There is a video on carvaka podcast which explains the lack of availability of horses as the number one reason of military defeat from Islamic invasions. The main guy explaining is AIM. that video is an eye opener.
Arey prakhar bhava, tu social genius honyasathi swatah jya guest la podcast sathi bolavtos,tyanche videos pan pahnyacha,samajnyaacha aadhi prayatn purvak homework karun yet jaa, mhnje tuze binary madhe chaalnaare supik prashn he dr.ankit shah sarkhya guest chya pratyek sentence madhe confused respondent houn yenaar nahi, tula je prashn hya podcast madhe padle aahet, te baryaapaiki uttare answers deun public paryant dr.ankit shah ji yanni swatah detail in depth explain kelele aahet, tyamule tu swatah podcast karnyaaadhi jaraa social genius ho, mhnje je aadhich indians la mahitiye, tey tu punha confused mind ne helpless ani excited houn discuss karnyaat dr.ankit shah yanchya followers cha ani dr. Ankit ji yancha swatahchaahi time vyarth ghaalvnaar nahis, kaaran tuzya prashnaanvarun ase distey ki tula ektyalach youtube var geopolitics ani geoeconomics yaa madhe history ,present and future samjaayla chance milalach nasaavaa....aadhi dr.shah ji yanche dusrya youtube channels varche itar youtubers sobat che discussion videos paha, nantar tuze prashn thode mature banav.....mag tyanna podcast sathi bolav, baaki dr.shah che bolne samjun ghenyacha pretend nako karus, tyapeksha tyanna 3 taas saglya topics var tyanchya hishebaane vina adthale bolu de, purn aik,samaj,digest kar, mag tyavar manan,chintan kar, next podcast madhe tyanna punha bolav,mag tuze vichar manthan kelele navneet prashn punha vichaar tyanna, aani punha vel de tyanna uninterrupted explain karnyacha sanatan model la tu parspar western educated mind ne process karun compare karun neglect va reject va accept karnyaachi ghaai karu nakos...bye best luck to host, Ani dr. Ankit Shah ji wel done, wel informed,wel explained in so short time, thanks for your body language observations, and your geoeconimical observations and your sharp mind who differentiates and also draw parallels between abrahmic systems and sanatan dharmik systems....yacha fayda bhartaala hoilch, oan garju ani adnyaanaat pichnaarya dukhi shoshit vishwaalaa hi hovo...ani bharat tumchya ya mahiticha laabh gheun savadhpane shatrukde tumchya wisdom chya asset chorun jaanyaaadhi rashtra rakshnaasaathi ani rashtra seve sathi, rashtra samruddhisaathi, rashtra aatmsanmaanaasaathi, vishva kalyaanaasaathi, bhavishyatil manav ani sarv jivaanchya uddhaaaraasaathi aaplya wisdom cha knowledge cha sadupayog ghadat raho akhand pane....yach parmeshwara javal yaachnaa
Bro, look the world 🌍 in biological terms, U will understand. Is Cancer 🦠 aware that by killing the body 🌳 it is killing itself😅😅😅😅 Cancer=Adharma=Western religion mind🤯🤯🤯 Dharma 🕉️=Indigenous cell mind🌳🌳🌳🌳🌳 Thank me later😂😂🎉🎉😂😊
The problem in the program is the host who is so deeply engrossed in the western system that he is unable to come out of his box. Time and again he would hide behind the rule based system rather then duty based system. Sir, to interview you have to leave your classroom system of standing first concept 😂😂😂
Angrezi study ka asar hai Bollywood Hollywood woke movies dekhke Aisa hi haal hota hai upar se western education vala apna system gurukul education system hata diya gurukul vala students kabhi faltu ka bakwas jabardasti ka chillana nai karte lazy nai hote sanskar bachapan se daale jaate hai western education pura reverse hai iska
His Prediction regarding Adani Hindenburg (on Sanjay Dikshit Channel: Jaipur Dialogue) made my profit 4× in till now. That day i was introduced to mr Ankit shah for the first time.
Yup he made the prediction about Indians getting killed was on point and about children of VIP will start getting gifts has also started, Prakhar was on his high horse tbh.
Prakhar is so full of himself and so much in love with his own thinking that instead of listening to Dr. Ankit, he is hell bent on proving him wrong. Feel sorry for this petty pompuus puchka. Big on tgecout side, empty inside. Huge respect fir Dr. Shah foe not losing his cool. Hats off boss.
Ankit shah is a very well researched and highly intelligent analyst. Initially it appeared that he is having weird predictions but as the Geopolitics and economics is shaping up, most of his predictions are holding ground. His views on Indian society, what we are now and what we should move to , that is sanatan/ mandir economics is so relevant for Hindu existence.
Absolutely, Ankit Shah's insights and predictions are proving invaluable, especially in today's geopolitical and economic climate. His deep dive into sanatan/mandir economics is crucial for understanding and preserving Hindu culture. It's a pity Prakhar's approach doesn't do justice to such depth, often overshadowing it with his own attempts to dominate the conversation. If this trend continues, seeking more insightful platforms by unsubscribing here might be the best move. #ValuingInsight #ConsiderUnsubscribing
It's a matter of governance .. Saudi does this or wealth via mosques is distributed globally but runs into trouble with terrorism funding issues. Mandir economic model can be worked sensibly to provide services to society if done correctly imo and proper role of democratic governments need to be aligned also
@@jay1645 bhai islam is also monotheistic religion wha vedant or phylosophy kha hai meditation kha hai ayurveda kha hai bahut kuch hai sanatan dharm me duty kha bhai usme gurukul dekhe hai ya nahin bhai discipline hote hain wo log bahut bhai
There is a sarcastic tone in prakhar voice at the end when Ankit ji said remove cameras and tech in western and see what happens.. @prakhar kindly refer to lockdown and how shops looting happened in western during corona times while in India it's low to none .. you might link to our Dharma left in our society that was taught by means of traditional, culture..etc
Looting happened when George Floyd riots were going on...India me jab riots hote hain toh looting toh chodo log public properties ko jalane pr utar aate hain
Totally agree. Prakhar's sarcasm overshadowed Ankit ji's meaningful points on societal values. This approach, trying too hard to dominate, detracts from the depth of discussion. If this continues, unsubscribing seems like a wise choice for more enriching content. #MissedDepth #UnsubscribeForBetter
Ankit Shah is a genius who deserves a careful lisening and a deep understanding to know the indepth reality of socioeconomic fabric of Sanatan society.
so intelligent that he said all westerners are stupid and were are an advanced race. Get a grip on reality and humble yourself. Although he provided with so many thought provoking ideas, there are many fallacies in them.
What I understand from Ankit Shah's Sanatan-economics is that what gov. provides function same as ancient temples, providing free public schools-universities, public hospitals-clinics and even relief to common people during flood-famine. Now public schools and hospitals fail every common man everyday while Christian convents and hospitals take advantage of the poor and needy and prey upon their needs. The Temples must be freed and their role as providers and protectors of communities be regained. Free Hindu Temples🙏
@@jbe-oe9pt by going into convent, u forfeited ur cultural heritage😂😂, u didn't get any dharmic knowledge, any dharmic point of view about ur history and tradition, u r completely cut from ur traditions 😂😂😂 Same is true with any public or private school, none have any root in dharma. Most of today's hindus have their knowledge of their dharma and ethics from reels and shorts or cartoon or serials 😖 I live in Jharkhand, here missions and hospital look like 1st world but where do they get such funds? India's native converts are either poor or tribals, who contributes such funds 🙏 These are all for conversion, As Gandhi and OSHO said Indians didn't become christian for "Christ" but rice or their basic needs and no well to do family needs christ. I assume u r from a well to do family to afford mission schooling but they have special quotas for tribal christians and our poor tribal brothers/sisters get preyed upon their weakness. Ur conversion took place as u lost ur dharmic background, u r just "nominal hindu" and the poors become christian. Most of FCRA license are cancelled to cut these missions getting huge sums of money just for conversion and today's missions r named after Xavier, a mass murderer of Goan Hindus 🤮 mockery of hindus by names of such institutions or venues from babur to Xavier. Free Hindu temples, so Hindus can use their own funds to establish their own ecosystem that I was talking about (above-mentioned) having our own free schools, colleges, foodings-lodgings, hospitals, volunteers, orphanage-old age homes. Our daan charity to temple is for these functions not to be gobbled up by corrupt gov. and their failed public healthcare and education system which only poor use and all well to do go for private institutions. This gap is preyed by missionaries (this word literally means mission to convert) but RSS's SSVM vanvasi kalayan asharms and Arya Samaj's DAV are good efforts by us(Hindus). All of Tribal northeast is christian as of now just bcoz of these missions and their preying tactics 🤮.
By going into convent, u forfeited ur cultural heritage😂😂, u didn't get any dharmic knowledge, any dharmic point of view about ur history and tradition, u r completely cut from ur traditions 😂😂😂 Same is true with any public or private school, none have any root in dharma. Most of today's hindus have their knowledge of their dharma and ethics from reels and shorts or cartoon or serials 😖 I live in Jharkhand, here missions and hospital look like 1st world but where do they get such funds? India's native converts are either poor or tribals, who contributes such funds 🙏 These are all for conversion, As Gandhi and OSHO said Indians didn't become christian for "Christ" but rice or their basic needs and no well to do family needs christ. I assume u r from a well to do family to afford mission schooling but they have special quotas for tribal christians and our poor tribal brothers/sisters get preyed upon their weakness. Ur conversion took place as u lost ur dharmic background, u r just "nominal hindu" and the poors become christian. Most of FCRA license are cancelled to cut these missions getting huge sums of money just for conversion and today's missions r named after Xavier, a mass murderer of Goan Hindus 🤮 mockery of hindus by names of such institutions or venues from babur to Xavier. Free Hindu temples, so Hindus can use their own funds to establish their own ecosystem that I was talking about (above-mentioned) having our own free schools, colleges, foodings-lodgings, hospitals, volunteers, orphanage-old age homes. Our daan charity to temple is for these functions not to be gobbled up by corrupt gov. and their failed public healthcare and education system which only poor use and all well to do go for private institutions. This gap is preyed by missionaries (this word literally means mission to convert) but RSS's SSVM vanvasi kalayan asharms and Arya Samaj's DAV are good efforts by us(Hindus). All of Tribal northeast is christian as of now just bcoz of these missions and their preying tactics 🤮.
Please don't invite guests if only you want to do the talking. Really very disappointed by not letting the guest to speak without any interruptions. Anyway huge respect for Dr. Ankit Shah for maintaining his composure.
I'm from business khandan n whatever Ankit bhai is saying is not new to me.... That means in my family we are still following sanatan economics but we don't have phrase or term to place it !!!! Thank u Ankit bhai ❤❤❤❤
Absolute cracker of a conversation.Those who are abusing the host are going against the whole concept of sanatana dharma which is the concept of questioning everything and trying to understand on what basis is someone saying something.Our scriptures and rishis have written that "kisi bhi Rishi ka mat antim mat nhi hai".Bcoz no one saint is absolutely correct.We can become better by listening to everyone 's point which is nothing but the concept of "samvaad".Both Ankit and Prakhar are imperfect in this conversation and we can agree after watching and observing both point of views of this conversation and come to a better conclusion that everything needs betterment.
It's that when you're conversation you have to listen. Nobody is against the host or have a personal vendetta against him but he didn't listen, interrupt the guest and then we couldn't find the conclusion of the conversation. The host is in argue mode.
Doesn't the person in 3d have higher intellect to explain to the person in 2d? There is a fantastic seies on YT. (Insert anything like music theory/quantum computing) Explained in 5 levels.
@@rutvikrs bro did u learn to make sentences 1st, then figures of speech, person/perspective, words, and at last alphabets. If not then how can you explain someone beyond their intellect horizon, start with the basics. 1hr of debate without any constructive criticism or consensus just arguments in frustration.
I felt podcaster made fool out of himself by insisting the guest to answer in binary of stupid or not-stupid. If this was intentional, then it was successful. Overall, presenting this as a debate, podcaster exposed his lack of knowledge on the topic. Ankitji's knowledge, use of words/ language, calm attitude, and smile on the face have balanced out for Prakhar's anxiety, denials, lack of knowledge, unnecessary interjections, and inability to comprehend what is being presented. @Ankitji, you don't deserve such podcasts. I wish you lots of better podcasts.
But in real world, Ankit argument is actually quite stupid right. It's not gonna happened, and he thinks that India is the centre of this universe but is it not.
@@abrajitota3618 India is reaching into its moment but Ankit is just realising what a mess it is, in slomo. Earlier he was triumphant about three rupee for a dollar conversion. But after Sanyal commented he is realising the existential risk it poses. Another example is how he was happy about the eventual flow of money into Indian markets. Slowly he is realising it will be the same old money that ran an agenda in the West and now preaches precaution.
@@rutvikrs actually his views are just like communist. India can't be a duty best society, or any country in this world can't. He just say some stupid thing, and some people who just came to internet and the politics. They think o my God it's so knowledgeable, but in reality it's useless. I see somewhere he say I predict the balakot air strike 5 month ago. Can anyone f****** believe this kind of thing
@@abrajitota3618 Christopher Columbus literally found America while trying to find Bharat. Bharat was very powerful and rich of civilization. America was never that big of a civilization and has lost even the last inch of it. Egypt and some other regions have kept their civilizations alive. I would not call India the centre of the universe (because it sounds narcissistic), but tell me a religion better than Sanatan? It's the only major religion that does not convert others, poses rules from a book, denies others, etc. It sure could be very important part of the world. If it were, it can be again. No denial.
We were wearing masks in Covid, are we wearing it now? Search Car robberies in Canada and you will know what police is capable of. Lots of love to Ankit ji. He is a true legend.
The moment he started going deep into the subject he started speaking in Hindi, that's why we should study in regional rich languages. Poor coloniel language shouldn't be glorified. Ankit ji namaskaram
Earlier I used to think Ankit Shah as some conman speaking anything. After watching 10+ videos on different channel I can tell you he is more aware than normal Indians on what is going on in world. He is analyst not Astrologer.
Ya but his way of explaining is bit irritating. Like he just jumps to some other points in between and starts talking abt it without completing the prior one.
Because ranveer doesn’t argue the point the guest. Sirf ha se me mila ke kuch critical thinking badh ne nahi wali. Hum Indians arguments se itna daar te kyu Hain?
@imperfectmammal2566 bhai bich me tokne ko arguments nahi bolte hai.. secondly, in podcasts, you shouldn't interrupt guests multiple times to clear your own understanding on single topic. You haven't hired coach for your own learning ...😃😃😃 Sablog ko samajh aa raha hai, sirf prakhar k bina.. 🤣😂😂
@@imperfectmammal2566Mammalji, if you think that Indians are afraid of arguments then your intellect is at least 10 ranj lower than Prakhar. Cause you kinda demonstrated that you did not understand an iota of what was said by Ankit Shah
@@TamaghnaBhattacharya Kya bol raha hai bhai. You bring guest to know about them and their ideas. If prakhar already knows everything than what is the point?
Poor guy. The host is frustrated with ankits logical & conceptual leaps. The host uses a western lens of logical predicates, arguments and conclusions. The guest presents two opposite pictures of reality whilst pointing out some interrelated elements, dynamics, principles and culture. The gap between these two beautifully demonstrates the gap between western & sanatan understanding
Bhai this is not Sanatan philosophy. I missed the part where he quoted a single shastra, book, verse or author. Please help me find it. I promise to change my mind.
@@rutvikrsprakhar can help because only he gave pravachan. Dr Shah allowed him to give a solo speech and strip himself down as stupid in front of the ppl.
Prakhar u need to read history before u open ur mouth.Be a good listener ur have gone tangent due to ur overconfident. the whole podcast is in bad taste.U failed to put ur question properly.Too much of abrupt jumping.
Totally agree with you. At first I thought the host was confused and so the debate was confusing. But I'm glad I decided to stay on (just to see how Ankit ji handled it) and I realized that he's actually trying to mock Dr Shah.
people are critising prakhar, but i actually enjoyed this argument kind of podcasting. prakhar raised the issues which every common man comes across when a completely raw and different kind of perspective is thrown at you.
The difference is clear The western template raised person with some form of sanatan roots arguing against a more sanatani mindset person arguing to progress together, This is how bharat will progresses and walk on the path of self discovery guided by sanatan dharama ❤
Arguing to progress together? 😂where that came from. He's literally name calling lefts and people who does not thinks like him. Clowns stop being blind. 🤡
@@progamermove3437 Well, he was asking for logical break-down of Ankit's conjecture which were very evidently weren't able to be delivered by the podcastee. Whereas J Sai is someone who breaks-down ideas logically unlike this fellow.
@@wrestlingtime9763he was not asking to breakdown ankit sir facts rather breaking ankit sir himself. All I saw was the host's ego to dominate Ankit somehow, he was constantly calling himself pro-sanatani well his behavior was saying completely things completely opposite. Calling himself pro-sanatani and saying that he is a fan of western capitalistic structure is very different. Isn't it? Well he was laughing at the ideas of someone who is accurately predicting things from wars to the economy. I started following Ankit sir recently and his predictions on Twitter made my jaw drop each and every time.
@@wrestlingtime9763 Ankit sir himself appreciates J Sai and reposts J sai tweets many times, why are you comparing them both? I personally love people like J sai and anand ranganathan.
Half of Iranian people not observed Ramadan this year. Looks like after Khameni, there will be no Islam in iran. Largest group of ex muslim live in iran by the way. So technically he is right about iran.
Lol he is not listening and he is asking Mr Ankit to listen carefully!! God!! Started watching because of Mr Ankit and now I’m skipping this video because of the anchor.
Yes anchor should be very docile. When a great great sanatani maharishi like Ankit is epistemologising at the other end the anchor should be listening like bhakt and not cross question his great great sanatani knowledge.
Hello prakhar, Ankit shah is a pure gentleman.. he understood sanatan economics more than anyone .. always appreciate his research & dedication for aware people of india.
give a single reference of sanatan economics first , people like ankit shah are the people who are embarrassing us hindus , he says obnoxious things without reference, academic paper nothing , he is honestly cringe ,being a hindutva supporter for two decades this us embarrassing for us hindus, he will take any issue and exaggerate it multi fold
The reality of that time might itself seem exaggerated. Only exaggerated explanations make sense. You should wonder how were we the Golden bird 400 years back and why did we have to face all this for more than a millennium? Why didn’t we end up like the erstwhile Persia or Egypt or Rome or some other civilization?
Bhai, ANKIT SHAHJI ke paas Sare points clear and evident hai. INDIA mein apne cheezoin ko gaali dena FASHION MODERNISM and INTELLECTUALISM hai. SANATAN ka naam sunte hi INTELLECTUALS ke pucchh pe jaise paaoin rakh diya gaya ho aise popcorns 🍿 ban jaate hain
@@ujjwalchoudhary7091 I'm not saying Ankit is wrong or prakhar is right vice versa, I'm just saying we need more heated debates like this where both parties are being honest to themselves. Warna guest host ek dusre ki chaat te reh jaate hai aur actual discourse kbhi ho hi nahi paata. I don't care if someone's arguments are completely bullshit, I just want the conversation to be honest.
Conversation ko conversation hi rehne de na bhai. The host after living for couple of years in US thinks he understands western society completely. Conversation ko argument kyun bana raha hai itna overly aggresive body language se. The guest was perfectly poised and relatively calm. The host needs to be a better conversationalist himself before calling this a conversation. Till then, he is just arguing.
Bhai western society chruch se govern hoti thi yr to unke yha secular jesa kuch hai hi nahi America me bible pe shapath hoti hai 😅 unke yha concept aya tha church ko state se separate karne ka or unko renessance bhi tabhi karna pada warna Protestant catholics orthodox aapas me lad rahe the ek dusre se 😅jisko ham dark ages of Europe bolte hai jese Islam ke naam par ladte hai monotheism ne yhi kiya hai peechle 2000 saal me 😊
Came here for Dr. Shah. Found a very confused host. Arguably, Dr. Shah speaks a little too abstract sometime but just the sheer stupidity of this host is what makes this podcast awesome.
Dr. Shah's abstract insights are a treasure, and honestly, the host's unique confusion adds an unexpected disturbance to the mix! #TeamChaos #DrShahRocks
Prakhar bhai bohot wide sense chahiye iss had tak sochane ke liye aur itna deep knowledge understand and digest karne ke liye ...thats the difference of gurukul and convent
@@archanayadav-yv8kf He and his friends did, some long back. He frequently changes his opinion as he talks too much on a regular basis😂. Try to see his older videos, u will see his changing expert fake analysis.
Prior to extending invitations to individuals of Dr. Ankit Shah's caliber, it is imperative that you undertake the necessary preparations and elevate your own professional standing to a level commensurate with that of the anticipated guests. This proactive approach will mitigate the risk of your becoming a source of amusement and compromising the integrity of the event.
Absolutely agree. Before inviting guests like Dr. Ankit Shah, it's crucial to be well-prepared and elevate your hosting skills. Otherwise, the integrity of the conversation suffers, and it becomes more of a spectacle than a meaningful exchange. If this trend persists, unsubscribing might be the best move for seeking out better-hosted discussions. #PrepareBetter #ConsiderUnsubscribing
Well done Prakhar, despite his polar disagreement with the rhetoric and even certain positions of Ankit, he conducted the debate with utmost respect and civility. Gave the interlocuter full freedom to express his arguments and had a good ear to listen and address each of them while steelmanning at every step. Regardless of what the comments say here, this was a fine job. Kudos to you!
Yeah ofcourse sanatan family economics is best. Just see typical local baniya's/businessmen families who don't follow western templates and do laxmi pujan, only earn ethical profits . Never seen them earning more than 25% profit margin, never seen them charging more than 6-7% interest rate to their borrowers and of course their employees which they call as naukar with respect earn more than 30-40K and there is no nepotism unlike IT jobs where it's always the son becomes the next CEO. One thing is best, they always pay taxes honestly to the country.
Respectfully, Prakhar's conduct didn't reflect respectful debate. Rather than challenging, he appeared to dominate a more knowledgeable individual. Genuine debate involves mutual respect and willingness to engage, which seemed lacking here. #RespectfulDebate #MutualEngagement
@@srsvg We both probably saw a different episode. Prakhar gave far more respect than what was due, and steelmanned Ankit's arguments to a far far higher degree than he needed to. He listened carefully to all his arguments, engaged with them, and point by point challenged them to get to a better place of understanding and learning. Ankit has a set in stone worldview(so much for not being abrahamic) based on vast generalizations and unprecise rhetoric, and he never gets genuinely challenged or countered or gets any opportunity to grow his or his interlocutor's knowledge or understanding. First time seeing his arguments get challenged in an empirical way. Perhaps his audience isn't used to all this, looking at the reaction in the comments.
@@Alduizard he couldn't even explain why would Americans destroy their own country knowingly, where their children also live. Koi kitna bhi selfish ho , they won't destroy their country just for no reason.
No nandi bull also got harmed. Joke was actually on nandi bulls. German shepherd might be laughing silently somewhere at the peak of stupidity displayed here.
Totally agree. Prakhar’s podcasting is pure cringe. What’s with the scoffing, exasperating, raising the voice, constantly interrupting, and putting words in the guest’s mouth.
These discussion are like "Samudra Manthan" - It produces good, bad, ugly and eventually great and gorgeous things. We need to ensure we don't give up when the bad things pops up initially.
Prakhar Bhai Baat ko samajhne ke liye shaant rahna zaroori hai I appreciate that you wanted to summarise things every now and then. But, most of the time you were just interrupting with something we call 'Ku-tark' which felt malicious. I also know that your intention wasn't so but you need not get over excited and jump to conclusions. Huge respect to Mr Shah, learnt a lot of new perspectives from him.
Absolutely! Prakhar's attempts at juggling between podcasting and debating really don't do justice to hosting someone like Ankit Shah. It feels like he's trying too hard but ends up stepping on the wisdom being shared. Letting the guest complete their thoughts could truly elevate the conversation. Here's to hoping for a change where brilliance can fully unfold!
Prakhar Bhai, sach mein, baat ko gehraai se samajhne ke liye shaant rahna padta hai. Aapka har samay beech mein 'Ku-tark' ke sath baat katna, bhale hi bura iraada na ho, sunne walon ko thoda pareshan kar deta hai. Mr. Shah se bohot kuch naya seekhne ko mila, par aapka Arnab Goswami banne ki koshish aur over excitement ne asli mudde se dhyaan bhatka diya. Agar aap bhi mehsoos kar rahe hain ki is channel se woh gehraai aur samajh nahi mil rahi, toh shayad unsubscribe kar dena hi sahi rahega. #SamajhAurGehraaiKiTalaash #UnsubscribeKarkeSahiDishaMeinJaaye
fun fact, austria has reduced girl marriage age limit from 19 to 15 yrs age and more european countries are doing this. So Ankit Shah's point kinda makes sense
He is right because in North India , Rajasthan you have aana system and in up Bihar you have gauna which means after child merriage you will go to your sasural after becoming adult that ritual is called gauna / aana
Sati system, child marriage, north Indians doing marriage ceremony in night,the groom keeps a sword or knife during marriage ceremony,Women taking घुंगट to cover the face were added in Hinduism as a safety against Islamic Invaders. It was Flexibility of Sanatan that we survived 1000 years of Islamic and British crusades.
But questions were so stupid that he ended up making a JOKE of himself. Whoever sees the last 15 mins would pity at the brain level of prakhar. What is so difficult to understand what Shah is saying. Prakhar foolishly forcing Shah to call parents and presidents stupid. Dr Shah proved Prakhar is the most stupid of all at the end.
Just 10 mins into podcast and can feel that the host is trying to pounce upon the guest. The body language is very aggressive and he is making points that are not at all making sense, his followup are not at all related to answers. Kudos to Ankit for keeping calm.
If simple counter questioning and logical rebuttals are made to better understand HIS arguments so they won't be misinterpreted seems like "pouncing" to you then dear sir please get out of echochambers
I’m not in any echo chambers & I was talking about his body language, he seemed to be almost shouting. Also his followup initially were way out of context.
@@vedantvasav9723lol in no way are those counter question, he simply doesn't understand about sanatana much, hence so many questions. The more he learns the lesser question he will have
This man lives in la la land - 99.?? % accuracy. He’s just observing current events , applying some primitive analysis and comes up with prediction… some comes up true and then he’s making much dramatic prediction which neo-right class finds aspiring so they follow him.. There are big holes in his long term predictions and his theories
Host have lots of opportunities to improve on understanding the proficient guest and preparing questions before inviting respected guest as Dr. Ankit Shah.
He didn't even raise his voice. It was all Prakhar getting agitated and asking stupid questions "stupid or not stupid?". What the hell was that? Why would you box anyone with binary options? I should ask him: What is your name? "Stupid or Not Stupid"? Only binary answers!
Dr Ankit Shah is a very keen observer of society and original thinker. I will clarify there is no contradiction in 25 yrs of brahmcharya and balika badhu. The four ashrams system was running in olden times when there was no real or apparent threat. But once the invaders came and started religious social and economic plunder balika badhu was one of the ways to provide securities to our girls. It must have led to population build up but emotional integration of the girls in there in laws homes was also better. Balika badhu was a temporary phase therefore and was auto corrected largely by society itself as people became more enlightened with improving education and which has now been taken care of by law
Indeed, Dr. Ankit Shah's insights are a treasure. It’s unfortunate how Prakhar's attempt to imitate Arnab Goswami’s confrontational style fails to do justice to such nuanced discussions. Shah's perspective on historical practices like Balika Badhu, framed within societal changes, deserves a platform that appreciates depth over drama. If you're also feeling the disconnect and seeking more meaningful content, hitting unsubscribe might just send the right message. #ValueDepth #TimeToUnsubscribe
Suppose a woman or girl can be picked up by anyone like sandeshkhali. Then how are you going to protect her. Only by marrying her you get 2 families to do that
Also the average lifespan was greatly reduced in the subcontinent after invasions. The number of people surviving beyond 35 years of age was quite low.
@@namansinghnegi8931 we can just look at the population of Kshatriyas , maximum is 9-10% range in Rajasthan Himachal Uttarakhand. Rest is 5-6%. Most states is less than 3%. So how much they have died in all the wars
19:11 Prakhar raised a brilliant point here which Ankit never addresses, that Sanatan society as Ankit describes it, paves way for the collective(s) over the individual in many ways, and how would an individual(not mob) based auto-reform mode function within such a setting. Would it not inevitably lead to many instances where the mob pressure wins, or the reforms genuinely go south or never happen? Infact, if we look at the reforms and the people who pursued them in our history, they faced quite a lot of backlash from the larger society of their times and went against the collective will in many ways to bring about a lot of such positive changes. Savarkar's example is one of them. The "auto-reform" mode doesn't function for exactly the same reason Prakhar mentioned in his argument. If we take this even further, the 'balika vadhu' example he gave, even there a bunch of potentially different reforms could have happened within hindu society that made it stronger to tackle the enemy more directly and firmly instead of those that required us to compromise significantly with our own lives and morals. The "auto-reform" mindset fails to comprehend that things that were needed to be reformed would not have existed to begin with if there weren't negative reforms(and instead better positive ones) in the first place.
I think thats why we had shastrarth were people will win by logical public debate. Although debate is not a peoper word Thats h9w shankaracharya through shastrarth reformed india and hinduism in a propee way
Listening to Ankit makes me feel how little I know about our Snantan Dharma and why reading is important. Need to extensively study old texts and understand the context
@@rutvikrs u r right he didn’t mention any verse. I’m saying about my need to learn about Dharma as to understand why we have/had certain traditions. We need to learn from our mistakes in past and pass knowledge to our future generations.
Prakhar please bring Robert Kiyosaki in you podcast and grill the same way you did with Ankit. I am sure he's going to have tantrums after 15 minutes. Kudos to Ankit for his patience. 🎉
The initial two minutes of the video reveal the host's egregious behavior, demonstrating a lack of respect. However, Dr. Ankit Shah deserves admiration for his poise throughout the ordeal.
Utterly disappointed by the way the host is moderating the podcast... He doesn't even have a minimal sense that you allow the guest to have his say after you ask him a question, Let him complete rather than imposing or interfering in between and spoiling the show... Dr. Ankit Shah responded in a calm and composed manner inspite of such haphazard way of hosting the show... I came here only for Dr. Ankit Shah but I'm quite dissatisfied by the way the podcast was organised...
Completely agree. The host's lack of moderation and constant interference overshadowed the insightful dialogue. Dr. Ankit Shah's composure amidst this chaos was commendable. If this continues, unsubscribing might be the best choice for better-organized content. #DisappointedViewer #ConsiderUnsubscribing
I enjoyed it. We romanticize our past way too much. We definitely had a few weaknesses as a civilization but Dr Ankit Shah can't admit it and that's problematic too. Prakhar's interrupts were necessary for the exact same reason.
The shock and awe is real for the first timer. But listening is a skill. You could have talked about the dharmic principles on which he has based his thoughts. Wokism is so real. Dharma is the counter.
Prakhar bro! Your arguments were irritating in this podcast. Or maybe Ankit shah was not able to explain properly. Maybe you were playing the devils advocate.
@@ankushmamgain8227 He didn't deny completely though. He agreed we were not centralized and britishers had already looted other countries on the way, thus had more experience at that. Also, looting without morales is easier than defending.
Definitely felt that too. It seemed like Prakhar was really trying, maybe a bit too hard, to stir things up by playing devil's advocate. But it just ended up making the conversation more challenging than it needed to be, especially with a guest like Ankit Shah. There's a fine line between healthy debate and disrupting the flow, and this time it leaned more towards disruption. Hoping for more harmonious exchanges in the future!
I beg to differ with most comments here. It's absolutely fantastic that Prakhar argues and interrupts the guest so much because that way he made it more lucid and clear right from the beginning, otherwise the topic would have gone over and above most common people's heads. Guest is fantastic in keeping his calm and answering each doubt with such clarity. Fantastic podcast.
I am a CEO of a software company and enjoying the success that my employees are having in their lives. Not focused on my own profits. The iterviewer needs to be more open. Listen bachhe. Don't speak. Give a thought.
@@rutvikrs It can be done. That's what Ankit said. Instead of saving money and investing in Share market, parents should give the funds to their children to start businesses. Investing in share market is literally making MNCs rich and creating jobs that their own children and gonna get. Job seeking mentality has to be replaced with entrepreneurial mentality.
Chomu, not everyone needs to be a yes sir merchants. If the guest agrees to a podcast he needs to face different forms of conversation not just expect nodding the head to everything you say.
Yes! Yes! This is actually the point Mr Ankit Shah was trying to make. We as an audience understood it perfectly, but the host didn't. Excellent observation.
He is correct ❤❤❤ and I am hindu wing ❤❤ and bcz of western model there are no family system in west we need sanathni model ❤❤ to save culture and family.
@@heisenborgir1615 No you are absolutely wrong... Kids demand freedom and wanna live free life with bf-gf. U can see it being copied to some extent in tier-1 cities in india.
I'm from the usa and i promise everyone here that you guys should not emulate the west culturally. Economically and developmentally yes, culturally no.
Prakhar u have less knowledge and awareness about geo economics , missionary school , history of India , culture , society , why r u trying to interrupt every second , i recommend u to listen ankit shah previous interview and there though , clear dikh rha h is podcast me ki apke palle hi nhi pad rha ye sb
Host needs to work harder to be able to understand what is being said in one time. Ankit had to say same concept in 2-3 ways to make him understand. Some questions of host was good but many were repetitive and too obvious to answer. Work on it. And by the way, the top example of Left pretending to be right was Abhijit Iyer Mitra. He used to keep abusing all day to the indic wing and now suddenly he became Modi Praising spokesperson. This change was because of people like Ankit Shah, who exposed them in public directly. Although there are many other examples.
(😊प्रखर ,अभिजीत अय्यर, कुशल मेहरा )वही लेफ्टिस्ट है जो राइट विंग दिखने का प्रयास कर रहा है। इसी की बात अंकित शाह जी कर रहे है,की कुछ लेफ्टिस्ट अचानक से राइट विंग बन गए है 2014 के बाद।😅
Absolutely agree! It's clear that Prakhar is putting in the effort, but when it comes to facilitating a conversation with someone as knowledgeable as Mr. Anikt Shah, there seems to be a gap. It's not just about asking questions; it's about understanding the depth of the answers. Here's hoping for better-prepared hosts in future episodes, for guests and viewers alike! 🙏 #RoomForGrowth
i used to think Ankit Shah was a scammer who is just talking stupid things bc the audience will like it. But after a year, i have to say, his logic and thinking is truly unique and bhartiya in every way. his talks makes sense and he doesn't force feed any opinion anyways
when i first started watching him on jaipur dialogues used to think he does not makes sense but all his predictions became true , now I have even left thinking the reasons and just accepted if it is his prediction it will be true
@@sg042 he predicted that there will be killings in pakistan , he predicted that saudi will go back to its pagan roots and 2 months later saudi announced that they take pride in their linear gods , he said you will see royals in diplomacy and then rajkumari divyakumari was given the work to handle emanuel maron and there are many more
Very impressive young man questioning Ankitji. Vital that queries are made non-sucophantically, and challenging done respectfully and non-egotistically.
To understand Ankit shah logic you have to be knowledge of 2000 years history , abrahamic religion , early system of Hindu society and the system of modern society. The early system of Hindu society is mainly focus on society collectively work they not much dependent on the state, state is only responsible for security that's why even invader came in Bharat most of the common people think it is normal fight as usual happened like the Bhartiya kings , when Bhartiya kings start fighting they not harm the civilians they fight like tournament there are much story where the fight is going on near by the farmer is farming written by foreigner traveller's
Absolutely, Ankit Shah’s insights need deep historical and societal understanding but host is overshadowing genuine conversation. It's a missed opportunity for rich dialogue. If you’re also seeking deeper content and are disappointed here, perhaps unsubscribing is the next step. #DeepInsightsNeeded #UnsubscribeForBetter
true ,he actully showed the mindset of western society when about Making Prediction topic started his first reaction was paisa hi paisa banao , i'll quit everything and do market and all bhal blah .They only think about money they dont have any moral or ethical values which ankit sir was talking about he was not even trying to understand this simple thing only thing he was doing waS arguing arguing and arguing. @@ip1325
In a simpler way : Some one is going to put gun on your mouth - The book says - time is 10.30 and you have to pray now. The other one is free to decide ; The first person will not flee , and therefore will not survive , while the other free person will .... I don't know why the guy finds its difficult to believe "auto mode" . The person who does not believe in book will flee , and he /she does not go in to fleeing mode forever .... once the threat is over he/she will get back to life. Is that too complex to understand?
I liked how ideas from Ankit are challenged in this podcast, but @PrakharkePravachan could have been a bit more polite. Great points raised by @PrakharkePravachan though! This will help Ankit think through his ideas throughly and help us all understand them even better rather than taking them on the face value. Kudos to you both!
Prakharke seemed clueless. When Ankit said a man should be celibate till 25, he brought up child marriage without getting the idea clear that in Sanatan you modify with time by keeping the core as similar as possible. Yes child marriage was need of course during invasion but that doesn’t mean people or man where all getting married at a young age. It was mostly region based. The region that faced most. Invasion saw change in society but regions where comparatively less affected, continued as it did before the invasion. Let’s make few things clear. We know things mostly about what happened 200yrs ago and based on that we have created many assumptions. Honestly. There are books writing by French travellers who wrote that Hindus women didn’t put veil but Muslims women did. Hindu women were more morally superior and lived a pious life with pride, while Muslims women got men visitors and were looked down upon by Hindus as well as foreigners!
Lol if you see from western lens you won't understand ankit.. But if even a common devout from a village is faced with ankit he can clearly understand him😂 bcz he talks of sanatana
Absolutely, challenging ideas is essential for a fruitful discussion, but there's a fine line between challenging and dominating. Prakhar's approach seemed more about asserting dominance rather than engaging in constructive dialogue. Ankit's insights deserved more respectful engagement. If this pattern continues, it might be worth reconsidering the dynamics of the podcast. #RespectfulDialogue #EqualEngagement
Prakhar bhaiya , i have an advice for you before next episode please do first a good research about our culture and sanatan system so that you could discuss more well in each and every topic with ankit sir because in this one you were looking like so impacted by western model . I respect you love you. Thats why i urge you we want 1 more podcast ...sir but with a good research ❤
@@harshad040 I have read 3 versions of it. ISKCON, Janapriya Valmiki Ramayana and Gita press. I am asking a specific question, what is Ankit's research based because I have never seen him quote a book, an author or even a verse.
@@harshad040 and I request you to stop using t phrases like "go read x/y/z" "do your research" and "you have western lens". These are non specific statements and show a lack of rigour.
@@rutvikrsif you read ramayana n mahabharata still didnt got anything out of it then your reading was not fruitful. Probably its out of your capacity but to understand sanatana you dont need to read scriptures. If you live in village which is far away from city and observe their kiving, their thinking their actiions, traditions. Have conversatiins with elders and you will understand sanatana dharma easily
That's his default mode ...and his approach is old and obsolete ..chote bachhe dekhe hai ...dekho 😂 let me understand aap ye kah rahe the ....half video goes into her himself understanding what his guest is saying
Thanks Prakhar. Your arguments really made sense to me atleast. Respect for you for going against the herd and asking things which really make sense rather than being in echo chamber. Ankit Shah promotes family entrepreneurship and blames capitalism (big corporates). Doesn't make sense to me why first is better than second. Just see any local Baniya, despite being least influenced by western culture. Are they not making more than 25% profits. Just compare the salaries of employees you will see who is exploiting more. Seen so many charging 24% interest rate, lying about the quality, but never faced any issues with DMART. Sethji at local shop might have less skill than his employee but still richer than him, but in corporate world so many people from poor background also get good salary and might even become CEO. That's why never seen these family businesses building revolutionary products(like chatgpt, youtube, google, tesla). Does he even know the benefit of fiat currency ? Agar fiat currency na hoti to covid mai economic downfall aane ke baad kabhi recvover nahi hota, fiat ki wajah se hi economy ko boost mila. In non fiat currency era, GDP used to fluctuate a lot and sometimes decrease for many decades because you can not simply kickstart an economy. Agar gold currency hoti to deflation hota and deflation is terrible for the economy. Why would someone invest his fiat currency, when currency itself is appreciating with time. Fiat currency promotes entrepreneurship. He thinks himself to be god or something. 99% predictions correct, Is he joking or what? . Just a simple argument he is not able to counter: IF American leadership are not stupid, why would they hurt their own interest ? Koi maja aayega kya desh khatam karke. NRIs are only successful, because they are Sanatani. Unka effort kuch kaam ka nahi, are they not more intelligent? The only way to improve as a society is to understand that yes we have some weaknesses but we can improve and not thinking like him that sab changa hai, wo to sab bahar wale hai jo kharab hai, hamari society best hai. Hamari society mai to casteism hi nahi hai, female empowerment bahut hai, when daily you see evidences against them. Chalo invasion mai ye sab hua, but aaj kyun ho raha hai, sanatan itna self correcting hai to already hua kyun nahi. Wo to bhala hai govt intervention ka jinki wajah se women representations bada, lower caste ke log temple mai enter kar paye. Aur ye attitude wale log kahte hai ki Indian's to hamesha debate karte hai and we are very rational. I understand why likes of Ankit Shah are popular, because their followers get sense of security ki baaki saari countries kharab hai aur ham best jee rahe hai and unhe yahi sunna achha lagta hai. I don't understand Why he compare only with America, why not compare with other countries ? I am pro India, pro right wing but this attitude of thinking we are best and there is no need to learn from others looks very bad to me. Ankit shah se ek baar to puchna ki aisi koi to cheez hogi jo ham learn kar sakte hai bahar se, I am damn sure he will say nothing "we are the best".
@@mayankindian3750 to kya unke Desh Mai koi acchi baat nahi hai Jo Sikha ka sake. And USA se hi compare kyun , Japan se kyun nahi . Ayodhya railway station dekh lo kitna unclean kar Diya logo ne , Japan ke log jab stadium jaate hai to stadium pura stadium clean kar ke aate hai. Yaha fiat currency, westernization kaha se aaya. But Ankit says like sanatana Dharma self correcting hai to automatic log achhe ho jayenge, but that's not the truth. I want india to be the best that's why I criticize it. Singapore, korea, Vietnam, china sab apne se bhi poor the but in countries ne bhi 50 years mai kitna improve Kiya , ye nahi bola ki USA ganda hai).
The podcast is aptly titled "Pravachan" coz the host clearly doesn't want to listen to the guest and wants to start preaching right away. Is he high on something? Substance, ego, western education maybe.
