H.Y Mardi Confused with what? The criteria for judging is already unfair, the comments were somehow insulting. The second round, some lip sync, others sing live. The diffrence in singing live and lip sync is pretty obvious. Well, it's my opinion, rude or what not. The panel there were also rude, some of them were/are so assuming.
and that elimination made lyn the worst guest in ICSYV replacing im chang jung. that gesture that stare, lyn 100% hate her for nothing (jealousy and insecure), what an ugly attitude. feel sorry for the girl
OMG! I couldn't agree more. I'm a girl but I'm definitely not siding with Lyn and the female audiences. What Lyn did is just so damn wrong and she should not be discriminate because of her beautiful face. This is just ridiculous. Oh how I hate Lyn's face when she eliminate her and keep insisting that she made the right choice.
JiYeen_KpopLover so you've never ever made a decision/judgement based on a person's appearance before? Saying one should hold off judgment is nice in theory and is purely idealistic. The truth is, if you've been through life itself long enough, you'll psychologically and subconsciously make a judgment based on things smaller than appearance, such as sound of their voice or how they walk. As far as Lyn choosing her to be tone deaf based on appearance, you can blame the kpop industry for pushing out a multitude of good looking female idols who cant sing. This is based off her past experience she has been through as a veteran singer. Can she be wrong? Sure, but if you're going to judge her based on her own opinion, maybe you should consider the circumstances that led her to that conclusion in the first place. Otherwise, you're being just as closed minded as you claim her to be. Also, in past episodes, male singers have picked female singers to be tone-deaf and not based on appearance alone. Unless you missed the title of the show, it's called "I can see your voice" it's based purely on appearance. So it seems like you have a problem with the concept of the show in general. Maybe just don't watch it then?
Wow.. ok.. I know it is only right to just agree with you and appreciate your time and effort to type all that. But let's just give me a chance to say that, I've watch this show since season 1 so i'm well understand of the concept. Excuse her for not being able to see the contestant's voice but still can't excuse her way of doing it (all what she said is kinda bad and hurtful). I know that everyone have their own reasons to do what they do so I try my best not to be prejudice. That's what I've been taught and trained. But again, I guess this time I made mistake in judgment maybe.. because that's what I saw and felt. I guess that's how Lyn felt to maybe.. so yeah..
The emotions in her eyes speaks a heart of true singer. I don't watch this show bit seen clips on here, scrolled down the comments and that sad she got eliminated.
Hofai Lee++ Could she be crying because of the judgemental comments from the female guest? Just asking....... Can't find the whole episode, subbed , to watch.
She just has an idol personalty, i think she has to be come famous cause she has such a nice voice 2:30 you can hear her nice voice clearly :) We wish the best for her with a lot of love ❤️
I like this show because it make me look that many people is good at singing but one things I hate the most is because they always firstly judge by face,if he is pretty and and the guest is girl she will pay more attention to the boy more and say that they can sing but when it is girl ,u want them to leave right away ,ooh
leo saranghae omg yes, like ppl hate the girl if the girl is too perfect. idk if u watch there's one season, an actress appeared. They said she was a tone deaf. She is an actress and she is really pretty. They expected her to be a tone deaf bcs they said if she can sings too, she is way too perfect (perfect means she can act, sing, and beautiful) lol. I don't understand this ppl, urghh
jesuisreconnaissant ʕ•ᴥ•ʔ yes I have watch this season but not all but the guest must chose based on the face first it hurt my feeling that they must do something like that , not like you a singer you can judge perfectly just by looking at their face,than it is not a singer....but a jealous person
leo saranghae hey, then how u choose the person on this show if its not from face/outer appearance? they doesnt know them or their voice, if its not from appearance then how can u choose? logic please
lyn said that 1) she is pretty so she is confirmed to be a tone deaf 2)when the mc asked her if she make a good decision, she said happily yes I think I made the right decision 3) lyn also said that "I hope she hurry and leave too"
marvin juan She didn’t embarrassed her. she was just rude to her. But you know the only thing that made me happy about her rude comments are that she admitted she was ugly bc “only ugly woman or girl can sing” apparently
everyone should hear "you stole my heart" of her, it was released a long time ago and is one of my fav song until now..so happy to see her in this program
Olilol She is a Korean singer in China and she was meant to feature in the Chinese I am a singer programme but the Chinese media forced her to be kicked out due to the tensions between Korea and China regarding the THAAD establishment. China taking out political conflicts on innocent people really
The I am a singer programmer only has really famous singers taking part like that's the main concept of the show. I don't see how she could have taken part.
Lol yea but like they were all debuted and famous singers. Like the one and 황치열. No one seems to know the girl in the video so I wonder why was she invited to be in I am a singer.
I love this show but I hate it how they keep saying if a certain person is pretty or handsome then they can't sing. That's gotta be the dumbest reason to eliminate somebody. Are they trying to refer that you have to be not so good looking to be a singer? Because if that's the case you can eliminated so many of the boy & girl bands and solo singers that's active right now including Lyn herself.
2:34 raw translation *"I am Han Sua, who have been a singer for 11 years... Probably there is no one recognize me anymore... After been living as unknown, I found a light (chance to being recognize) at China... But I became frustrated again due to country problem... But to not give up my dream, because there's a bit pieces of heart wanted to sing again... After 11 years, I waited desperately for this stage... Today at this moment, I hope I will be the brightest on this stage as much as I waited for this day... "*
I really want to know her name she's beautiful I got disappoint when lyn choose her in the first round because of her beautiful face they said she's such a beauty maybe she can't sing well but after they hear her singing they got shock I don know why she is tearing while singing maybe the song reflects to her story we're here to support so keep fighting Miss...!!
you can tell she's actually crying at the end not because of the emotional song but probably because of the comments made about her. maybe the song was just an add on to that idk
Man I don't like the celebrity guest in this episode, you can tell by the way she acts it's annoying, sure your the guest but you don't have to thrive so hard to be the main character of the episode, you are here to look for a singer specialist not someone you "like" and "dislike" , the fact that she eliminated this girl because "she was too pretty so she would be bad at singing" in her (the guest's) mind. Idk I just find it spiteful, she just doesn't seem genuine like other guests I've watched
Lyn is very sensitive, see other shows (duet song festival). Show crew do their job very well in deceiving everybody on the set, its easy for us to see flaws :) Genuine is hard to impose on a scorpio that are very good at emotion camouflage :)) see other shows you will be surprised in a good way ! :)
that also means for her she is ugly.. since that concept applies in her mindset and she can sing, therefore she accepted the fact that she is ugly herself.. lmao
First I saw her, I strongly announced to myself that you are a great singer. I'm totally freaking out, You can be a Kdramas Ost singer, just like Ailee.
it must be an awful pain in her heart singing this song on an elimination stage to a reason 'pretty girl can't sing'. The reason was so not nice :( anywho best wishes for her and with that talent im sure she will be noticed
She look so done when Lyn chose her 😫 Lyn reason was "she is to pretty to be a good singer" and also "i don't like when singers are good looking"... how rude! Anyway this is Han Soa go listen to her song "Tonight" which is my favorite! She also just released a song called "Dry Flower" I think that's the name.
Nurul Asyikin last week after happy together karaoke special, I became fans of lyn and impress with her collab during i can see your voice final stage.but after heard her comment on this girl number 1 about pretty girl shouldn't sang beautifully, I won't become Lyn fans anymore..
@@fachrudinmahmud8509 not only that, she confidently and happily said to the mcs that she choose the right person to be delaminated and even worse, she said "I hope she hurry and leave" and you said that's a normal reaction? lmao
I'm really upset by that Singer because she eliminated her just because of this reason that she's too pretty. Like, you can see, she is obvious that she wants to join this show with a serious purpose in her life. And also, why judging her looks? Like that's really immature for her to think that. I hope she realizes how terrible she did to judge her like that. She cried because she loves singing so much. But one simple reason made her eliminated.
Sometimes I really hate this show. Simply because it gives people the freedom to degrade and insult someone based off of their appearance. And personally seeing Shindong irks me too. Because 1 he can't sing himself. He was SUJU's main dancer. He lost a little weight and his personality changed and he was a dick and I seriously think that's the reason why no one made a big deal about him joining the military. But the nature of this show truly does not sit well with me. Because it shows how shallow people can be.
Lee Soo Man why do I think he's a bad person? Because on a radio show he told a fan that females should be skinny in order for them to be considered pretty or attractive. He also said fat girls are lazy and don't take care of themselves
After watching this, I really hate female guests who say hurtful words.!!!! I'm sorry for his fans but I really regret the rich words that came out of his mouth. His eyes and smile are very mocking. I feel bad for that contestant, he was crying not because he was eliminated but he was hurt by what the female guest said,. Even I who only heard it felt angry and hurt.!!! Once again, I apologize to the guest's fans, if I seem to hate the guest too much.!!🙂
She has such star quality. Her voice has so much soul and feeling and not to mention she is so pretty like omg she looks like a doll I hope the best for her future
4 years later and watching it. Damn, that Lyn is kinda nasty with her comments. It’s not like all the idols are either handsome or beautiful. Like dude, who is she to judge a girl like that?
