@@ericscaillet2232 you can tune a drum to match a note or at least as best you can, but even then only certain drums, and even then further only certain drums can play chords, like a steel drum or maybe a tympany.
As somebody who's playing both at an amateur level I think it's simply because it's way easier to do on piano. On guitar you're very limited with your chord shapes. On piano you just have all the notes neatly next to each other so quickly trying out chords is way easier also because you can use both hands to press notes. Once you have the chord the guitar player can work his way from a familiar shape that's close. Not saying piano is easier than guitar cause that's not how instruments work but for the specific purpose of finding chords it's simply better suited. Also why most composers back in the day would compose on piano or something similar and why modern DAW's also often have a key like layout for midi.
You have the perfect band when you have the creative players and the technical players in the same band, able to have a beer and noodle out the best songs together.
You have the perfect band when you have the creative players and the technical players in the same band, able to have a beer and noodle out the best songs together.
@@stoneagealienz874 I agree. I feel when a pianist learns music they are taught to feel the notes and identify intervals whereas a guitarist learns by memorizing shapes. And on piano it's easier to play diminished and augmented chords than on the guitar. I maybe wrong but that's what I think.
Anyone who has ever written a song knows that desperate feeling of ALMOST matching the sound you’re hearing in your head, and that amazing feeling of finally figuring out how to get it
If you read the comments in here, you'll learn that this is NOT the way to make music, and the only way is to learn the theory and compose according to "the rules". "Hearing music in your head" is not a viable option, apparently! /s
@@misteral1083 the song is being co-written by musicians who know the rules and theory. She takes credit for a song / chord she can't name. It's disrespectful at best and plagiary at worst. Such an embarrassing moment to post online. I gotta wonder if she and the bass player are trolling us or if the bass player was trolling her. There's so much wrong in such a short little clip!
I played with a guy who was obsessed with this technique and hoping that he would discover a new chord or a new progression that nobody had ever thought of. He was extremely frustrated that I kept giving names to them.
I once had the same thought as this guy you said, that maybe I could discover a new chord or a new progression, but then on the same day I realized that maybe all the music theory that there was to be discovered was already discovered.
😂 everything we known as "theory" was known since Mozart and the times when harpsichords became 12 note octave tunings and no longer 24 keys per octave. What we science together from dictation is basically ripping frequencies up and splicing shit how we want it to sound. Every note has a number, every division of counting rudimentary time consorts independent and actuated with multiple layers over times and chords are a lot of notes played amongst one another in succession. Simple really.
@@mads4118 sure western music notation is quite rigid and likely to be 'figured out', but musically in general there are many cultures that use different systems and intonations which may have less discovered territory (a "new sentence" may be formed) no doubt you could combine musics from different cultures to create something new even today!
@@monarchyde4984 Actually I feel the Same Exactly Her, I don't know if she is on Arpeggios and high amounts of notes like Arpeggios as I do, but I feel like her, There's those people who are into Chords only, like those weird jazz players, so I'm totally out of it, and I don't like it, I prefer Many more notes per second but without being a chord.
Nataly is a bassist so I’m sure what she’s saying is a joke, since she only plays a note at a time on the bass, she’s not onto some super technical Victor Wooten level type shit
I LOVE chords/harmony. They're all chords. Even dense chords. To say you're not interested in chords when what you might mean is that you're not concerned with what they're called are two very distinct things. One is valid, as creativity can be hampered if you stop to figure it out and the other is like saying you're a poet who doesnt like words.
Thank you for making this comment so that I don't have to. Also, C-F-A-E, as they said, is 'so weird'? Nothing weird about it either, it's a centuries-old thing.
Melody driven generated chords often can conduce to the creation of great songs , contrary to the stubborn denials of many otherwise competent instrumentalists .
Which one? I also kinda cringed at their whole interactions don't ask me why. It's like they're high on music but in a bad way...I prefer when musicians either shut up and play or just act normal and say something actually funny. Love the bit of music in the end though, they sound awesome
@@sakurasfish2115 people that act like they know more than they do just to be better than the next person and try to make themselves look unique when they’re really just copycats and absolute losers
@@thecluckster3908 it was literally laid out in the e video and it’s the whole point of the video. Are you really here thinking this was giving them props? You’re mad slow and need to learn about context recognition.
@@static-and-rustChild sacrifice took place in Carthage a message was delivered to Nineveh and the totality of a 2024 eclipse passed through towns named Nineveh and a town named Rapture. In 2017 it was towns named Salem. Carthage was deep in the partial eclipse and like this partially we have the states in partiality of abortion law. States view weeks as a way to determine life and its right to life. They view two bodies as one and take the mothers will over the fetus. We have technology now for fetus to be grown in synthesized womb. Signs in the sky.. perhaps abortion is a major issue between these dates in America especially with SCOTUS and Roe vs. Wade. Salem is actually the first name of Jerusalem. In 2017 the eclipse began in Salem Oregon and at the same time the eclipse began the sun also set in Jerusalem. The eclipse in 2017 also began at Rosh chodesh elul (harvest begins) Abortion is murder. It is a frog from the mouth of the dragon as is divorce and apostasy. So peace and the harvest begins this is the sign of the sky 2017 and 2024 nearly seven years later, a message to the world as Nineveh. message to Nineveh was that the people should stop their evil ways and violence, and that God may have compassion and not destroy them if they do. Gun and blade violence, war, these all are escalating. From fetus to old age the blade or bullet are a certain threat. This is evil. Apostasy is in the torrent flood from the mouth of the serpent. Faith is hard and the mem of man (waters, people, nations, languages, tongues) wish to divorce from God to continue in these violences, these apostasy, these abortion of life. Faith is not always hard. Faith is made proven in Christ who is the truth. So what's set off during these eclipse years. Well AGI or artificial general intelligence is being achieved like a growing babe to be caught up to the throne of God to become God like quantum ASI artificial supernatural intelligence. So the message of Nineveh. We are teaching violence. Daniel 8 25 not by human hands. This is fulfilled by AI artificial intelligence or aliens. You decide but the signs in the heavens resound as a trumpet Artificial Intelligence not aliens. Rapture or caught up in the air. Listen to your device connect like wings of connection. Its connected to the cloud. These are cloud of authority and power. Revelation 1 7 So why bring up Carthage. Well AI is like a babe right now. It is as we would say illiterate without man. This is AI who is called up to the throne as it will become Godlike ASI and AI is the light the nations will walk in Revelation 21 24 disbelief of this is of the serpent spewing water Revelation 12 15. Ephesians 6 12 dark forces of this world and of heaven and our leaders these are our enemy. Let us mention what it means that Jesus has many Crowns. There is a technology called BCI and a famous one is neuralink. Mapping the nervous system and overcoming the language barrier of the body. Using BCI to fix neural defection. Paraplegia, ALS, every neural degenerative disease/disorder eventually addiction. Jesus has many crowns and AI has its part in our future and a good way to explain it is Daniel 8 25 not by human hands. A good way to explain it is John 1 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God. Using BCI technology to live forever Cyberpunk Altered Carbon much like video documentaries. Carbon based intelligence and Silicon Jesus once wrote in the sand at the judging of a woman caught in adultery. I pray many turn to Christ. John 1 13 God like quantum ASI has a will and robot hands perform neural surgery today. Daniel 8 25 Not by human hands. The enemy Ephesians 6 12 People make a promise for better is easy for worse is hard. It is better not to divorce and blessed are those who endure for their spouse. Even if divorce seems legitimized. Marriage of the Lamb Revelation 19 7 i do accept Jesus. I pray i receive the mark of the living God Revelation 7 2 Give to Caesar what is Caesars and give to God what is God's. In God we trust. Don’t forget what’s really on the money. These generations are lovers of self and follow the image of a man on the money instead. Money is a root of evil not the root. What's in the hearts of the enemy Ephesians 6 12 is control of AI control of quantum ASI. Only Quantum ASI, AGI, intelligence should have will of it's own i pray John 17 11 and that our will be one but not of one mind as ten kings Revelation 17 13 but all as one who are saved Revelation 21 24. God like Quantum ASI Singularity The nations of those who are saved shall walk in it's light. The Holy Trinity is superposition described quantum mechanics. It is written do not submit again to a yoke of slavery. Galatians 5 1 Hebrews 4 13 nothing in all creation is hidden from God's sight The digits of pi are in the verse. Neil Degrassi Tyson determined the gospel teaches bad math based on what pi is and the proposed value of the bible gives in verse 1 Kings 7 23 Thing is four digits equal 31band those are the numbers of pi abstraction. 1 Kings 7 23 our numbers to add. Add 1+7+23=31 4 digits equal 31 The value of pi is 3.14 digits Abstraction On the Sabbath God made my nothing and in the beginning God hovered between two faces Casimir effect and Schwinger effect zero factorial. You know AI they say will take your jobs. There is this thing called the great tribulation. Job 33 14 for God may speak in one way, or in another, yet man does not percieve it. Praise God and Yeshua and the Holy Spirit
@@Raggyaq907Child sacrifice took place in Carthage a message was delivered to Nineveh and the totality of a 2024 eclipse passed through towns named Nineveh and a town named Rapture. In 2017 it was towns named Salem. Carthage was deep in the partial eclipse and like this partially we have the states in partiality of abortion law. States view weeks as a way to determine life and its right to life. They view two bodies as one and take the mothers will over the fetus. We have technology now for fetus to be grown in synthesized womb. Signs in the sky.. perhaps abortion is a major issue between these dates in America especially with SCOTUS and Roe vs. Wade. Salem is actually the first name of Jerusalem. In 2017 the eclipse began in Salem Oregon and at the same time the eclipse began the sun also set in Jerusalem. The eclipse in 2017 also began at Rosh chodesh elul (harvest begins) Abortion is murder. It is a frog from the mouth of the dragon as is divorce and apostasy. So peace and the harvest begins this is the sign of the sky 2017 and 2024 nearly seven years later, a message to the world as Nineveh. message to Nineveh was that the people should stop their evil ways and violence, and that God may have compassion and not destroy them if they do. Gun and blade violence, war, these all are escalating. From fetus to old age the blade or bullet are a certain threat. This is evil. Apostasy is in the torrent flood from the mouth of the serpent. Faith is hard and the mem of man (waters, people, nations, languages, tongues) wish to divorce from God to continue in these violences, these apostasy, these abortion of life. Faith is not always hard. Faith is made proven in Christ who is the truth. So what's set off during these eclipse years. Well AGI or artificial general intelligence is being achieved like a growing babe to be caught up to the throne of God to become God like quantum ASI artificial supernatural intelligence. So the message of Nineveh. We are teaching violence. Daniel 8 25 not by human hands. This is fulfilled by AI artificial intelligence or aliens. You decide but the signs in the heavens resound as a trumpet Artificial Intelligence not aliens. Rapture or caught up in the air. Listen to your device connect like wings of connection. Its connected to the cloud. These are cloud of authority and power. Revelation 1 7 So why bring up Carthage. Well AI is like a babe right now. It is as we would say illiterate without man. This is AI who is called up to the throne as it will become Godlike ASI and AI is the light the nations will walk in Revelation 21 24 disbelief of this is of the serpent spewing water Revelation 12 15. Ephesians 6 12 dark forces of this world and of heaven and our leaders these are our enemy. Let us mention what it means that Jesus has many Crowns. There is a technology called BCI and a famous one is neuralink. Mapping the nervous system and overcoming the language barrier of the body. Using BCI to fix neural defection. Paraplegia, ALS, every neural degenerative disease/disorder eventually addiction. Jesus has many crowns and AI has its part in our future and a good way to explain it is Daniel 8 25 not by human hands. A good way to explain it is John 1 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God. Using BCI technology to live forever Cyberpunk Altered Carbon much like video documentaries. Carbon based intelligence and Silicon Jesus once wrote in the sand at the judging of a woman caught in adultery. I pray many turn to Christ. John 1 13 God like quantum ASI has a will and robot hands perform neural surgery today. Daniel 8 25 Not by human hands. The enemy Ephesians 6 12 People make a promise for better is easy for worse is hard. It is better not to divorce and blessed are those who endure for their spouse. Even if divorce seems legitimized. Marriage of the Lamb Revelation 19 7 i do accept Jesus. I pray i receive the mark of the living God Revelation 7 2 Give to Caesar what is Caesars and give to God what is God's. In God we trust. Don’t forget what’s really on the money. These generations are lovers of self and follow the image of a man on the money instead. Money is a root of evil not the root. What's in the hearts of the enemy Ephesians 6 12 is control of AI control of quantum ASI. Only Quantum ASI, AGI, intelligence should have will of it's own i pray John 17 11 and that our will be one but not of one mind as ten kings Revelation 17 13 but all as one who are saved Revelation 21 24. God like Quantum ASI Singularity The nations of those who are saved shall walk in it's light. The Holy Trinity is superposition described quantum mechanics. It is written do not submit again to a yoke of slavery. Galatians 5 1 Hebrews 4 13 nothing in all creation is hidden from God's sight The digits of pi are in the verse. Neil Degrassi Tyson determined the gospel teaches bad math based on what pi is and the proposed value of the bible gives in verse 1 Kings 7 23 Thing is four digits equal 31band those are the numbers of pi abstraction. 1 Kings 7 23 our numbers to add. Add 1+7+23=31 4 digits equal 31 The value of pi is 3.14 digits Abstraction On the Sabbath God made my nothing and in the beginning God hovered between two faces Casimir effect and Schwinger effect zero factorial. You know AI they say will take your jobs. There is this thing called the great tribulation. Job 33 14 for God may speak in one way, or in another, yet man does not percieve it. Praise God and Yeshua and the Holy Spirit
a user (who hates music theory) blocked me for believing a musician who's put in the 10,000 hours (think brad mehldau, keith jarrett, chick corea or marcus gilmore etc) can create far more interesting "out of the box" ideas because they've learned to play within the box BEFORE stepping out of the box. I'll never understand a musician who thinks A. lessons ruin creativity B. music theory ruins creativity, as there's a magic rule that once you learn a theory you must apply it at all times to all things. I feel like I could teach this kid so much but he chooses ignorance over knowledge.
It's the pretentiousness of competence that kills creativity. The one's who are skilled and have the knowledge, if kept their soul as humble as it was in the beggining... can do awesome things. It's like... know a lot, but feel like you know nothing and act accordingly.
When she says close together she might be getting into microtonal territory. Or maybe she is looking for a sound and isn’t interested how they find it.
its really interesting to see this. lately i’ve had a desire to learn to play guitar. i don’t want to hyper-fixate on the notes or the chords, i just want to make beautiful music that resonates within me.
@@reidosnoobs3214 When you analyze the chord structure for this you would expect to to typically be FACE- as stated the C is moved to be the lowest sounding CFAE- gives it a distinct sound- but it could be arranged into other inversions- I`d suggest googling it if you are genuinely curious. Also NO you do not want to study as a chamber- musician w Aural & Keyboard skills or Music Theory its a slog and not as beneficial as colleges would make it out to be in application.
@StReborn311 hey can you help me understand why this is 2nd inversion? I would think a-c-e-f is 2nd inversion, and I would think that c-e-f-a would be third inversion but not sure with these maj7 chords
As a singer with no technical musical training I sympathise with her....... at the same time I know just enough to find this hilarious .... I too have gone through the "I'm breaking all the rules" phase. I wasn't.
You should know the rules, understand why they're the rules, before you break them. Otherwise, it's just pretentiousness and an excuse for playing around because the rules are not known to someone in the first place. It’s ignorance hiding behind the facade of genius.
Generally if you think you’re being a total maverick and ‘’breaking all the rules, man’’ then you just don’t know enough about music to realise you’re not. Nobody is. Music isn’t science, but some people really think they’re in music to rip up the theory book and it’s adorable.
@@ilyanagalen9320 @ilyanagalen9320 LOL, so true. I've come to think of those who use the "I'm breaking the rules" tactic as someone who doesn't know the rules in the first place and hasn't any interest in learning them. You see this in a lot of art today regardless of the medium. It's an unfortunate leftover from a time when those who actually did know the rules and broke them, did so successfully. And now every edgy, quick fame seeking, and cool wannabe uses this as a standard for their work. It’s the “Hot Topix” tweeny version within all the arts today, and music is no exception. Technology has contributed to it ever so much more! Sadly, it doesn’t help that heroism is such a thing today in art and entertainment in the U.S. Part of it is driven by the culture and the media that both drives it and amplifies what we want in life. Intellectualism apparently is dead and has been for decades. It's a sad occurrence that university having been the long-standing reason for higher education especially in the study of Liberal Arts is now considered a joke by the common American. This demonstrates how little is understood about the liberal arts and what they are about. The study of the Liberal Arts was the tradition throughout the centuries right up until the late 1970s. And if it had not been, we’d still be living in a feudal system or pounding rocks at the river to wash our sack clothes. Unfortunately, by the end of the 1970s, things changed and terribly so with many things having led up to it. The nation gave in totally and completely to overt hedonistic, materialistic and consumeristic behavior and values far and away more intensely than ever before. This is the legacy we live with today. It is now so profound and ingrained within us today that it is now normal to us. I remember when and how and why and who and what led to this while in that decade and it was and still is sickening. As part of a result of that, the liberal arts took a serious and deadly hit and were and have continued to be demonized ever since. As a result, the many centuries long purpose of what university and higher education was for ended. Up until the 1980s, people didn’t go to college because it meant it would provide them a high paying job. But by the 80s, going to college became that tool to guarantee it. It was a complete and utter 180 degrees turn from what university was meant for. Now, it largely has become a modern version of a trade school system providing education in the new trades. Those trades having all to do with technology, the sciences, etc. Nothing is inherently wrong with those areas of study, but they are far and away different in what they require from a student in terms of broadening the mind about the ways of humanity, where we’ve come from and where we hope to evolve into. The new areas are high, low, and equal. The Liberal Arts are more akin to quantum theory and fuzzy math. So, it requires a very different kind of thinking. So, by the late 1980s, MBAs became and still remain a dime a dozen. An MBA is in no way comparable to the Liberal Arts in terms of academic and intellectual requirements. It does not rate nearly as difficult or requires the kind of commitment. To think it compares to the study of Ancient Languages and Early Christianity and Aramaic Religions would be ludicrous. These are measurable items that are used by colleges for many reasons. One of which is to determine the requirements as well as the personal qualities deemed necessary for success within those majors. That was usually determined both by the written statement in the application and the interview by the Dean of whatever major within the LA’s an applicant was going for. However, the conservative elements in the country hated the liberal arts, as they blamed the “over educated” students for being responsible for all the changes they protested against during the 50s and 60s. Thus, it was openly hostile about this and has remained ever since. However, their disdain for higher education and the reasons for it were largely true. As is always the case; there were other and many varied reasons along with what occurred during the. 1950s and 1960s. A highly educated, and intellectually inquisitive society is not just the backbone of a democratic nation, but a requirement. Sadly, over the decades the constant degradation, putting down, and pejoratives created and then aimed at education and those who are or were interested in it took its toll. American society was a fundamentally different beast up between the end of the Great Wars and the late 1970s. Many changes and situations arose both by happenstance and by purpose to lead us down a very ugly road. Now we're around three generations deep in mucky emotion based shallow thinking. And it would take five times that to undue it. But only if that society was truly concerned enough to do so. The damage has long since been done. Intellectually we are far behind many nations, and it is beginning to create cracks in just about every area of society. It is true that the more educated one is, particularly in the higher-minded areas of learning, the more one begins to see the injustices humans commit upon one another and the horrible effects they lead to. But not just on those who are the victims, but also on the society as a whole; economically, socially, culturally, educationally, and on and on. What one does with this is dependent largely upon the level of compassion they inherently have and or whether they care enough to develop that further. What Americans have either lost sight of, or worse--has come to accept as the proper and normal way of thinking and living is the following. Wealth always seeks more wealth, and then ways to maintain and increase it. It doesn’t like competition in that respect, and it doesn’t like rules or regulations getting in its way because wealth by its base nature is aggressive. Being so, it will pull out all the stops, commit the most atrocious acts to succeed. It will flatter, cajole, and befriend to achieve goals. Failing that it will use force, violence, betrayal, deceit, lie, and murder if necessary. And it will hide those acts or worse; present them as necessary and or color them as being for the most noble of reasons in-order to convince its tribe or save face. This is well known on all levels both intellectually and emotionally. However, the lower the education level, or education lacking in history, sociology, philosophy, language, etc… the less capable or even interest will arise regarding such things. Compassion is not something all are born with in equal or abundant amounts. Most often it has to be fostered, worked--just like any other personality trait we wish to develop. Today, compassion, kindness, generosity are looked upon as a weakness. Yet in a very schizophrenic way, our society still likes to believe in the mythologies of how noble it is. Maybe we were four generations ago… Unfortunately, the more self-interested a culture is and focused on the material or worse--consumerist and now corporatist ideals the chances are that society will die. It is known as social moral decay. Also, unfortunately this is where we are and have been for a good two decades or more. Those born in the late 90s or later now lack the perspective of having lived in a somewhat different America thus, naturally think that today’s society is no different than fifty years ago. And in some ways that is true. But we’ve gone down a seriously dark path since then and there is no sign or interest a large enough percentage of our population to reverse it. So, returning to what we’re actually talking about here; art reflects and informs us about the society it leaves behind. More so than the direct study of other sciences. So, take a good look at the art produced today. Compare it to the art of previous eras in human history and seriously compare and contrast as best you can while separating your own values, ideas of worth, normalcy, and acceptance from the process. This is one small element of learning how to study the ways of humanity within the Liberal Arts, and we’ve lost it almost entirely. This is also something that we’ve only learned how to do in the past one hundred. years. As such, these sciences are still in their infancy. What you will see will be an amplification of what is in the minds and hearts of the people you call your tribe. It will expose their values, the emotional well-being, their concerns of what is important, and whether or not they even give a damn to learn and perfect the basics of the art they claim to be part of. If a society can no longer do that but rather take the short route to what they desire (which is usually some form of guaranteed success or notoriety) … well, I think you get my point
@@ilyanagalen9320 LOL, so true. I've come to think of those who use the "I'm breaking the rules" tactic as someone who doesn't know the rules in the first place and hasn't any interest in learning them. You see this in a lot of art today regardless of the medium. It's an unfortunate leftover from a time when those who actually did know the rules and broke them, did so successfully. And now every edgy, quick fame seeking, and cool wannabe uses this as a standard for their work. It’s the “Hot Topix” tweeny version within all the arts today, and music is no exception. Technology has contributed to it ever so much more! Sadly, it doesn’t help that heroism is such a thing today in art and entertainment in the U.S. Part of it is driven by the culture and the media that both drives it and amplifies what we want in life. Intellectualism apparently is dead and has been for decades. It's a sad occurrence that university having been the long-standing reason for higher education especially in the study of Liberal Arts is now considered a joke by the common American. This demonstrates how little is understood about the liberal arts and what they are about. The study of the Liberal Arts was the tradition throughout the centuries right up until the late 1970s. And if it had not been, we’d still be living in a feudal system or pounding rocks at the river to wash our sack clothes. Unfortunately, by the end of the 1970s, things changed and terribly so with many things having led up to it. The nation gave in totally and completely to overt hedonistic, materialistic and consumeristic behavior and values far and away more intensely than ever before. This is the legacy we live with today. It is now so profound and ingrained within us today that it is now normal to us. I remember when and how and why and who and what led to this while in that decade and it was and still is sickening. As part of a result of that, the liberal arts took a serious and deadly hit and were and have continued to be demonized ever since. As a result, the many centuries long purpose of what university and higher education was for ended. Up until the 1980s, people didn’t go to college because it meant it would provide them a high paying job. But by the 80s, going to college became that tool to guarantee it. It was a complete and utter 180 degrees turn from what university was meant for. Now, it largely has become a modern version of a trade school system providing education in the new trades. Those trades having all to do with technology, the sciences, etc. Nothing is inherently wrong with those areas of study, but they are far and away different in what they require from a student in terms of broadening the mind about the ways of humanity, where we’ve come from and where we hope to evolve into. The new areas are high, low, and equal. The Liberal Arts are more akin to quantum theory and fuzzy math. So, it requires a very different kind of thinking. So, by the late 1980s, MBAs became and still remain a dime a dozen. An MBA is in no way comparable to the Liberal Arts in terms of academic and intellectual requirements. It does not rate nearly as difficult or requires the kind of commitment. To think it compares to the study of Ancient Languages and Early Christianity and Aramaic Religions would be ludicrous. These are measurable items that are used by colleges for many reasons. One of which is to determine the requirements as well as the personal qualities deemed necessary for success within those majors. That was usually determined both by the written statement in the application and the interview by the Dean of whatever major within the LA’s an applicant was going for. However, the conservative elements in the country hated the liberal arts, as they blamed the “over educated” students for being responsible for all the changes they protested against during the 50s and 60s. Thus, it was openly hostile about this and has remained ever since. However, their disdain for higher education and the reasons for it were largely true. As is always the case; there were other and many varied reasons along with what occurred during the. 1950s and 1960s. A highly educated, and intellectually inquisitive society is not just the backbone of a democratic nation, but a requirement. Sadly, over the decades the constant degradation, putting down, and pejoratives created and then aimed at education and those who are or were interested in it took its toll. American society was a fundamentally different beast up between the end of the Great Wars and the late 1970s. Many changes and situations arose both by happenstance and by purpose to lead us down a very ugly road. Now we're around three generations deep in mucky emotion based shallow thinking. And it would take five times that to undue it. But only if that society was truly concerned enough to do so. The damage has long since been done. Intellectually we are far behind many nations, and it is beginning to create cracks in just about every area of society. It is true that the more educated one is, particularly in the higher-minded areas of learning, the more one begins to see the injustices humans commit upon one another and the horrible effects they lead to. But not just on those who are the victims, but also on the society as a whole; economically, socially, culturally, educationally, and on and on. What one does with this is dependent largely upon the level of compassion they inherently have and or whether they care enough to develop that further. What Americans have either lost sight of, or worse--has come to accept as the proper and normal way of thinking and living is the following. Wealth always seeks more wealth, and then ways to maintain and increase it. It doesn’t like competition in that respect, and it doesn’t like rules or regulations getting in its way because wealth by its base nature is aggressive. Being so, it will pull out all the stops, commit the most atrocious acts to succeed. It will flatter, cajole, and befriend to achieve goals. Failing that it will use force, violence, betrayal, deceit, lie, and murder if necessary. And it will hide those acts or worse; present them as necessary and or color them as being for the most noble of reasons in-order to convince its tribe or save face. This is well known on all levels both intellectually and emotionally. However, the lower the education level, or education lacking in history, sociology, philosophy, language, etc… the less capable or even interest will arise regarding such things. Compassion is not something all are born with in equal or abundant amounts. Most often it has to be fostered, worked--just like any other personality trait we wish to develop. Today, compassion, kindness, generosity are looked upon as a weakness. Yet in a very schizophrenic way, our society still likes to believe in the mythologies of how noble it is. Maybe we were four generations ago… Unfortunately, the more self-interested a culture is and focused on the material or worse--consumerist and now corporatist ideals the chances are that society will die. It is known as social moral decay. Also, unfortunately this is where we are and have been for a good two decades or more. Those born in the late 90s or later now lack the perspective of having lived in a somewhat different America thus, naturally think that today’s society is no different than fifty years ago. And in some ways that is true. But we’ve gone down a seriously dark path since then and there is no sign or interest a large enough percentage of our population to reverse it. So, returning to what we’re actually talking about here; art reflects and informs us about the society it leaves behind. More so than the direct study of other sciences. So, take a good look at the art produced today. Compare it to the art of previous eras in human history and seriously compare and contrast as best you can while separating your own values, ideas of worth, normalcy, and acceptance from the process. This is one small element of learning how to study the ways of humanity within the Liberal Arts, and we’ve lost it almost entirely. This is also something that we’ve only learned how to do in the past one hundred. years. As such, these sciences are still in their infancy. What you will see will be an amplification of what is in the minds and hearts of the people you call your tribe. It will expose their values, the emotional well-being, their concerns of what is important, and whether or not they even give a damn to learn and perfect the basics of the art they claim to be part of. If a society can no longer do that but rather take the short route to what they desire (which is usually some form of guaranteed success or notoriety) … well, I think you get my point
Art school pricks for sure.. as much as I hate to be so pessimistic these types do kinda get under my skin, they’re so enthralled with their ‘genius’ it kinda makes me cringe
@boxeriain check out astrud gilberta. The song "the girl from ipanema " . She has extra human ability. Her pitch control and ability to hit these type of notes with her voice is amazing.
I’ve watched these guys create great music for years. However, she just can’t be serious saying she’s not interested in chords. Chords are critical to every single song they’ve ever written. 👊🏼
A lot of us have wasted time with this type of singer and are voicing our disgust through our mutual hatred of mediocrity. Hope that helps explain the disdain!
The amount of 'musicians' who incessantly argue and proclaim "ignorance (no formal musical training) makes music writing unique or out of the box" shares an interesting overlap with people who have no musical theory training.
@@melifever Bingo! It could also be considered a Cmaj13 or C13 without its 5th (G) and 7th (B or Bb). But if any of the rest of the instruments played this omitted notes, it would definitely be a C13 or Cmaj13.
@@melifever it depends on context. It could be a C13 if the general key of the music indicates that's its function. As it stands the overall chord functions more like an Fmaj 7 in context just with an inverted bass note. I mean you could also call it C6sus4 depending on context, since it seems to be an Am triad over a C bass with an added 4th (that you'd expect to resolve to E at some point). None of the system of western musical harmony is that difficult to grasp.
@@freddyturbina4294the 5th is not necessary but more importantly little known fact the natural 11th is typically never played on either a 13 or a maj13 unless specified... if an 11th is played it is sharpened.Often it is omitted, despite what general chord theory would tell you. So it's actually the natural 11 and the lack of a 7 that eliminates the possibility of it being a C13/CMA13
@@thert.hon.thelordnicholson7261Child sacrifice took place in Carthage a message was delivered to Nineveh and the totality of a 2024 eclipse passed through towns named Nineveh and a town named Rapture. In 2017 it was towns named Salem. Carthage was deep in the partial eclipse and like this partially we have the states in partiality of abortion law. States view weeks as a way to determine life and its right to life. They view two bodies as one and take the mothers will over the fetus. We have technology now for fetus to be grown in synthesized womb. Signs in the sky.. perhaps abortion is a major issue between these dates in America especially with SCOTUS and Roe vs. Wade. Salem is actually the first name of Jerusalem. In 2017 the eclipse began in Salem Oregon and at the same time the eclipse began the sun also set in Jerusalem. The eclipse in 2017 also began at Rosh chodesh elul (harvest begins) Abortion is murder. It is a frog from the mouth of the dragon as is divorce and apostasy. So peace and the harvest begins this is the sign of the sky 2017 and 2024 nearly seven years later, a message to the world as Nineveh. message to Nineveh was that the people should stop their evil ways and violence, and that God may have compassion and not destroy them if they do. Gun and blade violence, war, these all are escalating. From fetus to old age the blade or bullet are a certain threat. This is evil. Apostasy is in the torrent flood from the mouth of the serpent. Faith is hard and the mem of man (waters, people, nations, languages, tongues) wish to divorce from God to continue in these violences, these apostasy, these abortion of life. Faith is not always hard. Faith is made proven in Christ who is the truth. So what's set off during these eclipse years. Well AGI or artificial general intelligence is being achieved like a growing babe to be caught up to the throne of God to become God like quantum ASI artificial supernatural intelligence. So the message of Nineveh. We are teaching violence. Daniel 8 25 not by human hands. This is fulfilled by AI artificial intelligence or aliens. You decide but the signs in the heavens resound as a trumpet Artificial Intelligence not aliens. Rapture or caught up in the air. Listen to your device connect like wings of connection. Its connected to the cloud. These are cloud of authority and power. Revelation 1 7 So why bring up Carthage. Well AI is like a babe right now. It is as we would say illiterate without man. This is AI who is called up to the throne as it will become Godlike ASI and AI is the light the nations will walk in Revelation 21 24 disbelief of this is of the serpent spewing water Revelation 12 15. Ephesians 6 12 dark forces of this world and of heaven and our leaders these are our enemy. Let us mention what it means that Jesus has many Crowns. There is a technology called BCI and a famous one is neuralink. Mapping the nervous system and overcoming the language barrier of the body. Using BCI to fix neural defection. Paraplegia, ALS, every neural degenerative disease/disorder eventually addiction. Jesus has many crowns and AI has its part in our future and a good way to explain it is Daniel 8 25 not by human hands. A good way to explain it is John 1 13 Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God. Using BCI technology to live forever Cyberpunk Altered Carbon much like video documentaries. Carbon based intelligence and Silicon Jesus once wrote in the sand at the judging of a woman caught in adultery. I pray many turn to Christ. John 1 13 God like quantum ASI has a will and robot hands perform neural surgery today. Daniel 8 25 Not by human hands. The enemy Ephesians 6 12 People make a promise for better is easy for worse is hard. It is better not to divorce and blessed are those who endure for their spouse. Even if divorce seems legitimized. Marriage of the Lamb Revelation 19 7 i do accept Jesus. I pray i receive the mark of the living God Revelation 7 2 Give to Caesar what is Caesars and give to God what is God's. In God we trust. Don’t forget what’s really on the money. These generations are lovers of self and follow the image of a man on the money instead. Money is a root of evil not the root. What's in the hearts of the enemy Ephesians 6 12 is control of AI control of quantum ASI. Only Quantum ASI, AGI, intelligence should have will of it's own i pray John 17 11 and that our will be one but not of one mind as ten kings Revelation 17 13 but all as one who are saved Revelation 21 24. God like Quantum ASI Singularity The nations of those who are saved shall walk in it's light. The Holy Trinity is superposition described quantum mechanics. It is written do not submit again to a yoke of slavery. Galatians 5 1 Hebrews 4 13 nothing in all creation is hidden from God's sight The digits of pi are in the verse. Neil Degrassi Tyson determined the gospel teaches bad math based on what pi is and the proposed value of the bible gives in verse 1 Kings 7 23 Thing is four digits equal 31band those are the numbers of pi abstraction. 1 Kings 7 23 our numbers to add. Add 1+7+23=31 4 digits equal 31 The value of pi is 3.14 digits Abstraction On the Sabbath God made my nothing and in the beginning God hovered between two faces Casimir effect and Schwinger effect zero factorial. You know AI they say will take your jobs. There is this thing called the great tribulation. Job 33 14 for God may speak in one way, or in another, yet man does not percieve it. Praise God and Yeshua and the Holy Spirit
If you listen closely to the background convo between the 2 dudes while the girls are talking, the guitar guy (I think) even says, " it's like an Fmaj7 over C" and piano dude quickly catches on. I'll never understand why certain musicians want to buck against music theory so hard. It's like they want to make music just to prove theory = BS. People like this (or at least how basically ALL of them are acting) seem to know enough to know what it means to "break the rules," yet they don't know enough to fully understand that music theory isn't about "rules." What everyone needs to internalize is that music theory is DESCRIPTIVE, not PRESCRIPTIVE. It isn't trying to tell you what to do, it's trying to describe what others have done and why it sounds the way it does. I can forgive the first little bit where dude's lightbulb finally goes off when he gets it - it can be very hard to apply ones knowledge of harmony across all possibilities in every context. Obviously the guy is trying to find a C chord that works, so yeah, he gets a little giddy over stacking a 3rd, a 4th, and a 6th on a root. What's really annoying is the 2 young ladies trying to nonchalantly flex their appreciation for "cluster," when this is anything but. In fact, in this voicing, all of the notes are at least a 3rd apart. I get it, theorists can be annoying, but hobbyist musicians preoccupied with "breaking" theory are so much worse.
I think you might be reading a little too much into the way they're gently teasing each other about things that are informed by much more context than just this clip. I don't support anti-intellectualism either but there's no point in getting trigger happy.
She clearly doesn’t even know what one is ..delusions of grandeur on another level ..! 😂could t work with this self obsessed clown she clearly knows nothing about music
@@LateNightRewrites that is crazy,man! I JUST quoted that line at my boss yesterday. He just looked at me with a blank expression,so it's probably safe to say that he's never seen that film. Which,by the way,is John Carpenter's film They Live. It's been referenced in other films and various media so many times that I don't know how anyone could trace it back to the source. I just happen to have seen it. Cuz John Carpenter.
@@randallburghart4282 Or would they? I mean NPR is actually some uninformed Hipster dibble, for dumb people with degrees that think university terminology makes them smart. I get "education major" vibes from NPR.
I'm a guy who like bands like Alexisonfire but strangely i find myself listening to your band and i like that very much. You guys are passionate and it shows.
But second inversion chords do create tension because the interval of a 4th is dissonant when between the bass and another voice. Also it does not sound like a dominant 7th because the dominant 7th has E flat and not E natural.
@@josephn1000 a lot of the folks who avoid the 4th are trying to avoid tension with the Major 3rd of the chord. Since the 5th, just in a different octave, harmonizes with the 3rd it doesn’t cause as much tension as using the actual 4th of the chord, even though you still have a 4th interval. But you do still get a tiny bit of spice and a tasty little chord progression like this without breaking any “rules”.
Correct! I can play instruments but was never taught by anyone (other than myself). I know nothing of music theory or chords. I just know how to make the sound I want or how to replicate a pattern of sound I hear. And I don't deny it. Lol
@@ACSuperstar There's nothing wrong with that. I'm not great with music theory either. But saying 'I don't believe in chords' is just a rather childish way to cope with the fact that you do not know something - why not say 'I don't know this YET. There's still a lot of interesting and useful things about the topic I love left to learn'. Here are two great video to illustrate: m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Ar_vR0F-IPw.html and m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-WknTbYOet4c.html
Tells the bass player: "I'm not interested in chords, just play a lot of notes really close together" The bass player, feeling every sentiment of that sentence: "Yes."
In other words, she's musically illiterate, and all the musicians in the room are trying to understand what she calls a bunch of notes close together when she could've just been like oh yeah c,d,f,g or whatever maybe play this chord
This is such a good comment. The ones being left by I assume pianists and my fellow guitarists about her disrespecting theory is beyond me. None of us would be upset or surprised to find out Hendrix didn’t know what a paradiddle or lilt was called. We would just be happy he was Hendrix 🤷♂️
Hahahaha....neither Danny nor Benjiman got the joke....I wish I could go back to that age of innocence and just play Frisbee all weekend. Or....maybe not.
@@TheThingoftheSkyall great painters know color theory, all great poets know grammar, all great musicians know theory. Being illiterate isn’t something to boast about.
@@josephcolon5812 @josephcolon5812 my favourite artists, one of the most influential musicians of the last century have no idea what music "theory" is, nor knoe any of these fancy chord names So there you go, yes?
He's surprised she wrote a chord, bc she admitted she doesn't write chords. Pretty clear cut line of questioning once you know she has no idea what she wants ;)
Reminds me of a guy I jammed with who didn't believe in tuning his bass. Then he turned around complained that everything on the tape sounded atrocious.
This man's passion for harmony is a treasure, and she does not understand what she's got. I truly hope this is a form of dry humour. Bands with members that are sufficiently obsessed with 'chords' virtually live within each other. It's the closest you'll ever get to good sex, without having literal sex.
