but if you could make some of this machines floating between 2 magnets in a container with no air but only Vacum then I belive infinite or really long motion could be achieved
Read what is in the description link before judging! You will find this: "Perpetual motion, although impossible to produce, has fascinated both inventors and the general public for hundreds of years."
"Perpetual Motion Machines" do not generate energy. They are just very efficient at transferring very little force into a lot of motion. Any attempt to havest that energy or even rubbing your hand against it, will reveal that there is very little energy powering these devices to begin with, in fact, slightly less energy than it took to start it.
+Mārtiņš Rozenbergs True Perpetual Motion Machines do not exist. Even the most well made ones will eventually slow down and stop due to friction and other factors if they do not have additional outside energy put in to sustain it. Think of a pocket watch, taking a few seconds to wind it and it will run a very complicated and precise machine running all day. However, the next day it needs to be wound again, or it'll eventually slow down and die. Same idea. A true perpetual motion machine would be wound once and would be able to sustain itself without being touched or having a batter or even taking in solar energy or being moved to self wind.
Cool video. Though I'm a bit ignorant on the subject, isn't perpetual motion supposed to be impossible? Sure, most of these machines can run for awhile, but will eventually halt due to external conditions, right? Give most of these (including your Part 1 video) a couple hours and they may stop functioning. Bah, impressive and interesting no less.
+SlamifiedBuddafied i cant say all, but most of them are being runt by an egine of some sort, for example on part 1, the blue water one, it says that the weight of the water pushes it down, but water pressure varies only on height, so it must have some kind of pump, probably in that black brace that secures the pipe to the table
+Explore&ShootTV If you look closely, similar observations to the one you wrote are valid for almost all braces you see in the vid. The shots are meticulously taken so that the source of energy is hidden, in most cases (if not in all). There is even a screw that starts and stops moving at some point, which is probably associated with a torque given by a motor. But those are nice toys to fool people.
+Explore&ShootTV It must. You can even see air bubbles shooting through the water at first. Plus the delay as the pump fills. That water should have gone through the tube instantly. No doubt camera angles hiding the giveaways.
В первом механизме можно увеличить КПД путём создания направленного удара, как при втором. Третий выходит за рамки моего понимания - это представляется мне открытием.
+ThePapino134 A prepetual machine would only accelerate if it had no forces to stop it! On earth you will have gravity and air recistance, but everywhere in the universe you have friction to overcome.... Than again making a machine that does neither accelerate and decellerate would be impossible. for example a "newton's cradle" seems to have figured out that stuff, but if you wait long enough they also stop...
Roughrider Gatlinghammer The few that I'm interested in wouldn't have to be powered for my pleasing. They last minutes on their own after you first "play" with it hence the term "toy" for me. It would be something on my desk/tables to fiddle with.
Very cool. BTW if anyone is still gullible enough to think these are real, read the guy's website, it say's "My Perpetual Motion Machines models are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of Inventors. "
Wow, very smart thinking. The big arc piece does 3 things. 1) It takes the weight off of the spinning assembly at the top of the down hill trek, 2) it rotates the weight on that same smaller wheel so that it cocks it back to create a kenetic downhill golf swing potential, then 3) releases the weight into the golf swing to maximize the downhill swing thrust, while the weights on the other two wheels have their weights hanging free and closer to the center, allowing them to rise due to the fact that the big wheel has less weight to lift on that side. In turn, PM, and a very nice version of an alternating weight wheel PMM.
Although these machines can't provide unlimited energy the unbalanced wheel and the three beams perpetual star can be dramatically improved and can be an electrical fan needing far less energy
All I see is visual stimulation that creates thoughtful dialogue in the comments. I think it's a win win. The fail is that we can't come up with a way to convert a slight amount of energy to a major amount of energy without combusting fuel to slam through life.
Imagine if these PM machines (Like the suspended gear mecha) could be applied to large-scale industrial applications, like power generation; Electric power for ETERNITY for ANY city and totally green on top of it! Alas, in a perfect world...
To all the commenters bellow: You have to be blind to think the intention of the video is to show how a perpetual motion machine works. This is just an art work, a very precise one.
+Cool Dude And latsly, have you read what is in the description? The link gives a description: "Perpetual motion, although impossible to produce, has fascinated both inventors and the general public for hundreds of years."
It isn't a big deal. When I was younger I was enraged by perpetual machine scams, but now after some university education I don't feel threatened. The video doesn't claim anything and the mechanism running the machine behind the rotating disk isn't misterious.
If any of these were true sources of perpetual motion, then don't you think someone somewhere would have already capitalized on the idea and started producing "free energy"? (I quote the words free energy because that term is 100% malarkey and breaks the laws of physics)
Jack Duno I find it funny how you cite physics like it's the fucking bible yet if you actually read a book on all the famous physicists hell scratch that, famous scientists in general. Each and every one dedicates their first words, with an iteration of "The guy before me is wrong this is how it really goes."
Shanethefilmmaker So what I'm getting here is that you doubt the laws of physics or something? Which famous scientist told you that any of the machines above are true perpetual motion machines?.. That's all I'm tring to argue
Jack Duno And what I am trying to tell you is the people who invented, not discovered, in ven ted, are people whom time and again has done it prove the scientist and physicist before him/her wrong. the laws of physics are unreliable sources when the people that invented them kept changing them as a means to prove each other wrong.
Jack Duno I hope that wasn't sarcasm, but seriously look up any scientist even the ones that cite the previous ones as their idols, they often begin with some variation of "He was great, but what he wasn't right about was this."
Notice you never see the back side of these "perpetual motion" machines. The shadow under the right wheel at 03:04 is a dead giveaway as to what is going on.
На магните вполне может работать как показано магнит находится в стороне как вечный источник движения и шарик к нему притягивается а потом на колесе спускается назад и снова притягивается
As these machines are not accelerating this only shows conservation of energy. Perpetual motion is real, I reference Newton: "An object... in motion will stay in motion unless acted upon by an unbalanced force," but the motion ceases to be perpetual once you try to tap it for energy.
Never trust a video without live audio. There’s obviously some source of wind or blower (via air compressor or other device) keeping these devices moving.
My perpetual motion starts at night in my bed. Initially seems like infinite and forever, but than comes to a halt. Anyways keep trying guys, all efforts are admirable if you don't try to fool others.
There is this thing at my local playground and its tilted. when you sit on it. you slowly begin to spin, your weight throwing it to make it go faster and faster.
Opposing magnets push against each other. The key to harness their power is being able to block them, creating an on- off effect, similar to a electric motor. The electric motor dors it with a armature and brushes. On, off, on, off. The magnetic force can be blocked using chrome plated stainless steel. Almost all modern electric motors use permanent magnets, making them brushless, and very much more efficient. The next step is to use permanemt magnets opposing each other with a lightweight blocking mechanism, thus eliminating the need for electricity. Im sure this has been done, is probably patented, and buried by the powers that be.
these are brilliant, harnessing the power of gravity - there is so much potential in perpetual motion - to design a perpetual engine that provides power efficiently (i.e. in vast quantities) is the future of power on earth! After the deign has been completed, a perpetual engine should generate power indefinitely if maintenance was not an issue.
screw the definition of perpetual motion, why has no-one hooked a dynamo up to like 300 of these and emplyed a few people to walk around and poke them with a stick every now and again
extremally unefficient. dynamo wpuld put put near all energy in secounds fron them and even if someone would poke it constantly... well it would be more efficient to just spin dynamo by yourself but as you probably know its waaaay less efficient that for example water turbine
I just discussed this with a couple of so Called engineer friends and its really tough to argue with people who don't want to listen to an argument based on facts.
so, you were trying to argue what? because for what you're saying, i assume the engineers were trying to say that perpetual machines don't exist and are impossible to make. either that or these are the most stupid engineers ever. care to explain?
Some of those are alright. The last one might be workable. When the weight is swinging from one stanchion to the next, a magnet could accelerate it's velocity. It would actually take 2 magnets so the weight could split their attraction. :-)
The second toy receives energy from Earths gravity to continue rotating. When the springs bend backwards, it converts gravitational energy into elastic potential energy, which is released when the spring hits the spoke.
Most of these I wonder how much energy loss you're getting from the mechanisms, and suggest a control using just a single wheel on one of those bearings. However, I have to admit the last one was pretty cool. I might replicate that as a desk toy some day.
In the last one, the arm is leading the pendulum. Not the other way around... That one has to have spmekind of motor in it because the arm moves too robotically and again, it leads the pendulum, which shouldn't happen in that type of machine. The pendelum is the only source of enegry so it should be pulling the arm, but if you watch closely, it doesn't.
Your craftsmanship and ability to build these machines is amazing!!! I love this. Two questions...first, is gravity considered an energy source when it comes to perpetual motion? And second, I know that perpetual motion isn't possible. But if it was, wouldn't the machine go faster and faster til it broke up? What stops your machines from speeding up? Maybe the fight between both forces?
If you watch at the 3:04 mark, you can see the shadow of the motor driving the two yellow wheels. I know its fake but that is just an insult that they didn't think anyone would notice.
*Guys, PAY ATTENTION. The creator himself said on his blog (on description) that these are MOTORIZED, meaning electricity was used. this is only a DEMONSTRATION to represent designs of perpetual motion machines*
Of all the 'perpetual motion' machines you've built, which one(s) actually perform the best 'unaided' ? You must be one of only a very small number of people able to answer this with any authority. I'm intrigued.
I know you put a large amount of effort into all these things but it's so obvious that they can never work (energy can never be created or destroyed ^^)
to be considered to be a perpetual motion machine it must run with 100% efficiency and needs to have excess energy that can be harnessed but instead these machines use all of their energy to keep themselves running therefore not perpetual motion. also there could be some mistake that causes them to stop running
No se equivoquen es solo energia perpetua Si es capas de girar < mas no capas de generar energia > ''Solo es un hermoso adorno '' si no me creen compruébenlo
I've seen so many videos of yours, some of them are hilarious but some I have doubts, I think that they might work perpetually. I beleave in perpetual machines. So has any of your machines worked?
My god, why is everyone freaking the hell out about these machines. Of course perpetual motion doesn't work due to the law of conservation of energy. That doesn't necessarily mean that the machines are motorized or anything. It is likely that they have minimal friction allowing them to run for a long time. Eventually, however, they will stop due to imperfect conversion of potential energy to kinetic energy (heat and friction). some of these you can buy online and test for yourself like the carousel one.
Since there is nowhere to route a wire, I think that one must be battery driven- at one point, you can see what looks to be the shadow of the drive behind the wheel on the right. Obviously, these are all mechanically driven- I really think the first one is may favorite because it must be belt driven through the hollow tube legs.
I can' t belive then the fourth model is perpetual, I think is impossible, why is it perpetual? I can't see any think then demonstrate it. Behind the model is there a motor?
these are really cool, but like everyone already said, there's no such thing-maybe they go for a long time.....hell, maybe for a reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeally long time, but even then, the parts themselves are subject to physically eroding over time due to friction, so.....eventually they WILL stop, all energy concerns aside
Could you send me the schematics of these also by pm to me i love perpetual motion its always been an interest and these are awesome. But you suspended wheel system doesnt look like its possible, how does that one work??
eine frage an leute mit erweiterter physik kenntnis: ist die Kraft die benötigt wird um 1kg einen meter zu heben die selbe die ensteht wenn 1kg einen meter fällt?
It's very lubricated, as the other ones. This, plus the fact that they're shown only for a few seconds, gives the illusion of perpetual motion, but if you attach, say, an electric generator they'll stop running
even if such machines as these are really perpetual what use would they be of? We can't harness any energy from such mechanisms since such machines would be a critical balance of the forces cleverly interlocked to pass through the mechanisms, where there always needs to be a source for the input for the force which for us should be kind of free source like gravity, sun any other.
