemacdonald876 Год назад
I hear you. I have had my 52 plate Nissan Micra for about 4 years now; it's got 70k miles on it and I'd never get rid of it willingly, even though a bloke came round to my house twice offering to buy it. It cost me £900 and I'd probably get that for it now (11 months MOT). I agree that the turn of the century was Peak Car.
Год назад
Dear Reader, To put it somewhat graphically: in the Netherlands 30% is becoming more riche per day, and 30% more poor per day. So there is a big demand for let's say Tesla's (subsidy for rich people) and old/small cars (for poor people). The middle class cars from a certain age are very cheap indeed. So it almost looks like Verelendung (impoverishment), to call in a Marxist phrase, on the car market. Really old and cheap cars and cars for the (subsidized) rich. Now I'm writing this it dawns on me. Thank you Mr. en Ms. Hubnut, for being the source for this. Perhaps it's an very interesting idea to work on building a small fleet of cheap classic cars (in our country older than 40 years, means no taxes). Perhaps specializing on a certain niche brand. So you become the centre for: Autobianchi, Citroen, Simca or Talbot or something along this line. Buying them cheap, tinkering and selling them to a niche group, of wich the NubNuts become the epicenter? Just a thought. Michel Poor Dutch Philosopher (no car)
@trevatkin4869
@trevatkin4869 Год назад
You're spot on with this video folks. There really aren't the good 'bangers' out there anymore at sensible money. There's a lot of overpriced rubbish for sale. And yes, selling cars is a serious pain, and people want a new car for a few hundred quid!
@stephencopeland238
@stephencopeland238 Год назад
Very seriously soui sensible thinking. Really appreciate your philosophy
@fhwolthuis
@fhwolthuis Год назад
I always have been surprised by the low prices of used cars in the UK. I guess it's because of nobody wants to have the RHD cars... Here in Europe, our older cars are mostly exported to Eastern Europe and continue driving there for several more years. On the other hand, a lot of used cars are imported to our country (NL) because we lack certain popular models that were just not sold a lot new here because of all kinds of government incentives. I am still driving my 14,5 year old FIAT Bravo, which I bought 2nd hand when 8 years old, because: I know it has been very well maintained, I drive only 5000k a year and I still like driving it. No point in trading it in and having to fork out at least 6000€ to buy another 10 year old car and start all over again fixing a backlog of maintenance. I don't understand why there are not a lot of the London cars moved to Wales and sold there?
@keithmatthews1673
@keithmatthews1673 Год назад
When used cars were cheap in the UK, many were shipped off to Africa in containers especially peugets and merceres in the days when they were reliable meaning there are few of those models left now in the UK!
@borderlands6606
@borderlands6606 Год назад
A friend in France is amazed how little we pay for used cars. Ten years ago he found it difficult to buy a beat up basic Renault for less than £2k, when the equivalent here was around £300. Sadly, we seem to be entering an era when paying a grand to keep an old car on the road is good economics.
@oocares
@oocares Год назад
Parents live in St. Davids. It was fine until they got into their 80's and couldn't drive any more. Bus every 2 hours into Haverfordwest that finishes at 6pm. Careful where you retire to....
@nickis_speedshop
@nickis_speedshop Год назад
Went looking for a K10 Micra a few months ago. Remember them being around 500-600 quid a few years ago, converted from local currency, for a really tidy example with low miles, few owners etc. But now, the few that are still being sold start at 1500£ in really rather subpar condition, with dodgy gearboxes and the like, and all the way up to 3000£ for tidy examples. Maybe a sign of everything considered even marginally "retro" automatically becoming exorbitantly expensive and "sought after". Just a thought. Great video as always!
@HubNut
@HubNut Год назад
Nostalgia always drives up prices, and the 1980s/early 90s are definitely finding their market now.
@OsellaSquadraCorse
@OsellaSquadraCorse Год назад
Or the always cringeworthy "sort after".
@fsodn
@fsodn Год назад
Have fun with the magnetic spark plug sockets! I have ONE in my airplane tool bag that I take with my on long-distance flying trips. It's so amazingly better than anything else (but also eye-wateringly expensive, so thus only one).
@delukxy
@delukxy Год назад
I sent those to Ian. Happy to say they were £7.50 for the pair post free so you must cry very easily! I hope he finds they work well.
@Karl_Burton
@Karl_Burton Год назад
It's the punitive car tax that's killing them, along with clean air zones.
@hectorshouse7348
@hectorshouse7348 Год назад
Fascinating stuff…thank you
@stealthkiwi1869
@stealthkiwi1869 Год назад
Here in New Zealand I picked up a 1300cc Toyota Ist 2005 model for $1000, did a oil change air filter, plugs and it just keeps going great looks like new inside and out, and every time I drive it I think of HubNut with a smile! and about 5ltrs per 100kms in economy with no lithium in sight!
@GryphLane
@GryphLane Год назад
Definitely holding on to my ST220, which although it's far from a banger, there weren't ever many of them about, and they deserve to be saved. I'm not quite brave enough for bangernomics though, not for my one and only car.
@shaunw9270
@shaunw9270 Год назад
Last year , I sold my '05 Corsa, 120k miles, MOT failure with massive oil leak for £250 scrap value & bought an '08 Mégane CC with 67k miles for £300.
@willswheels283
@willswheels283 Год назад
A very interesting subject, I think the days of finding a useable £500 or less car are behind us sadly, most cars that were previously in that category are now scrap or in the £800-£1000 area, some are even more! A lot of these cars as well seem to have similar issues to the cars that you could buy for £300-500! Car take back is a company I’ve used more than once, it’s so much easier selling an old car with issues that way and you get more than scrap value in some cases, selling cheap cars Is so tedious and stressful, people seem to want a lot for little or nothing. I wonder if rising used car prices will make people think twice before parting ways with their car that’s just failed its MOT, and now that car is worth enough money to warrant repairing it, where before it would have been sent to the scrapper!? Thanks for the vid guys, all the best! 👍
@keithleesley5979
@keithleesley5979 Год назад
Absolutely agree, I'm hanging on to my 2005 picasso hdi 2.0 ,low miles, 2 owner car and it's my 5th one and love them if only for my spinal problems, yes it's got some lacquer peel but I plan on some paintwork in spring and why not, at current prices I could get around 1500 quid for it but what on earth would I buy as a replacement? Nothing decent I fear, love this channel, proper real world motoring without the need for car debt!
@ianh.6825
@ianh.6825 Год назад
I'm still driving my year 2000 Nissan Primera 1.8s P11-144 which I bought for £350 in 2016 with a genuine 45,000 miles. It's nice to drive, very reliable and still shines up pretty well.
@markanderson9493
@markanderson9493 Год назад
Hi both.. im sure the golden age was when cars only died due to corrosion, albeit cars only lasted 10 years max, but in the 70s and 80s engines, gearboxes, in fact anything that could be unbolted would be changed.. oh the days of scrap yards where you just took off what you wanted, or exchange and mart.. filled with engine and gearbox recon companies..
@af5579
@af5579 Год назад
pre-covid the used cars yard i worked in was awash with 300-500 quid cars with a few months test, but since 2020 any car with MOT is baseline £800 if not more depending on how old or uncared for it is
@petroldrinker
@petroldrinker Год назад
Best car I ever owned was down to bangernomics. Had to sell my nice Audi to fund a business venture. I bought an mot failed 2002 Citroen C5. Fixed it for an afternoon with spanners and one new tyre with the aim of keeping it for six months. Ended up keeping it for 5 years. Such a lovely car to drive, completely reliable, so good on diesel. I drove from Kent to the highlands several times in quiet comfort, I just loved it. You hardly ever see them now. Future classic? I always smile when I see one.
@andrewentwistle515
@andrewentwistle515 Год назад
Another interesting video from Hubnut & Miss Hubnut. I must admit that I do like the older generation of car & understand the problems that a lot of people are facing these days. I think that there should be someone who is collecting and saving the cars from ULEZ problems.
@simonc858
@simonc858 Год назад
I bought a £1200 Volvo V50 a few years ago and I am not going to add up what I have spent since!! I love it and when it was last MOTd the man said it is virtually new underneath!!!
@erik_dk842
@erik_dk842 Год назад
The next repair might cost more than you can buy another, at first sight similar, one for. But it will have its own heap of problems. Rust is no longer the killer it used to be, for the good models at least.
@aaronbensi9723
@aaronbensi9723 Год назад
Great video. I think people are just holding on to there cars much longer. Here in Australia it’s the sam. Second hand cars have gone through the roof. And that includes the old one.
@seanhazell9174
@seanhazell9174 Год назад
There are a few still about but you have to look really hard and have some luck in the process. Managed to secure myself a 60 plate Punto Evo (1.4 Fire 8valve) for £400 about three months ago. Walked it's MOT. Just needed a new blower fan motor. They are out there.
@oompah01
@oompah01 Год назад
I found my old issue of Auto Trader from the year 2000 recently and it really brought the point home. Back then the under £1,500 "bargain buys" section was HubNut heaven in today's world, a kind of cross between Festival Of The Unexceptional and an everything-must-go fire sale! But back then insurance costs meant I had to choose a Fiesta over that £950 205 GTI - or Rover 800 fastback - the list goes on... (sigh)!
@MePeterNicholls
@MePeterNicholls Год назад
I’m learning more about modern electronics in cars and with the right diagrams and so on, I’m finding I can get along with it quite well. Sure you need a few more bits, but I enjoy it
@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968
Thanks for the information on scrap values increasing. I now know where my Mondeo is heading..🤔
@ourhudlathome8885
@ourhudlathome8885 Год назад
Just had to spend over £200 on a new battery for a 2016 Focus, the car then had to plugged into the Bosch diagnostic system via a PC to set up the new battery for the car (more expense). When these cars get older it won't be economic to do even small repairs like this. Great discussion, completely agree with your points.
@glmm2001
@glmm2001 Год назад
New cars are so expensive that old cars are getting more expensive everyday as most people can’t only access to old, used cars
@simonchristie4117
@simonchristie4117 Год назад
Great video, whilst watching I went on autotrader and did a national search for cars upto £500 and only sixteen cars available!
@captaccordion
@captaccordion Год назад
I'm a Bangernomics person without doubt. I've 6 cars, the newest of which is 1989. You reviewed that one - the Ford Telstar. My golden era in terms of user friendliness is the 1980s. Cabin ventilation and related matters were well sorted, brakes were good, gearboxes had overdrive gears, and yes, electronic ignitions and Jap fuel injection remain reliable today. Though if you've got points ignition, you always keep your most recently replaced points and condensor in the glovebox just in case. It's no big problem. In the UK of course you're at quite a disadvantage in that the cars of that era have all rusted away. Here in Australia that's not so, and I don't anticipate having to go newer than 1989 for a good while yet. Nevertheless, all that you've observed and commented on is happening here - it's just 10 years behind you. Your anecdote about the brake pads was a horrific one. I'll swap you with this one... Have you met staked in universal joints yet? As my girlfriend expensively found out in her X-Trail, universal joints are no longer replaceable when they wear out, and an entire new driveshaft had to be bought. Cheers.
@sewwilson4185
@sewwilson4185 Год назад
I had a 2002 berlingo 1.9 diesel so no turbo, absolute gem of a car. Bought it with 92k on it back in 2006 for £3000, and got rid of it only because the back end was collapsing and was cheaper to scrap it than get it fixed at the time. But I did have it for 11 years and when I got rid of it it had 195k miles. I so wish I had fixed because the engine was still running fine.
@karenleith6079
@karenleith6079 Год назад
Interesting points…. Also, the Warehouse could be called “Bangers ‘r’ Us”!
@markjackson3952
@markjackson3952 Год назад
I always used to do bangernomics for my cars, usually as I do get board of them. Last good deal I had was back in September 2021 when I picked up a 2009 Citroen C3 with 8 months mot for £350. We spent £175 including mot test to keep it going for another 12 months. It’s mainly used for my wife who works in Plymouth and struggles finding a parking spot (her main car is a 2010 Range Rover). Sadly there are very few reasonable cars around here under 1k
@moschops2002
@moschops2002 Год назад
The Scrappage Scheme certainly thinned out the vehicles that would now be prime bangernomics candidates.
@robinclayton8284
@robinclayton8284 Год назад
i'm not sure how much the original scrappage scheme would be having on todays market, it was 12 years ago and aimed at cars that were generally in the already older age bracket and probably would have naturally have gone maybe 5-6 years ago.. I think it had more of an effect as a mindset change, and allowed dealers to incentivise with fake scrappage deals.
@borderlands6606
@borderlands6606 Год назад
@@robinclayton8284 Look at some of the cars that fell to the scrappage scheme, and weep. People who had hung onto genuine classics (an Austin Healey among numerous examples) but had reached an age when they wanted a hatchback to run to the village shops. Dealers weren't allowed to divert them to survival status, so they went to the crusher.
@aintme2
@aintme2 Год назад
Totally agree with you Ian about the late 90's early 00's cars, on Saturday I'm travelling to Essex to pick up a 1997 Volvo V70 TDI, it's going to be my daily, and if it's like my 2000 C70 I had last year, should match modern cars for reliability. Ticket has been booked for Festival of the Unexceptional to, my first time attending!
@Bucharestguidedtours
@Bucharestguidedtours Год назад
Great video. I have had older cars for years, my old Vectra and an Escort I've had for 30 years, but within my group of motoring friends, which have cars from old stuff right up to a 2020 Nissan leaf We all notice the same thing, it's hard to change car, prices of old cars are through the roof and the top end of the market is suffering from a shortage of cars and inflated prices. A telling story was my friend with the Leaf had to buy an older car as his work place moved and he needed a non EV to get there! Skoda Octavia14 plate, while the Leaf sits dormant, costing a fortune every month. Its going to get like Cuba you know ...best wishes.
@robinclayton8284
@robinclayton8284 Год назад
I have been trying to bangernomics for 30 years. My aim is to achieve 10 miles for ever £1 spent. I often don't get there but it used to be easier. Our last galaxy went after breaking the barrier but having multiple issues just at MOT time... Got £350 scrap. But I could not find a suitable replacemnt in my original budget £1K, could not find a good alternative in my extended budget £2K... Spread my net, increased my budget, ended up with a£9K Kuga that's going to have to last us for 10-15 years (if it can).... But I do run 3 cars and a Van for less than what a colleague puts down on his single new Kia Sproutage every month.
@TruthTortoise81
@TruthTortoise81 Год назад
3 years ago I bought a 2007 Polo for £1300, I've spent £1500 on repairs/tires/MOTs and done 60,000 miles in it. so that's about 6p a miles not including petrol, which is probably about 15p a mile. So 21p a mile overall - but the car is still good and I will try and keep it going for 2 or 3 more years. So yeah 20p a mile is achievable.
@robinclayton8284
@robinclayton8284 Год назад
@@TruthTortoise81 My main problem now, is that I don't do enough miles a year spread between 4 vehicles ( my car, wifes, sons , van ). So things become low mileage but old.
@robinclayton8284
@robinclayton8284 Год назад
@@TruthTortoise81 I have a spreadsheet going back 19 years with each car on it with the non consumable costs ( tax,fuel,insurance ) and mileage. Total excluding the recent purchase is £23,174 over the 19 Years, always at least two cars on the road equates to ~£50 a month. And it's not a pair of superminis, family barge and a sports saloon mostly.. If I went PCP or something like that it would be £1200 a month ... and my Boss says he can't afford a second car over his New Kia.