Banana Republic scents are high quality. The dark cherry and tobacco & tonka bean are my favorites, and I may buy a backup of each. I also have the neroli woods that I gave my wife because it leans feminine.
Dark cherry is a banger, I love it. I got this and bought tobacco and tonka and both are really nice, hard to pick out of the two, but if I had a gun to my head I would pick dark cherry and amber. For 20 bucks each, I was shocked at the quality with these two.